Professional Documents
Culture Documents
10.2478 - Picbe 2023 0150
10.2478 - Picbe 2023 0150
A Human-Centered Approach
Marta – Christina SUCIU,
Bucharest University of Economic Studies, Bucharest, Romania
Romanian Academy, National Institute of Economic Research ”Costin Kiritescu”, Romanian
Academy of Scientists, Commission 9 for Economics, Law and Sociology
christina.suciu@economie.ase.ro
Abstract. The COVID-19 crisis, along with the other associated complex crises, has amplified the gap that
exists in terms of the number of women reaching leadership positions, despite the quality of their work and
their important contributions in various fields. This paper aims to explore women's leadership qualities,
and perceptions regarding leadership, based on quantitative data originating from four studies. Concerning
the research methodology it includes qualitative research and a comparative analysis of global studies. The
paper focuses on women, looking mostly for the proportion of women within organizations, and the main
characteristics of women's leadership. The analysis then turns to Romania, where we have identified the
proportion of women leaders. The main goal of the paper is to investigate the representation of women
leaders in EU countries and in particular in Romania. The results of the study illustrate that favorable work
conditions have a greater impact on women's aspirations to become leaders. Extrinsic structural
inequalities, such as bias against women in certain professions, and gender, racial and other discrimination,
are barriers to women's access and advancement in leadership positions in the workplace. Intrinsic
individual characteristics of successful women leaders, namely conscientiousness, respect, confidence,
acceptance, and resilience have facilitated their success in obtaining and maintaining leadership positions.
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic crisis has accelerated tendencies and behaviours towards a flexible
working environment, highlighting the importance of diversity for innovation and the need for
more empathy and transparency. (Schmidt, 2021) Many women, who already faced problems of
job insecurity and low pay before the pandemic crisis, have been more affected by the need to stay
with children and to take care of elderly family members. As a consequence, at the level of
individuals, the impact has been stronger on women that are more vulnerable in front of
unemployment challenges. Thus the gap regarding the equality of women opportunities compared
to those of men in the workplace are amplified.
Worldwide reduction of gender disparity mostly by increasing women's accessibility and
equity of career opportunities, including leadership is a priority for decision makers on different
levels. Despite the relatively small number of women in leadership positions, there has been a
relative increase in the percentage of women having an active presence within the Board of
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2023-0150
© 2023 M. C. Suciu; A. M. Bocăneală; D. O. Dumitrescu, published by Sciendo.
This work is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Directors for different organizations. We identified, based on a critical comparative analysis of four
studies, the proportion of women included within the Board of Directors who also benefit from
leadership positions. Next we examined the perception of women leaders about leadership based
on two Romanian case studies. We consider that this paper may contribute to the existing studies,
mostly in line with the development of a women human-centered leadership approach. The paper
includes three parts. The first part regards a brief literature review, focusing on the identification PICBE |
of the main characteristics of women leaders. The second part includes the two case studies 1682
mentioned previously. The third part illustrates some examples of success stories regarding the
careers of women leaders.
Literature review
John Maxwell expressed that Leadership is influence - nothing more, nothing less (Kruse, 2013).
