Economic Size

You might also like

Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
Download as xlsx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 22

ECONOMICAL

PIPE NO.
DIA

250

P-1
P-2
P-3
P-4
P-5
P-6
P-7
P-8
P-9
P-10
P-11
P-12
P-13
P-14
P-15
P-16
P-17
P-18
P-19
P-20
P-21
P-22
P-23
P-24
P-25
P-26
P-27
P-28
P-29
P-30
P-31
P-32
P-33
P-34
P-35
P-36
P-37
P-38
P-39(1)
P-39(2)(1)
P-39(2)(2)
P-40(1)
P-40(2)
P-41
P-42
P-43
P-44
P-45
P-46
P-47
P-48
P-49
P-50
P-51
P-52
P-53(1)
P-53(2)
P-54
P-55
P-56
P-57
P-58(1)
P-58(2)
P-59
P-60
P-61
P-62
P-63
P-64
P-65
P-66
P-67
P-68
P-69
P-70(2)
P-71
P-72
P-73
P-74(1)
P-75
P-76
P-77
P-78
P-79
P-80
P-81
P-82
P-83
P-84
P-85
P-86
P-87(1)
P-87(2)
P-88
P-89
P-90
P-91
P-92
P-93
P-94
P-96
P-97
P-98(2)
P-99
P-100
P-101(1)
P-101(2)
P-102
P-103
P-104
P-105(1)
P-105(2)
INPUT DATA FOR ECONOMICAL DESIGN OF RISING MAIN

