Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Original PDF Methods For Effective Teaching Meeting The Needs of All Students 8th Edition PDF
Original PDF Methods For Effective Teaching Meeting The Needs of All Students 8th Edition PDF
Original PDF Methods For Effective Teaching Meeting The Needs of All Students 8th Edition PDF
STRATEGIES THAT PROMOTE STUDENT HELPING STUDENTS BECOME BETTER THINKERS 185
UNDERSTANDING 172 Guidance from Teaching Standards 187
Identifying Similarities and Differences 172 Enhancing Critical Thinking 187
Summarizing and Note Taking 173
ENGAGING STUDENTS IN THE LEARNING
Reinforcing Effort and Providing Recognition 175
PROCESS 189
Homework and Practice 177
Nonlinguistic Representations 179 MOTIVATING STUDENTS TO LEARN 191
Setting Objectives and Providing Feedback 180
Generating and Testing Hypotheses 183 APPLYING THE SIOP MODEL TO STRATEGIES 193
Cues, Questions, and Advance Organizers 184 Strategies 193
Practice/Application 194
WORKING WITH COLLEAGUES 338 Why Some Families Resist Involvement 346
What is collaboration? 338 Working Through Cultural and Language
Why collaborate? 338 Differences 347
Collaborate with Whom? 339 CONTACTING AND COMMUNICATING WITH
Collaboration Skills and Dispositions 342 FAMILIES 348
WORKING WITH FAMILIES 344 Ways to Communicate with Families 349
Reasons for Working with Families 345 Parent-Teacher Conferences 358
REFERENCES 365
NAME INDEX 379
SUBJECT INDEX 383
Intended Audience
This book is designed primarily as the core textbook for courses in K–12 general teaching
methods, secondary/middle teaching methods, or elementary school teaching methods.
The content is applicable for teachers at all levels—elementary, middle level, and high
school. Additionally, it may be used as a supplementary book for other teaching methods
courses. This book is also appropriate for courses and staff development programs for in-
service teachers and as a handbook for teacher reference due to its comprehensive cover-
age of current classroom issues and practical teaching applications.
xi
Special Features
To maintain the reader’s interest and to accommodate different learning styles and instruc-
tional settings, Methods for Effective Teaching contains a variety of pedagogical features.
■■ Standards Tables. Two tables of professional standards can be found on pages xvi–xvii.
These tables feature references to the chapters in this book that address each part of the
standards.
■■ Objectives. Each chapter begins with a list of objectives that identify expected reader
outcomes.
■■ Chapter Outline. Each chapter begins with a graphic organizer displaying chapter
headings and subheadings to provide an advance organizer for the reader.
■■ Voices from the Classroom. These features are included in each chapter to provide
descriptions of ways that actual elementary, middle school, and high school teach-
ers deal with particular topics addressed in the chapter. These teachers come from all
parts of the country and different community sizes. There are over 50 Voices from the
Classroom features, evenly balanced among elementary and middle/high school levels,
including many from urban districts.
■■ Sample Standards. Each chapter has a Sample Standards feature that lists representa-
tive performances, essential knowledge, and critical dispositions from InTASC standards
that relate to the chapter in an effort to direct the reader’s attention to important con-
tent and characteristics.
■■ Classroom Case Studies. Each chapter includes a case study describing a situation
that a teacher may need to confront. Two or three questions following each case study
require the reader to reflect on and apply chapter concepts.
■■ What Would You Decide? Several features are placed in each chapter to help readers
consider the application of the content. Each feature includes several sentences describ-
ing a classroom situation related to an issue in the chapter followed by a few questions
asking the reader to make decisions about the application of the concepts.
■■ Key Terms. A list of key terms at the end of each chapter draws the reader’s attention to
significant terms. Each term is also highlighted in the text.
■■ Major Concepts. At the end of each chapter, a list of major concepts serves as a sum-
mary of the significant chapter ideas.
INTASC STANDARDS
The Interstate New Teacher Assessment and Support Consortium (INTASC) was formed
as a consortium of state education agencies and national educational organizations dedi-
cated to the reform of the preparation, licensing, and ongoing professional development
of teachers. Created in 1987, INTASC’s primary constituency is state education agencies
responsible for teacher licensing, program approval, and professional development. Its
work is guided by one basic premise: An effective teacher must be able to integrate content
knowledge with the specific strengths and needs of students to ensure that all students learn
and perform at high levels. With the 2011 updating of the standards, it removed the word
new from its title and made a lowercase n in the acronym (now it is InTASC). More infor-
mation can be found on the Council of Chief State School Officers, CCSSO, website.
PRAXIS TESTS
The Praxis tests have been developed and disseminated by the Educational Testing Ser-
vice (ETS) for assessing skills and knowledge at each stage of a beginning teacher’s career,
from entry into teacher education to actual classroom performance. More information
about the Praxis tests can be found at the Educational Testing Service, ETS, website.
