Cylindrical shell results under sinusoidal load

Boundary Condition : CCCC a = 1000 mm a/b = 1 a/h = 100

FIRST PLY FAILURE ULTIMATE PLY FAILURE Total Numbers
Governing Failure Governing Failure of Failure at
R/a Lamination Governing Failure Failed Gauss Governing Failed Gauss
Failure Load Failed Ply Failed Element Location (x, y) Failure Mode / Tendency Failure Load Failed Ply Failed Element Location (x, y) Failure Mode / Tendency Ultimate Ply
Criteria Point Failure Criteria Point Failure
(MPa) mm (MPa) mm
0.5 0/90 hashin 0.6257 1 40 2 Matrix Crushing
0.5 0/90/0 hashin 0.5383 1 32 4 Matrix Crushing
0.5 0/90/0/90 puck 0.4712 3 47 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C)
0.5 0/90/90/0 hashin 0.489 1 40 2 Matrix Crushing
0.5 45/-45 puck 0.5778 2 24 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.6645 1 24 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 32
0.5 45/-45/45 puck 0.5793 3 25 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) hashin 0.9766 3 49 3 Matrix Crushing 75
0.5 45/-45/45/-45 puck 0.5784 4 32 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.7908 2 17 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 79
0.5 45/-45/-45/45 puck 0.5722 4 48 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.7908 2 41 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 79
0.75 0/90 puck 1.0344 2 23 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.0344 2 23 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
0.75 0/90/0 puck 0.8798 3 15 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.8798 3 50 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 5
0.75 0/90/0/90 puck 0.6404 3 42 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.819 3 50 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 3
0.75 0/90/90/0 puck 0.7376 4 19 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.723 4 58 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 12
0.75 45/-45 puck 1.1839 2 42 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.1839 2 42 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
0.75 45/-45/45 puck 1.0626 3 47 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.0626 3 47 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
0.75 45/-45/45/-45 puck 1.0288 4 42 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) hashin 1.0289 3 44 1 Matrix Cracking 21
0.75 45/-45/-45/45 puck 1.011 4 46 2
1 0/90 puck 0.7253 2 39 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.7253 2 39 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1 0/90/0 puck 0.9103 3 50 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.5602 3 19 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 7
1 0/90/0/90 puck 0.5338 3 19 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.0906 3 18 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 6
1 0/90/90/0 puck 0.7903 4 10 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.7903 4 10 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1 45/-45 puck 1.0304 2 42 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.0304 2 42 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1 45/-45/45 puck 0.9522 3 18 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.9522 3 18 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1 45/-45/45/-45 puck 0.7989 3 39 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.7989 3 39 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1 45/-45/-45/45 puck 0.7988 3 31 3
1.25 0/90 puck 0.7565 2 34 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.7565 2 34 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 1
1.25 0/90/0 puck 0.7653 3 11 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 1.0387 3 11 1 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 3
1.25 0/90/0/90 puck 0.5537 3 43 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.5537 3 43 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 1
1.25 0/90/90/0 puck 0.6894 4 54 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.6894 4 54 2 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1.25 45/-45 maximum strain theory 0.8878 2 59 2 Matrix Cracking hashin 0.8878 2 61 2 Matrix Cracking 22
1.25 45/-45/45 puck 0.7425 1 44 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.7425 1 44 4 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1.25 45/-45/45/-45 puck 0.6899 4 35 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) puck 0.6899 4 35 3 Matrix Crushing (mode C) 2
1.25 45/-45/-45/45 puck 0.716 4 27 1

puck koro , jali lagbe na

 Governing failure load
0/90 1.00 0.6257
R / a 0/90/0 0.86 0.5383
0.5 0/90/0/90 0.75 0.4712 1.20
1.00
0/90/90/0 0.78 0.489 1.00 0.86
0.92 0.93 0.92
45/-45 0.92 0.5778 0.75 0.78

