Higher Nationals

Internal verification of assessment decisions – BTEC (RQF)

INTERNAL VERIFICATION – ASSESSMENT DECISIONS

Programme title Pearson Higher Nationals in Business

Assessor Internal Verifier

Unit 4: Leadership and Management

Unit(s)

Understanding different types of leadership and management theories and

Assignment title principals and their impact on the effectiveness and continuous improvement
of an organization.

Student’s name

List which assessment Pass Merit Distinction

criteria the Assessor has
awarded.

INTERNAL VERIFIER CHECKLIST

Do the assessment criteria awarded

match those shown in the assignment
brief?
Y/N

Is the Pass/Merit/Distinction grade

awarded justified by the assessor’s
comments on the student work? Y/N

Has the work been assessed

accurately? Y/N

Is the feedback to the student:

Give details:
 • Constructive?

Y/N
• Linked to relevant Y/N
assessment criteria?

• Identifying opportunities
for improved Y/N
performance?
Y/N

• Agreeing actions?

Does the assessment decision need

amending? Y/N

Assessor signature Date

Internal Verifier signature Date

Programme Leader signature (if

required) Date
Confirm action completed
Remedial action taken

Give details:

Internal Verifier
signature Date
Programme Leader
signature (if required) Date
Higher Nationals - Summative Assignment Feedback Form

Student Name/ID

Unit Title Unit 4: Leadership and Management

Assignment Number 01 Assessor
Date Received 1st
Submission Date submission
Date Received 2nd
Re-submission Date submission
 Assessor Feedback:

LO1 Examine leadership and management theories and principles, and their impact on the
effectiveness of an organisation
Pass, Merit & Distinction P1 P2 M1 D1
Descripts

LO2 Review the influence of different leadership and management styles on the culture of
organisations
Pass, Merit & Distinction P3 P4 M2 M3
Descripts

LO3 Develop a motivational strategy to optimise organisational performance

Pass, Merit & Distinction P5 M4 D2

Descripts

Grade: Assessor Signature: Date:

Resubmission Feedback:

Internal Verifier’s Comments:

Signature & Date:

* Please note that grade decisions are provisional. They are only confirmed once internal and external moderation has taken place and grades decisions have
been agreed at the assessment board.

Assignment Feedback
Formative Feedback: Assessor to Student
Action Plan

Summative feedback

Feedback: Student to Assessor

Assessor signature Date

Student signature Date

Pearson
Higher Nationals in
Business

Unit 4: Leadership and Management

General Guidelines

1. A Cover page or title page – You should always attach a title page to your assignment. Use previous page as
your cover sheet and make sure all the details are accurately filled.
2. Attach this brief as the first section of your assignment.
3. All the assignments should be prepared using a word processing software.
4. All the assignments should be printed on A4 sized papers. Use single side printing.
5. Allow 1” for top, bottom, right margins and 1.25” for the left margin of each page.

Word Processing Rules

1. The font size should be 12 point and should be in the style of Time New Roman.
2. Use 1.5 line spacing. Left justify all paragraphs.
3. Ensure that all the headings are consistent in terms of the font size and font style (First level 16/bold, Second
level 14/bold and Third level 12/bold).
4. Use footer function in the word processor to insert Your Name, Subject, Assignment No, and Page
Number on each page. This is useful if individual sheets become detached for any reason.
5. Use word processing application spell check and grammar check function to help editing your assignment.

Important Points:

1. It is strictly prohibited to use textboxes to add texts in the assignments, except for the compulsory
information. eg: Figures, tables of comparison etc. Adding text boxes in the body except for the before
mentioned compulsory information will result in rejection of your work.
2. Avoid using page borders in your assignment body.
3. Carefully check the hand in date and the instructions given in the assignment. Late submissions will not be
accepted.
4. Ensure that you give yourself enough time to complete the assignment by the due date.
5. Excuses of any nature will not be accepted for failure to hand in the work on time.
6. You must take responsibility for managing your own time effectively.
7. If you are unable to hand in your assignment on time and have valid reasons such as illness, you may apply (in
writing) for an extension.
8. Failure to achieve at least PASS criteria will result in a REFERRAL grade .
9. Non-submission of work without valid reasons will lead to an automatic RE FERRAL. You will then be
asked to complete an alternative assignment.
10. If you use other people’s work or ideas in your assignment, reference them properly using HARVARD
referencing system to avoid plagiarism. You have to provide both in-text citation and a reference list.
11. If you are proven to be guilty of plagiarism or any academic misconduct, your grade could be reduced to A
REFERRAL or at worst you could be expelled from the course
Student Declaration

I hereby, declare that I know what plagiarism entails, namely to use another’s work and to present it as my own
without attributing the sources in the correct way. I further understand what it means to copy another’s work.

