Download as pdf
Download as pdf
You are on page 1of 38
2) United States Patent Haider et al. (54) METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR COMPUTER AIDED SURGERY (71) Applicant: Bourd of Regents of the University of Nebraska, Lincoln, NE (US) (72) Inventors: Hani Haider, Carter Lake, LA (US) Osvaldo Andres Barrera, Omaha, NE ws) ersity of (73) Assignee: Bourd of Regents of the U Nebraska, Lincoln, NE (US) (4) Notice: Subjoct to any disclaimer the term of this patent is extended or adjusted under 35 USC. 1846) by 33 days This patent is subjeet to a terminal dis- claims, (21) Appl. Now 18/145,981 (22) Filed: Dee, 23, 2022 6s) Prior Publication Data 202310200009 AI Jun, 29, 2023 Related U.S. Application Data (63) Coatinnation of application No, 17/399,969, filed on Aug. 11, 2021, now Pat, No, 11,568,745, which is a (Continued) (1) Incr. AGIB 3420 4618 34/10 (201601) (201601) (Continued) a rand A61B 34/10 (2016.02); AOIB 17442 (2016.11), 4618 1715 (2013.01), 4618 ASH (2013.01) (Continved) A U 120 01185726582 US 11,857,265 B2 *Jan. 2, 2024 (10) Patent No.: (4s) Date of Patent: (58) Fleld of Classification Search cre AGIB 34/10; AGIB 34/20 See application file for compete seal histor. 66) References Cited US. PATENT DOCUMENTS. aqmaTT A sist NISRA Bugler 81973 Bent (Continved) FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS cx uus22st A 101997 (Continved) OTHER PUBLICATIONS Agus etal; A mkprocessor decoupled system forthe simlaton ‘of temporal bone argry, Comping and Visualization in ‘ol 3 Tssve 1, pp. 3543; Jl, 2002 (ator manuscript, 10 pes) (Continved) Primary Esaminer — Rochelle D Tuechen (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Nast Patent Law LLC Faisal K. Abou-Nast 7) ABSTRACT A number of improvements ate provided relating to come puter sided surgery. The improvement relates to both the methods used during computer aided surgery and the devices used during such procedures. Some ofthe improve- ‘ment relate to controlling the selection of which data to splay during a procedure andor how the data is displayed to aid the surgeon. Other improvements relate tothe stmc- ture ofthe tools used during a procedure and how the tools can be controled automatically to improve the efciency of the procedure, Sil other improvements relate to methods of providing feedback during a procedure to improve either the elicieney oF quality, ee bot, for 2 procedure, 20 Claims, 11 Drawing Sheets -600 80 | 570 WZ CK S & US 11,857,265 B2 Page 2 Related U.S. Application Data ‘continuation of application No. 14/831,601, filed on Aug. 20, 2015, now Pat. No. 11,116,574, which is a ‘continuation of application No. 11/927,429, filed on ‘Oct. 29, 2007, now abandoned, which is vont ation-in-part of application No. 11/764,506, filed on Jun. 18, 2007, now Pat. No. 8,560,047 (60) Provisional upplication No. 60'827,877, fled on Oct. 2, 2006, provisional application No. 60/814,370, fled ‘on Jun. 16, 2006, (1) Incr. AGIB 174 GIB 9000 AGI 34/30 AGB 9/11 AGIB IAS AGIB 176 GIB 