PUMP
GL AT LENGTH PUMPIN FLOW 2054 FLOW 2039 FLOW 2024 COMB. DESIGN COST OF INTREST OTHER
S.NO. STATUS PIPE NO. FROM TO GL AT END STAND BY
START (M) G HOURS (KLD) (KLD) (KLD) EFFFICIENY PERIOD PUMP/KW RATE LOSSES
%
1 P P-1 RABDEGA JUNANI CWR J-1 221 248.36 1,614 20 6083.6 5305.4 4632.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
2 P P-2 J-1 J-2 248.36 242.11 2,355 20 6012.8 5243.6 4578.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
3 P P-3 J-2 J-3 242.11 242.81 1000 20 4886.8 4259.6 3717.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
4 P P-4 J-3 J-5 242.81 240.95 5427 20 4619 4025.4 3512.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
5 P P-5 J-7 J-8 239.8 249.89 1,710 20 3995 3480.2 3035 75 30 16500 10 50 10
6 P P-6 J-8 J-9 249.89 266.58 1,843 20 3995 3480.2 3035 75 30 16500 10 50 10
7 P P-7 J-5 J-7 240.95 239.8 6,077 20 3995 3480.2 3035 75 30 16500 10 50 10
8 P P-8 J-9 J-10 266.58 267.01 88 20 3435.2 3001.8 2627.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
9 P P-9 J-10 J-11 267.01 262.84 201 20 2939 2568.4 2248 75 30 16500 10 50 10
10 P P-10 J-11 J-13 262.84 245.87 2900 20 2799.4 2446.4 2141.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
11 P P-11 J-13 J-14 245.87 250.08 2,112 20 2799.4 2446.4 2141.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
12 P P-12 J-14 J-15 250.08 257.34 1,108 20 2477.6 2165.4 1895.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
13 P P-13 J-15 BANKEY IPS INLET 257.34 257.1 49 20 2381.8 2081.6 1821.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
14 P P-14 J-4 J-6 240.1 236.39 933 20 1126 984 861.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
15 P P-15 J-2 J-4 242.11 240.1 507 20 1126 984 861.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
16 P P-16 J-12 J-16 236.43 232.52 2,526 20 692.8 605.4 530 75 30 16500 10 50 10
17 P P-17 J-6 J-12 236.39 236.43 2,154 20 692.8 605.4 530 75 30 16500 10 50 10
18 P P-18 J-5 PARUABHADI PROPOSED 240.95 269 2,062 20 624 545.4 477.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
19 P P-19 J-9 MAHULPALI PROPOSED 266.58 288.5 1,777 20 559.8 478.2 407.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
20 P P-20 J-10 GOCHHARA PROPOSED 267.01 287 55 20 496 433.6 379.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
21 P P-21 J-16 KUTRACHAUN PROPOSED 232.52 257 72 20 476.6 416.4 364.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
22 P P-22 J-6 HADIPALI PROPOSED 236.39 262 202 20 433.2 378.6 331.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
23 P P-23 J-14 BANKEY PROPOSED 250.08 284 1,100 20 321.8 281 246.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
24 P P-24 J-3 KHANDOKATA PROPOSED 242.81 264 273 20 267.8 234 205 75 30 16500 10 50 10
25 P P-25 J-16 J-17 232.52 234.8 1,927 20 216.2 189 165.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
26 P P-26 J-17 KUDAPADA PROPOSED 234.8 250.5 1,468 20 216.2 189 165.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
27 P P-27 J-11 GOCHHARA EXISTING 262.84 283.9 64 20 139.6 122 106.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
28 P P-28 J-15 BANKEY EXISTING (15 M) GOPALPALI 257.34 265.23 4,272 20 95.8 83.8 73.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
29 P P-29 J-1 KHANDOKAT EXISTING 248.36 253.84 140 20 70.8 61.8 54.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
30 P P-30 BANKEY IPS OUTLET J-18 257.1 275.93 5,037 20 2381.8 2081.6 1821.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
31 P P-31 J-18 J-20 275.93 274.43 1162 20 1300.4 1136.4 994.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
