bay
A Study of the Twenty Aspects of Sunyata
(Based on Haribhadra’s Abhisamaydlankara-aloka and the
Patcavim Satisthasrikd-prajndpdramitd-sitra)
The present article has for its aim the elucidation of the term
danyata, as interpreted by the Madhyamika school of the Buddhists.
It forms a part of my Analysis of the 8 principal subjects and the 70
topics of the of the Abhisamayalamkara of Maitreya-A:
subject dealt with at present refers to the first chapter of the
aiga.® ‘The
Abhisamayilamkara (Sarva-dhara-jnita-adhikara), to its 9th topie,—the
action of Accumulation (of the factors for the attainment of Enlighten-
meut by the Bodhisattva; sambhara-pratipatti), and more particularly
to the Bodhisattva’s Accumulation of Wisdom (jidana-sambhara;
Abhisam. Kariki I 47a contains only the word jndnam). This Accu-
mulation of Wisdom represents the cognition of the principle of
Sinyata=Non-substantiality or Relativily—in its various aspects by
the Bodhisattva on his Path. he subject, which is only pointed to
by a single word is discussed in detail in the Abhisa-
ammayiilam floki of Haribhadra. We
quote the . corresponding
passages of the said work (according to the MS. of Prof. ¥, Minaev,
now in possession of the Public Library at Leningrad), along with its
Tibetan translation (Tangyur, MDO, VI, Peking Edition).
The classification into 20 Aspecis has been made by
Haribhadra (as well as by his predecessors) in accordance with
the Paicaviméatisahasrikaprajaaparamithi
sitra. The passages of the latter are quoted and translated in
the foot-notes, in order to show the full concordance between the texts.
For other works as for instance in the Ma dh yantavibhanga
of Maitreya-Asaatga, in Ditnunaga’s
Astasahasrikapindartha ete. we have 16 or 18 aspects
‘This Analysis has been undertaken, for publication in the Caleutta Oriental
jes, ; :A Study of the Twenty Aspects of Sanyata 171
of sanyaté as the number usually admitted (cf. Mahdvyutpatti
§ 37). The last four forms which appear in the Paficaviméatisdhasrika
are evidently later additions.
As regards the translation of the term sinyata by ‘Relativity’,
§ adopted by Prof. Th. Sicherba
of Buddhist Nirvana. Objections have been raised against this render-
it has heen. firs
y in his Conception
ing. It is however in any case correct if we take the term from the
standpoint of the Madhyamika school (as in the Abhis, dloka,
Arar
Haribhadra is a Madhyamika, since he belongs to the Yo;
Madhymika-svatantrikas). In the Tibetan Commentaries it is especially
pointed to the fact that the term sanyaté has the same meaning as
pratitya-samutpada which latter term in the Madhyamika interpreta-
jion has the meaning of Relativity. This is most eloquently confirmed
by the Soka of Nagirjuna’s Lokitita-stava :—
a: MalerayeaTa: YeaaT Ga A Hart
ara eaeeat areca fegargraaiga:
“