177 AaiB 3400 A618 90190 ai 1700 AGI 1732 GIF 246 (2) US.a. CPC 1 A6IB 171675 (201301 (2006.01) (201601), (201601) (201601) (2006.01) (2006.01) (2006.01) (201601), (201601), (2005.01), (2006.01) (2006.01) AGIB 17703, (2013.01); AGI 171764 201301): ABLE 34720 (2016.02); AGIB 34/30 (2016.02), A61B HUH (2016.02): AGIB 906 (2016.02): 4618 17/1626 201301}; AGIB 34/25 (201602), A61B 90/90 (2016.02), 461 2017/0026 (2013.01), A61B 201700199 (2013.01), A618 2017000212 (2013.01); A61B 201700221 (2013.01), 4618 201700735 (2013.01), A618 20177320082 (2013.01): A61B 2034/01 (2016.02); 4618 2034/102 (2016.02, 461B 034/104 (2016.02), 4618 2034/05 (2016.02), 66) 3092 4 ‘Soso.oss DORLS A S2mc15 Adon 708 Sure sa2sors A x a a x 0.573 1618 2034/107 (2016.02), A61B 203/108 (2016.02), 461B 20342055 (2016.02); 461B 2034/2068 (2016.02): 4618 2034/2073 2016.02), 4618 2034/25 (2016.02); 4618 2034/286 (2016.02), 4618 034/258 (2016.02): 4618 2090061 (2016.02), 4618 2090/63 (2016.02), A6IB 2090/0812 (2016.02), 4618 2090/3653 (2016.02), 4618 2090367 (2016.02, 4618 20901372 (2016.02), 4618 20001395 (2016.02); 461B 2090/3937 (2016.02): A61F 2002/4632 (2013.01); A61F 2002/4633 References Cited USS. PATENT DOCUMENTS. Lys S1978 S930 Sips Si9si Tiss 1198s ‘visa Tivsa 119s 987 S987 Dinateo Droz Hevenor et Poors Fro eta ates ota Deorik el White Seilish ta Coun Gant ot Bromtoch @01301) +4560 970 Asceo87 Apas965 ainsi 300.095 Sawn Sora04 S265.988 Saeven Shas Saas S301 Sant s00 Siay's00 S433.717 She Sassen Ssotis9 Saou Ssenuts S01 S61 Sos.3is S11 028 Ser8s7 5622170 Soe sot S258 568.061 S901 Serer) So 85 SGs8.281 Seaton Sha0'so2 Shasrer Sasi it Ress'sis S769.087 Sheo.002 Ssae24 Sx00'976 Ss.206 30 S921 902 Soasoet S951478 595625) sor 767 Sorsere S98790) 5995738 41987 Ferano S198) Sandell et 21988. Keemn Kino ea Glassman ct Tyons Mick ea Hishner Sur Furmess Buch ta Helbrun tl. Rubik a. Bia eta Belge tal Wing eta Fries Gibson Mushabae Ten tal Helfbrun t Torenten etl haere. Schulz Sa Sklar Histo ot Berman e Fore eta Delp el Clipe ea. Sevait ea Cloutier eta Malin “Melaughin et Schule Westphal eta Wiliams, Ie Sahay eal. Shapiro eta Marin Evan ta. Milde Rosen et Sahay ea. eral Gan a. tips Digs I ea Gil Buuren Schule a Schule Contes ot Meyers etal Green Gers Gotshal Kaufman eta Stewart oa Messner Digi lea US 11,857,265 B2 Page 3 66) References Cited USS. PATENT DOCUMENTS. 6.002.839 ounsals dss 021s enssals Soseo02 Susana Ssn095 Sones fuso.t62 080.181 Sos. 163 onsa79 8216029 BI 6228.48 BI 6228089 BI 236.875 BL 248084 BL 6262738 BI 268230 BI o27kke? BL 6.285902 BI 9298262 BI 6314310 BI SLs BL 317616 BL 61310285 BI 0322567 BL 6320.78 BI 6332891 BI o336931 BL 347160 BI easrs73 BL 6368384 82 300982 BI 28.068 BI 6424885 BI eaaes47 BL 686868 B2 6468299 BI 6490207 BL 474159 BL 478802 B2 491,701 B2 21999 11599 11999 1/2000 3000 S00 5000 Gi 2000 2000 T2000 000 72000 72000 7000 83000 82000 9 2000 vo2u00 02000 112000 1000 i001 22001 aot 22001 32001 S200 2001 4001 4001 S001 Soo 5.001 2001 72001 72001 2001 9001 ono Hoo Huo 112001 