There are several types of Praxis tests:
■■ Praxis Core Academic Skills for Educators (CORE). These academic skills tests
are designed to be taken early in a student’s college career to measure reading, writ-
ing, and mathematics skills.
■■ Praxis Subject Assessments. There are several Praxis Subject Assessments, and
they measure a teacher candidate’s knowledge of the subjects he or she will teach, as
well as general and subject-specific pedagogical skills and knowledge. One of these
assessments is the Principles of Learning and Teaching (PLT) test, which many states
require teachers to pass for their licensure.
Methods for Effective Teaching is not intended to address the preprofessional skills of
reading, writing, and mathematics in Praxis CORE. However, it is designed to address the
Praxis Subject Assessments test on Principles of Learning and Teaching and the Praxis class-
room performance criteria areas, based on Danielson’s Framework for Teaching.
Supplements
INSTRUCTOR’S RESOURCE MANUAL WITH TEST BANK AND
POWERPOINT SLIDES
An instructor’s resource manual with test bank to accompany this textbook has been devel-
oped by the authors to guide teacher educators as they use this book for their courses. This
manual includes multiple-choice, true–false, short-answer, and essay/discussion questions for
each chapter. It also includes a sample course syllabus that is aligned to this book and teach-
ing suggestions to introduce content for each major section of each chapter. Additionally,
about 20 PowerPoint slides are provided for each chapter.
The instructor’s resource manual with test bank may be downloaded in PDF from the
Instructor Resource Center at the Pearson Higher Education website (http://www.pearson-
highered.com). Your local Pearson sales representative can help you set up a password for
the Instructor Resource Center.
Acknowledgments
Many people provided support and guidance as we prepared this book. A very special
acknowledgment goes to our spouses: Jennie Burden and Mary Byrd. Their support kept
our spirits up when deadlines were pressing, and their understanding during our ab-
sences while preparing the content enabled us to complete the project.
We also appreciate the help from the staff at Pearson who provided editorial guid-
ance, facilitated the preparation of the manuscript, and coordinated the production.
A number of classroom teachers provided descriptions of their professional practice,
which are included in the Voices from the Classroom features. Their experiences help il-
lustrate the issues and bring life to the content.
Finally, we would like to extend our gratitude to the following reviewers who provided
constructive feedback for this edition: Dr. Sonia K. Boone, Prairie View A&M University;
Joseph Cosgriff, Lincoln Memorial University; Bonnie J. Cummings, College of Education,
The University of Memphis; R. Stewart Mayers, Ed.D., Southeastern Oklahoma State
University; Kirk A. Swortzel, Mississippi State University.
Paul R. Burden
David M. Byrd
The following table indicates how the 2011 Interstate Teacher Assessment and Support Consortium (InTASC) model
core teaching standards are addressed in this book.
CONTENT KNOWLEDGE
4. Content Knowledge 3
Understands the central concepts, tools of inquiry, and structures of the discipline(s)
he or she teaches and creates learning experiences that make these aspects of the
discipline accessible and meaningful for learners to ensure mastery of the content.
INSTRUCTIONAL PRACTICE
6. Assessment 2, 11–12
Understands and uses multiple methods of assessment to engage learners in their
own growth, to monitor learner progress, and to guide the teacher’s and learner’s
decision making.
PROFESSIONAL RESPONSIBILITY
From Council of Chief State School Officers. (2011, April). Interstate Teacher Assessment and Support Consortium (InTASC) Model Core
Teaching Standards: A Resource for State Dialogue. Washington, DC: Author.
THE TEACHER AS A
REFLECTIVE DECISION
MAKER
Reflection
1.1 Describe the basic teaching functions and the MORE ENGLISH LANGUAGE
key characteristics of effective teachers. LEARNERS
1.2 Recognize the professional teaching standards Challenges of English Language Learners
and understand the purposes they serve. Teaching English Language Learners in All
1.3 Formulate a plan to use reflection to enhance Classrooms
teacher decision making. The SIOP Model
Even before instruction takes place, teachers think about and make decisions concern-
ing content, instructional strategies, the use of instructional materials and technology,
delivery techniques, classroom management and discipline, assessment of student
learning, and a host of other related issues. During instruction, teachers must imple-
ment these decisions as they interact with students in a dynamic way.
Decision making involves giving consideration to a matter, identifying the desired end
result, determining the options to get to the end result, and then selecting the most
suitable option to achieve the desired purpose. Teacher decisions about the issues just
mentioned ultimately will influence student learning.
To examine teacher decision making and its relationship to teaching methods, the dis-
cussion in this chapter centers on several questions: What is effective teaching? What
are the standards used to guide the professional development of teachers? How can
a teacher be a reflective decision maker? What are the conditions that are changing
the teaching environment? How can instruction of English language learners (ELLs) be
enhanced in all classrooms?
