Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1992 Damasio-BrainLanguage Brain and Language
1992 Damasio-BrainLanguage Brain and Language
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
Scientific American, a division of Nature America, Inc. is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize,
preserve and extend access to Scientific American
W
hat do neuroscientists talk about a collection of symbols in admissible combi
when they talk about language? We nations-and as the embodiment in the brain
talk, it seems, about the ability to of those symbols and the principles that de
use words (or signs, if our language is one of termine their combinations. The brain uses
the sign languages of the deaf ) and to com the same machinery to represent language
bine them in sentences so that concepts in that it uses to represent any other entity. As
our minds can be transmitted to other peo neuroscientists come to understand the neural
ple. We also consider the converse: how we basis for the brain's representations of exter
apprehend words spoken by others and turn nal objects, events and their relations, they will
them into concepts in our own minds. simultaneously gain insight into the brain's
Language arose and persisted because it representation of language and into the mech
serves as a supremely efficient means of anisms that connect the two.
communication, especially for abstract concepts. Try to ex We believe the brain processes language by means of three
plain the rise and fall of the communist republics without interacting sets of structures. First, a large collection of neu
using a single word. But language also performs what Patri ral systems in both the right and left cerebral hemispheres
cia S. Churchland of the University of California at San Die represents nonlanguage interactions between the body and
go aptly calls "cognitive compression." It helps to categorize its environment, as mediated by varied sensory and motor
the world and to reduce the complexity of conceptual struc systems-that is to say, anything that a person does, per
tures to a manageable scale. ceives, thinks or feels while acting in the world.
The word "screwdriver," for example, stands for many The brain not only categorizes these nonlanguage repre
representations of such an instrument, including visual de sentations (along lines such as shape, color, sequence or
scriptions of its operation and purpose, speCific instances of emotional state), it also creates another level of representa
its use, the feel of the tool or the hand movement that per tion for the results of its classification. In this way, people
tains to it. Or there is the immense variety of conceptual rep organize objects, events and relationships. Successive layers
resentations denoted by a word such as "democracy." The of categories and symbolic representations form the basis
cognitive economies of language-its facility for pulling to for abstraction and metaphor.
gether many concepts under one symbol-make it possible Second, a smaller number of neural systems, generally lo
for people to establish ever more complex concepts and use cated in the left cerebral hemisphere, represent phonemes,
them to think at levels that would otherwise be impossible. phoneme combinations and syntactic rules for combining
In the beginning, however, there were no words. Language words. When stimulated from within the brain, these sys
seems to have appeared in evolution only after humans and tems assemble word-forms and generate sentences to be
species before them had become adept at generating and spoken or written. When stimulated externally by speech or
categorizing actions and at creating and categorizing mental text, they perform the initial processing of auditory or visual
representations of objects, events and relations. Similarly, language signals.
infants' brains are busy representing and evoking concepts A third set of structures, also located largely in the left
and generating myriad actions long before they utter their hemisphere, mediates between the first two. It can take a
first well-selected word and even longer before they form concept and stimulate the production of word-forms, or it
sentences and truly use language. However, the maturation can receive words and cause the brain to evoke the corre
of language processes may not always depend on the matu sponding concepts.
ration of conceptual processes, since some children with de Such mediation structures have also been hypothesized
fective conceptual systems have nonetheless acquired gram
mar. The neural machinery necessary for some syntactic op
erations seems capable of developing autonomously. ANTONIO R. DAMASIO and HANNA DAMASIO have been in
Language exists both as an artifact in the external world- vestigating the neural basis of language and memory for the
past two decades. Antonio Damasio is professor and head of the
department of neurology at the University of Iowa College of
Medicine and adjunct profe ssor at the Salk Institute for Biologi
MARTIN LUTHER KING is remembered both for his vision of cal Studies in San Diego. He received his M.D. and doctorate
racial harmony and for his ability to find words that stirred from the University of lisbon. Hanna Damasio also holds an M.D.
his listeners to action. The central issue of the neurophysiol from the University of lisbon. She is professor of neurology and
ogy of language, the authors say, is to map the structures in director of the Laboratory for Neuroirnaging and Human Neu
the brain that manipulate concepts and those that turn the roanatomy at the University of Iowa.
concepts into words.
T
he same three-part organization gether. Such categorizations are denot different dimensions, symbolic repre
that explains how people man ed by yet another record in another con sentations such as metaphor can easily
age to talk about color applies to vergence zone. The essential properties emerge from this architecture.
other concepts as well. But how are of the entities and processes in any in
D
such concepts physically represented teraction are thus represented in an in amage to parts of the brain
in the brain? We believe there are no terwoven fashion. The collected knowl that participate in these neural
permanently held "pictorial" represen edge that can be represented includes patterns should produce cogni
tations of objects or persons as was the fact that a coffee cup has dimen tive defects that clearly delineate the
traditionally thought. Instead the brain sions and a boundary; that it is made categories according to which concepts
holds, in effect, a record of the neural of something and has parts; that if it is are stored and retrieved (the damage
activity that takes place in the sensory divided it no longer is a cup, unlike wa that results in achromatopsia is but one
and motor cortices during interaction ter, which retains its identity no matter example of many). Elizabeth K. Warring
with a given object. The records are how it is divided; that it moved along ton of the National Hospital for Nervous
patterns of synaptic connections that a particular path, starting at one point Diseases in London has studied catego
can re-create the separate sets of activi in space and ending at another; that ry-related recognition defects and found
ty that define an object or event; each arrival at its destination produced a patients who lose cognizance of certain
record can also stimulate related ones. specific outcome. These aspects of neu- classes of object. Similarly, in collabo-
For example, as a person picks up a
coffee cup, her visual cortices will re
spond to the colors of the cup and of
its contents as well as to its shape and
position. The somatosensory cortices
will register the shape the hand as
sumes as it holds the cup, the move
ment of the hand and the arm as they
bring the cup to the lips, the warmth of
the coffee, and the body change some
people call pleasure when they drink
the stuff. The brain does not merely
represent aspects of external reality; it
also records how the body explores the
world and reacts to it.
