Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mariano Marcos State University: College of Teacher Education
Mariano Marcos State University: College of Teacher Education
MODULE 2
Constructive Alignment
19
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
INTRODUCTION
Learning Outcomes
Learning Outcomes
At the end of this unit, you should have:
1. obtained adequate understanding about the nature and importance of constructive
alignment;
2. explained the importance of aligning assessments to the other major components of
instruction;
3. acquired knowledge and skills about aligning assessment methods, strategies and
tools to curriculum standards; and
4. learned how to formulate objectives which explicitly measure the expected student
learning for specific topics.
20
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
PRE-TEST
Before you browse through the module, you are required to take the pre-test. You
are encouraged to take the test with utmost honesty so that your teacher will be able to
provide the appropriate help that you need.
Answer the pre-test found at the end of this module. Scan your answer sheet and
send the file in the Assignment section.
LESSONS
Alignment in Instruction
To start with, let's talk about instruction. Instruction is made up of four main
components, namely: learning objectives, teaching strategies, learning activities and
assessments. These are the components which need to be aligned.
So what does it mean for instruction to be aligned? Instruction is aligned when the
learning objectives are carried out with appropriate teaching strategies, learning activities
and assessments.
21
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Then we ask the first question: Do the objectives help the students attain the intended
learning outcome?
Next, we look at the teaching strategies and ask this second question “Are the
students taught how to do what’s stated in the learning objectives?”
Then we focus our attention to the learning activities and ask the third question “Do
the students have an opportunity to practice or acquire the outcome as stated in the
learning objective?
Lastly, we take a look at the assessments and ask, “Does the assessment activity
measure how well the students have mastered the learning outcome described in the
learning objective?”
If our answer to each of the four questions above is YES, then we can say that the
instruction is aligned.
If our answer to one or more of these questions is NO, then the instruction is
misaligned and, in that case, one or more of the four components must be changed or
improved to bring the instruction into alignment.
Let us review the essential questions that need to be answered when checking
alignment in instruction:
Teaching Strategies Are the students taught how to do what’s stated in the learning
objectives?”
Assessment Does the assessment activity measure how well the students have
mastered the learning outcome described in the learning
objective?
22
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
In the example given, take a moment to review the instruction for alignment. Try to
answer each of the questions above. What is your answer to each question? So, is the
instruction aligned? Why or why not?
The correct answer is: The given instruction is aligned. The intended learning
outcome for the subject is “Makapagsagawa ng sariling negosyong angkop sa kakayahan”
which can be achieved only after several teaching sessions or after attaining several learning
objectives which are associated with the learning outcome. The learning objectives give
opportunity for the students to gain knowledge and understanding about business (mga
produkto at serbisyong maaaring pagkakitaan) and these actually help the students attain
the said learning outcome. The teaching strategies which are lecture and use of module
introduce to the students the information stated in the learning objectives. The learning
23
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
activities for this instruction (panonood sa lektura, pagbabasa ng modyul at pagsagot sa mga
pagsasanay) give the students an opportunity to practice or acquire knowledge about
business, particularly products and services. Finally, the assessment measures how well the
students have mastered the knowledge gained through test and non-test methods.
Notice that each of the four components of instruction includes the same key
element: products and services. Also notice that based on the descriptions provided, we
can answer YES to each of the four questions mentioned earlier. This instruction is aligned.
Let us look at another example of instruction. This time, the instruction is misaligned.
Intended Learning Outcome: Use the different science process skills in the context of real
life
Review the instruction and think about why or how the instruction is misaligned.
Also think about what could be done to bring this instruction back into alignment.
Can you see why this instruction is misaligned? Even though each component refers
to science process skills, different skills are indicated in the last component of instruction
which is assessment. The learning objectives require the students to use their knowledge
and skill about the basic science processes but their assessment task requires them to use
another set of skills which are integrated science process skills which are not covered in the
subject matter.
To bring this instruction into alignment, we could ask the students to do this: Look
around and make three observations. List down your observations and the corresponding
senses that you used to observe these.
