Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Inventory Question Bank 2013
Inventory Question Bank 2013
DEPARTMENT OF ACCOUNTANCY
AUDITING 3A
2013
You asked Tasha Mitton to submit a report to you on her attendance at the year-
end inventory count. The report contained the following information.
1. The inventory count took place over two afternoons, from 1pm to 5pm on
30 and 31 July. This was to enable the company to receive and dispatch
goods during the morning.
2. The count was carried out by the six warehouse employees who usually
pick the goods to fill the orders. This worked well because they are familiar
with the inventory categories and where everything is stored.
3. The pickers decided amongst themselves which section of the warehouse
to count. Maggie Motolo, the warehouse administration clerk, printed a list
of the computerised perpetual inventory system (inventory sheet) of each
item (description and quantity) in the section chosen by the picker. The
numerically sequenced inventory sheets were handed to the pickers who
then counted each item in their section of the warehouse, ticking off the
quantities on the inventory sheets once they had counted the item.
4. If the count quantity differed from the quantity on the inventory sheet, the
counter (picker) highlighted the item and quantity and wrote in the number
he counted.
5. At the conclusion of the count on the second day, the counters returned
the inventory sheets to Maggie Moloto who identified the highlighted items
and amended the quantities on the perpetual inventory records to reflect
the actual quantities on hand.
6. Prior to the count, I confirmed with the financial accountant that we would
be attending the inventory count. He confirmed the dates and times with
me.
7 I was assisted at the count on both days by Zane Mulla (the truck driver)
and we carried out the following procedures:
PRESENTATION (2)
QUESTION 1 (SUGGESTED SOLUTION)
Holding the count over two afternoons so as to allow normal delivery and
dispatch was not sensible (1)
Non-trading day or overtime count would have resulted in a more
efficient count (1)
Total count time only 8 hours – insufficient time (1)
The method of counting was inadequate; no tag system or double count.
(1)
No count controller appointed to direct count. (1)
Composition of the counters totally inadequate: (1)
o Counting should be done in teams (2 persons) (1)
o One of whom should be independent of the warehouse function. (1)
If pickers have been involved in misappropriating inventory, they are now
in a perfect position to hide any shortages by having the perpetual
inventory records amended (1)
Amendments were done without authority or investigation (1)
There is no evidence that the warehouse was prepared for the count;
although it is “tidy”, a number of procedures should have taken place. (1)
o Marking damaged, slow moving obsolete goods. (1)
o Identifying expired (nearly expired chemicals). (1)
o Preparing a secure area for deliveries to be received during the
count/making sure goods received up to the 30 th, have been
unpacked. (1)
o Identifying the location of Bushblaze Inc inventory (consignment
stock). (1)
3. No written instructions were prepared for the count which again will
result in a substandard count. (1)
You are busy planning the audit of the new inventory, warehousing and
production system and have documented the process as follows:
Raw Materials:
Potatoes, spices, oil and other raw materials are issued to production upon
receipt of a written authorized requisition from the production manager. The
materials requisitions are pre-printed and prepared sequentially. Raw materials
are transferred from the raw materials store to the factory using an authorized
transfer or issue note. Upon receipt of the materials at the factory, one of the
factory foreman inspects the goods and compares the details to a copy of the
requisition to ensure that the correct quantity and quality of raw materials are
received. He signs a copy of the materials requisition as proof of receipt and
returns it to the raw materials store man.
Production:
Raw materials are stored in a separate area in the factory warehouse until
needed for production. The production process consists of four stages: The
peeling, cutting and frying of the potatoes and the packaging of the finished
products. The production supervisor ensures that sufficient raw materials are
used in the production process. Potato chips are packaged using two weights :
30g and 150 g packets. Production reports clearly indicate the raw materials,
labor and overheads used as well as the quantity of the finished goods produced.
These reports are sent to the management accounting division where a cost
accountant updates the inventory records. A perpetual inventory system is in
place.
Finished goods:
The potato chips are transferred to the finished goods store as soon as the
production process has been completed. A transfer note is once again used to
remove the goods from the factory to the store. Upon receipt at the finished
goods store the goods are packed in boxes containing fifty 30g packets or
10 150g packets. These boxes are then sealed and stamped and are ready for
distributing to the various wholesalers.
You are required to:
Prepare a working paper for the internal audit on the inventory, warehousing and
production system of AM. Your working paper should include:
1. A relevant heading (2)
2. Four control objectives that are related to the production and inventory
cycle. (4)
3. Four risks relating to the production and inventory cycle (4)
4. The test of controls that should be performed on the production and
inventory cycle to ensure that proper controls are in place. (15)
QUESTION 2 SUGGESTED SOLUTION
(2)
Engagement objectives:
To ensure that raw materials issued to production are authorised
To ensure that valid products are produced
To ensure that goods are properly safeguarded, and
To ensure that recorded inventory actually exists.
