khz;GkpF FLk;g ey ePjpkd;wk; Kd;ghf

rptfq;if
MC.NO 19/2023
1.,d;ngd;l; ypd;rp(25/2023)
f/ng.me;Njhzp Nyhgd;
j/ng. mUs;jh];
fjT vz; 4/89
re;jdkhhpag;gd; Nfhtpy; njU
uhNk];tuk;.

2.mydh Nkhp\
j/ng.me;Njhzp Nyhgd;
fjT vz; 4/89
re;jdkhhpag;gd; Nfhtpy; njU
uhNk];tuk;.

3.Mbd; ngl;hpf;
j/ng.me;Njhzp Nyhgd;
fjT vz; 4/89
re;jdkhhpag;gd; Nfhtpy; njU
uhNk];tuk;. ….kDjhuh;

//vjph;//
me;Njhzp Nyhgd; (44/2023)
j/ng gpyNte;jd;
fjT vz;.144 A
Ntyhq;Fsk;
kuf;fhj;JHh;
fhisahh;Nfhtpy; tl;lk;
rptfq;if khtl;lk; ….vjph;kDjhuh;

Nkw;gb vjph;kDjhuh; jug;gpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; jhf;fy; nra;Ak;

ep&gz cWjpnkhop Mtzk;
rptfq;if khtl;lk;>fhisahh; Nfhtpy; tl;lk;> Ntyhq;Fsk; fpuhkj;jpy;
fjT vz; 144A y; trpf;Fk; gpyNte;jd; kfd; fpwpj;jtd; Rkhh; 42
taJila me;Njhzp Nyhgd; Mfpa ehd; rj;jp;a gpukhzj;jpd; ngahpy;
jhf;fy; nra;Ak; ep&gz cWjpnkhop Mtzk; vd;dntd;why;;:-
1.ehd; ,e;j kDtpy; vjph;kDjhuh; MNtd;.
2.ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why;> vd;Fk; 1k; kDjhuUf;Fk; fle;j 25.4.2016 md;W
rptfq;if khtl;lk;> fhisahh; Nfhtpy; tl;lk;> Ntyhq;Fsj;jpy; cs;s
Gdpj ,Uja khjh Myaj;jpy; fpwpj;Jt Kiwg;gb jpUkzk;
eilngw;wJ.jpUkzj;jpd; nghOJ 1k; kDjhuhpd; ngw;Nwhh; 1 rtuz; jq;f
eif kl;LNk rPjdkhf nfhLj;jdh;.jpUkzj;jpd; midj;J nryTfSk;
vd;dhYk;> vdJ FLk;gj;jpduhYk; kl;LNk nra;ag;gl;lJ. jpUkzr;nryT
VJk; mth;fs; nra;atpy;iy. jpUkzj;jpw;F gpwF ehDk; 1k; kDjhuUk;
vdJ Cuhd Ntyhq;Fsj;jpy; vdJ ngw;Nwhh; FLk;gj;Jld; trpj;J
te;Njhk;.jpUkzj;jpd; thapyhf fle;j 27.03.2017y; mydhNkhp vd;w ngz;
Foe;ijAk;> mjd; gpd; fle;j 31.12.2019 md;W Mbd;ngl;hpf; vd;w Mz;
Foe;ijAk; gpwe;jJ.
3. ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why;> ehd; tptrha FLk;gj;jpy; gpwe;jtd;> tho;thjhuj;jpw;F
tptrhak; nra;J gaphpl;L mjpy; ngWk; tUkhdj;ijf; nfhz;L
FLk;gr;nryTfis nra;J te;Njd;. 1k; kDjhuh; ,y;yj;jurp.tptrhaj;jpy;
Nghjpa tUkhd; ,y;yhjjhy; FLk;gr; nryTfis vd;dhy; rkhspf;f
,aytpy;iy .MfNt FLk;gj;ij tsg;gLj;jTk;> ey;y rk;ghhpf;f Ntz;Lk;
vd;w vz;zj;jpy; ntspehl;bw;F Ntiy nra;a nrd;Nwd;.gpwF jhd;
Ghpe;J nfhz;Nld; mJ jhd ehd; nra;j kpf nghpa jtnwd;W.
ntspehl;by; khjk; 35>000/- &gha; rk;gsk; ngw;w ehd; 5000/- kl;Lk; vdJ
