Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Computational Analysis of Triangular and Honeycomb Lattice-Structured Tapered Nanoholes For Enhanced Light Trapping in Thin-Film Si Solar Cells
Computational Analysis of Triangular and Honeycomb Lattice-Structured Tapered Nanoholes For Enhanced Light Trapping in Thin-Film Si Solar Cells
Computational Analysis of Triangular and Honeycomb Lattice-Structured Tapered Nanoholes For Enhanced Light Trapping in Thin-Film Si Solar Cells
SPIEDigitalLibrary.org/conference-proceedings-of-spie
Helmholtz-Zentrum Berlin für Materialien und Energie, Kekuléstr. 5, 12489 Berlin Germany
ABSTRACT
For an optimized light harvesting while using diverse periodic photonic light-trapping architectures in low cost thin film
crystalline silicon (c-Si) solar cells, it is also of prime importance to tune the features of their lattice point basis structure.
In view of this, tapered nanoholes would be of importance for envisaged better light in-coupling due to graded index
effect and also from the point of fabrication feasibility. Using a 3D finite element method based computational simulator,
we investigate the basis structural influence of triangular as well as honeycomb lattice-structured experimentally feasible
tapered air nanoholes in ~400 nm thick c-Si absorber on a glass substrate. We present a detailed convergence analysis of
volume absorption in Si absorber with cylindrical as well as tapered nanoholes. For a wavelength rage of 300 nm to 1100
nm, we present the computed results on light absorption of the engineered Si nanoholes for a lattice periodicity of600nm.
In particular, we study the influence of tapering angle of engineered nano air holes in Si thin film for the absorption
enhancement in photonic triangular and honeycomb lattice structured tapered nanoholes. Further we make a comparative
analysis of cylindrical and tapered nanoholes for a range of light incident angles from 0° to 60°. For the presented
triangular as well as honeycomb lattice structured nanoholes, we observe that in comparison to the cylindrical nanoholes,
the tapered nanoholes perform better in terms of light trapping for enhanced light absorption in textured Si thin films
even when the effective volume fraction of Si is lower in the absorber layer with tapered nanoholes in comparison to that
of cylindrical ones. From the maximum achievable short circuit current density estimation in the present study, the
performance of c-Si absorbing layer engineered with triangular lattice structured tapered air holes harvests light
efficiently owing to its higher lattice symmetry among periodic structures as well as graded index effect of the tapered
nanoholes.
Keywords: nanophotonic light trapping, finite element method, crystalline silicon, photonic crystals, thin-film solar cells
1. INTRODUCTION
In comparison to conventional thick crystalline silicon (c-Si) solar cells, thin-film c-Si solar cells are envisaged to use
much thinner layer of absorbing material than the absorption depth of c-Si itself [1]. Moreover, Si being an indirect
bandgap semiconductor, it has a lower absorption coefficient in the near infrared regime of desirable solar spectrum. So
efficient and optimized nanophotonic light trapping for thin-film c-Si solar cells is inevitable in order to effectively
increase the optical path length within the absorbing material in realizing the cost reduction of absorbing material
without compromising their optical absorption efficiency. Nanophotonic light trapping structures have been studied for
c-Si thin film solar cells as they significantly surpass the light path enhancement limit of geometrical ray optics [2] by
means of efficient optical coupling of the incident sunlight into the nanostructured thin-film absorber as well as a large
density of waveguide modes in the absorbing Si material [1, 3, 4]. Periodic nanophotonic structures being mostly
fabrication-friendly in concrete applications, molding the absorbing silicon material in diverse periodic lattice geometries
have been investigated to efficiently route and absorb the incident light [1, 3-9].
aid
(p) (3)
Ia ¡\ .00ii
Il ïr !11\ .rD r IÌI o OAÌI
;v#imfii)i$h#M%J
v
.7.0..
ipIQ1VQIQVIQ,I
11
e á O:o6 i9
n/VIDo.
D/".odi
Dii Dii
o
iLl..,
v0 v.r.va.
