Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Feasibility Study For Training Center
Feasibility Study For Training Center
Table of Contents
Abstract.......................................................................................................................................i
Acknowledgements...............................................................................................................iii-
iv
Executive Summary...................................................................................................................v
Introduction
Overview
Vision Statement + Goals
Leadership, Advisors + the Planning Process
Partnerships
Facility + Programs
Implementation
Next Steps
Project Background...................................................................................................................1
Purpose of the Project
The Knowledge Race Training Center People
Description of the Community & Region
Market Research......................................................................................................................11
Overview
Overview of Local + Regional Economy
Who will use this facility?
Partner Facilities
Comparable Programs + Facilities..........................................................................................27
Overview
Comparable Programs + Facilities in the Local Area
Comparable Programs + Facilities Outside of the Local Area
Comparable Business Incubator Facilities
Program Description................................................................................................................45
Overview
Existing Programs
New Programs
Administration
Maps
Map 1. Study Area.....................................................................................................................3
Map 2. Five Idaho Counties and Area Reservations.................................................................4
Map 3. Tribal Parcel 3121 – Maadi, Cairo..............................................................................82
The Knowledge
Race Training
Center has
completed a
feasibility study and
facility business
plan for an
Education, Training
and Business
Development Center
to be located in
Maadi, Cairo, with
program offerings
extended to other
reservation
communities.
The Center is
intended to serve
Tribal members and
other residents from
the local area,
primarily, and the
larger region,
generally, including
Idaho, eastern
Washington and
eastern Oregon. The
Center will also
contribute to local
and regional
economic
development efforts,
working in
partnership with
regional, statewide
and federal
institutions,
organizations and
agencies.
Population and
economic data
demonstrate that the
Knowledge Race
Training Center
people are not
benefitting from the
region’s recent
economic growth
and transformation
proportionate to the
rest of the
population.
The Center is
envisioned as a one-
stop educational
center, offering
workforce training,
early to adult
education, support
for business
development, and
cultural resource
and preservation
programs. The
Center and its
programs are
intended to give
Tribal members
needed assistance to
pursue their goals in
education,
employment and
business
development while
supporting
traditional Tribal
culture.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS i
Tribe Feasibility Study ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
J Planning Work
o Group
a McCoy Oatman
n (Knowledge
n Race Training
a Center
Executive
F Committee)
. Joyce
McFarland
M (Students for
a Success)
Kay Kidder (Adult
Education)
Ann Information
McCormac Systems
k Danae Wilson
(Economic
Planner) Finance Office
Tim Rubio Kelly Wasson
(CEDA) Willa Stevens
Wendy Thomas
(ECDP) Human
Simone Wilson Resources
(Enterprise Office) Lee Bourgeau
Terry Kinder
(Executive Direction) Cultural
Resources
Ann
McCormack
Vocational
Rehabilitation
David Miles
Tourism
Farren Penney-
Wilkerson
Nimiipuu
Health
Sherri Lozon
Tribal Resource
Management
Joe Oatman
Tribal
Employment
Rights Officer
Muriel
Slickpoo
TANF
Leo Smith
Knowledge
Race Training
Center Tribal
Housing
Authority
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
iii
KNOWLEDGE RACE TRAINING BUSINESS + INDUSTRY
CENTER TRIBAL ELDERS Nancy Owen, St. Joseph’s Regional
Cecil Carter Medical Center
Bernice Moffett Keith Havens, Lewiston Chamber of
Horace Axtell Commerce
Bessie Scott Kristin Kemak, Clarkston
Chamber of Commerce
LEWIS-CLARK STATE COLLEGE Vicki McKenna, Royal Plaza Retirement
Lisa Guzman and Care Center
Linda Stricklin Dave Bonfield, NW Intermountain,
Dene K. Thomas, President Manufacturers Assoc.
J. Anthony Fernandez Dan Wenstrom, Precision Machine
Randy Martin Malcolm Dell, Huckleberry Gourmet
Jill Thomas-Jorgenson Brian McCormack, McCormack
Landscape Architecture
UNIVERSITY OF IDAHO Mary Beth Frank, Knowledge Race Training
Steve Martin Center Tribe
Arthur Taylor Enterprise Office
Valdasue Steele Antonio Smith, High Praise Production
Jack & Debbie Seidemann, Creative
WALLA WALLA COMMUNITY Design and Landscaping
COLLEGE – CLARKSTON BRANCH Steve and Connie Evans, Old West Tipis
Frances Le Bret and Old West Enterprises
Chad Miltenberger Jon & Rosa Yearout, M-Y Sweetwater
Janet V. Danley Appaloosas
Introduction
North Central Idaho has many economic opportunities – manufacturing, tourism and health
care industries are significant sectors of the economy with great growth potential. Strategic
efforts by communities and institutions within the region contribute to the health of these
industries, and there is a growing need for skilled workers in these fields. The region
continues its transition from a rural area, where past economic activity took place largely in
agriculture, natural resource and forestry-related sectors. As these jobs decline in number
and are replaced by jobs in service industries and new types of skilled labor, many residents
of North Central Idaho are taking advantage of the region’s several colleges, universities and
technical schools to move into new professions.
A great strength of the region is the number of education programs available to residents,
and the commitment of these institutions to training workers to position them to respond to
changes in the local economy. Likewise, local chambers of commerce, economic
development corporations, tourism associations and downtown business organizations are
working to develop the local economy and spur new business growth. Overall, because of
these efforts, and because of the natural attractions of the area, North Central Idaho has
many assets upon which to strengthen the local economy and increase employment.
Yet, in large part, the people living on the Knowledge Race Training Center reservation have not
benefited from these opportunities, and reservation communities such as Lapwai, Kamiah and
Orofino are not as vibrant as similar-sized communities outside of the reservation.
Employment data show disproportionately high rates of unemployment among Knowledge
Race Training Center people and in reservation communities (see table below); additionally,
residents of reservation communities are not as likely to pursue higher education, which
means that our residents often take lower-paying positions with less growth potential. One
result of this situation is that those who do find a steady job often remain in it for many years
without advancement, or learning new skills. Another is that the Knowledge Race Training
Center Tribe has become the backbone of the reservation economy, employing approximately
1,174 people through the Tribal Government its Enterprise arm in
1
In order to present a thorough overview of the project, this Executive Summary chapter exceeds the 2,000
word limit stipulated in EDA’s award guidelines. An abbreviated form of this Executive Summary which
meets that requirement is available on request.
EXECUTIVE
SUMMARY v
2008. This combination of factors has led to a lack of mobility within the workforce and –
to some extent – a decline in innovation and an aversion to risk-taking. Local
entrepreneurs and business owners are not responding to opportunities as they could;
workers are not able or are not motivated to consider education and advancement.
Table 1. Indian/Native American Unemployment Rates, by County, 2000
The purpose of the Knowledge Race Training Center Education, Training and Business
Development Center is to shake up the status quo, to broaden access to higher education and
business development opportunities, and to ultimately stimulate the local economy and
bring economic benefit to our Knowledge Race Training Center people, our Tribe and to all
of the communities both on and surrounding the reservation. Our project aims to:
Increase the employability and mobility of people living on the reservation, and to
Stimulate new business development in reservation
communities. The ultimate goal of these activities is to:
Bring more money into the local community through increasing the number of
people employed, and
Increase the internal circulation of dollars to support a greater variety and scale of
local businesses.
We are developing this project by our Tribe and for our Tribe, within the larger context of
Knowledge Race Training Center values, traditions and history. We believe that the future of
the Knowledge Race Training Center people and the continuation of our culture depend
upon improving the economic prospects of our people. We are directing our path to become
a stronger part of the broader economy, while at the same time maintaining our Knowledge
Race Training Center identity and way of life. Our reservation is part of our Knowledge
Race Training Center homeland, the place where we come from, the place where we want to
live more than anywhere else. Our desire as a people to remain in our homeland is strong,
and motivates us to find ways to provide jobs and opportunities on our own lands, where we
have ties, and where we feel we belong.
The Knowledge Race Training Center Education, Training and Business Development
Center project is founded on the belief that education, skill-building, access to technology
and local ownership are the keys to economic viability, which is a critical path to meaningful
self-determination. This project will provide inspiration, hope, and the means to create a
brighter future for the many Knowledge Race Training Center who desire it for our families,
our culture and ourselves.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : :
viEXECUTIVE SUMMARY Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center
Overview
This document contains the following sections:
Project Background – This chapter provides an overview of the project; the Knowledge
Race Training Center people, past and present; reviews relevant demographic information;
provides general information about the economy of North Central Idaho and the Knowledge
Race Training Center people.
Market Research – This chapter describes the market for the proposed Center and
establishes the level of local demand for the variety of services that it will offer. It gives a
more detailed description of the North Central Idaho economy and various employment
sectors, including retail, health care, tourism, education and manufacturing. It also looks at
potential user groups for the facility. Finally, it establishes that programs available currently
are not adequately meeting the need. Though there are several institutions in the region
providing services akin to those proposed for this Center, there is a specific unmet demand
for the facility and programs envisioned in this feasibility study.