32 P P-32 J-20 J-21 274.43 274.41 684 20 1213.2 1060.4 928 75 30 16500 10 50 10
33 P P-33 J-21 J-23 274.41 276.9 2,204 20 1213.2 1060.4 928 75 30 16500 10 50 10
34 P P-34 J-23 J-25 276.9 291.27 482 20 1213.2 1060.4 928 75 30 16500 10 50 10
35 P P-35 J-18 J-19 275.93 265.56 1,206 20 1081.6 945.2 827.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
36 P P-36 J-19 J-22 265.56 253.79 3,501 20 982.8 859 751.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
37 P P-37 J-25 KUNTRA PROPOSED 291.27 321 44 20 634.2 554.2 485 75 30 16500 10 50 10
38 P P-38 J-22 J-24 253.79 264.93 2,279 20 631.8 552.2 483.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
39 P P-39(1) J-24 J-002 264.93 260.18 500 20 631.8 552.2 483.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
40 P P-39(2)(1) J-002 J-452 260.18 266.63 3,003 20 631.8 552.2 483.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
41 P P-39(2)(2) J-452 TELITILEIMAL PROPOSED 266.63 298 2,650 20 631.8 552.2 483.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
42 P P-40(1) J-25 J-001 291.27 297.7 365 20 579 506 442.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
43 P P-40(2) J-001 J-26 297.7 300 434 20 579 506 442.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
44 P P-41 J-26 KUSUMI PROPOSED 300 326 1,615 20 579 506 442.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
45 P P-42 J-22 TAINSAR PROPOSED 253.79 290 1,133 20 351 306.8 268.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
46 P P-43 J-19 TAINSAR EXISTING 265.56 284.53 64 20 98.6 86.2 75.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
47 P P-44 J-20 KUNTRA EXISTING (269.84) 274.43 290.84 789 20 87.2 76.2 66.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
48 P P-45 BARAMUSA CWR J-27 262.2 267.16 3,923 20 12716.2 10882.2 9210.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
49 P P-46 J-27 J-28 267.16 271.82 965 20 11897.8 10183.2 8614.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
50 P P-47 J-29 NAUDIHI IPS INLET 283.1 286.5 10,000 20 9228.2 7883.2 6633.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
51 P P-48 J-28 J-29 271.82 283.1 3,417 20 9228.2 7883.2 6633.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
52 P P-49 J-28 J-30 271.82 258.76 2,261 20 2669.6 2300 1980.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
53 P P-50 J-30 J-31 258.76 253.41 1,821 20 1524.8 1311.2 1126.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
54 P P-51 J-30 J-32 258.76 273.78 3,838 20 1144.6 988.6 854 75 30 16500 10 50 10
55 P P-52 J-34 J-35 247.58 274.98 4,318 20 1081.8 924.2 787.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
56 P P-53(1) J-31 J-454 253.41 248.79 3,315 20 1081.8 924.2 787.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
57 P P-53(2) J-454 J-34 248.79 247.58 4,300 20 1081.8 924.2 787.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
58 P P-54 J-27 KESAIBAHL PROPOSED 267.16 315 3,163 20 818.4 699.2 596 75 30 16500 10 50 10
59 P P-55 J-32 KABIRIBAHAL PROPOSED 273.78 303 780 20 587 501.4 427.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
60 P P-56 J-32 BAURIGUDA PROPOSED 273.78 288 2,842 20 557.6 487.2 426.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
61 P P-57 J-35 BABUNIKITIMAL PROPOSED 274.98 302 59 20 555.2 474.2 404.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
62 P P-58(1) J-35 J-003 274.98 276.76 3,466 20 526.6 449.8 383.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
63 P P-58(2) J-003 J-36 276.76 290.15 1,109 20 526.6 449.8 383.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