DN
%Oö íI1106
-. -. .r-i/ïr `DB.plp
1/v
.oIID,
eg
aoiilllQ_
O°:;m¡m¡. ïO- °
/%Owiii
IIpD' D. .pr.
,//'`1//,``ttI``il,'II``I'I
`r'ái "Oi óáij'Oi ói%Or \iib
;_Ì
I °..-i.
íi -I/1;i,`I''``II'
.-6i: .i -% iï00:p:/ïn
.-i: äi
II ' :e`--IIID',.IIIID.°ID:
iv
ïrGii',.:'Orï,::%C
...v::e`.
.I,11,.,,I111--
/I
'/I "
-':..,:..
-=-- :.,..á:
(w
'o..:':o..cv,:i:.Ilc':i
,%,:::
100 00 o/I uh=l
I A
.: --.:,IQIL:,IQI;,IIIIQ.;,l,.;,ll
-o,0D1- ---- - :I .'../
---D%- s>-- -.-z --
'-;:'o
.-' oGróC`iïii
,/ .c. ::rp.:...:
:.., vpw--
\a
: Ip I 1 ì ; / y : : l
,.-:
3' l li rÌ
>,.
%9; -c.
2:l
,aa. :
-.._---°..-:::==,.__.>=°.e-=::==..-:::=
..s i
lar Ice rir ir
(q) (e)
Fig. 1. (a) Triangular lattice structured air holes etched in Si thin-film on a glass substrate. (b) Honeycomb
lattice structured air holes etched in Si thin-film on a glass substrate. (c) and (d) are the respective x-z planes.
(d)
1.E +00 - t Rel errorforA=600 nm
f Rel errorforA=750 nm
1.E -01 -
-k-Rel errorforA=900 nm
1.E -04 -
1.E-05
0 1 2 3 4 5
The time harmonic volume absorption is computed considering the complex valued permittivity of Si-Palik. For the
convergence analysis of the volume absorption in material for a given wavelength, we keep the initial finite element
mesh and increase the finite element polynomial degree (p). From the resultant analysis, a combination of mesh
parameters and p with efficient computational cost as well as needed accuracy are chosen for the subsequent
computations. A semi-logarithmic plot of the relative error in volume absorption in Si absorbing layer is given in in Fig.
2d, where the relative error is calculated in reference to the solution of finite element degree of 6. We have taken the
cases of volume absorption at three different wavelengths respectively λ = 600 nm, 750 nm and 900 nm. We could
observe the expected exponential convergence as seen in the plots. The computations were executed on a multi-core
computer using 15 cores and maximum required memory was below 35 GB for the present study. The convergence
analysis of the volume absorption in Si layer was then repeated for the case of tapered triangular lattice air holes in Si
(d) tRel_erroratÀ=600 nm
1.E+00 - -0- Rel_erroratÀ=750 nm
-h- Rel erroratÀ =900 nm
1.E -01
o
1.E-04
1.E -05 -
1.E -06
0 1 2 3 4 5
p (Finite Element Degree)
Fig. 3. (a)-(c) Mesh grid schematic of triangular lattice structured Si film on a
glass substrate with tapered air holes with θta = 15. (d) Convergence analysis of
volume absorption in c-Si thin film absorber given in the model (a) for three
different incident light wavelengths. Relative error is calculated in reference to
the solution of finite element degree of 6.
r
honeycomb lattice structures in the optical absorption in textured Si layer.
(a) 4.09
-1
I, ,,
VII 1 -7.17
a
Fig. 4. Electric field intensity plots in log scale for triangular lattice structured Si absorber thin film (a)-(b) Electric field
intensity in Si lattice structured with cylindrical air holes respectively for wavelengths λ = 600 nm and 750 nm. Images are
respectively top x-y plane (left), x-y plane at a height of 200 nm below with in Si layer (middle) and centrally cut y-z plane
(right). (c)-(d) are respectively for lattice structured with tapered air holes with θta = 15.