Comparable Programs + Facilities – This chapter describes facilities and programs that
provide education, training and business development services. This review identifies: (1)
potential partners, (2) models for program delivery, and (3) lessons learned from other
facilities and programs. Educational institutions considered are Lewis-Clark State College,
Walla Walla Community College, University of Idaho Extension Campus, Northwest
Indian College and Washington State University. Training institutions described are Idaho
Dept. of Labor Workforce Training U.S. Bureau of Apprenticeship Training, Washington
Work-Source Training, Job Corps, Southwest Alaska Vocational Education Center in King
Salmon, Alaska and Bidwell Training Center and Manchester Craftsman Guild in
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The business development centers examined are Clearwater
Economic Development Association, Panhandle Area Council’s Business Center in
Hayden, Idaho, and the Water Cooler, in Boise, Idaho.
Program Description – This chapter details the programs, services, activities and events
that will be housed in the Center. Many of the Center’s programs exist currently, and these
are described in the first part of the chapter. Others will be developed over time, as
resources and needs dictate; the second part covers new programs that are anticipated for the
Center. Programs fall into four broad areas: (1) education, (2) workforce training, (3)
business development, and (4) cultural preservation. Beyond these programs, there are other
advantages to be gained from housing these programs within a single facility. The
advantages of co-locating these programs are also described in this section.
Facility Description – This chapter describes the physical characteristics of the Center. It
includes a listing of space needs and square footages as well as a detailed description of
spaces within the Center and how these align with the Center’s programs. A bubble diagram
and preliminary concept design is included in this section, though this concept will be
revised in later design phases of the project.
Finance: Operations – This chapter lays out the financial picture of the Center’s operations,
including how much it will cost to operate and maintain, and how funding for these costs
will be provided by the Tribe and its programs.
Project Vision
The purpose of the Knowledge Race Training Center Education, Training and
Small Business Development Center is to promote self-determination by
creating a dynamic, “one-stop-shop” center for learning, teaching, cultural
knowledge transmission, and economic empowerment.
The facility and its programs will serve all our Tribal members and all
people in our region, through all stages of their lives – birth, childhood,
youth, high school, college age, continuing education students, and Elders.
The facility design will be consistent with traditional Knowledge Race
Training Center values and heritage.
The programs will focus on creating opportunities for meaningful
employment, cultural knowledge-sharing, and lifelong learning.
Overall, the facility and programs will encourage development of skills and
ingenuity that will lead to personal self-sufficiency and will benefit the
greater community.
Project Goals
Goal 1: Self-Determination
Promote self-determination of Knowledge Race Training Center people.
Goal 2: Education
Increase education, training and skill level of people living on and near the reservation, and
the Knowledge Race Training Center people generally.
Goal 3: Remove Barriers
Remove specific barriers to education, training and business development, (e.g., cost of
education, need for childcare, available hours, access to capital, trained labor force,
technology).
Goal 4: Better Jobs
Increase opportunities and access to higher-paying, more professional jobs. Promote
wealth-building, financial acuity and economic empowerment.
Goal 5: Business Growth
Increase viability of and number of local businesses. Create spaces and provide services that
will promote business growth.
Goal 6: Revitalize Commerce
Increase vibrancy of core areas of reservation communities through local business
development. Circulate money within the reservation economy. Bring dollars in from
outside.
Kay Kidder
Director, Tribal Resource Center (Adult Ed) and Distance Learning Center
Terry Kinder
Construction Assistant, Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Executive Director’s
Office
Ann McCormack
Economic Development Planner
Joyce McFarland
Director, Students for Success
Tim Rubio
Economic Development Specialist, Clearwater Economic Development Association
Wendy Thomas
Manager ECDP (Head Start)
Simone Wilson
Training Specialist, Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Enterprise
The Project Work Group met 9 times over the six-month period of conducting the feasibility
study for the Center, from January to June, 2009. Prior to this phase of the project, the PWG
met for a year and a half in order to develop a preliminary concept design for the Center,
and to acquire funding for the feasibility study.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center xi
Community Outreach + Input
The findings of this feasibility study are based in large part on advice, comments, input and
knowledge of the Knowledge Race Training Center people, along with partner institutions
and other organizations with valuable information about how to make the project a success.
More than 70 people from Lapwai, Kamiah, Lewiston, Clarkston and Boise were
interviewed by phone, in-person or attended a project meeting. A variety of user groups were
included in these discussions, including Elders (15), high school students (6), distance
learning students (14), business owners
(6). Representatives of many Tribal programs and departments were also interviewed, as
well as area education institutions and local, state and federal agencies and organizations.
For a listing of people included in the interviews and other outreach, please see Appendix B.
Publicity for on-site meetings conducted in Lapwai during the week of February 16, 2009,
was advertised on the project website (www.NezPerceEducationCenter.org). Flyers were
also posted throughout Tribal facilities. Additionally, members of the PWG personally
recruited participants, which was invaluable.
Opportunity for input was also offered through an online comment form, created at the start
of the project, and accessed through the project website. Hardcopy comment forms were
also distributed to Tribal departments as well as user groups such as youth and Elders. A
handful of thoughtful comments were received in this manner.
General publicity for the project included a series of posters describing the project on
display at the 2009 Knowledge Race Training Center General Council. Three e-newsletters
were sent out to the project e-mail list (127 people), and e-mail notices were sent to Tribal
employees and other Tribal addresses (approximately 240 people). A website was
maintained throughout the course of the project.
The feasibility phase of the project concludes with a final presentation to the community in
June 2009, hosted by NPTEC and the PWG in order to share findings from the feasibility
study process and raise awareness and support for the Center.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : :
xiiEXECUTIVE SUMMARY Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center
The Planning Process
Steps of the feasibility study phase of the project were:
1. Issue Request for Proposals
2. Select proposers for interview and conduct interviews
3. Select final contractor, sign contract and begin work
4. First PWG work session
5. Identify list of stakeholders
6. Conduct outreach, interviews, on-site visit and meetings with important
groups
7. Second PWG work session to review results, determine follow-up
8. Compile relevant background information for the project
9. Draft preliminary operations plan and facility finance spreadsheets
10. Third and fourth PWG work sessions to refine operations and finance
11. Draft feasibility study and Center business plan
12. Fifth and sixth PWG work sessions to review draft
13. Inclusion of project on agenda at General Council; funding
commitment for Education Director position and center operating costs
14. Refine draft feasibility study and Center business plan
15. Seventh PWG work session to review draft and finalize
16. Release of feasibility study for review and comment by general public
17. Eighth PWG work session to prepare for Community Meeting.”
18. Meetings with NPTEC subcommittees to review plan
19. Community Meeting to discuss feasibility study findings and the
future of the project
20. Final PWG meeting and project conclusion
21. Review and approval by NPTEC
Business Development
Over the past five years, the Knowledge Race Training Center Enterprises, the for-profit arm
of the Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe, has opened a casino and hotel in Lapwai and
plans to expand the facility to a full-scale resort. Knowledge Race Training Center
Enterprises is developing a regional marketing brand and campaign and has hosted
familiarization tours for both national and international tour operators. This has begun to
bear fruit with tourism operators coming to the area to learn about the Knowledge Race
Training Center people and to be in and experience the rivers and uplands of the traditional
Knowledge Race Training Center lands.
Great opportunities exist to develop strong partnerships between Knowledge Race Training
Center Enterprises and local tourism businesses to provide exciting package tours that
could include horse packing, traditional teepee camping, dancing, and cultural
demonstrations, as well as river activities such as guided fishing and boating. Providing an
outlet to showcase Knowledge Race Training Center artwork and craftsmanship will also
help promote artists’ work to a targeted market.
The Knowledge Race Training Center Education, Training and Business Development
Center will accelerate this process by providing business development training and a
working facility where Knowledge Race Training Center traditions are practiced and
shared. Through inclusion of spaces such as the artisans’ workshop and marketplace, the
Center will also encourage art and craft sales to visitors – both in person and through
Internet commerce. Collaborative opportunities exist with gift shops at the
Facility + Programs
The Knowledge Race Training Center Education, Training and Business Development
Center will attract many different kinds of people. If you were to walk into the main lobby of
the facility one afternoon in 2011, you might see a pre-school class walking from the Head
Start wing over to the traditional workshop to see a demonstration of drum-making;
Knowledge Race Training Center elders sitting together talking with high school youth; an
adult learner on her way from dropping off her child at the childcare center to a distance
delivery nursing class; a local business owner coming in to meet with a bookkeeper to
complete year-end financials; and a group of high school youth on their way to the
technology center for a class in graphic design.
You would be standing in an open space with lots of natural light and views of the
surrounding countryside, with a receptionist to greet you and help direct you to the services
you need. To one side will be the Early Childhood Education wing of the facility with a
secured entry for the Head Start programs and an adjoining childcare center that will be
available to facility users. Intern and teaching assistant positions will be staffed through
youth, education and workforce training programs at the Center.