64 P P-59 J-36 TUREI PROPOSED 290.15 323 1,043 20 526.6 449.8 383.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
65 P P-60 J-31 J-33 253.41 254.55 2,990 20 443.2 387.2 338.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
66 P P-61 J-33 ARDABAHAL PROPOSED 254.55 277 2,890 20 264.6 231 202.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
67 P P-62 J-33 ARDABAHL EXISTING (100 KL) 254.55 277.94 64 20 178.6 156 136.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
68 P P-63 NAUDIDHI IPS OUTLET J-37 286.5 289.64 388 20 9228.2 7883.2 6633.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
69 P P-64 J-37 J-38 289.64 311.93 3,021 20 8235.2 7034.8 5910.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
70 P P-65 J-38 J-42 311.93 348.24 4,408 20 8235.2 7034.8 5910.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
71 P P-66 J-42 J-43 348.24 375.07 961 20 7678.8 6559.4 5505.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
72 P P-67 J-44 J-45 308.58 298.31 992 20 7072 6041.2 5063.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
73 P P-68 J-43 J-44 375.07 308.58 2,845 20 7072 6041.2 5063.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
74 P P-69 J-45 J-46 IPS INLET 298.31 294.11 5,294 20 7049.2 6021.6 5047 75 30 16500 10 50 10
75 P P-70(2) J-46 IPS OUTLET J-48 294.11 271.86 1,394 20 7049.2 6021.6 5047 75 30 16500 10 50 10
76 P P-71 J-48 J-49 271.86 268.22 2,792 20 4226.8 3610.6 2991.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
77 P P-72 J-49 J-50 268.22 264.22 1750 20 3591 3067.6 2528.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
78 P P-73 J-50 J-52 264.22 271.74 3226 20 3591 3067.6 2528.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
79 P P-74(1) J-55 J-96 293.14 315.9 1,888 20 2893.8 2472 2107.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
80 P P-75 J-52 J-55 271.74 293.14 2,462 20 2893.8 2472 2107.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
81 P P-76 J-48 J-51 271.86 255.02 4,025 20 2822.4 2411.2 2055.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
82 P P-77 J-51 J-53 255.02 248.61 2,395 20 2038.8 1741.4 1484.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
83 P P-78 J-53 J-56 248.61 253.81 4,187 20 1396.8 1193.4 1017.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
84 P P-79 J-56 J-58 253.81 273.02 3,259 20 1396.8 1193.4 1017.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
85 P P-80 J-58 GOVINDPUR PROPOSED 273.02 300 450 20 1396.8 1193.4 1017.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
86 P P-81 J-39 J-40 294.29 286.18 541 20 993 848.4 723 75 30 16500 10 50 10
87 P P-82 J-37 J-39 289.64 294.29 2,898 20 993 848.4 723 75 30 16500 10 50 10
88 P P-83 J-47 JARABAGA PROPOSED 310.91 351 1,430 20 993 848.4 723 75 30 16500 10 50 10
89 P P-84 J-40 J-41 286.18 290.5 2944 20 993 848.4 723 75 30 16500 10 50 10
90 P P-85 J-41 J-47 290.5 310.91 1000 20 993 848.4 723 75 30 16500 10 50 10
91 P P-86 J-54 J-57 254.6 262.45 1,558 20 783.8 669.6 570.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
92 P P-87(1) J-51 J-455 255.02 254.93 1,500 20 783.8 669.6 570.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
93 P P-87(2) J-455 J-54 254.93 254.6 3,340 20 783.8 669.6 570.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
94 P P-88 J-57 KUTARIMAL PROPOSED 262.45 305 760 20 783.8 669.6 570.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
95 P P-89 J-52 PINDATATHAR PROPOSED 271.74 325 2,483 20 697.2 595.6 421.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
96 P P-90 J-53 BAUNSALGA PROPOSED 248.61 278 450 20 642 548.2 467.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
