Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Corey 1983
Corey 1983
The clinical course and complications of 2 6 8 patients with patients were first classified as those with no previous history of
first episodes and 3 6 2 with recurrent episodes of genital genital herpes (first-episode genital herpes) and those with a
herpes infection were reviewed. Symptoms of genital previous history of genital herpes (recurrent genital herpes).
herpes were more severe in women than in men. Primary All patients with first episodes of genital herpes selected for this
first-episode genital herpes was accompanied by systemic study presented within 7 days of onset of lesions (mean, 4.6
symptoms ( 6 7 % ) , local pain and itching ( 9 8 % ) , dysuria days), and those with recurrent genital herpes all presented
( 6 3 % ) , and tender adenopathy ( 8 0 % ) . Patients within 48 hours of onset of lesions (mean, 1.4 days). At the
presented with several bilaterally distributed postular- initial clinic visit a standardized interview and genital examina-
ulcerative lesions that lasted a mean of 19.0 days. Herpes tion were done, a sketch of the lesions was made, and cultures
simplex virus was isolated from the urethra, cervix, and were obtained from all suspect genital lesions and from the cer-
pharynx of 8 2 % , 8 8 % , and 1 3 % of women with first- vix in women and the urethra in men. The patients were then
episode primary genital herpes, and the urethra and followed at intervals of every other day or more often until
pharynx of 2 8 % and 7 % of men. Complications included lesions resolved. At each follow-up visit a standardized inter-
aseptic meningitis ( 8 % ) , sacral autonomic nervous view and examination were done, and viral cultures were again
system dysfunction ( 2 % ) , development of extragenital obtained from all lesions and from the cervix. During the acute
lesions ( 2 0 % ) , and secondary yeast infections ( 1 1 % ) . episode of the disease, patients with recurrent genital herpes
Recurrent episodes were characterized by small vesicular were followed for an average of eight visits and those with a first
or ulcerative unilaterally distributed lesions that lasted a episode for an average of ten visits from the time of consultation
mean of 10.1 days. Systemic symptoms were uncommon until healing.
and 2 5 % of recurrent episodes were asymptomatic. The
LABORATORY METHODS
major concerns of patients were the frequency of
recurrences and fear of transmitting infection to partners Cultures for herpes simplex virus were obtained with a calci-
or infants. um alginate or dacron swab, placed into viral transport media,
and inoculated into duplicate tubes of diploid fibroblasts. Cul-
tures were examined three times weekly for 3 weeks for evi-
G E N I T A L HERPES SIMPLEX virus infection is of increas- dence of herpes simplex virus cytopathic effect. An aliquot of
ing public health importance. The advent of effective an- the first genital herpes simplex virus isolate from each episode
was frozen at — 70 °C for subsequent subtyping by an indirect
tiviral therapy, the recurrent nature of the infection, its
immunoperoxidase technique ( 1 1 ) .
differing clinical manifestations, and complications such Acute phase serum samples were drawn at the first clinic
as aseptic meningitis and neonatal infection, are of great visit, and convalescent serum 21 to 28 days later. Sera were
concern to patients and health care providers (1-5). We tested for anti-herpes simplex virus antibody by complement
review the clinical manifestations, course, and complica- fixation or neutralizing antibody assays (12, 13). In the neutral-
izing antibody assay, antibody subtype was calculated using a
tions of first and recurrent episodes of genital herpes sim- pNi-pN2 value ( 1 4 ) . Herpes simplex virus-2 neutralizing speci-
plex virus infections in studies done at the University of ficity was considered a pNj-pN2 of less than 0.05, herpes sim-
Washington Genital Herpes Simplex Virus Clinic. plex virus-1 neutralizing specificity as a value of greater than
0.5, and indeterminate specificity as a pNj-pN2 value between
0.05 and 0.5 ( 1 4 ) .
Materials and Methods
STATISTICAL METHODS
Since 1974 there has been a special clinic at the Harborview
Medical Center, Seattle, Washington, to study the natural histo- For analysis, patients with first-episode genital herpes were
ry and treatment of genital herpes simplex virus infections. Pa- placed in two groups: patients with primary genital herpes
tients and their sexual partners were referred to the clinic from (lacking complement fixation and herpes simplex virus neutral-
community clinics (20%), private practitioners (55%), stu- izing antibody in their acute phase sera), and those with non-
dent health services (5%), and sexually transmitted disease primary, first-episode genital herpes (possessing a greater than
clinics in Seattle-King County (20%). This report summarizes or equal to 1:8 titer of complement fixation or herpes simplex
the data on 648 patients with herpes simplex virus isolated from virus neutralizing antibody in their acute phase serum sample).
