Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Effects of organophosphorus and mineral

based flame retardants on combustibility and


mechanical performances of natural fiber
reinforced composites
Pooria Khalili, Kim Yeow Tshai and Ing Kong
Faculty of Engineering, Department of Mechanical, Materials and Manufacturing Engineering,
The University of Nottingham Malaysia Campus, Selangor, Malaysia

Abstract
Purpose – The study aimed to investigate epoxy composites reinforced with mechanical performances, thermal decomposition and ignitibility of
natural fiber (NF) and doped with 5 wt.% of varying flame-retardant (FR) compounds. The incorporation of ammonium polyphosphate (APP) and
zinc borate (ZB) showed improvement in modulus and elongation to break compared to the empty fruit bunch-filled epoxy (control). However, slightly
Downloaded by Hebei University of Engineering At 18:15 19 September 2016 (PT)

lower tensile and impact strengths were recorded in all FR-containing composites.
Design/methodology/approach – Among the FR-loaded specimens, enhancement in flexural property was observed in composites with APP,
whereas the addition of ZB and alumina trihydrate (ATH) resulted in the reduction of flexural strength. Thermogravimetric analysis results indicated
that the introduction of APP and ATH negatively impacted the thermal degradation temperature (Td) of the NF-filled composites. Greater mass
residue with FR-filled composites, where increment was in the range from 32-80 per cent compared to the control, was observed, with the greatest
being the ZB-containing formulation. Vertical Bunsen burner experiment revealed that the addition of ZB and APP led to a zero dripping flame
system, whereas such a phenomenon was absent in both the control and NF composites loaded with ATH. The bomb calorimeter results revealed
that addition of NF into neat epoxy significantly enhanced the FR behavior of the composite, and the gross heat of combustion was greatly reduced
when FRs were incorporated into the control sample.
Findings – Results from the current study concluded that non-halogenated FRs including APP, ZB and ATH were able to enhance the fire retardancy
of EFB epoxy composite without significantly deteriorate the mechanical behaviors.
Originality/value – It can be shown from scanning electron microscopy micrographs that the fabrication technique produced composites with good
interfacial adhesion between NF and epoxy matrix, and homogenous distribution of FRs were achieved.
Keywords Epoxy, Flammability and mechanical properties, ATH, APP, ZB, Palm fiber
Paper type Research paper

1. Introduction flame retardancy of composites has evolved as a crucial aspect for


fulfilling the safety specifications of the NF-based products
The merits of using natural fiber (NF) as the reinforcing filler
(Bakar et al., 2010). Among the many approaches available, one
in polymeric matrices are that these bio-derived sources are
abundantly available; are sustainable, recyclable, economically of the main strategies to improve flame retardancy is to use
non-abrasive and of low density; and possess highly specific flame-retardant (FR) compounds into the polymeric matrix or
performance to weight ratio (Bakar et al., 2010; Tshai et al., composite blend during fabrication process. Halogenated FRs
2014, 2015). Over the past decade, bio-based fiber-reinforced compounded with bromine and chlorine are among the available
polymer composites have been utilized in a wide array of additives. Nevertheless, these types of FRs are rarely used
industries, including, but not limited to, the upholstery, because of their menace to the human and environment health.
automotive and food packaging (Rowell, 2006). The variants of FRs most broadly applied to bio-based
Nevertheless, the main disadvantage of NF-filled polymer composites include mineral-based boron compounds, mainly
composites lies in its ease of ignitibility because the main borates (Sain and Kokta, 1994; Sain et al., 1993) and metal
constituents – NFs and polymeric matrices – show high hydroxide types, such as alumina trihydrate (ATH), (Sain et al.,
flammability properties in nature. Therefore, enhancement in the 2004; Wu et al., 1999) and those of organophosphorus-based
compound, such as ammonium polyphosphate (APP) (Li and
He, 2004).
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Boron-based FRs are less toxic and cheaper alternatives to
Emerald Insight at: www.emeraldinsight.com/1708-5284.htm
antimony oxide (as a traditional FR) (Shen et al., 2008). Zinc

This work was supported in part by the Ministry of Science, Technology


World Journal of Engineering
13/3 (2016) 193–198 and Innovation (MOSTI), Malaysia, under Grant 03-02-12-SF0212 and
© Emerald Group Publishing Limited [ISSN 1708-5284] the Faculty of Engineering at The University of Nottingham Malaysia
[DOI 10.1108/WJE-06-2016-025] Campus.