For more examples of aligned instruction, use Teaching and Assessment Ideas Tool
(TAIT) Gallery in this website: http://www.cityu.edu.hk/edge/obtl/elearn_tool/p8.html
24
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
TAIT is a quick and easy to use e-learning tool which supplies examples of some
possible constructively aligned components. You can see here concrete examples which
provide you with a useful starting point in doing constructive alignment in instruction. It is
designed to help you get started and provide you with ideas and examples of Action
Verbs, Teaching and Learning Activities, and Assessment Tasks.
This website is also intended to provide a basic introduction to the concepts of
Outcomes-Based Education and Constructive Alignment.
You can also watch the explanation of alignment in instruction in Youtube by
following the link provided below:
Designing Your Course to Achieve Alignment by Johns Hopkins University
https://youtu.be/npp6KnFgl48
This video discusses the need to align the key components of instruction: learning
objectives, teaching strategies, learning activities, and assessments. It explains what
instructional alignment is, provides examples, and explains why it is important.
25
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
2. Teaching and Learning Activities (TLA’s): These are a range of activities that are
designed to provide the students with the opportunity to achieve the stated
outcomes. These are simply any activity which stimulates, encourages or
facilitates learning of one or more intended learning outcomes. These include
teaching strategies.
3. Assessment Tasks (TA’s): Activities which can give feedback on the students’
attainment of the learning outcomes.
The diagram shows that the three stages of instruction are interrelated or consistent
which means they are aligned.
The term “constructive alignment” refers to ensuring that our teaching and learning
activities and assessment tasks are directly addressing the intended learning outcomes
chosen for a course or a programme. In other words, the three major components of
OBTL/OBE are clearly and explicitly linked. Choosing TLA’s and AT’s must be done carefully
to ensure that we are assessing the right intended learning outcomes
From the ILO, a teacher formulates appropriate specific and attainable objectives
which serve as bases in designing short-term lesson plans (such as daily or weekly lesson
plans) which help attain the ultimate target is which the ILO.
To know more about OBTL/OBE and Constructive Alignment, download and read
Handout 2.1. It contains information which were directly taken from the website of EDGE
Office of Education Department and Gateway Education
(http://www.cityu.edu.hk/edge/obtl/elearn_tool/p8.htm)
26
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
27
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Making a Dialogue:
Make a dialogue
script about safety
during the COVID-19
pandemic and
dramatize this in
class.
ANSWER: The intended learning outcome, focusing on the application of English
grammar in both spoken and written contexts, is effectively aligned with the
learning objectives, teaching strategies, learning activities, and assessment
methods. By engaging in story reading, learners can readily identify and grasp the
nuances of English grammar. Active participation and providing examples
contribute significantly to strengthening this understanding. To complete the
process and solidify their comprehension, a paper-and-pencil test serves as the
final step in the journey of recognition and proficiency in using English grammar.
28
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
29
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Self-Assessment Exercise 2
Review the instruction and identify which component is not aligned. Suggest what could be
done to bring this instruction back into alignment.
1. ILO: Sing or play a musical piece by reading the musical notations
30
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
3. ILO: Demonstrate understanding and application of lines, color, shapes, space, and
proportion through different art work
31
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
LESSONS
You have learned in Lesson 1 that all the components of instruction should be
aligned to achieve the intended learning outcome of the curriculum/program/course/unit.
One of these components is assessment. It is therefore very important that the assessment
activities which you provide to your students correspond to what you really intend to
measure. You may be teaching one thing but assessing another thing. Or your teaching and
assessments may be related but your assessment strategies and tools are not appropriate to
measure the attainment of the learning standards. To make sure that you are measuring
the correct learning standards, you have to be familiar with learning standards of the
present curriculum and you have to use appropriate assessment
methods/strategies/tools/tasks to align instruction.
For any type of assessment, you first must know where you want to end up. What are
your goals for your learners? An assessment cannot produce valid inferences unless it
measures what it is intended to measure. And it cannot measure what it is intended to
measure unless the learning standards have been clearly identified.