60,00
C 50,00
O
Ç. 40,00
Ó
jj 30,00
ó0 20,00
10,00
0,00
300 400 500 600 7W 800 900 1000 11W
Wavelength, nm
40,00
35,00
f (b)
%Avg. Absorption
si_Volume traction_unit cell (x 10^40 1703)
20,00
18,00
X
16,00 a IC
C 30,00 O
14,00 IJ C
6 25,00 12,00 3 ry
ó
It 20,00 10,00'.
a
lb 15,00
8,00 ô
6,00 IC
ae 10,00
4,00
5,00
2,00
Ñ
0,00 0,00
o 10 15 20 25
Tapering Angle (O.),"
Fig. 5. (a) Optical absorption analysis of triangular lattice structured Si absorber of 390 nm thickness engineered with air holes of
varying tapering angle. A planar Si thin film of same thickness is also given as reference. (b) Analysis of influence of tapering
angle in the present lattice basis geometry on the volume fraction of Si absorber as well as on average optical absorption.
The geometrical model was already explained in the previous section. We compare our results for tapered air holes in Si
with that of Si absorber with cylindrical holes having a diameter of 377 nm.
70,00
a -%Abs Bta =O Inc. Angle =0
-%Abs_Ota = 0_Inc. Angle = 20
%Abs_Bta = 0_Inc. Angle =40
60,00
-%Abs_Ota = 0_Inc. Angle = 60
50,00
4000
S 30,00
Q
zo,00
10,00
0,00
300 900 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100
Wavelength, nm
(b)
80,00
-% AbsBta = 15_Inc. Angle = 0
-% Abs__Bta = 15_Inc. Angle = 20
% Abs_Ota = 15_Inc. Angle = 40
70,00
-% Abs_Bta = 15_Inc. Angle = 60
60,00
C 50,00
O
a 40,00
Ó
á 30,00
20,00
10,00
t ¡
's-
7
.
3.76
_
. 1.
1
I-780
3.70
8.19
Fig. 7. Electric field intensity plots in log scale for honeycomb lattice structured Si absorber thin
film (a) Electric field intensity in Si lattice structured with cylindrical air holes for wavelength λ=
600 nm. Images are respectively top x-y plane (left), x-y plane at a height of 200 nm below with in
Si layer (middle) and centrally cut y-z plane (right). (b) Respectively for lattice structured with
tapered air holes with θta = 15.
Considering the importance of photonic honeycomb lattice in the field of photonic crystals [18], in the following part we
give an absorption analysis of Si thin film engineered with air holes arranged in this lattice structural geometry.
50,00
C
O 40,00
. 30,00
a
a 20,00
e
10,00
0,00
300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100
Wavelength, nm
Fig. 8. Optical absorption analysis of honeycomb lattice structured Si
absorber of 390 nm thickness engineered with air holes of varying tapering
angle. A planar Si thin film of same thickness is also given as reference.
We considered a rectangular unit cell for the case of honeycomb lattice structure. Otherwise, the structural parameters
such as Si thickness, hole diameter etc. of the layer layout used in optical modelling here is same as that of the triangular
lattice structure dealt earlier. In Fig. 7, the computed electric field intensity distributions are given. The optical
(a)
70,00 -% Bta =O lnc. Angle =0
-% Abs_eta a 0_Inc. Angle a 20
-. %Abs_eta = O_Inc. Angle a 40
60,00
-%Abs_Bta = 0_Inc. Angle = 60
50,00
C
ra 40.00
ó
30,00
4
20,00
10,00
0,00
300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100
Wavelength, nm
(b)
80,00 -% Abs_Bta = 15_Inc. Angle e 0
-% Abs_eta = 15_Inc. Angle a 20
% Abs Bta = 15 Inc. Angle r 40
70,00
-%Abs Bta 15_Inc. Angle r 60
60,00
CO 50,00
O. 40,00
Ó
VI
a 30,00
20,00
10,00
0,00
300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100
Wavelength, nm
Finally, in order to have a comparative glimpse on the performance of the hexagonal lattice structured air holes to those
of the honeycomb lattice structured air holes when they are engineered in c-Si absorbing layer, we calculated the
ultimate short circuit current density (jsc, ultimate) for a range of light incident angles from 0° to 60°. Here we assume that
each absorbed photon of the solar spectrum AM1.5g contributes on charge carrier [19]. For a given lattice structure we
have compared the cases of both cylindrical air holes and tapered air holes (θta = 15°). As shown in Fig. 10, for the given
structural parameters of the etched air holes, c-Si engineered with hexagonal lattice structured tapered air holes has an
upper hand on the maximum achievable short circuit current density.