The neural processes that describe
the interaction between the individual
and the object constitute a rapid se
quence of microperceptions and micro
actions, almost simultaneous as far as
consciousness is concerned. They oc
cur in separate functional regions, and
each region contains additional subdi
visions: the visual aspect of perception,
for example, is segregated within small
er systems specialized for color, shape lANGUAGE ACTIVITY is visible in this positron emission tomographic (PET) scan
of a normal individual performing a naming task. The PET image has been project
and movement.
ed onto a three-dimensional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) reconstruction of
Where can the records that bind to
the same individual's brain. There are many areas of increased activity in the left
gether all these fragmented activities
hemisphere, including the motor cortex and the anterior and posterior language
be held? We believe they are embodied sectors (arrows). The image was produced by the University of Iowa's Department
in ensembles of neurons within the of Neurology, PET Facility and Image Analysis Facility.
L
el that lets him know that they are liv Sions such as Boswell's, in the an going surgery for epilepsy and made di
ing and animate. Faced with a picture terior and middle regions of both rect electro physiological recordings of
of a raccoon, he says, "It is an animal," temporal lobes, impair the brain's the response.
but he has no idea of its size, habitat or conceptual system. Injuries to the left Damage in the posterior perisylvian
typical behavior. hemisphere in the vicinity of the sylvi sector, for example, disrupts the as
Curiously, when it comes to other an fissure, in contrast, interfere with the sembly of phonemes into words and
classes of nonunique entities, Boswell's proper formation of words and sentenc the selection of entire word-forms. Pa
cognition is apparently unimpaired. He es. This brain system is the most thor tients with such damage may fail to
can recognize and name objects, such oughly investigated of those involved speak certain words, or they may form
as a wrench, that are manipulable and in language. More than a century and a words improperly ("loliphant" for "ele
have a specific action attached to them. half ago Paul Broca and Carl Wernicke phant"). They may, in addition, substi
He can retrieve concepts for attributes determined the rough location of these tute a pronoun or a word at a more
of entities: he knows what it means for basic language centers and discovered general taxonomic level for a missing
an object to be beautiful or ugly. He the phenomenon known as cerebral one ("people" for "woman") or use a
can grasp the idea of states or activi dominance-in most humans language word semantically related to the con
ties such as being in love, jumping or structures lie in the left hemisphere cept they intend to express ("headman"
Swimming. And he can understand ab rather than the right. This disposition for "president"). Victoria A. Fromkin of
stract relations among entities or events holds for roughly 99 percent of right the University of California at Los Ange
such as "above," "under," "into," "from," handed people and two thirds of left- les has elucidated many of the linguis-
Ordinary notebook, $2,497. The tYPical notebook computer of today was designed to run
DOS only, not Windows 3.1. It doesn't have enough memory, speed or screen brightness, and
its screen isn't fast enough for high-quality graphicallXJmputing
The Apple" Macintosh" PowerBook� is the only personal computer to make the Products of the Year lists of Business Week, Fortune" and Info World,
And the only notebook computer to be named one of the Best Designed Products of the Year by Time� Because it's the only computer designed as
-L
a totally integrated system. Combining hardware, software and industrial design to make working on the road as comfortable as working
at your desk. It's more intelligent. Its more convenient. It's power anyone can use, anywhere you happen to be. The power to be your best�
The hard way: The easy way: The hard way: The easy way:
1. Double-click on the Main group in Program 1. Highlight the directory 1. Purchase a parallel-to-SCSI adapter. 1. Plug the drive into the SCSI port.
Manager. (folder) you want to rename. 2. Connect it to the parallel port. 2. Start up the PowerBook.
2. Start File Manager. 2.'fYpe a new name (up to 31 3. Plug the drive into the adapter.
3. Highlight the directory you want to rename. characters). 4. Insert the adapter's installation disk
4. Select "Rename" from the file menu. in drive A:.
5. 'JYpein a new name for the directory 5. Select drive A:.
(must be 8 characters or less). 6.'fYpe "INSTALL�
6. Go to Program Manager if needed. 7. Select appropriate options for your drive.
7. For each application in the renamed directory, 8. Select appropriate drive for software
select "Properties" from the file menu. installation.
8. For each application in that directory, 9. Restart.
change the command line to reflect the new 10. Run installation test program.
path to the application program.
The hard way: The easy way: The hard way: The easy way:
1. Purchase a sound upgrade kit. 1. Double-click on the sound's icon. 1. Purchase a pointing device (such as a 1. T he trackball is built in.
2. Attach sound upgrade hardware. mouse or trackball).
3. Install sound upgrade's software drivers. 2. Open notebook's back panel.
4. Start the sound recorder program. 3. Attach appropriate port adapter to
5. Select Open from the file menu. pointing device (if other than 9-pin).
6. Select the sound file you want to play. 4. Connect pointing device to proper port.
7. Choose OK. 5. Choose appropriate clamp arms.
8. Click on the Play button. 6. Attach pointing device to clamp arms
and adjust tilt angle.