193
Effects of organophosphorus and mineral based flame retardants World Journal of Engineering
Pooria Khalili, Kim Yeow Tshai and Ing Kong Volume 13 · Number 3 · 2016 · 193–198

borates (ZBs) have been used as a smoke suppressant and an Table I Composition of constituent materials
FR compound for polymers, where the intrinsic flame Wt.%
retardation function can be contributed through hindrance of Sample Epoxy EFB ATH ZB APP
oxygen’s entry to the underlying layers via the formation of a
porous borate surface coating and water release (Nelson, E 100 – – – –
1990). APP on the other hand is capable of producing a EFB/E 82 18 – – –
thermal shielding layer from its reaction with carbonaceous EFB/E/ATH 77 18 5 – –
parts of the NF, leading to a retardation of further fire spread E/ZB 77 18 – 5 –
(Samyn et al., 2007). Also, ATH, which is broadly used as a E/APP 77 18 – – 5
metal hydroxide FR, can enhance the fire retardancy by Notes: E ⫽ neat epoxy; EFB ⫽ empty fruit bunch fiber
liberation of water and formation of a protecting charred layer
upon combustion.
In the current work, three of the most widely used FRs – to 50 per cent. Stoichiometric amount of hardener (20 parts
ZB, APP and ATH – were incorporated into NF-filled epoxy hardener to 100 parts base epoxy resin by mass as
composite, and their effects on the thermal–mechanical recommended by the manufacturer) was added to the
properties and fire retardancy were investigated. sonicated volume. The mixture was left to de-gas for 10 min
prior to infusion.
2. Materials and methods
Downloaded by Hebei University of Engineering At 18:15 19 September 2016 (PT)

A custom-built mold was used for the fabrication of the FR


2.1 Materials EFB-filled epoxy composite. To obtain a flat top specimen
Pulverized oil palm empty fruit bunch (EFB) fibers with surface and uniform thickness, a cut to dimension peel ply,
average bundle diameter in the range of 100-200 ␮m and 10 infusion mesh, thin aluminum plate and vacuum bagging were
mm in length were purchased from Szetech Engineering Sdn. aligned in sequence on top of the dried fiber mat such that a
Bhd., Malaysia. APP phase II powder of trademark Exolit AP more even compression pressure could be achieved during
422 with degree of polymerization being more than 1,000 was vacuum-assisted resin infusion. An initial procedure was
provided by Clariant (Singapore) Pte Ltd. ATH with particle performed to ensure that the system is leakage free, i.e. full
size in microns and ZB 400 with particle size 3-5 ␮m were vacuum condition could be established; the catalyzed epoxy
provided by J.M. Huber Corporation, Malaysia branch. The FR mixture was infused into the mold, where the flow path of
matrix system, an ambient cure two-part epoxy resin Ultimeg the mixture was guided by a series of spiral tubing to achieve
U2020, was supplied by AEV Asia Sdn. Bhd., Malaysia. The full wetting of the dried fiber mat. Curing of the composite
epoxy/hardener mixture has a specific viscosity of 1.1, and its was allowed for 24 h under ambient conditions (humidity and
viscosity at 25°C was measured 0.2-0.6 Pa·s. The water based temperature). The cured FR-filled EFB epoxy composites
formaldehyde-free crosslinked acrylate binding agent Acrodur were removed from mold and cut into dedicated specimens
DS 3,530 was supplied by BASF Sdn. Bhd., Malaysia. size for mechanical, thermal and combustion analyses.