1001 Hoot 122001 12001 Tam02 2002 4002 $2002 72002 002 82002 82002 2002 $2002 2002 9002 92002 9002 102002 102002 2002 12002 122002 Digi 1 ea. Tamer ot Conan Soi tal. Bandon ta Foley etal Mite ta. Gibson Susnjra Katoh eta. Parking ta Hier el Para ea Schule al Kanade ta (Goce eta Verdi ta Badano eta Cosman Shani Foxln Masi Wiliams Wills Peskin Delt ca Digiia et al Kreioman et Pall Foley et al Wahibare Bue tal Mark eta Gibwon eta Haynor etl vera ea iene oa Franck et emai el Williams ea Glossop Fermaniez ot al Mites el Calpe Himes su eta Foner ea Bret Barstcin et Bova etal Bons Niemeyer a iar eal Mitel Brock eta Mizoguchi eta Schult Shahi ta Browse Acker etal Sito al Bont Simon eta Fein ta aor 3 6301997 500195 16508267 ‘6503277 esi 51828 ‘6520228 6322306 ‘6380397 16552,722 6378360 Tso 58839 6591.98 ‘e008 ‘0886 (6020181 620,198 esisors 538.253 ‘640.127 ‘640 128 satT S40 6589939 16562036 560838 6.560.710 676.69 7832 ‘8h 129 Gss711 90.964 ‘97 64 702821 eri 71894 6730.128 rss? enrssi (6878 77007 ‘6380 007 16753 328207 ess (629.384 sar 992 esina94 S59 561 16392000 ors ‘6020 347 onsi7 om 823 ‘50a7 786 ‘96094 (6.063.792 Bor 6093.34 sood004 0s 08 ae 702708 7032458 RES LOD 7084867 73021565, 122002 123002 2008 vi003 003, 008 22003 22003 22008 32003 42003 4003 ‘2003 o03 ‘2003 ‘e200 ‘62003, 72008 73008 2003 ‘003 ‘2003 102003 1012003 102003 to2603 112003 123003 2003 122003 122003 12004 1004 oo 22004 22004 22008 Soot 200 00a ‘#2004 2004 $2004 ‘2008 ‘62004 2004 2008 2004 Kelle Donat ta Kennedy ta Franck et a Shih ct al Rita st Roout Gallo e Carlson ta Sctee Ful ea nut Burstein ot Bonut Con et a Kowka otal Vilersir oa Lak Moll ta. Conta essa ea Moutatis cal Chale wa. Pearian Matsuri ot Axelson eal. ‘Bogor ea Kiendles Ill ta Bonut Reaune tal Kien ill then ta ethene a abi Sensen ea ‘Schoeiderman et Simeon ta Carson tl Grimm et. Sion eta Canasta Green Vaidyanathan a Delt ta Ebersole i Sion ef Sasso Gas Legge a Heth Kamae oa Tanaka Baimbers, Schult al Ho eal Kanade o a US 11,857,265 B2 Page 4 (66) References Cited 7949 544 52 9/2011 Mion ct Joes Ba Goll Dew etal USS. PATENT DOCUMENTS, 798738 B> 92011 Viswanathan 32011 etchant a ee S201 Rosner eta ee S201 Lombaet ea 2006s $2011 Quaid eal 10006 Barret $2011 Sith oa 739.601 B2 112006 heb et B2S2011 Hayes et a 7203277 B2 ‘42007 Bkenbach ea 2011 Sih a 7200805 62 4/3007 Dean B2 M2011 Sutherand et a 7300626 B2 43007 Quai eta B2 102011 Govai ea Toca Bs au? Shanks ta S080938 BL 112011 Groom te eta 7218508 B2 $2007 Zena S0s7a82 2102011 Cont eal 731737. Bo 3/007 Henderson ta. So74s62 B2 122011 unas ta Taiooe 2 S2007 Tene Sao 297 > "1012 Halu et a T2686 B26 07 O'neal $9699 B2 1/2012. Guteree a 728409 62 G 007 Hate weal. S108025 2 2012 Caavoy ea fase esl cane Stabs 83 22012 Claypool et 7258666 B2 2007 Hiroks aa S114092 B2 22012 tare eal 7302286 Bi 11/3007 Schellenberg S1ig847 B? 22012 Gatan ota 731400 B2 123007 Ciquhan a S117 B2 22012 Reiner Tsisoss Bs ‘To008 Mebeery S120675 B> 32012 Panda etal FA24015 B2 1/2008 Mm a 8126226 8223012 Bernal a 7361018 B2 4/3008 