1. I know that plagiarism is a punishable offence because it constitutes theft.

2. I understand the plagiarism and copying policy of the Edexcel UK.

3. I know what the consequences will be if I plagiaries or copy another’s work in any of the assignments for this
program.

4. I declare therefore that all work presented by me for every aspects of my program, will be my own, and where
I have made use of another’s work, I will attribute the source in the correct way.

5. I acknowledge that the attachment of this document signed or not, constitutes a binding agreement between
myself and Edexcel UK.

6. I understand that my assignment will not be considered as submitted if this document is not attached to the
attached.

Student’s Signature: Date:

(Provide E-mail ID) (Provide Submission Date)

Higher National Certificate/Diploma in Business

Assignment Brief

Student Name /ID Number

Unit Number and Title Unit 4: Leadership and Management

Academic Year

Unit Tutor

Assignment Title Understanding different types of leadership and management

theories and principals and their impact on the effectiveness and
continuous improvement of an organization.

Issue Date

Submission Date

IV Name & Date

Submission format

Section A:

The submission should be in the form of a written report that includes Management and leadership
theories and their impact on effectiveness and influence on the culture of the selected organization.
The key findings of the study need to be presented in a 15minutes PowerPoint presentation. (5
minutes allocated for the questions). Presentation slides and speaker notes should be attached to the
appendix in the report. The recommended word count for the report is 1,000–,1500 words but
learner will not be penalized for exceeding the total word limit.

The report is required to make effective use of signposting (numbered headings, bullet points and
subsections) in- text referencing as appropriate. Your research should be referenced using the
Harvard referencing system. Please also provide a reference list using the Harvard referencing
system.

Section B:

The submission should be in the form of an individual written report written in a concise, formal
business style using single spacing and font size 12. You are required to make use of headings,
paragraphs,and subsections as appropriate, and all work must be supported with research and
referenced using Harvard referencing system (in-text and end-text referencing). The
recommended word count for the report is 4,000–4,500 words but learner will not be
penalized for exceeding the total word limit.

Unit Learning Outcomes:

LO1 Examine leadership and management theories and principles, and their impact on the
effectiveness of an organisation

LO2 Review the influence of different leadership and management styles on the culture of
organisations

LO3 Develop a motivational strategy to optimise organisational performance

LO4 Apply leadership and management approaches to managing performance to ensure continuous
improvement.
Learning Outcomes and Assessment Criteria

Pass Merit Distinction

LO1 Examine leadership and management theories and LO1 and LO2
principles, and their impact on the effectiveness of an D1 Critically evaluate the impact of
organisation different approaches to leadership and
management.

P1 Discuss different theories M1 Analyse the impact of the

of leadership in relation to the application of leadership and
management activities in management theories on the
different organisations. effectiveness of a large
P2 Explore different theories organisation.
of management in relation to
the management and
leadership activities in
different organisations.

LO2 Review the influence of different leadership and

management styles on the culture of organisations

P3 Assess different leadership M2 Compare the impact of

and management styles and
their application in a range of
business situations in
different organisations.
P4 Examine the factors that
influence the development of
the culture in organisations.
leadership and management
styles on decision making in
different organisations.
M3 Evaluate the importance
of organisational culture on
the performance of different
organisations.

LO3 Develop a motivational strategy to optimise organisational performance

P5 Produce a motivational M4 Produce a detailed D2 Produce a comprehensive

strategy for an organisation motivational strategy for an motivational strategy that effectively
that supports optimal organisation that addresses addresses all variables of motivation to
achievement of organisational intrinsic and extrinsic
objectives. motivation. enhance organisational performance.

LO4 Apply leadership and management approaches to managing performance to ensure continuous
improvement.

P6 Apply to a range of M5 Assess how leadership D3 Make recommendations to improve

business situations,
appropriate leadership, and
management approaches for
managing performance and
continuous improvement.
and management approaches performance management that will
for managing performance ensure continuous improvement.
supports continuous
improvement.
Assignment Brief and Guidance:

Section A

Assume that you have been recruited as the Business Consultant for a well-known Sri
Lankan Firm. This firm is suffering a downgrowth in past few years. The top management
is requesting you to analyse the situation and compare the organizational situation with few
other organizations from the same industry. To achieve the above first, you need to explore
and discuss how different theories of leadership and management effecting practical
situations in chosen organizations. Then analyse how the application of leadership and
management theories impacting the effectiveness of those organizations.

Also, you need to identify an assess the application of different leadership and management
styles in selected business situations. You can compare your organization with selected
organizations differentiate the impact of leadership and management styles.

You need to examine the factors that influence the development of the culture in selected
organisations. Furthermore, evaluate how the organizational culture resulting on
performance of the selected organization. Your report also should include a critical
evaluation of the impact of different approaches that selected organizations practicing in
the leadership and management.