7. Start the computer.
8. Install driver software.
9. Restart.
B
processing of speech sounds, and so learning and that of regular verbs (those etween the brain's concept-pro
patients have difficulty understanding whose past tense ends in -ed) by habit cessing systems and those that
spoken words and sentences. Auditory learning. generate words and sentences lie
comprehension fails not because, as The anterior perisylvian sector, on the mediation systems we propose. Evi
has been traditionally believed, the pos the front side of the rolandic fissure, dence for this neural brokerage is be
terior perisylvian sector is a center to appears to contain structures that are ginning to emerge from the study of
store "meanings" of words but rather responsible for speech rhythms and neurological patients. Mediation sys
because the normal acoustic analyses grammar. The left basal ganglia are part tems not only select the correct words
of the word-forms the patient hears are and parcel of this sector, as they are of to express a particular concept, but they
aborted at an early stage. the posterior perisylvian one. The en also direct the generation of sentence
The systems in this sector hold au tire sector appears to be strongly as structures that express relations among
ditory and kinesthetic records of pho sociated with the cerebellum; both the concepts.
nemes and the phoneme sequences that basal ganglia and the cerebellum re When a person speaks, these systems
make up words. Reciprocal projections ceive projections from a wide variety of govern those responsible for word-for
of neurons between the areas holding sensory regions in the cortex and re mation and syntax; when a person un
these records mean that activity in one turn projections to motor-related ar derstands speech, the word-formation
can generate corresponding activity in eas. The role of the cerebellum in lan systems drive the mediation systems.
the other. guage and cognition, however, remains Thus far we have begun to map the
to be elucidated. systems that mediate proper nouns
T
hese regions connect to the mo Patients with damage in the anterior and common nouns that denote enti
tor and premotor cortices, both perisylvian sector speak in flat tones, ties of a particular class (for example,
directly and by means of a sub with long pauses between words, and visually ambiguous, nonmanipulable
cortical path that includes the left basal have defective grammar. They tend in entities such as most animals).
ganglia and nuclei in the forward por particular to leave out conjunctions and Consider the patients whom we will
tion of the left thalamus. This dual mo pronouns, and grammatical order is of call A.N. and L.R., who had sustained
tor route is especially important: the ac ten compromised. Nouns come easier damage to the anterior and midtem
tual production of speech sounds can to patients with these lesions than do poral cortices. Both can retrieve con
take place under the control of either a verbs, suggesting that other regions are cepts normally: when shown pictures
cortical or a subcortical circuit, or both. responsible for their production. of entities or substances from virtu
The subcortical circuit corresponds to Patients with damage in this sector ally any conceptual category-human
"habit learning," whereas the cortical have difficulty understanding mean faces, body parts, animals and botani
route implies higher-level, more con ing that is conveyed by syntactic struc cal specimens, vehicles and buildings,
scious control and "associative learn tures. Edgar B. ZuriJ of Brandeis Uni tools and utensils-A.N. and L.R. know
ing" [see "The Biological Basis of Learn versity, Eleanor M. Saffran of Temple unequivocally what they are looking
ing and Individuality," by Eric R. Kan University and Myrna F. Schwartz of at. They can define an entity's func
del and Robert D. Hawkins, page 78). Moss Rehabilitation Hospital in Phila tions, habitats and value. If they are giv
For instance, when a child learns the delphia have shown that these patients en sounds corresponding to those en
word-form "yellow," activations would do not always grasp reversible passive tities or substances (whenever a sourid
pass through the word-formation and sentences such as "The boy was kissed happens to be associated with them),
motor-control systems via both the cor by the girl," in which boy and girl are A.N. and L.R. can recognize the item in
tical and subcortical routes, and activity equally likely to be the recipient of the question. They can perform this task
in these areas would be correlated with action. Nevertheless, they can still as even when they are blindfolded and
the activity of the brain regions respon sign the correct meaning to a nonre asked to recognize an object placed in
sible for color concepts and mediation versible passive sentence such as "The their hands.
between concept and language. In time, apple was eaten by the boy" or the ac But despite their obvious knowledge,
we suspect, the concept-mediation sys tive sentence "The boy kissed the girl." they have difficulty in retrieving the
tem develops a direct route to the bas The fact that damage to this sector names for many of the objects they
al ganglia, and so the posterior perisyl impairs grammatical processing in both know so well. Shown a picture of a rac
vian sector does not have to be strongly speech and understanding suggests that coon, A.N. will say: "Oh! I know what
activated to produce the word "yellow." its neural systems supply the mechan it is-it is a nasty animal. It will come
Subsequent learning of the word-form ics of component assembly at sentence and rummage in your backyard and get
for yellow in another language would level. The basal ganglia serve to assem into the garbage. The eyes and the
again require participation of the peri ble the components of complex motions rings in the tail give it away. I know it,
sylvian region to establish auditory, kin into a smooth whole, and it seems rea but I cannot say the name." On the av
esthetic and motor correspondences of sonable that they might perform an erage they come up with less than half
phonemes. analogous ftmction in assembling word of the names they ought to retrieve.
It is likely that both cortical "associ forms into sentences. We also believe Their conceptual systems work well,
ative" and subcortical "habit" systems (based on experimental evidence of sim- but A.N. and L. R. cannot reliably ac-
T
nomenon has been reported in similar he evidence that lexical media and midtemporal cortices, miss many
form by Warrington and her colleague tion systems are confined to spe common nouns but still name colors
Rosaleen A. McCarthy of the National cific regions is convincing. In quickly and correctly. These correlations
Hospital for Nervous Diseases and by deed, the neural structures that medi between lesions and linguistic defects
Alfonso Caramazza and his colleagues ate between concepts and word-forms indicate that the temporal segment of
at Johns Hopkins University.) The pa appear to be graded from back to front the left lingual gyrus supports media
tients' ability to find names, however, along the occipitotemporal axis of the tion between color concepts and col
does not split neatly at the boundary of brain. Mediation for many general con or names, whereas mediation between
natural and man-made entities. A.N. cepts seems to occur at the rear, in the concepts for unique persons and their
and L. R. can produce the words for more posterior left temporal regions; corresponding names requires neural
such natural stimuli as body parts per mediation for the most specific con structures at the opposite end of the
fectly, whereas they cannot do the cepts takes place at the front, near the network, in the left anterior temporal
same for musical instruments, which left temporal pole. We have now seen lobe. Finally, one of our more recent pa
are as artificial and as manipulable as many patients who have lost their prop tients, G.]., has extensive damage that
garden tools. er nouns but retain all or most of their encompasses all of these left occipito-
In brief, A.N. and L.R. have a problem
with the retrieval of common nouns
denoting certain entities regardless of
their membership in particular concep
tual categories. There are many rea Components of a Concept
sons why some entities might be more
or less vulnerable to lesions than oth
C
oncepts are stored in the brain in the form of "dormant" records. When
ers. Of necessity, the brain uses differ these records are reactivated, they can re-create the varied sensations
ent neural systems to represent enti and actions associated with a particular entity or a category of entities.