Peak failure pressure

0.80
45/-45/45 0.93 0.5793 0.60
45/-45/45/-45 0.92 0.5784
0.40
45/-45/-45/45 0.91 0.5722
0.20
0.00
90 /0 90 /0 5 5 5
0/ 90 0/ 90 /-4 5 /4 /-4
0/ 0 / 0/ 4 5
/-4 4 5
/-4
0/
9
0/
9
45 5/ 5
/-4 /-4
45 45

Lamination

Governing failure load

0/90 0.87 1.0344
R / a 0/90/0 0.74 0.8798
0.75 0/90/0/90 0.54 0.6404 1.20
1.00
Peak failure pressure

1.00 0.87 0.90 0.87

0/90/90/0 0.62 0.7376 0.74
0.80 0.62
45/-45 1.00 1.1839 0.54
0.60
45/-45/45 0.90 1.0626 0.40
45/-45/45/-45 0.87 1.0288 0.20
45/-45/-45/45 0.85 1.011 0.00
90 /0 90 /0 5 5 5
0/ 90 0/ 90 /-4 5 /4 /-4
0/ 0 / 0/ 4 5
/-4 4 5
/-4
0/
9
0/
9
45 5/ 5
/-4 /-4
45 45

Lamination

Governing failure load

0/90 0.70 0.7253
R/a 0/90/0 0.88 0.9103 1.20
Peak failure pressure

1 0/90/0/90 0.52 0.5338

1.00
1.00
0.92
0.88
0/90/90/0 0.77 0.7903 0.77 0.78
0.80 0.70
45/-45 1.00 1.0304
0.60 0.52
45/-45/45 0.92 0.9522
0.40
45/-45/45/-45 0.78 0.7989
0.20
45/-45/-45/45 0.69 0.716
0.00
90 /0 90 /0 5 5 5
0/ 90 0/ 90 /-4 5 /4 /-4
0/ 0 / 0/ 4 5
/-4 4 5
/-
0/
9
0/
9
45 5/ 5
-4 -4
4 5/ 4 5/

Lamination
 0.20

Pe
0.00
90 /0 90 /0 5 5 5
0/ 90 0/ 90 /-4 5 /4 /-4
0/ 0 / 0/ 4 5
/-4 4 5
/-
0/
9
0/
9
45 5/ 5
-4 -4
4 5/ 4 5/

Lamination

Governing failure load

0/90 0.85 0.7565
R/a 0/90/0 0.86 0.7653
1.20
1.25 0/90/0/90 0.62 0.5537 1.00

Peak failure pressure

1.00 0.85 0.86 0.84
0/90/90/0 0.78 0.6894 0.78 0.78
0.80
45/-45 1.00 0.8878 0.62
0.60
45/-45/45 0.84 0.7425 0.40
45/-45/45/-45 0.78 0.6899 0.20
-45/45/-45/45 0.78 0.6899 0.00
90 /0 90 /0 5 5 5
0/ 90 0/ 90 /-4 5 /4 /-4
0/ 0 / 0/ 4 5
/-4 4 5
0/
9
0/
9
45 5/ 45
/
-4 5/
4 5/ -4

Lamination
 0.92 0.93 0.92 0.91
0.78

0 5 5 5 5
0/ /-4 5 /4 /-4 5 /4
5 5
4 /-4 5/
4 /-4
45 /-4 /-4
5
45 4 5

amination

1.00
0.90 0.87 0.85
0.62

/0 5 5 5 5
90 5 /-4 5 /4
5 /-4 5 /4
4 /-4 5/
4 /-4
45 /-4 /-4
5
45 4 5

amination

1.00
0.92
0.77 0.78
0.69

/0 5 5 5 5
90 5 /-4 5 /4
5 /-4 5 /4
4 /-4 5/
4 /-4
45 /-4 /-4
5
45 4 5

amination
 /0 5 5 5 5
90 5 /-4 5 /4
5 /-4 5 /4
4 /-4 5/
4 /-4
45 /-4 /-4
5
45 4 5

amination

1.00
0.78 0.84 0.78 0.78

/0 5 5 5 5
/9
0
5 /-4 5 /4
5 /-4 5 /4
4 /-4 5/
4 /-4
45 /-4 /4
5
5
45 -4
Lamination
 R/a Peak failure pressure 1.4
0/90 0.5 0.6257
1.2
0/90 0.75 1.0344
0/90 1 0.7253 1

