Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Salma Full
Salma Full
The client S.M was 48 years old divorced woman, educated till matric and 1st born among
4 siblings. She was initially seen by the consultant psychiatrist and then referred to the trainee
clinical psychologist at Centre for Clinical Psychology for the psychological assessment and
hopelessness, sadness, crying spells, constant fatigue, lack of interest in daily activities and
negative thoughts about future. She was assessed on formal as well as informal level. Informal
assessment was done with the help of Clinical Interview, Mental State Examination, Subjective
ratings of symptoms, DSM V Checklist and Dysfunctional thought record (DTR). Formal
assessment was done by using Beck Depression Inventory (BDI-II).The client was diagnosed
with Major Depressive Disorder. Therapeutic techniques which were used were
Double column technique and graded task assignments. 9 sessions were conducted with the
client and post treatment revealed significant improvement in the severity of symptoms and level
of functioning.
Bio Data
Name S.M
Age 48 years
Gender Female
Qualification Matric
No. of siblings 4
No. of children 4
Religion Islam
The client came to Centre for Clinical Psychology, with the complaints of of fear of
constant fatigue, lack of interest in daily activities and negative thoughts about future. She was
referred to the trainee clinical psychologist for the assessment and management of her problem.
Presenting Complaints
مجھے واشروم میں گھٹن محسوس ہونے لگ جاتی ہے اگر زیادہ دیر لگ جاُے تو
میں واشروم کا دروازہ بند کر کہ نہیں بیٹھ سکتی ایسا لگتا ہے میرا دم گھٹ جاے گا
The history of present illness of the client dates back when the husband of the client did
second marriage and gave divorce to the client. She was kicked out of the house by her husband.
He kept his sons with him and gave daughter to the client. The client came to his mother’s house
and started living with his brother. Few days after coming to her brother’s house, the client
started fearing in enclosed washroom. She had palpitations and sweating whenever she closed
میں واشروم میں زیادہ دیر بیٹھ نہیں سکتی گھٹن محسوس ہونے لگ جاتی ہے
On the other the client started having body pains and reported that she suffered from
fatigue almost every time. Gradually she lost interest in the activities of daily routine and used to
spend most of the time alone in the room. She reported that nothing made her happy. She started
missing meals because of loss of appetite. Her sleep also became disturbed as she reported that
she couldn’t sleep normally. She had feelings of hopelessness and had negative thoughts like:
She had crying spells and reported that she used to cry on silly things and remained in
that state for hours. She remained sad and nothing brought her happiness as she was worried
In 2011, she consulted a renowned psychiatrist who prescribed her anti anxiolytics. She
remained on that medication for 3 years. But there was no improvement in her symptoms except
she was able to sleep properly with help of those medicines. In 2014, she consulted a
psychiatrist at Services hospital who prescribed her same medicine and advised her to get
admitted in the hospital. But the client was not willing to get admitted in the hospital so she
From 2016, she was consulting a psychiatrist and was still on medication. She reported
that with the help of this medication she is just able to sleep properly and no other symptom is
improving. So one of her uncle suggested her to visit Centre for Clinical Psychology where she
was referred to trainee clinical psychologist for the assessment and management of her problem.
Background Information
Family History
The father of the client died at the age of 60 years. He was educated till matric and ran a
shop. The client was very attached to her father. He had cool temperament and used to get angry
occasionally. She was very close to him as she was his first daughter. she reported that the death
The mother of the client died after her divorce at the age of 75 years. She was
uneducated and the client had satisfactory relationship with her. She used to share her issues with
The client is eldest among all the siblings. The second and third born are sisters who are
married and lived out of station. The client has congenial relationships with her sisters as they
help her financially and also gifts clothes to her and her daughter. Fourth born is a brother who is
educated till intermediate and now works in a clock making factory. The client and her daughter
live with this brother. He is married and has three daughters. The client is very attached to him
and he also takes care of her needs. The last born is a brother who is physically disabled and
Personal History
The client reported that her mother told her that she was born through normal delivery at
home. She achieved all her milestones at appropriate level of age. She got extra care from her
father as he loved her a lot. The client had a friendly, jolly nature and temperament. She used to
get angry only occasionally. The client also reported that she was talkative by nature. She was
fond of doing household chores. She was interested in cooking and used to keep herself busy.
