Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Auditing Theory and Practices
Auditing Theory and Practices
Auditing Theory and Practices
Economic decisions in every society must be based upon the information available at the
time the decision is made. For example, the decision of a bank to make a loan to a business is
based upon previous financial relationships with that business, the financial condition of the
company as reflected by its financial statements and other factors.
If decisions are to be consistent with the intention of the decision makers, the information used in
the decision process must be reliable. Unreliable information can cause inefficient use of resources
to the detriment of the society and to the decision makers themselves
In the lending decision example, assume that the barfly makes the loan on the basis of misleading
financial statements and the borrower Company is ultimately unable to repay. As a result the bank
has lost both the principal and the interest. In addition, another company that could have used the
funds effectively was deprived of the money. As society become more complex, there is an
increased likelihood that unreliable information will be provided to decision makers. There are
several reasons for this: remoteness of information, voluminous data and the existence of complex
exchange transactions
As a means of overcoming the problem of unreliable information, the decision-maker must
develop a method of assuring him that the information is sufficiently reliable for these decisions.
In doing this he must weigh the cost of obtaining more reliable information against the expected
benefits
A common way to obtain such reliable information is to have some type of verification (audit)
performed by independent persons. The audited information is then used in the decision making
process on the assumption that it is reasonably complete, accurate and unbiased.
Origin term audit is derived from Latin word ‘audire’ which means to hear. Auditing is as old as
accounting. It was used in all ancient countries such as Greece, Egypt, Rome, U.K, India. The
main objective of auditing is to ascertain the accounts were true and fair and to detect and prevent
errors and frauds. The International Accounting Standard Committee and the Accounting Standard
Board of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India have developed standards accounting and
auditing practices to guide the accountants and auditors in the day to day work
Functions
1. Study The Accounting System :- It is the basic function of auditing. In order to determine the
nature, timing and extent of the audit procedures auditor should study the accounting system.
2. Internal Control System :- It is a process which determines that management policies are carried
out according the accounting principles. This system is very useful to safeguard the interest of the
enterprise. The auditor determines the effectiveness of this system.
3. Vouching :- This function is essential to determine the accuracy of accounting record. Through
audit those documents can be checked which support and prove the business transactions. All
entries in books of accounts are made on the basis of relevant vouchers.
4. Verification Of Assets :- It is the function of auditing that it should verify the assets of the
business. It is concerned with the determination of value, ownership and possession of business
asset. The auditor can check the existence of asset.
5. Legal Requirement :- It is the function of auditing to verify that statements are prepared under
the legal requirements or not. There are various laws like company and income tax ordinance
which are introduced by the govt.
6. Liabilities Verification :- The liabilities of the business can be verified from the books of
accounts. The auditor can write a letter to the creditors for the verification of liabilities. The auditor
must receive the certificate from the management in this regard.
7. Capital And Revenue :- Auditing should make difference between capital and revenue items.
The capital items are compared to note the financial position of the business. The revenue items
are compared to determine the income. The income and expenses related to many years can be
divided in current and coming year.
8. Valuation Of Liabilities :- Through auditing value of liabilities can be checked from the books
of accounts and other papers. The auditor can also confirm the value from outside sources. The
value of liabilities is given in the balance sheet by the management but it is the function of auditing
which confirms this value.
9. Valuation Of Assets :- The management gives the value of assets and auditor can apply the
accounting principles to assess the value of assets. The auditor critically examines and takes help
from the expert.
10. Reporting: - Auditing important function is reporting. An auditor is an independent person,
and it is his duty to submit his report in writing. If he is satisfied, he can present clean report
otherwise he can give qualified report
FAIR VIEW:
An audit of accounts by an independent expert assures the outside users that the accounts
are proper and reliable. The outsiders can rely on the accounts if the auditor reports that the
accounts are true and fair. The accounts are said to be true and fair:
Merits
Assurance of true and fair accounts: An audit provides an assurance to the investors, government,
lenders, creditors, owners, management etc. That the final account presented shows the true and
fair picture of the profit and losses and financial position of the concern
True and fair balance sheet: The user of final accounts can be sure that the assets and liabilities
disclose true and fair view of financial position of the concern, it’s neither more nor less, and it’s
free from window dressing or secret reserve.
