Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original PDF Converging Media A New Introduction To Mass Communication 4th PDF
Original PDF Converging Media A New Introduction To Mass Communication 4th PDF
Original PDF Converging Media A New Introduction To Mass Communication 4th PDF
6 Interactive Media: The Internet, Video Games, and Augmented Reality 159
Interactive Media vs. Mass Media 161 Historical Development of the Internet and
the World Wide Web 166
Historical Development of User Internet Protocol 167
Interfaces 163 World Wide Web 168
Television Interfaces 163 Graphical Web Browsers 168
Intuitive Interfaces 164 Broadband 169
Keyboards 164 Distribution Dynamics 169
Computer Mouse 165
Video Games 171
Touch Screens 165
Natural Input Methods 165 Historical Development of Video Games 171
Contents xi
What Is News? 220 News Values and the Associated Press 223
The Historical Development of Pulitzer and Hearst: The Circulation Wars,
Journalism 222 Sensationalism, and Standards 225
xii Contents
www.oup.com/us/pavlik
Trends in the Development of Public Relations 275 Media Quiz Answers 283
PR and Media Relations 276
Pseudo-Events 276 Features
Distributing News to the Media in the Digital Age 276 Media Quiz: The Dynamics of Persuasion 253
Finding Sources Online 277 Media Pioneers: Madam C.J. Walker 257
PR Firms and the PR Industry 277 Convergence Culture: Me 2.0: The Guide to
Branding Yourself 262
Changing Trends in Advertising
International Perspectives: Global Advertising 270
and PR 278
Media Pioneers: Daniel J. Edelman 274
Looking Back and Moving Forward 281
Ethics in Media: Fooling Most of the People Most of
Discussion Questions 282
the Time . . . Digitally 279
Further Reading 282
Journalism and Political Coverage 372 Social Media and Civic Engagement 386
Politicians Using the News 374 Databases and Government Transparency 387
Sound Bites and Horse Races 375 Smart Mobs 388
The Changing Tone of Television Looking Back and Moving Forward 390
Political Coverage 375 Discussion Questions 390
Opinion Polls 376 Further Reading 391
Political Advertising 377
The Impact of Negative Advertising 377 Features
Negative Advertising Effectiveness 379 Media Quiz: Playing Politics 373
Politics and Entertainment 380 Ethics in Media: Can Imagery Lead
to Action? 379
Political Campaigns and Entertainment 380
Convergence Culture: Image Is
Political Debates 381
Everything 382
Social Media and Political International Perspectives: Crowdsourcing
Campaigns 383 Election Monitoring 386
Changes with Social Media 384 Media Pioneers: Bill Adair and PolitiFact 389
Changing Rules for Politicians 385
xvi Contents
www.oup.com/us/pavlik
Converging Media provides extensive content on the twelve core values and compe-
tencies of the Accrediting Council on Education in Journalism and Mass Commu-
nications (ACEJMC). As a nationally elected member of the ACEJMC from 2004 to
2007, John V. Pavlik recognized that the ACEJMC-based learning goals provide a
useful benchmark for assessing student learning. By covering the twelve core values
and competencies, this text provides a strong foundation for students to become
well-rounded journalists and experts in mass communication.
1. FREEDOM OF SPEECH: Understand and apply the • Regulation of journalism and mass communication in the digital age
principles and laws of freedom of speech and press including libel and censorship (p. 314–323)
for the country in which the institution that invites • Fairness (p. 332)
ACEJMC is located, as well as receive instruction in • The public’s right to know (p. 299)
and understand the range of systems of freedom of • Media systems around the world (pp. 393–415)
expression around the world, including the rights
to dissent, to monitor and criticize power, and to
assemble and petition for redress of grievances.
