Professional Documents
Culture Documents
LOQPAABPED05
LOQPAABPED05
I many physical s y s t e m s , the potential energy V(q) will have a minimum a t some n
, value of the coordinate q, s a y q,
which c l a s s i c a l l y would b e the r e s t position of the s y s t e m .
In many c a s e s of i n t e r e s t , w h e r e the excitation energy of the s y s t e m (measured from expansion V(q) V,), we c a n approximate the potential i n the vicinity of q,
E i s small
by a Taylor
V, +
. . .. .
m i n this potential then becomes
q o , i. e. x = q - 90
J
and where
W2
i s n o t included i n the Lagrangian a s not affecting the equations of motion, appearing only a s a shift in the origin i n the m e a s u r e m e n t of the energy. F r o m the Lagrangian of equation 5. 2 we then define t h e Hamiltonian
5. 1.
Eigenvalues and eigenfunctions The transition to Quantum Mechanics m a y be m a d e by replacing the conjugate momentum
to the coordinate x
by
p=-ifia ax
(5. 6 )
We have encountered this equation before i n the context of the minimum joint s p r e a d problem in chapter 2. that the eigenvalues I t s analytical solution i s d i s c u s s e d i n Appendix C. a r e d i s c r e t e and given by T h e r e we found
so that the e n e r g i e s
a r e given by
E~
= (n +
$) bur
where
and
An
hw
above
E,,
Recall
- E ,
(n+l)=
&En
En
En-l
= 2n+l
( i i i ) T h e ground s t a t e wavefunction ( a normalized Gaussian) s a t i s f i e s the minimum joint s p r e a d condition a s was shown i n c h a p t e r 1. harmonic o s c i l l a t o r Hamiltonian, The r e a s o n f o r this is that the
s p a c e respectively.
5.2.
where
i s given by
[a,at]
i s given by
H operating on a wavefunction
un (x) yields
a a
i. e.
or
at
alone?
In)
,
In
m u s t b e a s i m p l e multiple of the s t a t e
1).
We accordingly w r i t e
= (n
I~C;,
cnln
1 ) = jcnla
,
a and at
Iln
1 ) = 1.
w h e r e we again have used that the s t a t e s and 5.20 we m u s t then have lcnla = n
In)
a r e normalized.
= n 1/2
(5. 2 1) Conse-
'note
f r o m equation 5. 15 that
aat
a a = 1.
We s e e that the r e s u l t of the operation of lowest s t a t e o r , equivalently, c a l l the o p e r a t o r s e e that at/n) The o p e r a t o r at a
on the s t a t e
In)
hru.
to annihilate a quantum of e n e r g y
the annihilation o p e r a t o r .
= (n+l)1/21n+l)
.
The operators a
(5.23) and
a r e called l a d d e r o p e r a t o r s b e c a u s e they c a n be used to go up and down the l a d d e r of They a r e useful in p r o b l e m s p o s s e s sing a uniformly spaced eigenvalue
eigenvalues. spectrum.
Using t h e s e o p e r a t o r s , we c a n solve the ~ c h r g d i n ~ e r equation r a t h e r effortlessly. p a r t i c u l a r , the ground state, corresponding to n=O, m u s t b e the solution to the equation
In
if n e c e s s a r y ,
by substituting equation
was obtained much m o r e painfully by solving the second o r d e r differential Schrgdinger equation i n appendix C. Having the ground s t a t e , we may obtain a l l the higher excited
'
' ~ o t e that
h,
(5) =
25.
See appendix C.
T h e r e is a one-to-one
c o r r e s p o n d e n c e between the
un (x) and the s c a l a r product a s defined i n c h a p t e r 1, and t h e occupation number s p a c e with eigenvectors cussion, i. e. In) and the s c a l a r product that w a s implicitly defined i n the preceding d i s -
1
X
ar. $(at, a ) ] I n )
(5. 2 6 )
and
mhw = i(-j,-)
1/2
(a
a)
O p e r a t o r s in this s p a c e a r e m a t r i c e s .
By way of example
whereas
It can easily be verified by d i r e c t substitution that t h e s e b a s i s v e c t o r s and m a t r i x o p e r a t o r s satisfy the fundamental relations a s given by equations 5.22 and 5.23. 5.3. Harmonic o s c i l l a t o r s i n t h e r m a l equilibrium. Any s t a t e a harmonic oscillator can a s s u m e c a n be r e p r e s e n t e d by a superposition of t h e eigenfunctions un(x), i. e.
n or, equivalently,
where
and
(E) = ( $ I H I $ )
T , we
and t h e r e f o r e ( E ) = hw
1
where x = hw/k T.
Now
and t h e r e f o r e
i. e . ,
tiw/kgT
<< 1,
IE)- k g T ,
i n a g r e e m e n t with c l a s s i c a l Maxwell-Boltzmann s t a t i s t i c s and the correspondence principle.
