Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Efficacy of Zinc Supplementation in The Management of Acute Diarrhoea
Efficacy of Zinc Supplementation in The Management of Acute Diarrhoea
To cite this article: Lakkana Rerksuppaphol & Sanguansak Rerksuppaphol (2019): Efficacy of zinc
supplementation in the management of acute diarrhoea: a randomised controlled trial, Paediatrics
and International Child Health, DOI: 10.1080/20469047.2019.1673548
Article views: 2
acute diarrhoea. The hypothesis was that zinc supple- indistinguishable in colour, taste and appearance. Each
mentation can hasten recovery. arm of the trial received the treatment according to the
registered protocol and the trial contributors were not
able to recognise the treatment or the placebo.
Subjects and methods Attending physicians were responsible for the manage-
Study setting ment of diarrhoea, the close observation of patients and
decisions to discharge, as per the study protocol.
From June 2018 to April 2019, a double-blind, rando-
mised, placebo-controlled trial was conducted in the
Paediatric Department of Srinakharinwirot University Data collection and outcome definition
Hospital, Nakorn Nayok. The study aimed to measure
the efficacy of zinc supplementation in children At enrolment, a detailed clinical assessment including the
admitted with acute diarrhoea. history and clinical examination was undertaken by the
attending physicians. Baseline demographic data includ-
ing age, gender, bodyweight and height were collected
Sample size and eligibility criteria and analysed. Weight was measured using an electronic
The sample size was calculated on the basis of scale to the nearest 0.1 kg. For children <2 years old,
a previous report which demonstrated that the mean length was measured in the recumbent position using
(SD) time to resolution of acute diarrhoea was 114.3 an infantometer, and in a standing position for children
(30.9) hours [11]. A sample size of 43 patients for each aged ≥2 to the nearest millimetre using a stadiometer.
group was determined to detect a 20% reduction in the Body mass index (BMI) was calculated as weight (kg)/
duration of diarrhoea with a sample power of 90% and height (m2). Children with a weight for height <-2 SD
95% confidence. (≤5 years) or BMI <-2 SD (>5 years) were defined as
Children aged ≥6 months admitted with acute diar- wasted and children with a length (height) for age <-2
rhoea were eligible to participate in the trial. Acute SD were defined as stunted [12]. Clinical dehydration was
diarrhoea was defined according to the following cri- determined according to WHO guidelines [13]. Fever was
teria: (i) patients who passed abnormal watery and/or defined as a body temperature of ≥37.8°C and the resolu-
mucous stool, (ii) more than three times within the tion of fever was defined as the first decrease of body
previous 24 hours, and (iii) for less than 2 weeks. The temperature to a normal level on two consecutive mea-
exclusion criteria were (i) patients with severe dehydra- surements with a 4-hour interval.
tion, (ii) evidence of systemic infection, (iii) chronic med-
ical conditions such as chronic liver or renal diseases,
immune deficiency or chronic gastrointestinal condi-
Laboratory procedures
tions, and (iv) who had received zinc or vitamin supple- A venous blood sample was collected using trace
mentation within the last 3 months. Eligible children element-free vacutainers for estimation of zinc levels.
were randomly allocated to receive either zinc or pla- Serum zinc was measured by flame atomic absorption
cebo. All randomisation procedures were performed spectrometry and levels <9.9 μmol/L were considered
using a computer programme (GraphPad QuickCalcs, to indicate zinc deficiency [14]. Haemoglobin, haema-
San Diego, CA, USA). Patients’ personal information tocrit, total and differential leucocyte counts and fae-
were entirely encrypted to randomisation sequence cal examination were performed on admission by the
codes. Patients’ families, research investigators, the sta- central laboratory. In addition, faecal examination for
tistician and the attending healthcare workers were rotavirus was undertaken by an immunochromatogra-
blinded to these codes. phy assay (Rota-strip, Coris Bioconcept, Belgium).
Stool culture was performed by a central laboratory
unit. At the end of the study, adverse events were
Intervention and procedures
estimated by interviewing children and/or parents
Enrolled children were randomised to receive either zinc with non-leading questions. Compliance was evalu-
bisglycinate (15 mg elemental zinc) or a placebo twice ated by total drug intake.
a day until discharge from hospital. The zinc bisglycinate The primary outcome of the study was the time to
and placebo were prepared in powder form in a single- recovery from diarrhoea; it was defined as the period
dose sachet (Qualimed, Bangkok, Thailand) and dis- between hospital enrolment until the passage of two
solved in water for administration. The manufacturing consecutive semi-formed stools or not passing stool
company which produced both the zinc and the pla- for 12 hours since the last defaecation. Secondary
cebo had no role in the study design, data analysis, outcomes were the number of abnormal watery or
interpretation of results or the publication process. The mucous stools, time of intravenous fluid administra-
powder form of zinc bisglycinate and the placebo were tion and length of hospital admission.