Effective Teaching
What are teachers’ responsibilities, and what makes teachers effective in meeting these
responsibilities? To answer these questions, it is useful to examine the basic teaching func-
tions, essential teacher characteristics, and expectations for effectiveness.
Planning. Planning involves teacher decisions about student needs, the most appropri-
ate goals and objectives, the content to be taught, instructional strategies, lesson delivery
techniques, instructional media, classroom climate, and student assessment. These deci-
sions are made before actual instruction takes place. The goal of planning is to ensure
student learning. Planning occurs when teachers are alone and have time to reflect and
consider issues such as short-range and long-range plans, student progress, time available,
and instructional materials. Planning helps arrange the appropriate flow and sequence of
instructional content and events.Planning is considered in more detail in Chapters 3 and 4.
Assessing. Assessing involves determining the level of student learning. Actually, many
aspects of assessment are determined during the planning phase when instructional goals
and content are identified. The means to measure student learning include paper-and-
pencil tests, portfolios, work samples, projects, reports, journals, models, presentations,
demonstrations, and various other types of product and performance assessments. Once
assessment data has been gathered, the information is recorded and judgments are made.
Assessment is considered in more detail in Chapters 11 and 12.
Teacher decisions about planning, implementing, and assessing matter a great
deal. As attempts are made to improve schools and increase student achievement, one
constant has remained: Teachers are the most important factor in improving schools.
Attempts to reform or improve education depend on the knowledge, skills, and commit-
ment of teachers. This point is made emphatically in A Good Teacher in Every Classroom:
Preparing the Highly Qualified Teachers Our Children Deserve (Darling-Hammond and
Baratz-Snowden, 2007). Teachers need to know how to implement new practices con-
cerning the basic teaching functions, but they must also take ownership or the innova-
tion will not succeed.
Knowledge. Effective teachers must know the facts about the content they are teaching.
That is vital, but it is not sufficient. Teachers also must have at least three other types of
knowledge.
First, they must have professional knowledge related to teaching in general. This
includes information about the historical, economic, sociological, philosophical, and psy-
chological understanding of schooling and education. It also includes knowledge about
learning, diversity, technology, professional ethics, legal and policy issues, pedagogy, and
the roles and responsibilities of the profession of teaching.
Second, teachers must have pedagogical knowledge, which includes the general con-
cepts, theories, and research about effective teaching, regardless of the content area. Thus,
it involves general teaching methods.
Finally, teachers must have pedagogical content knowledge. This involves teaching
methods that are unique to a particular subject or the application of certain strategies in
a manner particular to a subject. For example, there may be some unique ways to teach
map reading skills in a social studies class. You must have a thorough understanding of
the content to teach it in multiple ways, drawing on the cultural backgrounds and prior
knowledge and experiences of the students.
Thus, teachers must possess rich knowledge about the content, foundational infor-
mation about teaching and learning, information about teaching methods in general, and
information about teaching techniques unique to particular subjects.
1. How would it be evident in your lesson that you have the necessary knowledge,
skills, and dispositions to be an effective teacher? What would the students
observe in your teaching to identify these qualities?
2. What could you do during your teacher preparation program to acquire these
qualities?
Skills. Teachers also must possess the necessary skills to use their knowledge effectively
in the four areas just described to ensure that all students are learning. Teachers must be
able to apply these skills as they plan, implement, and assess in diverse teaching settings.
In listings of professional standards, the term performances is sometimes used instead of
the term skills.
Dispositions. Teachers also must have appropriate dispositions to promote learning for
all students. Dispositions include the necessary values, commitments, and professional
ethics that influence teacher behaviors. Dispositions are guided by beliefs and attitudes
related to values such as caring, fairness, honesty, responsibility, and social justice. Dis-
positions are affective, thus in the mind of teachers. But dispositions show up in teacher
behaviors. For example, a teacher might be willing to use a variety of instructional strate-
gies to promote learning for all students. This disposition could be evidenced by written
plans indicating the use of cooperative learning groups, demonstrations, and a role-playing
activity, and by the actual use of those approaches when instruction took place.
When making decisions, you must have the necessary knowledge, skills, and disposi-
tions to help promote learning for all students. Research has shown that teacher expertise
is one of the most important factors that influences student growth and achievement. There
is interest in the educational community to develop criteria for the knowledge, skills, and
dispositions that teachers need to promote student achievement.
As a prospective teacher, it is important that you identify these essential teacher char-
acteristics (knowledge, skills, dispositions) when you examine the main teaching func-
tions of planning, implementing, and assessing. As the teaching functions are discussed
in this book, several chapters have a boxed feature to indicate the knowledge, skills, and
dispositions related to the chapter topic using the descriptions in the InTASC standards.
For example, Chapter 3 on planning will include a box of information about representative
knowledge, skills, and dispositions related to planning.
