NEW - The Comet Short Paper

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

Introduction:

"The Comet," a gripping short tale written by the legendary W.E.B. Du Bois, is a powerful work

of science fiction literature. Set against the backdrop of a horrific occurrence, it looks on

everlasting themes such as humanity, race, and the tenacious human spirit in the face of

adversity. In this paper, I will argue that "The Comet" is an allegory, a literary device through

which Du Bois ingeniously crafts a tale about human endurance and togetherness in the face of

impending disaster.

In the world of "The Comet," cosmic powers combine to lead Earth into the path of an oncoming

comet that threatens all life. Du Bois clearly portrays humanity's ability to meet and overcome

hardship in this period of imminent tragedy, where social, racial, and economic barriers no

longer hold influence. As it approaches, the comet serves as a leveling force, eliminating the

barriers that have long divided people and rendering societal hierarchies and biases obsolete.

The importance of "The Comet" goes beyond its narrative; it is profoundly anchored in the

socio-historical setting in which it was created. Du Bois' essay, published in 1920 at a period of

racial unrest and injustice in the United States, serves as a subtle yet poignant commentary on the

socio-political scene of the time. Confronting the segregation, discrimination, and systematic

racism that plagued African Americans at the time, "The Comet" paints a vivid picture of a world

in which racial and privileged divides are wiped by the oncoming cosmic danger of destruction.

Readers are introduced to the major character, Jim, an African American man living in a racially

divided and cruel society, throughout the story. The approaching arrival of the comet, on the

other hand, serves as a catalyst for Jim's change. As he navigates the aftermath of the disaster, he

crosses paths with Julia, a white lady who was previously a symbol of societal divide. The novel
highlights the capacity of individuals to mature, break free from preconceived biases, and see

past the superficial barriers established by society via their unexpected alliance and common

desire for survival.

As reoccurring motifs in "The Comet," solidarity and collaboration emerge. Survivors of the

cosmic disaster are pushed into a post-apocalyptic world, where their combined efforts serve as

the foundation for constructing a new civilization. The teamwork of Jim and Julia represents a

larger cultural change toward unity and cooperation. Du Bois uses their story arc as a microcosm

of larger society development, showing humanity's ability to transcend its own biases and divides

when presented with an existential crisis.

While "The Comet" is a piece of science fiction, a genre known for its innovative explorations of

the future, its message transcends fiction. It invites readers to consider their own preconceptions,

biases, and divides, as well as how to overcome these obstacles when confronted with global

concerns such as climate change or public health crises. The novel offers a heartbreaking

reminder of the significance of unity and collaboration in the face of existential challenges,

asking readers to reconsider their own biases and differences, and ultimately applauding

humanity's unparalleled ability to unite for the greater good.

"The Comet" is more than just a work of fiction; it is a call to action, a rallying cry to band

together, to use our collective capabilities, and to nurture a more fair and inclusive society. Du

Bois reminds us via the visionary domain of science fiction that the human spirit can transcend

its constraints, establishing relationships that redefine our idea of unity and perseverance, even in

the darkest hours, when faced with tragedy and catastrophe.


Catastrophe as the Great Equalizer:

Readers are thrown into the chaos of an imminent cosmic tragedy in "The Comet," with Earth

rushing towards a huge cosmic invader, a comet of epic proportions. This disaster, however,

brings with it a different narrative aspect. It has no prejudice, no concern for society boundaries,

and it strikes without regard for race, class, or nationality. This crucial part of the narrative begs

the question, "What if the dissolution of divisions was not merely a cosmic accident?" Why did

the author chose to represent it in this manner, deliberately blurring the lines that have

traditionally divided characters within the narrative?

In Du Bois' cosmos, where cosmic forces threaten to wipe out all life, obliteration emerges as a

formidable natural force free of human creations of privilege, bias, and hierarchy. The oncoming

disaster disregards artificial divisions, prompting an important question: What if we could peek

beyond the fictitious realm of "The Comet" and into the domain of our own reality? Why do

divisions persist in times of crisis, whether they be global pandemics, climate change-induced

calamities, or social upheavals? Why do we, as humans, cling to our beliefs and biases even

when presented with existential stakes?

The presentation of the comet as the great equalizer forces us to analyze not just the story's goal

but also the mirror it throws on us.

Is it only accidental that the story's characters' divides melt in the face of annihilation? The story

appears to propose that these differences are, to some part, human constructs—structures that

may be demolished when the need for oneness takes precedence. So, why is it that it frequently

takes a terrible catastrophe or an existential danger for mankind to consider breaking free from

the bonds of separation and prejudice? Is it an inherent feature of human nature to hang onto

divisions and hierarchies?


"The Comet" challenges us to consider our own social structures, as well as the "what if"

possibilities that develop amid crises.

