Professional Documents
Culture Documents
"Behavioral Biases On Investment Decision": Dr. Janki Mistry
"Behavioral Biases On Investment Decision": Dr. Janki Mistry
SUBMITTED BY
APRIL 2023
Page 1 of 117
DECLARATION
I further declare that the personal data and information received from any respondent
during survey has not been shared with any one and is used for academic purpose
only.
Further, I would like to declare that this report has not been submitted to any other
University or institute for the award of any degree or diploma.
Place: Surat
Date:15/04/2023
SPID: 2021070124
Surat.
Page 2 of 117
Department of Business & Industrial Management
Surat
DEPARTMENT CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that SAMEER FIROZ NOORANI has completed his project report as a
part of MBA curriculum. He has successfully completed a study on “BEHAVIORAL
BIASES ON INVESTMENT DECISION”
DR,JANKI MISTRY
(Professor)
Page 3 of 117
Acknowledgement
The success and final outcome of this project required a lot of guidance and
assistance from many people and I am extremely fortunate to have got this all along
the completion of my project work. Whatever I have done is only due to such
guidance and assistance and I would not forget to thank them
Firstly, I would like to thank our honorable Department Head, Professor who always
work and think in the direction of betterment of the students and institute as well as
supporting us with all the necessary resources to finish our two golden years of
post-graduation.
Lastly, I would thank all my friends & other persons directly or indirectly, who have
supported me in completing this report.
Sameer Noorani
Page 4 of 117
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Comprehensive Project Report on “To study the impact of behavioral biases on
investment decision”- of M.B.A. program for the year 2023 includes the following
chapters.
The first chapter includes the introduction of the topic where all the information about
overall Behavioural biases and what is investment.
The second chapter is industrial profile where information about Global, National and
State level, PESTEL Analysis, Major players.
The third chapter is literature review which displays the past research on investing
behaviour of investors and related to this topic from different researchers, from which
the base for this report is made. I have included 7 literature reviews.
The fifth chapter is data analysis which shows the analysis for the collected data and
its interpretation through frequency tables and charts. And also included Graphical
representation of data with statistical analysis and interpretation Analysis also helps
for the conclusion and findings.
There are finding from data analysis; it shows the specific result from the analysis
made.
The last chapter is conclusion of the whole report, it states the final decision,
determination or result from which the answer to the problem for which research is
been made is obtained.
Page 5 of 117
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER TITLE PAGE NO.
1 INTRODUCTION OF THE STUDY 12
2 INDUSTRY PROFILE OF INVESTMENT INDUSTRY 20
2.1 GLOBAL SCENARIO 21
2.2 NATIONAL SCENARIO 24
2.3 STATE LEVEL SCENARIO 26
2.4 MAJOR PLAYERS ACCORDING TO THE CURRENT 27
TRENDS
2.5 PESTLE ANALYSIS OF INVESTMENT INDUSTRY 32
3 LITERATURE REVIEW 37
4 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 41
4.1 PRROBLEM STATEMENT 42
4.2 RESEARCH OBJECTIVE 42
4.3 RESEARCH DESIGN 42
4.4 SAMPLE DESIGN 43
4.4.1 SAMPLING METHOD 43
4.4.2 SAMPLE SIZE 43
4.4.3 SAMPLE ELEMENTS 43
4.4.4 SAMPLING FRAME 43
4.5 DATA COLLECTION SOURCE 43
4.6 DATA COLLECTION METHOD 44
4.7 INSTRUMENTS AND TOOLS FOR ANALYSIS 44
4.8 BENEFITS OF THE STUDY 44
4.9 LIMITATIONS OF STUDY 44
4.10 SCOPE OF THE STUDY 44
Page 6 of 117
5 DATA ANALYSIS 45
KRUSKAL – WALLIST TEST 76
CORRELATION ANALYSIS 86
FINDINGS 106
6 CONCLUSION 109
BIBLIOGRAPHY 113
ANNEXURE 114
Page 7 of 117
SERIES TITLE OF TABLE PAGE
NO. NO.
13 Table: 6.13 I buy "hot" stocks and avoid stocks that have 59
performed poorly recently
Page 8 of 117
15 Table: 6.15 I buy the new equity offering of the company I 61
have
already invested in
Page 9 of 117
SERIES TITLE OF FIGURE PAGE
NO. NO.
1 Figure: 1.3.1 Origin of Biases 5
Page 10 of 117
CHAPTER-1
INTRODUCTION
Page 11 of 117
1.1 INTRODUCTIONOF INVESTMENT AND BEHAVIOUR FINANCE AND ITS
BIASES
INVESTMENT:
Income earned by people can be either spent for current consumption or saved for
futureconsumption. But savings itself are not investments. When you do something to
your savings to make them increase over the time, it is known as Investment.
1. Risk
2. Return
3. Safety
4. Liquidity
BEHAVIORAL FINANCE:
Page 12 of 117
Behavioural finance is an idea evolved with the inputs taken from the sector of
psychology and finance. It attempts to recognize the diverse complicated elements in
inventory markets to provide higher reasons for the same. These elements or
abnormalities had been to start with termed as marketplace anomalies, as they
couldn't be defined withinside the Neo-classical framework. To solution the elevated
quantity and kinds of marketplace anomalies, a brand-new method to economic
markets had emerged- the Behavioural finance. Behavioural finance is described
because the observe of the impact of socio-mental elements on an asset’s price. It
specializes in investor behaviour and their funding decision-making process.