Measures of Effectiveness. Various approaches have been used to indicate the qual-
ity of teaching and its influence on student learning. One approach has been to examine
student achievement test scores over a three-year time period in a so-called value-added
comparison. This value-added concept compares the performance of a student against
that same student’s performance at an earlier time. The difference in the two assessments
is taken as a measure of student learning growth, which can also be conceptualized as the
value added by the instructional effectiveness of the teacher. Students’ average annual rates
of improvement are then used to estimate how much value a teacher has contributed to
student achievement.
A second approach to determining the quality of teaching has involved the study of
teacher test scores and their relationship to the achievement of students in their classes. A
series of studies correlated teachers’ basic skills tests and college entrance exams with the
scores of their students on standardized tests. These studies have found that high-scoring
teachers are more likely to elicit significant gains in student achievement than their lower-
scoring counterparts (Card & Rothstein, 2007).
A third approach to determining the quality of teaching has involved the review of
teachers’ content knowledge. A teacher’s deep understanding of the content he/she teaches
has a positive influence on student achievement. This appears to be especially true for sci-
ence and mathematics teachers. In a review of research, Michael Allen, program director
for the Education Commission of the States (ECS) Teaching Quality Policy Center, found
support for the necessity of teachers being knowledgeable in their subjects and on how
best to teach a particular subject (Allen, 2003).
In addition, teaching experience appears to have an influence on student achievement.
Teachers with less teaching experience typically produce smaller learning gains in their
students compared with more seasoned teachers (Murnane & Steele, 2007). However, most
of those studies have also discovered that the benefits of experience level off after the first
five or so years of teaching.
Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA). While education is often considered a local and
state matter, the federal government in the past two decades has increased its involvement
in how teachers are prepared and certified and how education is conducted in school dis-
tricts. This effort was undertaken through the “highly qualified” teacher provisions of the
No Child Left Behind Act (NCLB, 2002). A new Every Student Succeeds Act (2015) rolled
back many, but not all, of the provisions for accountability embedded in NCLB.
The Every Student Succeeds Act is a federal law that required states to develop plans
that address standards, assessments, school and district accountability, and special help
for struggling schools. ESSA replaced the No Child Left Behind Act and represents a shift
from broad federal oversight of primary and secondary education to greater flexibility and
decision making at the state and local levels.
With ESSA, states are still required to give substantial weight to accountability plans
and academic indicators. With ESSA, states will:
1. Have greater flexibility in selection of goals for testing, English-language learner pro-
ficiency measures, and graduation rates.
2. Be required to include a minimum of one indicator of school quality or student success.
Examples include measures of student engagement; educator engagement; access to
completion of advanced coursework; postsecondary readiness; and school climate/safety.
3. Have to identify and intervene in the bottom 5 percent of low-performing schools and
high schools with graduation rates at or below 67 percent.
4. Still have to test students in reading and mathematics in grades 3-8 and once at the
high school level and report data on subgroups of students (e.g., English learners,
students receiving special education services, racial minorities, and those in poverty).
In 2017, further changes to the federal accountability systems were passed by Congress. For
example, states will no longer be required to label all schools with a summative uniform
s a m p l e STANDARDS
DECISION MAKING AND R EFL ECTION
There are 10 InTASC standards (see pages xvi–xvii), and ESSENTIAL KNOWLEDGE
each standard in the original document includes a list
■■ The teacher understands and knows how to use a vari-
of performances, essential knowledge, and critical dis-
ety of self-assessment and problem-solving strategies
positions to indicate more clearly what is intended in the
to analyze and reflect on his/her practice and to plan
standard.
for adaptations/adjustments.
Because this chapter deals with decision making and
reflection, some representative statements from InTASC ■■ The teacher knows how to build and implement a plan
Standard #9, Professional Learning and Ethical Practice, are for professional growth directly aligned with his/her
listed here concerning topics in this chapter. needs as a growing professional using feedback from
teacher evaluations and observations, data on learner
performance, and school and system-wide priorities.
PERFORMANCES
■■ The teacher engages in ongoing learning oppor-
tunities to develop knowledge and skills in order to CRITICAL DISPOSITIONS
provide all learners with engaging curriculum and ■■ The teacher sees him-/herself as a learner, continuously
learning experiences based on local and state seeking opportunities to draw upon current education
standards. policy and research as sources of analysis and reflec-
■■ The teacher engages in meaningful and appropriate tion to improve practice.
professional learning experiences aligned with his/her ■■ The teacher understands the expectations of the pro-
own needs and the needs of the learners, school, and fession, including codes of ethics, professional stan-
system. dards of practice, and relevant law and policy.