The question is how a leader might influence other people by keeping a positive attitude based on
applying a coherent set of values and behaviors such as to help people to co-operate in line with
the organization’ strategic plans, and to continually renew it (Mckinsey & Company, 2022). Thus,
women's leadership has to focus on guiding and influencing the organization’ outcomes in
different, but positive ways. Thus we consider human oriented leadership have to enable and
empower women such as to manifest assertiveness, decisiveness and persuasiveness by
incorporating core competencies and skills that focus on caring and nurturing, soft skills, informal-
interpersonal communication, collaboration based on a participative leadership style (Syed &
Murray, 2008). Women are able to develop an ethic of caring. They also have negotiation and
conflict resolution skills. In line with the modern approach of a human centered leadership; women
are considered to be more transformation-oriented than men. Female leaders focus more on trust
and team building than men and thus they are considered to be more human oriented. Women's
leadership includes a set of abilities (such as art, craftsmanship, narrative, caring heart) that are
perceived as attributes of female leadership based on dialogue and cooperation with men leaders
(Deloitte Global Boardroom Program, 2022). While many CEOs and leaders support the promotion
of women to senior management and board positions, there is still a need for a cultural shift and a
long-term vision to guide women on their career development that leverage their education and
skills (Deloitte Global Boardroom Program, 2022). Women leaders have to set top goals and be
proactive in developing high skills such as to achieve these goals. Leadership and its influence
within an entrepreneurial are key ingredients for competitive organizations and firms (Baltazar &
Franco, 2023)
According to the (GEM) Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM, 2022) women leaders
have an important impact on all the levels of activities (micro, mezzo and macroeconomics)
through innovation, job creation and competitiveness. Some authors (Bhatt, 2015) consider that
today there is a higher demand for women leadership due to the difficult and turbulent periods of
transformation we have to face. Leadership is based on a social building process (DeRue &
Ashford, 2010). There are authors (Post, 2015) who argue that women leaders are more likely than
their men co-leaders to facilitate team cohesion, trust building, cooperative learning, and
participative communication. Women's leadership path focuses on inclusion and thus, the emphasis
is on process rather than end goal. Women leaders aim to establish frequent and positive
interactions with team members.
The quality of these human-centered relationships will influence positively and thus affect
members' attitudes. Leadership is about building trust and a kind and decent relationship (DeRue
& Ashford, 2010). Women's leadership has the ability to overcome structural barriers within
Methodology
In order to achieve the main goal of this paper, we used a qualitative methodology. According to
(Jemielniak & Ciesielska, 2018) qualitative research has a long and rich history in organizational
studies, mostly for those dedicated to human oriented approach. Thus we used qualitative research
conducted globally, as for instance the reports called symbolically Women in the boardroom: A
global perspective, Women in Business 2021: A window of opportunity, Women’s
Entrepreneurship Report: From Crisis to Opportunity, Women on Boards in Romania. We selected
these global reports taking into account the quality of the data and the relevance of the samples
used.
For this paper we focused on career management and development for leadership women
based on some examples of best practices. Our paper had first looked for the theoretical and
methodological background based on literature review. Next we investigated the international
practical expertise starting from the global reports mentioned previously. The following step was
to select and analyze some of the most relevant career success stories in women's leadership, as
best examples of how women's leadership managed to face challenges. More specifically, the unit
of analysis in this paper took into account women’s proportion in organizations and women’s
leadership. For this purpose we used four international reports, analyzing the situation of the
percentage of women on the board of directors holding managerial positions within organizations.
The analysis had been directed to the Romanian case, where we had identified the proportion of
women leaders. The analysis includes some relevant success stories of women leaders. Since the
main goal of this paper is to investigate the representation of women leaders in EU countries and
correspondingly in Romania we tried to look also for the most important characteristics of women
leaders, taking into account at the same time the expected trends for the future, with a clear focus
on a human and heart centered approach.
UE average
28,3%
According to the data illustrated by figure 1 it is interesting to note that EU countries have
a significant share in the percentage of female board members compared to the US. For example,
France has a percentage of 43,20% followed by Norway 42,40%, Italy 36,60%, Belgium 34,60%.
At the bottom part of this ranking are Greece, Luxembourg and Romania. The UE average
is 28,3%, and the value for SUA is 23,90. We may also notice that the percentage of women on the
board in the US is lower compared to the EU average.
Within the European Union since 2010 there had been some initiative dedicated to
strengthening gender diversity on company boards. In line with this in 2010, a gender equality
strategy was launched. Next, in 2012 there was a Directive on women on company boards, aimed
at promoting diversity on company boards in the European Union, with the main objective of
PICBE |
1686
As illustrated in figure2, in 2021, the average share of women on board sets in the EU was 28.36%.
We may notice that on average in 2021, the share of women increased by 4,50% percent.