Page 13 of 117
Thus, Behavioural finance may be defined withinside the following ways:
• Behavioural finance is a try to give an explanation for what reasons a number of the
anomalies which have been discovered and stated withinside the finance literature.
Given the run up in inventory (capital) marketplace in 2004 to the cease of 2007 and
next downturn of monetary marketplace, know-how irrational investor behaviour is as
crucial because it has ever been. In gift situation behavioural finance has grown to be
a quintessential a part of selection making system because of its effect on overall
performance of funding inventory marketplace in addition to mutual funds.
Most vital trouble is marketplace player can't behave rationally always, they deviate
from rationality and anticipated software assumption, whilst surely making funding
decisions. So, behavioural finance assist buyers in addition to marketplace individuals
to apprehend biases and different mental constraint of their interaction in marketplace.
Page 14 of 117
1.3 BEHAVIOURAL BIASES THAT INFLUENCE INVESTMENT DECISIONS:
Page 15 of 117
• The representativeness heuristic involves estimating the likelihood of an event
by comparing it to an existing prototype that already exists in our minds.
• The availability heuristic is a cognitive bias in which you make a decision based
on an example, information, or recent experience that is that readily available to
you, even though it may not be the best example to inform your decision
(Tversky&Kahneman, 1973).
• Familiarity bias is the idea best illustrated by the old Wall Street adage: “Invest
in what you know.” It is defined as the tendency for individuals to prefer what is
familiar and to seek to avoid the unknown. While this tendency is present in all
areas of life (such as the foods we choose to eat or the route we take on our
morning commute), it is especially prevalent in the investment selection
process.
Page 16 of 117
currency risk, transaction costs, and asymmetric information. Behavioural
finance issues include employees overinvesting in their own companies’ stock,
overconfidence in forecasting returns on familiar assets, risk avoidance,
patriotism, and social identification.
• The disposition effect refers to our tendency to prematurely sell assets that
have made financial gains, while holding on to assets that are losing money.
We are driven to sell our winning investments in order to ensure a profit, but are
averse to selling losing investments in hopes of turning them into gains.
Page 17 of 117
• Loss aversion is a tendency in behavioural finance where investors are so
fearful of losses that they focus on trying to avoid a loss more so than on
making gains. The more one experiences losses, the more likely they are to
become prone to loss aversion. Research on loss aversion shows that investors
feel the pain of a loss more than twice as strongly as they feel the enjoyment of
making a profit.
• The negative effect of this, of course, is that investors often continue to hold
onto losing investments much longer than they should and end up suffering
much bigger losses than necessary. That’s what loss aversion looks like in
practice.
• Though the rational part of our mind reminds us that selling winners and not
letting losers go is a wrong behavioural pattern, we still often struggle to take
the necessary actions. It means that trades often don’t have enough discipline
and self-control to sell the losers and not to sell winners too quickly.
• Although it’s unlikely that we will be able to bury the disposition bias for good, it
is possible to learn how to reduce its influence on our decision-making.
• According to Shefrin and Statman, traders tend to “open a new mental account”
for every investment. By doing so, they focus on the performance of each and
Page 18 of 117
every trade, instead of tracking the performance of their portfolio as a whole.
This is an example of a narrow framing. It makes hard to sell a losing stock,
because traders see it as closing the mental account at a loss.
• Selling at a loss, even if it seems totally rational, means admitting a trader was
wrong, which is hard for many people. Holding the stock allows him to avoid
the feeling of regret, which follows the mistakes we make.
• In case of a winning trade, holding onto it means risking the profit a trader has
already made. Taking a small profit instead creates the feeling of pride.
• – Following your intestine feeling and inherent beliefs. In truth that is your
default option.
• – This technique is logical and methodical, something that calls for a deep
notion process.
Page 19 of 117
CHAPTER-2
INDUSTRY PROFILE
Page 20 of 117
2.1 GLOBAL SCENARIO OF INVESTMENT INDUSTRY:
• There’s no higher manner to put together yourself for 2023 than understanding
what the arena’s professionals are predicting for the 12 months ahead. A
Tehelka Bureau file.
• The2023 Global Forecast Report created the use of over 500 predictions from
greater than one hundred one-of-a-kind sources, consisting of greater than 20
financial institution reviews and outlooks provides a thrilling worldwide
scenario. The VC+ file provides the pinnacle banks’ forecasts for the S&P 500,
treasury yields, and recession timelines charted. It additionally offers a bird’s
eye view of the IMF’s inflation, unemployment, and GDP increase outlooks for
countries and a set of the “spiciest” and maximum outrageous predictions from
professionals for the 12 months ahead.
Is a recession coming?
• For the U.S. and Global Macroeconomics Bank of America going into 2023, one
predicted surprise remains: recession. The U.S., Euro place and UK are all
predicted to look recessions subsequent 12 months, and the relaxation of the
arena ought to preserve to weaken, with China an extremely good exception.