Council of Chief State School Officers. (2011, April). Interstate Teacher Assessment and Support Consortium (InTASC) Model Core Teach-
ing Standards: A Resource for State Dialogue. Washington, DC: Author.
rating system (high to low performing). In addition, the U.S. Department of Education
updated the application that states submit as part of gaining federal approval for state
accountability plans. The major changes focused on fewer requirements, including the
elimination of the requirement that states must reach out to groups of educators and advo-
cates in the development of an accountability plan. These changes are consistent with the
recent accountability shift away from the federal government and to the states.
“‘Ha, ha, ha! Tam Beattie,’ added she, ‘where is a’ your courage
now? Cannot ye lift up your voice and sing a stave wi’ your auld
crony? And cannot ye lift up your een, and see what region you are in
now?’
“I did force open my eyelids, and beheld light, and apparently
worlds, or huge lurid substances, gliding by me with speed beyond
that of the lightning of heaven. I certainly perceived light, though of a
dim, uncertain nature; but so precipitate was my descent, I could not
distinguish from whence it proceeded, or of what it consisted,
whether of the vapours of chaotic wastes, or the streamers of hell. So
I again shut my eyes closer than ever, and waited the event in terror
unutterable.
“We at length came upon something which interrupted our farther
progress. I had no feeling as we fell against it, but merely as if we
came in contact with some soft substance that impeded our descent;
and immediately afterwards I perceived that our motion had ceased.
“‘What a terrible tumble we hae gotten, Laird!’ said my
companion. ‘But ye are now in the place where you should be; and
deil speed the coward!’
“So saying, she quitted my hand, and I felt as if she were wrested
from me by a third object; but still I durst not open my eyes, being
convinced that I was lying in the depths of hell, or some hideous
place not to be dreamt of; so I lay still in despair, not even daring to
address a prayer to my Maker. At length I lifted my eyes slowly and
fearfully; but they had no power of distinguishing objects. All that I
perceived was a vision of something in nature, with which I had in
life been too well acquainted. It was a glimpse of green glens, long
withdrawing ridges, and one high hill, with a cairn on its summit. I
rubbed my eyes to divest them of the enchantment, but when I
opened them again, the illusion was still brighter and more
magnificent. Then springing to my feet, I perceived that I was lying
in a little fairy ring, not one hundred yards from the door of my own
hall!
“I was, as you may well conceive, dazzled with admiration; still I
felt that something was not right with me, and that I was struggling
with an enchantment; but recollecting the hideous story told me by
the beldame, of the deadly discord between my two sons, I hasted to
watch their motions, for the morning was yet but dawning. In a few
seconds after recovering my senses, I perceived my eldest son
Thomas leave his tower armed, and pass on towards the place of
appointment. I waylaid him, and remarked to him that he was very
early astir, and I feared on no good intent. He made no answer, but
stood like one in a stupor, and gazed at me. ‘I know your purpose,
son Thomas,’ said I; ‘so it is in vain for you to equivocate. You have
challenged your brother, and are going to meet him in deadly
combat; but as you value your father’s blessing, and would deprecate
his curse—as you value your hope of heaven, and would escape the
punishment of hell—abandon the hideous and cursed intent, and be
reconciled to your only brother.’
“On this, my dutiful son Thomas kneeled to me, and presented his
sword, disclaiming at the same time all intentions of taking away his
brother’s life, and all animosity for the vengeance sought against
himself, and thanked me in a flood of tears for my interference. I
then commanded him back to his couch, and taking his cloak and
sword, hasted away to the Crook of Glendearg, to wait the arrival of
his brother.”
Here Andrew Johnston’s narrative detailed the selfsame
circumstances recorded in a former part of this tale, as having passed
between the father and his younger son, so that it is needless to
recapitulate them; but beginning where that broke off, he added, in
the words of the old laird: “As soon as my son Francis had left me, in
order to be reconciled to his brother, I returned to the fairy knowe
and ring, where I first found myself seated at daybreak. I know not
why I went there, for though I considered with myself, I could
discover no motive that I had for doing so, but was led thither by a
sort of impulse which I could not resist, and from the same feeling
spread my son’s mantle on the spot, laid his sword beside it, and
stretched me down to sleep. I remember nothing farther with any
degree of accuracy, for I instantly fell into a chaos of suffering,
confusion, and racking dismay, from which I was only of late
released by awaking from a trance on the very seat, and in the same
guise in which I was the evening before. I am certain I was at home
in body or in spirit—saw my sons—spake these words to them, and
heard theirs in return. How I returned I know even less, if that is
possible, than how I went; for it seemed to me that the mysterious
force that presses us to this sphere, and supports us on it, was in my
case withdrawn or subverted, and that I merely fell from one part of
the earth’s surface and alighted on another. Now I am so ill that I
cannot move from this couch; therefore, Andrew, do you mount and
ride straight home. Spare no horseflesh, by night or by day, to bring
me word of my family, for I dread that some evil hath befallen them.
