Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Campbell1994 (Article) (Obs. Título - Plant and Soil Analysis - An Australian Perspective)
Campbell1994 (Article) (Obs. Título - Plant and Soil Analysis - An Australian Perspective)
Campbell1994 (Article) (Obs. Título - Plant and Soil Analysis - An Australian Perspective)
Communications in Soil
Science and Plant Analysis
Publication details, including instructions for
authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/lcss20
To cite this article: Lindsay C. Campbell (1994) Plant and soil analysis: An
Australian perspective, Communications in Soil Science and Plant Analysis,
25:7-8, 767-780, DOI: 10.1080/00103629409369079
Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all
the information (the “Content”) contained in the publications on our
platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors
make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy,
completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any
opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and
views of the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor
& Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and
should be independently verified with primary sources of information.
Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims,
proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities
whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content.
This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study
purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution,
reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any
form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access
and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms-and-
conditions
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
COMMUN. SOIL SCI. PLANT ANAL., 25(7&8), 767-780 (1994)
Lindsay C. Campbell1
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
1. Visiting Professor of Plant Nutrition, Department of Soil, Crop and Atmospheric Sciences,
Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853.
767
enterprise considers the adoption of the technique. DPTA seems to be the most
widely used extractant for micronutrient analyses of soils.
Plant testing ideally should be perceived for its preventative and monitoring
capabilities as well as a diagnostic tool for a deficiency or toxicity. Its potential to
examine the complete nutrient status of the plant taking into account nutrient ratios
and interactions has not been widely developed. This is probably due to the lack of
knowledge of plant nutrition in the educational background of advisers and district
agents. Another factor is the slow turn-around time from time of sampling to
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
BACKGROUND
Countries having a geologically old landmass are usually confronted with
fertility levels which are less than optimum for plant growth. Mineral nutrient
deficiencies are often expressed in the vegetation and animal species which are not
adapted to the infertile conditions. Thus indigenous plants may have sufficient
adaptation to grow—albeit slowly —but introduced crop and pasture species,
which are comparatively fast growing and often bred on or adapted to highly
fertile soils, readily succumb to nutrient deficiencies. Since Australia is an ancient
continent, it is not surprising that nutrient deficiencies of nearly all the essential
nutrients have been found in crops and pastures. Nutrient deficiencies in pastures
in particular have resulted in major nutritional problems in sheep, cattle, and other
species (Lee, 1974). Intensive livestock industries, e.g. chicken and pig
production, which depend on grains have also learn the necessity for mineral
nutrient supplements. On account of these factors, both plant and soil analysis
should play a major role in plant and animal production systems in Australia.
In the Australian context, the major cropping and horticultural enterprises are
located in rather narrow bands up to 500 km from the south-western, southern,
and eastern seaboards (Figure 1). Horticultural activities are likely to increase in
SOIL AND PLANT ANALYSIS IN AUSTRALIA 769
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
500 km
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
I Black Earth
I Cracking Clays
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
Ironstone/Sand
I Solodised Solonetz
and Solodic Soils
I Other
SOILS
Australian soils have been degraded both before and after white settlement
(Hughes and Sullivan, 1986; Jenkin, 1986). Some of the major soil types for
772 CAMPBELL
cropping and pastoral activities are shown in Figure 3. As the Australian soil
classification system is different to the United States and other world schemes, an
approximation to the United States system is presented in Table 1. Details of
Australian soil classification can be found in Stace et al. (1968) and Northcote et
al. (1975) and keys in Northcote (1979). The black earth and some of the gray
clay soils are generally fertile and are prone to severe cracking in dry conditions
and often have self-mulching properties. These soils tend not to respond to P until
cropping has taken place for many decades; however, if double cropping (one
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
summer and one winter crop in the same year) is practiced for about ten years,
then responses to this element can be demonstrated. This is interpreted in terms of
the rate of release of P from the soil being insufficient to meet the total demand
once the relatively labile pool of P has been utilized. When cropping activities are
less frequent and often with a long fallow or pasture in the rotation, zinc (Zn) is
often one of the first nutrients to be deficient.
