Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Injury: David J. Wright, Brent Etiz, John A. Scolaro
Injury: David J. Wright, Brent Etiz, John A. Scolaro
Injury: David J. Wright, Brent Etiz, John A. Scolaro
Injury
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/injury
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: Introduction: Bicondylar tibial plateau fractures with meta-diaphyseal comminution commonly have a
Accepted 4 July 2021 compromised soft tissue envelope. Combined plate-nail fixation is an emerging technique that utilizes
Available online xxx
a limited anterolateral approach for plate application and percutaneous incisions for placement of an
Keywords: intramedullary nail. This technique alleviates the need for a separate medial approach to the proximal
Bicondylar plateau tibia. We report a series of patients treated with this approach and outline the steps for implementation.
Tibia Methods: We performed a retrospective review of 18 consecutive patients treated with combination lat-
Plate
eral locked plating and intramedullary nailing at a single academic institution from 2016 to 2019. Of
Nail
these, 16 patients met inclusion criteria and were included in this study. All patients had AO/OTA type
41C2/C3 fractures. Primary outcomes included coronal plane and sagittal plane alignment at latest follow
up, rate of articular subsidence at latest follow up, and rate of postoperative infection.
Results: Of the 16 patients included, average followup was 8.2 months (range 0.1-29.7 months). At latest
follow-up, average coronal alignment ranged from 0.8±1.2 degrees of varus (maximum 4.0 degrees) to
1.4±1.7 degrees of valgus (maximum 4.0 degrees). Average sagittal alignment ranged from 0.8±1.1 de-
grees of procurvatum (maximum 3.0 degrees) to 0.6±1.2 degrees of recurvatum (maximum 4.0 degrees).
There was no radiographic evidence of articular subsidence at latest follow up for any patient. One pa-
tient (5.9%) presented at 141 days postoperatively with a draining wound and infection.
Conclusions: Combination plate-nail fixation is a viable option for treating patients with select bicondylar
tibial plateau fractures with meta-diaphyseal comminution. This case series with short-term followup
demonstrates acceptable radiographic and clinical outcomes, as well as rates of postoperative infection
and implant removal similar to those currently reported in the literature for other techniques used to
treat these fractures.
© 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Introduction soft tissues for the desired surgical approach(es). The anterolateral
approach is frequently used for fixation of bicondylar patterns, but
Bicondylar tibial plateau fractures are complex injuries. Treat- controversy remains regarding indications for a concurrent medial
ment goals include anatomic reconstruction of the articular sur- or posteromedial approach. Initial results following use of the dual
face, restoration of coronal and sagittal plane alignment, and stable incision technique reported an unacceptably high complication rate
fixation allowing for immediate range of motion. Many bicondylar [5]. More contemporary studies report a complication rate between
plateau fractures are the result of high energy trauma, and man- 8-23% [1,6–8].
agement of the soft tissue envelope is critical in order to avoid The combined use of a proximal tibial plate and intramedullary
complications. nail has been described for the fixation of noncontiguous uni-
Currently, many high energy tibial plateau fractures are treated condylar tibial plateau and shaft fractures [9]. To our knowledge,
in a staged manner. Initial external fixation is followed by ad- concurrent tibial plate and intramedullary nail fixation of intra-
vanced radiographic evaluation and surgical planning [1–4]. Timing articular bicondylar tibial plateau fractures, AO/OTA types 41C2/C3,
of definitive surgical fixation is determined by the readiness of the has not been described in the literature. This technique utilizes a
relatively small anterolateral surgical approach for reduction and
fixation of the articular surface with a proximal tibial locking plate,
∗
Corresponding author. followed by percutaneous placement of an intramedullary nail.
E-mail address: jscolaro@hs.uci.edu (J.A. Scolaro).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2021.07.010
0020-1383/© 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Please cite this article as: D.J. Wright, B. Etiz and J.A. Scolaro, Combined plate and nail fixation of bicondylar tibial plateau fractures,
Injury, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.injury.2021.07.010
JID: JINJ
ARTICLE IN PRESS [m5G;July 15, 2021;9:31]
D.J. Wright, B. Etiz and J.A. Scolaro Injury xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 1. Anteroposterior (A) and lateral (B) radiographs of a 41-year-old male in-
volved in a motorcycle collision showing a proximal tibia fracture with metaphyseal
comminution and a depressed lateral plateau.