• Most banks are anticipating the U.S. to go into a recession withinside the latter
1/2 of of 2023. Experts estimate a 35% opportunity that the U.S. economic
system enters a recession over the subsequent 12 months. Similarly maximum
banks are anticipating the U.S. to go into a recession withinside the latter 1/2 of
of 2023. These consist of J.P. Morgan, Goldman Sachs, Bank of America,
Morgan Stanley, Barclays, Wells Fargo and PNC Deutsche Bank. “We estimate a
Page 21 of 117
35% opportunity that the U.S. economic system enters a recession over the
subsequent 12 months,” says Goldman Sachs
Interest rate
• While many professionals are forecasting a top and eventual cuts in hobby
quotes for 2023, the Federal Reserve’s today's projections best see quotes
going higher. While the Federal Reserve’s projections don’t foresee charge cuts
in 2023, economists have been greater constructive while polled via way of
means of the WSJ. Top sixty-six economists gave their predictions for in which
the midpoint of the Fed Funds Rate might be on the give up of 2023. They see a
top UK hobby charge of 4.0%–4.5% withinside the 2d sector. Higher quotes
below scenario #1 ought to motive domestic income to drop via way of means
of greater than 10% subsequent year. In scenario #2, domestic income drop via
Page 22 of 117
way of means of 7% to 8%. And in scenario #3, domestic interest might also
drop in addition via way of means of greater than 15%.
• Inflation may also fall even supposing labour pressures continue to be strong.
The fast decline withinside the working-age populace is possibly to generate
non-stop labour shortages of blue-collar and guide offerings workers. The
charge of salary boom in those jobs ought to be highly sturdy in maximum
years till the following recession. The U.S. unemployment charge ought to top
at 5.5% withinside the first sector of 2024, hindering purchaser spending.
Inflation is poised to drop beneath Neath salary boom.
• Already withinside the first 10 days of January groups have begun out layoffs.
For example, Salesforce has laid off 8,000 employees, Amazon 8,000, Goldman
Sachs 3,200, Huobi 275, Byte Dance 70-100, Silver gate 200, Twitter 52, Genesis
60 and Gate.io 160.
• Significantly, rising markets have higher boom, decrease inflation, and much
less sovereign and personal debt, but EM equities and currencies exchange at
crisis-stage valuations. Gold will continue to be a applicable hedge in
opposition to numerous geopolitical risks, in addition to the threat of a 2d wave
of inflation. The tech IPO marketplace will rebound in 2023, unexpected quite a
lot everyone. U.S.-China members of the family will possibly stabilize extremely
Page 23 of 117
in early 2023 given Xi’s ongoing appeal offensive, one aimed toward repairing
Beijing’s badly broken recognition without changing any of its malign behaviour.
• One key vicinity this will manifest is withinside the battlefield of social media
systems. AI advances make it smooth for bots to seem greater human, and
unfold disinformation. In 2023, we’ll additionally see a dramatic growth
withinside the availability of smooth-to-adopt, completely supported AI
workflows primarily based totally on what are known as Transformer models.
AI is turning into the inspiration for data-processing systems and a critical
engine of each commercial enterprise and enterprise.
• Until 2021, buyers had a worry of lacking out and had made numerous
investments without due diligence. In 2022, we witnessed a slow shift
withinside the funding approach. In 2023, startups have to reveal how
differentiated they're. They need to display their scalability and capacity to
develop and display how they're decreasing coins burns.
• By 2022, venture capital firms have hoarded as much as $1.3 trillion in private
equity and $580 billion globally by some estimates. However, start-up funding
has slowed significantly.
• As investors aim to deploy capital next year, they are likely to be more selective
in their choices, focusing on startups with solid ideas and competent teams to
Page 24 of 117
build on. perform effectively. Only startups that meet these criteria are likely to
receive funding in 2023 and beyond. Investors will be cautious about the
presence of idle resources. Wish they were more meticulous in their due
diligence and only fund startups with a clear path to success.
• Funding currently occurs only when the startup can demonstrate a clear path to
monthly profitability. They are now asking startups to clarify metrics,
specifically the cost of acquiring a customer and the long-term value of their
product or service. Startups must now explain how they intend to profit from ad
spend and other such metrics. There is a lot of scrutiny by investors, which is a
sane approach to investing. This has had a positive impact on the ecosystem,
with startup founders paying more attention to business fundamentals in
addition to the solution they provide.
• The impact of the global recession will certainly be felt, but it may be limited to
mid-to-large startups looking for late-stage funding. The investment scenario
will be more difficult than it was two years ago as investors will focus on
startups that have proven strong indicators. We can expect some consolidation,
mostly among startups that cannot secure their funding at a later stage. With
investors becoming more diligent, we could see mergers and acquisitions
(M&A) happening this year.
• Startups that operate There's a lot to look forward to in the field of supply chain
optimization, warehousing and logistics. The sector has tremendous growth
potential, and with the changing geopolitical landscape, companies are
realizing that supply chains are becoming a competitive differentiator.
• The deep tech sector, where startups work on AI, blockchain, biotechnology,
robotics and quantum computing will also be key areas of investor interest.