2. HISTORY: Demonstrate an understanding of the • Origins of photography, movies, television, and video games (pp. 124,
history and role of professionals and institutions in 128, 143, and 171)
shaping communications. • History of journalism (p. 222)
• History of advertising (p. 256)
• History of public relations (p. 272)
• History of media law and the regulation of electronic media (p. 323)
• Early research on media effects (p. 345)
• History of recorded music and radio (pp. 95 and 109)
• History of print media (books, newspapers, magazines) (pp. 64, 75,
and 85)
• History of the Internet (p. 166)
3. GENDER, RACE, AND SEXUALITY: Demonstrate • Effects of media and advertising on women and men (p. 350)
an understanding of gender, race ethnicity, sexual • Role of women in the history of magazines (p. 86)
orientation, and, as appropriate, other forms of • Diversity in the newsroom (p. 246)
diversity in domestic society in relation to mass • Minority newspapers (p. 224)
communications.
4. GLOBAL SOCIETY: Demonstrate an understanding • Relationships among various global and local media sources
of the diversity of peoples and cultures and of the (pp. 393–415)
significance and impact of mass communications in a • Cultural and socioeconomic impact of global media (pp. 399–413)
global society • “International Perspectives” boxes throughout (example, p. 12)
• International theories of the press (p. 394)
• Media in a global society appears as a theme in several chapters
5. THEORY: Understand concepts and apply • Photography, movies, and television (pp. 123–157)
theories in the use and presentation of images and • Grammar of media (p. 44)
information. • Information overload in the digital age (p. 57)
• Major media theories and research (pp. 343–369)
(Continued)
xviii ACEJMC Learning Goals
www.oup.com/us/pavlik
7. CRITICAL AND CREATIVE THINKING: Think • “Convergence Culture” boxes throughout (example, p. 56)
critically, creatively, and independently. • “Media Quizzes” in chapter openers (example, p. 39)
• Discussion questions at the end of each chapter (example, p. 282)
• Critical-Thinking Questions in selected image captions
(example, p. 127)
• Foundations for critically examining media presented early in the text
(example, p. 55)
8. RESEARCH: Conduct research and evaluate • Chapter on media theory teaches students to evaluate research
information by methods appropriate to the methods and findings (pp. 343–369)
communications professions in which they work.
9. WRITING ABILITY: Write correctly and clearly in • Appropriate writing style for particular media and for the
forms and styles appropriate for the communications communities and purposes that media professionals serve
professions, audiences, and purposes they serve. (pp. 235–239)
• Importance of clear and accurate writing in news creation
(pp. 231–235)
10. EVALUATION OF WORK: Critically evaluate • “Convergence Culture” feature “Me 2.0” provides a self-reflective case
their own work and that of others for accuracy and study (p. 262)
fairness, clarity, appropriate style, and grammatical
correctness.
11. NUMERICAL AND STATISTICAL CONCEPTS: • Data for students to analyze about newspaper circulation and
Apply basic numerical and statistical concepts. readership and advertising impact (pp. 82–84)
• Pricing structure of the recording industry (p. 104)
• Figures and tables throughout apply numerical and statistical
concepts (example, p. 270)
• “US Media Giants” (pullout at the back of the book)
12. TECHNOLOGY: Apply tools and technologies • Social media (pp. 187–217)
appropriate for the communications professions in • Interactive media (pp. 159–185)
which they work. • Role of mobile media, such as the iPad, in delivering video
(pp. 123 and 143)
• Mobile media and digital books (p. 69)
• Impact of touch screens on human–computer interface (p. 165)
• Use of digital technology in journalism (p. 239)