PAEDIATRICS AND INTERNATIONAL CHILD HEALTH 3
Table 2. Effect of zinc supplementation on clinical outcome Regardless of baseline serum zinc status, time to
in children with acute diarrhoea. remission of diarrhoea and to resolution of fever
Characteristic Zinc, n = 43 Placebo, n = 43 p-value exponentially declined in patients receiving zinc com-
Time to recovery from 44 (24–48) 52 (36–80) <0.01
diarrhoea, hrs
pared with children receiving a placebo. There was
Recovery by 3 days, n (%) 42 (97.7) 30 (69.8) <0.01 a significant reduction in the number of diarrhoeal
Recovery by 5 days, n (%) 43 (100) 40 (93.0) 0.24 episodes in the zinc group compared with the control
Recovery by 7 days, n (%) 43 (100) 42 (97.7) 1.00
No. of diarrhoeal stools per 5 (3–12) 7 (4–17) 0.02 group. In addition, the duration of hospitalisation and
admission of rehydration with intravenous fluids were markedly
Duration of intravenous fluid 40 (24–56) 56 (40–73) <0.01
therapy, hrs reduced in children receiving zinc compared with
Time to resolution of 12 (4–44) 20 (8–48) <0.01 those receiving a placebo. Zinc supplementation was
fever, hrs
Duration of hospital stay, hrs 60 (44–72) 84 (56–136) <0.01 safe and compliance was good.
Median (IQR) unless otherwise indicated; p-values in bold type are Recent research has demonstrated that zinc is an
statistically significant. essential factor in minimising the morbidity and mor-
tality associated with acute and chronic diarrhoeal
child in the zinc group had persistent signs of diarrhoea diseases [15]. Experimental research has found that
compared with three (7.0%) in the placebo group. The zinc can maintain the mucosal immune response to
median (IQR) number of stools during the trial was sig- enteric pathogens as well as the integrity of the
nificantly lower in the zinc group [5 (3–12)] than in the intestinal epithelium [16,17]. Additionally, animal stu-
placebo group [7 (4–17), p = 0.02]. The median duration dies have shown that zinc deficiency increases the
of intravenous fluid therapy and of hospitalisation was susceptibility to diarrhoea through several mechan-
considerably less in the zinc group than in the controls (p isms; it may induce alteration of the intestinal mor-
= 0.001 for both). Fever in the patients receiving zinc phology and mucosal integrity by decreasing the
resolved within a median of 12 hours and within a median villous height and crypt depth. In addition, zinc can
of 20 in the control group (p < 0.01). No patient experi- enhance lamina propria infiltration through stimula-
enced any serious adverse event during the trial. After tion of specific inflammatory cell reactions and loss of
24 hours of treatment, 38 (88.4%) patients in the zinc intestinal mucosal integrity [18].
group had no vomiting compared with 35 (81.4%) Results of trials on the efficacy of zinc for diarrhoea
patients in control group. The median duration of vomit- are contradictory [19–25]. In this study, zinc supple-
ing in the zinc and placebo groups was similar [0 (0–8) mentation significantly reduced stool frequency.
and 0 (0–24), respectively] and the median number of Consistent results were demonstrated in another trial
vomits [0 (0–2) and 0 (0–3), respectively]. There was good in which administration of zinc reduced the frequency
compliance with zinc and placebo in both groups. of diarrhoeal episodes (62% reduction with zinc vs
26% reduction with a placebo) and normalised the
stool consistency [19]. In another randomised trial in
Discussion Bangladeshi children aged 3–24 months, zinc supple-
This randomised trial demonstrated that zinc supple- mentation in a multivitamin syrup reduced diarrhoeal
mentation ameliorated acute diarrhoea in children. episodes by 38% (p < 0.05) and diarrhoea duration by
Figure 1. Cox regression plots for the survival function that predicts the probability of diarrhoeal recovery in the placebo and
the zinc groups.
