Professional Documents
Culture Documents
4 Modulo
4 Modulo
3
Evidence that Supports the Effectiveness
of OT-SI with Individuals with ASD
4
Challenges in Determining Effectiveness
Challenges in ASD Population
• Heterogeneity in strengths and challenges in ASD population
• Heterogeneity in sensory differences and challenges
• Heterogeneity in how these differences impact functional performance
and participation areas
• Heterogeneity in contexts and supports provided to individuals with ASD
Challenges in Research
• Inconsistencies in use of outcome measures
• Inconsistencies in clinical environments when applying sensory integration
intervention
• Inconsistencies in fidelity to OT‐SI intervention
• Inconsistencies in intervention dosage
• Inconsistencies in knowledge/training of occupational therapists related to
sensory integration
5
Evidence to Support OT-SI
Improvements in functional performance and participation areas
• Individualized goals on Goal Attainment Scaling (Pfeiffer et al., 2011; Watling & Hauer, 2015; Schaaf et
al., 2013)
• Motor skills (Steinbrenner et al., 2020)
• Cognition, pre‐academic, and academic skills (Steinbrenner et al., 2020; May‐Benson
& Koomar, 2010)
• Improved sleep (Watling & Hauer, 2015; Piravej et al., 2009)
• Adaptive behavior and self‐help (Steinbrenner et al., 2020)
• Play skills & social responsiveness (Pfeiffer et al., 2011; Ayres, 1980; Dunbar et al., 2015)
• Decreased self‐stimulatory and self‐injurious behaviors (Watling & Hauer, 2015; Ayres, 1980;
Smith et al., 2005; Roberts et al., 2007, Steinbrenner et al., 2020)
• Reduced caregiver assistance in self‐care and social participation (Pfeiffer et al., 2011;
Watling & Hauer, 2015; Schaaf et al., 2013)
• Improved family participation in community activities and outings (Schaaf & Nightlinger,
2007)
Improved Outcomes
• Language & communication
• Increased awareness of and interaction with the environment
• Social relatedness
• Engagement in purposeful activity
• Decreased self‐stimulatory behavior 7
Evidence to Support OT-SI
Blanche, E. I. , & Reinoso, G. (2007). Literature review: Sensory processing deficits in the autism spectrum.
Chilean Journal of Occupational Therapy, 7 pp. 59 ‐ 68. doi:10.5354/0717‐5346.2007.79
Lang, R., O’Reilly, M., Healy, O., Rispoli, M., Lydon, H., Streusand, W., Davis, T., Kang, S., Sigafoos, J., Lancioni, G.,
Didden, R., & Giesbers, S. (2012). Sensory integration therapy for autism spectrum disorders: A systematic
review. Res Autism Spectr Disord, 6(3), 1004‐1018. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rasd.2012.01.006
Case‐Smith, J., Weaver, L. L., & Fristad, M. A. (2015). A systematic review of sensory processing interventions for
children with autism spectrum disorders. Autism: The international journal of research and practice, 19(2), 133–
148. https://doi.org/10.1177/1362361313517762
Watling, R.L., Hauer, S. (2015). Effectiveness of Ayres Sensory Integration and Sensory‐Based Interventions for
People with Autism Spectrum Disorder: A Systematic Review. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 69(5),
1‐12.
Schaaf, R. C., Dumont, R. L., Arbesman, M., & May‐Benson, T. A. (2018). Efficacy of Occupational Therapy Using
Ayres Sensory Integration®: A Systematic Review. The American Journal of occupational therapy: Official
publication of the American Occupational Therapy Association, 72(1), 7201190010p1–7201190010p10.
https://doi.org/10.5014/ajot.2018.028431
Schoen, S. A., Lane, S. J., Mailloux, Z., May‐Benson, T., Parham, L. D., Smith Roley, S., & Schaaf, R. C. (2019). A
systematic review of Ayres sensory integration intervention for children with autism. Autism research: Official
journal of the International Society for Autism Research, 12(1), 6–19. https://doi.org/10.1002/aur.2046
8
Recommendations for Clinicians
Working with Individuals with ASD
9
Recommendations for General Practice with Individuals with ASD
Shift attention from inward focus to outward engagement with the
environment and others
Provide reinforcement and motivation for attending to and engaging with
others
Provide an enriched environment
Visual Visuodyspraxia
Sensory Integration Intervention
General Concepts
Type of Issue Sensory Experience Adaptive Response
Gravitational Insecurity • Start with anterior/posterior pelvic tilt • Stay in the optimal band
• Linear vertical experiences with prop • Grade experiences so that you do
• Practice falling into space with not see anxiety, sweating, or crying
deep touch or prop after the
Modulation Based Concerns
experience
Inadequate Vestibular Postural Intense rotary inputs in various head • Increased postural responses
Patterns Related to Problems in Perception and
Inadequate Vestibular Ocular While swinging, facilitate coordination of head Increased automatic and conscious eye
Responses and eye movements movements
• static person to moving person
• static environment to moving
environment
Inadequate Vestibular Bilateral While moving on suspended equipment, Better coordinated movements
Integration assist child in pushing & pulling in a
coordinated way.
