Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Group Work Audit
Group Work Audit
1................................................................................................................................................................... 1
Executive Summary.....................................................................................................................................1
2 Introduction.........................................................................................................................................6
2.1 Background........................................................................................................................................6
2.2 IGEA Objective & Methodology.......................................................................................................6
3.2energy sources....................................................................................................................................9
3.3WATER sources................................................................................................................................10
3.4 Inventory..........................................................................................................................................10
3.4 Maintenance practices......................................................................................................................12
3.5Maintenance Budget.........................................................................................................................13
3.7 Building Energy Management Policy..............................................................................................13
Energy Balance..........................................................................................................................................13
4.1 Basis for energy balance..................................................................................................................13
4 System Performance...............................................................................................................................16
4.1 Data and measurements...................................................................................................................16
4.2 Lighting System...............................................................................................................................17
4.3 Identification of possible EE and RE opportunities.............................................................................21
UPGRADES TO THE LIGHTING SYSTEM.......................................................................................21
Systems For Air Cooling........................................................................................................................21
Refrigeration systems........................................................................................................................21
5 Recommended Energy Performance Improvement Actions (EPIAs)in EE and RE Measures for
Implementation........................................................................................................................................21
Other initiatives/project concepts for consideration...................................................................................24
5.1Awareness program...........................................................................................................................24
5.2 Automatic door closures..................................................................................................................24
5.3 Projected energy consumption.........................................................................................................25
Executive Summary
This study presents a comprehensive evaluation of energy utilization within the University of
Energy and Natural Resources, focusing on a block with a classroom, a chemistry laboratory, and
four office spaces. Energy audits are pivotal in assessing actual energy performance against
designated benchmarks or industry standards. The research emphasizes the critical role of energy
audits in identifying current energy consumption patterns, potential energy-saving opportunities,
and prioritizing efficient energy usage.
Key issues identified in the energy audit process encompass inefficient and inaccurate auditing
methodologies and tools, discrepancies in opinions and perceptions among auditors, misdirected
approaches due to missing or incorrect information, and the inability to provide a holistic view
enabled by life-cycle costing. Additionally, inadequacies in billing analytics pose challenges in
accurately assessing energy consumption.
This assessment aims to address these challenges by employing comprehensive energy audit
methodologies specifically tailored to the unique energy requirements of the block, classroom,
chemistry laboratory, and office spaces within the university. Through this investigation, it seeks
to provide actionable insights and recommendations to optimize energy usage, promote
sustainability, and reduce overall energy costs within the university setting.
(Haji-Sapar & Lee, 2005)
the auditing activity conducted within the block at the University of Energy and Natural
Resources was specifically limited to the chemistry laboratory and four office spaces, despite the
fact that the electricity bill encompasses energy usage for the classroom building as well. The
primary source of energy for this building complex is electricity, supplied by the Electricity
Company of Ghana Limited (ECG). Notable inventories assessed during this auditing process
comprise lighting systems, air conditioning units, refrigerators, water heating and cooling
systems, office equipment, and various other energy-consuming devices.
Observations made during this audit could likely revolve around specific energy consumption
patterns within the chemistry laboratory and office spaces. For instance, the observations might
reveal discrepancies in energy usage between the audited areas and the classroom building,
potential areas for energy-saving measures within the audited sections, inefficiencies in the usage
of lighting, cooling or heating systems, and general energy consumption trends within these
specific areas of the university buildings. (Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland, 2011)
The findings and insights gleaned from these limited audits in the chemistry lab and office spaces
provide a basis for action-oriented recommendations aimed at rectifying inefficiencies,
optimizing energy use, and ultimately guiding the university towards more sustainable and cost-
effective energy practices across all its buildings and facilities covered by the electricity bill.
Electricity is received from the grid and distributed. There is a separate meter for the
metering of electricity consumption provided by ECG. Since this meter accounts for the
supply to the APP LAB’ block, a suitable methodology was adopted to arrive at the
monthly electricity consumption of the ‘Main’ block.
● Estimated annual electricity consumption is about 166,920 kWh/y and the electricity
costs are about 341,593 GHC/y (75,910 $/y).
● Overall, air conditioners account for about 63% of the total electricity consumption
followed by lighting systems at 15%. Consumption in refrigerators accounts for about
9% and the energy consumption by office equipment and others account for about 10%.
Water dispenser and electric kettles accounts for 1% and 2% respectively.
● Specific energy consumption of the building is 143 kWh/m2/y.
● Specific lighting energy consumption is 21.28 kWh/m2/y and the specific air conditioning
energy consumption is 90.12 kWh/m2/y.
● Electricity tariff is 1.95 GHC/kWh (0.433 $/y)
The three categories below comprise the identified Energy Performance Improvement Actions
(EPIAs).