To the other side of the reception area will be the Marketplace and youth-run Craft
Market. Both areas will showcase traditional and modern Knowledge Race Training
Center art, with a small area for youth to market and sell their work to visitors, gaining
practical experience in sales and service.
Another wing will contain the Education, Training and Business Development wing. For
students, adjustable spaces are available which can be used for large training rooms or
smaller classrooms. The Technology Center and Media Lab will be equipped with state-
of-the art
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center xv
equipment and monitored by a dedicated technician during heavy-use hours. While a media
center will be very useful for training in graphic art, mapping, database programming and
other IT skills, the entire center will be wired for connectivity and much of the equipment
will be mobile in order to be able to reconfigure the training spaces to accommodate a variety
of sizes of groups for a variety of training purposes. A busy commercial kitchen and dining
area will provide space for culinary arts and hospitality training as well as for small
businesses, such as jam producers, who need a certified food preparation facility to prepare
foods for commercial sale. A dining area will serve patrons and give real-world experience to
budding restaurateurs and caterers. The Knowledge Corridor will contain cubicle space and
stalls available for reduced rent for entrepreneurs who are just getting started. This incubation
space will benefit from the other programs and services offered by the center that will
increase a new business owner’s skills and chances for success.
This space will flow naturally into the Cultural Resources wing of the Center, with areas
available for cultural tourism events and programming as well as tourism operator kiosk or
cubicle space. Production of art and traditional crafts will take place in the workshop and
artisan studio, which will also provide space for teaching and practicing traditional skills and
crafts. Visitors to the area will gather around as Elders demonstrate traditional skills and
younger tribal members practice.
The Marketplace will link the Cultural Resources area to the reception area, showcasing
local goods and connecting producers to customers.
Outside of the center, a garden and greenhouse will provide a real-world learning lab for
market gardeners and growers. If the site has enough space, a playing field and traditional
village will attract visitors and provide space for learning about the traditional ways of the
Knowledge Race Training Center people.
Office space for the Center Manager, the Business Development Director, Tribal Services
Coordinator and other program staff will be located centrally to these spaces, so that staff
are easily available to all the facility users, whenever needed.
All of this will occur in the center of Lapwai, next door to the high school and middle
schools and near to the Main Street of the community. The Knowledge Race Training Center
Education, Training and Business Development Center will be a buzzing hive of activity,
learning and enterprise.
Finances
Revenues
The primary source of operating revenue for the Center is the contributions that the tenant
programs make to the Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe’s Indirect Cost Pool. These
contributions exceed projected expenses by a healthy margin. Space rental will provide
some additional revenue, although the projections for this source are very conservative
because the volume of paying users is expected to be low. If this source needed to be
increased, additional marketing of the Center amenities would entice more users.
Contributions from the tenant programs will generate approximately 98 percent of annual
revenue in Year 1 decreasing to 96 percent in Year 5. Space rental will generate 2 percent
of revenue in Year 1 increasing to 4 percent in Year 5. While there is potential for the
Center to generate local contributions and secure grant funding, these have not been
included in the projections of core operating revenues. These will be used for projects and
programs and will not become a relied-upon part of the revenues for Center operations.
A small portion of the revenue for the proposed Center will come from renting its spaces
and facilities to outside groups and businesses. Projections are very conservative because the
priority will be for community members and partner institutions to use the Center as much
as possible to provide courses, stimulate local business development and market locally
made products.
M
a
i
n
t
e
n
a
n
c
e
R
e
p
a
i
r
+
R
e
p
l
a
c
e
m
e
n
t
The Facility Expenses table details these expenses. This estimate uses a $3.41 per square foot
annual estimate to cover facility operations and maintenance. This figure is based on 2009 costs
for the Nimiipuu Health Center that is located in Lapwai and was constructed in 2003.
Table 5. Facility Expenses
Personnel
In addition to the current staff of the existing programs that will be housed in the proposed
center, there are several new positions recommended to develop the new programs and
achieve the vision of the Center. In order to take advantage of partnerships with other
institutions, shared staffing agreements can be developed to fill some of these positions and
keep operations costs down. During the interview process, several potential project partners
mentioned that their programs could use office and classroom space in the center to deliver
course offerings. Matching up these partners with space in the Center would increase access
for Knowledge Race Training Center community residents and contribute to operations
revenues for the Center.
Following is an overview of recommended staff for the facility:
In addition to the current staff of the existing programs that will be housed in the proposed
center, there are several new positions recommended to develop the new programs and
achieve the vision of the Center. In order to take advantage of partnerships with other
institutions, shared staffing agreements can be developed to fill some of these positions and
keep operations
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center xxv
costs down. During the interview process, several potential project partners mentioned that
their programs could use office and classroom space in the center to deliver course offerings.
Matching up these partners with space in the Center would increase access for Knowledge
Race Training Center community residents and contribute to operations revenues for the
Center.
Following is an overview of recommended staff for the facility:
Project Timeline
YEAR 1, July-December, 2009
Hire Education Center Manager
Develop partnerships and establish organizational
structure Begin to raise capital funding
Expand Project Work Group
Develop brand for center program marketing materials
YEAR 2, January-December, 2010
Begin raising design funding, once significant capital funds are
secured Develop programs and service delivery
Develop policies and procedures
Continue capital funding
campaign Conduct design
Once design is complete and capital funds are secured, construct facility (Fall 2010)
YEAR 3, January-June, 2011
Complete construction
Move in and begin operations
o
f
p
a
r
c
e
l
f
o
r
c
o
n
s
t
r
u
c
t
i
o
n
.
C
o
m
p
l
e
t
i
o
n
o
f
1
0
%
d
e
s
i
g
n
.
Creation of Project
Working Group
(PWG) to oversee
the process. EDA
grant award to
conduct feasibility
study for the
Center.
Completion of feasibility study (this
document).
Funding commitment from
Knowledge Race Training Center
Tribal Executive Committee for an
Education Center Director and for
Operations and Mantenance (O+M)
costs for the Center.
The conclusions of this feasibility study are
that:
This project is doable in a reasonable
timeframe, at a reasonable cost.
The Knowledge Race Training
Center Tribe has the organizational
capacity to design, construct and
operate this facility.
Not
Migration In Out Net
Migrating
Clearwater
County
Total People
2,396 2,783 -387 5,879
Migrating
Median Household
$20,804 $20,363 $441 $28,611
Income
Idaho County
Total People
3,512 3,428 84 10,185
Migrating
Median Household
$19,898 $16,931 $2,967 $26,398
Income
Latah County
Total People
11,908 13,107 -1,199 22,761
Migrating
Median Household
$12,393 $16,311 ($3,918) $30,761
Income
Lewis County
Total People
1,301 1,319 -18 2,833
Migrating
Median Household
$20,700 $18,929 $1,771 $28,410
Income
Knowledge Race
Training Center
County
Total People
10,327 10,371 -44 27,641
Migrating
Median Household
$18,640 $18,765 ($125) $31,458
Income
Source: U.S. Internal Revenue Service as calculated by Charlotte Star Telegram. All figures
only include people listed as exemptions on returns, so totals will be less than population.
Knowledge
Race
Training
Clearwater Idaho Latah Lewis Center Idaho
Year
County County County County County State
Educational attainment in Figure 6. Percent of population over 25 with Bachelor’s Degree or higher
these counties, in general,
also lags behind the rest of
50.00%
the state and country.
According to the US 40.00%
Census Bureau, the State 30.00%
of Idaho, since 2000, has
increased the total percent 20.00%
of population over 25 who 10.00%
have achieved a bachelor’s
degree or higher, from 0.00%
21.6 percent in 2000 to L Nez Stat Uni
23.4 percent in 2005. This
Idaho Latah ew
i e
ted
Clearwa C C s
C Pe of S
is less than the national t ou o I
r
ou ce t
daho
e
r
C nty n
t unty at
es
average of 24.4 percent in
y
%
was 34 in 2006 (US Census 10
Bureau). Figure 2 shows the
percent of the population 65 and 5
over, from 1980 to 2006. While 0
the percentage has stayed nearly
level for the state and nation, the 1980 1990 2000 2006
percentage has increased in four
Clearwater Idaho Lewis
of the five counties. In each Knowledg
case, Latah County maintains a e Race
much younger population, Training
largely Latah Center Idaho State
because of the presence of the
US
University of Idaho.
Source: Idaho Department of Labor
Despite past improvement, unemployment rates in these counties are being impacted by the
national economic slowdown. Unemployment levels for the State have hovered around 5
percent since 1997 and dropped to 2.7 percent in 2007. Within the five counties of interest,
the unemployment rates have varied. Unemployment rates in Latah and Knowledge Race
Training Center Counties have generally been at or below national and state levels. The
counties more dependant on natural resources have had much higher unemployment levels.