If you find them in life, give them many charges from me of brotherly
love and affection; if not—what can I say, but, in the words of the
patriarch, if I am bereaved of my children, I am bereaved.”
The two brothers, in utter amazement, went together to the green
ring on the top of the knoll above the castle of Cassway, and there
found the mantle lying spread, and the sword beside it. They then,
without letting Johnston into the awful secret, mounted straight, and
rode off with him to their father. They found him still in bed, and
very ill; and though rejoiced at seeing them, they soon lost hope of
his recovery, his spirits being broken and deranged in a wonderful
manner. Their conversations together were of the most solemn
nature, the visitation deigned to them having been above their
capacity. On the third or fourth day, their father was removed by
death from this terrestrial scene, and the minds of the young men
were so much impressed by the whole of the circumstances, that it
made a great alteration in their after life. Thomas, as solemnly
charged by his father, married Ellen Scott, and Francis was well
known afterwards as the celebrated Dr Beattie of Amherst. Ellen was
mother to twelve sons; and on the night that her seventh son was
born, her aunt Jerdan was lost, and never more heard of, either
living or dead.[9]
9. This will be viewed as a most romantic and unnatural story, as without
doubt it is; but I have the strongest reasons for believing that it is founded on a
literal fact, of which all the three were sensibly and positively convinced. It was
published in England in Dr Beattie’s lifetime, and by his acquiescence, and owing
to the respectable source from whence it came, it was never disputed in that day
that it had its origin in truth. It was again republished, with some miserable
alterations, in a London collection of 1770, by J. Smith, at No. 15, Paternoster Row,
and though I have seen none of these accounts, but relate the story wholly from
tradition, yet the assurance obtained from a friend of their existence, is a curious
corroborative circumstance, and proves that if the story was not true, the parties at
least believed it to be so.—Note by the Author.
THE ELDER’S FUNERAL.
By Professor Wilson.
How beautiful to the eye and to the heart rise up, in a pastoral
region, the green silent hills from the dissolving snow-wreaths that
yet linger at their feet! A few warm sunny days, and a few breezy and
melting nights, have seemed to create the sweet season of spring out
of the winter’s bleakest desolation. We can scarcely believe that such
brightness of verdure could have been shrouded in the snow,
blending itself, as it now does, so vividly with the deep blue of
heaven. With the revival of nature our own souls feel restored.
Happiness becomes milder, meeker, and richer in pensive thought;
while sorrow catches a faint tinge of joy, and reposes itself on the
quietness of earth’s opening breast. Then is youth rejoicing—
manhood sedate—and old age resigned. The child shakes his golden
curls in his glee; he of riper life hails the coming year with temperate
exultation; and the eye that has been touched with dimness, in the
general spirit of delight, forgets or fears not the shadows of the grave.
On such a vernal day as this did we, who had visited the Elder on
his death-bed,[10] walk together to his house in the Hazel Glen, to
accompany his body to the place of burial. On the night he died, it
seemed to be the dead of winter. On the day he was buried, it seemed
to be the birth of spring. The old pastor and I were alone for awhile
as we pursued our path up the glen, by the banks of the little burn. It
had cleared itself off from the melted snow, and ran so pellucid a
race that every stone and pebble was visible in its yellow channel.
The willows, the alders, and the birches, the fairest and the earliest of
our native hill-trees, seemed almost tinged with a verdant light, as if
they were budding; and beneath them, here and there peeped out, as
in the pleasure of new existence, the primrose lonely, or in little
families and flocks. The bee had not yet ventured to leave his cell, yet
the flowers reminded one of his murmur. A few insects were dancing
in the air, and here and there some little moorland bird, touched at
the heart with the warm and sunny change, was piping his love-sweet
song among the braes. It was just such a day as a grave meditative
man, like him we were about to inter, would have chosen to walk
over his farm in religious contentment with his lot. That was the
thought that entered the pastor’s heart, as we paused to enjoy one
brighter gleam of the sun in a little meadow-field of peculiar beauty.
10. See ante, page 280.
“This is the last day of the week, and on that day often did the
Elder walk through this little happy kingdom of his own, with some
of his grandchildren beside and around him, and often his Bible in
his hand. It is, you feel, a solitary place,—all the vale is one seclusion
—and often have its quiet bounds been a place of undisturbed
meditation and prayer.”
We now came in sight of the cottage, and beyond it the
termination of the glen. There the high hills came sloping gently
down; and a little waterfall, in the distance, gave animation to a
scene of perfect repose. We were now joined by various small parties
coming to the funeral through openings among the hills; all sedate,
but none sad, and every greeting was that of kindness and peace. The
Elder had died full of years; and there was no need why any out of his
household should weep. A long life of piety had been beautifully
closed; and, therefore, we were all going to commit the body to the
earth, assured, as far as human beings may be so assured, that the
soul was in heaven. As the party increased on our approach to the
house, there was even cheerfulness among us. We spoke of the early
and bright promise of spring—of the sorrows and joys of other
families—of marriages and births—of the new schoolmaster—of to-
morrow’s Sabbath. There was no topic of which, on any common
occasion, it might have been fitting to speak, that did not now
perhaps occupy, for a few moments, some one or other of the group,
till we found ourselves ascending the greensward before the cottage,
and stood below the bare branches of the sycamores. Then we were
all silent, and, after a short pause, reverently entered into the house
of death.