ties that differ in structure or behavior A coffee cup, for example, can evoke visual and tactile representations of its
or entities that a person relates to in shape, color, texture and warmth, along with the smell and taste of the coffee
different ways. or the path that the hand and the arm take to bring the cup from the table to
A.N. and L.R. also have trouble with the lips. All these representations are re-created in separate brain regions, but
proper nouns. With few exceptions, they their reconstruction occurs fairly simultaneously.
cannot name friends, relatives, celebri
ties or places. Shown a picture of Mari
lyn Monroe, A.N. said, "Don't know her
name but I know who she is; I saw her
movies; she had an affair with the pres
ident; she committed suicide; or maybe
somebody killed her; the police, may
be?" These patients do not have what
is known as face agnosia or prosopag
nosia-they can recognize a face with
out hesitation-but they simply cannot
retrieve the word-form that goes with
the person they recognize.
Curiously, these patients have no dif
ficulty producing verbs. In experiments
we conducted in collaboration with Tra
nel, these patients perform just as well
as matched control subjects on tasks
requiring them to generate a verb in re
sponse to more than 200 stimuli depict
ing diverse states and actions. They are
also adept at the production of prep
ositions, conjunctions and pronouns,
and their sentences are well formed and
grammatical. As they speak or write,
they produce a narrative in which, in
stead of the missing noun, they will
substitute words like "thing" or "stuff "
or pronouns such as "it" or "she" or
D
derstand fairly well where nouns are an apple might generate "eat." These uring the past two decades,
mediated, but where are the verbs? subjects activated a region of the lateral progress in understanding the
Clearly, if patients such as A.N. and and inferior dorsal frontal cortex that brain structures responsible for
L. R. can retrieve verbs and functor corresponds roughly to the areas delin language has accelerated Significantly.
words normally, the regions required eated in our studies. Damage to these Tools such as magnetic resonance im
for those parts of speech cannot be in regions not only compromises access to aging have made it possible to locate
the left temporal region. Preliminary evi verbs and functors, it also disturbs the brain lesions accurately in patients suf
dence points to frontal and parietal grammatical structure of the sentences fering from aphasia and to correlate
sites. Aphasia studies performed by our that patients produce. specific language deficits with damage
group and by Caramazza and Gabriele Although this phenomenon may seem to particular regions of the brain. And
Miceli of Catholic University of the Sa surprising at first, verbs and functors PET scans offer the opportunity to study
cred Heart, Milan, and Rita Berndt of constitute the core of syntactic struc the brain activity of normal subjects
the University of Maryland show that ture, and so it makes sense that the engaged in linguistic tasks.
Considering the profound complexi
ty of language phenomena, some may
wonder whether the neural machinery
that allows it all to happen will ever be
understood. Many questions remain to
t
be answered about how the brain stores
concepts. Mediation systems for parts
of speech other than nouns, verbs and
\
functors, have been only partially ex
plored. Even the structures that form
words and sentences, which have been
under study since the middle of the 1 9th
century, are only sketchily understood.
Nevertheless, given the recent strides
that have been made, we believe these
structures will eventually be mapped
and understood. The question is not if
but when.
FURTHER READING
THE SIGNS OF LANGUAGE. Edward S. Kli
ma and Ursula Bellugi. Harvard Univer
ahhh . . .
sity Press, 1 9 79.
KNOWLEDGE OF LANGUAGE: I T S NATURE,
ORIGIN, AND USE. Noam Chomsky.
Greenwood Pre ss, 1 98 6 .
LESION ANALYSIS IN NEUROPSYCHOLOGY.
Hanna Damasio and Antonio R. Dama
sio. Oxford University Pre s s , 1 9 89.
NEURAL REGIONAUZATION OF KNOWL
EDGE ACCESS: PREUMINARY EVIDENCE.
A. R. Damasio, H. Damasio, D. Tranel
and J. P. Brandt in Cold Spring Harbour
Symposia on Quantitative Biology, Vol.
LV: The Brain. Cold Spring Harbor Lab
oratory Press, 1 9 90.
APHASIA. A. R. Damasio in New England
Journal of Medicine, Vol. 3 2 6 , No. 8 ,
pages 5 3 1 - 5 3 9 ; February 2 0 , 1 9 9 2 .
A N INTRODUCTION T O LANGUAGE. Victo
ria Fromkin and Robert Rodman. Har
court Brace Jovanovich College Publica
tions, 1 9 9 2 .
rain disorders include well over 650 As the only national organization promoting all
disorders-ranging from stroke, head aspects of brain research, the National Foundation for
and spinal cord injury, to Alzheimer's Brain Research's ongoing mission is to:
----.�iiiIIII�- Disease, schizophrenia, alcoholism -Improve public awareness and support for scien
and drug addiction-which devastate tific research on the brain and its disorders;
the lives of an estimated 50 million -Serve as a clearinghouse for national and interna
Americans. Some disorders, like brain tional activities concerning the "Decade of the Brain"; and
------ tumors and multiple sclerosis, are -Bring together government, medical, and scientific
killers. Others, like learning disabilities and sleep disor societies, voluntary health agencies, and industry in joint
ders diminish much of the meaning of life. As a category, programs of public and professional education.
brain disorders are a leading cause of death in the United Ongoing NFBR projects include the development of
States today and they are the most common and severe television series, dissemination of government reports on
cause of social, economic, and psychological disability in brain research, and an annual scientific symposium in
this country. Washington. One of NFBR's most exciting projects is a
The National Foundation for Brain Research science museum exhibit on the brain. The exhibit opened
(NFBR) is dedicated to the proposition that brain research in June at the Franklin Institute Science Museum in
is the best investment the American people can make to Philadelphia and will tour eight cities, with the last stop in
prevent or ameliorate some of the most debilitating disor October 1994 scheduled for the California Museum of Sci
ders of the human condition. To accomplish this goal, the ence & Industry in Los Angeles.