There was no reported history of serious physical injury, illness or trauma. No neurotic traits
Educational History
The client started going to school at the age of 6 years. She reported that her school was
near her home and she completed her studies till matric from that school. She reported that she
was not much interested in studies but was studying as his father wanted her to do matric. She
was an average student and had congenial relationship with her teachers and fellows. After
matric she remained at home and started helping her mother in household chores.
Sexual History
The client reached puberty at the age of 14 years. She was not aware of that significant
change in her body. Her mother guided her regarding the ways to handle her menstrual time
period. She adjusted herself in that major transition and faced no difficulty in accepting it. She
had no sexual relationship before her marriage. The client had no homosexual inclination. No
sexual or physical abuse was reported during her childhood. The client had her first sexual
Marital History
The husband of the client ran a clinic and gave medicines to people. The client reported
that she had satisfactory relationship with her husband only for 1 year. He started abusing her
physical and verbally right after the birth of her daughter. She reported that she was very
beautiful at the time of her marriage so her husband took care of her and loved her. With the
passage of time, as her beauty declined, he started losing his interest in her and used to fight with
her all the time. Initially they had normal sexual life that she found mildly pleasurable but due to
continuous fights with her husband, the client could not maintain regular sexual relation with her
husband. After 15 years of marriage the husband of the client married again and kicked her out
of his house. She had 4 children. The eldest child was a daughter of 22 years who had dome
intermediate and was now giving tuitions to children. She lived with her mother. She has
congenial relationship with her mother. The 2nd born son has done matric and was helping his
father at clinic, the third born is also a son who is not educated and is free nowadays. The last
born has recently done matric and is willing to continue his studies. The sons are not allowed by
the father to meet their mother but they often come to meet her. Client has congenial
Premorbid Personality
The patient’s personality was reported to be pleasant and cheerful before her illness. She
was friendly, outspoken and she spent her leisure time in useful activities like cooking or
laundry. Her predominant mood was cheerful. She also had friendly relationships with her
siblings and had appropriate relationships with her family. She was sensitive and was vulnerable
to stress but she reported that she was able to cope with her stress effectively. She was good in
maintaining relationships. She was religious throughout her life and reported that she became
more close to her religion after the death of her father. She had a compromising nature and was
Psychological Assessment
Psychological assessment of the client was carried out to get the information regarding
the nature of her symptoms, causes and maintaining factors for diagnosis and managing them.
Formal Assessment
Informal assessment
Informal assessment
Clinical Interview
DSM V Checklist
Clinical Interview
A detailed clinical interview was conducted with the client and her daughter to get
thorough and detailed information about her present illness, presenting complaints, identifying
data, family history, educational history, background information and personal history as well as
premorbid personality. It was also done to probe every possible factor which led to the problem
and also the factors which were maintaining the illness. Moreover, it provided detailed
information about the history of present illness and previous treatment. This information was
used to devise an idiosyncratic case formulation and management plan for the client.
Mental State examination was conducted in first session to analyze the current
functioning level on cognitive and behavioral level of the client. The client had bloomy
expressions. She had an average height. She was wearing dress of dull color. She was sitting on
the chair bent towards the therapist. She maintained eye contact for some time and used to look
down most of the time. Her speed of speech was slow and tone was low. She was cooperative
towards the therapist and showed compliance. She was motivated to deal with her symptoms.