Section B

In this written report, you can select one organization out of the chosen organizations in
Section A. You must make a comprehensive motivational strategy and apply variety of
business situations for suitable leadership, and management approaches for managing
performance and continuous improvement.

Your strategy should include how this motivational strategy will support optimal
achievement of organizational objectives. Also, the motivational strategy should address
intrinsic and extrinsic motivation with regards to selected organization. Make sure to
effectively address all variables of motivation to uplift organizational performance.

You are required to suggest recommendations to improve performance management that

will ensure continuous improvement of the selected organization. To achieve above apply
appropriate leadership and management approaches to managing performance in range of
business situations. Also, the recommendations should assess how leadership and
management approaches for managing performance supports continuous improvement of
the chosen organization.
Grading Rubric

Grading Criteria Achieved Feedback

P1 Discuss different theories of

leadership in relation to the
management activities in different
organisations.

P2 Explore different theories of

management in relation to the
management and leadership activities in
different organisations.

P3 Assess different leadership and

management styles and their application
in a range of business situations in
different organisations.

P4 Examine the factors that influence

the development of the culture in
organisations.

P5 Produce a motivational strategy for

an organisation that supports optimal
achievement of organisational
objectives.

P6 Apply to a range of business

situations, appropriate leadership, and
management approaches for managing
performance and continuous

17
improvement.

M1 Analyse the impact of the

application of leadership and
management theories on the
effectiveness of a large organisation.

M2 Compare the impact of leadership

and management styles on decision
making in different organisations.

M3 Evaluate the importance of

organisational culture on the
performance of different organisations.

M4 Produce a detailed motivational

strategy for an organisation that
addresses intrinsic and extrinsic
motivation.

M5 Assess how leadership and

management approaches for managing
performance supports continuous
improvement.

D1 Critically evaluate the impact of

different approaches to leadership and
management.

D2 Produce a comprehensive
motivational strategy that effectively
addresses all variables of motivation to
enhance organisational performance.

D3 Make recommendations to improve

performance management that will
ensure continuous improvement.

18
19
 OBSERVATION RECORD

Learner name:

Qualification: BTEC Level 4-HNC/HND Diploma (RQF)

Unit number & title: Unit 4: Leadership and Management

Description of activity undertaken

Assessment criteria targeted

How the activity covers the requirements of the assessment criteria (this does not confirm
achievement of assessment criteria or confer an assessment decision)

Learner name:

Learner signature: Date:

Assessor name:

Assessor signature: Date:

WITNESS STATEMENT

20
Learner name:

Qualification: BTEC Level 4-HNC/HND Diploma (RQF)

Unit number & title: Unit 4: Leadership and Management

Description of activity undertaken (please be as specific as possible)

Assessment criteria (for which the activity provides evidence)

How the activity covers the requirements of the assessment criteria, including how and where the
activity took place (this does not confirm achievement of assessment criteria or confer an assessment
decision)

Witness name: Job role:

Witness
Date:
signature:

Learner name:

Learner
Date:
signature:

Assessor name:

Assessor
Date:
signature:

21
Contents
1. Leadership & Management: Keels Supermarket............................................................................24
Section A..................................................................................................................................................25
1.1 Effective functioning using Leadership principles and management theories ......................25
1.1.1 Overview of Keels Supermarket Chain.................................................................................25
1.1.2 Leadership Theories..............................................................................................................25
1.1.3 Management Theories...........................................................................................................26
1.1.4 Theory X and Theory Y........................................................................................................27
2. Organisational culture..........................................................................................................................28
2.1 Influence of management style on the culture of an organisation................................................28
1. Leadership Approach:................................................................................................................28
2. Communication:.........................................................................................................................28
3. Employee Empowerment:..........................................................................................................29
4. Feedback and Recognition:........................................................................................................29
5. Conflict Resolution:...................................................................................................................29
6. Risk Tolerance:..........................................................................................................................29
7. Adaptability to Change:.............................................................................................................29
9. Values and Ethics:......................................................................................................................29
2.2 Organisational culture of Keels Supermarket...............................................................................30
Section B..................................................................................................................................................31
3. Organisational performance.................................................................................................................31
3.1. Importance of motivation to increase the overall performance of Keels Super..........................31
3.1.1. Definition of Motivation.....................................................................................................31
3.1.2.The significance of the employee motivation to the performance of Keels Super...............31
3.1.3 Action Plan to boost motivation of the Keels Super employees................................................34
3.1.4 KPI for employee of Keels Supermarket...................................................................................36
4. Management Approaches....................................................................................................................38
4.1 Lean management.........................................................................................................................38
4.2 Continuous Improvement..............................................................................................................39
5,Conclusion............................................................................................................................................39

List of Figures

Figure 1.1 Mc Gregors Theory (TEW, 2020)…………………………………………………………29

Figure 2 –Maslow Theory (Mcloyed, 2023)………………………………………………………….33

22
List of Tables

Table 3.1 – Motivation Strategies…………………………………………………37

Table 3.1 -KPI ……………………………………………………………………..40

23
Understanding different types of
leadership and management theories
and principals and their impact on the
effectiveness and continuous
improvement of an organization.