genital lesions, who received either no treatment (44%), place- Comparison of demographic characteristics between groups
bo preparations (33%) [water washable base creams (13%), was done by Wilcoxon rank sum test. Chi-squared analysis or
polyethylene glycol ointment (14%), or dimethyl sulfoxide so- the Mann Whitney test were used as specified.
lution (6%)]; or treatment that had no influence on the course
of genital herpes (23%) [topical surfactants (15%), 3% vidar- Characteristics of the Study Population
abine ointment (8%)] (1, 6-10). At the initial clinic visit, all
T h e m e a n a g e o f patients w i t h s y m p t o m a t i c genital
• From the Departments of Laboratory Medicine. Medicine, Pediatrics, and Ob- herpes w a s 27.1 years; 9 6 % were white, 3 2 % were m e n ,
stetrics and Gynecology, University of Washington, the Children's Orthopedic 6 4 % were single, and t h e m e a n educational status w a s
Hospital Medical Center, and the Seattle Public Health Hospital; Seattle, Wash-
ington. 15.1 years o f formal education ( T a b l e 1 ) . T h e d e m o -
Meii Worn en
First Episode Recurrent First Episode Recurrent
of Disease Disease of Disease Disease
(77=104) (/i = 218) (77=182) (77=144)
graphic composition of our patients was similar to that of current episodes of genital herpes in other areas of the
a recent nationwide survey of patients with genital herpes United States, England, and Japan (19-22). Herpes sim-
(15). The proportion of patients who were white and the plex virus-1 has accounted for a widely differing propor-
mean educational status were significantly higher than in tion of isolates from first episodes of genital herpes, aver-
patients previously studied in Seattle with Neisseria go- aging 7% in Seattle, 50% in Sheffield, England, and 35%
norrhoeae (16), and our population differed from the in Japan. Some researchers have speculated that this find-
predominantly lower socioeconomic class groups with ing may be related to more frequent oral-genital contact
genital herpes described in the late 1960s (17, 18). in such populations. Oral sex was, however, a frequent
Genital herpes simplex virus infection was the first sex- sexual activity of patients we studied (Table 1). Al-
ually transmitted disease most patients had acquired. though data comparing the incidence of genital herpes in
Past gonococcal infection was reported by 31 % of men the United States and other countries are not available,
and 12% of women who presented with their first episode the reported incidence of most sexually transmitted dis-
of genital herpes. The mean number of lifetime sexual eases is higher in the United States today than in Japan
partners before the acquisition of disease was 8.8 for or England. The proportion of patients with clinical geni-
women and 32.8 for men. For men the number of part- tal herpes attending our King County sexually transmit-
ners was similar to the number reported by men who ted disease clinics (4.8%) is double that of attendees of
presented to our sexually transmitted disease clinic with sexually transmitted disease clinics in England (2.3%)
nongonococcal urethritis, but less than half that reported (23). The higher proportion of genital herpes cases
by men with gonococcal infection (16). Sixty-six percent caused by herpes simplex virus-1 as compared to herpes
of women and 6 1 % of men with first episodes of genital simplex virus-2 in the English and Japanese studies may
herpes had only one sexual partner during the 30 days show a lower risk of genital herpes simplex virus-2 infec-
before the acquisition of disease, and in 39% the source tion in these populations rather than an increased risk of
contact was a new sexual partner. A clinical history of genital herpes simplex virus-1 infection due to more fre-
genital herpes in the source contact was elicited by inter- quent oral-genital contact. Factors such as the frequent
view for 47% of the female and 35% of the male index use of a condom during intercourse (common in Japan)
cases with first-episode genital herpes. Direct interview of may also influence these data.
the source contact, however, disclosed a history compati-
ble with previous genital herpes in 66% of male and fe- First Episode
male source contacts. The mean time from the last sexual COMPARISON OF PRIMARY A N D N O N P R I M A R Y FIRST
exposure to the onset of disease was 5.8 days (range, 1 to EPISODES
45 days). Of 286 patients with first episodes of genital herpes,
209 had primary first-episode genital herpes and 76 non-
Viral Type in First and Recurrent Episodes of Genital Herpes primary first episodes of disease. From 1975 to 1977, of
Herpes simplex virus-1 was isolated from genital le- 137 consecutive patients who presented to our clinic with
sions from 21 (7%) of 286 persons with first episodes of first episodes of genital herpes simplex virus infection,
disease and only 6 (2%) of 362 persons with recurrent 40% had serologic evidence of previous herpes simplex
genital herpes (p < 0.05). Herpes simplex virus-1 has virus infection, and 60% had primary first episode genital
been more frequently associated with first than with re- herpes. The higher proportion of patients with true pri-
Corey et al. • Genital Herpes Infections 959
mary genital herpes in our more recent series shows our fection was characterized by a high frequency of systemic
particular interest in this form of disease. In the patients symptoms, particularly in women. Fever, headache, mal-
with nonprimary first episodes of genital herpes, neutral- aise, and myalgias were present for 2 or more consecutive
izing antibody in acute phase sera showed past herpes days in 39% of men and 68% of women with primary
simplex virus-1 specificity in 7 1 % (pNi-pN 2 > 0.5). Se- herpes simplex virus-2 disease (p < 0.05) (Table 3).