1. Ready to go EPIAs: Opportunities that can be implemented immediately without any further
studies or preparatory work. Projects that would fall under this category are listed in the
following table. Total envisaged savings in electricity is about 32,401 kWh/y with a monetary
benefit of about 63,058 GHC/y (14,013 $/y). Investment requirements are estimated at about
460,833 GHC (102,407 $) and the simple payback period would be about 7.3 years. Payback
period is little over due to the inclusion of the EPIA on ‘Real time energy monitoring
system’, the savings of which will not be quantified, though it would result in a savings of
about 5% to 10% as per the available literature and our own database.
After evaluation, the Life Cycle Costs (LCC) of the aforementioned projects show some
encouraging results. The LCC summary is provided in the table below.
● Awareness program, which will help to save the energy on the long run
● Neutral current reduction or avoidance
● Cogeneration system
A detailed M&V plan has been developed for the first category of projects, which is discussed in
detail in section 6 of this report.
One of the concern area is the louver type windows in some of the air-conditioned rooms. Out of
all the air-conditioned rooms, at least, 6 rooms are with louver type windows. Nearly 29 air-
conditioned rooms do not have automatic door closures and kept partially opened most of the
time. Both these result in considerable heat loss. One of the most needed interventions is to
replace the louver type windows with sliding windows and to provide automatic door closures to
reap the benefit of installing the new energy efficient air-conditioning systems at this facility.
2 Introduction
2.1 Background
Efficient energy utilization is crucial for sustainable operation within buildings or systems while
maintaining desired outputs. Energy wastage often results from inefficient usage and a lack of
awareness among users Raising awareness among consumers is essential to address this issue
[2]. In pursuit of energy efficiency, opportunities exist across power systems, both on the supply
and demand sides. More efficient generation, cleaner energy sources, and enhanced distribution
systems are required on the supply side. Conversely, various available technologies can be
implemented on the demand side to increase efficiency and reduce costs. Coordinated supply and
demand programs further enhance energy efficiency [3]. However, the sustainability of energy
efficiency programs heavily relies on user awareness and engagement.
Conducting an energy audit is a fundamental step in comprehending the energy performance of a
building or system, enabling the identification of potential areas for improvement [4]. The
University of Energy and Natural Resources (UENR) A.P.P. block, consisting of a classroom, a
chemistry laboratory, and four offices, serves as a focal point for investigating and improving
energy consumption within the university infrastructure.
Given the diverse functions within the A.P.P. block, ranging from educational spaces to
administrative offices, understanding and optimizing energy usage within these areas is critical.
The examination of energy flows and consumption patterns within each space is vital to identify
areas for potential energy savings without compromising operational output.
Efforts to implement energy audits and improve energy consumption within the A.P.P. block are
essential to ensure efficient resource utilization in modern-day operations. Such measures not
only contribute to cost reduction but also align with the University's commitment to
sustainability and responsible energy management.
By centering energy audit efforts on the APP Lab and the offices, UENR can tailor its strategies
and actions more precisely, leading to targeted energy efficiency improvements, enhancing
operational effectiveness, and setting an example within the institution for sustainable energy
management.
Particulars Details
Name of the building
Address
Telephone
Fax
Contact person
Telephone
Mobile
Fax
Email
Number of buildings in the complex 2 (Main block & Annex building)
Total number of floors- Main block Ground floor + 2
Total number of floors-Annex building Ground floor + 1
Total build up floor area 1,167m2
Total carpet area 817m2
Total air-conditioned area 715m2
Non-air-conditioned area 102m2
Non-active carpet area 49 m2
Car park area 1,050m2
Working hours per day 9 h/d – 8 am to 5 pm
Working days per week 5 d/week
Working days per year 244 d/y
Number of staffs 130
Average no. of visitors per day More than 100/d
Average no. of persons at any time in 130 Persons/d
office
Occupancy level 90% (as per information provided by the
facility)
Type of ownership Government
Contract demand NA – prepaid meter
Connected load NA – prepaid meter
Sanctioned load NA – prepaid meter
Table 4 : Description of the facility
3.2energy sources
Although the main energy source for operations within the block is electricity from the
Electricity Company of Ghana Limited (ECG), it's likely that this facility uses secondary or
alternative energy sources. Typical supplementary energy that could be used in place of or in
addition to electricity (MINISTRY OF ENERGY , 2010)
The prepaid connection from ECG are billed as per Tariff Code 21 consumer of low tension (LT)
supply at 0.440 kV, with following tariffs applicable as per the below table:
3.3WATER sources
The primary energy source utilized for operating the equipment within the block is electricity
supplied by the Electricity Company of Ghana Limited (ECG). Additionally, alternative energy
sources are also employed for powering various equipment within this facility.
$/1,00L 1.45
Firefighting tax % 1
Table 6 Tariff structure for power from ECG
3.4 Inventory
The main electrical inventories on the property are summarized in the table below.