The country with the most significant increase in 2021 compared to 2018 was Austria with an
increase of 8.5%, followed by Italy (7.3%), Poland (7.3%), Spain (7.10%), Portugal (6.30%) and
France (6.%). The countries with the lowest growth rate were: Finland (0.80%), Norway (1.40%),
Sweden (1.40%), Germany (2.70%), Luxembourg (3.50%). It is also important to mention that in
2021 only France (43,20%) and Norway(42,40%) exceeded the target of 40% of board seats held
by women, in line with the target set in 2012 by the directive previously mentioned. France adopted
in January 2017 a 40% legislative quota for both genders to be represented on boards of directors.
This quota applies in listed companies, government companies, government organizations and
private companies with revenues or total active revenues of more than €50 million and employing
250 or more people. In the Women in the Boardroom study for France, a total of 171 companies
were analyzed, in which 771 women on the board had been identified. The industries with the
highest percentage of women on the board are: consumer business 47.4%, financial services 45.4%,
and energy & resources 44.4%. In 2021, the percentage of women CEOS was 9.7%, higher as
compared to 6.2% in 2018.
According to the Women in Business 2021, A window of opportunity Report, the main actions
taken in order to promote gender equality in 2021 were: Ensuring equal access to developmental
work opportunities (39%), Creating an inclusive culture (36%), Providing mentoring and coaching
(32%.). The report also mentions that in 2017 a quarter of the management positions were occupied
by women. Progress continued slowly, such as in 2021, it reached 31%, indicating that, in the short-
DOI: 10.2478/picbe-2023-0150 pp. 1681-1690, ISSN 2558-9652 |
Proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Business Excellence 2023
term, a third of all senior management positions are likely to be held by women. In the case of
Romania, the situation regarding the proportion of women with managerial positions is still low.
As we can see from figure 2, in 2021 the percentage was 12.8%. compared to the EU average of
28.36%. We notice an increase of 1.8% compared to 2018. Currently, in Romania there are no
minimum legal requirements in support of women participation in company leadership. Instead,
there is a Bucharest Stock Exchange initiative, the Bucharest Stock Exchange Code of Corporate PICBE |
Conduct. (Bucharest Stock Exchange, 2015). It is mentioned in an explicit way that Boards of 1687
Directors and its committees should have an appropriate balance of skills, experience, gender
diversity, knowledge and independence such as to enable and empower them to effectively carry
out their tasks and responsibilities. The Romanian Government, through the National Agency for
Equal Opportunities between Women and Men adopted in 2018 the National Strategy 2018-2021;
which promotes equal opportunities between women and men, as well as an operational plan for
its implementation (Romanian Government, 2018).
Women on Boards Report mentions for Romania that, following the analysis of the companies
listed on the regulated market of BVB in Romania in 2020, 184 women were registered in the
executive committees and boards of directors out of 760 members in total, while in 2015 only 114
were women actively involved within the executive committees.
25%
23% 21%
20% 19%
18%
15% 14%
10%
2021
5%
0%
In figure 3 we notice the percentage of women involved within the industry sector in 2020.
The largest proportions are in: Manufacturing, Services and Financial Services.
Based on this situation we tried to design a profile of the main characteristics of women
leaders as these had been expressed by some successful women leaders who had also highlighted
some of the expected future trends. We illustrate some of these characteristics synthetically in table
1 considering it might be helpful for career management and development for the women leaders
in Romania. The table is inspired by the examples of stories of success of remarkable women
leaders.
References
Baltazar, J., Franco. M. (2023). The Influence of Different Leadership Styles on the Entrepreneurial
Process: A Qualitative Study. Economies.
BCG (Boston Consulting Group). (2021). Human centered leaders are the future of leadership.
Bhatt, E.R. (2015). Women Heralding Change. In: Kumar, P. (eds) Unveiling Women’s
Leadership. Palgrave Macmillan, London. https://doi.org/10.1057/9781137547064_8
Bucharest Stock Exchange. (2015). Code of Corporate Governance
Chatwani. N. (2015). Looking Ahead: The Feminization of Leadership. Unveiling Women’s
Leadership. Palgrave Macmillan.
Corrigall, F. (2015). The experience of successful leaders: an ipa study on senior female clinical
psychologists. The University of Leeds School of Medicine Academic Unit of Psychiatry
and Behavioural Sciences.
Deloitte Global Boardroom Program, (2022). Women in the boardroom: A global perspective.
Seventh edition.