fund a 813138 B2 32012 Burglar 7306862 B2 42008 Dukesbre ea $1470 82 42012 Zhao ea FstOes B2 $2008 Lloyd ee a 8187826 B2 42012 Deng eta Ponies ies a tame S1e0.677 B2 42012 Ginn a. Tar79%4 B2 $008 Raisck a S1sh429 B2 $2012 Seno 7388073 B16 2008. Above etal S1SS951 B2 62012 Rapaport ot Fso9940 B27 008 Heo ta 62012 Reglos tal 7822.605 B2 92008 Barcin {62012 Nester ot 763.893 B2 122008 Birkenbach et 72012 Foxtin ta Fass Bz '2008. Zombo ea 8226690 B2 72012 Aare tal 7492930 B2 2/3000 Keir ea. S200.568 B2 72012 Frngin Vac es eerie 823963 > 72012 Hartmann ea F586652 B2 72009 Angin et S248415 B2 82012 Gattan etal ZESR617 B2 72009 Minne S2iN;414 B2 82012 Gatan al fakin sven eens $267.969 > 92012 hare et F561733 B2 72009 Vismeir ea 8536) B2 102012 Malackowski eta Tsar Be 7009 Clayon ea S287.600 B? 102012 Angtoaud 770986 B2 83000 Huang ca, $390°5% B2 102012 Hoppe ea 7574280 B2 £2009 Niemeyer ssinsit 2012, Catoy ea. 75940939 B29 2009 Rammecel tb Sisi99 2012 Jeane st a 7390.70 B2 102009 Hunter «a S300612 BY 112012 Knob aa 71680505 B2 123009 Marga a $320.96 2 112012 Panay a Teswose B2 12.2009 Phlpn «a. 833% B2 122012 Lown eal Zeaieeo B2 ‘1/010 Lakinet a SSeO047 B2 102013 Haider @ a Tei3.862 B2 12010. Schocateld 1OS56.795 2 220% Hola Feaes00 B2 22010 Hume sa 200110084839 AI 102001. Matackowshi eat Theses? B2 22010 Staton IV at a aon, 0si907 81122001 Ot over ed a aeseleeetatl aon3iootesas At "33002 Paterson ea 71997973 B2 42010. Swommer el gouzonioess AL 23002 Vang a 7506683 82 4/2010 Rosmer eta 2ooz0040220 AL 43002 Zune a eee es adeno] eee aun2!00m865 AL 62002 Banco eta Tse B3 $010 eka 200300120038 AL 92002 Conperthwaite 7326864 B2 62010. Golitch et a 20020156365 AI 102002 ‘Tckos ZTRN68 B26 2010 Raceague ea. 20020170399 AL 112002 Gas a aera ee casio oeune Sonsiooosst9 AL "13003 Trade ta Sarai B> 62010 Banke al 20030069891 AL 42003. Carson eta 7338495 6272010 Pease cea aoovorrests At 42003 Kanade cal Fho0909 B2 73010 Manus aunsooresss AL 42003 Haley Treen BS AG010 Gltah Jr. oa Gonso1siors AL $2003 Whiteide T7714 Be 82010 Patel ea 2ans02090% AI 112003 Pandey ea Eee eee aici donsioatosi2 AL 112003 Khamvne ta ‘Thotiee BS S010. Canante a aonsois720 AL 11200) Monta ea Salo Sigaat oisia39279 Al 122003 Arms UiBolo Bay coat aonarotsore AL "T2004 Tian ea etme aonaooe36s AL 2004 sek et a TRV B2 112010 Kruse eta aooanowass AL 32004 Hass FASO BE 122010 Grate a aooaoossi73 At 42004 Viswanathan 788.786 B2 123010 Waren ca aonaroests7 AL 42004 Keae ta GSieoat B10 Gites duoaioontiea AL $2004 Lin tal ss8705 8222011 Murphy aonaiooo2033 A $2004 Shaotan a 7394872 B2 22011 Shean 2004 0106916 AL 62004 Quai eta. Fo0$31 B—A2OLL Axelon ot a 2nna138586 AL 72004 Conman J>S341 BD ADOLL gwen ta 2onai7ie%4 AL 92004 Mine tf B2 42011 Reiner aonamoiss? Al 102004 Fostin B2 $2011 Redon etal. 200810015005 AL 12008 Koekso US 11,857,265 B2 7 erences Ci aos at ema (56) ae Cited 20080228108 At ‘Von Jako ef al Us prea Docume BEES N BBe ieee 2080107920 AL $2005 Ban sta ous 2s2726 aL a OSLO AL S205 Oana 20080269755 AL Malackowski