2.2 Preparation of fiber mats 2.4 Characterization of mechanical properties


Palm EFB fibers of 20 g were contained into a customized A bench type tensile machine Lloyd Instruments LR50K Plus
rectangular sieve measuring 180 ⫻ 320 mm (length ⫻ width) was used to characterize the tensile and flexural properties of
and then soaked in a mixture of water and Acrodur binder at the composites. The tensile and flexural experiments were
a 10:1 ratio. The sieve was gently vibrated to enhance fiber conducted in accordance to the ASTM D3039/3039M and
distribution across the sieve, whereas the suspension was ASTM D790 standards, respectively. A constant crosshead
mechanically stirred to enhance dispersion of the binding speed of 2 mm/min was applied to the tensile specimens
agents in the aqueous medium. The wet fiber mat was taken measuring 120 ⫻ 20 ⫻ 2 mm (length ⫻ width ⫻ thickness).
out from the water-binder suspension, and few minutes were Flexural samples having dimensions 100 ⫻ 20 ⫻ 2 mm
allowed for draining out the excess water. An assembly of (length ⫻ width ⫻ thickness) were subjected to a uniform
heavy metal plate, blotting papers and top load weighing of 10 crosshead speed of 5 mm/min at mid-point over a span length
kg was used to press out the remaining water. The fiber mats of 60 mm. The impact strength was tested on rectangular
were then kept for 24 h in an oven heated to 70°C to eliminate specimens of 63.5 ⫻ 12.7 ⫻ 2 mm in accordance to ASTM
the residual moisture. D6110 standard with the aid of MH-358 Charpy Impact
Tester. Three samples from each material composition were
2.3 Fabrication of FR-filled EFB epoxy composites tested and the average value of the respective property was
The FR and palm EFB-filled epoxy composite specimens analyzed.
were prepared through vacuum resin infusion techniques.
Sonication was used to enhance the dispersion of the FR 2.5 Characterization of thermal properties
microparticles in the epoxy matrix. The composition for each A Mettler-Toledo simultaneous TGA/DSC 1 instrument was
of the constituent is given in Table I. used for characterization of the thermal properties. Sample
For FR-filled specimen, 5 wt.% of the three types of FRs weighing of 10-15 mg placed within an open alumina crucible
(ATH, ZB and APP) was separately added to the base epoxy was heated from room temperature to 600°C at a constant
resin, and the mixture was exposed to sonication for a period 20°C/min ramp, and the assembly was maintained under
of 15 min with the aid of Hielscher UP400S ultrasonic nitrogen environment supplied at 20 ml/min. Three tests were
processor, operating at 20 kHz and the amplitude was tuned performed for each formulation, and the average thermal

194
Effects of organophosphorus and mineral based flame retardants World Journal of Engineering
Pooria Khalili, Kim Yeow Tshai and Ing Kong Volume 13 · Number 3 · 2016 · 193–198

degradation curve (in percentage weight loss) plot against Figure 1 reveals the flexural properties of the composite
temperature variation was analyzed. specimens. As observed, the inclusion of FR caused a negative
effect on the flexural behavior of the composites, where the
2.6 Characterization of combustibility properties flexural strength and strain decreased for ATH- and ZB-filled
A bomb calorimeter PARR 6100 was used to characterize the composites, ascribed to the poor wettability of the epoxy resin
gross heat of combustion (GHC) of the composite specimens in the present of FR. However, the E/APP formulation
in accordance to ASTM D-240 standard. The dedicated fuse demonstrated better flexural strength relative to other
wire was positioned such as it touched the top surface of the formulations.
solid specimen fragment for combustion to occur. In all cases, The impact behavior of neat epoxy, EFB/E and FR-filled
a specimen fragment of less than 1 g was used. compositions are exhibited in Figure 2.
It can be seen that addition of EFB fibers provided a
2.7 Characterization of flammability properties reinforcing effect in terms of the impact strength of the
Vertical burn tests were set up in accordance with the composite contributed by the establishment of good interfacial
specification of Federal Aviation Regulation (FAR) 25.853 adhesion between the EFB fiber and epoxy resin. Inclusion of
12s vertical burn test standard. Rectangular specimen FRs however reduced the impact strength; in general, the
equivalent to half of the standard FAR dimension, measuring FR filler disturbed the epoxy continuity, acting as a
152.5 ⫻ 37.5 ⫻ 2 mm, were vertically suspended by a clamp stress-concentrated site, and as a result, prone to the initiation
of micro-crack (Mareri et al., 1998).
Downloaded by Hebei University of Engineering At 18:15 19 September 2016 (PT)