Peak failure pressure

0/90 1.25 0.7565
0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

-2.22044604925031E-16
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25

R/a

1.4
R/a Peak failure pressure
0/90/0 0.5383 1.2 0
0.5

Peak failure pressure

0/90/0 0.75 0.8798 1
0/90/0 1 0.9103 0.8
0/90/0 1.25 0.7653
0.6

0.4

0.2

-2.22044604925031E-16
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25
R/a

1.4

1.2
0/90/0

1
Peak failure pressure

R/a Peak failure pressure 0.8

0/90/0/90 0.5 0.4712
0/90/0/90 0.75 0.6404 0.6
0/90/0/90 1 0.5338 0.4
0/90/0/90 1.25 0.5537
0.2

0
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25

R/a
 Peak failur
0.6

0.4

0.2

0
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25

R/a

1.4

1.2 0/90/
R/a Peak failure pressure 1
0/90/90/0 0.5 0.489

Peak failure pressure

0/90/90/0 0.75 0.7376 0.8
0/90/90/0 1 0.7903
0.6
0/90/90/0 1.25 0.6894
0.4

0.2

-2.22044604925031E-16
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25

R/a

R/a Peak failure pressure 1.4

45/-45 0.5 0.5778
1.2
45
45/-45 0.75 1.1839
45/-45 1 1.0304 1
Peak failure pressure

45/-45 1.25 0.8878

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

0
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25

R/a

R/a Peak failure pressure 1.4

45/-45/45 0.5 0.5793
45/ - 4
45/-45/45 0.75 1.0626 1.2
45/-45/45 1 0.9522
1
45/-45/45 1.25 0.7425
Peak failure pressure

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

-2.22044604925031E-16
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25
R/a
 1

Peak failure pressure

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

-2.22044604925031E-16
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25
R/a Peak failure pressure
R/a
45/-45/45/-45 0.5 0.5784
45/-45/45/-45 1.0288 1.4
0.75
45/-45/45/-45 1 0.7989 45/ -45/ 45
1.2
45/-45/45/-45 1.25 0.6899
1

Peak failure pressure

0.8

0.6

0.4
R/a Peak failure pressure
45/-45/-45/45 0.5 0.5722 0.2
45/-45/-45/45 0.75 1.011
45/-45/-45/45 1 0.7988 -2.22044604925031E-16
45/-45/-45/45 0.716 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25
1.25
R/a

1.4
- 45/ 45/ -45/ 45
1.2

1
Peak failure pressure

0.8

0.6

0.4

0.2

-2.22044604925031E-16
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25 1.5
R/a
 0/90

0.75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a

0/90/0

0.75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a

0/90/0/90

75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a
75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a

0/90/90/0

0.75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a

45/ - 45

75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a

45/ - 45/ 45

0.75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a
 0.75 1 1.25 1.5
R/a

45/ -45/ 45/ -45

0.75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a
 R/a Peak failure pressure 0/90 0/90/0
0/90 0.5 0.6257 0.5 0.6257 0.5383
0/90 0.75 1.0344 0.75 1.0344 0.8798
0/90 1 0.7253 1 0.7253 0.9103
0/90 1.25 0.7565 1.25 0.7565 0.7653

R/a Peak failure pressure

0/90/0 0.5 0.5383 1.4
0/90/0 0.75 0.8798
0/90/0 1 0.9103
0/90/0 0.7653 1.2
1.25

Peak failure pressure

R/a Peak failure pressure
1
0/90/0/90 0.5 0.4712
0/90/0/90 0.75 0.6404
0/90/0/90 1 0.5338 0.8
0/90/0/90 1.25 0.5537