True and fair profit and loss account: The user of final accounts should be sure that the profit and
loss account show true amount of profit or less as it is. Tally with books of accounts: The audited
final accounts should tally with the books of accounts of the concern. So it can be easy to calculate
the taxable income without going through all the transactions. As per law: The audited final
accounts should be prepared as per the rules and guidelines laid down by law. Disclose all material
facts: The audited final accounts should disclose all material facts, thus users can rely on them for
making useful decisions of lending, investing etc.
Detection of errors and frauds: It is assumed that the audited final accounts are free from errors
and frauds, the auditor with his expertise knowledge would detect the errors and fraud so as to
show the true figure of final accounts. Moral check on employees: Auditing techniques such as
verification, vouching of cash, assets, stock etc. act as a moral check on the employees, this forces
them to keep the accounts up-todate and free from errors and frauds.
Advice to concern: Auditor can also advise the client about internal control, taxation, finance,
accounting system etc.
Demerits
All transactions cannot be checked: It is not possible for an auditor to check each and every
transaction; he has to check them on sample basis
Evidence is not conclusive: Audit evidence is not conclusive in nature the confirmation of debtors
is not conclusive evidence that all amount will be collected, the conclusions are persuasive rather
than conclusive.
Not easy to detect some frauds: It’s not easy for an auditor to detect the deeply laid frauds which
involves acts designed to conceal them such as forgery, false explanation, and not recording
transaction and so on.
Audit cannot assure about profitability or efficiency of management: Even though the accounts are
audited it doesn’t mean that the user can take granted the future profitability or prospects of
concern as audit don’t comment on efficiency of the management. Rely on experts: The auditor
has to rely on experts like lawyers, engineers, valuers etc. for estimation of contingent liability and
valuation of fixed assets
Latest Trends in audit
The AC (Audit Committee) plays a critical role in helping organizations navigate today’s
challenging business environment, providing guidance and oversight on a wide range of complex
issues. This means audit committees must focus on ensuring the right skills are at the table and
that all members continue to expand their knowledge in key areas. Encouragingly, more than 70
percent of respondents indicated that their board assesses its skills on an annual basis with an eye
to facing evolving challenges.
1. Talent and human capital: So much data gathering work is being automated now in internal
audit and finance. Talent-wise, that means internal audit will be looking for people who are more
astute on the levels of data and information analysis – people who can use data strategically to help
the organization realize its vision and goals. We’re really seeing the emergence of a different
capability in internal audit, where it’s moving from a ‘doing’ function to a ‘leading/ influencing’
function.
2. Technology and cyber security: Businesses really need to think harder about technology
infrastructure, as it appears to be moving from one model to another model. Organizations are
unsure what their capital investment should look like going forward, as a pay-as-you go approach
is becoming more practical. This is an area that is changing at a tremendous rate and it just isn’t
as well understood as it should be. For those that get it right, it could create significant innovation
differentiation.
3. Disruption to business models: It is clear that the innovation agenda will continue to be a core
focus for organizations, whether to optimize cost, differentiate the customer experience or grow
new products and services. It is critical to move past the buzzwords and for ACs to truly understand
the existing and future risks and opportunities posed through innovation disruption, which is
occurring at an exponential rate.
4. Evolving regulatory landscape: In our globalized economy, organizations should start thinking
not just about complying with regulations in other countries, but about whether their operations in
those countries are living up to home country standards and regulations. This is particularly
relevant given the rapid rise of social media and its use to highlight what individuals believe to be
inappropriate corporate behaviour. Companies have a social responsibility to think about these
issues, and their brand can be damaged if they are not properly addressed.
5. Political and economic uncertainty: For ACs to address risk issues around uncertainty – whether
political or economic – they need access to, and engagement with, leading insights. Those insights
can come from a variety of places: subject matter experts, experience gleaned from other boards,
or external advisors who can assess the business and understand how the broad range of
uncertainty-based risks applies.
6. Changing reporting expectations: The importance of operational and non-financial metrics will
only continue to increase. As a result, the finance function’s responsibilities will expand beyond
traditional financial reporting and controls. Audit committees should ensure their finance function
is taking the full range of externally reported KPIs(Key Performance Indicators) into account and
leveraging them to give external stakeholders more assurance around the accuracy of all reports.