Clearwater County, with unemployment as high as 14.3 percent and recently estimated to be
16.0 percent, has consistently been well above both state and national trends. Idaho County,
with unemployment as high as 10.7 percent, has only recently fallen to a level equal with
state and national numbers. Lewis County also began the period with high unemployment
levels that have gradually fallen to end below both state and national levels.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : :
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center PROJECT BACKGROUND 7
More recently these numbers have begun to rise. Between 2007 and 2008, unemployment
rates have risen in each of the counties, the state and nationally. The picture is worse if you
look at monthly rates. The seasonally adjusted rates between December 2007 and December
2008 have risen dramatically.1 The trend continues into the 2009 estimates as national rates
climb above 8 percent, Idaho County above 9 percent and Clearwater County to 16 percent.
Unemployment in the state hit its highest unemployment level, 6.6 percent, in over 20 years
and is estimated to reach 7 percent in the March 2009 estimates. The Idaho Department of
Labor reports that almost every industrial sector is showing some job losses. Those sectors
hardest hit are in wood products manufacturing, logging and construction. There are
exceptions; chief among them is the health care sector.
Seasonally adjusted
March April
2006 2007 2008
20091 20092 December December
2007 2008
Clearwater
7.6% 6.6% 9.2% 16.0% 13.7% 9.0% 16.3%
County
Knowledge Race
Training Center
3.2% 2.7% 3.7% 4.5% 4.9% 2.1% 5.1%
County
1
Seasonally adjusted is a process applied to unemployment rates that discounts normal seasonal changes. This
is done by either raising or lowering employment numbers by a certain percentage to reflect normally
occurring changes.
Overview
This chapter describes the market for the proposed Center and establishes the level of local
demand for the variety of services that it will offer. It gives a more detailed description of
the North Central Idaho economy and various employment sectors, including retail, health
care, tourism, education and manufacturing. It also looks at potential user groups for the
facility. Finally, it establishes that programs available currently are not adequately meeting
the need. Though there are several institutions in the region providing services akin to those
proposed for this Center, there is a specific unmet demand for the facility and programs
envisioned in this feasibility study.
The primary functions of this facility will be to:
Offer education and training to prepare students to enter the job market and to
offer continuing education to those already employed or looking to develop new
skills;
Provide resources to entrepreneurs starting independent business ventures and to small
business owners who wish to expand or improve the services they currently offer;
Serve local artisans and craftspeople to develop their skills and market their
products. The Center will also serve visitors to the area interested in gaining a
greater understanding of the local environment, history and culture.
In order to be efffective in serving these functions, the Center will need to fill the gap in the
existing array of higher education programs and institutions in the area. While there are
many similar institutions in the area, the fact remains that the people living in Knowledge
Race Training Center communities are not fully taking advnatage of these opportunities.
The focus of our work will be to bridge that gap.
Sources consulted to develop
this section include interviews
with user groups, interviews
with facilities that provide
comparable programs,
interviews with local
employers, population data,
US Census information and
similar demogrpahic data
from the State of Idaho and
related sources.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : MARKET RESEARCH
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center 11
Overview of Local + Regional Economy
The region that the Knowledge Race Training Center facility will serve is experiencing a
contraction of the industries that once offered the most employment. As described in the
Background chapter, the population is aging and is below state averages in both income and
education. The forestry and agricultural markets, once economic mainstays, are slowing
down with competition from a global market and a slowdown of national markets. These
remain important sectors, but economic vitality will depend on increasing the education level
of the local workforce and being innovative about exploring the region’s unique
opportunities. Education will make the economic transition more successful and the
population more adaptable to change.
Historically, resource-based industries have dominated the local economy with forestry and
large-scale agriculture as the leaders. As with many areas of the country, these industries are
now in decline, are less profitable, and employ fewer workers than in recent decades. The
local economy is in the midst of a transition from resource extraction to an economy based
on manufacturing, services and value-added products. Green energy and information
technology are promising sectors. Healthcare services and tourism are already growing. This
transition necessitates that existing workers re-train and gain new skills, and that young
people entering the workforce set their sights on different horizons than their parents or
grandparents. Areas of interest expressed during stakeholder interviews include land and
fisheries management and stewardship, business management and marketing, retail sales, and
tourism.
Table 12 shows job growth trends over Table 12. Job Growth, 2005-2008
the past several years. While national
and 2005 to 2006 to 2007 to
state trends show a continual loss of 2006 2007 2008
jobs, the rate of job loss for the five 0.8 -2.2
United States 1.6 percent
counties (Region 2) has slowed in percent percent
the past year, due to a combination 1.5 -4.0
Idaho 4.0 percent
of stabilizing industry sectors and percent percent
new economic opportunities. 1. Region 2 is composed
1 -3.2Latah, Lewis
of Clearwater, Idaho, -1.0
Region 2 5.4 percent
Federal and state employment percent
and Knowledge Race Training Center counties. Source: percent
provides some economic stability Idaho Department of Labor
for the regional
workforce. Knowledge Race Training
Center Tribal programs and services
also offer a number of employment
opportunities. Most
notably, the private sector is growing in the region. Latah County, for example, has seen the
introduction of several new businesses. Clearwater County’s private sector employment grew
between 2007 and 2008 while the state average was a contraction of -5.1 percent (Idaho
Department of Labor). Private-sector employers increased 13 percent between 1997 and
2007, from 919 to 1,036, respectively (Idaho Department of Labor). The natural amenities in
these areas are beginning to attract individuals with mobile income sources, such as tourists
and retirees. The most promising sector for many of these counties is the health care industry
that grew both nationally and locally in several counties. The following section provides an
overview of the economy and employment in the region.
Knowledge Race Training Center
Tribe Feasibility Study : :
12 MARKET RESEARCH Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center
Tribal Government
The Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe employs 465 full and part time employees
working in thirteen departments in seven Idaho counties, two Oregon counties, one
Washington and one Montana County. Five percent of these are seasonal positions provided
by the Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe’s Natural Resource Division, which includes
Fisheries, Forestry and Wildlife. In this division, according to an interview with the deputy
director, employees fall into two tiers, Professional and Technical. Professional-level jobs
usually require advanced degrees and are permanent positions. The Technical-level jobs
more often provide seasonal employment with lower job qualifications. One of the priorities
for the Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe is to increase the number of Tribal members
in the Professional-level positions. In order to do this, however, a clear track for professional
development is needed, coordinated with degree programs from other institutions. This is a
perfect example of the kind of service the proposed Center could provide to encourage high
school students to enter promising fields and to provide courses and resources closer to
home.
For other Tribal departments, the need for professional development and recruitment of
skilled workers is just as great. In the next 10 years, 30 percent of current Tribal employees
will be ready for retirement. The proposed Center is a critical piece of the strategy to ensure
that a trained pool of workers is ready to take these positions when current employees retire.
Developing educational opportunities for Tribal members of all ages is a priority for a rural
population that has high unemployment and underemployment rates. The Knowledge Race
Training Center Reservation and the north central Idaho counties of Clearwater, Idaho,
Latah, Lewis and Knowledge Race Training Center have chronically high unemployment
rates in rural areas and underemployment throughout the region. Seasonal jobs include road
construction, tree planting, wild fire fighting and fishery programs. Though these jobs
provide job opportunities, they do not provide year round income and contribute to
underemployment. According to the Bureau of Labor statistics (2009), the unemployment
rate for the United States was 8.1 percent and the State of Idaho was 5.4 percent. The latest
available statistics (2005) for the Native American population of the Knowledge Race
Training Center Reservation show an unemployment rate of 21 percent.
Retail
Knowledge Race Training Center County is a regional hub and strong retail center.
Clearwater, Idaho and Lewis counties in Idaho State and Asotin and Columbia counties in
Washington State tend to rely on the Lewiston area in Knowledge Race Training Center
County for goods and services not available locally (Idaho Department of Labor). In the
community of Clarkston, there is a demand for additional retail services in the downtown
area to serve growing summer tourist traffic. A Chamber of Commerce representative
reported that there are opportunities to develop retail services focused on specialty shops,
furniture, clothing, crafts and gift items.
Health Care
Clearwater, Idaho and Knowledge Race Training Center Counties have been extremely
competitive nationally in terms of the growth and availability of health care employment.
The growth in positions has exceeded both national and industry growth over the past
several years. The region has large healthcare employment centers; for example, St.
Joseph’s Regional Medical Center located in Knowledge Race Training Center County,
employs nearly 900 people (Idaho Department of Labor). Data show that this sector
continues to grow at statewide and national levels. Over the past five years, professional,
research and technical professions related to the health care industry have all grown faster
than the overall national and industry average in Knowledge Race Training Center and
Idaho Counties.
One aid to professional development in the state is the Idaho Nursing Workforce Center,
whose goal is to ensure that Idaho has enough nurses to meet the state’s future health care
needs. The Federal Department of Health and Human Services estimates that by 2020 Idaho
will lack about 30 percent of the nurses the state needs (P.L. 102-477). Lewis Clark State
College in Lewiston, Idaho (adjacent to the Knowledge Race Training Center Reservation)
began constructing a new nursing and health sciences center in 2008. The Idaho State
Legislature approved the funding for the new building to help offset a national and state
nursing shortage. The building will allow Lewis Clark State College to double the size of
graduates from the Nursing Program.