Since there is no separate metering system for the RCEES offices and RCEES classroom, the
floor-by-floor, four-office, lecture room, and chemical lab detailed inventory list of the APP lab
block is also provided in building inventory details. This is a cross check for the monthly
electricity distribution.
The location-based inventory of the main components of this project, which include the lighting,
air conditioning, fans, and refrigeration system, other laboratory equipment are provided in
figure7. Floor-by-floor and room-by-room mapping of these inventories was done to make
identification easier during the implementation phase; the results are shown graphically in
Annexure-3.
Lighting Stock List: Sodium vapor 150W, LED 60W, LED 120W, LED 18W tube single, LED
2X18W tube, LED bulb 9W, T8 36W, T5 28W, T5 2X28W, and T5 4X14W are among the 317
light fixtures of various sorts that are present.
4% 4%1%
1%
1%
1%
01%
%0%
0% 5%
3% 1% T8 36W T5 28W
3% 2% T5 2X28W T5 4X14W
4% LED 18W LED T82x18W
1% LED Bulb 9W LED Bulb 2X18W
2%
Sodium Vapor 150W LED 60W
LED 120W AC (Split) 1.5 TR*
29% 13 AC (Split) 1.8 TR*1,643.7 AC (Split) 2.0 TR*
Refrigerator 110W Refrigerator 90W
Refrigerator 125W Refrigerator 190W
Refrigerator 150W Refrigerator 215W
Refrigerator 230W
36%
The facility is equipped with an internal engineering team responsible for inspecting and
identifying faults. However, the university block faces resource and personnel constraints,
limiting its capacity to conduct thorough examinations of malfunctioning appliances, assess
connections, maintain inventory records, and address issues related to lighting fixtures.
3.5Maintenance Budget
The APP Lab Block, under consideration, encompasses four lecturer offices, a lecture hall, and a
chemistry lab. Funding for building service, maintenance, and repair work is derived from three
primary sources: internally generated funds, development partner funds, and funds from the
Ghana National Petroleum Corporation (GNPC).
The annual maintenance budget for was utilized for the following major activities:
● Payment of electricity Bills
● Purchase of Diesel
● Building service and repairing
Payment of water bills Breakups for the individual activities were not made available.
Energy Balance
here are the average high and low temperatures for each month presented in tabular form:
It is evident from the preceding table that there is very little fluctuation in the outside
temperature and weather, which would only have a little effect on the amount of AC power used.
The effect on electricity usage for the other intervention areas (lighting & freezers) would be
negligible.
In the project region, the ambient conditions are consistent throughout the year. Nevertheless, the
average monthly temperature fluctuates from 24 to 30 degrees Celsius, which could affect the
baseline. Monthly energy consumption over time. The specific energy usage varies by nearly 3%
for each degree Celsius that the ambient temperature changes, according to DESL's database.
There is some effect because of shift in the relative humidity as well, although the influence is
somewhat smaller than the thermal circumstances.
4 System Performance
Additionally, the following information was gathered in order to be used for reporting,
performance evaluation, and analysis:
Building details, including location, area, etc.
● Electricity bills and electricity tariff
● Arrangements for metering
● Lamps, ACs, refrigerators and other energy consuming equipment specifications
● Inventory details of lamps, ACs and refrigerators
● Details on the maintenance practices
● Building energy management systems, if any
● Other relevant information
Additionally, measurements that are required to determine the performance were made. The
following table contains the measurement details:
Sl. Item Measured parameters Measurement Sample
No. duration
1 Electrical Voltage, current, power, 24 hours At feeder level of
distribution power factor, voltage & ‘Main’ block and
system current harmonics, ‘Annex’ building
voltage and current
unbalance, etc.
2 Lighting system Lux, power of lighting Spot Lux at all
circuit, room area measurements available rooms
and power on
a sample basis
3 Air conditioning Supply air & return air Temperatures, 10 samples (25%)
system temperature and RH, Air RH and air
velocity, power and velocityspot
room Power- spot to 7
area hours
4 Refrigeration Power 14 min to 43 min 4 samples (15%)
system
Table 9 measurement details
LED 60W
T528W
T5 2X28W T5 2X28W
20%
T5 4X14W
LED T8 18W
LED Bulb 9W
53% LED Bulb2X9W
T5 4X14W LED Bulb 9W
16%
LED T8 18W
LED Bulb2X9W 6%
2%
As indicated earlier, the annual energy consumption in lighting system is about 24,838 kWh/y.
The breakup of lighting energy consumption as per the type is given in the following figure.
light baseline population
LED T8 18W; 3 LED 60W; 7
LED Bulb2X9W; 1
T528W; 0.5
T5 2X28W; 31
Room dimensions within the range of 11m² to approximately 121m² exhibit diverse lighting
characteristics. The average lux levels span from around 38 to 720, with installed power varying
from 54W to 690W. Installed load efficacy (ILE), representing the average maintained
illuminance per circuit watt on a horizontal working plane, ranges from 13 lux/(W/m²) to 103
lux/(W/m²).
