Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pinch ChildbirthFemaleFigurines 1983
Pinch ChildbirthFemaleFigurines 1983
Pinch ChildbirthFemaleFigurines 1983
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
ANIMADVERSIONES
Geraldine Pinch
(Tab. V-VI)
Orientalia - 27
The Bed
Plant Decoration
The central figure of the woman on the bed is similar in many respects
to the corresponding figure on the ostraca. Both detached and attached
figures are usually lying down with their arms at their sides (Plate VI and
VA 2344). The attached figures almost always occupy the centre of the bed,
leaving no room for a male partner. B. Bruyere does however illustrate a
detached fertility figurine sitting up and suckling a child. He states that
quite a number of these figures were found at Deir el-Medina18. On the
ostraca the main figure is more often clothed than naked but with the figurines
this is reversed. Some of the seated figurines from Deir el-Medina were cloth-
ed, and occasionally a reclining figure is painted white, which probably in-
dicates clothing19. The majority however are naked. Their slender bodies
are painted either red or, less commonly, yellow, with the pubic triangle some-
times marked in black.
A girdle round the hips is sometimes shown, and a broad collar and large,
disc earrings are often worn. Both collar and earrings also occur on many
of the naked or semi-naked figures on the ostraca (Plate V).
The headgear consists of a long, full wig, whose elaborate plaiting can
be seen on some stone examples 20 . As on the ostraca (Plate V and Brunton
and Engelbach, Gurob pl. 15.6), a fillet and lotus are often worn and the wig
may be surmounted by the mysterious "incense cone" (Plate VI). This cone
is given particular prominence on the ostraca and on some examples a dish
containing a cone is shown under the bed or being presented to the mother 21 .
The Child
19 London BM 55595.
20 London BM 2367; London UC 16758.
21 BT 71; P 133; VA 2355, 2360-63, 2862.
22 For examples of other types of fertility figurines carrying children see
C. Desroches Noblecourt, " 'Concubines du mort' et mères de famille au Moyen
Empire", BIFAO 53 (1953) fig. 14, pl. 4; D. Downes, The Excavations at Esna,
1905-1906 (Warminster 1974) fig. 48; W. Hayes, The Sceptre of Egypt I (New
York 1953) fig. 13; The Sceptre of Egypt II (New York 1959) fig. 6; W. M. F.
Petrie, Objects in Daily Use (London 1927) pl. 52; London BM 23424.
23 J. Borriau and A. Millard, "The Excavation of Sawama in 1914 by
G. Wainwright and T. Whittemore", TEA 57 (1971) 33, pl. 17.
24 BT 67; P 132; VA 2337, 2340, 2347, 2348.
26 VA 2337, 2338, 2858.
26 Brunton and Engelbach, Gurob pl. 47 b; Bruyère, Rapport sur les fouilles
de Deir el Médineh ( 1934-5 ) fig. 59; Hölscher, Medinet H abu V, 11, fig. 12; Mi-
chalowski et al., Tell Edfu 1939 (Cairo 1956) pl. 25; G. Roeder, Hermopolis
1929-39 (Hüdesheim 1959) pl. 47.
the chest to hold her breast and the wig is tucked out of the way behind the
left shoulder.
In a larger number of models, the child lies at the mother's side, usually
on the right (Plate VI). The child's face is often level with the mother's thighs
and the woman's fingers sometimes touch the child's head, or upraised hand.
These two positions correspond to what is found on the ostraca, where the
child is either suckling, or lying beside its mother. On the ostraca the mother
is always sitting up, while in the figure groups she is usually lying flat on the
bed or slab. This apparent contrast is probably due to the different media
and should not be interpreted too literally 27 .
Subsidiary Figures
Vandier d'Abbadie suggested that it was the ka of the newborn child. How-
ever the tufted hairstyle and the posture are strongly reminiscent of the paint-
ing of a Nubian dancer in Theban tomb 78 33 . Another Deir el-Medina
ostracon, VA 2858, shows a woman sitting on a stool suckling a child. A small
black servant washes her feet, while a second attendant holds up a mirror.
In front of this group is a male figure, dressed in kilt and broad collar. His
head appears to be partially shaven, but six long tufts of hair are visible. The
man, who is holding a hand to his forehead and kicking up one leg, is clearly
dancing 34 .
It is possible therefore that the black figures found with some fertility
figurines, represent attendants engaged in a dance. A Nubian servant, or
a dwarf, may perhaps have taken on the role of Bes and danced to protect
mother and child. Kemp describes a wall painting showing dancing Bes figures
which he associates with the "Wochenlaube" scenes, in a workman's house
at el-e Amarna.
found in quantity at other New Kingdom town sites 38, and the detailed pro-
venance is known for about sixty figures from el-f Amarna 39.
A small number of the type of figurine associated with model beds, were
found in temple refuse at Deir el-Medina40. Some similar figures occurred
among votive offerings in Hathor shrines at Serabit el-Khadim and Mirgissa
and in temple refuse of the late New Kingdom at Armant, Hermopolis and
Memphis41. Any analysis of the functions of the fertility figurines, must
therefore take into account their varied context.