Her mood was low. There was no evidence of hallucinations and delusions. There was no
evidence of obsessions and compulsions or suicidal ideation. She had insight about the
psychological nature of her problem. She was well oriented in time, place and person. She was
motivated enough to seek the treatment. Her general knowledge and abstract thinking was
Visual Analogue
The severity of the presenting complaints was assessed on 0-10 point scale. The client
was asked to rate her presenting complaints from 0-10 to get an estimate of the intensity of
symptoms at pretreatment stage. In the given scale, 0 indicated no problem at all, while 5
Table 1
Pre-Treatment Subjective Ratings of Presenting Complaints By The Client On 0-10 Point Scale
Sadness 10
Loss of Interest 10
Feelings of hopelessness 9
Fatigue 8
Crying spells 9
precipitating factors, negative automatic thoughts, intensity of the beliefs on NAT’S and coping
Table 2
Areas Content
husband
happy
Formal Assessment
Beck depression Inventory and Beck Anxiety Inventory were administered as formal assessment
Table 3
44 30-63 Severe
The client obtained a score of 44 on Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) which falls in the
category of severe depression. It shows that the client had severe level of depressive symptoms.
Table 4
27 17-29 Moderate
The client obtained a score of 27 on Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI) which falls in the
category of moderate anxiety. It shows that the client had moderatelevel of anxiety symptoms.
Diagnosis
Case Formulation
pleasurable activities, loss of appetite and sleep, psychomotor agitation, feelings of helplessness
and hopelessness, recurrent thoughts of death and significant distress in social and occupational
functioning since last two weeks is diagnosed as major depressive disorder. The above
mentioned symptoms related to the case of client became the reason of diagnosis of Major
Depressive Disorder. The client was also fearful of enclosed washroom and she started having
symptoms like sweating and palpitations there. She also fulfilled the criteria of specific phoba so
negative thinking pattern of self, others and the world. People who interpret their future and
experiences as negative way make certain thinking errors which become the reason for
persistence of depression (as cited in Comer’s 2000). In the present case, client also had negative
triad. She had negative view about herself; I am worthless as I have failed my marriage. She also
had negative view about her future; I have not hopeful regarding my future as I will never be
Client found herself inadequate and helpless in her life as she thought everything is out of
her control this is consistent with attribution-helplessness theory, when people view events as
beyond their control, they ask themselves why this is so (Taube-Schiff & Lau, 2008; Abramson
et al., 2002). If they attribute their present lack of control to some internal cause that is both
global and stable (“I am inadequate at everything and I always will be”), they may well feel
helpless to prevent future negative outcomes and they may experience depression.
According to Seligman (1975) as cited in Comer’s 2012, such feelings of helplessness are
at the center of her depression. Seligman has developed the learned helplessness theory of
depression. It holds that people become depressed when they think (1) that they no longer have
control over the reinforcements (the rewards and punishments) in their lives and (2) that they
themselves are responsible for this helpless state. So, it is consistent with the background history
of patient as she had learned that she is unable to control her situation and became helpless
of these maladaptive attitudes they hold, the more depressed they tend to be (Evans et al., 2005).
Depressed individuals seem to recall unpleasant experiences more readily than positive ones, rate
their performances on laboratory tasks lower than non depressed people do, and select
pessimistic statements in storytelling tests, this is consistent with the case of this patient’s belief
that as he reported (“I expect I never can do anything good”, I can’t expressed my feelings, no
one have concern with me). Depressed people experience automatic thoughts, a steady train of
unpleasant thoughts that keep suggesting to them that they are inadequate and that their situation
is hopeless. As patient reported that “I’m worthless . . . I’ll never amount to anything. . . .
Everyone hates me. . . I’ve failed as a person... Everything is difficult for me” (Mendels, 1970)
as cited in Burn (1980). In the present case they client only focused on the negative things in her
life.
Watson's (1919) has viewed specific phobia as resulting from a learned association of a
negative consequence paired with a neutral stimulus. According to Mowrer two factor model of
phobia (1960), the initial fear was established through classical conditioning (e.g., the neutral
stimulus of the symptoms presence in washroom was paired with the negative experience of
being suffocated, breathlessness and palpitation). However, avoidance of the close spaces in the
future was based on operant conditioning that is, when the patient approached an enclosed
washroom there was an increased fear. Avoiding or escaping was associated with reduction of
fear (thereby negatively reinforcing the operant of escape or avoidance through the consequence
of fear reduction). The two-factor model thus accounted for the acquisition of fear through
classical conditioning and the avoidance of feared stimuli through the negative reinforcement of
reducing fear through the operant of escape of avoidance. Fear was thereby conserved.