7. Environment and climate change: Many of Canada’s leading industry sectors could well suffer
negative consequences from climate change if they don’t take action. The cost of recent
catastrophic weather events and the potential negative impact of climate change on business
models and asset valuations are increasingly driving home this realization. To play an effective
role, ACs have a responsibility to understand and ensure that management has addressed the
potentially material impacts of climate change and related disclosure requirements.
2. Subsidiary Objective
These are such objectives which are set up to help in attaining primary objectives. They are
as follows:
(A) Detection and prevention of errors Errors are those mistakes which are committed due to
carelessness or negligence or lack of knowledge or without having vested interest. Errors may be
committed without or with any vested interest. So, they are to be checked carefully. Errors are of’
various types. Some of them are:
1.Errors of Accounting principle- When principles of book keeping and accountancy are not
followed in recording of business transactions ,it is known as error of principle.
• Wrong posting of income transaction
• Wrong posting of expenditure
• Wrong allocation of expenditure between capital and revenue. Revenue expenditure may be
treated as capital expenditure and vice-versa. Such errors are not disclosed in trial balance, debit
and credit sides of transactions are same. Such errors can be detected by thorough checking of
each and every transaction. Error of principle affect the reliability of financial statement. it is an
accounting mistake in which entry is recorded in the incorrect account, the value recorded was the
correct but placed incorrectly.
2. Errors of omission- When a transaction is omitted fully or partly from books of accounts, such
type of errors are known as error of omission. Usually it arises due to mistake of clerk. • Omission
of purchases from purchases book
• Omission of sales from sales book
• Omitting the entry for charging depreciation in the books.
• Rent or interest paid for 11 months, the remaining amount which is unpaid or outstanding has
not been entered in the books.
3. Errors of commission- When the entries made in the books of original entry or ledger are
incorrect wholly or partly, such are called error of commission. Usually these error arise due to
negligence in recording of some business transactions.
➢ Ex:-wrong recording in the books of original entry wholly or partly. Goods purchased for
Rs.10,000 recorded in purchases book as Rs.1000
➢ Wrong totaling of original entry, while totaling sales day book or purchase day book mistake
is made in the total sales. Sales day book is totaled Rs.100 short and posted to ledger. This error
will affect trial balance, the credit side total will be short by Rs.100. it will lower the profit by
Rs.100.
➢ Wrong subsidiary book used for recording a transaction . For ex:-credit sales to x and co. Were
recorded in purchase day book or credit purchases to y and co. were recorded in sales day book.
4. Compensating errors- When an error offsets the effect of another error, such error is known as
compensating error. These errors don’t affect trial balance. Sometimes under casting of one
account is compensated by over casting of another account, such as ‘X’ a/c is under totaled by
Rs.100 and’ Y’ a/c is over totaled by Rs.100.
5. Errors of Duplication- When a transaction is recorded twice and also posted twice in the ledger.
Such an error will not affect trial balance. It is more difficult to locate such errors. Only thorough
checking and comparing of vouchers with entries in the books. If two entries on the same side are
appearing with the same amount.
(B) Detection and Prevention of frauds
Frauds are those mistakes which are committed knowingly with some vested interest in the
direction of top level management. Management commits frauds to deceive tax, to show the
effectiveness of management, to get more commission, to sell a share in the market or to maintain
the market price of share etc. Detection of fraud is the main job of an auditor. Such frauds are as
follows:
1. Misappropriation of cash- Misappropriation of cash is done by theft of cash receipts, petty cash,
cheques, negotiable instruments, showing fictitious (false, fake) payments to workers, creditors,
purchases etc; misappropriation of cash is very easy. With the increase in size of business, the
opportunities of committing fraud also increase because the owners of the business have no direct
control over receipts and payments of cash.
MEANING OF AUDITING:
Auditing is the process of examining and evaluating financial information, transactions,
systems, and processes of an organization to ensure accuracy, compliance with relevant laws and
regulations, and adherence to internal policies and procedures. The primary purpose of auditing is
to provide an independent and objective assessment of an entity's financial statements and other
information.
Here are some key aspects and objectives of auditing:
• Financial Auditing: This involves the examination of an organization's financial
statements and related transactions to ensure they present a true and fair view of the entity's
financial position and performance. Financial audits are typically conducted by external
auditors.