What if, outside of fiction, we were to rethink the borders that divide us, not only after disasters,

but as a proactive endeavor? What if the togetherness and equality that arise in times of stress

could become guiding principles in our daily lives, rather than just in times of crisis? Why is it

that the narrative, with its cosmic disaster backdrop, serves as a painful reminder of the human

ability for togetherness, yet we often struggle to maintain such unity once the threat of crisis has

passed?

These questions are not meant to undercut the plot of "The Comet." Instead, they want to elicit a

better knowledge of the human condition that the film so wonderfully examines. The cosmic

disaster becomes a metaphor, compelling us to consider the layers of social and psychological

complexity that govern our response to disasters, questioning the notion that unity should be

reserved for the most catastrophic of circumstances. The comet's annihilation of differences acts

as a literary testament, enabling us to imagine a future in which togetherness is not only a

reaction to grave concerns, but a deliberate decision that defines our humanity.

Transformation of the Protagonist:

Readers are introduced to the protagonist, Jim, in "The Comet," a young African American man

living in a world defined by profound racial differences and harsh conventions. With the

approaching arrival of the cosmic visitor, the comet, the tale takes an exciting turn. We see a

remarkable shift in Jim in the aftermath of this horrific tragedy, causing us to ask whether this

metamorphosis is just the effect of external disaster.


Why has the author selected the comet as a catalyst for change, and what does this tell us about

people's ability to overcome prejudices when their existence is at stake?

The character arc of Jim represents the socioeconomic differences discussed in "The Comet." His

era's racial stereotypes are abundantly shown as he navigates society's racially divided streets.

However, Jim's worldview is drastically altered by the impending cosmic menace. As he travels

across the post-disaster world, he comes into Julia, a white lady who formerly represented

societal divide. I see Jim's maturation via their common survival instinct and the developing

friendship they create.

This shift raises basic questions: What if Jim's transformation demonstrates the resilience of

human ideas and perceptions, demonstrating that even grave circumstances may challenge

deeply rooted prejudices? Why does Jim see Julia's humanity only when she is about to die, and

does this represent a broader statement on the human psyche?

"The Comet" challenges us to examine the causes for change and to consider why mankind

frequently requires an existential danger to transcend prejudice. What if people could accept

variety, realize shared humanity, and overcome cultural prejudices without fear of imminent

disaster? What if this transition could be launched voluntarily rather than by force?

Furthermore, we must investigate the ramifications of this transition outside the scope of the tale.

Is Jim's metamorphosis inspiring us to consider our own ability for transformation, even in the

absence of apocalyptic events? Why do society differences linger after the cosmic threat has

passed, and may "The Comet" be interpreted as an analogy for our unwillingness to overcome

our preconceived biases in more mundane times?


"The Comet" emerges as a thought-provoking investigation of human transformation and the

motivating forces behind it as I consider these concerns. Despite being situated in a hypothetical

environment, it challenges us to critically evaluate our own reality by giving a fascinating "what

if" scenario that causes us to question the nature of change, prejudice, and unity not just in times

of crisis but also in our daily lives. Jim's metamorphosis is more than just a character

development; it's a striking reflection on people's innate ability to change and the larger

consequences of such changes.

Unity and Cooperation:

A post-apocalyptic planet emerges in the aftermath of the devastating comet crash shown in "The

Comet," providing survivors with the tremendous challenge of recreating civilization from the

wreckage of disaster. In this scenario, Jim and Julia's teamwork acts as a microcosm of the larger

society drive toward unity and cooperation. When confronted with existential dilemmas, Du Bois

expertly emphasizes humanity's ability to transcend biases and divides. However, we are led to

wonder: What if such solidarity was not merely a reaction to disaster? Why is it that it frequently

takes the most dire of crises to create collaboration and solidarity?

Jim and Julia's relationship develops as a symbol of optimism and perseverance in a chaotic

world. Following the comet's disastrous impact, their partnership becomes a key story thread,

demonstrating people's capacity to put aside differences and preconceived biases when their

survival is at danger.

Yet, when we consider the transforming power of this oneness, we can't help but wonder: What if

such collaboration could be a purposeful decision rather than a reactive reaction to disaster? Why

do we regularly see a revival of division and prejudice after the initial shock of a crisis has worn
off? The narrative inspires us to ponder the transient nature of togetherness in times of great

need, as well as the long-term consequences of such unity in our own environment.

While "The Comet" is a work of science fiction, it forces us to question our reality. What if

mankind could extend the spirit of collaboration beyond the immediate aftermath of a disaster?

Why does the goal of unity and cooperation appear to imply the oncoming threat of extinction,

and may this story be seen as a metaphor for the world's battle to overcome global concerns such

as climate change and inequality?

The story's powerful message, which advocates togetherness and solidarity as tools for crafting a

more equal future, has far-reaching ramifications.

Can "The Comet" be viewed as a motivation for readers to go beyond their own biases and

divisions? Why does the prospect of disaster need us to recognize the capacity of collective

action in altering society for the better?

As we consider these themes, "The Comet" transcends its position as fiction and emerges as a

call to action, encouraging us to consider the nature of togetherness, collaboration, and solidarity.