Page 25 of 117
• Over the past two years, we've seen a number of tech giants explore the
potential of the metaverse. We can expect investors to be interested in startups
that work with the underlying technologies that enable metaverse development,
such as AR/VR and 3D development. Investor interest in fintech solutions could
also continue for much of the year. However, investors can be cautious in the
technology sector, as the education sector lies between online and traditional
classrooms.
• Now is a good time for Indian startups to step back and review their
fundamentals to stay relevant in the investment landscape. They need to ask
themselves the tough questions and figure out how to build a sustainable
business model. To get through next year, startups need to sit back and
manage growth and profitability expectations. They have to prove that they can
handle the money, that they are frugal, and that they can thrive even in tough
times.
• Gujarat offers great opportunities for investment in the industrial sector. There
are opportunities to invest in new projects in petrochemical and downstream
industries, chemical sector including pharmaceuticals, engineering, ceramics,
agro-processing, IT and BT and infrastructure projects. The Gujarat Industrial
Development Board (GIDB) has also lined up a number of infrastructure
development projects.
Page 26 of 117
3.4 MAJOR PLAYERS ACCORDING TO CURRENT TREND:
4. Automobile Companies
Page 27 of 117
5. Infrastructure
6. Pharmaceuticals Stocks
• The twentieth century turned into the technology of production. From the
Nineteen Nineties to 2010, it turned into the time for the net boom. And
currently, it’s the time for statistics.
• There are many elements which might be boosting the boom of this enterprise
like technological advancement, monetary needs, the Indian authorities taking
useful decisions (virtual India), and many others.
Page 28 of 117
• A few of the predominant gamers withinside the IT Industry like TCS, Infosys,
WIPRO, HCL, Tech Mahindra, and many others have already mounted a terrific
logo fee and created massive wealth for his or her shareholders.
• FMCG is the maximum protecting area for lengthy-time period funding in India.
Most of the goods on this Industry had been utilized by human beings for over
one hundred years and but will keep withinside the future.
• Few FMCG organizations like HUL, Dabur, Emami, ITC, Nestle, and so on are not
unusual place names in Indian houses. The majority of the human beings
dwelling in Indian cities/cities had been the use of their merchandise for a
completely lengthy time.
• However, the traits are converting those days. Therefore, those agencies have
an excellent boom possibility in the one’s regions area. If you're searching out a
secure enterprise to invest, then the FMCG enterprise is one of the high-quality
sectors for long-time period funding in India.
• The desk underneath lists the names of India’s high-quality FMCG stocks.
Page 29 of 117
Hindustan Unilever 620,000
ITC 386,000
• India is a growing country (in fact the fastest growing country in the world). And
housing finances companies or NBFC (Non-banking finance companies) are
going to play a crucial role in the growth story of India.
• This is easily one of the best sectors for long-term investment in India. Unlike
major public sector banking companies in India, housing finance companies
are performing well for the past many years and will continue to do so.
• They have actually low NPAs (Non-performing Assets) when compared to the
PSU banks. Few major players in this industry can be HDFC, LIC Housing
Finance, India bulls Housing Finance, GRUH Finance, and DHFL.
• According to a CNBC report- The world’s fleet of electrical cars grew fifty-four
percentage to approximately 3.1 million in 2017. The forecasted wide variety of
electrical cars on the street round the sector will hit a hundred twenty-five
million with the aid of using 2030.
Page 30 of 117
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. 18.68
• When you visit an advanced country, what's the primary factor which you notice?
Big buildings, towers, flyovers, and many others, right?
Page 31 of 117
gamers on this enterprise are Lupin, Sun Pharma, GlenmarkPharma,
AurobindoPharma, etc.
Page 32 of 117
• Trade policies & price lists associated with Financials
• Pricing policies – Are there any pricing regulatory mechanism for Financials
The Macro environment factors such as – inflation rate, savings rate, interest rate,
foreign exchange rate and economic cycle determine the aggregate demand and
aggregate investment in an economy. Economic factors that Investment industry
should consider while conducting PESTEL analysis are –
Page 33 of 117
• Skill level of workforce in Financial Services and investment industry.
• Discretionary income
• Unemployment rate
• Inflation rate
• Interest rates
Society’s way of life and manner of doing matters effect the way of life of a company
in an environment. Shared ideals and attitudes of the populace play a top not position
in how entrepreneurs at Investment industry will apprehend the clients of a given
marketplace and the way they layout the advertising and marketing message for
Financial Services and investment enterprise consumers. Social elements that
management of Investment industry ought to examine for PESTEL evaluation are –
• Entrepreneurial spirit and broader nature of the society. Some societies inspire
entrepreneurship at the same time as a few don’t.
Page 34 of 117
• Attitudes (health, environmental consciousness, etc.)
A firm should not only do technological analysis of the industry but also the speed at
which technology disrupts that industry. Technology analysis entails information the
subsequent impacts -
• Weather
• Climate change
• Recycling
Page 35 of 117
• Waste control in Financials sector
• Discrimination regulation
• Employment regulation
• Data Protection
Page 36 of 117
CHAPTER-3
LITERATURE REVIEW
Page 37 of 117
According to Dr Anju Singh (2018) in her research paper;
This study aims to investigate the relationship between locus of control and emotional
and cognitive behavioural biases in investor decision-making. Three stages made up
our research. First, they conducted a thorough assessment of the literature to pinpoint
20 biases that frequently affect investor decision-making. At the second stage, they
looked into each bias separately in order to recognize them and create tools to
measure them when investors make decisions. Some of these biases were grouped
together during the pilot phase on the basis of exploratory factor analysis. To create a
validated tool for assessing these biases, confirmatory factor analysis was used. At
stage three, a group of investors from throughout the nation were given the finalized
questionnaire and Levenson's locus of control.