non-profit NFBR has galvanized professional societies, NFBR is widely recognized for its leadership on the
lay organizations, and governmental and corporate bodies Decade of the Brain initiative. In recognition of the impor
to work toward a common objective: the enhancement of tance of neurological and mental research, President
brain research. George Bush signed into law a Congressional resolution
-,7-
science, neuroimaging, neurophysiology, neurogenet- also can tell researchers what therapeutic interventions
ics, molecular biology, and many other disciplines. and strategies for prevention can interdict brain dys-
What makes neuroscience new is its emer- function and deg eneration. Finally, neuro-
Of
gence from a set of principles that are unlikely to science can help tell us who we are CJ,'i)ETHE8�
be falsified. For example, we now know for certain and whether intelligence has survival !§
that nerve impulses result from the flow of different value for H. sapiens. ��
-Dominick P. Purpura, M .D. , "'"q
___
BR 2
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC
Schering-Plough has also entered into a licensing Research operates on a continuum. Basic brain
agreement with Carter-Wallace Inc. , New York, for research focuses on understanding the fundamental struc
overseas marketing rights to felbamate, a promising ture and functions of the brain. In particular, scientists are
compound for treating epilepsy. intent on discovering the fundamental ways in which neu
When the Research Institute moves in Decem rons-the building blocks of the brain-work. At the other
ber to the Drug Discovery Facility, a 1 -million sq.-ft., end of the spectrum, applied research builds upon the
state-of-the-art facility in Kenilworth, N.J., additional information derived from basic research to develop treat
CNS product areas will be considered. Says Dr. Bul ments and diagnostic devices for diseases of the brain.
lock: "The neurosciences and CNS will present some The federal government is the primary sponsor of
very attractive research opportunities." basic brain research. Pharmaceutical companies and
medical products manufacturers conduct applied research
BR 3
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC
c/J Schering-Plough
Schering-Plough Research Institute
2000 Galloping Hill Road
Kenilworth, N.J. 07033
BR 5
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC
Pioneering
Research in the
Cause, Treatment
and Cure of
Alzheimer's
Disease
The name and logo HOECHST are registered trademarks of Hoechst AG. Q67003-1291
Despite the analytic potential of imaging technologies RECENT AOVANCES IN BRAIN RESEARCH
that display the brain, "biomedicine has been almost More has been learned about the brain's structure and
exclusively observationally oriented," points out James functions in recent decades than in prior recorded history.
J. Conklin, M.D. , president and CEO of Bio-Imaging During the 1960s and 1970s, enormous advances
Technologies Inc. Further, "The use of proprietary occurred in the methods used to study the chemistry of
hardware - software systems has prevented an the brain, resulting in increased knowledge about the
exchange of image data between MRI devices, PET roles of natural chemicals and pharmaceuticals in mental
and SPECT scans, and CAT technologies." disorders. In the 1980s, advances in molecular biology
Bio-Imaging Technologies' task is to bring quan and imaging techniques opened new doors in the study of
titative disciplines into imaging. In doing so, the two the roles of genetics in brain anatomy and activity. In the
and-a-half year-old company from West Trenton , N.J. , 1990s, the Decade of the Brain, science is poised to com
hopes to speed the process of clinical evaluation and bine the experience of the past 20 years to refine the
regulatory review for its clients: biotechnology and study of brain activity in living subjects. Science holds
pharmaceutical companies seeking FDA approval of great promise for breakthroughs in a number of areas,
drugs and medical devices. Because more precise including neurogenetics, neurobehavioral sciences, and
data gleaned from images means the reliability of sta neural injury.
tistical evidence improves, Bio-Imaging theoretically Even a cursory review of where brain research has
can decrease the number of patients needed to provide brought us in the past 20 years is staggering. Unprece
clinical trial results. That, in turn, could reduce the aver dented advances in molecular genetics and functional
age $231 million cost and slash the typical 12-year and structural brain imaging have provided new ways to
timetable to bring a new drug to market. conceptualize the healthy brain and the injured or dis
Bio-Imaging's proprietary technology includes eased brain. Currently, much attention is focused on
tools to insure that each imaging technology-whether alterations in neurotransmitter systems. Scientists are
it's a CAT or a PET scan-studies the same exact site. investigating the possible association of increased or
The company's image processing technology, based on decreased levels of dopamine with symptoms of schizo
satellite imaging techniques, digitizes and converts phrenia, and the role of monoamines in mood disorders.
images to a standard format. Data from various systems Molecular biology, combined with the techniques
are fused and and knowledge of neuroscience, is bringing the develop
translated into ment of drugs for diseases of the brain into a new phase
three-di men through what is known as rational drug design (ROD). The
sional image principle behind ROD is that if the structure of a specific
displays and drug receptor is known, then it is possible to "tailor design"
quantitatively drugs which selectively interact with, and modulate, its
analyzed. By functions. ROD focuses on understanding the physiologi
following par cal basis of disease, concentrating on the activity of hor
ticular patients mones and hormone receptors, enzymes, cell replication,
"Fused" MRI and PET images allow Bio-Imaging over time, Bio and protein synthesis.