Most Australian soils are N deficient. A considerable portion of this N comes
from the use of legumes in rotation with non leguminous species. The traditional
rotation in the winter dominant rainfall zone was a subterranean clover (Trifolium
subterraneum) or medic (Medicago sp.) pastoral phase for three to five years
followed by a cropping phase, e.g. two wheat crops followed by barley. In the
last 25 years, lupins have been introduced as a leguminous crop into the rotations
as well as diversifying into other crops especially oilseeds. With the greater
emphasis on cropping, the use of nitrogenous fertilizers especially urea,
ammonium nitrate, and combined N and P fertilizers has increased substantially. A
ten-fold increase in N usage has occurred in the past 30 years.
Phosphorus deficiency is prevalent throughout the continent. Wheat yields
typically declined late last century as the soil phosphate levels declined. Although
the first responses to P were recorded in 1882, it was not until the 1920s that
superphosphate was used extensively in the production of wheat. The widespread
application of superphosphate to pastures occurred from the 1950s onwards.
Many of the soils in South Australia and Western Australia are deficient in the
trace elements as well as N and P. In the case of the sandy soils, concentrations of
trace elements in soil solution are extremely low and this limited pasture and
animal production in the early part of this century. Addition of trace elements
usually in conjunction with phosphate (superphosphate)—Zn, copper (Cu),
manganese (Mn), molybdenum (Mo), and cobalt (Co)—has boosted productivity.
SOIL AND PLANT ANALYSIS IN AUSTRALIA 773
Equivalent
(approximate)
Black Earth Pellustert,
Chromustert
Red-Brown Earth Natrixeralf,
Rhodoxeralf,
Paleustalf,
Haplustalf
Cracking Clays Torrert,
Chromustert,
Pellustert
Solodic and Solodised Natrustalf,
Solonetz Natrixeralf,
Paleustalf
Sands Quartzipsamment,
Torripsamment,
Xeropsamment
Adapted from Moore et al. (1983)
774 CAMPBELL
The residual value of these trace element additions is typically five or more years.
In South Australia, some of these trace element deficient soils are calcareous.
Manganese deficiency occurs unless applied frequently, e.g. a soil application
followed by up to three foliar applications (Hannam et al., 1984; Reuter et al.,
1988).
ANALYTICAL SERVICES
Plant and soil analytical services across the nation undertake about 170,000
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
determinations annually (Peverill, 1993). Plant samples only account for 20% of
the analyses. Data from the United States show that soil samples comprise about
75% of the analyses (Jones, 1993a) so the Australian experience is not atypical.
However, approximately half of the samples come from a single state, Western
Australia (Peverill, 1993), which is far beyond the relative agricultural production
of this state to that of the nation. Samples from commercial enterprises are
probably less than that for research purposes (Handson and Shelley, 1993). As
the number of farms in Australia is about 200,000 and that more than a single
sample is sent from a farm, the conclusion drawn is that market penetration for
these analytical services is low. Good data on the usage of plant and soil analytical
services by horticultural, floricultural, cropping, and pastoral enterprises are not
readily available. It is likely that the more intensive industries rely more on these
services than the broadacre establishments.
Although growth in analytical services has occurred during the last decade, the
question must be posed as to why market penetration is small. Several hypotheses
are advanced: (i) the slow turn around time, (ii) reliability of results particularly in
relation to sampling procedures rather than the analytical procedures, (iii) lack of
clear communication of the benefits of soil and plant testing and especially the use
of these services in prevention and crop monitoring, (iv) interpretation of results,
(v) use of antiquated units of measurement, and (vi) comparison of analytical
results from different laboratories can not occur because of unstated testing
method; Most of these factors lead to loss of confidence or acceptance of the
value of the service—with the exception of propositions (ii) and (iv)—the others
can be rectified readily. A recent conference in Australia highlighted many of these
factors (Soil and Plant Analyses Council, 1993)
The anecdotal evidence is that many farmers, especially floriculturalists, send
sampk s by overnight air freight to the United States for analysis on account of the
SOIL AND PLANT ANALYSIS IN AUSTRALIA 775
fast turn-around time. The results are sent by facsimile to the grower. With
modern instrumentation, e.g. microwave digestion and ICP, the old batch-wise
procedures become less relevant. A fast turn-around time is essential for this type
of service.