Inadequate Proprioceptive • Heavy work activities Better grading of force and use of muscle
Processing o lifting, carrying, pulling, hanging synergies
• Be aware of biomechanical alignment
• Encourage muscle synergies
Inadequate Tactile • Enhanced full body tactile inputs Improved body schema and awareness of
Discrimination while the child is navigating 3D space body relationship to objects
• Increase the complexity of tactile inputs.
Combine textures.
18
Photo courtesy of Linsey Grunes
Sensory Experiences
• The sensory experiences, the combination of sensory
information, and the way in which we engage individuals with
ASD can be very different depending on…
• The opportunities provided within the environment,
therapeutic equipment, and the creativity of the therapist
• Individualized evaluation and analysis of the assessment data
• Improvement in function and participation
• The importance of play and fun
• The constant search for increasingly complex adaptive
responses
• Engaging the individual’s interests/inner drive; child “led” and
“shaped” by OT
19
Examples of Sensory Experiences
22
Examples of Sensory Experiences
24
Photo courtesy of Gustavo Reinoso, 2022
Examples of Sensory Experiences
25
Examples of Sensory Experiences
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
Assignment: Complete and submit this assignment through the Assignments tool. 27
Assignment: Sensory Experience
1 2 3
5 6
4
28
Photo courtesy ofJanet Gunter & Gustavo Reinoso, 2022
Adaptive Responses
An effective response or interaction with the environment
• A challenge that can be met successfully
• Promotes personal growth
• Promotes mastery over the environment
• Utilizes and organizes the sensory information in the
environment
• Range in complexity:
– Simpler adaptive responses can be innate
– More complex require initiative and cognition
– Long‐term increase in repertoire of activities and health
29
Adaptive Responses
• The child’s ability to obtain and maintain the optimal level of
arousal and prepare the central nervous system to engage in
the highest level of an adaptive response
30
Adaptive Responses
• Initiates, plans, and completes a novel, complex
activity that includes novel motor planning, timing,
and multiple adaptive response within one activity
• Initiates and maintains a simple 2‐3 step activity that
requires novel or complex motor planning
• Initiates and maintains an activity that requires
known and simple movements
• Initiates an activity the requires simple and familiar
movements, but cannot maintain them
• Alternates between use of contractions and
relaxation of muscle groups
• Holds on and stays still
• Responds to passive stimuli
31
Ayres, 1980 Image source: https://freesvg.org/1465450581
Adaptive Responses in Functional
Performance Areas
• Increase in language & functional communication
• Improved social skills
• Decrease in stereotyped & repetitive behaviors
• Improved imitation
• Decrease in aggressive and/or self‐injurious behaviors
• Increased engagement (with you or others in environment)
• Regulation (co‐regulation, self‐regulation)
• Decreased behavioral rigidity, increased flexibility
• Improved ideation, attention & organization
• Decreased levels of support and direction required for successful
participation
32
Exercise: Adaptive Responses 1 Table
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Download the forms for this exercise from the “Download Lecture” link near the top right corner of this screen. 33
Please complete this exercise on your own before downloading the answers.
Exercise: Adaptive Response 1 Photo
34
Photo courtesy of Gustavo Reinoso. ©Copyright, do not reproduce without permission
Exercise: Adaptive Responses 1 Possible
Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive response(s) you will be promoting Context/ Physical What will you
experience(s theme of environment that do to
) related to play will be used (e.g., establish and
the specialized clinic, maintain the
pattern(s) of home, school, park, therapeutic
dysfunction natural alliance?
environment, etc.)
1. Flexion against gravity
2. Vestibular (because it is probably on a rotary
device)
3. Proprioception when holding on (if therapist
emphasizes client holding on)
4. Feedback motor planning (getting on and off)
5. Feedforward motor planning (interacting with
stable or moving objects, while the equipment is
in motion)
6. Ocular stability if while the swing is moving
the child must reach for objects or throw at a
target 35
Exercise: Adaptive Responses 2 Table
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Download the forms for this exercise from the “Download Lecture” link near the top right corner of this screen. 36
Please complete this exercise on your own before downloading the answers.