Fig. 2. Clinical photos showing lateral (A) and medial (B) soft tissues following ini-
This technique eliminates the need for a medial surgical approach tial external fixation. The medial soft tissue envelope was characterized by marked
abrasions and a subcutaneous degloving injury.
and fixation by providing intramedullary support to resist varus
failure. One of the primary advantages of the technique is preser-
vation of the subcutaneous medial soft tissue envelope, which is
commonly traumatized. The limited surgical footprint needed for
lateral plate and intramedullary nail placement may decrease the
complication rate associated with use of a standard dual inci-
the anteromedial surface of the tibia results in added risk for soft
sions approach. Furthermore, the time between injury and defini-
tissue complications following definitive fixation utilizing a medial
tive treatment may be shortened, expediting rehabilitation and de-
approach. Therefore, evaluation of the anteromedial soft tissues is
creasing hospital length of stay. In this study, we describe our sur-
one of the critical factors in selecting patients for combined plate-
gical technique and experience in a series of 18 consecutive pa-
nail fixation.
tients treated with combined pre-contoured lateral locked plat-
Next, close evaluation of the AP and lateral radiographs is per-
ing and intramedullary nailing for intra-articular bicondylar tibial
formed. Bicondylar tibial plateau fractures with metaphyseal com-
plateau fractures.
minution and relatively simple intra-articular pathology are ideal
candidates for this technique. Furthermore, patterns that have a
Surgical technique large medial plateau fragment are ideal. Knee fracture dislocations
in which there is a medial plateau fragment that requires a direct
Pre-operative evaluation anatomic reduction and fixation with a medial sided buttress plate
are not desirable patterns for this technique.
Initial evaluation of any patient with a bicondylar tibial plateau Axial, coronal, and sagittal CT imaging is then closely evaluated
fracture begins with an appropriate history and physical examina- (Fig. 3A-C). The anterior aspect of the proximal tibia is evaluated
tion. A full neurovascular examination of the limb is mandatory to ensure that the anticipated intramedullary nail start point is not
and should be documented. Given the high-energy nature of many within a zone of comminution, contiguous with a displaced artic-
of these injuries, particular attention should be given to evaluation ular fragment on either the medial or lateral plateau, or in a posi-
of the associated soft tissue injury as well as signs and/or symp- tion that may induce malreduction. Next, the anterior tibial cortex
toms of compartment syndrome. Standard anteroposterior (AP) and and tibial tubercle are evaluated to ensure that the nail will not
lateral radiographs of the affected extremity are then be obtained displace these fragments (when present) or prevent maintenance
(Fig. 1A-B). For length-unstable injuries, we employ a staged man- of nail position within the proximal segment. Finally, the medial
agement protocol beginning with application of a knee-spanning plateau is carefully evaluated. As noted, if a posteromedial frac-
external fixator. Following restoration of limb length, alignment, ture fragment is displaced or the size/morphology is such that it
and rotation with the use of an external fixator, a postoperative cannot be adequately captured by a laterally based proximal tib-
CT is obtained to further evaluate the fracture morphology and aid ial locking plate, then a separate medial approach and implant is
in pre-operative planning for definitive fixation. indicated [10]. A posteromedial fracture fragment does not neces-
Selection for combined plate nail fixation is based on multi- sarily preclude fixation with a plate and nail. However, if a for-
ple factors. First, the technique is considered when there has been mal approach is made on the medial side, then fixation will com-
marked injury to the soft tissues about the proximal tibia that monly proceed with a plate, alleviating the need for an additional
may delay or prohibit a medial-sided exposure. In closed fractures, intramedullary implant. Relative indications and contraindications
soft tissue injuries commonly manifest as abrasions, ecchymosis, or to plate-nail fixation of bicondylar tibial plateau fractures are sum-
subcutaneous degloving (Fig. 2A-B). The subcutaneous position of marized in Fig. 4.
2
JID: JINJ
ARTICLE IN PRESS [m5G;July 15, 2021;9:31]
D.J. Wright, B. Etiz and J.A. Scolaro Injury xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 3. Axial (A), sagittal (B) and coronal (C) computed tomography images showing lateral plateau depression and bicondylar involvement of the fracture.
Fig. 4. Relative indications and contraindications when considering combined plate-nail fixation of intra-articular proximal tibia fractures.