32
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Learning Standards
Learning standards are concise, written descriptions of what students are expected to
know and be able to do at a specific stage of their education. Learning standards describe
educational objectives—i.e., what students should have learned by the end of a course,
grade level, or grade span
There are terminologies associated with learning standards: learning outcome,
competency, knowledge, skill, ability and learning objectives.
1. Learning Outcome
A learning outcome is a statement that describes the significant and essential
learning that learners have achieved and can reliably demonstrate at the end of a
grade, course, program, unit, quarter or activity.
It is typically a one-sentence statement about what students should know,
understand and/or be able to do or demonstrate after completion of a process of
learning.
It is a broad statement and it covers several competencies which learners are
expected to possess.
In Outcomes-Based Education (OBE), the learning outcome usually defines the
readiness of a completer to respond to the challenges of the work that he/she is
expected to perform in real life.
DepEd (2019) adopts the definition of UIS (2011) on learning outcome: the totality of
information, knowledge, understanding, attitudes, values, skills, competencies or
behaviors an individual is expected to master upon successful completion of an
educational program.
2. Competency
33
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
It details the knowledge and skills of students who have completed a course or
program (Hartel & Foegeding, 2004).
Competencies often serve as the basis for standards that specify the level of
knowledge and skills required to successfully perform tasks in the workplace.
DepEd 2019 defines learning competencies as specific skills performed with varying
degrees of independence, have varying degrees and performance levels. These
also refer to the ability to perform activities according to the standards expected
by drawing from one’s knowledge, skills and attitudes.
In the above definition, we can draw out three (3) important components of
competency, namely, knowledge, skill, and ability.
a. Knowledge is the condition of being aware of something that is acquired through
training and/or experience.
b. Skill refers to specific activities or tasks that a student can proficiently do; skills can
be clustered to form specific competencies
c. Ability is the capacity or aptitude to perform physical or mental activities that are
associated with a particular task; can be roughly categorized into cognitive,
psychomotor and affective abilities. (This will be discussed in Lesson 3 when you
will learn how to construct learning objectives in the cognitive, affective and
psychomotor level).
So, to assess well the competency gained and to align assessment, you must
provide activities that can measure each of the three components of a
competency.
34
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Most competencies cannot be achieved in just one teaching because these compose
of a cluster of knowledge, skills or abilities. As a result, a desired competency is then
unpacked or broken down into its basic parts by determining what the participant would
need to know or what skills/abilities they would need to possess to be able to perform this
competency at a specific level.
In the pre-activity for Lesson 1 we have differentiated between learning objectives and
learning outcomes. Here are additional definitions.
3.Learning Objectives
Sometimes, the word “targets” is used instead of objectives. A target is a
quantifiable performance level or change in performance level to be attained
within a specific time (Muller & Associates, 2001).
A learning objective is an explicit statement that clearly expresses what the
learners are able to do at the completion of a learning session.
It has the following characteristics: specific, written in behavioral terms, contains
action verbs that are observable and measurable and identifies what behaviors a
participant must demonstrate in order to confirm the intended learning occurred.
Let us remember the acronym SMART for the characteristics of learning objectives
(Muller & Associates, 2001).
Specific,
Measurable and manageable,
Achievable, appropriate and agreed,
Relevant, realistic and recorded, and
35
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Time-related
Typically, there is more than one learning objective defined for a given
competency so the connection between competencies and learning objectives
would look like this:
Though most often there are learning competencies that are very specific such that
when they are unpacked, the learning competency is also the learning objective.
According to DepEd (2012), there are competencies in the K to 12 Curriculum Guide that
are too specific and appear as learning objectives. The said department also considers as
competencies the knowledge, understanding, skills, and attitudes that students need to
demonstrate in every lesson and/or learning activity.