nryTf;fhf vLj;Jf;nfhz;L kPjk; 30000/- &ghia 1k; kDjhuUf;F
mDg;gp itj;Njd;.Mdhy; mij mth; Kiwahf nrytplhky;> mtuJ
Kd;dhy; fhjyUld; kfpo;r;rpahfTk;>cs;shrkhfTk; nrytopj;Js;shh;.
4. ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why;> ehd; 12k; tFg;G tiu kl;LNk gbj;Js;Nsd;. ntspehl;by;
ehd; Ntiy nra;J mDg;gpa gzj;ij 1k; kDjhuh; mtuJ Kd;dhs;
fhjyUld; Mlk;gukhf nrytopj;jhy;>,d;W FLk;gj;ij ghh;j;Jf;nfs;s
topapd;wp tptrhak; nra;J tUfpNwd;. NkYk; tptrhak; gUtfhyj;ij
nghWj;Nj ifnfhLf;Fk; vd;gjhy;>epue;ju tUkhdk; ,d;wp gUtfhyj;jpy;
fpilf;Fk; tUkhdj;ij Nrkpj;J itj;J FLk;gj;ij guhkhpj;J
tUfpNwd;; . NkYk; vdJ jhahhpd; kUj;Jt nrytpw;F $l topapd;wp gy
,lq;fspd; fld; ngw;W vdJ jhahUf;F itj;jpak; ghh;j;J tUfpNwd;.
5.ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why;>fle;j 25.03.2019 md;W ntspehl;by; ,Ue;J jpUk;gpa ehd;
27.03.2019 md;W vdJ kfs; mydNkhpapd; gpwe;jehis vq;fsJ Chpy;
nfhz;lhbNdhk;.mjpy; $l 1k; kDjhuh; Nrh;e;J nfhz;lhl tpUg;gk;
fhl;ltpy;iy> FLk;gj;Jld; Nrh;e;J nghOij fopf;f mtuhy;
,aytpy;iy. mtuJ vz;zk; KOtJk; NtW vq;Nfh
,Ue;jJ.mg;nghOJ rpq;fg;G+hpy; ,Ue;J vd;dhy; 1k; kDjhuUf;F
mDg;gg;gl;l &gha; 8>00>000/- fzf;F tpguk; Nfl;;l nghOJ Kiwahf
gjpy; VJk; $whky; mtuJ jahh; ngw;w flid milf;f mjid
nrytopj;Jtpl;ljhf $wpdhh;.me;j gjpy; vdf;F
re;Njfj;ijAk;>vhpr;rYl;baJ.tpthj Kbtpy; mjid jdJ Kd;dhs;
fhjYldhd njhlh;G njhpa te;jJ. Foe;ijfspd; vjph;fhyj;ij
fUj;jpy; nfhz;L ehd; mtUf;F mwpTiu $wpNdd; Mdhy; mth; mJ
vijAk; nrtprha;f;ftpy;iy. jhd ehspjopy; ghh;j;jjhfTk; mjpy;
Cr;rePjpkd;wk; jdf;F tpUg;gKs;sth;fSld; Nrh;e;J ,Ug;gJ
Fw;wkhfhJ vd;W vd;Dld; tPz;thjk; nra;jhh;. ,jd; %ykhf mth;
Kd;dhs; fhjyDld; njhlh;gpy; ,Ug;gij ntspg;gilahfNt
xg;Gf;nfhz;lhh;;.
6. .ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why; NkYk; eP kpfTk; tajhdtd; vjw;Fk; yha;f;fpy;yhjtd;
cd;Dld; vd;dhy; tho KbahJ vd;W cwtpdh; Kd;dpiyapy; $wptpl;L
Foe;ijfis ,Oj;Jr;nrd;Wtpl;lhh;. mjd; gpd; fle;f 31.12.2019 y; 1k;
kDjhuUf;F Mbd; ngl;hpf; vd;w Mz; Foe;ij gpwe;jJ.
7.ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why;.ehd; vt;tsT mwpTiu $wpAk; 1k; kDjhuh; Nfl;fhjjhy;