rologic evidence of past herpes simplex virus-2 infection These systemic symptoms appeared early in the course of
in acute phase sera was evident in 8% of patients with the disease, reached a peak within the first 4 days after
historic first episodes of disease, suggesting previous onset of lesions, usually at the time of presentation to the
asymptomatic acquisition of herpes simplex virus-2 infec- clinic, and gradually receded during the remainder of the
tion. first week of the illness (Figure 1).
Viral Type: Herpes simplex virus-1 was isolated from Pain, itching, dysuria, vaginal or urethral discharge,
genital lesions from 10% of patients with primary first and tender inguinal adenopathy were the predominant
episodes compared to 1 % with nonprimary first episodes local symptoms. Genital lesions were described as painful
( p < 0 . 0 2 ) . These data suggest that previous herpes sim- by 95% of men (mean duration, 10.9 days) and 99% of
plex virus-1 infection protects against the acquisition of women (mean duration, 12.2 days). The severity of local
genital herpes simplex virus-1 disease. Whether previous symptoms gradually increased over the first 6 to 7 days of
herpes simplex virus-1 infection also protects against the illness, peaked between days 8 and 10 and gradually re-
acquisition of genital herpes simplex virus-2 disease is ceded over the second week of illness. Tender inguinal
unknown. Inoculation of high titers of herpes simplex adenopathy appeared during the second and third week
virus (even a patient's own strain) onto a susceptible of illness and often was the last manifestation to resolve.
mucosal surface or into the subcutaneous tissue can re- Inguinal nodes were usually enlarged and mildly tender
sult in lesions, and subsequent recurrences in the same and nonfluctuant. Tenderness to palpation lasted signifi-
anatomic areas (24). Persons with previous herpes sim- cantly longer in women (14.2 days) than in men (8.6
plex virus-1 infection should continue to avoid oral-geni- days) (p < 0.05). Suppurative lymphadenopathy was
tal contact with a person with active oral-labial lesions. not seen in any of the patients in this series. Recently,
Clinical Severity: The frequency of constitutional however, we have seen one patient who presented with
symptoms, number of lesions, and the duration of symp- chancroid-like penile lesions and a firm, non-fluctuant in-
toms were similar for the 20 patients with primary genital guinal node. Herpes simplex virus was isolated from an
herpes simplex virus-1 and the 189 patients with primary inguinal aspirate of this node.
genital herpes simplex virus-2 infection (Table 2). How- Duration of Lesions and Viral Shedding: Widely
ever, patients with nonprimary genital herpes simplex vi- spaced bilateral lesions on the external genitalia were the
rus-2 infection had significantly lower frequencies of sys- most frequent presenting sign in both men and women.
temic symptoms, shorter duration of pain, fewer lesions, The mean number of lesions was 15.5, and the mean area
less frequent appearance of new lesions during the course of involvement was 427 mm 2 in men and 550 mm 2 in
of infection, a shorter duration of viral shedding from women. Lesions were described as starting as small mul-
lesions, and shorter healing time than persons with pri- tiple papules or vesicles that by the time of the first clinic
mary herpes simplex virus-2 infection. Thus, previous visit had already coalesced into large pustular or ulcera-
herpes simplex virus-1 infection ameliorates the severity tive areas (Figures 2a and 2b). Seventy-five percent of
and duration of first episodes of genital herpes. patients formed new lesions during the course of infec-
tion (Figure 2c). Ulcerative lesions persisted between 4
CLINICAL M A N I F E S T A T I O N S OF PRIMARY INFECTION and 15 days. Lesions on the penis and mons pubis be-
Symptoms: Primary genital herpes simplex virus-2 in- came crusted before reepithelializing. Lesions on mucosal
960 June 1983 • Annals of Internal Medicine • Volume 98 • Number 6
simplex virus was isolated from the pharynx from 18 and infection recurs as frequently as oral-labial herpes sim-
from none of 20 patients who did not have a sore throat. plex virus-1 infection or as frequently as genital herpes
Clinical signs of herpes simplex virus pharyngitis ranged simplex virus-2 infection is unknown.
from mild erythema to severe diffuse ulcerative or exuda- Herpes Simplex Virus Urethritis: Among our patients
tive pharyngitis of the posterior pharynx (Figure 3b). with primary genital herpes, dysuria was reported by
Occasionally lesions extended into the anterior gingival 83% of women and 44% of men (p < 0.05). Urethral
area. Fever, malaise, myalgia, headache, and tender ante- cultures for herpes simplex virus were done in 63 men
rior cervical adenopathy were usually present, and many and 57 women with primary herpes simplex virus-2 infec-
patients had recently been diagnosed as having strepto- tion. Herpes simplex virus was isolated from 28% of
coccal pharyngitis. these men and 82% of women (Table 3) (p < 0.01).
