Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Saph 3 H 3
Saph 3 H 3
-807.91
-625.7
-706.15
-1187.01
-926.67
-859.78
-1202.03
-718.79
-1052.78
-1263.06
-930.48
1
-807.9
-1170.5
-639.5
-1065.09-1261.76
-1289.28
-1050.57
2
4
14.0
5
-1187.3
-56
-629.6
-107.91
-63.68 -84.31
4
9.15
1
1
-797
-863 40.4
-940.1
-1051.08 -90
-1205.05
-9.44 -185.05
-108.0 -703.45
-44.14
-28.4
.59
6
44.0 .73
-88 476 . 44
9
-14 45
-90
-61.7
44.67
-24.18
3
.54
0.07
863
-858.7
94.3
-931.01
.13 -1 5
-1175.99
19
600.87
-703.41
-14 1.53 59 1.
-121.4
2 44 62
-292.
68 0.5 -1
3
-4.87
-5
-0.13
-24 45.27
-79.57
73
9
8
475.17
-25
47.3
830.33
628.64
-59.1
.42 5
601.26
-56
7
392 .1 2 1.
82 8
-14 -24967 4.3 82 .76 0.
90 -14 62
-225
41
-82.75
499.18
-39 1 -8
867.76
-801.02
-12.25
57
840.43
-629.62
43.89
673.6
-2
-83.91
.2
630.59
3
6
.5
25
-7.42
.93
600.0
-26
88 555 3
51. -24 6.7 5 4 1
-90 39 1.7 1 .2 8 .3
-40 49 .69
478.4
86 8.2 80
882.46
5
-1-44107
698.02
4
2.7 -3 9 58
853.64
82
673.23
78
829.05
-42 -8 - 1
9
-52.59
.84
2
454.4
-26.14
961 4
-98.62
63 801 8
2.3 96
.0 .3
7
-39 -42 3 3
29 04 9. 32
628.3
654.65
8
.75 -66 -4 46
840.26
27
673.71
62 77
-4 -2
838.32
-9.003
6
0.
5
475.0
5 5 9 61
4.5 -443
3
2.6 -8 5
74 36 .76 .8
1
-25
8
.8
-68 58 27 .4
-119.36
73
9 -6
6 23
62
-39
-58.21
49
-2
1
601.2
6 .5 -2
631.19
87
825.58
-2 7 .29
475.85
59 8
96 .7
3
83
-6 38
0.
.3
6 66
8
1 -6
13
10
7.9 56 18
-4
79 - 0.
5 -25 61
5.9 -2
4
47 .3
5
-44 31
9
598.07
.9
62
455.77
78
-6
11
-4
9
.4
4 .4
50 63
58
4
7
.6
42 -1
79
-
10
-4
8
.6
68
62
-2
SAP2000 22.0.0 Axial Force Diagram (COMB2 1.2 DL + 1.6 LL) Kgf, m, C
SAP BERLI FATIMAH
M. REZA
SAP LOLA AZAHRAH.sdb
ISKANDAR.sdb
APRILIA.sdb 18/10/2021
20/11/2022
10/1/2020
-807.91
-625.7
-706.15
-1187.01
-926.67
-859.78
-1202.03
-718.79
-1052.78
-1263.06
-930.48
1
-807.9
-1170.5
-639.5
-1065.09-1261.76
-1289.28
-1050.57
2
7
88.0
5
-1187.3
-58
-629.6
-111.85
-65.57
4
0.16
1
5
-797
-876 77.6
-940.1
-1051.08 -9 1
-1205.05
-15.3 -185.05
-84.31
-111.8 -703.45
-49.45
-28.4
.59
4 3
-89 58.0 6.7 . 65
9
4 7
-14 77
-91
-61.7
44.67
-24.18
5
8.04
4.9
-858.7
0.16 57
-931.01
.13 -1 6
-1175.99
-876 .53
453.19
794
600.87
-703.41
59 07
-121.4
42.
-4.87
3
2.8
14.44
92
-0.13
45.27 -5
-79.57
-24 05
7
475.17
7 -26
830.33
22
88.0
628.64
-65.5
.42 3
601.26
7
90 -1 76
-82.75
-
499.18
867.76
05
-801.02
-12
-39 .89 -8
840.43
8.0.25
43.89
-26
673.6
-629.62
-83.91
630.59
3
1
.5
-15.3
48
600.0
43 -27
4
65 .