Surgical fixation direct reduction techniques are then used to restore length align-
ment and rotation to the extra-articular metaphyseal/diaphyseal
At the time of surgical fixation, general anesthesia with phar- component of the fracture. Proximal fixation then occurs in the
macologic skeletal relaxion is administered. The patient is posi- most proximal row of the plate. Locking or nonlocking screws can
tioned supine on a radiolucent table with a bump under the ipsi- be utilized based on surgeon preference, fracture morphology, and
lateral ischium. If the patient has previously been placed in an ex- bone quality. Distally, unicortical locking or nonlocking screws are
ternal fixator, the clamps and bars are removed, and the half pins placed in a percutaneous manner into the lateral cortex of the tib-
are left in place for possible use with an intraoperative external ial diaphysis. If the plate is utilized to assist in the reduction of
fixator or universal distractor. After preparation and draping of the the tibial shaft, a bicortical screw can be used initially and then
leg, fixation commences with a standard anterolateral approach to exchanged for a unicortical screw prior to nail placement. A mini-
the proximal tibia including a sub-meniscal window, if needed, for mum of two distal screws are required for provisional fixation.
direct visualization of the articular reduction. Fixation priority is After both intra-articular and extra-articular reduction have
given to the articular surface. Any direct articular reduction of the been achieved and provisional plate fixation is complete, the in-
lateral plateau can be performed from this approach (Fig. 5A-B). tramedullary nail is placed. The authors prefer a semi-extended
If a medial-sided injury is amenable to percutaneous clamp place- approach to minimize manipulation of the limb, decrease the
ment and/or fixation, this is subsequently performed following lat- procurvatum deformity commonly seen in proximal tibia fracture
eral articular reduction. All provisional or definitive fixation should patterns with hyperflexion of the knee, and provide a percuta-
be placed in a subchondral location, outside of the anticipated pre- neous approach which is relatively remote from the zone of injury
contoured plate or intramedullary nail position. compared to an infra-patellar technique. The knee is placed over
Next, a standard anterolateral proximal tibial locking plate is a small radiolucent triangle or bump and a standard suprapatellar
placed in a submuscular fashion along the anterolateral surface of incision is made (Fig. 5D). The extended entry cannula is placed
the tibia (Fig. 5C). The length of the plate should span the meta- in a retropatellar fashion and tibial nailing proceeds with stan-
physeal comminution by a minimum of three holes. Direct or in- dard placement of the starting guidewire, proximal entry reamer,
3
JID: JINJ
ARTICLE IN PRESS [m5G;July 15, 2021;9:31]
D.J. Wright, B. Etiz and J.A. Scolaro Injury xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 5. Intraoperative lateral fluoroscopic images of the proximal tibia showing initial joint depression (A), elevation of the joint surface with a curved bone tamp (B),
provisional subchondral wire placement and positioning of lateral proximal tibia plate (C) and initiation of tibial nailing with three posterior screws within top row of plate
and unicortical shaft screws.
Fig. 6. Fluoroscopic views showing tibial nail placement (A) as well as AP (B) and lateral (C) fluoroscopic images showing completion of fixation with the remainder of
proximal-row screws and conversion of distal unicortical shaft screws to bicortical shaft screws placed anterior to the nail.
ball tipped guidewire, and medullary reamers. Once the nail length of the plate is obtained. When possible, one or more of the unicor-
and diameter have been selected, the nail is then passed over the tical screws is converted to a bicortical nonlocking screw directed
guidewire and positioned to the desired depth. In most cases our anterior or posterior to the nail (Fig. 6B-C). Final fluoroscopic ra-
preference is to place the nail such that the proximal end of the diographs are then obtained, and the knee joint and surgical in-
nail lies just distal to the proximal row of screws in the plate. Af- cisions are thoroughly irrigated (Fig. 7A-C). Closure is performed
ter nail placement, proximal interlocking bolts are placed in the according to the surgeon’s preference. If half pins remain in the
available positions. A minimum of two bolts, positioned along dif- femur or tibia they are removed at this time and sterile dressings
ferent axes, are recommended (Fig. 6A). Distally, the nail is locked are placed.