on a lab stand. A natural gas Bunsen flame was applied to the


leading edge of the bottom specimen surface for a period of 12
s and then detached. The flame time, drip flame time and final 3.2 Thermal properties
mass loss (%) were recorded. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) curves of the composites
with varying formulation are depicted in Figure 3. The mass
2.8 Characterization of morphological properties residue at 600°C and the thermal degradation temperature
A FEI Quanta 400F field emission scanning electron (Td) corresponding to 50 wt.% mass loss, i.e. at peak DTG,
microscopy (FESEM) was used for the analysis of specimen are shown in Table III.
surface topography. The fractured surface of composite The composites were thermally stable up to approximately
specimens was mounted upright, and scannings were 300°C where the main decomposition took place. The
performed under accelerating voltage of 20 kV and ZB-loaded composite showed the best thermal properties
low-vacuum environment. relative to other FR-based composites and the control. In
terms of the thermal degradation, it can be observed that the
Td for ZB-containing composite increased by about 4°C
3. Results and discussions
compared to the control. Furthermore, the residual mass of
3.1 Mechanical performances ZB-loaded composite at 600°C was found to be approximately
The measured tensile strength, modulus and elongation to 80 per cent greater than the control. The results imply that the
break of the EFB-filled epoxy composites containing various ZB additive is much superior in enhancing thermal behavior of
types of FR are summarized in Table II. the composite at an elevated temperature and is capable of
It can be observed that addition of ATH and APP FRs forming a large quantity of residue. Such phenomena could be
resulted in a much reduced tensile strength, whereas the attributed to the formation of a glassy insulating layer, which
incorporation of ZB produced a relatively similar response dilutes combustible gases, and also the reaction of ZB residue
with that of the control (i.e. composite without FR). The with hydroxyl (OH) functional group of natural fiber, such as
percentage drop in tensile strength for ATH- and APP-loaded hemicelluloses and celluloses, produces extra amount of water
composites was approximately 19 and 21 per cent, vapor, which contributes to the improved char formation
respectively. Typical with additives, the inclusion of FR into (Khelfa et al., 2008).
polymeric matrices generally resulted in deterioration of the Overall, the residue attained increased with the
tensile performances, which can be attributed to the weakened incorporation of FRs relative to the control. ATH and APP
mechanical interlocking between the EFB and epoxy matrix as generate alumina (metal oxide) and ammonia (phosphoric
a consequence of the present of FR (Kurt and Mengeloğlu, acid), respectively, throughout their reactions with EFB
2011; Shen et al., 2008). However, such an effect appeared to and epoxy resin, leading to the formation of a charred
be less significant with ZB. The measured modulus and barrier layer against thermal decomposition, insulting the
elongation to break indicated that E/APP and E/ZB substrates (Bourbigot et al., 2006). Neat EFB fiber showed
formulations tend to produce much higher values compared to a large amount of residue, mainly because of the presence of
E/ATH and the control. lignin constituents that are highly thermally stable, and

Table II Tensile properties of EFB-filled epoxy composites with ATH, APP and ZB
Sample Tensile strength (MPa) Modulus (GPa) Elongation to break (%)
EFB/E 32.62 2.53 4.05
E/ATH 26.39 2.42 3.87
E/APP 25.60 3.12 4.33
E/ZB 31.26 3.13 5.62

195
Effects of organophosphorus and mineral based flame retardants World Journal of Engineering
Pooria Khalili, Kim Yeow Tshai and Ing Kong Volume 13 · Number 3 · 2016 · 193–198

Figure 1 Flexural behavior of the composites Figure 4 Bunsen burner test observations of the composite
specimens
Downloaded by Hebei University of Engineering At 18:15 19 September 2016 (PT)