Glezen and associates (33) reported that primary her- Ninety percent of men with primary herpes simplex
pes simplex virus-1 infection was a frequent cause of virus-2 infection who had urethral discharge had dysuria,
pharyngitis in college students. Herpes simplex virus-2 and had herpes simplex virus isolated from their urethra.
pharyngitis is also common among patients with primary The urethral discharge was usually clear and mucoid.
genital herpes. Severe exudative herpes simplex virus The subjective severity of dysuria was out of proportion
pharyngitis leading to laryngeal obstruction has been re- to the amount of discharge found on genital examination,
ported (34). Whether oral-labial herpes simplex virus-2 and was significantly worse than dysuria associated with
9 6 2 June 1983 • Annals of Internal Medicine • Volume 98 • Number 6
Constitutional symptoms were infrequent with episodes 10.6 days in men and 9.3 days in women.
of recurrent genital herpes appearing in 5% and 12% of We isolated herpes simplex virus type-1 from genital
men and women, respectively. The mean duration of lo- lesions in only five patients with recurrent episodes of
cal symptoms, the mean duration of viral shedding, the genital herpes. Among women who presented with recur-
mean time to crusting of lesions, and the time to com- rent genital vulvar lesions, herpes simplex virus was con-
plete healing of lesions were all significantly shorter in comitantly isolated from the cervix from only 12%. Her-
patients with recurrent genital herpes than those with pes simplex virus ulcerations were seen on the exocervix
first-episode primary or first-episode nonprimary infec- only infrequently, although culposcopic examination was
tions (Figure 4 ) . not routinely done. Extragenital lesions were seen at the
The symptoms of recurrent genital herpes were more time of recurrent genital herpes in 3 % of men and 5% of
severe in women than in men. Lesions were described as women.
painful by 88% of women and 67% of men. Most women
described the pain as moderate to severe whereas most R E C U R R E N T INFECTION IN I M M U N O C O M P R O M I S E D
men described the pain as mild. The mean duration of PATIENTS
pain was 5.9 days in women and 3.9 days in men Although much of the literature describing herpes sim-
(p < 0.05). Dysuria, described as external by most wom- plex virus infection in immunosuppressed patients has
en and internal by most men, was reported by 27% of concentrated on recurrent herpes simplex virus-1 infec-
women and 9% of men. Herpes simplex virus was isolat- tions, the increasing prevalence of genital herpes and the
ed from the urethra from only 4% of men with recurrent increasing use of immunosuppressive agents have result-
genital herpes. ed in an increasing awareness of genital herpes in this
Nearly 50% of the patients with recurrent genital her- patient population (65). In immunocompromised pa-
pes had a prodrome consisting of a mild "tingling" hy- tients, recurrent genital herpes may cause large numbers
peresthesia or dysesthesia that began from 1 to 2 days to of coalescent vesicles and ulcers from which the virus can
a few hours before the appearance of the vesicles. In some be isolated for prolonged periods of time (median, 13 to
patients, the prodrome included pain that radiated into 15 days) (66). Recurrent genital herpes may also lead to
the buttocks and hips (sacral dermatomal neuralgia). In disseminated infection. Ramsey and associates (67) re-
many patients these symptoms were often the most both- ported the isolation of herpes simplex virus-2 from lung
ersome part of the recurrent episode. parenchyma of 1 of 15 adult bone marrow transplant
The mean lesion was area approximately 10% that recipients who developed herpes simplex virus pneumoni-
seen with primary genital herpes. The number of lesions tis. Early antiviral chemotherapy is useful in decreasing
differed greatly, but in contrast to the single large vesicu- the morbidity of these episodes in immunosuppressed pa-
lar lesions typical of recurrent oral-labial herpes, recur- tients (66, 68). In some settings the use of prophylactic
rent genital herpes usually produced several small vesicu- acyclovir may decrease the incidence of recurrent genital
lar lesions that coalesced into larger ulcers (Figure 5). herpes (68, 69).
Lesions generally increased in size over the first 3 days of
the episode, reached a plateau during days 4 to 8, and R A T E OF R E C U R R E N C E
then rapidly resolved (Figure 6). New lesions developed The risk and rate of recurrence of genital herpes ap-
during the course of infection in 4 3 % of men and 28% of pears to be influenced by herpes simplex virus type, host
women (p < 0.05). The mean duration of lesions was immune response to genital infection, and a previous his-
9 6 6 June 1983 • Annals of Internal Medicine • Volume 98 • Number 6