Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Oxidative Degradation of Acetaminophen by Permanganate in Neutral Medium-A Kinetic and Mechanistic Pathway
Oxidative Degradation of Acetaminophen by Permanganate in Neutral Medium-A Kinetic and Mechanistic Pathway
Oxidative Degradation of Acetaminophen by Permanganate in Neutral Medium-A Kinetic and Mechanistic Pathway
To cite this article: S. Tabassum, S. Sabir, O. Sulaiman, M. Rafatullah, I. Khan & R. Hashim
(2011) Oxidative Degradation of Acetaminophen by Permanganate in Neutral Medium-A
Kinetic and Mechanistic Pathway, Journal of Dispersion Science and Technology, 32:2, 217-223,
DOI: 10.1080/01932691003656938
217
218 S. TABASSUM ET AL.
the basis of kinetic results. The specific objectives are a) to of acetaminophen and KMnO4 at desired temperature in
examine reaction order, degradation rate and kinetic the range (25–55 C). The progress of the reaction was
behavior of acetaminophen in reaction with permanganate, observed spectrophotometrically by pipetting out aliquots
b) to demonstrate the extent of degradation, and c) to at different time intervals and measuring the change in the
investigate the reaction at different temperatures which absorbance at its kmax 525 nm. The first-order rate constants,
allows the determination of the activation parameters with kobs were obtained from the plots of log (At A1) versus
respect to the slow step. The overall mechanistic sequence time (refer to Figure 2), where At refers to absorbance at
described here is consistent with product, mechanistic and any time t and A1 is at infinite time which excludes the
kinetic studies. absorbance of any Mn(VI) during the reaction.
In order to obtain spectroscopic characteristics of
intermediates or products formed during the reactions,
MATERIALS AND METHODS the reaction solution was successively scanned by a UV-vis
Apparatus scan spectrophotometer.
Thermo spectronic Genesis 20 UV-visible spectrophoto-
meter with matched quartz cells was used to measure
absorbance. A high precision water bath was used to RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
control the heating temperature for color development.
General Considerations
Reagents and Standards The limiting logarithmic method[21] was used for the
determination of the molar ratio between KMnO4 and
All reagents and chemicals used were of analytical
PAM in the reaction. This method depends on measuring
grade. Potassium permanganate (GR Grade, Merck
the optical densities of solutions of KMnO4 and PAM in
Limited, Mumbai, India) was prepared in deionized water.
which the concentrations of the two species are varied.
The drug, paracetamol (Glaxo) used in the study.
The ratio may be found by plotting the logarithms of the
Deionized water was used throughout the experiment.
absorbance (A) of the two sets of solutions versus compo-
sition, one with constant KMnO4 concentration and
Sample Solution of Acetaminophen
variable PAM concentration, the other with constant
Two tablets were weighed and powdered. The powder PAM and variable KMnO4 concentration. The slope of
equivalent of 0.01 g of active ingredient was weighed the curve in first case yields the number of moles of PAM
accurately, stirred well with deionized water for 30 min- while that in second case give the number of moles of
utes and filtered through Whatmann No. 42 filter paper KMnO4 and so the composition of the compound produced
(Whatmann International Limited, Kent, UK). The resi- can be evaluated. The molar ratio was found to be 1:2 for
due was washed well with deionized water for complete
PAM and KMnO4. To examine the effect of variables,
recovery of the drug. The content of the drug was then experiments were carried out under pseudo-first-order
diluted to 50 ml. It was further diluted according to the conditions.
need and subjected to the degradation procedure for
acetaminophen.