1. Leadership & Management: Keels Supermarket

Effective business success hinges on leadership, management, and employee

motivation. A conducive leadership and management environment fosters efficiency
and a competitive edge. This assignment explores diverse leadership and management
theories, analyzing their impact on large organizations. It delves into leadership and
management styles across various business scenarios, assessing factors influencing
organizational culture development. The comparison of their impact on decision-
making and the crucial role of organizational culture in performance is thoroughly
evaluated. Additionally, the assignment presents a comprehensive motivational
strategy addressing intrinsic and extrinsic motivation for optimal organizational
achievement. Appropriate leadership and management approaches for performance
management and continuous improvement are examined, along with their pros and
cons. Recommendations for enhancing performance management to ensure ongoing
improvement are also provided.

24
Section A
1.1 Effective functioning using Leadership principles and
management theories .

1.1.1 Overview of Keels Supermarket Chain

Keells Super is a prominent supermarket chain in Sri Lanka, recognized for its
extensive network of stores offering a diverse range of groceries, fresh produce,
household items, and more. Established in 1983, Keells Super has evolved into a
trusted brand, providing a convenient and reliable shopping experience for customers
across the island. With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, Keells Super has
become a leading name in the retail industry in Sri Lanka. (Ratnayake, 2015)

1.1.2 Leadership Theories

Leadership theories are frameworks that seek to explain how individuals become
effective leaders and influence others within an organizational context.

 Trait theories focus on identifying inherent qualities that make someone a good
leader, emphasizing characteristics like intelligence and charisma.
 Behavioral theories, on the other hand, examine the actions and behaviors of
successful leaders, categorizing them as either task-oriented or relationship-
oriented.
 Contingency theories assert that effective leadership depends on situational
factors, proposing that different situations require different leadership styles.
 Transformational leadership emphasizes inspiring and motivating followers to
achieve beyond their self-interests, fostering a sense of collective purpose.
 Transactional leadership, in contrast, involves exchanges between leaders and
followers, with a focus on rewards and punishments.
 Situational leadership suggests that leaders should adapt their style based on the
maturity level of their followers.

25
These theories offer diverse perspectives on leadership, acknowledging the
complexity and dynamic nature of the leader-follower relationship in various
organizational settings. (Uhl‐Bien, 2007)

1.1.3 Management Theories

Management theories have been formed to carry out the 4 main managerial functions
namely, Planning, Organizing, Leading, and Controlling .
1. Scientific Management (Copley, 2002)
Fredric Taylor expounded this theory which focuses on efficiency through systematic
work methods, time and motion studies. Emphasizes worker productivity and
standardized processes for increased output.
2. Administrative Management (Henri Fayol):
Emphasizes management functions such as planning, organizing, coordinating, and
controlling. Aims for organizational efficiency through clear hierarchy and well-defined
roles. (Edwards, 2018)
3. Bureaucratic Management (Max Weber):
Advocates for a rational and systematic organizational structure based on rules and
hierarchy. Aims to eliminate ambiguity and increase predictability in decision-making.
(Pearson, 2019)
4. Human Relations Approach (Elton Mayo):
Prioritizes the social and psychological aspects of work. Emphasizes the importance of
employee satisfaction, motivation, and interpersonal relationships for improved
organizational performance. (mayo, 1990)
5. Behavioral Management (Douglas McGregor):
Examines management assumptions about employee behavior. Theory X assumes
employees dislike work, while Theory Y assumes they are intrinsically motivated and
seek responsibility. (Kopelman, 2008)
6. Total Quality Management (W. Edwards Deming):
Focuses on continuous improvement, customer satisfaction, and employee involvement.
Aims to enhance product and process quality through teamwork, training, and a customer-
centric approach. (Hackman, 1995)
7. Strategic Management (Michael Porter):

26
Concerned with long-term planning to gain a competitive advantage. Involves analyzing
industry forces and developing strategies for positioning a business effectively in the
market. (Hoskisson, 1999)

1.1.4 Theory X and Theory Y

Figure 1.1 Mc Gregors Theory (TEW, 2020)

1. Theory X:
Theory X assumes that employees inherently dislike work, are lazy, and will avoid it
if possible. It suggests that people need to be closely supervised and controlled to
ensure they meet organizational goals. The management style associated with Theory
X is authoritative and directive. Managers using this approach tend to rely on
coercion, tight control, and a system of rewards and punishments to motivate
employees. Employees are considered to be inherently unambitious, seeking security
over all else, and needing constant direction and oversight.