their thermal decomposition resulted into a large quantity


of char residual.
Figure 2 Impact behavior of the composites
3.3 Combustibility properties
Figure 4 exhibits the observations from the vertical Bunsen
burn tests, which provide further qualitative observations of
fire spread and pyrolysis on the composites.
The results showed comparable mass loss pattern to that of
the TGA for FR-filled composites, where ZB followed by
APP-loaded composites demonstrated higher mass residue
relative to the ATH containing formulation. With regard to
the drip flame time, ZB- and APP-based compositions did not
generate any dripping, whereas ATH and EFB/E recorded
dripping for approximately 25 and 55 s, respectively. This
indicated that ZB and APP provide greater effect on reducing
ignitibility behavior of the EFB epoxy composites. ATH-filled
Figure 3 TGA curves of the composites composite was observed to burn more rigorously than other
FR-based samples, where an approximately 4 min flame time
and dripping were recorded, suggesting that ATH is poorer in
restricting the liberation of flammable gases during the event
of fire. Furthermore, APP- and ZB-loaded composites
maintained the physical integrity and shape throughout
the combustion, whereas the control and ATH-containing
samples experienced shrinkage and warp, resulting in the loss
of their original structure.
The large drip flame time for EFB/E was owing to an
increasingly deteriorating NF network, which was not
protected by the dilution of ignitable oxidizable gases via ZB
and APP-containing formulations. This resulted in extensive
pyrolysis of the EFB/E sample and consequently accelerated
the burning progression, increasing the dropped parts.
The flammability behaviors were also investigated with a
bomb calorimeter instrument, where gross heat release and
fire decomposition were analyzed. Figure 5 showed the GHC
Table III Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) data under nitrogen
atmosphere
of the formulation with varying FR additives.
The neat epoxy specimen E100 demonstrated the highest
Sample name Char residual at T600 (wt.%) Td (°C) GHC owing to its inherent nature to flammability. Addition of
EFB/E (control) 15.56 385.87 EFB fibers into epoxy significantly dropped the GHC from
E/ATH 20.47 383.37 about 35 to 31.8 MJ/kg.
E/APP 21.41 376.784 Incorporation of FRs had a considerable positive effect of
E/ZB 27.92 389.49 reducing the GHC of the EFB epoxy composites, which is
Nest EFB fiber 30.72 346.864 favorable to fire retarding performance. The enhanced fire
retardancy could be related to the shielding char layer formed

196
Effects of organophosphorus and mineral based flame retardants World Journal of Engineering
Pooria Khalili, Kim Yeow Tshai and Ing Kong Volume 13 · Number 3 · 2016 · 193–198

by the presence of ATH, APP and ZB. ATH and ZB is 3.4 Combustibility properties
capable of producing metal oxide, whereas APP forms The tensile fractured surfaces were subjected to scanning
phosphorous acid. In addition, the FR investigated in the electron microscopy (SEM). The SEM micrographs of the FR
current work has the tendency to generate water vapor from formulations are illustrated in Figure 6.
their thermal decomposition. Water absorbs the heat released The image shown in Figure 6(a) revealed establishment of
by combustion and reduces the amount of flammable gases in good bonding between EFB fiber and epoxy matrix.
the combustive zone, thereby improving the formation of char. Moreover, the micrographs in Figure 6(b-d) showed good
dispersion of ATH, APP and ZB within the epoxy, which
indicated the good compatibility between FRs, EFB and
epoxy polymer.
Figure 5 Gross heat of combustion
4. Conclusions
Results from the current study concluded that non-halogenated
FRs, including APP, ZB and ATH, were able to enhance the fire
retardancy of EFB epoxy composite without significantly
deteriorating the mechanical behaviors. The tensile strength of
ATH- and APP-loaded composites were reduced by
Downloaded by Hebei University of Engineering At 18:15 19 September 2016 (PT)

approximately 19 and 21 MPa, respectively, in comparison with


the neat EFB epoxy composite (control), whereas elongation at
break and modulus were improved with the addition of APP and
ZB particles. The flexural and impact strength of FR-based
composites seem to reduce compared to the control, with the
exception for the APP-containing sample, which was found to
experience enhancement by around 35 per cent. The reason for
such improvement merit further investigation.

Figure 6 SEM micrograph of the composites

197
Effects of organophosphorus and mineral based flame retardants World Journal of Engineering
Pooria Khalili, Kim Yeow Tshai and Ing Kong Volume 13 · Number 3 · 2016 · 193–198