Technologies 10 pinpoint blood perfusion defects I maging can
and evaluate recovery in stroke patients.
build far more
statistically valid analyses than more subjective mea BRAIN IMAGING
sures allow. Until recently, examination of the human brain was possi
For example, M RI brain studies of a stroke ble only through surgery or autopsy. In the past 20 years,
patient map the individual's anatomy; a PET scan the potential to understand and treat brain disorders has
clearly shows areas of the brain where blood does not been enormously advanced through the development of
flow and therefore are likely damaged. By combining ways of "imaging" or seeing the brain operating intact,
those two tools in progressive time-studies, Bio-Imag allowing for unprecedented access. Imaging techniques,
ing's technology can help pharmaceutical researchers already useful in the diagnosis of some mental disorders,
to methodically chart improvement. are of fundamental importance in basic research aimed at
Bio-Imaging's technology applies to all diseases mapping the regions of the brain and correlating those
and conditions amenable to imaging-from gastroin regions with function.
testinal ulcers and heart disease to skin lesions. How One technique, positron emission tomography
ever, "The roots of our technology are in the brain," (PET), allows measurement of energy levels-or activ
says Dr. Conklin. The technology was first used in CNS ity-in the brain. By giving moment-to-moment pictures of
studies at Maryland Psychiatric Research Center and the working brain, PET scans provide an inside look at
(continued on page BR11)
BR 7
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC
MEASURE
in the clinical evaluation of drugs and
medical devices.
WHAT
biostatistical measures from medical images
captured by a variety of imaging and sensor
devices, from MRI , CAT, PE T and nuclear
scanners to fiberscopes and infrared sensors.
THE EYE
T hese biostatistical measures are used to
quantitatively analyze the therapeutic effect of
drugs or the diagnostic utility of medical devices.
CAN'T SEE
BIO-IMAGING TECHNOLOGIES applies its
medical image processing, image base and data
management expertise to prepare fully inter
active, computerized regulatory submissions.
CIBA-GEIGY CORP.
Ciba-Geigy, the wholly owned U.S. doing something about that."
subsidiary of a $1 5 billion conglomer Ciba-Geigy's long list of drugs
ate headquartered in Basel, Switzer tor CNS conditions include Lioresal,
land, generates about one-third of tor the relief of spasms in multiple
Ciba-Geigy's worldwide pharmaceuti sclerosis conditions; Ritalin, tor atten
cal business from its Summit, N.J., tion deficit disorders; and Totra.nil, for
division. Summit's research concen depression.
trates on arthritis, pulmonary disease, One of the most widely pre
cardio-vascular, cancer, and central scribed medications worldwide tor the
nervous system disorders. treatment of epilepsy is Ciba-Geigy's
"We have a corporate commit Tegretol. First introduced in Europe
ment to researching and developing duri ng the early 1960s, Tegretol One 01 the most widely prescribed
drugs tor CNS disorders," says Carlos became available in the U.S. in 1968 medications worldwide lor the treatment 01
epilepsy is Ciba-Geigy's Tegretol.
Staglis, product director tor the CNS for the treatment of trigeminal neural
area. "There is a tremendous emo gia and in 1974 for epilepsy. Earlier OROS, a new slow-release formula
tional stigma and burden with CNS this year, Ciba-Geigy submitted a tion ofTegretol.
conditions and we're committed to ne w drug application tor T egretol The CNS therapeutic area
can claim its share of major suc
"------. cesses lately. For example, Habitrol,
a transdermal nicotine patch to aid
in smoking cessation, was launched
in December with the intent of help
ing many of the nation's estimated
50 million smokers quit by reducing
cigarette craving. Another of the
Books on Ihe]Jrilin
division's claims to fame is
Anafranil, the first and only drug
approved in the United States for
treating Obsessive-Compulsive Dis
order (OCD).
Culturing Nerve Cells As many as one in 40 people,
edited by Gary Qanker and or 5 million Americans, suffers from
Kimberly Goslin OCD. These individuals experience
foreword by Charles F. $tevens uncontrollable recurring thoughts
"An excellent book that fills a substantial (obsessions) and feel forced to act
need in biomedical literature." out meaningless behaviors frequently
- Dennis W. Chpi, Washington University and repeatedly (compulsions). The
$55.00 (October) School of Medicine most common obsessions involve
Cellulor ond Molecular Neuroscience Series preoccupation with dirt and fear of
docrinology A Bradford Book 453 pp:, 89 illus. $55.00
acting on violent thoughts. The most
Becker, S. Marc Breed/ave, common compulsions entail exces
and David Crews The Computational Brain s ive cleaning, washing, counting,
"This book provides a superb introduction to Patricia S. Church/and and arranging rituals, and hair pulling.
the field ... It will stimulate students and Terrence 1. Sejnowski Cleared by the FDA for mar
attract many to the next generation of " ...Essential rea q ing for anyone interested keting in 1989, Anafranil blocks the
behavioral endocrinologists." in neuroscience.".l..;- James H. Schwartz, reuptake of serotonin and norepi
- Arthur P. Arnold, UCLA Columbia Universi� c.p.s. n ephrine-neurochemicals that
A Bradford Book 574 pp., 133 iIIus. ComputatianalNeuros . Series
A Bradford Book Milius. $39.95
carry messages between nerve cells
$65.00 cloth, $34.95 softcover
in the brain that have been linked to
OCD behavior. Patients who
responded to the drug averaged a
To order books call toll-free 1.800.356.0343 or 617.628.856 2. MasterCard � VISA ciCcepted.
35% to 42% reduction in symptoms,
55 Hayward Street The MIT Press (amoridge,MA 02142 with 85% saying they experienced
some reduction in symptoms.
BR 9
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC AMERICAN, INC
At elBA-GEIGY,
people are
the active ingredient
to pharmaceutical Pharmaceuticals Division
CIBA-GEIGY Corporation
innovations of tomorrow. .. Summit. New Jersey 07901
BR 1 AMERICAN,
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC 1 INC
�
Brain-Impaired Adults Groups
WHERE TO FIND MORE INFORMATION 425 Bush Street
Suite 500
35 Wisconsin Circle, Suite 440
Chevy Chase, MD 20815
�T�� Many organizations exist to help patients and San Francisco, CA 94108
(415)434-3388
(301 )652-5553; (800)336-GENE
'\
/§ families living w"h var�us disorders of the National Fo un dati o n for Jewish
� brain. These organizations typically provide CIAICIT....TIffI .. Genetic Diseases
Charcot-Marie-Tooth Association 250 Park Avenue, Suite 1 000
,- information about the treatments available for
601 Upland Avenue New York, NY 10017
\ '";
the particular disorder and useful information
to families, and many support research.