etal 2005:0116673 62005. Cart et al. 2008'0281989 AL lager ct al. 20050119550 oe 200810291219 AL “Morita et al. Ssuleban AL Gas tS a fosmhae Xt oe 2 Snowe At ae Soosoioasea AL 92003 Waller 2ano)0017420 At ere Bourse at Sais Nesom geome At Mice Missle Aas Maer iaponsi A1 od led a 2009/0051763 AL “Adler et al. 20050210 eos 20090124891 AL ‘Shechter et al. Rsoustto At ioaies plore mmo A ee ae Rogie Al 6200 sited eee 33¢ i 2009/0228045 Al 9/2009 Hayes et al. Sonos AL 130 Mfg a aioe AI 9310) te 2eoswonIdoL AL y2an6, Showalter 20090981419 Al 112005 ‘Tvocskem tb poten peieboncr Suoooazassr AL 12200 Carey aa a ppetGt 201010036393 Al 2/2010 Unsworth. Socolass At Sa Bie ea promis a1 22010 Uno aaaeesaereiee tas amiea aes DOIMOLAIO6I AL — 62010 Kaobel et a. SiStams At Sal era oe 20060224151 AL 102006 Whaler aovo 174886 AL 72010. Smith ta pee poe cane SOMOS? AL 92010. Mtowie et a 20060241388 eee 20100256504 Al 10/2010 Moreau-Caudry et al. paces setae eae pice At Toate Mendy Pion aoe roaneeu etal 2O1V0130761 AL Plaskos et al. appear AL "Taos chanel mitoiirt At ao mpm AL 3ar Taal dnisnosan AL 333E i ca ROPOMINTS AL HOT ian Basu A ee oreo Vino Me 20140107471 AL laider et al rss AL at oer ts te 20070118140 52007 Bur et al 201710281280 Al 102017 Haider et al Impolssin Al to? Mon FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS Brus At 3207 a eee A eee et BE soos ae Sironestt At loa? owt | #2 Mirae AL (odor toate z ea ea Mocs At 706 Deke at B ong! ‘aati Simos AI 1s Shas z yon Bt gat Sawin At 1205 Sc = isu BI wate Roewsen At [es 2s B feiss at Waid Ses At 205 Sa 5 ici A'S aisoioor AL 365 See re ise SESUGDo Al Solos loam a Sar At gee imeolanes At $8 pee ws Selon at ie aioli AL $3005 xoabesta we ees ate race Miulsor Al 720g Cotte i ee aa Rosuison Al 740s ca aa Stites Ae Rosvig Al Taos casa we Siar AL S201 Aosvisiy AL 708 Kea WS Bums ae Ansesio AL Sao aimed 3S BURNS A TRS ser, At Sans han a Ho Bosses AP Ls US 11,857,265 B2 Page 6 66) References Cited FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS. wo 2ooso72629 AL 8/2005 wo aoosoranos AL 82008 wo ao0sorsons AL $2008 wo doomosens AL 5 2007 wo aou7onsssi AL 62007 wo ao070sso09 A2 $2007 wo aoonussis A? 102007 wo aoosoediz6 A'S 2008 wo do0sov6079 AL 6.2008 wo oos07619 AL 12009 (OTHER PUBLICATIONS Amsttz«€alis Preset prosthesis: Principle, Res, and Tesh niques (Chap. 20} pp. 261-270. Im Amstutz, HC. (Ey Hip Arthroplasy Ist; Elsevier Heath Sciences, Avg. 1991 ‘Nmuna ot al; Recent Advances in Augmented. Realty: IEEE ‘Computer Graphics and Applications; 2106 pp. 3447; Now Dee 2o0t B Braun / Aosculap AG: OnhoPilo®, Onhopaatic Navigation Systems 1p printed frm hip wseeothpio.com epwrde schg ac-onhopaltensinths sa’7218 kml on Ot 24, 2019 This ‘web adds was avaiable to aplican() at east as of un 2008). Bach etal: Scoring sytem in tal knee asthoplast. Clin Orthop Relat Res: 299: pp. 184196, Jun. 2002. Barrera eal, “Comparison of Distal Femoral TKR Bone Cts by Frechand Novation vs Conventional Citing igs”, CADS Inter sana, Chicago, 112004 