• Impact of digital technology and mobile media on advertising (p. 266)
Features
Convergence Culture
User-Generated Content: Creativity or Piracy? (Chapter 1) p. 19
Dos and Don’ts of Evaluating Online Information (Chapter 2) p. 56
Freesheets: Riding the Rails of Newspapers’ Future? (Chapter 3) p. 83
NPR and PRI: America’s Public Radio Networks (Chapter 4) p. 112
3-D Movies: What Will Be the Impact? (Chapter 5) p. 142
Is Playing Video Games Bad for You? (Chapter 6) p. 178
Are We Really Separated by Six Degrees? (Chapter 7) p. 206
Platypus Journalism: The Future, or Evolutionary Dead End? (Chapter
8) p. 233
Me 2.0: The Guide to Branding Yourself (Chapter 9) p. 262
Forbidden Fruit (Chapter 10) p. 304
The Great Network Neutrality Debate (Chapter 11) p. 326
Advertising’s Potential Negative Effects on Women—and Men
(Chapter 12) p. 350
Image Is Everything (Chapter 13) p. 382
Following a Natural Disaster (Chapter 14) p. 400
International Perspectives
Crying in a BMW (Chapter 1) p. 12
Mobile Telephony in the Developing World (Chapter 2) p. 50
Global EBook Marketplace (Chapter 3) p. 68
Trusting in the Power of the Airwaves (Chapter 4) p. 118
The Internet of Babel (Chapter 6) p. 162
New Kid on the Social Network Block (Chapter 7) p. 197
Covering Islam (Chapter 8) p. 230
Global Advertising (Chapter 9) p. 270
Mistaken Identity: One Life Lost, Another Ruined (Chapter 10) p. 293
The Rise and Fall of Russian Media (Chapter 11) p. 327
Theories Old, Theories New, Theories Borrowed . . . (Chapter 12) p. 361
Crowdsourcing Election Monitoring (Chapter 13) p. 386
Ethics in Media
Interactively Mapping Gun Owners (Chapter 1) p. 22
When SNL Parody Gets Taken Seriously (Chapter 2) p. 54
Prank Calls . . . on the Radio (Chapter 4) p. 108
The Photojournalist’s Dilemma: Trauma and the Photojournalist
(Chapter 5) p. 126
xix
xx Features
www.oup.com/us/pavlik
Media Pioneers
Steve Jobs (Chapter 1) p. 10
Emilie Jacobi (Chapter 3) p. 72
Amanda Palmer and the Grand Theft Orchestra (Chapter 4) p. 102
Kathleen Kennedy, Producer (Chapter 5) p. 138
Super Mario (Chapter 6) p. 174
Jack Dorsey (Chapter 7) p. 202
Mary Ann Shadd Cary and the Role of Minority Newspapers (Chapter
8) p. 224
Madam C.J. Walker (Chapter 9) p. 257
Daniel J. Edelman (Chapter 9) p. 274
Anthony Lewis and Legal Journalism (Chapter 11) p. 318
danah boyd, Researcher (Chapter 12) p. 357
Bill Adair and PolitiFact (Chapter 13) p. 389
Steve Chen, Chad Hurley, Jawed Karim—YouTube Founders
(Chapter 14) p. 407
Timelines
History (and Pre-History) of Newspapers (Chapter 3) p. 24
Milestones in Early Radio-Technology Development (Chapter 4) p. 110
Development of Photography (Chapter 5) p. 126
Selected Milestones in Early Motion Pictures (Chapter 5) p. 130
Milestones in the Development of the Internet (Chapter 6) p. 166
Milestones in the Development of Video Games (Chapter 6) p. 172
Tables
Table 1-1: Traditional Theories or Models of Analog Media p. 24
Table 2-1: Reframing Political Issues for Conservatives p. 43
Table 2-2: Reframing Political Issues for Liberals p. 43
Table 3-1: Top Ten U.S. Paid-Circulation Magazines p. 88
Table 4-1: The Major Record Labels and Their Main Subsidiary Labels and
Artists p. 100
Table 4-2: Top U.S. Radio Groups p. 114
Features xxi
Figures
Figure 1-1: Three Types of Convergence and Their Influence on Media p. 8
Figure 1-2: “Media Iceberg” p. 9
Figure 1-3: Shannon and Weaver Mathematical Theory p. 29
Figure 1-4: Schramm-Osgood Model p. 30
Figure 2-1: Semiotic Signifier and Signified p. 41
Figure 3-1: Book Publishers’ Net Dollar Sales p. 70
Figure 3-2: Book Publishers’ Units p. 71
Figure 3-3: Top 10 U.S. Newspapers by Circulation, in millions, 2012 p. 74
Figure 3-4: Major Newspaper Chains in the United States p. 80
Figure 3-5: Circulation Numbers of Morning, Evening, and Sunday Papers,
United States 2009 p. 82
Figure 3-6: Newspaper Print Ad Revenue Declines p. 84