Upland, PA 19015
(215)499-7486
(212)554-9712
atAIIIAE n-.
Charcot-Marie-Tooth Inti. Guillain-Barre Syndrome
1 Springbank Drive Foundation International
...... .. IAmrs .. St. Catherine, Ontario l25 2K1 P.O. Box 262
Alzheimer's Association Batten's Disease Support and Canada Wynnewood, PA 19096
70 East Lake Street Research Association (416)687-3630 (215)667-0131
Suite 600 2600 Parsons Avenue
� IOIACIIE
Chicago, IL 60601 Columbus, OH 43207 American Association for the
(312)853-3060; (800)621-0379 (800)448-4570 Depression After Delivery
P.O. Box 1282 Study of Headache
French Foundation for Alzheimer IIII IJRTI Morrisville, PA. 19067 875 Kings Highway
Research March of Dimes Birth Defects (215)295-3994; (800)944-4773 Suite 200
11620 Wilshire Boulevard Foundation West Deptford, NJ 08096
Suite820 1275 Mamaroneck Avenue National Foundation for (609)845-0322; (800)255-ACHE
Los Angeles, CA 90025 White Plains, NY 10605 Depressive Illnesses
P.O. Box 2257 American Council for Headache
(213)445-4650; (800)477-2243 (914)428-7100 Education
New York, NY 10116
AIYI-..c LAltIAL lCl98II IfPIAIIIPAIII (800)248-4344 875 Kings Highway
The ALS Association Benign Essential Blepharospasm Suite 200
21021 Ventura Boulevard Foundation Inc. BIllIB West Deptford, NJ 08096
Suite 321 2929 Calder Avenue, Suite 304 Vestibular Disorders Association (609)845-0322; (800)255-ACHE
Woodland H ill s, CA 91364 Beaumont, TX 77704 P.O. Box 4467
National Headache Foundation
(409)832-0788 Portland, OR 97208-4467
(818)340-7500; (800)782-4747 (503)229-7705
5252 N. Western Avenue
Chicago, IL 60625
MEV _ --
IYIAITa.A (800)843-2256
Anxiety Disorders Association of American Brain Tumor Assn.
America 3725 N.Talman Avenue Dysautonomia Foundation Inc. I8I IJ1RY
Chicago, IL 60618-4712 20 East 46th Street
6000 Executive Boulevard, #513 National Head Injury Foundation
Rockville, MD 20852 (312)286-5571; (800)886-2282 Suite 302
1 140 Connecticut Avenue, NW
New York, NY 10017
(900)737-3400 Brain Research Fund Foundation (212)949-6644
Suite 812
of London Washington, DC 20036
AT. (202)296-6443; (800)444�6443
National Ataxia Foundation 111 Waterloo Street, Suite 600 BYIlfXIA
15500 Wayzata Boulevard, #750 London, Ontario N6B 2M4 The Orton Dyslexia Society ....1 ..,
Wayzata, MN 55391 Canada Chester Building Hereditary Disease Foundation
(612)473-7666
(519)624-7755 8600 LaSalle Road
1427 7th Street, Su ite 2
Suite 382 Santa Monica, CA 90401 -9990
Brain Tumor Foundation for
Baltimore, MD 21204-6020 (213)458-4183
� IAlfIIIATII Children Inc.
2231 Perimeter Park Dr.
(410)296-0232
The AVM Support Group Huntington's Disease Society of
107 Bella Vista Way Suite 9 IYI18I America
San Francisco, CA 94127 Atlanta, GA 30341 Dystonia Medical Research 1 40 W. 22nd Street, 6th Floor
(415)421-7330 (404)458-5564 Foundation New York, NY 1 001 1 -2420
8111 Brain Tumor Society 8383 Wilshire Blvd., Suite 800 (212)242-1968; (800)345-HDSA
258 Harvard Street, Suite 308 Beverly H ills, CA 9021 1
Autism Society of America nB8'IU
8601 Georgia Avenue Brookline, MA 02146 (213)852-1630
(617)433-7033 National Hydrocephalus
Suite 503 fPII.EPIY Foundation
Silver Spring, MD 20910 The Children's Brain Tumor Epilepsy Foundation of America 400 N. Michigan Ave., Suite 1102
(301)565-0433 Foundation 4351 Garden City Drive Chicago, IL 6061 1
The New Jersey Center for 35 Alpine Lane Landover, MD 20785 (312)645-0701; (800)785-6161
Outreach and Services for the Chappaqua, NY 1 0514 (301 )459-3700
(914)238-4917 I.fMIINC IIUIIlJ110
Autism Community Inc. IlfUL IIBJIII Learning Disabilities Association
123 Franklin Corner Road National Brain Tumor Foundation National Easter Seal Society Inc. of America
Suite 21 5 323 Geary Street, Suite 510 70 East Lake Street 4156 Library Road
Lawrencevill e, NJ 08648 San Francisco, CA 94102 Chicago, IL 60601 Pittsburgh, PA 15234
(6'09)895-0190 (800)934-CURE (31 2)726-6200 (VOice); -4258 (412)341-1515; (41 2)341 -8077
BR 1AMERICAN,
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC 3 INC
National Center for learning NABCIlfPSY Parkinson Support Groups Paralyzed Veterans of America
Disabilities American N arcol e psy Association of America Spinal Cord Research
99 Park Avenue P.O. Box 26230 11376 Cherry Hill Road Fo u ndati o n
6th Floor San Fra n cisco , CA 941 26-6230 #204 801 1 8th Street, NW
New York, NY 1001 6 (415)788-4793 Beltsville, MD 20705 Washington, DC 20006
(21 2)687-721 1 (301 )937-1545 (202)41 6-7659
Narcolepsy Network
LfUI8IIYSTIIPIIY P.O. Box 1365 Parkinson's Disease Foundation Spinal Cord Society
United leukodystrophy FDR Station Col umbia-Presbyterian Wendell Road
Fo u ndati o n New York, NY 1 0150 Medical Center Fergus Falls, MN 56537
2304 Highland Drive (415)591-7884; (914)834-2855 650 West 168th Street . (218)739-5252
Sycamore, Il 60178 New York, NY 1 0032
National Sleep Foundation SPIUL IIISCIIlAB ATIIPIIY
(800)728-5483 (212)923-4700; (800)457-6676 Families of S.M.A.