4. CONCLUSION
We have investigated using a 3D finite element method based computational simulator, the lattice basis structural
influence of triangular as well as honeycomb lattice-structured experimentally feasible tapered air nanoholes in ~400 nm
thick c-Si absorber on a glass substrate. We have presented the computational convergence analysis of volume optical
absorption in Si absorber with cylindrical as well as tapered nanoholes. For a wavelength rage of 300 nm to 1100 nm, we
have presented the computed results on light absorption of the engineered Si nanoholes for a lattice periodicity of 600
nm. In particular, we have presented our results on the influence of tapering angle of engineered air holes in Si thin film
for the optimized absorption enhancement in triangular and honeycomb lattice structured tapered nanoholes. Further we
have presented a comparative analysis of cylindrical and tapered nanoholes for a range of light incident angles up to 60°.
ry
12
--_ .-_--_ __
-- _ --- '---_ ______-- ---_____-___ __________<
_______
= ------- _
á10 11' ---'---- --------------a
É
8
6-
4
o 10 20 30 40 50 60
Incident Angle ( °)
Fig. 10. Estimated maximum achievable short circuit current densities (jsc)
for a range of incident angles. Neither anti-reflection layer nor back reflector
is considered here. Silicon deposition thickness = 390 nm.
For the presented triangular as well as honeycomb lattice structured nanoholes, we observe that in comparison to the
cylindrical nanoholes, the tapered nanoholes perform better in terms of light trapping resulting in an enhanced light
absorption in textured Si thin films even when the effective volume fraction of Si is lower in the absorber layer with
tapered nanoholes in comparison to the film with cylindrical air holes. From the maximum achievable short circuit
current density estimation in the present study, the performance of c-Si absorbing layer engineered with triangular lattice
structured tapered air holes harvests light efficiently owing to its higher lattice symmetry among periodic structures as
well as graded index effect of the tapered nanoholes.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Authors thank S. Burger, M. Hammerschmidt, D. Lockau, and F. Schmidt of ZIB, Berlin for the fruitful discussions.The
German Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) is acknowledged for funding the research activities of the
Young Investigator Group ‘Nano-SIPPE’ (Nanostructured SIlicon for Photonic and Photovoltaic ImplEmentations) at
HZB in the program NanoMatFutur (no.03X5520).
REFERENCES
[1] Yu, Z., Raman, A., and Fan, S., “Fundamental limit of light trapping in grating structures,” Opt. Express 18,
A366 (2010).
[2] Yablonovitch, E., “Statistical ray optics,” J. Opt. Soc. Am. 72, 899 (1982).
[3] Polman, A.., and Atwater, H. A.., “Photonic design principles for ultrahigh-efficiency photovoltaics,” Nat. Mat.
11, 174 (2012).
[4] Bozzola, A., Liscidini, M., and Andreani, L. C., “Photonic light-trapping versus Lambertian limits in thin film
silicon solar cells with 1D and 2D periodic patterns,” Opt. Express 20, A224 (2012).
[5] Han, S.E., Chen, G., “Optical Absorption Enhancement in Silicon Nanohole Arrays for Solar Photovoltaics,”
Nano Lett. 10, 1012 (2010).
[6] Du, Q. G., Kam, C. H., Demir, H. V., Yu, H. Y., and Sun, X. W., “Enhanced optical absorption in
nanopatterned silicon thin films with a nano-cone-hole structure for photovoltaic applications,” Opt. Lett. 36,
1713 (2011).