Additionally, the Allied Health and Safety Education program offered at Walla Walla
Community College in Clarkston operates a nursing program in a newly constructed, state-
of-the art facility and also provides public health and education programs and operates
distance-learning programs. Distance learning classes currently offered through the
partnership include Medical Laboratory Technology and Physical Therapy Assistant. The
Allied Health and Safety Department also offers Healthcare Training opportunities for
professionals.
With an aging population to care for and an established health care delivery and education
systems in place, the Knowledge Race Training Center facility will be well positioned to offer
students a way to advance their skills sets and move into an employment sector with a promising
future. Establishing educational programs on the paraprofessional level such as a Certified
Nursing Assistant credential or a Personal Care Attendant credential would help the local
workforce to meet demands for home health services. The center can also provide a bridge to the
courses available
Tourism
Several counties in the region have natural amenities that attract individuals and
families for pleasure travel or for retirees making a permanent move. Attractions to the
area include:
Knowledge Race Training Center National Historical Park – the Historical Park
Includes 38 sites spread over four states: Idaho, Montana, Oregon, and Washington.
These sites interpret Knowledge Race Training Center history and culture for area
visitors. The Park encompasses sites that stretch across the homeland of the
Knowledge Race Training Center people. There are activities at the visitor’s centers
at Spalding and Big Hole National Battlefield, and a museum at Big Hole National
Battlefield. There are many activities available throughout the region
(http://www.nationalparklover.com/nezperce01.htm ). Total visitation recorded for
the park in 2008 was over 28,000 persons (National Park Service data).
Fishing and Hunting – Fishing and hunting draw large numbers of visitors to the area
each year. The rivers and lakes offer steelhead, salmon, trout, bass, kokanee, dolly
vardin and sturgeon. For visitors interested in hunting, elk, mule deer, big horn sheep
and black bear are among the animals commonly hunted. Grouse, quail, chukar and
pheasant are a few of the upland game birds available, while Canada geese and
mallards are the most common waterfowl. Outfitters and guides are available, though
there seems to be room for more development in this area.
Gaming – The Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe operates two gaming
facilities: Clearwater River Casino near Lewiston and It’se Ye-Ye in Kamiah. The
Clearwater Casino was recently constructed and includes a hotel and development
area for a future resort area.
Hells Canyon Recreation Area – North America’s deepest river gorge, Hells Canyon
encompasses over 650,000 acres of diverse terrain carved by the Snake River.
Recreation opportunities in the area include whitewater boating, hiking, horseback
riding, fishing, wildlife viewing, viewing artifacts from prehistoric tribes and early
miners and settlers.
The growth of small businesses will increase the amenities of the area as entrepreneurs
capitalize on opportunities to provide lodging, package tours, cultural tourism, eco-tours and
arts and crafts sales. The Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe currently offers
certification for individuals to become certified interpreters of Knowledge Race Training
Center culture and history.
A growing arts community also draws some visitors, as well as making the county more
attractive to individuals looking to relocate to the area, such as retirees. Over the past
several years, several retirement communities have been developed.
1 http://www.tpwd.state.tx.us/huntwild/wild/wildlife_trails/coastal/
2 http://www.exploreasheville.com/what-to-do/seasonal-fun/fall-color-in-the-asheville-area/fall-
crafts/fall-craft-excursions/index.aspx
Manufacturing
The large number of educational facilities that exist in the region offers a unique opportunity
for economic development. According to an interview with David Bonfield of the Northwest
Intermountain Manufacturer’s Association, the area supports a range of manufacturing firms
from those with 2,000 employees to those with only one employee, partly due to the
presence of research institutions that are hives of invention for new products and technology.
These firms are often in need of a stable workforce with good technical skills. Another need
is for business management and bookkeeping services to assist small business owners with
business management and development.
There are a number of opportunities in manufacturing, including: developing a large-scale
wind energy project and developing the supply chain for the wind industry; the jet boat
industry, which started in the area with eleven manufacturers currently operating; and,
finding new ways to use wood products, such as pelletizing for converting wood waste into
energy and insulation and turning farm waste into fertilizer. The “hard craft areas” such as
welding, fitting, hydraulics, electronics, as well as related marketing and sales of
manufactured products are needed skills in the area.
A skilled workforce is critical for this sector of the local economy to develop further. An
advantage to manufacturing, particularly smaller, niche-firms, is that they can be located all
over the region in rural areas. The limiting factor is the availability of skilled workers and
raising awareness among young people and schoolteachers of the importance of this sector.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : MARKET RESEARCH
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center 17
The Northwest Intermountain Manufacturing Association recently trained teachers and
administrators from ten local schools to teach students to use Solid Works, a 3-D software
program. After the students had learned to use the program and had created designs in the
classroom, the manufacturing association enlisted manufacturers to build them. This project
sought to open the eyes of young people to the opportunities in this sector. Mr. Bonfield
observed in an interview for this study that it used to be that a high school diploma was all
that anyone needed in order to have a well-paid, stable job in farming or timber. Today, he
believes, even in those traditional industries (and particularly in emerging industries and
manufacturing) additional technical training is needed in order to secure quality
employment. Training needs to begin with high school-aged students in order for them to
understand the demands of the job market they will soon enter.
Another growth area in manufacturing is to teach manufacturers to export. A recent survey
of 100 manufacturers in the area found that only 8 percent export their products. This
compared with a rate in comparable places of closer to 50 percent. The Northwest
Intermountain Manufacturing Association is currently working to teach manufacturers to
export and to expand their businesses accordingly.
Agriculture, forestry,
14.28 - 4.35 - - 3.93
fishing and hunting
Arts, entertainment,
0.42 0.69 1.13 0.74 0.88 0.96
and recreation
Accommodation and
0.99 1.99 1.09 0.61 0.91 0.99
food services
Source: US Bureau of Labor Statistics. Boxes with no value indicate areas where data could not be calculated or could not be disclosed.
While a location quotient is useful for giving a static picture of a county’s strengths and
weaknesses, it does not explain the sources of change. Shift-share analysis tries to explain
the changes in the county economy by breaking that change into three sources: national
share, industry share and regional share. The national share estimates the impacts of total
national growth or decline in a particular industry. The industry share shows how much
local change in employment can be attributed to national growth or decline in that
particular sector. These two parts describe the change that would have occurred in the
county economy if it followed national and industry trends. The regional share reveals the
effects of region-specific factors affecting local employment. Industries where the regional
share is largest are often the best targets for economic development individually or in
clusters with other similarly positioned industries.
National Share 16 16 37 1 97
In the above table, as an example, Clearwater County gained 53 jobs between 2005 and 2006 in
the health care and social assistance sector. Most of that gain (39 jobs) was due to the very
competitive share of those jobs in Clearwater County. Although sixteen jobs were due to general
national economic growth it was offset slightly by a share loss of two jobs due to a slowdown
nationally in health care and social assistance sector growth. The example shows that Clearwater
County has a very competitive position in the health and social assistance sector but it is in an
industry that is, over the past year, growing slightly more slowly than the national average.
Knowledge Race Training Center
Tribe Feasibility Study : :
20 MARKET RESEARCH Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center
Summary of Opportunities for Employment Growth and Economic Development
The overview provided here identifies a number of growth areas where the proposed
Center could focus efforts to prepare workers for employment:
Professional development for Tribal government employees to encourage
promotion into permanent positions and increase mobility between positions.
Recruitment and training should focus on sectors of Tribal government
employment where senior positions are currently filled with people nearing
retirement.
Because it is the largest division, the employment needs of the Fisheries and Habitat
Division should be particularly examined in order to move employees in the
Technical positions into the Professional tier and to encourage young people to attain
the advanced degrees necessary to qualify for Professional-level employment.
Small-scale farming and horticulture for specialty food and agricultural products
such as organic vegetables, heirloom varieties and cut flowers.
Healthcare, Personal Care Assistance for Elders, and small business opportunities
such as home health services and assisted living homes.
Small business development in retail and in hospitality related services such as
guiding, lodging, arts and crafts production and marketing, and cultural
interpretation.
Business management, marketing and bookkeeping to provide services to
other entrepreneurs to help them manage and grow their businesses.
Employment at educational institutions for professors, teaching assistants,
program managers, IT support and other employment needed on local
campuses.
Manufacturing and technical skills such as welding, fitting and fabrication.
Local goods and services such as automobile repair, childcare, local retail, printing
and copying, restaurant and hospitality.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : MARKET RESEARCH
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center 21
Who will use this facility?
The primary users are those who will take advantage of the training, certification and
higher education opportunities offered at the Center. The secondary users are those who
will directly benefit from having access to a trained and educated workforce.
This center will provide services and programs for all ages, “from cradle to grave.”
Three specific user groups include:
Students of all ages: children, youth, adults and Elders
Artisans and craftspeople
Entreprenuers and business
owners Secondary user groups include:
The programs and divisions of the Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe that will
be able to hire from a wider, well-trained pool of employees and will be able to
access training and certification to build the skills of existing employees and improve
job performance and productivity.