77. 924 3
6. 7 7 5 4
-91 -24 39 91.6 1.2 4 .9
478.4
74
882.46
-40144610.7 9 86 8.0
698.02
65
853.64
2.4 -39 95
673.23
- - 41 -1
829.05
37
-8
9
-52.59
.9 -43
2
454.4
-26.14
574
-98.62
-16 4
8.2 01.04
-15.3
63 . 38 6
.06 9 .4
3
-395 -42
628.3
8
92 049
.4 24
654.65
72
840.26
.6 62 -4 33 49
673.71
77 -6
838.32
6 -4 -2
-91 0.1
6
5
475.0
5.0
3 76
6 -8
2.8 -443
3
.69
05
89
62 .76 85 3
-119.36
.
-26
.
83 78 .4
81
-6 958 89
-65.57
62
74
9 -6 51
601.2
-2
.5 1 -3
631.19
76 -2
825.58
475.85
-2 78 9
9.2
3
8
65 .7
76
-69 6 07 38
0.
8. 66
61
. 8 88 -6
52
1
-5 3
-4
60 .4
5 -2 24
5.9 249
47 -
598.07
5
-44 .3
4
455.77
.1
31
58
62
16
-6
-4
.9
4 9 74
7 2. 65
-1
6
33
.7
-4
10
16
-4
9
.8
81
74
-2
-1387
7.8
.119
-6.1 7
-210
8-1
-6
.24.73
.3
.4 -9
4.8
-5 1 97.9
.7
50.8 8
-214
6.0
-000.4.2294 -1-4
0
4.0
.2
9.12
-40.6
275
.0 1-3
01.72
-21 3 5.0.275
05-.5
04.53
4.1 874
7 -1-50314
.1.3.87
0.4 11 1-0
343.26
9.8
-1 3 -15 30..1
08 764 -6
163.2
- . 868.15
50-1
1.9
858 0.3 6246.7
4.0
-105
6.0.61437 -.4
.334.4.6 -21
1
105.1
--03.1 475 57.0 8 159 4
2040
-2.5961181
.9
.1 -0.41.5 712 0.9
602.517
.7991 -4. 06.77
.95 4.8
.6
.6
0.6
-1
-22
-130 64-.2
320..58454 1-4
5.6.458
.0 5 -4.4 718.8 1-460.5658 21.8
5.8585 -72-34.5
-0 .578 2 -13..940.5 9 16
2.3
.7
-23 0-4.0. 2.526 -11..6-04.6 41
0.52
-94 336
8
27-2 -3
1.3
6.33 .35
24.01. 7 16-3544.212 3.1421 .8
-1.4540782.7 -13-34..57
1..6.43943 3 -1-421. 37
28.98
-142
7 7.11
9 2 -32..4 .1737 2.8
8651
5
-1 1.5 3.39
232.5
.97
.6
63 1-05 2.0239479.9 -4-5154.818
8.9
.0
1714. 8. 1 9 -12. 991
.24
-0.904625.7 -5.83.288 1-75140 -15
072. 7 6 -15- 71.1
.283 -20
4 -21.305.72924-2-5012.5..0578838518 -653103. 65 3.40.16.4.69.982 5.2 6090.4 62 .3-130
8726. 43.1 5 76 3 -54443.264 .2
.38915
.42 -21. 586239- .15..086 3.2 860.77
-1 -13. 13
76 46
7.9
110 5-312..1.04 -2 1
8
0492 -3.4041294 -13--4742.3.12.46.5917.4711 -4-336. 9 -207 -16
-01..813.4.37 .5 -2 1 4649 18 .9.5.234 8.3 42.9
2
20.6.35.673..757579 -23.8 04981 4-12 493.487
3 64
-22 7.2.99 4. .02
-1
18 -71.4 .4 3. 11685.
98
-15391
2. -4
-48132.7469 7 6.8 35796 -22
-3. 62785. 5.2. 7 .59 --5324 90
5 5 -21..8 026.823 2.44 -3 0 5
.432-..22.6
3.8 .3-51
3 2 66
- 19
.07 413..4052
7
-81-
43.6.