Upon the event of fire, the char formed among EFB, FR Rowell, R.M. (2006), “Advances and challenges of wood
and epoxy was found capable of inhibiting the mass and heat polymer composites”, paper presented at the Proceedings of
transfer into the bulk of the substrate, leading to larger mass the 8th Pacific Rim Bio-based Composites Symposium,
residue as evident from TGA, the reduced GHC and zero Forest Research Institute Malaysia, Kuala Lumper,
molten drip flame for ZB- and APP-filled composites. In Kepong, 20-23 November.
general, NF and FRs contributed to the improvement in Sain, M. and Kokta, B. (1994), “Polyolefin–wood filler
thermal properties and fire retardancy of epoxy polymer. composite. I. Performance of m-phenylene
bismaleimide-modified wood fiber in polypropylene
References composite”, Journal of Applied Polymer Science, Vol. 54
No. 10, pp. 1545-1559.
Bakar, M., Ishak, Z., Taib, R., Rozman, H. and Jani, S.M.
(2010), “Flammability and mechanical properties of wood Sain, M., Kokta, B. and Maldas, D. (1993), “Effect of reactive
flour-filled polypropylene composites”, Journal of Applied additives on the performance of cellulose fiber-filled
Polymer Science, Vol. 116 No. 5, pp. 2714-2722. polypropylene composites”, Journal of Adhesion Science and
Bourbigot, S., Duquesne, S., Sébih, Z., Ségura, S. and Technology, Vol. 7 No. 1, pp. 49-61.
Delobel, R. (2006), “Synergistic aspects of the combination Sain, M., Park, S., Suhara, F. and Law, S. (2004), “Flame
of magnesium hydroxide and ammonium polyphosphate in retardant and mechanical properties of natural fibre-PP
flame retardancy of ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer”, composites containing magnesium hydroxide”, Polymer
Downloaded by Hebei University of Engineering At 18:15 19 September 2016 (PT)

paper presented at the ACS Symposium Series, ACS Degradation and Stability, Vol. 83 No. 2, pp. 363-367.
Symposium Series, Vol. 922. Samyn, F., Bourbigot, S., Duquesne, S. and Delobel, R.
Khelfa, A., Finqueneisel, G., Auber, M. and Weber, J. (2008), (2007), “Effect of zinc borate on the thermal degradation of
“Influence of some minerals on the cellulose thermal ammonium polyphosphate”, Thermochimica Acta, Vol. 456
degradation mechanisms: thermogravimetic and No. 2, pp. 134-144.
pyrolysis-mass Spectrometry Studies”, Journal of Thermal Shen, K.K., Kochesfahani, S. and Jouffret, F. (2008), “Zinc
Analysis and Calorimetry, Vol. 92 No. 3, pp. 795-799. borates as multifunctional polymer additives”, Polymers for
Kurt, R. and Mengeloğlu, F. (2011), “Utilization of boron Advanced Technologies, Vol. 19 No. 6, pp. 469-474.
compounds as synergists with ammonium polyphosphate Tshai, K., Chai, A., Kong, I., Hoque, M. and Tshai, K.
for flame retardant wood-polymer composites”, Turkish (2014), “Hybrid fibre polylactide acid composite with
Journal of Agriculture and Forestry, Vol. 35 No. 2, empty fruit bunch: chopped glass strands”, Journal of
pp. 155-163. Composites, Vol. 7, p. 7.
Li, B. and He, J. (2004), “Investigation of mechanical Tshai, K., Tan, H., Khiew, P., Hoque, M. and Chia, C.
property, flame retardancy and thermal degradation of (2015), “Effects of aluminum trihydrate on the
LLDPE–wood-fibre composites”, Polymer Degradation and flame-retardant and smoke-suppressant properties of
Stability, Vol. 83 No. 2, pp. 241-246. natural fibres filled composites”, Polymers Research Journal,
Mareri, P., Bastide, S., Binda, N. and Crespy, A. (1998), Vol. 9 No. 2, p. 181.
“Mechanical behaviour of polypropylene composites Wu, Y., Isarov, A.V. and O’Connell, C. (1999), “Thermal
containing fine mineral filler: effect of filler surface analysis of high density polethylene-maple woodflour
treatment”, Composites Science and Technology, Vol. 58 composites”, Thermochimica Acta, Vol. 340, pp. 205-220.
No. 5, pp. 747-752.
Nelson, G. (1990), Fire and Polymers-Hazards Identification
and Prevention, American chemical society (ACS
Corresponding author
symposium series), Washington, DC, p. 425. Pooria Khalili can be contacted at: pooria.khalili@gmail.com

For instructions on how to order reprints of this article, please visit our website:
www.emeraldgrouppublishing.com/licensing/reprints.htm
Or contact us for further details: permissions@emeraldinsight.com

198

You might also like