• Compliance Auditing: This type of audit focuses on verifying whether an organization
adheres to applicable laws, regulations, and internal policies. Compliance audits help
ensure that the company is operating within the legal framework and following established
guidelines.
• Operational Auditing: This type of audit assesses the efficiency and effectiveness of an
organization's internal processes and operations. It aims to identify areas for improvement
in terms of productivity, cost-effectiveness, and risk management.
• Information Systems (IS) Auditing: IS auditors examine the controls and security
measures in an organization's information systems to ensure the confidentiality, integrity,
and availability of data. This is crucial in the digital age, where information technology
plays a significant role in business operations.
• Internal Auditing: Internal auditors are employed by the organization to provide
independent and objective evaluations of its activities. They examine various aspects,
including financial records, internal controls, and risk management, to help improve overall
organizational effectiveness.
Auditing is essential for maintaining the trust of stakeholders, such as investors, regulators, and
the public. It adds credibility to financial information and ensures that organizations operate
ethically and in compliance with relevant standards
The need for auditing arises from several important reasons, and it serves various stakeholders
in the business environment. Here are some key reasons why auditing is essential:
• Reliability of Financial Information:
o Auditing provides assurance regarding the accuracy and reliability of financial
information presented in an organization's financial statements. This is crucial for
stakeholders, such as investors, creditors, and the public, who rely on this
information to make informed decisions.
• Stakeholder Confidence:
o Audits enhance stakeholder confidence by ensuring that the financial statements
are free from material misstatements and fraud. Trustworthy financial information
promotes confidence among investors, creditors, employees, and other
stakeholders, contributing to a healthy business environment.
• Compliance with Laws and Regulations:
o Auditing helps organizations ensure compliance with applicable laws, regulations,
and industry standards. This is particularly important in industries with strict
regulatory requirements, as non-compliance can lead to legal consequences,
financial penalties, and damage to the organization's reputation.
• Risk Management:
o Auditors assess an organization's internal controls and risk management processes.
Identifying and addressing weaknesses in these areas helps mitigate risks related to
financial mismanagement, fraud, and operational inefficiencies.
• Prevention and Detection of Fraud:
o Auditors play a crucial role in detecting and preventing fraud within an
organization. Through their examination of financial records and internal controls,
auditors can identify irregularities and take steps to prevent fraudulent activities,
safeguarding the organization's assets and interests.
• Corporate Governance:
o Auditing contributes to good corporate governance by ensuring transparency and
accountability. It helps align the interests of management with those of shareholders
and ensures that decision-makers act in the best interests of the organization and its
stakeholders.
• Decision-Making Support:
o Reliable financial information provided through auditing supports effective
decision-making by management, investors, creditors, and other stakeholders.
Audits can uncover insights into the financial health and performance of an
organization, aiding in strategic planning and resource allocation.
• Investor Protection:
o Audits protect the interests of investors by providing an independent and objective
assessment of an organization's financial position. This is particularly important in
publicly traded companies where shareholders rely on accurate financial
information for investment decisions.
• Enhanced Business Credibility:
o An audited financial statement enhances the credibility of an organization in the
business community. It signals to stakeholders that the company is committed to
transparency and accountability, which can positively impact relationships with
customers, suppliers, and partners.
.
DEFINATION OF AUDITORS:
Definition 1.
PROF.L.R.Dicksee, “auditing is an examination of accounting records undertaken with a view to
establish whether they correctly and completely reflect the transactions of which they relate.”
2. R.K.Mautz,” auditing is concerned with the verification of accounting data determining the
accuracy and reliability of accounting statements and reports.”
MEANING OF AUDITORS:
An auditor is a professional who is responsible for conducting audits, which are systematic
examinations or reviews of financial information, records, systems, and processes within an
organization. The primary role of an auditor is to provide an independent and objective assessment
of the accuracy, completeness, and reliability of financial statements and other information.
Key aspects of the auditor's role include:
Independence:
Auditors are expected to be independent and unbiased. This independence is crucial to ensure that
the audit process is objective and that there is no conflict of interest that could compromise the
integrity of the audit findings.
Verification of Financial Information:
Auditors examine an organization's financial records, transactions, and systems to verify the
accuracy of financial statements. They assess whether the financial information presented fairly
represents the financial position and performance of the entity.