Area manufacturers, health care facilities, tourism operators and other area
businesses that will also have a wider pool of potential well-trained employees.
Local residents of Lapwai, Orofino, Kamiah, Lewiston, Clarkston and other nearby
communities who will benefit from an increase in the number and success of small
businesses and an increased circulation of wealth within their communities.
Visitors to the area who will have the opportunity to learn about the area’s culture,
language, history and future, observe traditional arts and crafts and to collect art
pieces and purchase gifts.
Interviews with the primary user groups listed above revealed common themes in
interests among potential users. Summaries from these interviews are below.
Children
The Knowledge Race Training Center facility will primarily serve young children by
housing a Head Start, Early Head Start and a childcare program. As the table below shows,
there is a below-average percentage of children under the age of five in neighboring counties
as compared with the entire state of Idaho. However, for the adult learners interviewed for
this study, childcare was mentioned as one of the most important facilitators to allow them
to access higher learning courses.
Co-locating the early childhood facility with the adult education and business
development programs will produce a number of benefits:
Children will benefit from participating in the cultural programs offered at the
Center and from increased interaction with local Elders.
Adult learners who have children will be able to pursue training and courses while
their children are cared for in a high quality early education center, making it easier
to fit in higher learning with the demands of parenting and work.
Knowledge Race Training Center
Tribe Feasibility Study : :
22 MARKET RESEARCH Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center
Table 15. Estimates for Population Under 18 in Five County area, 2007
Population Population
Total Population Under 18 Percent Under 5 Percent
Elders
Elders emphasized the importance of establishing cultural programs and courses that
encourage community connectivity. Offering evening classes in areas such as Knowledge
Race Training Center language study and arts and crafts production that draw on their skills
and knowledge was suggested. Training in marketing traditional crafts was also mentioned.
Overview
The purpose of this section is to share examples of facilities and
programs that provide services similar to the facility and
program envisioned for the Knowledge Race Training Center
facility. By looking at these examples we can establish:
Ways that Knowledge Race Training Center programs
can partner and dovetail with other programs that exist
in the area.
Examples of models that can guide the
development of Knowledge Race Training
Center programs. Lessons learned by effective
programs that are already successfully operating.
Comparable programs and institutions from the local area
include: Lewis-Clark State College (Lewiston), Walla Walla
Community College (Clarkston), Independent Study in Idaho
(distance learning), Northwest Indian College (Lapwai and
Kamiah) and Washington State University (distance learning).
Some of these institutions are already partners of the
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe’s education and training
programs and offer great potential for increased partnership in
the new Center.
Programs from outside of the local area include: Southwest
Alaska Vocational Education Center in King Salmon, Alaska,
and Bidwell Training Center and Manchester Craftsman Guild in
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. The business incubator examined is
The Water Cooler, in Boise, Idaho. These are provided in order
to share examples of programs that offer similar services as the
proposed Center.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : COMPARABLE FACILITIES
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center 27
Comparable Programs + Facilities in the Local Area
According to education program directors interviewed for this study, North-Central Idaho
is fortunate to be served by a number of high-quality higher education and training
facilities and programs. However, as stated earlier in this study, the residents of
Knowledge Race Training Center communities are not taking advantage of these
opportunities or reaping the benefits from them at a level comparable to members of other
communities in the area.
These institutions already collaborate with the Knowledge Race Training Center education
programs in order to help connect students with courses at partner institutions. These
partnerships are hampered, however, by the lack of adequate space and facilities to provide
courses from other institutions at a location convenient for Knowledge Race Training
Center students, and by the lack of an Education Director who can spearhead the
development of new programs and stronger partnerships to really bring the benefit of
partner institutions to the people of the Knowledge Race Training Center communities.
The goal of the Knowledge Race Training Center Education, Training and Business
Development Center is not to attempt to duplicate these institutions. The goal is to
increase effective partnerships with these institutions, and to increase access to their
programs, so that Knowledge Race Training Center residents can benefit from the history,
resources and breadth of programs avialble in the area.
Enrollment
In the spring of 2009, LCSC reported 3,601 students enrolled. The total enrollment for
LCSC Allied Health programs is just under 1,000 students per year. The apprenticeship
programs target mostly graduating high school students, and have enrollment of
approximately 100 students. The Allied Health programs of LCSC have the highest
enrollment of any program in the college. According to Linda Stricklin, Allied Health
Coordinator for Workforce Training, the Allied Health Program has more students enrolled
in a single semester than any other program has in an entire school year.
Programs Offered
LCSC Workforce Training Center offers the following programs:
• Allied Health – these programs includes many different types of medical and
healthcare courses and certifications.
• Businesses – includes computer training, and other classes that are developed
according to industry needs. This program houses a lab that includes Adobe
software and additional business programs such as Quickbooks, etc.
• Additional beginning-level classes: welding, Certified Nurse Assistant (CNA),
dental assistant; apprenticeships in electrical, plumbing and HVAC; real estate,
flagging, fire service.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : COMPARABLE FACILITIES
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center 29
Special Uses of Technology
LCSC Workforce Training Center offers an on-line Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
certification program. Students participating in this program come to campus for six on-
site sessions rather than the 22 sessions required for the standard program. Additionally,
the business management program has a portable training lab to provide off-site training.
The business management program also rents the business lab to groups who have their
own teachers and curricula they would like to deliver. For example, St. Joseph’s Hospital
used the facility to train employees in on-line charting. It can also be used to provide
employee training to keep up with advances in technology and the in the workplace.
How many students attend 12,000 students annually at two campuses: Walla Walla and Clarkston
1600 students per year enrolled, number has held steady over
How many students attend
the years
ISI courses do not follow the calendar year and are available at
Special uses of technology anytime. Online courses are taught using Blackboard Learning
Systems, a course management tool.
Lummi Library
photo via www.nwic.edu
Located on the Lummi Indian Reservation in Washington State, 20 miles from the Canadian
border, Northwest Indian College is the only accredited Tribal college in the states of
Washington, Oregon and Idaho. NWIC grew from the Lummi Indian School of Aquaculture
(founded in 1973), a single-purpose institution developed to provide a supply of technicians
for employment in Indian-owned and-operated fish and shellfish hatcheries throughout the
United States and Canada. In 1983 the Lummi Indian Business Council recognized the need
for a more comprehensive postsecondary institution for Tribal members, and the school was
chartered as Lummi Community College, an Indian-controlled, comprehensive two-year
college designed to serve the postsecondary educational needs of Indian people living in the
Pacific Northwest. In June of 1988, the Northwest Association of Schools and Colleges
(NWASC) approved Lummi Community College as a candidate for accreditation, and on
January 20, 1989, Lummi Community College became Northwest Indian College. 1
At Northwest Indian College the student body is a diverse group. The average student is a
29-year-old female with at least one dependent. Although, the growing Athletic Program is
drawing increasing numbers of traditional college age students right out of high school.
Over 75 percent of students come from federally recognized Indian Tribes representing over
90 different Tribal nations. The Northwest Indian College proudly serves over 1,200
students annually.
Northwest Indian College is located in Bellingham, Washington. The college also has
outreach campuses in Nespelem WA, Auburn WA, Lapwai ID, Tulalip WA, La Conner
WA, Kingston WA, and Olympia WA servicing the nearby reservations of the surrounding
areas.
The Northwest Indian College is currently a strong partner with the Knowledge Race
Training Center Tribe and provides courses at the Lapwai campus. These existing
programs will be incorporated into the proposed Center.
1
Information from Northwest Indian College’s website: http://www.nwic.edu/index.php?
option=com_contentandtask=viewandid=51andItemid=193
Knowledge Race Training Center
Tribe Feasibility Study : : 34 COMPARABLE FACILITIES Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business
Development Center
List of programs offered
Northwest Indian College offers the following: Bachelors Degree in Native
Environmental Science, Associate of Arts and Science, Associate of Technical Arts,
Associate of Science Transfer as well as certificate programs and awards of
competency.
Table 19. WSU Center for Distance and Professional Education Program ‘At-A-Glance’
WSU Center for Distance and
Professional Education
How many students attend Up 600 in last semester, trend is up in past few years.
A number of other training, apprenticeship and vocational education programs and resources
that operate in the local area that will be accessed by students at the proposed Center include
the following:
Job Corp
Job Corp was is a free education and vocational training program run by the U.S.
Department of Labor and authorized by the Workforce Investment Act (WIA). The program
was established in 1964 and has been training young people ages 16 through 24 since its
inception. Run through a nationwide network of campuses, Job Corp teaches academic,
vocational, employability and independent living skills. There are 122 Job Corps center
campuses located throughout the US operated for the U.S. Department of Labor by private
companies or by other Federal Agencies. The Job Corps center in Idaho is located in Nampa,
ID in the Centennial Center. There are also three centers in Montana that are near to some of
the Knowledge Race Training Center communities: Anaconda campus, Kicking Horse
campus in Ronan, and the Trapper Creek campus in Darby.