97 P P-91 J-49 UCHAKAPAT PROPOSED 268.22 300 519 20 635.8 543 463 75 30 16500 10 50 10
98 P P-92 J-43 RANGIATIKIRA PROPOSED 375.07 395 64 20 606.8 518.2 441.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
99 P P-93 J-42 LARIAPALI PROPOSED 348.24 375 61 20 556.4 475.4 405.2 75 30 16500 10 50 10
100 P P-94 J-45 RANGIATIKIRA EXISTING (350.1) GARDEGA 298.31 374.08 5,847 20 22.8 19.6 16.6 75 30 16500 10 50 10
101 P P-96 J-95 J-96 315.54 315.9 39 20 862.4 736.6 628 75 30 16500 10 50 10
102 P P-97 J-96 J-97 315.9 309.38 1,726 20 1422.4 1215.2 1035.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
103 P P-98(2) J-456 J-98 309.65 324.72 1,929 20 901.6 770.2 656.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
104 P P-99 J-98 KINABAGA PROPOSED 324.72 364 2,095 20 901.6 770.2 656.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
105 P P-100 J-95 GARPOSH PROPOSED 315.54 343 66 20 862.4 736.6 628 75 30 16500 10 50 10
106 P P-101(1) J-96 J-450 315.9 322.81 6,960 20 608.8 520 443.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
107 P P-101(2) J-450 SAGARA PROPOSED 322.81 333 1,700 20 608.8 520 443.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
108 P P-102 J-97 GHANSARA BOOSTER INLET 309.38 309.72 482 20 1422.4 1215.2 1035.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
109 P P-103 J-99 J-100 331.92 417.13 434 20 520.8 445 379.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
110 P P-104 J-100 RABAGA PROPOSED 417.13 474.77 3,683 20 520.8 445 379.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
111 P P-105(1) GHANSARA BOOSTER OUTLET J-456 309.72 309.65 10 20 1422.6 1215.2 1035.8 75 30 16500 10 50 10
112 P P-105(2) J-456 J-99 309.65 331.92 8,975 20 520.8 445.00 379.4 75 30 16500 10 50 10
INPUT PIPE No.
5 P-5
Rising Main - Clear Water Design
DESIGN FOR ECONOMIC SIZE OF RAW WATER RISING MAIN - FROM Intake Well to WTP
1 Water Supply Scheme to be pumped 250 Input Data for Pipe
Year Discharge
Initial 2024 3.035 MLD Dia of pipe (mm) Class Base Price/m Wt. Quantity Labor Rate Sum CP+OH Total Cost
Intermediate 2039 3.480 MLD
Ultimate 2054 3.995 MLD a b c=bx366 d=a+c e=15% of d f=d+e
100 DI K-9 1164.58 0.163 59.66 1224.24 183.64 1407.87
2 Length of Rising main 1,710 meter 150 DI K-9 1687.63 0.248 90.77 1778.40 266.76 2045.16
3 Static head including residual head 0.00 meter 200 DI K-9 2171.00 0.333 121.88 2292.88 343.93 2636.81
4 Design Period 30 Years 250 DI K-9 2892.01 0.438 160.31 3052.32 457.85 3510.17
5 Combined efficiency of Pumping set 75 % 300 DI K-9 3659.48 0.555 203.13 3862.61 579.39 4442.00
6 Cost of Pumping Unit Rs. 16500 Per KW 350 DI K-9 4474.58 0.693 253.64 4728.22 709.23 5437.45
7 Interest rate of Capitalisation Factor 10 % 400 DI K-9 5340.58 0.828 303.05 5643.63 846.54 6490.17
450 DI K-9 6327.03 0.988 361.61 6688.64 1003.30 7691.93
8 C Value of Pipe 140 500 DI K-9 7462.77 1.150 420.90 7883.67 1182.55 9066.22
9 Class DI K-9 600 DI K-9 9596.19 1.520 556.32 10152.51 1522.88 11675.39
10 Life of electrical motor & Pump 15 Years 700 DI K-9 12651.84 1.938 709.31 13361.15 2004.17 15365.32
11 Energy charges 5 Rs.per unit 750 DI K-9 14220.06 2.175 796.05 15016.11 2252.42 17268.53
12 Hours of Pumping Average 800 DI K-9 15679.97 2.408 881.33 16561.30 2484.19 19045.49
20 Hours 900 DI K-9 18891.57 2.928 1071.65 19963.22 2994.48 22957.70
13 Stand by KW 1st Stage 50.00% % 1000 DI K-9 22809.83 3.498 1280.27 24090.10 3613.51 27703.61
14 Stand by KW 2nd Stage 50.00% % 1100 DI K-9 27276.72 3.498 1280.27 28556.99 4283.55 32840.54
1200 DI K-9 31211.69 3.498 1280.27 32491.96 4873.79 37365.75
Solution