Compliance:
Auditors also evaluate whether the organization is complying with relevant laws, regulations, and
internal policies. This includes assessing whether financial reporting follows accounting standards
and that the organization operates within the legal framework.
Risk Assessment:
Auditors assess the internal controls and risk management processes of an organization. This
involves identifying areas where there may be a risk of material misstatement or fraud and
designing audit procedures to address those risks.
Reporting:
After completing the audit, the auditor provides a report that communicates their findings to
stakeholders. This report includes an opinion on the fairness of the financial statements and may
also highlight any significant issues or recommendations for improvement.
There are different types of auditors, including:
External Auditors:
These auditors are independent professionals hired by an organization to conduct an external audit.
External auditors provide an unbiased opinion on the accuracy of financial statements, and their
reports are often used by investors, regulators, and other external stakeholders.
Internal Auditors:
Internal auditors work within the organization and conduct internal audits. They focus on assessing
and improving internal controls, risk management, and operational processes. Internal auditors
provide valuable insights to management and the board of directors.
Government Auditors:
In the public sector, government auditors are responsible for reviewing the financial operations of
government agencies to ensure compliance with laws and regulations.
Forensic Auditors:
These auditors specialize in investigating and detecting financial fraud and irregularities. They
may be called upon to examine specific transactions or events that raise concerns about potential
misconduct.
DEFINATION OF AUDITORS:
An auditor is one who conducts an audit. Specifically, an auditor is a person or firm (usually
an accountant or accounting firm) that conducts a formal examination and verification of an
individual’s or organization’s records and accounts, finances, or compliance with a set of
standards.
The qualities and qualifications of an auditor can vary depending on the type of audit and the
specific requirements of the role. Here are some general qualities and qualifications that are
typically important for auditors:
Qualities of an Auditor:
• Integrity and Independence:
o Auditors must maintain high ethical standards and act with integrity. Independence
is crucial to ensure unbiased assessments and avoid conflicts of interest.
• Analytical Skills:
o Auditors need strong analytical abilities to evaluate complex financial information,
identify patterns, and detect anomalies during the audit process.
• Attention to Detail:
o The ability to pay meticulous attention to detail is essential for auditors, as they
review financial records and transactions to ensure accuracy and compliance.
• Communication Skills:
o Effective communication skills are important for auditors to convey audit findings
clearly in reports and to communicate with various stakeholders during the audit
process.
• Problem-Solving Skills:
o Auditors encounter challenges and discrepancies during audits. The ability to
analyze problems and develop effective solutions is a valuable quality.
• Professional Skepticism:
o Auditors should approach their work with a level of professional skepticism,
questioning information and being cautious about potential errors or fraud.
• Time Management:
o Auditors often work with deadlines. Efficient time management skills are crucial
to ensure that audits are completed within the specified time frame.
• Understanding of Business and Industry:
o A good auditor should have a solid understanding of the business or industry they
are auditing. This knowledge helps in assessing risks and understanding the context
of financial transactions.
Qualifications of an Auditor:
• Educational Background:
o A bachelor's degree in accounting, finance, or a related field is typically required.
Many auditors also pursue advanced degrees such as a Master of Accountancy or
an MBA.
• Professional Certification:
o Many auditors hold professional certifications such as Certified Public Accountant
(CPA), Chartered Accountant (CA), Certified Internal Auditor (CIA), or other
relevant certifications depending on the jurisdiction and industry.
• Audit Experience:
o Practical experience in auditing is valuable. Entry-level auditors may start with
junior or staff auditor positions and gain experience in various audit processes.
• Continuing Professional Education:
o Auditors often engage in ongoing professional development to stay informed about
changes in accounting standards, auditing practices, and relevant regulations.
• Understanding of Auditing Standards:
o Auditors need a thorough understanding of auditing standards and frameworks,
such as Generally Accepted Auditing Standards (GAAS) or International Standards
on Auditing (ISA).
• Legal and Regulatory Knowledge:
o Awareness of relevant laws and regulations impacting the industry and jurisdiction
is important for auditors to ensure compliance during audits.
• Technology Skills:
o With the increasing use of technology in auditing, familiarity with audit software,
data analytics, and information systems is becoming more important.
• Communication and Interpersonal Skills:
o Effective communication and interpersonal skills are crucial for auditors to interact
with clients, management, and other stakeholders.