Degradation of ½MnO 4 and [Acetaminophen]
Preparation of KMnO4 Solution In order to investigate the kinetics of PAM-MnO 4
KMnO4 (0.040 gm) was quantitatively transferred into a reaction, a series of experiments were carried out under
25 ml standard flask, and makeup with distilled water. The pseudo-first-order conditions. [PAM] is varied from
solution of KMnO4 was stored in a dark glass bottle. 0.1 104 to 1.0 104 mol dm3 at constant ½MnO 4
Potassium permanganate solution is freshly prepared. 0.6 103 mol dm3 (Table 1). The kobs [PAM] plot is
linear passing through the origin, indicating first-order
Kinetic Procedure dependence on [PAM]; Figure 1 depicts the dependence
The oxidation of acetaminophen by permanganate was of kobs on [PAM] at constant ½MnO 4 . The pseudo-first-
followed under pseudo-first-order conditions. The spectro- order rate constants kobs, min1 were calculated from the
photometric kinetic studies were performed on the basis of slopes of plots of log Abs versus time. The degradation
the absorbance (optical density) noted at kmax (wavelength) of permanganate is also shown, ½MnO 4 varied from
as a function of time. These reading were conveniently 0.3 103 to 1.0 103 mol dm3, at constant [PAM]
made with a Genesis 20 spectrophotometer for relatively 0.5 104 mol dm3. It is observed that as the initial
slow reactions. The sample was withdrawn from the ½MnO 4 was increased, the value of kobs decreased
thermo stated reaction mixture for measurement. The (Table 1). The abnormal behavior probably was due to
reaction was initiated by mixing the required quantities possible flocculation of colloidal particles.
OXIDATIVE DEGRADATION OF ACETAMINOPHEN 219
TABLE 2
Effect of [PAM] on the R0 for the oxidation of acetamino-
phen with ½MnO 4 ¼ 0.6 10
3
mol dm3, Temp ¼ 35 C
[PAM] r0 103
104 mol dm3 mol dm3 min1 R
(0.4, 0.5, 0.6, and 0.7) 104 mol dm3. The initial per-
manganate concentration was fixed at 0.6 103 mol dm3
for all experiments. The initial reaction rates were determ-
ined as the tangent to the PAM concentration-time curve.
The rate at which PAM is degraded can be simply measured
when the other reactant, permanganate, is held essentially
constant throughout the experiment. In Figure 2, the log
of initial rates versus the log of the initial PAM is shown.
The slope of the calculated linear regression gave the rate
order x ¼ 0.8056 (1), indicating that the reaction is also
first-order reaction with respect to PAM concentration.
In the second set of four similar experiments, the initial
concentration of PAM was fixed at (0.5 104 mol dm3)
and PAM was reacted with permanganate ranging from
(0.3, 0.4, 0.5 and 0.7) 103 mol dm3. Figure 3 shows
the log of the pseudo-first-order rate constant (kobs) versus FIG. 3. Plot of kobs versus initial permanganate concentration at
the log of initial permanganate concentration. The slope of constant initial PAM concentration of 0.5 104 mol.dm3 at 35 C (kobs,
regression line is y ¼ 1.0864 (1), indicating that the reaction pseudo-first-order rate constant in min1; Permanganate0, initial
Permanganate concentration in mol dm3).
is first-order with respect to the permanganate concentration.
From Figure 3, the rate constant for the overall reaction
can be calculated. The y-intercept of the gradient (5.9485)
is the antilog of the second order rate. Thus, Equation (1) relationship, indicating first order with respect to the PAM
can be rewritten as Equation (6). The results indicate that concentration. Similarly, at different initial dichromate con-
the overall reaction is a second-order reaction and first-order centrations, the log of permanganate=permanganateo versus
reaction with respect to both permanganate and PAM time also shows a linear relationship, demonstrating first
order with respect to the PAM concentration as well.