36
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Content Standards Content standards identify and set the essential knowledge and
understanding that should be learned. They cover a specified
scope of sequential topics within each learning strand, domain,
theme or component. It answers the question, “What should the
learners know?” (DepEd 2019)
Performance Standards Performance Standards describe the abilities and skills that
learners are expected to demonstrate in relation to the content
standards and integration of 21st century skills. The integration
of knowledge, understanding, and skills is expressed through
creation, innovation, and adding value to products (performance
37
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Code Code of the learning area, strand, grade level, domain, quarter
week and competency number
Example: S11ES – I a – 1
S – Learning Area / Strand - Science
11 – Grade Level - Grade 11
ES – Domain - Earth Science
I – Quarter - First Quarter
a – week - Week one
1 - competency # - Competency # 1
38
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
First, in unpacking a learning competency, look for the verb or the behavioral
objective – this will help you determine the skill that students / pupils need to
learn.
Second, identify the topic associated with the verb.
Third, combine the verb and the topic.
So, there are two unpacked learning objectives in our first example.
Example 2
Let us take from another CG (Grade 10 English)
This is an example of a very specific competency such that the unpacked learning
objective is similar to the learning competency.
Most of the learning competencies in the K to 12 CG are very specific.
39
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Example 3
Learning Competency from Grade 1 Math CG
40
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
(From CG of Grade 9
Science)
There are assessment methods, strategies and tools that match specific learning
standards. If appropriate assessments are used, you can be sure that assessment is
accurate to give feedback about how the standards have been achieved.
The following table shows the levels of learning standards and suggests appropriate
assessment strategies and tools to accurately measure the standards.
41
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
42
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
43
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
learned in our
subjects.
Self-Assessment Exercise 4
Explore the CG and copy samples of learning standards in your field of specialization
( e.g. Grade 7 Science or Grade 7 Values Education) . Suggest an assessment
method/strategy/tool that can be used to assess learning. Use this format:
44
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
LESSONS
45
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
46
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
47
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Self-Assessment Exercise 5
Lorin Anderson, a former student of Bloom and David Krathwol revisited the
cognitive domain in the learning taxonomy in the mid-nineties and made some changes,
with perhaps the two most prominent ones being, 1) changing the names in the six
categories from noun to verb forms, and 2) slightly rearranging them (Pohl, 2000). This new
taxonomy reflects a more active form of thinking and is perhaps more accurate:
48
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Anderson and Krathwohl believed that a learner’s ability to evaluate came before his or her
ability to synthesize/create and therefore changed the order of these last two categories in
Bloom’s Taxonomy.
49
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
4. Analyze – Breaking material into its constituent parts and detecting how the
parts relate to one another and to an overall structure or purpose.
a. Differentiating
b. Organizing
c. Attributing
5. Evaluate – Making judgments based on criteria and standards.
a. Checking
50
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
b. Critiquing
6. Create – Putting elements together to form a novel, coherent whole or make
an original product.
a. Generating
b. Planning
c. Producing
The affective domain (Krathwohl, Bloom, Masia, 1973) includes the manner in which
we deal with things emotionally, such as feelings, values, appreciation, enthusiasms,
motivations, and attitudes. The five major categories are listed from the simplest behavior to
the most complex.
51
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
To inform management
on matters that one feels
strongly about.
Organization Integrating a new value adhere, alter, arrange, To recognize the need for
into one’s general set of combine, compare, balance between freedom
values giving it some complete, defend, and responsible
ranking among one’s explain, formulate, behavior.
general priorities. generalize, identify,
integrate, modify, To accept responsibility
order, organize, for one's behavior.
prepare, relate,
synthesize. To explain the role of
systematic planning in
solving problems.
To prioritize time
effectively to meet the
needs of the organization,
family, and self.
Characterization Acting consistently with act, discriminate, To show self-reliance
by Value the new value display, influence, when working
modify, perform, independently.
practice, propose,
qualify, revise, serve, To cooperate in group
solve, verify activities (displays
teamwork).
To use an objective
approach in problem
solving.
52
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
To display a professional
commitment to
ethical practice on a daily
basis.
There are three primary taxonomies for the psychomotor domain. These are by
Simpson, Dave and Harrow.