(4)
Risks:
Incorrect quantities and inferior qualities of raw materials are issued to the
production proses
Unnecessary goods and inefficient quantities are produced
Theft, damage of goods and
Recording of inventory items that do not exist (overstatement of inventory)
(
4)
Test of Controls:
Marks will be allocated for any other valid audit procedure given. Maximum
15
QUESTION 3: (12 MARKS)
You are currently the senior internal audit trainee of Bubbles (Pty) Ltd, a
company which manufactures and sells soaps and other cleaning materials. You
asked a junior trainee to explain the control objectives relating to bubbles (pty)
Ltd’s inventory of R1 832 916 reflected in the financial statements at 31 March
2012. He responded as follows:
You are the newly appointed financial manager of The Shoebox (Pty) Ltd, which
operated a chain of 29 large retail shoe stores in and around Port Elizabeth,
selling on a cash only basis. The stores are controlled from a central head office
and all inventory is issued to the stores from a central warehouse. All inventory
deliveries to stores are made by the shoebox (Pty) Ltd’s own delivery vans.
An analysis of the most recent branch accounts revealed that the average gross
profit margin for the 20 stores was 51% but that five stores reported margins
below 20%.
You approached the managers of the stores in question and the company
internal auditor and they all ascribed the poor margins to weak internal control
systems which enables theft in particular, to go undetected. Their explanations
for this, with which you agreed, is that the internal control system has not kept up
with the rapid growth of the company. You therefore decided to design internal
controls to improve the control over branch inventories.
Due to the nature of the stores clientele, the company introduced a “down
payment scheme”. This enables a customer to purchase shoes over six months
by making payments when they are able to. The selected shoes are put aside
and only once the six payments have been made are the shoes handed over to
the customer. Internal controls over this scheme are particularly poor.
Design an internal control system for the control of inventory under the following
headings:
1. Despatch from central warehouse to stores (12)
2. Receiving of goods by stores (5)
3. Physical control over inventory at stores (10)
4. The “down payment” scheme (5)
Detailed computer application controls should not be considered.
QUESTION 4: SUGGESTED SOLUTION
3. Physical controls
3.1 The branch manager should maintain a simple cardex of all
inventory on hand. The cardex should be written up from
despatch notes (see 1.3)
cash sales invoices
3.2 The manager and a salesperson/cashier should perform frequent
inventory counts (on a test basis) and the count quantities should
be reconciled to the cardex quantities.
3.3 The internal auditor should conduct surprise inventory counts
frequently and should agree the inventory on hand to the inventory
cardex. Managers are responsible for all shortages.
3.4 The storeroom should only be accessible through the shop itself,
i.e. any outside doors, windows should be barred off
it is obviously necessary that the staff have free access to the
storeroom, but no other persons should be allowed in the
storeroom e.g. customers, delivery people. Manager and staff
to enforce this control by being vigilant as physical controls are
inappropriate.
storeroom and shop to be protected against fire etc.
3.5 Inventory in the store itself should also be controlled by displaying
only one of the pair of shoes.
3.6 The store should be laid out in such a way as to make it very
difficult for someone to leave without passing a till
a security guard/electronic detectors should be used to reduce
shop lifting.
3.7 Staff should be checked at the end of the day to ensure that they
are not removing inventory (feet as well).
3.8 Security guards should be on duty at night.
4. Down payments
Note: There is a danger that “down payment” monies could be used to hide an
inventory shortfall.
Posh Shoe Ltd (hereafter Posh Shoe) is a listed company that is situated in
Sandton City, and specialises in the manufacturing of elite footwear for men,
women and children.
Posh Shoe purchases all of the raw materials needed for the production of the
shoes from Chic Shoes (Pty) Ltd (hereafter Chic Shoes) in Europe. A variety of
materials are used for the making of the shoes, such as leather fabrics, plastic,
rubber, fabrics, wood, jute fabrics, and metal. With the development of modern
machines, a pair of shoes can be easily manufactured in less time than it would
take to manufacture it manually, as each step in its manufacturing is performed
by a separate footwear making machine.
The process for issuing raw materials and producing the shoes is as follows:
You have just been appointed as the head of Internal Audit of Buy and Sell Ltd, a
company that purchases domestic goods and then distributes them to retail and
the public. The head office of the company is located in Johannesburg with
several branches in Gauteng, Mpumalanga and North West. All purchases are
made by the head office, however, each branch has its own store and goods are
delivered either at the head office and then distributed to the other stores, or
delivered directly to the branches’ stores. No sales take place at the main store.
Buy and Sell Ltd is renowned for having sound internal controls procedures in
place for all their warehouses. The company uses a perpetual inventory system
and inventory takings, on a surprise basis, are also executed continuously by the
internal auditor.
The company has decided to conduct an inventory taking over the upcoming
weekend. Although the company trades over the weekends, the warehouses are
at least all closed on Sundays.
As the internal auditor you will be co-coordinating the inventory taking. The
current inventory figure of R39 564 279 represents a material portion of the total
assets in the financial statements.
a)Fixing the date All employees concerned with the count should be 1
informed, well in advance, of the date of the count,
or dates, where the count will occupy several days.
Fixing responsibility Responsibility for the work should be clearly 1
defined and all staff involved in the count informed
to facilitate cooperation.
b) Controls:
The actual counting and recording of the inventory should be done under 1
proper supervision and the instructions issued strictly followed.
Provision should be made for the counting, the recording and the checking to 1
be distinct functions.
The supervisor should scrutinise the record for such signatures or initials and 1
add his or her own as evidence of review.
Maximum marks 5