The goal of this study is to give a model of the decision-making process for
investments. A thorough analysis of the literature revealed that consumer behaviour
was rarely included when looking at individual investors. Instead, behavioural finance
and social psychological perspectives were used. This research combines behavioural
Page 38 of 117
finance, consumer behaviour, and social psychological views to fill in the gaps and
develop a model to explain investors' decision-making. This study also suggested that
perceived risk has a moderating effect on the correlation between consumer
behaviour, investment intentions, and behavioural finance characteristics. The planned
behaviour theory, social cognitive theory, and prospect theory are the foundations of
this study. The information was gathered through survey questionnaires that
employees from various Pakistani organisations had to fill out. Using SmartPLS, the
data that was gathered was examined. After doing initial tests and testing hypotheses,
548 observations were deemed to be helpful. The measuring model ensures the focus
constructs' validity and dependability.
According to the results of the hypothesis testing, factors that appear to have a
substantial impact on investment intentions are uncertainty avoidance,
overconfidence, product knowledge, product participation, perceived behavioural
control, and subjective norm.
This study examines the impact of Big Five personality levels on determinants of risk
behaviour in investment decisions. It provides a meaningful contribution to the
existing literature, as no studies have simultaneously investigated the effects of
personality traits on risk attitudes, risk perceptions, and return expectations in
investment decisions. Using a proprietary dataset containing his 100 private investors
in the South Gujarat region. It is therefore possible to determine which determinants of
risk-taking are influenced by the Big Five traits and induce individuals to take
investment risks. Five major traits were found to influence her risk attitudes. Highly
extroverted individuals are less risk averse than less extroverted individuals, and highly
neurotic individuals are more risk averse than less neurotic individuals. Personal
personality should be considered as an influencing factor.
The study examines the impact of behavioural biases on mutual fund selection for a
large sample of US investors in discount brokerage businesses and develop new
Page 39 of 117
measures of news attention, tax awareness, and familiarity biases at fund level. Use
previous studies in addition to behavioural and demographic characteristics.
Behaviourally biased investors typically make poor decisions about fund style and
cost, frequency and timing of trades, resulting in poor performance. Moreover,
trend-following appears to be more associated with behavioural biases than rational
inferences about management skills from past performance. Analysis of the factor
suggests that biased investors often follow stereotypes characterized as gamblers,
clever, overconfident, narrow-minded framers, and mature.
JoyitaBanerji (2020)
Standard investment theory assumes that all investors are the same and have the
same motives for investing. Investor sentiment can affect stock returns, and stocks
favoured by retail investors are sensitive to slight shifts in investor sentiment.
Behavioural finance offers another explanation for behaviour that traditional
economics fails to address. It is unlikely that all investors will react in the same way to
all biases. Some investors may not subscribe to certain prejudices. A better
understanding of how economic decisions are made can help investors make better
decisions. This study delves further into investigating whether the proposed -group
aversion, mental accounting, attitude, and interpretation biases apply in practice.
Standard investment theory assumes that all investors are the same and have the
same motives for investing. Investor sentiment can affect stock returns, and stocks
favoured by retail investors are sensitive to slight shifts in investor sentiment.
Behavioural finance offers another explanation for behaviour that traditional
economics fails to address. It is unlikely that all investors will react in the same way to
all biases. Some investors may not subscribe to certain prejudices. A better
understanding of how economic decisions are made can help investors make better
decisions. This study delves further into investigating whether the proposed -group
aversion, mental accounting, attitude, and interpretation biases apply in practice.
Sukanya. R (2015)
Page 40 of 117
cognition, emotion, and culture, is at the core of behavioural funding. The behavioural
finance paradigm suggests that investment decisions are largely influenced by
psychological and emotional factors. They know that investors do not always act
rationally or consider all available information in their decision-making process. As a
result, they regularly make mistakes. Also, the mistakes they make are found to repeat
in the same way and are called, hence systematic errors. Fortunately, due to this
systematic nature, these errors are often predictable and avoidable. Common
mistakes they make are also called behavioural biases, among which are
overconfidence, fixation, grazing, regret, disgust, misunderstanding, randomness,
mental speculation, and representativeness. Behavioural biases in investment
decisions.
Page 41 of 117
CHAPTER-4
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Page 42 of 117
4.1 PROBLEM STATEMENT:
1. Exploratory research:
2. Descriptive research:
3. Causal research:
• From the above types we have used descriptive research design to study the
impact of behavioural biases on investment intention of investors.
Page 43 of 117
4.4 SAMPLE DESIGN:
non probability sampling method is used for this study because of the researcher
collect the data according to their convenience timing, data availability.
• A total 201 respondents filled the survey, with varied demographics like-
• Samples are taken from those people only who are investing in stock market
only.
• Researcher has used primary data for this study: For the primary data, data
were collected with the help of filling questionnaire by Internet based (google
form).