2. Theory Y:

27
Theory Y, on the other hand, assumes that work is as natural as play and rest. It posits
that people are not inherently lazy; rather, work can be a source of satisfaction and
that individuals can be self-motivated and creative. The management style associated
with Theory Y is participative and collaborative. Managers using this approach
believe in decentralization, delegation, and creating a work environment that
encourages employees to reach their full potential. Employees are seen as responsible,
capable of self-direction, and capable of contributing to decision-making processes.
Theory Y managers trust and empower their employees.

McGregor argued that the choice between Theory X and Theory Y reflects the
manager's assumptions about the nature of people and greatly influences their
management style.

2. Organisational culture

2.1 Influence of management style on the culture of an organisation.

Management style has a profound impact on the culture of an organization. The way
leaders manage and interact with their teams shapes the work environment, employee
attitudes, and overall organizational culture. Here are some ways in which
management style can influence organizational culture: (Locke, 2007)

1. Leadership Approach:
An autocratic management style, where decisions are made by a single authority, can
create a culture of strict hierarchy and limited employee empowerment. On the other
hand, a democratic style, where decision-making involves employees, fosters a more
inclusive and participative culture.

2. Communication:
A management style that encourages open communication and transparency tends to
foster a culture of trust and collaboration. Conversely, closed communication can lead
to a culture of secrecy and mistrust.

28
3. Employee Empowerment:
Micromanagement stifles employee autonomy and creativity, fostering a culture of
dependency and low morale. Delegating responsibilities and trusting employees to
take ownership can create a culture of innovation and accountability.

4. Feedback and Recognition:

A management style that emphasizes positive reinforcement and constructive
feedback contributes to a culture of continuous improvement and employee
development. Constantly providing negative feedback without recognition can lead to
a culture of fear and low morale.

5. Conflict Resolution:
A collaborative approach to resolving conflicts encourages open dialogue and
resolution, contributing to a culture of teamwork and cooperation. Authoritarian
conflict resolution may lead to a culture of fear and resentment.

6. Risk Tolerance:
A risk-averse management style may lead to a cautious and stable culture, but it might
hinder innovation. A more risk-taking approach can foster a culture that values
experimentation and creativity.

7. Adaptability to Change:
A management style that embraces change and encourages adaptability can lead to a
culture that is dynamic and responsive to market trends. A rigid management style
may result in a resistant and stagnant organizational culture.
8. Work-Life Balance:

A management style that values work-life balance and supports employee well-being
contributes to a positive organizational culture. Conversely, a demanding and
inflexible management style may create a culture of burnout and dissatisfaction.

9. Values and Ethics:

The management style sets the tone for ethical behavior within the organization.
Ethical leadership contributes to a culture of integrity and trust, while unethical
practices can erode organizational values.

10. Inclusivity and Diversity:

29
A management style that promotes inclusivity and diversity contributes to a culture
that values different perspectives and experiences. Exclusive management practices
can result in a homogeneous and exclusive organizational culture.

2.2 Organisational culture of Keels Supermarket

Organizational culture is a complex and multifaceted aspect that encompasses the

values, beliefs, behaviors, and practices within a company. supermarkets often
prioritize customer service, efficiency, teamwork, and adaptability. They may foster a
culture of responsiveness to customer needs, employee engagement, and continuous
improvement. As with any organization, the specific cultural attributes of Keels
supermarket can vary based on its leadership, history, and overall strategic objectives.

In an interview, the CEO reflects on the journey of their supermarket business,

emphasizing its evolution from being an event to a convenience. The company's core
purpose revolves around enhancing people's quality of life by adapting to changing
lifestyles. Initially facing slow growth and limited profitability, they opened only five
stores until 2000, as the parent company had other priorities. A renewed focus on the
retail sector in 2012 led to innovation, introducing bakery sections and juice counters
to distinguish themselves from competitors.

Despite challenges in a market where supermarkets constitute a small percentage of

sales, the speaker highlights the need to attract new customers and employees. Start-
up costs, long payback periods, and slim margins pose obstacles that require rapid
scaling for profitability. The lack of glamour in food retail jobs adds complexity to
hiring and retaining employees, making career progression within the company
crucial. (Hamsa, 2019)

30
Section B

31
Today, we'll delve into the world of leadership and management theories, exploring
their profound impact on organizational effectiveness and continuous improvement.

Leadership theories provide frameworks to understand how leaders influence their

teams. Let's briefly overview some key theories that have shaped leadership thinking.

32
On the management side, various theories have evolved to enhance organizational
efficiency and structure. These include Scientific Management, Administrative
Management, and Bureaucratic Management.

33
While distinct, effective organizations often integrate both leadership and
management principles for optimal results. Leadership sets the vision, and
management ensures efficient execution.