04
2 .0 4. 70.89
1.8107698 7--2 7
-2 86 .63.27.
-0 118617. -23
8. -1
-292549 09 25
.
2.5 13.18.32 - .18
5-6295 9.746 21
.0
-47
4.8
.528. 1
1.76 932388 8-11.
63.93648
5
2. 74.47
-2
58
14
-1 19
0
.4 -66
.0
2 41 .7 3 .8
-2 5
4
2 .22 30 7
-5427 4 0.0
6.72. .61.15
30.86 98538 -1 160. 1-52
17
89 .0.306
-2 3294.6
-1
19 -6
32
.4 79
1
.5
.0
7
-1
65
0.
56
493. -6
.6 76
19
-4 70.1 .8
.0
6 4
7
-4
8 9.
98
1114
-106
0.2
.77
8
SAP2000 22.0.0
REZA
-11121
1244
530.9.
.54
-8144
168
30.27
924.5
.87
2161 6
.28 -17
54
229
.1
5.08
APRILIA.sdb
.369
-4 2
-1176
0.4
1626
17.8 .6
6
5
2924 6
FATIMAH
.3
1125.
-336
74
.44
3.3 9
-118
2.1
082 3.
148.1
1015.3
1830
5
7
-3
-1522
-472451
..086
7.1
2
.85
-5
1
1524.7
5
-2329.3
2.9.554
--140.
1
1911.7 6
5.
-1668755
.3849
661
28.4.391 105.7 2090.3
-1
231-3
9.201 .667
8
1786.9 -15 66
6764
13.1
.2 9
3
.56 739.69
-1166
-13257 3125.9
8
ISKANDAR.sdb
2801.1 .3
4018
1396.76
-197
2
-33
493.4
88.6 4559.6
9
238.4
1
6
.82
.4.119
17
7164
28.35 -2556.81
-1263.45
-4
..54
9
-3585.3
-27.2
3
88
74
-4716.75
6
-1290.87
-1766.1
.0
3
-2 -4
-11
-6-5
38
08
00 -25
7
-18644
631
55
56 411.
9.
.483
03
47 .1
30.4 3.2.
21
27
15 -2617
79.54
.34
-1210 -114122.9
.4
.0197 73
0.7
-3100541 09
1230.42
.93
41
75..25 .132
25
333.2 -2654.75
-1556 56.5
7.7
0.26 1516.36
..001 4
1706.27 -23-5100.
07154
7926930
.18.58 2182.1
2093.131228.4 2324.16
AZAHRAH.sdb
10
-149
231
1-6242
-1766
-11
-61
86
.0
-1
-1691
14.9
-3
107
-27.3
.82
-2575
-2056
9
.958
.77
-2087.67
.8
.4 -2329.36 -2621
9262
.59
.32
2.
54.
.19 -2556.95
..32
..7094
-101930 -4713
-3542
-2794-3636
47 .8
-114187..6705
-1032 .72
.55
.52
.5 3
-5202
-5724
-3649
-11194.6 5
83
.06
10.195
30051 -4966
-4755.91
.89
.13
56 36
.45
.53
.41.
-84630.36
.8
-1675 -5000
-3527
-3443
98
795
2923
35004
34.573.03 .22
.51
.04.32
8
.02
49
1827
104.3.31
08
1699.84
2806.93
1627.75 910.83
2607.61 1709.01 3170.72 2073.01
1972.59 2013.7 1218.21
3313.68 1917.61 1210.97
-1
2015.03
35
3320.59 3160.84 -154752.1
1-7202
2066.37
10197
-1025.73
-108
3.3
1696.66
25.1
-12848.42
-17367.06
-37689.67
-37189.05
8
1632.98 -7376.43
86.4
-5065.84
-3426.15
-4981.3
-6220
-2103
.683
915.06 -4719.95
.296
-2748.02
-2591.68
0.31
-242
3.
2430
-172
7146431.51
73.99
.77
70..90
-355270.
16 -44.
-3530
55
-5028.47 .11
77
..1193 -2
-3584
-3586
-4733
.84 .06
-4922.83.98
.66
.46 2280.45
.13
-2071
-20692189.2
-277
-2611
59
.13
.44
0.3
.7
-31 02
-57-97 2419.78 .617 1233.32
9
3. 8.3
-0.8
-32 2319.71
-1
9426.