• For the research we used basically two methods for data collection which were
as follows:
Page 44 of 117
Here online responses via google form and physical
questionnaire were used to collect primary data.
The secondary data for the study was carried out from
the search engine like- google, google scholar and only scientific papers,
articles and websites were included like- IBEF, emarketer.com, Wikipedia.
• For the analysis of our study and conclude our data’s output, we were used
spss software to analysis and conclude our primary data.
Page 46 of 117
The demographic analysis stated that gander, age, education level, monthly income
level and occupation strongly influence the investment decision making of individual
investors while making investment.(objective=3)
Page 47 of 117
Figure: 6.1 What is your main objective for investment?
• In 201 respondents,
2. I do invest in...
I do invest in...
Page 48 of 117
Figure: 6.2 I do invest in...
Page 49 of 117
Strongly 16 8.0 8.0 100.0
Disagree
Table: 6.3 I use the information as most people e.g., company profit.
4. If many people rely on a certain kind of information (e.g., return on assets) then
it’s likely that the information is reliable.
Page 50 of 117
Total 201 100.0 100.0
Table: 6.4 If many people rely on a certain kind of information (e.g., return on assets)
then it’s likely that the information is reliable
5. In time of uncertainty in the market, I will mostly do what other people are doing
Table: 6.5 In time of uncertainty in the market, I will mostly do what other people are
doing
Page 51 of 117
• With 201 respondents,
6. I'm likely to copy the investing decision made by people that I know
I'm likely to copy the investing decision made by people that I know
Table: 6.6 I'm likely to copy the investing decision made by people that I know
Page 52 of 117
• 27 respondents with 13.4% were strongly agree with this statement.
Table: 6.7 I'm generally very good at reading trends in the market
Page 53 of 117
• 85 respondents with 42.3% were agreeing with this statement.
Table:6.8 I am generally better than other investors when it comes to reading trends in
the market
Page 54 of 117
• With 201 respondents,
Table: 6.9 I generally don't need the services of a financial planner when investing in
financial products
Page 55 of 117
• With 201 respondents,
10. I prefer low-risk investments over risky investments, even if their returns are low
Table 6.10 I prefer low-risk investments over risky investments, even if their returns are
low
Page 56 of 117
• With 201 respondents,
Page 58 of 117
• 30 respondents with 14.9% were disagreeing with this statement.
13. I buy "hot" stocks and avoid stocks that have performed poorly
I buy "hot" stocks and avoid stocks that have performed poorly
recently
Table: 6.13 I buy "hot" stocks and avoid stocks that have performed poorly recently
Page 59 of 117
• 9 respondents with 4.5% were strongly disagreeing with this statement.
Page 60 of 117
15. I buy the new equity offering of the company I have already invested in
I buy the new equity offering of the company I have already invested
in
Table: 6.15 I buy the new equity offering of the company I have already invested in
Page 61 of 117
Frequency Percent Valid Cumulative
Percent Percent
Table: 6.16 I appear to believe that past return is indicative of future returns
Page 62 of 117
17. My trading is affected by recent experience in the market
Page 63 of 117
18. I use the purchase price of the stock as reference points in trading
Table: 6.18 I use the purchase price of the stock as reference points in trading
Page 64 of 117
19. I usually rely on experience in the market for my next investment
Table: 6.19 I usually rely on experience in the market for my next investment
Page 65 of 117
20. Before buying a share, I ignore the market information that conflates with mine.
Table: 6.20 Before buying a share, I ignore the market information that conflates with
mine.
Page 66 of 117
21. Before buying a share, I appreciate the market information that supports mine
Table: 6.21 Before buying a share, I appreciate the market information that supports
mine
Page 67 of 117
22. To support all information which is I predication
Page 68 of 117
23. Gender: 1. Male, 2. Female, 3. Other.
Page 69 of 117
24. Age:
Age
Frequenc Percent Valid Cumulative
y Percent Percent
15-25 98 48.8 48.8 48.8
26-35 60 29.9 29.9 78.6
36-45 22 10.9 10.9 89.6
Valid
46-55 16 8.0 8.0 97.5
>56 5 2.5 2.5 100.0
Total 201 100.0 100.0
Table: 6.24 age
Page 70 of 117
25. Monthly Income:
Monthly Income
Page 71 of 117
• With 201 respondents,
26. Occupation:
retired 1 .5 .5 100.0
Page 72 of 117
Figure: 6.26 occupation
• 41 were businessmen.
• 9 were homemakers.
27. Education:
Page 73 of 117
post-graduatio 73 36.3 36.3 89.6
n
Page 74 of 117
KRUSKAL-WALLIST TEST:
A Kruskal-Wallis Test is used to determine whether or not there is a statistically
significant difference between the medians of three or more independent groups.