Exercise: Adaptive Responses 2 Photo
37
Photo courtesy of Gustavo Reinoso. ©Copyright, do not reproduce without permission
Exercise: Adaptive Responses 2 Possible
Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive response(s) you will be Context/ Physical environment What will you do
experience(s) promoting theme of that will be used (e.g., to establish and
related to the play specialized clinic, maintain the
pattern(s) of home, school, park, therapeutic
dysfunction natural environment, alliance?
etc.)
Download the forms for this exercise from the “Download Lecture” link near the top right corner of this screen. 39
Please complete this exercise on your own before downloading the answers.
Exercise: Adaptive Responses 3 Photo
40
Photo courtesy of Gustavo Reinoso. ©Copyright, do not reproduce without permission
Exercise: Adaptive Responses 3
Possible Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive response(s) you will be Context/ Physical What will you do to
experience(s) promoting theme of environment that establish and
related to the play will be used (e.g., maintain the
pattern(s) of specialized clinic, therapeutic
dysfunction home, school, park, alliance?
natural
environment, etc.)
41
Context of Play
• Honor differences in play preferences, meaning, and intrinsic
motivation
• Build on play skills – imitation, symbolic and constructional
play
• Teach parts of activities first to engage in a whole play
activity
• Balance preferences and need for repetitive play with
redirection and introduction of novelty
• Utilize yourself and peers to build social and collaborative
play, consider as adaptive responses
42
Video: Context of Play 1
Use focused interests as a starting point
46
Video courtesy of Janet Gunter
Context of Play 3
Possible Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive response(s) you Context/theme of Physical What will you do to
experience(s) will be promoting play environment that establish and maintain
related to the will be used (e.g., the therapeutic
pattern(s) of specialized clinic, alliance?
dysfunction home, school, park,
natural environment,
etc.)
The sensory Although he had trouble with Opportunities for Specialized clinic The OT balances the
experiences in this task, particularly the creative free play and structure and organization
this activity imitation part, adaptive trial and error. Th OT of the session with
includes: responses included his brings materials from opportunities for creative
vestibular and spontaneous initiation of the previous play free play and trial and error.
proprioceptive appropriate use of the blocks to activity to the next to
input, continue stacking, participation encourage him to She watches first as James
in the car activity a second time, expand his ideation changes the play trajectory
pushing the car up and use of this object to understand his intention
independently , and motor in different play instead of immediately
planning to get into the car. schemes. redirecting him back to the
structured task.
47
Therapeutic Alliance
Ensure Physical Safety
• Be alert and prepare for unexpected and dramatic changes in
regulation, unpredictable movements and behaviors, lack of
awareness of environment
Download the forms for this exercise from the “Download Lecture” link near the top right corner of this screen. 53
Please complete this exercise on your own before downloading the answers.
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 1 Video
54
Video courtesy of Janet Gunter
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 1
Possible Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive Context/ Physical What will you do to establish and maintain the
experience(s) response(s) theme of environment that therapeutic alliance?
related to the you will be play will be used (e.g.,
pattern(s) of promoting specialized clinic,
dysfunction home, school, park,
natural
environment, etc.)
1. Scaffolds the activity and direction
2. Invites his engagement and allows time for a
response
3. Provides verbal direction, and allows time for a
response
4. Models the task and allows time for a response
5. Allows increased time for processing
6. Elicits language and problem solving through
asking questions and providing choices
7. Offers alternative responses to verbal/language
8. Uses affect to increase arousal
55
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 2 Video
56
Video courtesy of Linsey Grunes
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 2 Table
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive Context/theme Physical environment What will you do to establish
experience(s) response(s) you of play that will be used (e.g., and maintain the therapeutic
related to the will be specialized clinic, alliance?
pattern(s) of promoting home, school, park,
dysfunction natural environment,
etc.)
Download the forms for this exercise from the “Download Lecture” link near the top right corner of this screen. 57
Please complete this exercise on your own before downloading the answers.
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 2
Possible Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive Context Physical environment What will you do to establish and maintain the
experience(s) response(s) /theme that will be used (e.g., therapeutic alliance?
related to the you will be of play specialized clinic, home,
pattern(s) of promoting school, park, natural
dysfunction environment, etc.)
58
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 3 Video
59
Video courtesy of Linsey Grunes & Joan Surfus
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 3 Table
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive Context/theme Physical environment What will you do to establish
experience(s) response(s) you of play that will be used (e.g., and maintain the therapeutic
related to the will be specialized clinic, alliance?
pattern(s) of promoting home, school, park,
dysfunction natural environment,
etc.)
Download the forms for this exercise from the “Download Lecture” link near the top right corner of this screen. 60
Please complete this exercise on your own before downloading the answers.