Discussion of the fertility figurines of all types has tended to polarise
between those who see the figures as primarily concerned with conception and
birth, and those who associate them with sexual pleasure, whether for male
or female. As Kemp points out, Brunner-Traut has been criticised for failing
to recognise an "erotic element" in many of the ostraca she characterises as
"Wochenlaube" scenes42.
Several scholars have seen the figurines as primarily erotic43. Der ch
associates them with the probable sexual connotations of hair-dressing scene
A. Hermann compares them to a Deir el-Medina ostracon, VA 2345, which
shows a woman in a transparent dress reclining on a bed. He sees both as
reflecting the imagery of New Kingdom love poetry and to him the frequent
presence of a child on the bed is no obstacle to an erotic interpretation 45.
Such an interpretation might seem to be supported by the Turin Erotic
Papyrus. In the erotic scenes on one part of this papyrus, the female par-
ticipant is clad, like the fertility figurines, only in her jewellery and a full wig
with lotus and fillet46. Other elements in common with the "Wochenlaube"
scenes include twining convolvulus, toilet items under the bed and a dwarfish
attendant, but since deliberate parody may be intended, the papyrus is an
ambiguous piece of evidence.
L. Keimer went so far as to suggest that all types of fertility figurine
represent women of the "demi-monde"; singers, dancers, concubines or even
prostitutes. One of his main arguments for this interpretation was the ap-
parent tattooing shown on some types of Middle Kingdom fertility figurine.
He also drew attention to various New Kingdom figurines and paintings which
show women with a figure of Bes on one or both thighs, and proposed that
this was the mark of a prostitute47. Since one fertility figurine from Kom
Medinet Ghurab, and another of Theban provenance48 (Plate VI), have marks
of this kind, the theory is of interest for the general interpretation of the figurines.
For the general association of tattooing with prostitution, Keimer can
only produce modern analogies. Although Bes can be linked with male sexu-
ality, especially in the Graeco- Roman Period, his connection with childbirth
is even better attested49. His role was that of a protector and a spell from
Papyrus Leiden I 348 recommends women in childbirth to wear a nm n sin
a "dwarf of clay" 50. A Bes amulet or tattoo might then be a charm worn
to protect women in childbirth, or possibly, to encourage conception. This
would certainly link Bes with sexual activity, but without the implications
of immorality which Keimer insisted on. The varied context of the fertility
figurines is a strong argument against regarding them as frivolous or obscene.
There is no obvious reason for depositing representations of prostitutes in the
graves of women or children; nor is there any evidence that such a practise
would be relevant in temples.
The presence of various types of fertility figurine among votive offerings
to Hathor, has led several scholars to refer to them as "Hathor figures", and
G. Hornblower saw all the figurines as representations of an Egyptian "Mother
Goddess" 51 . None of the types of fertility figurine resemble any known re-
presentation of Hathor. The common use of the figurines in the main city at
el-e Amarna, might also be used to argue against a direct identification with a
goddess.
Nevertheless, there is extensive evidence for Hathor's role as bestower
of human fertility and protector of women in childbirth. In a spell from Pa-
pyrus Leiden I 348 women are encouraged to identify with the birth pangs
of Dendara during their own confinement62. The identification of human
mothers and babies with the divine mother and child is known from texts
on Middle Kingdom apotropaic wands and from New Kingdom healing spells 5
S. Morenz has argued that the fertility figurines may be associated with
desses such as Hathor and Isis in that they represent women who might,
the crisis of birth, identify with the suffering and triumph of the divi
mother64. Because of Hathor 's role as patroness of lovers in New Kingdo
poetry, the connection of several types of fertility figurine with this godde
has also been used by those who see the models as primarily concerned w
sexual pleasure or potency 65 . Most of the followers of the "erotic" inter
tation prefer to view the figurines which are actually accompanied by childr
as a quite seperate group 66 . With all types of fertility figurine this is hard
justify, but especially in the case of the figures on beds.
There is frequently no appreciable difference in terms of posture, he
gear and ornaments between the figures with, and without children. Some
figures have the hair tucked behind the left shoulder, or even the right hand
holding the breast, when no child is visible 67 . Since this is the suckling po-
sition, a child is clearly implied. The inclusion of elements from the "Wochen-
laube" scenes, such as the snakes painted on the bed, or papyrus entwined with
convolvulus, also seem to suggest a child where none is shown58.
Although this resemblance between the models and the "Wochenlaube"
scenes supports the connection of the figurines with childbirth, an erotic element
need not be ruled out. Der chain applies his interpretation of the erotic signif-
icance of hair-dressing scenes to representations of married couples in tomb
reliefs59. If both the ostraca and the figurines are primarily concerned with
the successful production of children, this includes an association with con-
ception as well as childbirth.
There is no reason to suppose that Egyptian marriage partners rigidly
seperated a desire for children from the desire for sexual pleasure. The nudity
of the figures on beds, and the emphasis on the sexual organs in earlier types
of fertility figurine, should not be allowed to carry connotations of immorality.
It must be remembered that in the cause of fertility, the erotic, or even the
oļ) scene, have often been considered permissable in otherwise modest or prudish
socities 60 .
Kemp concludes that "These paintings are essentially prophylactic, il-
lustrating either the successful termination to childbirth and its ensuing period
of uncleaness or the deities who would ensure this (Bes and Thoëris) ..." 81 . The