r ¼ 1:13 106 ½PAM ½permanganate ½6
Effect of Temperature on the Reaction Rate
The first-order reaction rate with respect to the initial
The effect of change in temperature was examined in the
PAM concentration is also confirmed in the log of PAM=
temperature range 25–55 C. As the temperature increases,
PAM0 versus time of four different initial PAM concentra-
the rate of the reaction should increase according to
tions. The slope of the linear regression shows a linear
Arrhenius equation. For the effect of change in temperature
on reaction rate, the Arrhenius equation was used to calculate
the various activation parameters of the reaction products:
ln k ¼ ln A Ea =RT ½7
TABLE 3
Value of k (rate constant) calculated from slopes of log
absorbance versus time plots multiplied by 2.303. Reaction
Conditions: [PAM] ¼ 0.4 104 mol dm3,
½MnO 4 ¼ 0.6 10
3
mol dm3
Temp. (K) 1=T Slope k log k
FIG. 4. Arrhenius plot: log k versus 1=T for activation energy. The negative entropy of activation is characteristic of the
existence of compact transition state. DS# suggests the for-
mation of an activated complex with a reduction in the
of activation of the reaction product were calculated degrees of freedom of molecules. The fairly high positive
using Eyring equation: value of enthalpy (DH#) indicates that the transition state
is highly solvated. A meaningful mechanistic explanation of
k kb DS # DH # 1
log ¼ log þ ½8 the apparent values of DS# and DH# is not possible because
T h 2:303R 2:303R T the kobs do not represent a single elementary kinetic step.
The plot log k=T versus 1=T (Figure 5) was linear with
correlation coefficient of 0.9841. DH# was evaluated from Electronic Spectra
the slope (DH#=2.303 R) and DS# from the intercept [log The UV-visible spectra of the reacting solution over
(kb=h) þ DS#=2.303R] of the compiled Eyring plot. The the time are shown in Figure 6. The spectra show two
values of DH# and DS# were found to be 21.4 kJ mol1
and 225 JK1 mol1 respectively (Table 3). The Gibbs
free energy of activation was determined at 298 K and
found to be 88.4 kJ mol1 by using the following equation:
Mechanism
Permanganate ion, MnO 4 , is a powerful oxidant, as it
exhibits many oxidation states; the oxidation was indicated
by the appearance of brown color in the reaction mixture
after the addition of oxidant. Oxidation of acetaminophen
was found to take place very quickly as observed by color
change of the reaction mixture from violet to red color and
then to orange color, as the reaction proceeds, slowly yel-
low turbidity develops, after keeping for a long time the SCH. 2. Oxidation-reduction pathways of PAM.
CONCLUSIONS
In this work, acetaminophen has been used as a model
SCH. 1. Degradation pathways of PAM. compound for the destruction of pharmaceutical industry
OXIDATIVE DEGRADATION OF ACETAMINOPHEN 223
wastes. Acetaminophen is only partly degraded (to benzo- [7] Verma, R.S., Reddy, M.J., and Shastry, V.R. (1976) J. Chem.
quinone) rather than fully mineralized. Furthermore, since Soc. Perkin Trans. II, 2: 469–472.
the rate of mineralization depends linearly on substrate [8] Rao, V.S., Sethuram, B., and Rao, T.N. (1979) Int. J. Chem.
concentration, the degradation method will be best suited Kinet., 11: 165–173.
[9] Girgis, M.M., El-Shatoury, S.A., and Khalil, Z.H. (1985)
to relatively high strength wastes, and not to the very low
Can. J. Chem., 63: 3317–3321.
concentrations typical of incompletely degraded sewage
[10] Szammer, J. and Jaky, M. (1992) Int. J. Chem. Kinet., 24:
effluents. At present time, oxidative degradation of aceta- 145–154.
minophen by KMnO4 is less expensive and probably [11] Perez-Benito, J.F., Arias, C., and Brillas, E. (1990) Int.
sufficiently rugged to be considered for long-term indus- J. Chem. Kinet., 22: 261–287.
trial use. This permanganate oxidation can be effectively [12] Raju Khan, Z. and Kabir-ud-Din. (2005) Colloid Polym. Sci.,
used in the waste water treatment at the sites contaminated 284: 26–35.