PAEDIATRICS AND INTERNATIONAL CHILD HEALTH 5
44% (p < 0.05) compared with a multivitamin syrup As far as we know, this is the first randomised trial in
without zinc [20] and these findings are consistent Thailand examining the efficacy and tolerability of zinc in
with our trial. Furthermore, a small trial (n = 60) children with acute diarrhoea but it has several limita-
demonstrated that, compared with rehydration solu- tions. Firstly, the attending physicians were responsible
tion alone, zinc supplementation in conjunction with for interventions and discharge decisions; however, all
a rehydration solution lessened the cost by 5% and procedures were randomly and blindly performed and
the duration of diarrhoea by 17 hours [21]. A recent the remission of acute diarrhoea was recognised as
study in Pakistan also showed the benefits of zinc a primary treatment endpoint. Secondly, the trial did not
supplementation in reducing the number and dura- evaluate treatment outcomes by long-term follow-up.
tion of diarrhoeal episodes and improving stool con- Thirdly, the sample size was small which prevented any
sistency in children with acute diarrhoea treated in subgroup analysis or the proposal of any future standard
the outpatient department [22]. practices. For instance, the age range of the study subjects
On the other hand, other trials have shown no ben- was 6 months to 9.25 years which is different from most
efits of zinc supplementation for diarrhoea [23–25]. In an published reports which have studied children <5 years.
open-label trial in Turkish children with acute diarrhoea, Future studies should examine age-specific outcomes of
zinc had no effect on the duration and severity of diar- zinc supplementation for acute diarrhoea. Lastly,
rhoea and there was no significant effect on the inci- although the trial outcome was not influenced by the
dence and prevalence of diarrhoea [23]. In a controlled baseline zinc level, various factors might have affected
trial in patients aged 28 days to 5 months randomly the results such as dietary minerals, phytates and zinc
assigned to receive 10 mg zinc or a placebo, the mean dosage. Phytates are common in Thai food [28] and the
duration of diarrhoeal episodes was slightly longer in parents and guardians might have given the children
those receiving zinc compared with a placebo, but the many of these food ingredients. In addition, the zinc
effect was not statistically significant, and there were no dosage was approximately two-to-three times the recom-
reported differences between the zinc and placebo mended daily allowance prescribed for the treatment of
groups with regard to stool frequency, the proportion zinc-deficient conditions [29]. Therefore, future large-
of diarrhoeal attacks and vomiting rates [24]. In another scale, randomised studies with longer follow-up and
large-scale trial comparing zinc, placebo and zinc com- direct diet observation are recommended to thoroughly
bined with copper, no significant difference was re-investigate and assess the efficacy of zinc supplemen-
observed in any group in the duration and severity of tation in children with acute diarrhoea. Furthermore, sub-
diarrhoea [25]. group analysis of different variables such as age, gender,
In an effort to establish a rigorous effect size, various and zinc form and zinc dosage are required.
systematic reviews and meta-analyses have examined In conclusion, supplementation with 15 mg ele-
the impact of zinc in acute diarrhoea [9,26,27]. In a meta- mental zinc bisglycinate can reduce the time to reso-
analysis of 18 randomised trials including 7314 children lution of acute diarrhoea and lessen the length of
under 5 years of age, zinc was effective in reducing the hospital stay and the frequency of stools. Treatment
duration of diarrhoea [26]. However, the incidence of outcome was not affected by baseline zinc status.
vomiting was significantly higher in the zinc group than Zinc supplementation was safe and compliance was
in the controls. Furthermore, reduction in the duration good. These results need to be confirmed by large-
of diarrhoeal episodes was marked in malnourished scale trials with extended follow-up.
children. However, this quantitative meta-analysis was
limited by the considerable heterogeneity. Based on
Acknowledgments
a sensitivity analysis, the authors attributed this hetero-
geneity to the nutritional status of the patients. The We gratefully acknowledge the children, parents and
authors acknowledged that the evidence from this sub- healthcare workers for their various contributions to the
group analysis cannot be generalised since it comprised research.
a small number of studies and most of the trials did not
separate the subjects according to nutritional status Author contributions
[26]. A recent systematic review of 33 trials including
10,841 children aged 1 month to 5 years with acute or Both authors defined and developed the initial research
idea. Both were involved in designing and implementing
persistent diarrhoea found that there is insufficient evi-
the study, as well as analysis and interpretation of the
dence in well conducted randomised controlled trials to results and writing the manuscript. Both authors have read
confirm the efficacy of zinc supplementation for acute and approved the final manuscript.
diarrhoea in reducing mortality or hospitalisation.
However, zinc supplementation may be beneficial in
children aged ≥6 months living in areas endemic for Disclosure statement
zinc deficiency or where there is a high prevalence of No potential conflict of interest was reported by the
malnutrition [27]. authors.
6 L. RERKSUPPAPHOL AND S. RERKSUPPAPHOL