34
Effective leadership is built on principles like clear communication, inspiring vision,
and empathy. Let's explore these principles in more detail.

35
Despite the benefits, organizations often face challenges in implementing these
theories. We'll explore some common obstacles and discuss potential solutions.

Thank you for your attention. Now, let's open the floor for any questions or
discussions you may have on the topic of leadership and management theories and
their impact on organizational effectiveness and continuous improvement.

36
Organisational performance

3.1. Importance of motivation to increase the overall performance of

Keels Super

3.1.1. Definition of Motivation

Motivation is the driving force that initiates, guides, and sustains goal-oriented
behaviors. It involves the internal and external factors that stimulate the desire and
energy to achieve a particular outcome. A classic definition of motivation is provided
by , (Francis, 2012)who describe it as "the processes that account for an individual's
intensity, direction, and persistence of effort toward attaining a goal."

3.1.2.The significance of the employee motivation to the performance of Keels

Super

37
A company's triumph hinges on effective direction, motivation, and leadership, with
motivation playing a pivotal role in understanding and fulfilling both employee and
organizational needs. Managers deploy diverse motivational techniques to propel
individuals towards their maximum potential, elevating organizational performance.
A motivated workforce exhibits heightened capacity and eagerness for continuous
improvement through education and training. Motivated employees positively
influence colleagues' attitudes, fostering a supportive work culture. Additionally,
motivation aids in navigating organizational changes by building trust and
transparency, alleviating concerns among personnel. This collaborative approach
enhances job satisfaction, communication, and overall productivity, culminating in
organizational success.

3.2. Motivational strategy for Keels Super

3.2.1. What are Motivational theories
Motivational theories play a crucial role in shaping the work environment and
employee performance within the Keels supermarket setting. Applying these theories
can enhance job satisfaction, increase productivity, and foster a positive workplace
culture. Here are several motivational theories that can be effectively applied to
supermarket employees:

38
Figure 2 –Maslow Theory (Mcloyed, 2023)

1. Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs

Maslow's theory suggests that individuals have a hierarchy of needs, ranging from
basic physiological needs to higher-order psychological needs. For supermarket
employees, ensuring fair wages, comfortable working conditions, and job security
addresses their basic needs. Providing opportunities for career growth, training, and
recognition satisfies higher-level needs, fostering a sense of fulfillment.

2. Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory (Motivator-Hygiene Theory):

According to Herzberg, job satisfaction and dissatisfaction are influenced by

separate factors. Hygiene factors such as salary, working conditions, and company
39
policies can prevent dissatisfaction, but they do not necessarily motivate. Motivational
factors like recognition, responsibility, and achievement can inspire supermarket
employees and contribute to job satisfaction. (Fisher, 2009)

3. Expectancy Theory:
This theory posits that individuals are motivated to act in a certain way if they
believe their efforts will lead to desired outcomes. Supermarket managers can apply
expectancy theory by clearly communicating performance expectations and linking
them to meaningful rewards such as bonuses, promotions, or recognition. Employees
are more likely to be motivated if they perceive a strong connection between their
efforts and the rewards they receive.

4. Goal-Setting Theory:
Goal-setting theory emphasizes the importance of setting specific and challenging
goals to enhance motivation. In a supermarket setting, managers can work with
employees to establish clear, measurable objectives related to sales targets, customer
service, or process improvements. Regular feedback and recognition for achieving
these goals can further boost motivation. (Hoskisson, 1999)

5. Equity Theory:
Equity theory suggests that employees compare their inputs (effort, skills) and
outputs (rewards) with those of their colleagues. Supermarket managers should strive
for perceived fairness in workload distribution, recognition, and rewards. When
employees feel they are treated fairly, they are more likely to be motivated and
engaged in their work.

6. Social Learning Theory:

Social learning theory highlights the role of observing and modeling the behavior of
others. In a supermarket setting, creating a positive and collaborative work culture,
where employees can learn from each other and share best practices, can enhance
motivation. Encouraging teamwork and providing opportunities for mentorship can
also contribute to employee satisfaction. (Fisher, 2009)

7. Job Characteristics Model:

40
 This model identifies key job design elements that contribute to employee
motivation. Supermarket managers can enhance motivation by incorporating variety,
autonomy, task significance, and feedback into job roles. For example, allowing
employees to rotate tasks, providing autonomy in decision-making, and emphasizing
the importance of their contributions to the overall success of the supermarket.

Applying these motivational theories in tandem and tailoring strategies to the specific
needs and preferences of supermarket employees can create a work environment that
fosters motivation, engagement, and ultimately, improved performance. (Pierce,
2009)

3.1.3 Action Plan to boost motivation of the Keels Super employees.

Motivating employees in a supermarket chain involves a combination of strategies
that cater to their professional development, well-being, and job satisfaction. Here's
an action plan to boost employee motivation: (Schüler, 1987)

Topic Strategy

Understand Employee Needs Conduct surveys or one-on-one

discussions to understand the needs and
expectations of your employees

Identify common themes or issues that

might be affecting motivation.