Watson and Rayner (1920) originally argued that phobias are simply intense classically
conditioned fears that develop when a neutral stimulus is paired with a traumatic event, such as
in this case intense fear of close and confined spaces paired with washroom. As she was in
washroom when she felt palpitation, breathlessness and anxiety, she associated them with
washroom. It can be confirmed that many people with phobias can recall a traumatic
conditioning event when their phobia began (O¨st & Hugdahl, 1981)
Idiosyncratic Case Conceptualization
Early Experiences
Divorce
Assumptions Activated
My future is dark
Symptoms of Depression
Somatic: Headache
Trigger
Going to washroom
Perceived Threat
Anxiety
The management plan was devised on the basis of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy
Case conceptualization
To alter the client’s negative beliefs and views regarding her and world.
Rapport Building
Rapport was build with client by asking her favorite activities etc. Therapist initiated
rapport by introducing herself, by active listening and showing empathy toward her issues.
Trustworthy relationship with client and was billed by therapist and confidentiality was assured
to client.
Clinical interview was also conducted with client in order to probe the history of present
illness and stressors of the client. Therapist took the subjective ratings of presenting problem.
This ranged from 0-10 point severity rating scale. The purpose of this rating was explained to
client that this will be helpful for therapist to devise appropriate management plan and to assess
its effectiveness.
Rapport was easily built with the therapist as she started explaining her issues to the
therapist
Psycho education
The client was psycho-educated regarding her problem. Cognitive model of depression
was used to inform her how her symptoms were persisting by explaining the vicious cycle to her.
The client was also informed about possible causal factors and other factors which played an
important role in the maintenance of her depressive symptoms and phobia. Psychoeducation was
further broadened by informing her about the details of the therapeutic process and the time of
each session. She was educated about automatic thoughts and negative automatic thoughts
through ABC model. She was educated that NATs were a part of her depressive state and led her
to believe that these negative thoughts resulted in impaired functioning. Model of CBT was also
explained to the client. Panic cycle was introduced to make her understand her fear and reason
why she started having bodily symptoms. She was also informed regarding the possible ways to
get the treatment along with the affectivity of treatment. The client reported to have clear
Daily thought record was given to the client to get the details about her negative
automatic thoughts and fear. The chart was given to the client and she was asked to fill it
according to her thoughts. After getting the filled chart the negative automatic thoughts (NAT’s)
and her fear of washroom were identified which were catered then in the upcoming sessions.
(See Appendix C:
Verbal Challenging
In the present case reattribution training was done to help the client in identifying her
maladaptive attributions i.e. whatever happened to the client attributed it totally to herself which
depicted that client had internal attribution style of negative events occurring in her life. In this,
the client was asked to tell the last event and the attribution to that event was discussed. The
client was then explained the link between attribution given to the event and the associated
feelings i.e. sadness, worthlessness and hopelessness. It helped in understanding the role of
The client was also challenged regarding her fear using ‘What…If’ questioning. She was
guided about her maladaptive thoughts that activated her bodily symptoms in washroom. Panic
cycle was also explained to the client to make her understand what are the reasons that hold her
fear in enclosed washroom. She understood the cycle and related it with herself .
Relaxation Exercises
The client was taught Progressive Muscle Relaxation and Deep Breathing to alleviate and
manage her physiological and somatic symptoms. She was given the instructions in written form
and was asked to practice them twice a day. Moreover it also helped in teaching her the
discrimination in relaxed and tensed states. She was asked to practice this exercise in her daily
routine to keep herself relax and calm. The client reported that her headaches and general body
activity sheet and PMR were used. It was done with the client, in which the client was asked to
follow the tasks and routine devised in the session with the help of the client and the therapist.
She was asked to rate her mood on a 100 point scale before and after performing the given task.