076.4
1
-2556
63.95
.02 2691.02 1511.54
5.
-15
2791.93
49
1970.2 52.53
121.
-2329.36 -6992
48
1711.3
1.9
1-797
-360
201 0.51
3.7
7
4 097
8.14
-1166
-32
13
-3379.9
1
3320.23 74.8
121
3 7.3
4 -15
.8461
-1747.
18
23-26
-14
-11
-28 41 08.83
1
-165
75
92
058325.18.4
0.4
7.8 3169.13 8.6
4011.0
8.684
78
.0
7
.29
-5
-623
1364.74 -305
435.
4.85
49 20 80 .07
3..17
3.44
-1192
-471
888.1.
44
9133 13 92 .23 18 31 .24 89
65
346.
.5
.566
51..93
-23
43 1896.57 -2594.69
71
2416.96 728.55
0.9
-13.
1018.87
49
2
-164
2970 2324.54
0.
.1 .9
.712
33
2
7 04.9
33
1-97
6
-1
-2579 504.
.34 -359 05
23 1515.6
7059
9.31 .9
1
72.38 -3
-337
28
.166
1
1364.7 441.
6.
284
.83
7
4017
2071.8 -1
3 54 71
.519
646
5
3.9
.6
.056
- 16 -0.44
1392.3
-256 53
9.0
2279
6.0
.925 -169
.42
6
.3.1
5
3 2 1 728.6
1-51
-2 8 9.26 4
61.
-12653 329.3
89.3.21
1695
.94 6
4
8985
1233.2
1-72
3
-13
1632
0206
.86
9.8
.90
15
4
-1111
0767
915.0
2
..27
61
-10
-103
3.19
87
.88
10/1/2020
Kgf, m, C
18/10/2021
20/11/2022
SAP
SAPLOLA
BERLI
-1
218668
4.2
.448
-636
SAP2000 22.0.0
M. REZA
.77
4-7
-75
42037.76
9.3
7.9
1
-4
-28
534767
1.6
.053 -2
2-2
221
-94
977
48.7
0.9
8.3.9
APRILIA.sdb
21
4
2.9
9
-10
FATIMAH
-5
-4
484
947
626
1.5
26
.1
.264
-1
3
14778
.63
965 .8
82.0
.99
42
-37
-6
-77.3
8
4-5
048
02
1
0.5
5
5
.9.8
-18
0.6
-4
6
44
104
372
8
.4
55.0
.95
88
.24
8-7
-2463
8139
65.6
6.23
2 -4
7 97
495773
-00..9
.48.5
31 6. 59
3.35
.17
552
-93
-2
228
931
227 .7
8.4
7480.9 9
.846
4.1
-95
ISKANDAR.sdb
4-5
-4
-12
96
4835
1.
422.6
.5
44
8.8
-3
-2
35
-3
2775
67
583.
869.
.436
.901
3
28
6.8
4 - 49
25
-5
51
7
-4113
861
42
.6
.1
.5 -5
52
64
24 -628
.4
63
72
610.
.8
.0 -18
12.4
4.42
29
1 34
1874
83
-5.
90.25
.6
.09
6
.51
1
9
62.6
-2
-8-7 66
63
-613
59
-864 -41
64
37
8
1366
87 3.
.0
78.3 16
8.61 38
4131 .8
38.5
.8
8
93
303.1
.87.2
76 8155
-428 1 -41
70 61.
4659. 51
45
00.41
.48
6.3.28
147
-4005.
1878.02
AZAHRAH.sdb
-6
-2157.12
-6
77.9
22.5
-7
0.9
26
2.6
-1798
-2
3476.3
1762.9
-5 1
4
.84
2
7.2
8
2976.
3568.
-3684 -4135.4
2.4
85
87
-294999
.21
.4 6418.0 -3600
3693.
4075.9988 -2775 12
2808.65
.28
-1622.06
4114.28
-4301.17
.04 6173.66
1
-32834. -6625
-5404
5459.
6498.
3 .4
31
-1847 .46
.19
56
72
7
-5409
-7841
6040.
6598.4 86 .17
.18
6889.4 -5311
-6584
5304.
6651.