At the door the son received us with a calm, humble, and
untroubled face; and in his manner towards the old minister, there
was something that could not be misunderstood, expressing
penitence, gratitude, and resignation. We all sat down in the large
kitchen; and the son decently received each person at the door, and
showed him to his place. There were some old gray heads, more
becoming gray, and many bright in manhood and youth. But the
same solemn hush was over them all, and they sat all bound together
in one uniting and assimilating spirit of devotion and faith. Wine and
bread were to be sent round; but the son looked to the old minister,
who rose, lifted up his withered hand, and began a blessing and a
prayer.
There was so much composure and stillness in the old man’s
attitude, and something so affecting in his voice, tremulous and
broken, not in grief but age, that no sooner had he begun to pray,
than every heart and every breath at once were hushed. All stood
motionless, nor could one eye abstain from that placid and
patriarchal countenance, with its closed eyes, and long silvery hair.
There was nothing sad in his words, but they were all humble and
solemn, and at times even joyful in the kindling spirit of piety and
faith. He spoke of the dead man’s goodness as imperfect in the eyes
of his Great Judge, but such as, we were taught, might lead, through
intercession, to the kingdom of heaven. Might the blessing of God, he
prayed, which had so long rested on the head now coffined, not
forsake that of him who was now to be the father of this house. There
was more—more joy, we were told, in heaven, over one sinner that
repenteth, than over ninety and nine just persons which need no
repentance. Fervently, too, and tenderly, did the old man pray for
her, in her silent chamber, who had lost so kind a parent, and for all
the little children round her knees. Nor did he end his prayer without
some allusion to his own gray hairs, and to the approaching day on
which many then present would attend his burial.
Just as he ceased to speak, one solitary stifled sob was heard, and
all eyes turned kindly round to a little boy who was standing by the
side of the Elder’s son. Restored once more to his own father’s love,
his heart had been insensibly filled with peace since the old man’s
death. The returning tenderness of the living came in place of that of
the dead, and the child yearned towards his father now with a
stronger affection, relieved at last from all his fear. He had been
suffered to sit an hour each day beside the bed on which his
grandfather lay shrouded, and he had got reconciled to the cold but
silent and happy looks of death. His mother and his Bible told him to
obey God without repining in all things; and the child did so with
perfect simplicity. One sob had found its way at the close of that
pathetic prayer; but the tears that bathed his glistening cheeks were
far different from those that, on the day and night of his
grandfather’s decease, had burst from the agony of a breaking heart.
The old minister laid his hand silently upon his golden head; there
was a momentary murmur of kindness and pity over the room; the
child was pacified, and again all was repose and peace.
A sober voice said all was ready, and the son and the minister led
the way reverently out into the open air. The bier stood before the
door, and was lifted slowly up with its sable pall. Silently each
mourner took his place. The sun was shining pleasantly, and a gentle
breeze, passing through the sycamore, shook down the glittering
raindrops upon the funeral velvet. The small procession, with an
instinctive spirit, began to move along; and as I cast up my eyes to
take a farewell look of that beautiful dwelling, now finally left by him
who so long had blessed it, I saw at the half-open lattice of the little
bedroom window above, the pale weeping face of that stainless
matron, who was taking her last passionate farewell of the mortal
remains of her father, now slowly receding from her to the quiet field
of graves.
We proceeded along the edges of the hills, and along the meadow-
fields, crossed the old wooden bridge over the burn, now widening in
its course to the plain, and in an hour of pensive silence, or pleasant
talk, we found ourselves entering, in a closer body, the little gateway
of the churchyard. To the tolling of the bell we moved across the
green mounds, and arranged ourselves, according to the plan and
order which our feelings suggested, around the bier and its natural
supporters. There was no delay. In a few minutes the Elder was laid
among the mould of his forefathers, in their long-ago chosen spot of
rest. One by one the people dropped away, and none were left by the
new made grave but the son and his little boy, the pastor and myself.
As yet nothing was said, and in that pause I looked around me, over
the sweet burial-ground.
Each tombstone and grave over which I had often walked in
boyhood arose in my memory, as I looked steadfastly upon their
long-forgotten inscriptions; and many had then been erected. The
whole character of the place was still simple and unostentatious, but
from the abodes of the dead I could see that there had been an
improvement in the condition of the living. There was a taste visible
in their decorations, not without much of native feeling, and
occasionally something even of native grace. If there was any other
inscription than the name and age of the poor inhabitants below, it
was, in general, some short text of Scripture; for it is most pleasant
and soothing to the pious mind, when bereaved of friends, to
commemorate them on earth by some touching expression taken
from that Book which reveals to them a life in heaven.