Guided Response: The early stages in copy, trace, follow, Science: To operate an
53
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
learning a complex skill that includes react, reproduce, apparatus by following the
imitation and trial and error. respond instruction of a manual or by
Adequacy of performance is achieved following the instruction of
by practicing. the teacher.
54
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
55
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Naturally, perfectly
Completion of one or more skills
with ease and making the skill To read sentences on the
5. Naturalization
automatic with limited physical or blackboard
mental exertion. To read a given story.
56
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
The taxonomy of Simpson, Dave and Harrow have been reorganized and simplified
into four categories or levels.
2. Imitating ( similar to Begin, explain, move, copy, To copy the basic strokes
guided response by display, proceed, react, written on the blackboard.
Simpson and Imitation by show, state, volunteer To follow the procedure of
Dave) an experiment
To imitate the sound of an
animal.
3. Practicing ( similar to Bend, calibrate, construct, To demonstrate how to
mechanism and complex differentiate, dismantle, operate the triple beam
overt response by display, fasten, fix, grasp, balance accurately with
Simpson and precision grind, handle, measure, mix, confidence in front of the
and articulation by Dave) operate, manipulate, mend class.
To write the letters of the
alphabet legibly.
To recite a poem
confidently.
4. Adapting (similar to Organize, relax, shorten, To design a procedure of
adaptation and sketch, write, rearrange, an experiment.
origination by Simpson compose, create, design, To compose a song or a
and naturalization by originate poem
Dave) To develop a new
57
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Self-Assessment Exercise 6
The following are examples of learning outcomes / learning objectives. Write the
domain (cognitive, affective, psychomotor) in the second column for each of learning
outcome / learning objective and in the third column the level or category to which the
learning outcome / learning objective belongs.
2. To perform
repeatedly with
speed and accuracy
4. To memorize the
letters of the
alphabet.
5. To accept leadership
58
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
responsibility with
commitment
7. To follow a procedure
in operating an
instrument as
demonstrated by the
teacher.
8. To recite and
participate actively
during class
discussion.
9. To rephrase the
definition of
measurement,
assessment and
evaluation.
Note:
1. For the cognitive domain, use either the levels of Bloom's or Anderson's Taxonomy.
2. For the psychomotor domain, use the simplified version by Simpson, Dave, and
Harrow
59
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Buendicho, F.C. (2010). Assessment of Student Learning 1. Rex Bookstore Inc. Sta. Mesa
Heights, Quezon City
DepEd (2012). DepEd Order No. 73, s. 2012. Guidelines on the assessment and rating of learning
outcomes on the K to 12 Basic Education Curriculum
DepEd (2019). DepEd Order No. 21, s. 2019. Policy Guidelines on the K to 12 Basic Education
Program
DepEd (2020). Guidelines on the Use of the Most Essential Learning Competencies (MELCs)
60
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
Gabuyo, Y.A (2015). Assessment of Learning 1. Rex Bookstore Inc. Sta. Mesa Heights,
Quezon City
Hartel, R., & Foegeding, E. (2004). Learning: Objectives, competencies, outcomes? Journal of
Food Science Education, Vol. 3, 69-70. https://bit.ly/3klHnVe
Muller, D. & Associates (2011). Target setting in school education: A discussion paper.
https://bit.ly/34ggjBh
Navarro, R. & Santos, R. (2013). Authentic assessment of student learning outcomes. Assessment of
Learning 2. Second Edtion. Lorimar Publishing Incorporated.
Navarro, R.L, Santos, R.G. and Corpuz, B.B. (2019). Assessment of Learning 1. Lorimar
Publishing Inc. Quezon City, Metro Manila
Santos, R D (2007). Assessment of Learning 1. Lorimar Publishing Inc. Cubao, Quezon City
http://www.edpsycinteractive.org/topics/behavior/psymtr.html
http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/hrd/bloom.html
61
MARIANO MARCOS STATE UNIVERSITY
College of Teacher Education
62