Figure 6-1: Client/Server and Peer-to-Peer Networks p. 170
Figure 7-1: Social-Networking Site Launches p. 204
Figure 8-1: Salary Range for Journalists by Experience p. 245
Figure 9-1: Change in Advertising Dollars by Region from 2011 to
2012 p. 270
Figure 9-2: Salaries for Advertising Account Managers by Experience p. 280
Figure 9-3: Salaries for Corporate PR Specialists by Experience p. 280
Figure 10-1: The Potter Box p. 297
Figure 14-1: World Internet Users and Penetration Rates p. 403
Preface
Media convergence is in many ways a double-edged sword. Digital technologies, in-
cluding mobile and social media, have empowered citizens to access, interact with,
and generate content and stories around the world and on demand. In recent years,
Twitter and similar services have helped citizens throughout the globe organize pro-
tests against government policy and oppressive regimes.
At the same time, these powerful digital tools have enabled governments, cor-
porations, and others to conduct sweeping surveillance of citizens, as the leaks by
former National Security Agency (NSA) employee Edward Snowden have shown.
Privacy may be little more than a memory in an age when ubiquitous high-definition
cameras, big data analytics, and social media are generating massive databases en-
compassing nearly every man, woman, and child around the globe. “Most of us
have fully identified, high-definition frontal photos of ourselves online,” says Ales-
sandro Acquisti, associate professor of information technology and public policy at
Carnegie Mellon University (in a 60 Minutes interview with Lesley Stahl, 2013). On
Facebook alone, users have posted billions of photos of themselves, their friends,
and their relatives. Facebook continues to refine its facial-recognition technology,
which will make tagging friends easier but which will also help others track you.
The existence of such vast repositories of data, valuable for security and com-
mercial potential (such as individually targeted advertising), raises concerns for
civil liberties, including freedom of speech and the right to privacy. Another issue
concerns who has the right to own and control this information, especially with
the telecommunications companies and Internet giants contributing to the NSA’s
surveillance program.
Meanwhile, the transformation of media into digital form and the convergence
of media formats and industries have continued unabated. Research indicates that we
now spend more time using digital devices than we do with any other medium, includ-
ing television. Digital content is more likely to be viewed on a tablet or a smartphone
than it is on a laptop or a desktop computer. Digital distribution is now the dominant
format for music, television, and radio, whether delivered terrestrially, by satellite, or
via the Internet. Thanks to tablets and e-readers, ebooks have seen a dramatic surge in
popularity. Newspapers and magazines, which have experienced significant declines
in print circulation, are nonetheless seeing growth in tablet, smartphone, and online
distribution. Digital movies, television, and video-game distribution is now main-
stream, with companies such as Netflix and Amazon producing and streaming their
own original television shows. Tablets and other mobile devices are blurring the lines
between Internet, movies, and television while allowing technology companies like
Google, Apple, and Amazon to challenge traditional media distributors.
Our engagement with media has also changed, becoming more active as mass
and interpersonal communications converge. Any person can broadcast his or her
opinion on Twitter or via other social media, and increasingly people do so while
consuming traditional media, such as television. They post comments and engage
in conversation about popular shows. Interactive media, including video games,
constitute an increasingly popular form of entertainment.