Foe;ijfSf;fhf > mtu;fspd; vjpu;fhyj;ij fUj;jpy; nfhz;L
ngupath;fis itj;J Ngrp jPh;T fhz KbT nra;Njd;.midj;J
Kaw;rpfSk; Vkhw;wj;ij juNt 1k; kDjhuUf;F vjpuhf ,k;khz;GkpF
FLk;gey ePjpkd;wj;jpy; tpthfuj;J kD jhf;fy; nra;Njd;.me;j
kDthdJ I.D.O.P NO. 117/2022 vd ek;guhfp rkurk; Ngr rkur
ikaj;jpw;F mDg;gg;gl;lJ. mjpy; ehd; rpy Nfhhpf;iffis
Kd;itf;fNt> mjid 1k; kDjhuh; kWj;jhh; vdNt rkur ikaj;jpy;
jPh;T fhz glhjjhy;> rkur ikaj;jpy; ,Ue;J kPz;Lk; ePjpkd;wj;jpw;F
tof;fhdJ rkur ikaj;jpd; jiyik mjpfhhp mth;fshy;
mDg;gg;gl;lJ. Mdhy; mjd; gpd; 06.07.2022 md;W 1k; kDjhuh; Nrh;e;J
tho;tjw;F kWghprPyid nra;a Ntz;bdhh;;. mjd; gb ehDk; 1k;;
kDjhuUk; Nrh;e;J tho nkNkh jhf;fy; nra;Njhk;.mjd; ngahpy; me;j
kDthd ID.OP No.117/2022 js;Sgb nra;;ag;gl;lJ. Mdhy; 1k; kDjhuh;
vd;Dld; Nrh;e;J tho tuhky; 2022 nrg;gk;gh; 26k; ehs; Foe;ijfSld;
te;J tPl;bd; thrypy; jfuhW nra;J> rz;ilapl;L kWehs; 27k; Njjp
fhisahh;Nfhtpy; fhty; epiyaj;jpy; Gfhh; mspj;jhh;.mjd; gpd; kPz;Lk;
tof;fk; Nghy; 1k; kDjhuh; vd;id iftpl;L jdJ rhjpia rhh;e;j
Kd;dhs; fhjyUld; xOf;ff;Nflhd tho;f;ifia mtuJ Cuhd
,uhNk];tuj;jpy; Nkw;nfhz;lhh;.
8. ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why; ,e;j kDit 1k; kDjhuh; vdf;F vjpuhf jhf;fy; nra;a
vdf;Fk; 1k; kDjhuUf;Fk; ve;j njhlh;Gk; ,y;iy. ,jdhy; kpfTk;
ntl;fkilfpNwd;> tPjpapy; vd;dhy; jiy epkph;e;J elf;f ,aytpy;iy
.,e;j R+o;epiyapy; vdf;F ,uz;L topfs; kl;LNk cs;sJ xd;W vd;
tho;it Kbj;Jf;nfhs;tJ kw;nwd;W mtUld; tpthfuj;J nra;J
nfhs;tJ. Xt;nthU epkplKk; ehd; kdjstpy; ghjpf;fg;gl;Ls;Nsd;. 1k;
kDjhuhpd; xt;nthU nraYk;>eltbf;iffSk; NtjidiaAk;>
rpj;jputijaAk; kdjstpy; Fog;gj;ijAk;>kd mOj;jj;ijAk;
Vw;gLj;JfpwJ.
9. ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why; NkYk; 1k; kDjhuh; vd;dplk; NkhrkhfTk;>nfhLukhd
KiwapYk; ele;J nfhs;tJ vdf;F kpFe;j kdcisr;riy
Vw;gLj;jpaJ.NkYk; vd;id iftpl;L fle;j 29.3.2019 y; ,Ue;J
xOf;ff;Nflhd tho;f;ifia Nkw;nfhz;Ls;shh; .MfNt ,dpNkw;nfhz;Lk;
,UtUk; Nrh;e;J tho;tnjd;gJ rhj;jpakw;wnjhd;W. NkYk; fle;j tUlk;
jhf;fy; nra;j tpthfuj;J kDthdJ rkurj;jpd; ngahpy; js;Sgb
nra;ag;gl;lJ jFjpapd; tprhuizapd; mbg;gilapy; ,y;iy. MfNt
fle;j 06.07.2022 md;W IDOP.No 117/2022 y; toq;fg;gl;;l jPh;g;ghdJ res