Recognition and Rewards Implement a recognition program to

acknowledge and reward outstanding
performance.

Recognize both individual and team

achievements regularly.

Consider offering tangible rewards such

as gift cards, vouchers, or other
incentives.

Professional Development Provide opportunities for skill

development and career advancement.

Offer training programs or workshops to

41
 enhance their skills.

Establish clear career paths and

encourage employees to set personal
development goals.

Effective Communication Foster open communication channels

between management and employees

Encourage feedback and act on it when

appropriate.

Work-Life Balance Promote a healthy work-life balance by

respecting employees' time off.

Consider flexible scheduling options or

remote work arrangements when
possible.

Offer employee assistance programs to

support their well-being.

Employee Involvement Involve employees in decision-making

processes when applicable.

Create employee committees or forums to

discuss improvements and ideas.

Encourage a sense of ownership and

pride in their work.

Table 3.1 – Motivation Strategies

3.1.4 KPI for employee of Keels Supermarket

Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for supermarket employees can help measure their
effectiveness, efficiency, and contribution to overall store performance. Here's a set of
KPIs tailored for supermarket employees:

KPI Strategy

42
Sales Performance Measure the overall revenue generated by
the employee.

Evaluate the average amount spent per

customer transaction.

Track the percentage of transactions

where additional items are successfully
upsold.

Customer Service Measure customer satisfaction through

surveys or feedback to assess the quality
of service provided

Monitor the time customers spend

waiting in line at checkout counters.

Track how quickly and effectively

employees resolve customer issues or
complaints.

Inventory Management Measure the accuracy of inventory levels

compared to recorded quantities.

Evaluate the percentage of inventory loss

due to theft, damage, or other factors.

Operational Efficiency Measure the average time it takes for an

employee to complete a transaction.

Track the time it takes to restock shelves

43
 and replenish inventory.

Monitor the length of customer queues

during peak hours.

Product Knowledge Regularly assess employees on their

knowledge of products and their locations
in the store

Measure the effectiveness of employees

in promoting and selling new products.

Attendance and Punctuality Track the percentage of scheduled hours

that employees actually work.

Measure how often employees arrive on

time for their shifts.

Safety and Compliance Ensure compliance with safety

procedures to minimize accidents.

Monitor adherence to local, state, and

federal regulations related to food
handling and safety.

Table 3.1 -KPI

44
Regularly reviewing these KPIs can provide valuable insights into the performance of
supermarket employees and help identify areas for improvement. It's essential to
establish benchmarks and set realistic targets based on the specific goals and priorities
of the supermarket.

4. Management Approaches
4.1 Lean management
In implementing a lean management plan for a supermarket, the first step is to
identify and eliminate waste throughout the entire value stream. This involves
analyzing each process, from stocking shelves to checkout, to identify non-value-
added activities and streamline operations. For instance, excess inventory can lead to
waste, so adopting just-in-time inventory management can help reduce carrying costs
and prevent overstocking. Additionally, optimizing layout and product placement can
enhance the flow of both customers and staff, minimizing unnecessary movements
and improving overall efficiency. Continuous improvement is at the core of lean
management, and regular employee training and involvement in identifying and
addressing issues are vital to sustaining lean practices. Regular performance
measurements, such as tracking wait times at checkout and monitoring inventory
turnover rates, can provide valuable insights to further refine processes. (Slack, 2004)

Another crucial aspect of the lean management plan for a supermarket involves
fostering a culture of continuous improvement and empowering employees at all
levels to contribute to efficiency enhancements. This includes implementing regular
team meetings to discuss improvement opportunities, encouraging open
communication, and recognizing and rewarding employees for their contributions to
lean initiatives. Cross-training employees to perform multiple tasks ensures flexibility
and adaptability in response to fluctuations in customer demand. Furthermore,
technology can play a pivotal role in lean management, with the implementation of
point-of-sale systems and inventory management software to automate processes and
provide real-time data for decision-making. By focusing on waste reduction,

45
continuous improvement, and employee involvement, a lean management plan can
enhance the overall operational efficiency and customer satisfaction of a supermarket.