APPOINTMENT OF AUDITORS:
The appointment of auditors is a significant decision for an organization, and it involves a
formal process that varies depending on the type of organization and its governing laws or
regulations. Here's a general outline of the steps involved in the appointment of auditors:
Selection Process:
Organizations typically have a process for selecting auditors. In publicly traded companies, this
process may involve recommendations from the audit committee or board of directors. In private
companies, the process may be managed by the owner or management.
Audit Committee Approval:
In larger organizations, especially those with publicly traded securities, the audit committee of the
board of directors often plays a crucial role in selecting and approving the appointment of auditors.
The audit committee is responsible for overseeing the financial reporting process and ensuring the
independence of the auditors.
Proposal and Bidding:
In some cases, organizations may request proposals or bids from different audit firms. This process
allows the organization to evaluate the qualifications, experience, and proposed fees of potential
auditors before making a decision.
Shareholder Approval:
In certain jurisdictions or under specific circumstances, the appointment of auditors may require
approval from the shareholders. This is common in publicly traded companies, where shareholders
may have a vote on the selection of auditors during the annual general meeting.
Engagement Letter:
Once the auditors are selected, an engagement letter is typically issued. The engagement letter
outlines the scope of the audit, the responsibilities of the auditors, and the terms of the engagement,
including fees. It is a formal agreement between the organization and the audit firm.
Independence Confirmation:
Auditors are required to confirm their independence from the organization being audited. This is
a critical aspect to ensure that the audit is conducted objectively and without any conflicts of
interest.
Communication with Outgoing Auditors (if applicable):
In cases where there is a change of auditors, the incoming auditors may communicate with the
outgoing auditors to facilitate the transition. This may include discussions on the organization's
accounting practices, internal controls, and other relevant information.
Notification to Regulatory Bodies:
Depending on the jurisdiction and the type of organization, there may be a requirement to notify
regulatory bodies or authorities about the appointment of auditors. This is often the case for
publicly traded companies.
Commencement of Audit:
After the formalities of the appointment are completed, the audit process begins. The auditors
conduct their examination of the organization's financial statements, internal controls, and other
relevant information.
TYPES OF AUDITS:
(A)On The Basis Of Scope:-
(1) Management audit
(2) Cost audit
(3) Tax audit
(4) Operational audit
(5) Proprietary or Performance audit
CONCLUSION:
In conclusion, auditing theory and practices play a pivotal role in ensuring the reliability,
transparency, and integrity of financial information within organizations. The field of auditing has
evolved to address the dynamic nature of business environments, incorporating theoretical
frameworks, professional standards, and practical methodologies to meet the challenges of an ever-
changing landscape.
Auditing serves as a critical mechanism for providing assurance to stakeholders, including
investors, creditors, and the public, regarding the accuracy and fairness of financial statements.
The adherence to established auditing standards, such as Generally Accepted Auditing Standards
(GAAS) or International Standards on Auditing (ISA), reinforces the credibility of audit processes
and reports.
Theoretical foundations in auditing emphasize principles such as independence, professional
skepticism, and due professional care. These principles guide auditors in conducting objective
assessments, promoting ethical conduct, and maintaining a high level of professional competence.
Practical aspects of auditing involve a systematic examination of financial records, internal
controls, and risk management processes. Auditors employ a variety of techniques, including
substantive testing, analytical procedures, and the assessment of internal controls, to gather
evidence and form conclusions.
Moreover, the diversity of audit types, such as financial audits, compliance audits, operational
audits, and information systems audits, highlights the adaptability of auditing practices to the
specific needs and risks of different organizations.
The audit report, as the culmination of the auditing process, communicates the auditor's opinion
on the fairness of financial statements and provides insights into any identified issues or
recommendations for improvement. This report serves as a crucial tool for stakeholders in making
informed decisions and maintaining trust in the financial reporting of organizations.
As the business landscape continues to evolve, auditing theory and practices must remain dynamic,
embracing technological advancements, addressing emerging risks, and responding to regulatory
changes. Continuous professional development, adherence to ethical standards, and a commitment
to delivering high-quality audits are essential elements for auditors to navigate the complexities of
the modern business world and uphold the integrity of financial information. In essence, auditing
theory and practices serve as cornerstones in fostering accountability, transparency, and
confidence in the global marketplace.