but good universal solutions have not yet been found. For plant samples, it is
generally accepted that samples of a leaf (or petiole) of a given physiological age
are better indicators of nutrient status than whole plant samples. For soil samples,
the problem of obtaining a representative sample is still of paramount importance.
The relative contributions of the topsoil and subsoil are often neglected. For soils
where phosphate fertilizers have been added to the topsoil, sampling the topsoil is
likely to be more important. For micronutrients, investigation of the subsoil may
be found to be more profitable since very deep placement of micronutrients has
been shown to be beneficial (Graham and Asher, 1994).
There has been considerable reluctance to introduce new soil tests which
partially stems from problems of field calibration. Comparisons between soil test
extractants need to be made as has been done for the coastal plains soils of the
United States (Gascho et al, 1990). Soil tests are generally developed by non-
profit organizations, e.g. universities or publicly funded agencies which do not
receive grant money for extensive field testing. As a consequence, the tests are not
widely calibrated in the field. Commercial laboratories, whose clients are widely
scattered, are reluctant to undertake these field calibrations and often state that the
responsibility for these calibrations lies with the other party. A combined
approach would be very beneficial to all concerned. Calibrations should be
published with some estimate of reliability, i.e. confidence limits need to be
explicitly shown. If this were done, credibility of the service would be developed
in the long term by the client. Little investigation on the use of the Mehiich tests is
being undertaken. For micronutrients, DPTA is the extractant of choice, although
great care should be taken in the interpretation of results from this test (Evans,
1988; O'Connor, 1988). An excellent handbook is available for soil testing
methods from the Soil and Plant Analysis Council (1992).
However, two new soil tests are being adopted commercially. One test is the
lactate test for P (Holford and Doyle, 1992) and the other test for sulfur (S) in
776 CAMPBELL
pastoral land (Blair et al., 1991). The use of the P-test strips developed by Menon
et al. (1989, 1990) should be evaluated for the Australian context. It is possible
that the effectiveness of the P-test strips may diminish due to the variability in
rainfall (Holford et al., 1988). Notwithstanding the new lactate test for P, the
most frequent tests for this nutrient are based on the Olsen test (or some
modification of it) or on one of the Bray tests.
The new S soil test proposed by Blair et al. (1991) uses potassium chloride
(0.25M KC1) as the extractant and is an improvement over the monocalcium
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
phosphate extractant. Potassium chloride extracts sulfate esters from the soil.
Results indicate a greater stability of the test over a range of Australian soil types
and that the critical levels for pastures are very tight (6.4 to 6.6 mg/kg).
The measurement of soil pH is not necessarily a standardized procedure and
pH values can be quite disparate depending on whether the measurement is made
in water or a salt solution—usually calcium or potassium chloride (Sumner,
1994). Within the Australian context, measurement in calcium chloride in a 1:5
(soil.-solution) ratio predominates in recent times. In the Australian Nutrient
Database (a computer database), Campbell and Farrell (1992) make provision for
different methods, viz. extraction in water, calcium chloride, etc. As liming is
becoming of increasing importance (Merry et al., 1990; Cumming, 1991), it is
desirable that pH is measured in both water and salt solutions.
Mostly plant tissue is digested in nitric and perchloric acids for mineral
nutrients (Sale and Campbell, 1980; Reuter et al., 1982; Robson et al., 1984), or
occasionally dry ashed (Alva et al., 1991), and subsequently analyzed by atomic
absorption spectrometry or ICP. Some commercial laboratories use only nitric acid
but there is always a risk of incomplete digestion for trace elements. With the
advent of microwave digestion techniques, oxidation with perchloric acid is
probably not advisable. Nitric acid and hydrogen peroxide are favored oxidants
for microwave digestions (Kalra et al., 1989; Rechcigl and Payne, 1990).