4.2 Continuous Improvement

Continuous Improvement in a supermarket involves a systematic approach to
enhancing operational processes, customer satisfaction, and overall efficiency. It
begins with regular evaluations of inventory management, product placement, and
staff performance. By analyzing customer feedback and market trends, supermarkets
can adapt and optimize their product offerings, ensuring relevance and
competitiveness. Employee training programs foster a culture of continuous learning,
empowering staff to provide excellent customer service and stay updated on industry
best practices. (Daniel, 1991)

Efficiency gains can be achieved through technology integration, such as automated

inventory systems and streamlined checkout processes. Regular performance reviews
and feedback loops encourage employees to contribute ideas for improvement.
Sustainable practices, like reducing packaging waste or energy consumption, can be
incorporated into daily operations. Continuous Improvement not only drives cost-
effectiveness but also enhances the overall shopping experience, fostering customer
loyalty and ensuring the supermarket remains agile in a dynamic market. Regularly
reassessing and adapting strategies based on data and feedback ensures that the
supermarket stays ahead of industry trends and customer expectations.

5,Conclusion
The key to effective business success lies in leadership, management, and employee
motivation. This involves creating a conducive environment for leadership and
management, which enhances efficiency and competitiveness. The assignment
explores different leadership and management theories and their impact on large
organizations. It has analyzed various leadership and management styles in different
business scenarios, considering factors influencing organizational culture
development. The study compares their effects on decision-making and emphasizes
the crucial role of organizational culture in overall performance. Furthermore, a

46
comprehensive motivational strategy is presented, addressing both intrinsic and
extrinsic motivation for optimal organizational achievement. The assignment also
examines appropriate leadership and management approaches for performance
management and continuous improvement, weighing their pros and cons.
Recommendations are provided to enhance performance management and ensure on-
going improvement.

References

Copley, F.B., 2002. Frederick W. Taylor, father of scientific management.

https://ci.nii.ac.jp/ncid/BA22331741.

Daniel, S.J..&.R.W.D., 1991. Linking quality strategy with management control systems: Empirical
evidence from Japanese industry. Accounting Organizations and Society. 6(7), 601–618.
https://doi.org/10.1016/0361-3682(91)90015-7.

Edwards, R., 2018. An Elaboration of the Administrative Theory of the 14 Principles of Management
by Henri Fayol. International Journal for Empirical Education and Research. 41–52.
https://doi.org/10.35935/edr/21.5241.

Fisher, E.A., 2009. Motivation and Leadership in Social Work Management. 33(4), 347–367.
https://doi.org/10.1080/03643100902769160.

Francis, L.J..R.M..&.R.A.0., 2012. Called for Leadership: Psychological Type Profile of Leaders
within the Newfrontiers Network of Churches in the United Kingdom. Journal of Psychology and
Theology, 40(3), 220–228. https://doi.org/10.1177/0.

Hackman, J.R..&.W.R., 1995. Total Quality Management: Empirical, conceptual, and practical issues..
Administrative Science Quarterly, 40(2), 309. https://doi.org/10.2307/2393640.

Hamsa, M., 2019. organisational Culture of Keels Super. pp.https://www.echelon.lk/keells-

supermarkets-journey-on-retail-innovation/.

Hoskisson, R.E..H.M.A..W.W.P..&.Y.D.W., 1999. Theory and research in strategic management:

Swings of a pendulum.. 253417456101177014920639902500307nd ed. Journal of Management.

Kopelman, R.E..P.D.J..&.D.A.F., 2008. Douglas McGregor’s Theory X and Y: Toward a Construct-

Valid Measure. Journal of Managerial Issues, 20(2), 255. https://www.jstor.org/stable/40604607.

47
Locke, W., 2007. Higher education mergers: Integrating organisational cultures and developing
appropriate management styles. Higher Education Quarterly. Higher Education Quarterly, 61(1), 83–
102. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2273.2006.00339.

mayo, E., 1990. Mastering public administration: from Max Weber to Dwight Waldo. Choice Reviews
Online, 27(07), 27–4135. https://doi.org/10.5860/choice.27-4135.

Mcloyed, S., 2023. Maslow Theory. pp.https://www.simplypsychology.org/maslow.html.

Pearson, 2019. Managing and leading today's police: challenges, best practices, & case studies.

Pierce, J.L..J.I..&.C.A.L., 2009. Psychological ownership within the job design context: revision of the
job characteristics model. Journal of Organizational Behavior. 30(4), 477–496.
https://doi.org/10.1002/job.550.

Ratnayake, R., 2015. Traditional Small Retail Shops vs. Emerging Supermarkets. 4(1), 44.
https://doi.org/10.4038/bhumi.v4i1.4.

Schüler, R.S..&.J.S.E., 1987. Linking Competitive Strategies with Human Resource Management
Practices.. 1(3), 207–219. https://doi.org/10.5465/ame.1987.4275740.

Slack, N..L.M.A..&.B.H., 2004. The two worlds of operations management research and practice.
International Journal of Operations & Production Management. 24(4), 372–387.
https://doi.org/10.1108/01443570410524640.

TEW, 2020. McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y of Motivation. https://medium.com/the-enterprise-

diary/mcgregors-theory-x-and-theory-y-of-motivation-2a12b53731fb.

48