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 3
Possible Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive Context Physical What will you do to establish and maintain the
experience(s) response(s) /theme of environment that therapeutic alliance?
related to the you will be play will be used (e.g.,
pattern(s) of promoting specialized clinic,
dysfunction home, school,
park, natural
environment, etc.)
61
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 4 Video
62
Video courtesy of Linsey Grunes & Joan Surfus
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 4 Table
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Sensory Adaptive Context/theme Physical environment What will you do to establish
experience(s) response(s) you of play that will be used (e.g., and maintain the therapeutic
related to the will be specialized clinic, alliance?
pattern(s) of promoting home, school, park,
dysfunction natural environment,
etc.)
Download the forms for this exercise from the “Download Lecture” link near the top right corner of this screen. 63
Please complete this exercise on your own before downloading the answers.
Exercise: Therapeutic Alliance 4
Possible Responses
A. Link client’s reason for referral with identified pattern(s) of dysfunction
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
64
Relationship-Based Intervention
• Observe & identify subtle social and engagement cues (i.e. follow gaze and
body orientation, sensory cues) these may be more subtle due to differences
in communication & processing
• Keep in mind that signals and cues can be very subtle due to differences in
communication and processing (e.g., use of eye gaze to show intent/choices,
slight changes in facial expression or body language, etc.)
• Experiment with various ways to communicate (use visual strategies, body and
environmental cues, simple auditory cues)
• Allow for increased time to establish therapeutic connection and develop trust
• Adjust your pace for synchrony, follow the child’s rhythm and temporal cues
• Therapeutic use of self for co‐regulation and in grading social demands of
activity
• Incorporate peer relationships to facilitate social skill development, social
communication and for opportunities for imitation
65
Relationship-Based Intervention
Collaboration in Activity Choices:
• Use strengths and focused interests as a starting point
B. Describe 1 treatment activity based on sensory integration theory and intervention principles
C. Clearly identify the components of your sensory integration treatment activity
Assignment: Complete and submit this assignment through the Assignments tool. 68
Measuring Outcomes
How can we systematically measure our client’s
progress in a way where we can both identify gains
in functional performance, while also identifying
improvements in underlying sensory factors?
69
Measuring Outcomes
Proximal Outcomes Distal Outcomes
“The identified factors “The skills, abilities, and behaviors
that affect participation” that are expected to change in
(Faller et al., 2016, p. 2)
response to the intervention”
(Faller et al., 2016, p.2)
Example: changes in
responsivity to tactile input Example: decreased anxiety and
increased independence in
bathing/showering routine
71
Knowledge Check 1
In recent manuals that identify current clinical practices
used with individuals with ASD, sensory integration is
considered to be which of the following:
72
Knowelege Check 2
Occupational therapists who feel confident in their use
of sensory integration perceived greater progress in
children with ASD
A. True
B. False
73
Knowledge Check 3
One of the challenges faced in the investigation and
generalization of evidence to support the use of SI with
individuals with ASD is that they present with which of the
following:
A. Negative results
B. Mixed results
C. Positive results only related to motor skills
D. Positive results
75
Knowledge Check 5
A 4‐year‐old client with a diagnosis of ASD was referred due to problems with dressing
and grooming routines. Results of their OT‐SI evaluation indicate that many of their
difficulties appear to be related to a pattern of dysfunction related to tactile hyper‐
responsiveness. During their intervention you try to incorporate the following sensory
experiences:
A. Deep pressure, loud tone of voice, and positive affect to the increase in the level
of arousal
B. Light touch to decrease over‐responsivity and get them used to light touch
D. Fast, rotary vestibular input followed by 10 minutes of soft auditory input while
applying deep pressure with pillows covered in different fabric/materials
76
Additional References
• Steinbrenner, J. R., Hume, K., Odom, S. L., Morin, K. L., Nowell, S. W., Tomaszewski,
B.,Szendrey, S., McIntyre, N. S., Yücesoy‐Özkan, S., & Savage, M. N. (2020). Evidence‐based
practices for children, youth, and young adults with Autism. The University of North Carolina
at Chapel Hill, Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute, National Clearinghouse on
Autism Evidence and Practice Review Team.
• Kashefimehr, B., Kayihan, H., & Huri, M. (2018). The effect of sensory integration therapy on
occupational performance in children with autism. OTJR: Occupation, Participation, and
Health, 38(2), 75‐83. https://doi.org/10.1177/1539449217743456
• Schoen, S. A., Lane, S. J., Mailloux, Z., May‐Benson, T., Parham, L. D., Smith Roley, S., &
Schaaf, R. C. (2019). A systematic review of ayres sensory integration intervention for
children with autism. Autism research : official journal of the International Society for Autism
Research, 12(1), 6–19. https://doi.org/10.1002/aur.2046
77