1 22 S. Robertson Boulevard
BAL IWISS Suite 201 Parkinson's Educational Program P.O. Box 1 465
Natl. Alliance for the Mentally III los Angeles, CA 90048 - USA Highland Park, Il 60035
21 01 Wilson B l vd . (310)288-0466 3900 Birch Street (708)432-5551
Suite 302 #105 ST.
HDFIBRIIATUI Newport Beach, CA 92660
Arlington, VA 22201 American Heart Association
(703)524-7600; (800)950-NAM I
Neurofibromatosis Inc. (714)250-2975; (800)344-7872 7272 Greenville Avenue
3401 Woodridge Court
National Mental Health Assn. Mitchellville, MD 20721 -2817 United Parkinson Foundation Dallas, TX 75231
1021 Prince Street (301 )577-8984 360 W. Superior Street (214)373-6300
Alexandria, VA 22314 Chicago, Il 60610 (800)242-8721
(800)969-NMHA IllElllVE.-uvE IIIREI (312)664-2344 National Stroke Association
Obsessive Compulsive
PlmU SYNBIE 300 E. Hampden Avenue
BAL BEl_. Foundation
Suite 240
The Arc P.O. Box 9573 I nternational Polio Network
Englewood, CO 801 23-2654
500 E. Border Street New Haven, CT 06535 5100 Oakland Avenue
(303)762-9922
Suite 300 (203)772-0565 #206
(800)STR-OKES
Arlington, TX 76010 St. louis, MO 63110
(817)261-6003 P. (314)534-0475 ".WEIE\I SYaIIE
American Chronic Pain Assn. The Sturge-Weber Foundation
I..TIPlE IClBIISIS P.O. Box 850 Polio Survivors ASSOCiation
P.O. Box 460931
Multiple Sclerosis Association Rocklin, CA 95677 12720 La Reina Avenue
Aurora, CO 80046
of America (916)632-0922 Downey, CA 90242
(310)862-4508
(303)360-7290; (800)627-5482
601 -605 White Horse Pike
Oaklyn, NJ 08107
National Chronic Pai n SYBRIYEUA
Outreach Association PIICBIVE IIPIMICLEAR PALSY
(800)833-4MSA American Syringomyelia
7979 Old Georgetown Road Society for Progressive Alliance Project
Multiple Sclerosis Foundation Suite 100 Supranuclear Palsy Inc.
P.O. Box 1 586
6350 N. Andrews Avenue Bethesda, MD 20814-2429 2904 M arnat Road
longview, TX 75606-1586
Fort lauderdale, Fl 33309 Baltimore, MD 21209-2420
(301)652-4948 (903)236-7079
(305)776-6805; (800)441-7055 (410)484-8771
PMWIA TAYWIIS
National Multiple Sclerosis American Paraplegia Society BErT SYNBIE National Tay-Sachs and Allied
Society 75-20 Astoria Boulevard International Rett Syndrome Diseases Association I nc.
733 3rd Avenue Jackson Heights, NY 1 1 370 851 1 Rose Marie Drive 2001 Beaco n Street
6th Floor (71 8)803-3782 Fort Washington, MD 20744 Brookline, MA 02146
New York, NY 10017 (301)248-7031 (617)277-4463
(212)986-3240; (800)624-8236 ''''S IISfASE
American Parkinson Disease 1EYE1 SYNBIE TDETTE IYPIBn
IDSCU lYmRY Association National Reye's Syndrome Tourette Syndrome Association
M uscular Dystrophy ASSOCiation 60 Bay Street Foundation 42-40 Bell Boulevard
3561 East S unri se Drive Staten Island, NY 10301 426 N orth lewis Bayside, NY 11361
Tucson, AZ 85718 (71 8)981 -8001; (800)223-2732; Bryan, OH 43508 (71 8)224-2999
(800)572-1717 (800)732-9550 (toll free in NY) (419)636-2679; (800)233-7893; (800)237-0717
IYASTBIA ClAVI
(800)231-7393 (Toll free in OH)
California Parkinson's 1B8R
Myasthenia Gravis Foundation Foundation SPIUL _ IJUBY I nternational Tremor Foundation
53 West Jackson Boulevard, 2444 Moorpark Avenue American Paralysis ASSOCiation 360 W. Superior Street
Suite 600 Suite 31 6 500 MorriS Avenue Chicago, Il 60610
Chicago, Il 60604 San Jose, CA 95128 Springfield, NJ 07081 (31 2)664-2344
(312)427-6252; (800)541-5454 (408)998-2722 (201 )379-2690; ( 800)225-0292
TUB£R8IIS ICl.BIIIIS
IYICLDNIIS National Parkinson Foundation National Spinal Cord Injury National Tuberous Sclerosis
Myoclonus Research Foundation 1501 NW 9th Ave. Association Association
200 Old Palisade Road Bob Hope Road 600 W. Cummings Park 8000 Corporate Drive
Suite 17D Miami, Fl 331 36 Suite 2000 Suite 1 20
Fort lee, NJ 07024 (305)547-6666; (800)327-4545; Woburn, MA 01 801 landover, MD 20785
(201 )585-0770 (800)433-7022 (toll free in Fl) (617)935-2722; (800)962-9629 (301 )459-9888; (800)225-6872
BR 1 4 AMERICAN, INC
© 1992 SCIENTIFIC