It invites us to consider our own capacity for transformation as well as the conditions that

motivate it. Du Bois' story reminds us that, while unity is a powerful response to catastrophe, it is

also a choice, one that has the capacity to construct a more equal and peaceful world.

Implications for the Real World:

Although "The Comet" is definitely science fiction, it has a message that goes well beyond the

bounds of its fictitious plot. It reflects on the possibility of real-world transformation and

presents important questions that invite readers to examine their own preconceptions, biases, and

divides. Du Bois encourages us to consider how these hurdles may be overcome when
confronted with global concerns such as climate change, public health crises, or any other

existential threat. However, this begs the question: What if we could overcome these boundaries

without fear of impending disaster? Why do we need the threat of approaching tragedy to rally

and work together for the greater good?

The themes explored in "The Comet" are not limited to science fiction; they have real-world

implications, prompting us to reflect on our own prejudices and biases and consider the obstacles

that global society must confront in the face of challenges that threaten all of humanity.

What if we saw the narrative as an analogy for our unwillingness to transcend our divides in the

absence of imminent existential threats? Why is it that once the crisis has gone, we typically

revert to our preexisting biases, unable to retain the togetherness and solidarity that formed when

we faced calamity directly?

"The Comet" pushes us to consider our answers to serious global concerns. Its message goes

beyond its fictitious setting, challenging us to recognize the potential of collective action when

our common future is threatened. Why is it that our reaction to existential dangers frequently

displays the finest qualities of our nature—unity, collaboration, and a commitment to the larger

good? Can we use the story's metaphorical power to encourage proactive change in our world?

The novel challenges us to think about our society and political structures and how they

contribute to divides. What if we could imagine a future in which mankind uses its innate ability

for unity and collaboration without the threat of disaster? How can we turn the message of "The

Comet" into real-world policies and activities that promote a more egalitarian and inclusive

future for all?

Finally, "The Comet" is more than a work of fiction; it is a call to action, a firm belief that our

world's issues and divides can be overcome through communal effort, regardless of the enormity
of the catastrophe. Du Bois encourages us to reconsider our own capacity for change, unification,

and the pursuit of the larger good by forcing us to contemplate the significance of the narrative in

our own lives and society.

Conclusion:

W.E.B. Du Bois exhibits a great mastery of the science fiction genre in "The Comet," employing

it to examine themes intrinsically connected with the human experience: perseverance, unity, and

transformation. Du Bois provides a powerful metaphor for humanity's ability to overcome its

differences and biases, particularly in times of great crisis, via the prism of an impending cosmic

disaster. Despite its science fantasy setting, this story contains vital lessons for our everyday

lives.

The impending approach of the comet, which has the ability to obliterate all life, serves as a

harsh warning that when faced with existential challenges, human divides lose meaning. It

emphasizes our intrinsic species oneness, which is capable of overpowering cultural biases,

artificial barriers, and ingrained prejudices. However, this forces us to consider an important

question: What if we could harness this togetherness without fear of disaster? Why does it take

impending disaster to uncover the best aspects of our nature?

As we follow Jim, the story's altered protagonist, we see a significant shift in perspective brought

about by the imminent arrival of the comet.

It accelerates his development by challenging him to move beyond the racial divides that

previously characterized his environment. This is a monument to human adaptation, which is

frequently launched in the face of the most dire challenges. What if we could bring about such
transformation proactively, breaking away from cultural constructions and prejudices without the

force of disaster?

"The Comet" is a call to action, encouraging us to reconsider our prejudices and divides and

tackle them openly.

It makes us wonder why we often fail to maintain togetherness and solidarity after the crisis has

gone. It inspires us to consider its real-world ramifications, acting as a vivid mirror in which we

may examine our answers to global concerns such as climate change, public health crises, and

socioeconomic injustice.

It is a powerful appeal to overcome divides and work together to create a more equal and

inclusive society. "The Comet" demonstrates that, even in the midst of tragedy, the human spirit

has an unrivaled power to unify and drive transformation. This story is more than just a work of

fiction; it is an inspiration, calling us to join together, eradicate divides, and work together to

create a more peaceful future.


Works Cited

Du Bois, W.E.B., "The Comet." Darkwater: Voices from Within the Veil, Harcourt, Brace and

Howe, 1920, pp. 156-178.

Hartwell, David G. "Themes: Science Fiction." The Cambridge Companion to Science Fiction,

edited by Edward James and Farah Mendlesohn, Cambridge University Press, 2003, pp. 1-14.

Smith, Charles R. "W.E.B. Du Bois: The Science Fiction Connection." Science Fiction Studies,

vol. 12, no. 1, 1985, pp. 67-70.

Stein, Karen F. "Race and Science Fiction: The Different Strange Worlds of Octavia E. Butler

and H.G. Wells." A Companion to Science Fiction, edited by David Seed, Wiley-Blackwell,

2008, pp. 250-263.

You might also like