The Clearwater Economic Development Association has served Clearwater, Idaho, Latah,
Lewis, and Knowledge Race Training Center Counties for the past 41 years. CEDA offers a
range of services to individual businesses and communities in order to stimulate and stabilize the
local economy. These include project and program development, grant writing and
administration, business development services including financing and technical assistance,
technical assistance with state and federal procurement procedures and compliance, advocacy,
facility leasing and referrals.
CEDA is already a strong partner of the Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe and, in an
interview with the director conducted for this study, she would like to see additional
resources available for residents of the Knowledge Race Training Center communities,
particularly focusing on high school age students.
Programs offered
SAVEC offers training in the following areas: heavy equipment training; construction
crafts; fisheries; off-road Commercial Driver’s Instruction; health-related skills; youth
academies that provide youth short-term experiences with various trades.
Partners
Each of the following regional organizations collaborates with SAVEC and has
representation on SAVEC’s board: Bristol Bay Housing Authority, Bristol Bay Area
Health Corporation, Bristol Bay Economic Development Corporation, University of
Alaska, Fairbanks, Bristol Bay Campus, Lake and Peninsula Borough and Bristol Bay
Borough.
SAVEC also partners with Alaska Works Partnership, Inc., a construction training and
placement system that partners with Alaska’s building trades unions, to deliver many
construction-related courses. The Alaska Department of Labor and Workforce
Development, the U.S. Department of Labor, and the Denali Training Fund provide faculty
for trainings such as heavy equipment operation and construction crafts. SAVEC also
collaborates with local school districts to restore programs that used to be provided at the
high school level but are no longer included in the curriculum.
Lessons Learned
SAVEC has significant infrastructure to provide training courses. The facilities at the King
Salmon Air Force Base provide adequate outdoor space for heavy equipment training and
the necessary equipment is available for rent from a nearby contractor. The center is
equipped with distance learning capabilities.
SAVEC is an independent organization, which gives it a strong measure of flexibility and
the ability to respond quickly to the needs of industries. A recent business plan developed
for the Center outlined increasing contributions from industry partners and increasing the
advisory role of the partners through the regular meeting of the Bristol Bay Industry
Council. A less tangible but critically important additional asset is the strong collaboration
of the regional organizations in Bristol Bay that came together to start SAVEC and that
remain committed to its long-term success. For SAVEC, strengthening relationships with
the mining, oil and gas, tourism, and fishing industries, as well as the local communities, is
the priority for sustainability.
Knowledge Race Training Center
Tribe Feasibility Study : :
40 COMPARABLE FACILITIES Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center
Bidwell Training Center, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
The Bidwell Training Center exists as a subsidiary of the Manchester Bidwell Corporation,
which also includes the Manchester Craftsmen’s Guild (MCG). The Bidwell Training Center
offers vocational training as well as job placement assistance. Manchester Craftsmen’s Guild
is a multi-discipline, minority directed, center for arts and learning that employs the visual
and performing arts to foster a sense of accomplishment and hope in the urban community.
In 1986, after a $6.5 million capital campaign, the Manchester Bidwell Corporation opened
a 62,000 square foot building that also includes the subsidiaries: the Bidwell Training
Center, the Manchester Bidwell Development Trust and the National Center for Arts and
Technology. The facility has classrooms, workshops, gallery spaces, and a 350-seat
auditorium that hosts jazz performances, and other subsidiary-specific elements.
For four decades, the nonprofit Bidwell Training Center has offered vocational training in a
variety of fields: health care administration, including health unit coordinator, medical
claims processor, medical coder, pharmacy technician, and chemical laboratory technician;
the culinary arts; office administration; and horticulture technology. Several of these
programs include externships with area companies. This enables students to combine skills
learned in the classroom with on-the-job experience and provides an opportunity to begin
the transition from school to employment.2
The programs are free to adults with a high school diploma or GED who pass a competency
exam. The Bidwell Training Center state-of-the-art campus opened in 1987 and a commercial
greenhouse was added in 2003. The Bidwell Training Center’s Executive Director, who has been
with the center for 40 years, has helped found similar centers in San Francisco, Cincinnati and
Grand Rapids, Mich., with others planned in Limerick, Ireland; Halifax, Nova Scotia; and
Israel.3
The Bidwell Training Center employs a full-time placement staff to work directly with
students and assist them in finding training-related employment. Professional development
classes are integrated into the Bidwell Training Center’s curriculum. Classes are taught on
communication skills and career search techniques, resume and professional writing. Prior
to graduation, the placement staff brings in representatives from local employers to conduct
mock interviews. The interviewer provides the interviewee with feedback as preparation for
actual employment interviews. The center also networks with local employers; attends
career fairs, advisory board and community partner meetings; as well as reviews Internet
and newspaper postings.
Most relevant to the Knowledge Race Training Center Education Center is the Bidwell
Training Center’s Horticulture program. The Horticulture Program has classroom and lab
components within the one-acre greenhouse complex to provide a practical, professional
learning environment. The externship allows students to concentrate on the particular career
path suited to their long-term employment goals. The combination of theory and practical
training helps students be desirable candidates for employment in the greenhouse industry.
2
Reference: http://manchesterbidwell.org/bidwell-training-center/index.php
3
Information from Flashbulbs, Pittsburg City Paper, February 19, 2009, Author: Melissa
Meinzer http://www.pittsburghcitypaper.ws/gyrobase/Content?oid=oidpercent3A59332
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : :
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center COMPARABLE FACILITIES
41
The program consists of a 30-week, 8:00 a.m. through 3:00 p.m., Monday through Friday.
Half of the time is spent in the greenhouse, hands on with the plants, and the other half, in
the classroom, taking a full cohort of courses related to botany and horticulture as well as
business management and marketing of horticultural enterprises.
The greenhouse grows vegetables, ornamental plants and the Training Center's signature
flower, the phalaenopsis orchid. The Bidwell Training Center sells the plants they cultivate
to grocery stores and commercial retail florists, and the funds generated are reinvested in the
program.
Not only does the center provide professional training, it also puts people into contact with
the kind of beauty often reserved for the “well to do”. This idea is reflected in the
Manchester Craftsmen’s Guild as well; the first tenet of their mission is to “Educate and
inspire urban youth through the arts and mentored training in life skills”. The Bidwell
Training Center has a strong focus on mentorship, and the placement rate of 79percent
speaks to the success of their programs.
Educational programs
Manchester offers Summer Studio intensives and supports the Artist in Schools (AIS)
program. MCG also hosts the Art Explorers program for middle school students. It enables
them to critically examine artwork by contemporary artists and create works of their own
based on what they experience. Manchester Craftsmen’s Guild also holds adult education
classes in ceramics, digital arts, design arts and photography in programs called Art
Afterdark. They offer some partial scholarships in each class to current Pittsburgh public
school teachers to earn continuing education credits. Examples of classes taught are
ceramics for all skill levels, figure drawing, digital video making, the future of photography
using a GigaPan robot, and traditional photo processes. All classes accommodate beginners
to advanced students. Manchester Craftsmen’s Guild also has professional artist-in-
residence programs.
The WaterCooler
The WaterCooler is a small business incubator for technology-related businesses located in
Boise, Idaho. The WaterCooler is a for-profit venture, created by a private development
firm funded by real estate development and personal investment. The firm is interested in
attracting new technology businesses to Boise. This same firm is also working to develop a
Boise-located alternative energy-related small business incubator. The long-term goals of
the WaterCooler include development of 4-5 additional incubator facilities over the next ten
years. These new incubators will be located within walking distance from one another, in
order to promote cross-pollination and networking.
The WaterCooler offers fledgling businesses work space on a lease term priced well below
market rate. Nine suites each rent for varying amounts and are approximately 3-400 square
feet. The WaterCooler works with tenants to tailor rental fees to a level each business can
afford. For example, one cubicle that can house one or two people rents for $2-300 a month.
Included in the rental package is the use of the small conference room and the large meeting
space (called the Idea Room). Internet and utilities are available for $75 per month and
includes one phone and a high-speed T-1 internet connection.
Currently the WaterCooler provides office space for eight technology-related firms. The
WaterCooler plans for additional capital improvements, however, once the construction bills
are paid, the WaterCooler will be breaking even.
Knowledge Race Training Center Tribe Feasibility Study : : COMPARABLE FACILITIES
Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center 43
Panhandle Area Council’s Business Center, Hayden, Idaho
The Panhandle Area Council that serves Northern Idaho established a business center to
assist start-up companies in light industrial manufacturing during their first two years in
operation. Designed to house between eight and twelve companies, the center offers between
100 and 1500 square feet of space to those companies. Companies pay a reduced rental fee
and can take advantage of the consulting, shared office facilities and professional assistance
provided by the business center.
Start-up companies that have completed basic business planning and are in limited
production occupy the larger bays. Companies occupying the minimum space are expected to
develop a business plan, marketing plan, and manufacturing operation with the assistance of
the PAC staff. The rental fee is $400.00 per month for each bay in a package price including
both space and services. The rental space for desk space is $70.00 per month and is rented on
a month-to-month basis. PAC’s loan program is targeted to qualified incubator tenants as
funds become available.