R/a Peak failure pressure 0.6

0/90/90/0 0.5 0.489
0/90/90/0 0.75 0.7376
0/90/90/0 0.7903 0.4
1
0.25 0.5
0/90/90/0 1.25 0.6894

R/a Peak failure pressure

45/-45 0.5 0.5778
45/-45 0.75 1.1839
45/-45 1 1.0304
45/-45 1.25 0.8878

R/a Peak failure pressure

45/-45/45 0.5 0.5793
45/-45/45 0.75 1.0626
45/-45/45 1 0.9522
45/-45/45 1.25 0.7425

R/a Peak failure pressure

45/-45/45/-45 0.5 0.5784
45/-45/45/-45 0.75 1.0288
45/-45/45/-45 1 0.7989
45/-45/45/-45 1.25 0.6899

R/a Peak failure pressure

-45/45/-45/45 0.5 0.5784
-45/45/-45/45 0.75 1.0288
-45/45/-45/45 1 0.7989
-45/45/-45/45 1.25 0.6899
 0/90/0/90 0/90/90/0 45/-45 45/-45/45 45/-45/45/-45 45/-45/-45/45
0.4712 0.489 0.5778 0.5793 0.5784 0.5722
0.6404 0.7376 1.1839 1.0626 1.0288 1.011
0.5338 0.7903 1.0304 0.9522 0.7989 0.7988
0.5537 0.6894 0.8878 0.7425 0.6899 0.716

1.4 0/90
0/90/0
0/90/0/90
1.2 0/90/90/0
45/-45
45/-45/45
45/-45/45/-45
1
45/-45/-45/45

0.8

0.6

0.4
0.25 0.5 0.75 1 1.25 1.5

R/a
1.1839 1 1 FI

Governing Governing
R/a Lamination
Failure Failure Load
Criteria (MPa)
1.0626 0.897542 2
0.9522 0.804291 2 0.5 45/-45 puck 0.5778
0.9103 0.768899 3 0.5 45/-45/45 puck 0.5793
0.8878 0.749894 3 0.5 45/-45/45/-45 puck 0.5784
0.8798 0.743137 3 0.5 45/-45/-45/45 puck 0.5722
0.7565 0.63899 4 0.75 45/-45 puck 1.1839
0.7425 0.627164 4 0.75 45/-45/45 puck 1.0626
0.7376 0.623026 4 0.75 45/-45/45/-45 puck 1.0288
0.7253 0.612636 4 0.75 45/-45/-45/45 puck 1.011
0.6257 0.528507 5 1 45/-45 puck 1.0304
0.5793 0.489315 6 1 45/-45/45 puck 0.9522
0.5784 0.488555 6 1 45/-45/45/-45 puck 0.7989
0.5784 0.488555 6 1 45/-45/-45/45 puck 0.7988
0.489 0.413042 6 1.25 45/-45 maximum strain theory
0.8878
0.4712 0.398007 7 1.25 45/-45/45 puck 0.7425
1.25 45/-45/45/-45 puck 0.6899
1.25 45/-45/-45/45 puck 0.716

jali
 FIRST PLY FAILURE
Non- Ranks in Rank in terms Rank in terms of
Rank in terms
dimensionaln terms of of difficulty of difficulty of Sum of
Failed Ply of latency of
ormalised failure fabricating fabricating ply ranks
damage
failure load load curvature lay-up
2 0.49 7 4 1 1 13
3 0.49 7 4 2 1 14
4 0.49 7 4 3 1 15
4 0.48 7 4 3 1 15
2 1.00 1 3 1 1 6
3 0.90 2 3 2 1 8
4 0.87 2 3 3 1 9
4 0.85 2 3 3 1 9
2 0.87 2 2 1 1 6
3 0.80 3 2 2 1 8
3 0.67 5 2 3 2 12
3 0.67 5 2 3 2 12
2 0.75 4 1 1 1 7
1 0.63 5 1 2 1 9
4 0.58 6 1 3 1 11
4 0.60 5 1 3 1 10