1st 15 year 2nd15 years


1) Discharge at installation MLD 3.035 3.4802 Mld
2) Discharge at the end of 15 years 3.4802 3.995 Mld
3) Average discharge (MLD) 3.2576 3.7376 Mld
4) Hours of pumping for discharge at the end of 15 years 20 20 hrs
5) Average hours for pumping for average discharge 18.42 18.54 hrs
Discharge in pumping hours 4.18 4.79 Mld
Discharge in pumping in m3/sec 0.0483 0.0555 m3/sec
6) KW required 0.63 H1 0.73 H2
7) Annual cost of electrical energy 33638.60 KW1 33857.75 KW2
= 21254.37 H1 24557.32 H2
Table1 showing velocity and loss of head for different pipe size
Sr no Pipe size in Frictional head loss per 1000 Velocity in m/sec 1st stage flow 2nd stage flow
mm meter
1st stage flow 2nd stage flow 1st stage 2nd stage flow Frictional loss Other lossses Total losses H1 Frictional Other lossses (in mt.) Total losses H1 including
flow (in mt.) including static head loss static head
0.0483 0.0555 10% 0 10% 0%
m3/s m3/s (in mt.) of friction loss (in mt.) (in mt.) of friction loss (in mt.)
1 100 307.05 396.43 6.15 7.06 525.05 52.51 577.56 677.89 67.79 745.68
2 150 42.62 55.02 2.74 3.14 72.87 7.29 80.16 94.09 9.41 103.49
3 200 10.50 13.55 1.54 1.77 17.95 1.80 19.75 23.18 2.32 25.49
4 250 3.54 4.57 0.98 1.13 6.05 0.61 6.66 7.82 0.78 8.60
5 300 1.46 1.88 0.68 0.78 2.49 0.25 2.74 3.22 0.32 3.54
6 350 0.69 0.89 0.50 0.58 1.18 0.12 1.29 1.52 0.15 1.67
7 400 0.36 0.46 0.38 0.44 0.61 0.06 0.68 0.79 0.08 0.87
8 450 0.20 0.26 0.30 0.35 0.35 0.03 0.38 0.45 0.04 0.49
9 500 0.12 0.16 0.25 0.28 0.21 0.02 0.23 0.27 0.03 0.29
10 600 0.05 0.06 0.17 0.20 0.09 0.01 0.09 0.11 0.01 0.12
11 700 0.02 0.03 0.13 0.14 0.04 0.00 0.04 0.05 0.01 0.06
12 750 0.02 0.02 0.11 0.13 0.03 0.00 0.03 0.04 0.00 0.04
13 800 0.01 0.02 0.10 0.11 0.02 0.00 0.02 0.03 0.00 0.03
14 900 0.01 0.01 0.08 0.09 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.02 0.00 0.02
14 1000 0.00 0.01 0.06 0.07 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.01 0.00 0.01
TABLE 2 SHOWING KILOWATTS REQUIRED AND COST OF PUMP SETS FOR DIFFERENT PIPE SIZES
Sr no Pipe size in 1st stage flow 2nd stage flow
mm H1 total head Kw required Cost of H2 total head Kw required with Cost of Pump
loss (in m) with stand by Pump ( loss (in m) stand by ( Rs. In
Rs. In thousand)
thousand)
1 100 577.56 547.39 9032 745.68 811.27 13386
2 150 80.16 75.97 1254 103.49 112.60 1858
3 200 19.75 18.71 309 25.49 27.74 458
4 250 6.66 6.31 104 8.60 9.35 154
5 300 2.74 2.60 43 3.54 3.85 64
6 350 1.29 1.23 20 1.67 1.82 30
7 400 0.68 0.64 11 0.87 0.95 16
8 450 0.38 0.36 6 0.49 0.53 9
9 500 0.23 0.22 4 0.29 0.32 5
10 600 0.09 0.09 1 0.12 0.13 2
11 700 0.04 0.04 1 0.06 0.06 1
12 750 0.03 0.03 0 0.04 0.04 1
13 800 0.02 0.02 0 0.03 0.03 1
14 900 0.01 0.01 0 0.02 0.02 0
15 1000 0.01 0.01 0 0.01 0.01 0
G
r
a
n
TABLE 3 SHOWING COMPARATIVE STATEMENT OF OVER ALL COST STRUCTURE OF PUMPING MAIN FOR DIFF. PIPE SIZES 1
d
0
Sr no Pipe size in Total head in (m) Cost of Cost of Pump Annual cost of Energy charges Total Cost of Pump Annual cost of Energy Initial capital Grand total m
mm Pipeline of energy charges capitalized capitalized energy charges investment for of T
.
length mts. cost charges capitalized pumpset & capitalized o
Total Cost annual cost for 30 t
electrical years a
charges l

1st stage 2nd stage 1710 1710 :


1 100 577.56 745.68 1991 2408 9032 12276 93372 104812 13386 18312 139283 36548 141360
2 150 80.16 103.49 2886 3498 1254 1704 12961 17712 1858 2542 19335 5073 22786
3 200 19.75 25.49 3712 4509 309 420 3195 8012 458 626 4761 1249 9262
4 250 6.66 8.60 4945 6003 104 142 1080 7187 154 211 1605 421 7608
5 300 2.74 3.54 6258 7596 43 58 441 8080 64 87 662 174 8254
6 350 1.29 1.67 7652 9299 20 27 205 9525 30 41 312 82 9606
7 400 0.68 0.87 9132 11099 11 14 106 11216 16 21 160 42 11258
8 450 0.38 0.49 10819 13154 6 8 61 13221 9 12 91 24 13245
9 500 0.23 0.29 12761 15504 4 5 38 15546 5 7 53 14 15560
10 600 0.09 0.12 16409 19965 1 2 15 19982 2 3 23 6 19988
11 700 0.04 0.06 21635 26275 1 1 8 26283 1 1 8 2 26285
12 750 0.03 0.04 24316 29530 0 1 8 29538 1 1 8 2 29540
13 800 0.02 0.03 26813 32568 0 0 0 32568 1 1 8 2 32570
14 900 0.01 0.02 32305 39258 0 0 0 39258 0 0 0 0 39258
15 1000 0.01 0.01 39005 47374 0 0 0 47374 0 0 0 0 47374