Overview
The heart of any community facility is
the programs offered within it. While the
facility itself is important, as it provides
a sense of place, a safe and nurturing
environment, and is a testament to the
work done there – it is the activities
housed within the facility that give it
meaning and purpose; it is the events that
take place in its spaces that give it life;
and it is the services offered that make it
a needed, useful part of the community.
This chapter undertakes to desribe the
programs, services, activities and events
that will be housed in the Knowledge
Race Training Center Education,
Training and Business Development
Center. Many of the Center’s programs
exist currently; others will be developed
over time, as resources and need dictate.
The first part of this chapter gives an
overview of those existing programs.
The second part covers the new
programs that the Center could develop
in both the short- and long-term.
Program descriptions are grouped by the
area they relate to or fall within:
Education
Workforce training
Business development
Cultural preservation and resources
The Program Table (Figure 9) gives an
overview of the existing programs and
services that will be located in the Center,
and highlights the proposed future
programs and services. The Program Map
(Figure 10) gives an overview of these
same programs showing how they relate
to the Center’s different user groups., i.e.,
children, youth, adults and Elders. An
illustration of the Knowledge Race
Training Center Tribe’s overall
departmental structure is included in the
Governance chapter.
The purpose of collecting these diverse
programs within one facility is:
To create a “one stop shop” for
learning, cultural transmission
and self-determination where all
family members – from children,
to youth, to adults and Elders –
can develop.
To improve the classroom and
related spaces available in
Lapwai, and ensure programs are
in spaces adequate to their needs.
To increase the number of people
who can be served by the Tribe’s
programs.
To allow related prgorams to
work together more closely,
more efficiently and more
effectively.
To demonstrate the importance
that the Knowledge Race
Training Center place on
education, cultural transmission,
economic empowerment,
family, and self-determination –
all values that are enhanced and
embodied by the creation of the
Knowledge Race Training
Center Education, Training and
Business Development Center.
To grow the local economy and build
a skilled, mobile workforce.
9
.
E
x
i
s
t
i
n
g
a
n
d
F
u
t
u
r
e
P
r
o
g
r
a
m
s
S
e
r
v
i
c
e
s
Knowledge Race Training Cente
46 PROGRAM DESCRIPTION Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Bu
F
i
Education
Workforce Training
Business Development
Cultural Preservation
Education
Business Development
Small Business Incubator
Create space within the facility to house a small business incubator – low-cost,
professional spaces with Internet and phone access that can be used by start-up
businesses. Services that can be provided to tenants businesses might include
streamlined small business loans, accounting and bookkeeping assistance, marketing
assistance, shared web hosting and advertising, business plan development, assistance
securing investors and other business development services.
Tourism Development Program
Working with the Tourism Office, and the Enterprise Board, develop a program
to promote tourism on the reservation and as well as to promote development of
Knowledge Race Training Center-owned tourism businesses and training and
hiring of Tribal members as employees of tourism-related businesses throughout
the region.
Marketplace and Youth Craft Co-Op
The facility will house a display area for featuring art and crafts generated by Tribal
youth and promoting the sale of youth-produced goods. The youth will supply
pieces, manage the display area and be responsible for sales. Adult users of the
Artisan Studio and Traditional Crafts Workshop will also have adjacent space for
display and sale of their pieces in the Marketplace. Marketplace space can also be
used by others interested in selling other types of goods and services ast booths and
kiosks.
Farmer’s Market Program
In conjunction with the facility’s greenhouse, as well as with local farmers, gardeners
and craftspeople, formalize and promote the Farmer’s Market program
Commercial Kitchen
The facility will provide a commerical kitchen which can be used for training in
hospitality and cooking as well as low-rent business incubator space for local
catering companies or small-scale commerical production of food items.
Knowledge Race Training Center
Tribe Feasibility Study : :
52 PROGRAM DESCRIPTION Multi-Purpose Training, Education + Business Development Center
Cultural Preservation
Artisan Studio and Traditional Crafts Workshop
The facility will contain a space for the practice of traditional crafts such as tipi
construction, tanning, sewing, and beadwork. The space will encourage youth-Elder
interaction, allow for the creation of materials to be sold at the Center’s Marketplace,
as well as through arrangement with other local gift shops (such as at the Clearwater
River Casino and Resort and Knowledge Race Training Center National Historic
Monument gift shop), maintain important cultural activities and allow for traditional
knowledge sharing, and create an opportunity for value-added cultural tourism,
where visitors are allowed to see the artists crafting pieces and visit their studio
spaces.
Fisheries-Related Programs
Fisheries Education and Outreach
Create a curriculum for teaching young children about the ecology of the local area,
fish species that reside in local waterways, the work that is done at the hatchery and
the types of jobs available in fisheries and related natural resources fields.
Fisheries Internship Program
In conjunction with local high schools and youth programs, run a fisheries
internship program to introduce youth to the skills needed in the variety of
fisheries programs operated by the Tribe.
Professional Fisheries Track
Through specific policy changes, create an incentivized track for Tribal members
wishing to develop necessary skills to obtain professional positions within the
Knowledge Race Training Center Fishery.
Administration
Following is an overview of recommended staff for the facility, in addition to Program
staff affiliated with programs described above.
Facility Elements
Some of the education and business
development programs that will be
housed in the proposed center are
already operating in separate locations
scattered around the Tribe’s facilities
in Lapwai. Some of the programs also
operate satellites in other communities,
such as the adult learning campus and
the Head Start facilities in Kamiah.
The proposed center would bring all of
the programs together under one roof
in order to better share resources and
provide a continuum of service to
clients and users.
To achieve the goal of coordinating
and sharing resources among
programs, the facility itself must be
conducive to coordination and sharing.
Also, in order to serve the needs of all
users from Lapwai and other
communities in the region, the facility
must have state-of-the-art information
technology capabilities, both to
facilitate collaboration within different
parts of the center and between the
center and remote sites. The
Information Services (IS) department
at the Knowledge Race Training
Center Tribe has secured significant
band width and a high degree of
expertise and will be able to provide
the necessary IS services to this center.
The Project Working Group developed
the facility program described below,
based on the input from stakeholder
interviews. The program is designed to
be ‘right sized’ to find a balance
between the needs and wants of tenant
programs and potential users and the
Tribe’s financial capability to sustain
the center over the long term.
The program is divided into seven
main areas: reception, offices, Early
Education Center, Educational and
Training Facility, Traditional
Knowledge, Outdoor Space and
Maintenance, Operations Support and
Circulation. Since this is a very
preliminary space program, the
estimated square feet per function have
been included for guidance, as well as
a generous net to gross factor of 40
percent to allow for future refinements
once the design process is underway.
The preliminary space program defines
a facility with a total of 31,136 gross
square feet.
Description of Spaces
The preliminary program for the center includes the following spaces.
Reception
In order to foster collaboration and resource sharing the reception area will be an open area
with plenty of natural light that will invite users and visitors in to the center. A central
reception desk will be staffed by an employee from one of the tenant programs and will act
as a connection
Offices
The center will bring together the Tribe’s education and business development programs
under one roof. Three of the programs have a total stable workforce of eight full time staff.
The Students for Success program is grant funded, and staffing levels fluctuate between four
and seven full time employees. One of the programs has a part-time administrative assistant.
The facility program estimates a total of 2,100 net square feet to accommodate office space,
a break room, storage, an internal reference library and a confidential meeting space for
client meetings. This space should be configured to strike a balance between shared working
space that fosters collaboration and barriers that provide some noise and visual separation.
As the programs of the center are developed, it may be that some of the staff members of the
tenant programs are deployed in new ways to staff expanded programming. This will affect
the type and amount of office space required to house these programs.
The office and associated staff areas are estimated at 2,100 net square feet.
Traditional Knowledge
The traditional knowledge area will house an artisan studio and a general workshop
where traditional arts, crafts and skills will be taught. This area of the facility will also
house a space where visitors can be welcomed into the center to learn about the
traditional culture and language of the Knowledge Race Training Center.
A critical element of the Traditional Knowledge area will be the Marketplace with a specific
area for a youth co-op to sell their goods. Engaging youth in traditional crafts and marketing
and selling goods is an important goal of the Center.
The traditional knowledge area is estimated at 2,900 net square feet.
Outdoor Space
Because of the wide range of user groups for this facility that will include very young
children, teens, adult learners and elders, as well as visitors to the area, a number of outdoor
spaces will enhance the main instructional spaces. The site selected for this project may not
be large enough or configured correctly to provide for all of these desired uses. If this is the
case, it may be possible to accommodate some of these uses off-site. Required outdoor
spaces include the Early Education Center playground. Desired outdoor spaces include a
playing field, a traditional village or home site, a garden and greenhouse where horticulture
and market gardening could be taught, and an amphitheater for outdoor performances and
presentations.
The size of these spaces has not yet been estimated other than the required space for the
Early Education Center playground will need to provide 75 square feet per child.