Page 75 of 117
193 193 193 193 532
Page 76 of 117
193 532 193 193 532
Page 77 of 117
193 193 921.5 193 780.5
Page 78 of 117
193 780.5 780.5 780.5 972.5
Page 79 of 117
193 780.5 972.5 532 193
Page 80 of 117
532 193 532 193 780.5
Page 81 of 117
193 532 780.5 780.5 532
Page 82 of 117
532 532 921.5 780.5 921.5
Page 83 of 117
R 64557 87611.5 127331.5 99978 126037
n 1005
k 5
H 167.025463
p- Value 0.082085
Page 84 of 117
I use my own predictive skills to
413**
outperform the market trends
201
.000
I am generally better than other investors
when it comes to reading trends in the
.464**
market
201
.000
I generally don't need the services of a
financial planner when investing in
.368**
financial products
201
.000
I prefer low-risk investments over risky
investments, even if their returns are low
.382**
201
.000
I readily sell shares that have increased in
.417**
value
201
.000
after a prior loss, I become more
risk-averse
.366**
201
.000
I buy "hot" stocks and avoid stocks that
.384**
have performed poorly recently
201
.000
CORRELATION ANALYSIS:
.365**
decision
201
.000
I buy the new equity offering of the
.359**
company I have already invested in
201
.000
I appear to believe that past return are
indicative of future returns
.389**
201
.000
My trading is affected by recent experience
in the market
.403**
201
.000
I use the purchase price of the stock as
.385**
reference points in trading
201
.000
I usually rely on experience in the market
.456** for my next investment
201
.000
Before buying a share, I ignore the market
.174*
201
.014
variables which are measured at the ordinal or higher level of measurement.
201
.000
to plot them on a “scatter plot”. While there are many measures of association for
variables. We can get a general idea about whether or not two variables are related, is
201
.000
Page 85 of 117
520** .452** .401** .329** .454** .315** .444** .318** .406** .465** .445** .376** .382** .258** .359** .404**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 86 of 117
305** .477** .479** .396** .420** .469** .469** .175* .308** .361** .270** .377** .391** .394** .207** .262**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .013 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .003 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 87 of 117
308** .496** .455** .389** .488** .463** .512** .259** .357** .444** .371** .362** .437** .468** .277** .279**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 88 of 117
630** .522** .489** .423** .396** .446** .418** .499** .457** .389** .482** .378** .511** .232** .456** .422**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .001 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 89 of 117
1 .453** .541** .417** .555** .448** .497** .487** .463** .493** .486** .331** .465** .240** .561** .521**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .001 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 90 of 117
453** 1 .603** .480** .546** .563** .521** .445** .547** .495** .489** .465** .425** .472** .379** .430**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 91 of 117
541** .603** 1 .538** .499** .545** .509** .315** .467** .484** .462** .283** .529** .365** .372** .330**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 92 of 117
417** .480** .538** 1 .556** .564** .540** .492** .356** .602** .524** .458** .491** .342** .464** .367**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 93 of 117
555** .546** .499** .556** 1 .493** .652** .396** .430** .549** .456** .436** .470** .356** .473** .459**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 94 of 117
448** .563** .545** .564** .493** 1 .589** .553** .406** .621** .497** .433** .543** .500** .444** .437**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
497** .521** .509** .540** .652** .589** 1 .455** .475** .586** .528** .473** .538** .489** .463** .484**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 95 of 117
487** .445** .315** .492** .396** .553** .455** 1 .465** .553** .585** .552** .556** .266** .600** .545**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 96 of 117
463** .547** .467** .356** .430** .406** .475** .465** 1 .385** .519** .461** .446** .382** .419** .449**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
493** .495** .484** .602** .549** .621** .586** .553** .385** 1 .576** .460** .557** .443** .530** .411**
Page 97 of 117
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
486** .489** .462** .524** .456** .497** .528** .585** .519** .576** 1 .469** .677** .238** .497** .441**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .001 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 98 of 117
331** .465** .283** .458** .436** .433** .473** .552** .461** .460** .469** 1 .497** .394** .426** .544**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
Page 99 of 117
465** .425** .529** .491** .470** .543** .538** .556** .446** .557** .677** .497** 1 .351** .607** .515**
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
.001 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .001 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000 .000
201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201 201
• The correlations presented in the table show the strength and direction of the
linear relationship between pairs of these statements based on the responses
of the participants.
• Sig. level less than 0.05, Indicated that HO is rejected and H1 is failed to
rejected. Where we could say that for HO- there were no significant difference
between two variable.
• Sig. level more than 0.05, indicated that HO is failed to rejected (accepted) and
H1 is rejected. Where we could say that for HO- there were significant
difference between two variables.
• For example, the correlation between "I use the same information as most
people e.g. company profit" and "If many people rely on a certain kind of
information (e.g. return on assets) then it's likely that the information is reliable"
is 0.628, which suggests a positive and moderately strong relationship between
these two statements.
• Similarly, the correlation between "In time of uncertainty in the market, I will
mostly do what other people were doing" and "I'm likely to copy the investing
decision made by people that I know" is 0.567, which suggests a positive and
moderately strong relationship between these two statements as well.
• Out of 201 investors 43.3% investors was invested in SIP, 31.3% in mutual fund,
20.4% in spot market and 5% investors was invested in derivative.
• Out of 201 respondents 37.8% investors was female and other 62.2% investors
was male.
• Out of 201 respondents 48.8% investors was from age group 15 – 25 years,
29.9% was from 26 – 35 years, 10.9% from 36 – 45 years, 8% from 46 – 55 and
rest of the investors was from age more than 56 year.