Convergence also operates on a global scale today. The globalization of media in-
dustries and distribution has produced a cultural convergence that, at best, e nables
diverse local viewpoints to be heard and, at worst, smothers local culture in a homoge-
xxii
Preface xxiii
neous Westernized culture. Yet the impact of other viewpoints is beginning to shape
the content of new Hollywood blockbusters and other forms of Western media.
Rarely have there been such differences in media usage between the digital
natives and those who grew up in a pre-Internet era of mass communication. One
group may enjoy reading a printed newspaper over breakfast; the other group may
get their news on a tablet—if they get any news at all. One group may have impres-
sive collections of CDs and DVDs; the other group may have their music and movie
collections in the digital, online “cloud” and accessible from any location or on their
portable devices. The younger group may worry how increased product placement
may affect the type of shows that are produced; the older group may wonder what
product placement is and why it matters. One group may believe that it is nobody’s
business what their relationship status is; the other group may publicly post that
and much more personal information on social-networking sites.
Interestingly, this media divide is often represented in the college classroom,
where college students are the digital natives and their professors are from an older
mass-media tradition. Yet the two parties converge, just like the media discussed in
this book, to form a greater understanding of where media have been, where they
are today, and where they are going.
One way to look at the state of mass communication today is that convergence is
bringing us the kinds of tools that audiences have long wanted with their media—the
ability to have greater control over what they watch, read, or listen to and the ability
to share their stories and their lives with others. But with that greater control also
comes greater responsibility and a greater need for us to understand how our media
work and how they may affect our society and political systems. A double-edged sword
cuts both ways, but which way it cuts depends largely on who is wielding it.
the world as students live in it and prepares them to understand the changes
that are taking place. This organization invites students and professors to
engage in timely discussions of media within a larger framework of under-
standing traditional mass-communication topics.
· Comprehensive Coverage of Traditional Media. In order to understand
the present, we have to study the past. We cover the development and his-
torical influences of print and electronic media and the issues these media
face today. The communication professions of journalism, advertising, and
public relations are viewed from historical, societal, and career perspectives,
giving students insights into how they interact and influence each other.
· Unique Coverage of Social Media. As the first introductory mass-
communication textbook to devote a chapter to this emerging area, we place
social media within a larger media and sociocultural context. Today’s popular
social media tools are given a historical context and are connected thematically
to older online communication tools. Social media are such an integral part of
the media mix for so many people that they must be covered in an introductory
course, not introduced in an upper-division media and technology course.
· Cutting-edge Examples. We have chosen examples that are diverse, inter-
esting, and up to date. We have written Converging Media with students always
in mind—understanding the changing world they live in today. Taken from
popular media that are familiar and relevant to undergraduates, the examples
illustrate how the landscape of media has evolved—and is still evolving.
· Cultural Context. Mass communication, media technologies, and conver-
gence take place firmly within a sociocultural milieu that simultaneously
affects and is affected by these forces. Understanding this cultural context
is vital for a complete grasp of convergence and today’s media environment.
The authors emphasize the cultural influences and implications of media
technologies while explaining how they work and how they were developed.
· Emphasis on Ethics. The book has a chapter devoted entirely to ethics (Chap-
ter 10) and continues to thread ethics-related discussions throughout other
chapters, as appropriate. Students should learn that ethical considerations are
tightly linked to a full understanding of mass communication and media. Eth-
ics can also help guide us in the complex and often-confusing world of converg-
ing media, giving a basis for sound and humane decisions on media use and
production and new technologies and the way they affect people.
· International Perspectives. A new chapter on today’s global media en-
vironment (Chapter 14) provides a broad perspective on media in various
countries and the social, economic, and cultural effects of media globali-
zation overseas and domestically. The remaining chapters also highlight
international perspectives in feature boxes and in the text itself. Through
comparisons and contrasts, students obtain an appreciation for different
media systems throughout the world and how they work.