She was also given the importance and role of this activity in the therapy and the management of
her symptoms. Through this technique, the client was inclined to presume a normal daily routine
and less time was spent in negative thoughts and helplessness. The schedule gave the client a
sense of direction and self-control. It was kept under consideration to enable client to seek
pleasure from her favorite activities which were being ignored by her due to her symptoms
negative experiences. A written chart was given to the client initially to rate her mood before and
after each activity performed. Later, the charts were withdrawn and the client began to mentally
rate the mastery and pleasure to enable her to automatically do so. (See Appendix C: )
Lethargy Cycle
Lethargy cycle was explained to the client to make her able to understand the vicious
cycle of depression and its role in lethargy. She understood the cycle and decided to break it by
her inner motivation. She was guided regarding controlling of the factors which led towards the
Double Column
The client was educated regarding the logical errors to help her identify her own faulty
logics. She was given examples of her daily life. The technique was used to identify the
maladaptive thoughts. In the next session, when the client had identified her illogical thinking,
she was helped to generate rational responses and was given it as homework to practice at home.
The client was able to generate logical responses to negative thoughts that came to her mind.(See
Appendix C: )
To induce sense of gratitude in the client
She was guided to manage her grudges in healthy manner. She was asked to generate a
list of things she is grateful about in her life. A list of gratitude was maintained by asking the
client. It made her able to understand that she had many positive things and people in her life. It
Coping statements were also given to the clients to deal with her fear in washroom. The
coping statement were short statements like “I can control my fear”, “nothing will happen to me
if I think this way”, “I am powerful than my symptoms” written on the flash cards. The client
was asked to repeat them loudly whenever she felt anxious in the washroom. These statements
helped the client in dealing with her thoughts that used to disturb her in the washroom and lead
Behavioral Experiments
Initially the client was asked to imagine the situation she was fearful of in the session
room. The therapist dictated all the cues that made her fearful in the washroom but she couldn’t
experience the symptoms as she reported that she will not have the symptoms this way. Then the
daughter of the client was guided about how to perform behavioral experiment at home. She was
guided to close the door initially at 60 degree angle and stand outside the washroom. She was
guided to rate the anxiety every time she goes to washroom. When the anxiety was reduced she
was to guided to reduce the angle of closing the door at 30 degree and rate the anxiety. The
symptoms of anxiety, palpitations and sweating started reducing as she was asked to practice
coping statement during these experiments. These behavioral experiments and coping statements
Outcome of Therapy
Post assessment
Table 5
Pre- and Post-Treatment Subjective Ratings Of Presenting Complaints By The Client On 0-10
Point Scale
Sadness 10 5
Loss of interest 9 5
Feelings of hopelessness 9 5
Fatigue 8 3
Crying spells 9 2
Table 6
Pre and post Raw score, Cutoff and corresponding Remarks of BDI at pre-treatment level
The comparison of pre and post treatment revealed significant improvement in the level
Table 7
Pre and post Raw score, Cutoff and corresponding Remarks of BAI at pre-treatment level
27 Moderate 14 Mild
The comparison of pre and post treatment revealed significant improvement in the level
Graph 1
10
4
Pre treatment ratings
Post treatment ratings
2
0
ss e t ss ue lls
ne ur es ne pe oo
m
d as ter
ss atig s r
Sa le in le F g sh
fp of pe yin wa
ss
o st Ho Cr d
Lo Lo se
clo
n
ofe
ar
Fe
Critical Evaluation
The client was 48 years old female who was diagnosed with Major Depressive Disorder
and Specific phobia. Therapeutic techniques which were used were Psychoeducation,
engagement of the client in therapy, Deep breathing, Progressive Muscle Relaxation, Pleasant
activity Sheet Identification of negative thoughts and Double column technique. All the
techniques proved to be very effective with the client as there was marked improvement in the
symptoms of the client. Behavioral experiment was also proved to be very effective.
9 sessions were conducted with the client and post treatment revealed significant
improvement in the severity of symptoms and level of functioning. Follow up sessions were
suggested to be taken.
References