Table 3 shows that the most economical size of Main is 250 mm costing Capitalised Rs. 7608360
Dia of economical size of rising main 250 mm

DESIGN FOR ECONOMIC SIZE OF PUMPING MAIN 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 600 700 750 800 900 1000

3.0E+6
Total Cost

2.0E+6
1.0E+6
0.0E+0
100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 600 700 750 800 900 1000
Pipe Dia in mm
sts od
P-1 300 300
P-2 300 300
P-3 300 300
P-4 300 250
P-5 250 250
P-6 250 250
P-7 250 250
P-8 250 250
P-9 250 200
P-10 200 200
P-11 200 200
P-12 200 200
P-13 200 200
P-14 150 150
P-15 150 150
P-16 100 100
P-17 100 100
P-18 100 100
P-19 100 100
P-20 100 100
P-21 100 100
P-22 100 100
P-23 100 100
P-24 100 100
P-25 100 100
P-26 100 100
P-27 100 100
P-28 100 100
P-29 100 100
P-30 200 200
P-31 150 150
P-32 150 150
P-33 150 150
P-34 150 150
P-35 150 150
P-36 150 150
P-37 100 100
P-38 100 100
P-39(1) 100 100
P-39(2)(1) 100 100
P-39(2)(2) 100 100
P-40(1) 100 100
P-40(2) 100 100
P-41 100 100
P-42 100 100
P-43 100 100
P-44 100 100
P-45 450 400
P-46 400 400
P-47 400 350
P-48 400 350
P-49 200 200
P-50 200 150
P-51 150 150
P-52 150 150
P-53(1) 150 150
P-53(2) 150 150
P-54 150 150
P-55 100 100
P-56 100 100
P-57 100 100
P-58(1) 100 100
P-58(2) 100 100
P-59 100 100
P-60 100 100
P-61 100 100
P-62 100 100
P-63 400 350
P-64 350 350
P-65 350 350
P-66 350 350
P-67 350 350
P-68 350 300
P-69 350 300
P-70(2) 350 300
P-71 250 250
P-72 250 250
P-73 250 250
P-74(1) 200 200
P-75 200 200
P-76 200 200
P-77 200 200
P-78 150 150
P-79 150 150
P-80 150 150
P-81 150 150
P-82 150 150
P-83 150 150
P-84 150 150
P-85 150 150
P-86 150 150
P-87(1) 150 150
P-87(2) 150 150
P-88 150 150
P-89 100 100
P-90 100 100
P-91 100 100
P-92 100 100
P-93 100 100
P-94 100 100
P-96 150 150
P-97 150 150
P-98(2) 150 150
P-99 150 150
P-100 150 150
P-101(1) 100 100
P-101(2) 100 100
P-102 150 150
P-103 100 100
P-104 100 100
P-105(1) 150 150
P-105(2) 100 100
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
Hmax=Cvo/g
Hmax= Max pressure rise in the closed conduit
C= Velocity of pressure wave travel in m/sec
g= Acceleration due to gravity
V0= Normal velocity in pipeline

C=1425/(1+(kd/Ect))^0.5

K= Bulk modulus of water kg/sqm 2.07x10^8


d= Diameter of pipe in mtr
Ct=Wall thickness of pipe in mtr
E= Modulus pf Elasticity of pipe material in kg/sqm
E for different pipe matewreial
DI 1.7x10^10
CI 7.5x10^9
Steel 2.1x10^10
917.297762478486
WATER HAMMER CALCULATIONS

Sl No Pipe dia Bulk Class of pipe Modulus of elasticity Wall Velocity of Nominal
(d) in mm modulus of of pipe material (E) thickness pressure velocity in
water (k) in in (kg/m2) (Ct) in mm wave (C) in m/sec
(kg/m2) m/sec