by flouroquinolone antibiotics. Insoluble manganese [13] Arrizabalaga, A., Andres-ordax, F.J., Fernandez-Aranguiz,
dioxide formed, provides advantages in the removal of phe- M.Y., and Peche, R. (1997) Int. J. Chem. Kinet., 29: 181–185.
nol and other organic contaminants from the waste water. [14] Lee, D.G. (1982) In Oxidation in Organic Chemistry, Part D,
Although there has been no proof that very low amounts of edited by W.S. Trahanovsky; New York: Academic Press;
pp. 147.
pharmaceuticals in natural waters have any adverse health
[15] Simandi, L.I. (1983) In The Chemistry of Functional Groups,
effects, they can produce toxic effects to aquatic organisms
edited by S. Patai and Z Rappoport; Chichester, UK: Wiley
and in the case of antimicrobials, the development of [16] Lee, D.G., Lee, E.J., and Brown, K.C. (1987) Phase Transfer
multi-resistant strains of bacteria.[30] To avoid the danger- Catalysis; New Chemistry, Catalysis and Applications;
ous accumulation of drugs in the aquatic environment, Washington, DC: ACS Symposium Series; American Chemi-
research efforts are underway to develop more powerful cal Society.
oxidation methods than those currently applied in waste- [17] Fatiadi, A.J. (1987) Synthesis, 106: 85–127.
water treatments for achieving their complete destruction. [18] Perez-Benito, J.F. and Lee, D.G. (1987) J. Org. Chem., 52:
Besides the practical implications of the research, these 3239–3243.
results hold basic interest. Further work in our laboratory [19] Daughton, C.G. and Ternes, T.A. (1998) Water Res., 32:
is directed towards development and investigation of oxi- 3245–3260.
[20] O’Brien, P.J., Khan, S., and Jatoe, S.D. (1991) Adv. Exp.
dative material that can degrade acetaminophen more
Med. Biol., 283: 51–64.
effectively in assessing the ecological relevance of the
[21] Roso, J. (1964) Advanced Physiochemical Experiments;
present study. The results of this investigation indicate that London: Sir Issac Pitman and Sons.
acetaminophen of analgesic class is substantially degraded [22] Mehrotra, R.N. (1968) J. Chem. Soc. B, 1123–1127.
under conditions yielding lower mass degradates. [23] Rosenblatt, D.H., Davis, G.T., Hull, L.A., and Forbery,
G.D. (1968) J. Org. Chem., 33: 1649–1650.
[24] Fatiadi, A.J. (1976) Synthesis, 65: 133–167.
[25] Kotai, L., Kazinczy, B., Keszier, A., Holly, S., Gacs, I., and
REFERENCES
Banerji, K.K. (2001) Z. Naturforsch, 56: 823–825.
[1] Daughton, C.G. and Ternes, T.A. (1999) Environ. Health [26] Khan, Z., Kumar, P., and Kabir-ud-Din. (2004) Colloids
Persp., 107: 907–938. Surf. A, 248: 25–31.
[2] Bautitz, I.R. and Nogueira, R.F.P. (2007) J. Photochem. [27] Vogel, A.I.A. (1981) Textbook of Quantitative Chemical
Photobiol. A, 187: 33–39. Analysis; 5th ed.; London: Longman Group.
[3] Nogueira, R.F.P. and Guimaraes, J.R. (2000) Water Res., 34: [28] Sultan, S.M. (1987) Talanta, 34: 605–608.
895–901. [29] Drummand, A.Y. and Waters, W.A. (1953) J. Chem. Soc.,
[4] Pode, J.S.F. and Waters, W.A. (1956) J. Chem. Soc., 717–724. 2836: 3119–3123.
[5] Ladburry, J.W. and Cullis, C.F. (1958) Chem. Rev., 58: 403–438. [30] Balcioğlu, I.A. and O } tker, M. (2003) Chemosphere, 50:
[6] Hasan, R.M., Mousa, M.A., and Wahdan, M.H. (1988) 85–95.
J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans., 3: 605–609.