statically. Post operatively, the patient is placed in a soft dressing. Periop-
Once the nail has been placed, the remaining screws in the erative antibiotics and chemical venous thromboembolic prophy-
proximal row of the plate are placed in standard fashion. Addi- laxis are given as indicated. We utilize a protocol that allows for
tional distal screws within the metaphyseal section of the plate can immediate range of motion of the knee. Weight bearing is initiated
be placed around the nail, if desired. Finally, the distal unicortical based on degree of articular injury. Generally, patients remain non-
screws are revisited. A lateral fluoroscopic view of the distal end weight bearing for 6 – 12 weeks and are subsequently progressed
4
JID: JINJ
ARTICLE IN PRESS [m5G;July 15, 2021;9:31]
D.J. Wright, B. Etiz and J.A. Scolaro Injury xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 7. Final AP (A) and lateral (B) plain radiographs showing final plate and nail fixation construct. Clinical image (C) showing limited anterolateral approach and percuta-
neous incisions utilized for fixation.
to full weight bearing (Fig. 8). The broad steps of the surgical tech- tive fixation, weightbearing restrictions after surgery, knee range of
nique are summarized in Fig. 9. motion and incidence of knee pain at latest follow up, rate of ra-
diographic union, time to radiographic union, and rate of implant
Case series removal. Radiographic union was defined as bridging callus seen
on at least 3 of 4 corticies assessed by AP and lateral views. Other
Methods patient and demographic factors including age, gender, BMI, frac-
ture classification, open fracture, and smoking status were also in-
We performed a retrospective review of consecutive patients cluded.
with proximal tibia fractures treated with this technique at a single
academic institution from 2016 to 2020. Institutional Review Board Results
Approval was obtained for this study. Exclusion criteria included
extra-articular fracture patterns (AO/OTA 41A-type fractures) and Sixteen patients were included in the final analysis (7 fe-
fractures treated with adjunctive mini fragment plate(s) or an iso- males, 9 males, average age 52.1±17.4 years old). Average BMI was
lated rim-plate in addition to intramedullary nailing. A total of 18 26.4±4.2 kg/m2 . Six patients were active smokers at the time of in-
patients met inclusion criteria. Two patients were excluded after jury. There were 8 AO/OTA type 41C2 fractures and 8 AO/OTA type
further radiographic review deemed their injuries to be predom- 41C3 fractures. There were 3 open fractures. There were no cases
inantly extra-articular fracture patterns (AO/OTA type 41A frac- of compartment syndrome. Thirteen patients underwent temporiz-
tures). The remaining 16 patients were included in the study. Pri- ing external fixator placement at an average of 0.92 days after in-
mary outcomes included coronal plane and sagittal plane align- jury (range 0-2 days). The remaining 3 patients were managed in
ment at latest follow up, rate of articular subsidence at latest fol- long leg splint or knee immobilizer until definitive fixation. Aver-
low up, and rate of postoperative infection. Alignment measures age time to definitive fixation was 6.3±3.6 days after injury (range
were based on the best available AP and lateral radiographs at lat- 2-17 days). Average estimated blood loss was 306±144ml.
est follow up for each patient. As most patients did not have x- Average follow up was 8.2 months (range 0.1-29.7 months). At
rays of the contralateral uninjured extremity, 3 degrees of proximal latest follow-up, average coronal alignment ranged from 0.8±1.2
tibial varus and 7 degrees of posterior tibial slope were used as degrees of varus (maximum 4.0 degrees) to 1.4±1.7 degrees of
reference values. Varus/valgus and procurvatum/recurvatum were valgus (maximum 4.0 degrees). Average sagittal alignment ranged
measured relative to these reference values. Secondary outcomes from 0.8±1.1 degrees of procurvatum (maximum 3.0 degrees) to
included time to temporizing fixation, time to definitive fixation, 0.6±1.2 degrees of recurvatum (maximum 4.0 degrees). There was
rate of compartment syndrome, estimated blood loss during defini- no radiographic evidence of articular subsidence at latest follow up
5
JID: JINJ
ARTICLE IN PRESS [m5G;July 15, 2021;9:31]
D.J. Wright, B. Etiz and J.A. Scolaro Injury xxx (xxxx) xxx
Fig. 9. Surgical flowchart outlining the steps of the surgical technique beginning with articular reduction, followed by metaphyseal reduction, anterolateral plate fixation,
nail placement, and completion of plate fixation.
6
JID: JINJ
ARTICLE IN PRESS [m5G;July 15, 2021;9:31]
D.J. Wright, B. Etiz and J.A. Scolaro Injury xxx (xxxx) xxx