There is a sort of gradation, a scale of forgetfulness, in a country
churchyard, where the processes of nature are suffered to go on over
the green place of burial, that is extremely affecting in the
contemplation. The soul goes from the grave just covered up, to that
which seems scarcely joined together, on and on to those folded and
bound by the undisturbed verdure of many, many unremembered
years. It then glides at last into nooks and corners where the ground
seems perfectly calm and waveless, utter oblivion having smoothed
the earth over the long mouldered bones. Tombstones, on which the
inscriptions are hidden in green obliteration, or that are mouldering,
or falling to a side, are close to others which last week were brushed
by the chisel;—constant renovation and constant decay—vain
attempts to adhere to memory—and oblivion, now baffled and now
triumphant, smiling among all the memorials of human affection, as
they keep continually crumbling away into the world of
undistinguishable dust and ashes.
The churchyard, to the inhabitants of a rural parish, is the place to
which, as they grow older, all their thoughts and feelings turn. The
young take a look of it every Sabbath-day, not always perhaps a
careless look, but carry away from it, unconsciously, many salutary
impressions. What is more pleasant than the meeting of a rural
congregation in the churchyard before the minister appears? What is
there to shudder at in lying down, sooner or later, in such a peaceful
and sacred place, to be spoken of frequently on Sabbath among the
groups of which we used to be one, and our low burial-spot to be
visited, at such times, as long as there remains on earth any one to
whom our face was dear? To those who mix in the strife and dangers
of the world, the place is felt to be uncertain wherein they may finally
lie at rest. The soldier—the sailor—the traveller—can only see some
dim grave dug for him when he dies, in some place obscure,
nameless, and unfixed to the imagination. All he feels is, that his
burial will be—on earth—or in the sea. But the peaceful dwellers who
cultivate their paternal acres, or tilling at least the same small spot of
soil, shift only from a cottage on the hillside to one on the plain, still
within the bounds of one quiet parish; they look to lay their bones at
last in the burial-place of the kirk in which they were baptised, and
with them it almost literally is but a step from the cradle to the grave.
Such were the thoughts that calmly followed each other in my
reverie, as I stood beside the Elder’s grave, and the trodden grass was
again lifting up its blades from the pressure of many feet, now all, but
a few, departed. What a simple burial had it been! Dust was
consigned to dust—no more. Bare, naked, simple, and austere is in
Scotland the service of the grave. It is left to the soul itself to
consecrate, by its passion, the mould over which tears, but no words,
are poured. Surely there is a beauty in this; for the heart is left unto
its own sorrow—according as it is a friend—a brother—a parent—or a
child, that is covered up from our eyes. Yet call not other rites,
however different from this, less beautiful or pathetic. For willingly
does the soul connect its grief with any consecrated ritual of the
dead. Sound or silence—music—hymns—psalms—sable garments, or
raiment white as snow—all become holy symbols of the soul’s
affection; nor is it for any man to say which is the most natural,
which is the best, of the thousand shows and expressions, and
testimonies of sorrow, resignation, and love, by which mortal beings
would seek to express their souls when one of their brethren has
returned to his parent dust.
My mind was recalled from all these sad, yet not unpleasant
fancies, by a deep groan, and I beheld the Elder’s son fling himself
down upon the grave and kiss it passionately, imploring pardon from
God. “I distressed my father’s heart in his old age—I repented—and
received thy forgiveness even on thy death-bed! But how may I be
assured that God will forgive me for having so sinned against my old,
grayheaded father, when his limbs were weak and his eyesight dim!”
The old minister stood at the head of the grave without speaking a
word, with his solemn and pitiful eyes fixed upon the prostrate and
contrite man. His sin had been great, and tears that till now had, on
this day at least, been compressed within his heart by the presence of
so many of his friends, now poured down upon the sod as if they
would have found their way to the very body of his father. Neither of
us offered to lift him up, for we felt awed by the rueful passion of his
love, his remorse, and his penitence; and nature, we felt, ought to
have her way. “Fear not, my son,” at length said the old man, in a
gentle voice—“fear not, my son, but that you are already forgiven.
Dost thou not feel pardon within thy contrite spirit?” He rose up
from his knees with a faint smile, while the minister, with his white
head yet uncovered, held his hands over him as in benediction; and
that beautiful and loving child, who had been standing in a fit of
weeping terror at his father’s agony, now came up to him and kissed
his cheek—holding in his little hand a few faded primroses which he
had unconsciously gathered together as they lay on the turf of his
grandfather’s grave.
MACDONALD, THE CATTLE-RIEVER.