• Out of 201 respondents per month income (RS.) was as follows- 28.9%
investors having less than 10000, 15.4% having 10000 - 20000, 20.9% having
20000 - 30000, 16.4% having 30000 – 40000, 8% having 40000 – 50000, and
rest of the 10.4% investors having more than 50000 per month.
• Out of 201 respondents 40.8% of our respondents was students, 20.4% was
business person, 33.8% was from service sector, 4.4% was home makers, and 0.
5% was retired.
• Out of 201 respondents 42.3% was graduate person, 35.8% was post graduated,
10% was from professional background, 10.9% was from school background
and rest of the investors was from diploma and diploma mech.
• Out of the 201 respondents most common answer were given is neutral, agree.
• Similarly, the correlation between "In time of uncertainty in the market, I will
mostly do what other people were doing" and "I'm likely to copy the investing
decision made by people that I know" is 0.567, which suggests a positive and
moderately strong relationship between these two statements as well.
• On the basis of this research and it were out puts we can say that investors was
invested and somehow behavioural biases were affected them during
investment decision.
It's important to note that correlation does not imply causation, and other factors may
be influencing the relationship between these statements. Additionally, these
correlations were based on the responses of the participants in this particular study
and may not generalize to other populations or contexts.
Babajide, A. A., &Adetiloye, K. A. (2012). Investors’ Behavioural Biases and the Security
Market: An Empirical Study of the Nigerian Security Market. Accounting and Finance
Research.
Banker, A., Jadhav, D., & Bhatt, V. (2020). A CLASSIFICATION OF E-BANKING USERS
BASED ON IMPACT OF SERVICE QUALITY PARAMETERS IN BANKING INDUSTRY.
PalArch's Journal of Archaeology of Egypt/Egyptology, 17(12), 1746-1758.
Beck, T., Demirgüç‐Kunt, I., A. S., &Maksimovic, V. (2005). Financial and legal
constraints to growth: does firm size matter? The journal of finance.
Beck, T., Demirgüç‐Kunt, I., A. S., &Maksimovic, V. (2005). Financial and legal
constraints to growth: does firm size matter? The journal of finance, 137-177.
Benston, G. J. (1973). Required disclosure and the stock market: An evaluation of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934. The American Economic Review, 132-155.
Berkowitz, D., Pistor, K., & Richard, J. F. (2003).Economic development, legality, and
the transplant effect.European economic review, 47(1), 165-195.
Costa, D. F., Carvalho, F. D., & Moreira, B. C. (2019). Behavioural economics and
behavioural finance: a bibliometric analysis of the scientific fields. Journal of
Economic Surveys, 33(1), 3-24.
https://www.ibef.org/industry/fmcg#:~:text=Fast%2Dmoving%20consumer%20goods
%20 https://www.alliedmarketresearch.com/fmcg-market
https://ezspss.com/one-way-anova-in-spss-including-interpretation
IAEME Publication, IJMET, IJCIET, IJCET, IJECET, IJARET, IJEET, IJM, International
Journal Publisher & Journal Impact Factor, Journal Publication in Chennai, Journal
Publication in India, Journal Subscription in India, Engineering Journals Subscription,
Technology Journals Subscription, Management Journals Subscription, Journal
Publication in Chennai, Thomson Reuters' Research ID : H-3771-2015 Indexed Journals,
Journal publisher in India, High Impact factor journals, UGC Approved Journals, AICTE
Approved Journals, University Approved Journal
https://ezspss.com/one-way-anova-in-spss-including-interpretation
https://www.bing.com/search?q=INVESTIGATING+PERCEPTIONS+OF+BACHELOR+S
TUDENTS+OF++DIFFERENT+MAJORS+ON+THE+ATTRACTIVENESS+OF+BANGKOK+
+UNIVERSITY%27S+MASTER+OF+BUSINESS+INNOVATION%3A+A+CASE+STUDY+OF
++BAISE+UNIVERSIT&form=ANNTH1&refig=210e4734e51b41b296350612f95feebe
Your responses and personal information will remain confidential and this survey
questionnaire is being conducted for education research purpose only. Thank you!
o Savings
o Tax Benefits
o Wealth Maximization
o Other
2. I do invest in...
o SIP
o Spot Market
o Derivative
o Mutual Funds
If many people rely on a certain kind of information (e.g., return on assets) then it’s
likely that the information is reliable
In time of uncertainty in the market, I will mostly do what other people are doing
I'm likely to copy the investing decision made by people that I know
I am generally better than other investors when it comes to reading trends in the
market
I generally don't need the services of a financial planner when investing in financial
products
I prefer low-risk investments over risky investments, even if their returns are low
I buy "hot" stocks and avoid stocks that have performed poorly recently
I buy the new equity offering of the company I have already invested in
Before buying a share, I ignore the market information that conflates with mine.
Before buying a share, I appreciate the market information that supports mine
4. Name?
5. Gender:
o Male
o Female
o Other
6. Age (year):
o 15 - 25
o 26 - 35
o 36 - 45
o 46 - 55
o > 56
o 10000 - 20000
o 20000 - 30000
o 30000 - 40000
o > 50000
8. Occupation:
o Student
o Business
o Service
o Retired
9. Education Qualifications:
o School
o Graduation
o Post Graduation
o Professional