41
.29
.86
.46
.5
-4723 6341 63561-6392
5578.
6853.
-5371 .94
34
72
.35
.8
-4079.76
.3 1.2 .18
84
.01 99
.6
4
-1447 2.32
1
13.22 -4571.38
-3913.61
-25554.09
23
3913.61
4571.38 686 4079.3
4723.76 1847.17
2162.49
4.
622
14333.12
-70059.6
63.63
8526.92
-7280.77
57
5330.12
6529.69
-6883.29
-5568.96
54
.25
8 .2
-6638.87
-5311.76
5335.79
6526.51
.51
-2813.96
-3682.16
2786.48
3579.47
2
28.
-8547
.92
.77
71909.9 5368
-5371
-6458
1.8
6867.81
.7
.55
.68
59
-6558
6645
-542 .64
.01
54287.7
8
.23
1.9
3695
-2961
-3589
2960.56
.6
.46
.52
5
-9152
2515369.8
49.66
-0
04.
0.23
7 09
-62
-41
.5
4301
-1
14.
02.17
.96
28
2
9
-40
-64
4135
75 -17202.6
38.01 1
32
05.48
.23
.98
.5
-7
9
-511
2
517
4843.62
1.02
2.5
6.5
-17
-34
1798
62
64.84 -49
542
48461.2
57.
.92 8.22
3
.8
1.3
2.54
5
-22
292
22281.
2.1
1.9
73
12
42
929
-79
-71
80 71
9111
02
55 3.4
.48
.32
7.487
.9
9.2
-6
68
-55
53
52
73
68
72 .9
7..11
26
9
.33
52 -5
-6
53
66
53
30
12
39
5.
0..0
.2
44
288
5
12
.7
1
-2
-357
80
27
3674
83 98
46
8..0
.3 6
7
1.
.97
-4
-6
48
410
100
89
0..5
.2
51
5
1 -824
29.7
1.
7.494
32
-6
-4
04
44111
5. 6
38.9
.84
6 -4
5184
13
672.
.6
.8527
95
49
-4
54
84
61
34
7.4
2.
.2
.7
54
9
-1
-3
0.2
7573 188
8
483
62
3..0
.8
09
933
.28 9 -222
29
22 27
81
3.
2.2
.4
.14
2
.19
-4
-6
40
71
731
88.8.7
28
.4
1473157.9
.98
71
23
4.
.94
-4 -1
-3
17
28
3951
73 476792
58.9
.3
.82
1.6
.318 94
68
6.
79
-447027
39.7
.36
62
6.9
-2
1814672
.1
.978
20/11/2022
10/1/2020
Kgf, m, C
18/10/2021
SAP M. REZA
BERLI
SAP LOLA ISKANDAR.sdb
FATIMAH
APRILIA.sdb AZAHRAH.sdb 20/11/2022
18/10/2021
10/1/2020
-3.96
3.19
0.51 -2.58
2.51 -0.0
4
803.9
-0.3 -0.1
5
1 0.23 119 7 0.03 1.98 76
1 .48 49.2
9
- 2.
3.1 120 0.2
3 -1.91 1.3 3 5
-0.0 78.4 0.12
8 0.5 6 6
85
-4-19..8 3.5
8 9
11 -0.4
73 1
-2.77 .78.8 -02.0 87. -91
7 0.06 .125 65 .322 0.21.025
-10.1
-00..3
78 4-7 3 -0.3
0.2 07.8.6 4 -804
79 127
3
.41
4.4 -2. 9 9 .45 -02..07 -16
5 1 2. 1.9 .78 -1.2
71 42 -84 1 .7 2 5
0.03
13 -
86 2.87 1.9
.4 0. 7
5 .5 0.5 -119
-10.
.1558
. 48
-2.
9
2.4 -7.8 -1 1 16 1.17
7 6 .78
0 .6 38 6 -2.
59 14 - 2.0 313.1 72 4 -0.7
1.5
.4 1.2
5
6 9.0 4 -88 0 .96 6 1. 01 4 9
3 -96.59 - 0.7
.9 4.8
62 0-0.4 -00. 43 2 6 -12
-00..43 -91
9.9
10 .32 .1583
6 . 19 .19 -01..0-02. -15
.2 04. 3.2
18 3. 1 1 1 852 .0244 -4.