Microwave digestion of plant material has one potential limitation, viz. sample
weights for digestion are 50% or less than conventional techniques. Therefore, the
importance of obtaining a representative sample for analysis must be stressed.
Boron (B) and chloride (Cl) are extracted only in water. Nitrogen is analyzed by a
Kjeldahl, near infrad reflectance (NIR), or Dumas method, methods that are well
described by Jones (1991).
Sampling for tissue analysis has been recently reviewed by Robinson (1993).
Experience in my laboratory has consistently shown the need for sampling the
SOIL AND PLANT ANALYSIS IN AUSTRALIA 777
most responsive plant part and taking those samples from plants of the same
physiological age. Tissue testing after anthesis has been unreliable for both
macronutrients and micronutrients in cereals and soybeans (Campbell, unpub-
lished data). Sap tests have not been dealt with in this overview, a they are more
likely to be useful as qualitative guides than as good quantitative predictors.
Nitrogen status of cotton by petiole sap analysis is currently used by farmers. On
the other hand, a test kit for the determination of the P status of plants using
expressed sap has turned out to be a commercial disaster.
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
CONCLUSIONS
Plant and soil analytical services are likely to expand in the future. They
should be seen as complementary tests. Preventative plant and soil nutrition
should be practised more widely rather than using them as diagnostic tools. The
detection of hidden hunger in crops and pastures before clinical symptoms appear
is an important but overlooked use of plant analysis. All too often plant analysis is
resorted to as a post mortem rather than emphasizing its preventative and monitor-
ing roles. This will become increasingly important as environmental issues must
be taken into account in any well managed agricultural enterprise. The need for
fast turn-around times is paramount if the benefits of these services are to be
captured and for these services to be creditable. Likewise well trained and well
informed personnel are necessary such services are to be successful.
778 CAMPBELL
REFERENCES:
Alva, A.K., D.G. Edwards, and C.J. Asher 1991. Effects of acid soil infertility
factors on mineral composition of soybean and cowpea tops. J. Plant Nutr.
14:187-203.
Blair, G.J., N. Chinoin, R.D.B. Lefroy, G.C. Anderson, and G.J. Crocker.
1991. A soil sulfur test for pastures and crops. Aust. J. Soil Res. 29:619-
626.
Boer, R., D.J. Fletcher, and L.C. Campbell. 1993a. Rainfall patterns and
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
Holford, I.C.R., E.J. Corbin, C.L. Mullen, and J. Bradley. 1988. Effects of
rainfall variability on the efficacy of soil phosphate tests for wheat on semi-
arid soils. Aust. J. Soil Res. 26:201-209.
Hughes, P.J. and M.E. Sullivan. 1986. Aboriginal landscape, pp. 117-133. IN:
J.S. Russell and R.F. Isbell (eds.) Australian Soils: The Human Impact.
University of Queensland Press, St Lucia, Australia.
Jenkin, J.J. 1986. Western civilization in Australian soils: The human impact, pp.
134-156. IN: J.S. Russell and R.F. Isbell (eds.) Australian soils: The
Human Impact. University of Queensland Press, St Lucia, Australia.
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015
O'Connor, G.A. 1988. Use and misuse of the DPTA soil test. J. Environ. Qual.
17:715-718.
Peverill, K.I. 1993. Soil testing and plant analysis in Australia. Aust. J. Exp.
Agric. 33: (in press).
Rechcigl, J.E. and G.G. Payne. 1990. Comparison of a microwave digestion
system to other digestion methods. Commun. Soil Sci. Plant Anal. 21:2209-
2218.
Reuter, D.J., A.M. Alston, and J.D. McFarlane. 1988. Occurrence and correction
of manganese deficiency in plants, pp. 205-224. IN: R.D. Graham, R.J.
Downloaded by [New York University] at 03:10 02 February 2015