asters et al, "Comparison of Distal Femoral TKR Bone Cats by Freehand Navigation vs Conventional Cutig Jigs", The Fourth Annual Conference of the Intemational Society for Computer Assed OrthopadieSuigery, CAOS Intemational, Chicago 1.2004 Barrera et aly "Frechand Navigation Cuting for Distal Femoral ‘TKR bone for MIS", Annual Symposium of Itermational Society for Technology in Anhropasty (ESTA), Rome, Kaly2004 Hartera ct aly “Int Operative Graptcl nterfce for Frechand Navigated Bono Cuning for TKR Without Jigs Assessment of First Cus” Poster 246, Sth Combined Meatng ofthe Onopaedic Research Socicis of Canada, USA, Japan and Burope, Ban Albers, Canaa200, Baytra eal, "Comparison of Distal Femoral TKR Bone Cus by Frechand Navigation vs Conventional Cig Jigs", The Fousth Annval Conference of the Inemational Soeisy for Computer ‘Assisted Onhopuedic Surgery. CAOS-Tntrational, Chicago 1, Sun, 2004 Barrera tal, *Frechand Navigation Cuting for Distal Femoral TRE bone for MIS", Anal Symposium of Itemational Society {oy Technology in Athroplasty (STA), Rome aly, Sep. 2008 artes ct aly “Int Operative Grape ntrface for Frechind Navigated Bone Cuting for TKR Without figs Assessment of Fist Cus" Poster 246, Sth Combined Meating ofthe Onhopaedic Research Socieis of Canada, US.A. Japan and Europe, Ban Abeta, Canad, Oct. 2004 Bastera et al. "Simulation and Navigation for Knce Replacement Surgery", Paper presented at the 1th Annual Nebraska Biomedical Rese Workshop, Omaha, NE; Apr. 2003 artern etal Towns a stndand in assem of bone cating for “TKR: (pvesonation postr), 8th Ann. Symposium of the Intra tional Society for Technology and Arthroplasty (IST), Kyo, Sapa: Sop 29.0.2, 2008, Bellamy etal: Validation study of WOMAC: a health status instrument for measuring clinically inpowtat patent selevaat out ‘comes (oanshtumate dug therapy in pias with ota ‘ofthe hip or kee. Rheumatol 18 (12); pp 1833-1840; De. 1988 Be Beh Technologies, Ines NavioP FS) (brochure) 4 pass @ 2013; dowloaded fom: hp. wow blubeliech com, ths eb “ado availabe to applicant(s) a lest a8 of Nov 2012 Bobym eal Oseopente phenomens across endotel bone implant spaces wih porous surficed intramedullary Implants. Acta Onhop Scand: 5202) pp. 145-153, Gear of pub. suicinty cartier than sfetive US ile and any freien pron date) 1981 anf Image-Giided Surgery Platforms; 2 pages: rintd on et, 24.2013 from hp: wore bana conv producttery mage gied- suger platforms (This web adress was avaiable to applcant()at eat ae of Jun, 2008), Bison tal, “Precision Frechand Sculpting of Bone", CAOS International, Spin2003, Brisson etal, Pression Frechand Sculping of Bone; Lecture Notes Jin Computer Science vl. 32175 MICCAT 20,7 intermtionsl (Cont. Proceedings, Pat I; SsintMalo France: pp. 105-112: Sep 26-29, 2004 Crlsiom etal; Implant fation impeovel by close fe. Cynical Jimplani-bone interface stdin mbit. Acta Onhop Scand, 59 G).2725, Jun. 1988. Collier tas Macroscopic and microscopic evidence of prosthetic ‘ation with porous-

You might also like