1 1.4
2 2 2 -2.1 -1.898 2 3
.8 -1 5
84 19 1.7 8
1.
-1 -5 .25 .44 -20 -04.1.
.9 4. .2 4 13
3 87 -1. 3 .9
1.54 6 3 -1. 8 -12
75 0.8 1. 6 97
-11 .1
8 -2.5 71.7
0.5 85.1 -018..0. 2 4 5
-1 2 -82 .1352
13
.8
6
.5
4.8 8 -00. 14
.55
042371
8 -31
5 -1 6 5.7
1.4 .0 -01. 5
2 0 .8 .0456
23 0-01.1.2
39
-1 1. 9887
.73
2.
4 1. 15
38
47 .69 -44
1 .0
16 .88 -7 1. 6
.7 -0 96 4
5 8 1. .8
0 .1 5 9 6 -1
.9
18 -0 -1 .16
-8
5.
. 57 27
73
6.5 -44
9.6
8
3
.0 2.
-2 7
13
7 -4
.9
-9 46
8
17 .
.5 99
6
-3
22
.2
5
SAP2000 22.0.0
REZA
767.3
4
767.3
847.6 4
4
APRILIA.sdb
847.6
847.6 4
4
FATIMAH
847.6
4 767.3
4
1534.6
847.6 7
4 1695.2
8 1534.67
4
847.6 767.34
1695.2 1695.28
8 847.64
ISKANDAR.sdb
1695.28
847.64
767.34 1534.67
847.64 1695.28 1534.67
1534.67
767153
.344.67
AZAHRAH.sdb
767.3
4
10/1/2020
18/10/2021
Kgf, m, C
20/11/2022
SAP
SAP
SAPLOLA
BERLI
SAP2000 22.0.0
M. REZA
178.
45
178.4
342.6 5
2
APRILIA.sdb
342.6
854.7 2
8
FATIMAH
854.7
8 178.4
5
356.9
342.6
2 685.25 356.9
342.6
2 178.45
1197.4 685.25
342.62
ISKANDAR.sdb
1709.55
854.78
178.45 356.9
342.62 685.25 356.9 356.9
AZAHRAH.sdb
178.4
5
10/1/2020
Kgf, m, C
18/10/2021
20/11/2022
SAP
SAP
SAPLOLA
BERLI
SAP2000 22.0.0
0.24
-0.41
M. REZA
-54.4
9
-0.35
-37.9 78.54
2
APRILIA.sdb
1.1
49.13
FATIMAH
-41.7
1
103.0
9 2.59
-4.46
4.46
2.93
-1.4
-2598
0.5
2.37 -9.02
-7.25
7
7.95
-0.
21.55
4.27
-2.64
43
-30.77
7.96
ISKANDAR.sdb
-2625
6.74 23635.
75 -32.
6.295
0.22
-223.06
-1.0
8
0.7
6
285.52
0.7
54.79
5
-6.31
37.46 0.23 0.45 -6.02
-0.7
-7.44 2.49
AZAHRAH.sdb
0.49
0.7
0. 5
0.
-0.4
0.24
0.77
5
1
0.37
0.35
28
-68.27 7.15 -54.12 -77.75
154703.06 32.21 2.62 -3.6 2.61 8.92
-100828.9 177069.57 -16.55 -1.17 -3.51
-2.85
23983.72
-0.45
1.64 1.31
-285.52 2.41 7.24 8.93 0.38
-66.36 -54.64 5424.89
-77.75
968.09
0.5
42.29
1
4.46 37.62
2.33 54.58
0.44 0.37
6290.37 -5.75
-0.41
0.74 -4.69
0.
244285.12
-3.59 -1.6
-1.41
49
2.84
0.5
9
856.56 -0.42 1.63
244833.86
-2.7 363.59 0.3
0.41
-0.22
-4.46 -1.91
0.
-1.55 -4.57
77
5.64
0.
1142.0
8 -2.46
42
5.14
2.96
76
-6.69 -9.07
0.
0.73
1.44
86
-42.4
8
-37.75 5.17
65.7
4
0.46 -54.68
-0.99
54.73
77.7
3
10/1/2020
Kgf, m, C
18/10/2021
20/11/2022