judicata Mf nray;glhJ. res judicata vd;gJ rl;lk; kw;Wk; cz;ik gw;wpa
Nfs;tpfis cs;slf;fpaJ>MfNt jFjpapd; mbg;gilapy; cj;juT
toq;f rhl;rpapd; Mjhuq;fs; Njitg;gLfpwJ.khz;GkpF cr;r
ePjpkd;wj;jpd;; mwpf;ifaplg;gl;l AIR 2015 cr;rePjk ; d;w tof;F vz;
3357(Vaish Aggarwal Panchayat vs Inder kumar and others) y;
mwpf;ifaplg;gl;l khz;GkpF cr;r ePjpkd;wj;jpd; jPh;g;gpy; cs;s
mtjhdpg;Gfspd; gb res judicata Mf nray;glhJ. vdNt kDit
epuhfhpf;f mJ fhuzkhf ,Uf;fhJ.
10. ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why; NkYk; 1k; kDjhuh; jdJ tho;f;ifapy; xOf;ff;Nflhd
tho;f;ifia tho;e;jth;. mjdhy; mtuhy; vdJ Foe;ijfis rhpahd
Kiwapy; topelj;j jFjpaw;wth;.MfNt ehd; vdJ ,uz;L
Foe;ijfisAk; ghuhkhpf;f jahuhf cs;Nsd;.NkYk; ,k; khz;GkpF
ePjpkd;wj;jpy; xU fhbad; mry; kDit jhf;fy; nra;a tpUk;GfpNwd;.
11. ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why;>NkYk; 1k; kDjhuh; gl;lg;gbg;ig epiwT nra;j
gl;ljhhp>NkYk; xU kPd;gpb epWtdj;jpy; vOj;juhf gzpGupfpwhh; khj
rk;gskhf &45>000/- ngw;W jd;idj;jhNd guhkhpf;Fk; mstpwF
jd;dpiwT ngw;wth;.
12. ehd; ,k;khz;GkpF ePjpkd;wj;jpy; kpfTk; gzpTld; rkh;gpg;gJ
vd;dntd;why; 1k; kDjhuh; kdjstpy; vd;id Jd;GWj;j Ntz;Lnkd;Nw
,e;j kDit jhf;fy; nra;Js;shh;.1k; kDjhuhy; kd uPjpahf
ghjpf;fg;gl;l ehd; jw;nghOJ ve;j xU Ntiyf;Fk; nry;y ,ayhky;
eilgpzkhfNt tho;e;J tUfpNwd;. NkYk; vdJ jhahhpd; kUj;Jt
nrytpw;F $l topapd;wp gy ,lq;fspy; fld; ngw;W> md;whl nrytpw;F
topapd;wp jpz;lhb tUfpNwd;.
vdNt ,k;khzk;GkpF ePjpkd;wk; fUiz $h;e;J ,k;kDit
js;Sgb nra;J cj;ju gpwg;gpf;FkhW kpfTk; gzpTld; Ntz;lg;gLfpwJ.

NkNy fz;l rq;fjpfs; ahTk; cz;iknad cWjpf;$wp rptfq;ifapy;

03.07.2023 md;W vd; Kd;dhy; ifnahg;gk; nra;jhh;.

tof;fwpQh;
khz;GkpF FLk;g ey ePjPkd;wk;
rptfq;if

MC.NO 19/2023
_______________________________
vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; jhf;fy;
nra;Ak; gpukhz cWjpnkhop Mtzk;
________________________________________________________
kDjhuh;fs;
,d;ngd;l; ypd;rp kw;Wk; ,Uth;

tof;FiuQh;fs;
jpU M.FUjh]; B.A.,B.L.,
jpU O.rptf;Fkhh; BSc.,B.L.,
jpU K.fhh;j;jpf; M.B.A.L.L.B.,
jpU S.Mfh~; B.B.A.,L.L.B.,
jpU P.mUz; BSc.,L.L.B.,

vjph;kDjhuh;
me;Njhzp Nyhgd;