THE SEA
By Barry Cornwall
RIGHTEOUS WRATH
By Henry Van Dyke
—Outlook.
TO THE SIERRAS
By J. J. Owen
SUNSET
By Ina Coolbrith
SOMETHING TO LOVE
By William Bansman
BROTHERHOOD
By Edwin Markham
MORNING
By Edward Rowland Sill
SLEEP
By Elizabeth Barrett Browning
LABOR
By Frank Soule
Despise not labor! God did not despise
The handicraft which wrought this gorgeous globe,
That crowned its glories with yon jeweled skies,
And clad the earth in nature’s queenly robe.
He dug the first canal—the river’s bed,
Built the first fountain in the gushing spring,
Wove the first carpet for man’s haughty tread,
The warp and woof of his first covering.
He made the pictures painters imitate,
The statuary’s first grand model made,
Taught human intellect to re-create,
And human ingenuity its trade.
Ere great Daguerre had harnessed up the sun,
Apprenticeship at his new art to serve,
A greater artist greater things had done,
The wondrous pictures of the optic nerve.
There is no deed of honest labor born
That is not Godlike; in the toiling limbs
Howe’er the lazy scoff, the brainless scorn,
God labored first; toil likens us to Him.
Ashamed of work! mechanic, with thy tools,
The tree thy ax cut from its native sod,
And turns to useful things—go tell to fools,
Was fashioned in the factory of God.
Go build your ships, go build your lofty dome,
Your granite temple, that through time endures,
Your humble cot, or that proud pile of Rome,
His arm has toiled there in advance of yours.
He made the flowers your learned florists scan,
And crystallized the atoms of each gem,
Ennobled labor in great nature’s plan,
And made it virtue’s brightest diadem.
Whatever thing is worthy to be had,
Is worthy of the toil by which ’tis won,
Just as the grain by which the field is clad
Pays back the warming labor of the sun.
’Tis not profession that ennobles men,
’Tis not the calling that can e’er degrade,
The trowel is as worthy as the pen,
The pen more mighty than the hero’s blade.
The merchant, with his ledger and his wares,
The lawyer with his cases and his books,
The toiling farmer, with his wheat and tares,
The poet by the shaded streams and nooks,
The man, whate’er his work, wherever done,
If intellect and honor guide his hand,
Is peer to him who greatest state has won,
And rich as any Rothschild of the land.
All mere distinctions based upon pretense,
Are merely laughing themes for manly hearts.
The miner’s cradle claims from men of sense
More honor than the youngling Bonaparte’s.
Let fops and fools the sons of toil deride,
On false pretensions brainless dunces live;
Let carpet heroes strut with parlor pride,
Supreme in all that indolence can give,
But be not like them, and pray envy not
These fancy tom-tit burlesques of mankind,
The witless snobs in idleness who rot,
Hermaphrodite ’twixt vanity and mind.
O son of toil, be proud, look up, arise,
And disregard opinion’s hollow test,
A false society’s decrees despise,
He is most worthy who has labored best.
The scepter is less royal than the hoe,
The sword, beneath whose rule whole nations writhe,
And curse the wearer, while they fear the blow,
Is far less noble than the plow and scythe.
There’s more true honor on one tan-browned hand,
Rough with the honest work of busy men,
Than all the soft-skinned punies of the land,
The nice, white-kiddery of upper ten.
Blow bright the forge—the sturdy anvil ring,
It sings the anthem of king Labor’s courts,
And sweeter sounds the clattering hammers bring,
Than half a thousand thumped piano-fortes.
Fair are the ribbons from the rabbet-plane,
As those which grace my lady’s hat or cape,
Nor does the joiner’s honor blush or wane
Beside the lawyer, with his brief and tape.
Pride thee, mechanic, on thine honest trade,
’Tis nobler than the snob’s much vaunted pelf.
Man’s soulless pride his test of worth has made,
But thine is based on that of God himself.