1 150 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 10 1198.37 6.29


2 200 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 11 1162.80 3.54
3 250 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 12 1135.47 2.26
4 300 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 13 1113.78 1.57
5 350 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 14 1096.15 1.16
6 400 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 15 1081.53 0.88
7 450 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 16 1069.21 0.70

1 150 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 5.9 1243.98 6.29


2 200 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 6.3 1210.17 3.54
3 250 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 6.8 1183.00 0.23
4 300 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 7.2 1160.67 0.92
5 350 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 7.7 1141.98 1.18
6 400 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 8.1 1126.10 0.88
7 450 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 8.5 1112.44 1.08
8 500 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 9.0 1100.57 1.21
9 600 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 9.9 1080.92 0.70
10 700 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 10.8 1065.33 0.70
11 750 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 11.3 1058.68 0.70
12 800 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 11.7 1052.65 1.45
13 900 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 12.6 1042.13 0.70
14 1000 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 13.5 1033.27 0.70

1.22E-02
Surge Normal Total Total 2L/C
pressure Pressure Pressure Pressure
(Hmax) in m in m in m in Kg/cm2

768.37 1946 2714 271.4


419.60 528 948 94.8
261.59 216 478 47.8
178.25 121 299 29.9
129.62 86 216 21.6
97.02 71 168 16.8
76.29 64 140 14.0

797.62 1464 2262 226.2


436.70 407 844 84.4
27.74 175 203 20.3
108.85 104 213 21.3
137.36 350 487 48.7
101.02 67 168 16.8
122.47 104.14 227 22.7
135.75 38.75 174 17.4
77.13 63 140 14.0
76.02 64 140 14.0
75.54 65 141 14.1
155.59 35 191 19.1 1.3869773
74.36 67 141 14.1
73.73 68 142 14.2
WATER HAMMER CALCULATIONS

Sl No Pipe dia Bulk Class of pipe Modulus of Wall Velocity of Nominal Surge
(d) in mm modulus of elasticity of thickness pressure velocity in pressure
water (k) in pipe material (Ct) in mm wave (C) in m/sec (Hmax) in m
(kg/m2) (E) in (kg/m2) m/sec

1 150 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 10 1198.37 6.29 768.37


2 200 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 11 1162.80 3.54 419.60
3 250 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 12 1135.47 2.26 261.59
4 300 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 13 1113.78 1.57 178.25
5 350 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 14 1096.15 1.16 129.62
6 400 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 15 1081.53 0.88 97.02
7 450 2.07E+08 CI-B 7.50E+09 16 1069.21 0.70 76.29

1 150 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 5.9 1243.98 6.29 797.62


2 200 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 6.3 1210.17 3.54 436.70
3 223.4 2.07E+08 hdpe 9.00E+07 13.3 226.35 0.23 5.31
4 300 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 7.2 1160.67 1.57 185.75
5 350 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 7.7 1141.98 1.18 137.36
6 400 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 8.1 1126.10 0.88 101.02
7 450 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 8.5 1112.44 1.30 147.42
8 500 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 9.0 1100.57 1.16 130.14
9 600 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 9.9 1080.92 0.70 77.13
10 700 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 10.8 1065.33 0.70 76.02
11 750 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 11.3 1058.68 0.70 75.54
12 800 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 11.7 1052.65 1.45 155.59
13 900 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 12.6 1042.13 0.70 74.36
14 1000 2.07E+08 DI-K9 1.70E+10 13.5 1033.27 0.70 73.73
Normal Total Total 2L/C
Pressure Pressure Pressure
in m in m in Kg/cm2

1946 2714 271.4


528 948 94.8
216 478 47.8
121 299 29.9
86 216 21.6
71 168 16.8
64 140 14.0

1464 2262 226.2


407 844 84.4
51 56 5.6
104 290 29.0
350 487 48.7
67 168 16.8
101.53 249 24.9
140 270 27.0
63 140 14.0
64 140 14.0
65 141 14.1
35 191 19.1 1.3869773
67 141 14.1
68 142 14.2

You might also like