6
Overall
rank

8
9
10
10
1
3
5
5
2
3
7
7
2
4
6
5
1.1839 1 1 R/a LaminationFIRST PLY FAILURE
1.0626 0.897542 2 Governing G
F overning Failed Ply
1.0344 0.873722 2 0.5 0/90 hashin 0.6257 1
1.0304 0.870344 2 0.5 0/90/0 hashin 0.5383 1
1.0288 0.868992 2 0.5 0/90/0/90 puck 0.4712 3
1.0288 0.868992 2 0.5 0/90/90/0 hashin 0.489 1
0.9522 0.804291 2 0.5 45/-45 puck 0.5778 2
0.9103 0.768899 3 0.5 45/-45/45 puck 0.5793 3
0.8878 0.749894 3 0.5 45/-45/45/-puck 0.5784 4
0.8798 0.743137 3 0.5 45/-45/-45/puck 0.5722 4
0.7989 0.674804 4 0.75 0/90 puck 1.0344 2
0.7989 0.674804 4 0.75 0/90/0 puck 0.8798 3
0.7903 0.667539 4 0.75 0/90/0/90 puck 0.6404 3
0.7653 0.646423 4 0.75 0/90/90/0 puck 0.7376 4
0.7565 0.63899 4 0.75 45/-45 puck 1.1839 2
0.7425 0.627164 4 0.75 45/-45/45 puck 1.0626 3
0.7376 0.623026 4 0.75 45/-45/45/-puck 1.0288 4
0.7253 0.612636 4 0.75 45/-45/-45/puck 1.011 4
0.6899 0.582735 5 1 0/90 puck 0.7253 2
0.6899 0.582735 5 1 0/90/0 puck 0.9103 3
0.6894 0.582313 5 1 0/90/0/90 puck 0.5338 3
0.6404 0.540924 5 1 0/90/90/0 puck 0.7903 4
0.6257 0.528507 5 1 45/-45 puck 1.0304 2
0.5793 0.489315 6 1 45/-45/45 puck 0.9522 3
0.5784 0.488555 6 1 45/-45/45/-puck 0.7989 3
0.5784 0.488555 6 1 45/-45/-45/puck 0.7988 3
0.5778 0.488048 6 1.25 0/90 puck 0.7565 2
0.5537 0.467692 6 1.25 0/90/0 puck 0.7653 3
0.5383 0.454684 6 1.25 0/90/0/90 puck 0.5537 3
0.5338 0.450883 6 1.25 0/90/90/0 puck 0.6894 4
0.489 0.413042 6 1.25 45/-45 maximum st 0.8878 2
0.4712 0.398007 7 1.25 45/-45/45 puck 0.7425 1
1.25 45/-45/45/-puck 0.6899 4
1.25 45/-45/-45/puck 0.716 4
Non-dimensRanks in teRank in te Rank in term
Rank in terms of difficulty of fabricating ply lay-up
0.528507 6 1 4 1 12
0.454684 7 1 4 2 14
0.398007 7 2 4 3 16
0.413042 7 1 4 3 15
0.488048 7 1 4 1 13
0.489315 7 1 4 2 14
0.488555 7 1 4 3 15
0.483318 7 1 4 3 15
0.873722 3 1 3 1 8
0.743137 4 1 3 2 10
0.540924 6 2 3 3 14
0.623026 5 1 3 3 12
1 1 1 3 1 6
0.897542 2 1 3 2 8
0.868992 3 1 3 3 10
0.853957 3 1 3 3 10
0.612636 5 1 2 1 9
0.768899 4 1 2 2 9
0.450883 7 2 2 3 14
0.667539 5 1 2 3 11
0.870344 3 1 2 1 7
0.804291 3 1 2 2 8
0.674804 5 2 2 3 12
0.674719 5 2 2 3 12
0.63899 5 1 1 1 8
0.646423 5 1 1 2 9
0.467692 7 2 1 3 13
0.582313 6 1 1 3 11
0.749894 4 1 1 1 7
0.627164 5 1 1 2 9
0.582735 6 1 1 3 11
0.604781 5 1 1 3 10