ILE serves as a pivotal metric for evaluating lighting performance. The Installed Load Efficacy
Ratio (ILER), calculated by comparing actual ILE to the target ILE, is a valuable indicator.
Ratios equal to or exceeding 0.75 are generally deemed satisfactory, while ratios ranging from
0.51 to 0.74 warrant investigation for potential improvements. Low ratios may be justified by
specific requirements, such as the use of less efficient luminaires to achieve desired lighting
outcomes. However, it is crucial to assess whether opportunities for more efficient alternatives
exist. Installations with an ILER of 0.5 or less necessitate thorough examination to identify
options for transitioning to more efficient lighting equipment.
This assessment approach, comparing ILE with target values based on Room Index and
application type, is applicable not only to existing installations but also for evaluating the
efficiency of designs for new or replacement general lighting installations. If the calculated ILE
falls below the target value during this process, it is advisable to investigate the reasons. Possible
factors include luminaire type, surface reflectance, or environmental conditions, with a focus on
identifying opportunities for more efficient solutions.
The four offices air conditioning system has been mapped. The specifics of the design of the
Present ACs were gathered. By monitoring the temperature and air flow, the split air
conditioners' performances were assessed on a sample.
Total 8 105,163
Refrigerator Systems
There is only one refrigerator in the chemistry lab. They hardly switch it on.
Refrigeration systems
These locations have non-star refrigerators installed, which have been reported to use more
energy. This is an excellent chance to swap out these outdated, inefficient refrigerators for star-
rated, energy-efficient models.
The following EPIA’s may be considered for implementation under this project.
Sl. No. As Is To Be
Item Number Item Number
EPIA#2: Replacement of inefficient non-star rated split AC with inverter type split AC:
As Is: The split air conditioners that are situated in the building's block lack an energy star
certification. There are some less star rated ACs. When compared to their rated cooling output,
the majority of ACs are not delivering enough cooling. The specific energy consumption is
relatively high (kW/TR; see section 4.4).
It is advised that the forty current air conditioners be swapped out for at least 3star-rated inverter
air conditioners.
To Come: The following will be the "to be" system.
Sl. As Is To Be
No.
As Is: The ECG-provided meter is being used to measure the electricity that is received from the
grid. The facilities energy manager is taking careful note of the meter readings. Other power
parameter details aren't provided, though .It is advised to install smart meters at the feeder and
floor levels and collect all electrical characteristics, including the hourly energy consumption
details, in order to raise awareness and instill accountability. Additionally, appropriate software
may be set up to evaluate the gathered information and generate a daily report. Additionally, this
would provide improved measurement and verification.
As Is: The lighting in the rooms and corridors was turned on even though no one was using them.
Suggestion: A total of 16 motion sensors should be installed in the lecture’s offices and chemistry
lab
Sl. As Is To Be
No.
1 Corridors and washrooms of the block: The four offices and chemistry of the
Without motion sensor and the lights are on APPLAB block With motion sensor and
always during the working hours the lights are on only when people are
around.
Other initiatives/project concepts for consideration
5.1Awareness program
The following may be included in an awareness program, which is crucial to gaining the benefits
of habit-oriented energy-saving opportunities, such as turning off lights, fans, and air
conditioners when not in use and closing doors and windows while the air conditioner is running.
Holding monthly or quarterly high tea meetings with all building employees and asking a
few resource people to speak about the advantages of energy efficiency and conservation
(EE&C).
This issue underscores the importance of addressing the fundamental aspect of door closures
before contemplating the replacement of existing air-conditioners with energy-efficient
counterparts. To optimize the benefits of installing new energy-efficient air-conditioning systems
at our facility, it is imperative to rectify this door closure deficiency.
The installation of automatic door closures in all relevant rooms is a requisite step, with an
estimated need for approximately 29 closures. This enhancement is not merely a logistical
formality; rather, it serves as a strategic precursor to the broader initiative of transitioning to
energy-efficient air-conditioning systems.
The following table shows the estimated energy cost and consumption.
GROUND FLOOR
Lecturer 28.49 9 2 2 1
office 1
Lecturer 121.0 9 2 11 1 4
office 2 3
Lecturer 44.00 9 12 3
office 3
Lecturer 43.07 9 6 1 2
office 4
Lecturer 50.82 9 4 7 3
hall 1
Chemistr 50.38 9 31
y lab1
1.5 2.7
Room no. 209 Sliding Glass 1.5 2.7 4.05
Room no. 210 Sliding Glass 1.5 3.7 9.6
1.5 2.7