5. 4
oscillators a s a sum N
a r e the N-dimensional v e c t o r s
Note that if the o s c i l l a t o r s of the s y s t e m w e r e coupled, the Hamiltonian could not be s e p a r a t e d into the s u m of such t e r m s , t e r m s between the coordinates. By way of example, but would involve c r o s s
if the interaction between
a q(9,t j
= H q(9,t )
q(9,t) =
where
n
j
+j(qj, t )
,
i = l,N
if e v e r y one of the N o s c i l l a t o r s
where
and
= ( n l , c2,.. . . . , nN)
Ve can now define, a n a l t e r n a t e s e t of b a s i s eigenvectors, by analogy to the single harmonic oscillator, in particular,
nN)
Ir,)
lnl,na,.
. . . .,
(5.45)
and
) ;1
= n j 1 /2 In1,
"0,.
. . . . ,n.J
1,.
. . . . ,4) . . . ,n
= (n. + 1 ) 1 / 2 / n 1 , % ,. . . . . , n + I , . .
J j
~ )
1")
eigenstates, i. e . ,
n where
o r , equivalently
we have f o r uncoupled o s c i l l a t o r s ,
cn =
IT
j
u nj
* 4J 1.J ( 9 J. , 0 ) d q1. .l
or,
since
we have
5. 5
I this s y s t e m of o s c i l l a t o r s i s in t h e r m a l equilibrium a t s o m e t e m p e r a then the probability of finding the jth o s c i l l a t o r a t a l e v e l n . would be J given by a Boltzmann f a c t o r t u r e T,
which,
yields
We note that each one of the t e r m s in the summation o v e r j, i s equal to the energy a t t h e r m a l equilibrium of a n isolated harmonic o s c i l l a t o r and therefore, taking the r e s u l t of equation 5.35, we have,
frequencies ,u j'
i. e . ,
and
m + dw.
(3
'U+'id
I
Ln any event, the summation c a n b e r e c o v e r e d f r o m the i n t e g r a l using
s e e problem 2. 16, we obtain the black body spectrum of Planck, i. e. equation 2. 130.
This
r e s u l t suggests that the light quanta of Planck behave like the excitation levels of harmonic oscillators whose fundamental frequency
JJ
Taken a t At f i r s t
face value i t i s a l e s s than obvious model to assocaate w i t h light, to be sure. sight, i t would be difficult to assign a
mass
show that there exlst a s e t of coordinates f o r the photon field, in t e r m s of which the Hamiltonian is given bv equation 5. 36, o r equivalently, equation 5. 48. To show that, of
course, would b e sufficient and we will then have derived Planck's formula through a r a t h e r unexpected route.
5. 6
Phonons.
W e can always treat a matter a s a continuum when the smallest length scale of interest,
say
a, i s much larger than the (mean) spacing between the constituent particles.
In other
words, we can neglect the atomic nature of gases, liquids and solids if
where
pm
This approximation i s
the limit of equation 5. 6 1 is quite different from the reasons that dictate a quantum v e r s u s a classical description of a phenomenon. (Planck's constant) i s negligible o r not. The l a t t e r decision i s based on whether the size of F o r many systems, especially a t low temperatures
h
where only the lowest energy levels a r e excited, a quantum mechanical treatment of the continuum behavior i s in fact appropriate. This we will do by following the usual procedure The transition to
Quantum Mechanics i s then made by selecting a representation for the conjugate coordinatemomentum pairs such that
Cqj, pj1
* i
* .
(5. 6 2 )
In describing the motion of the medium, consider the displacement q along the x-axis,
of a medium element which has a r e s t position a t x.
If we now compare q(x), the displacement of the element f r o m x , to q(x+6x), the displacement of the element from x+6x, we have that the difference in the displacements 6q i s given
pd,
P 6x = P W ,
where
,
x + q and
x + d x + q + 6q.
(5. 6 4 )
Combining
where
.3
To define the Lagrangian, we note that the kinetic energy p e r unit volume of the medium i s given by
1 Z p ( 5 t ) I&
t)la
(i)
(ii)
and
is isotropic
(iii)
a fluid).
These conditionr a r e m a t by a liquid, f o r which we can consider the potential energy p e r unit volume a s possessing a minimum a t the equilibrium value
p a po , a s sketched below.
For small deviations from the equilibrium density we can then approximate tho potential energy per unit volume by a Taylor expansion about its e q d i b r i u m value
Y(p)
po,
i. e.
Y(po
1 7 (P
- p,Ia
V4(P,)
1 X
C P ( ~ ~ ) - P O ] ~ ~ ' E ,
~ C ~ ( & , I[&.3(3t)la
{
X
dai
Let us now assume that the displacement field satisfies periodic boundary conditions a t the edge planes of a rectangular box of volume
V o
Lx Ly L 2' i.
2,
a.
t)
- Ly/2,
2.
t) = 9(x. Ly/2,
Z, t)
and
q(x, Y,
t)
.
a -xq ax
n 0,
(5.75~) we can
ff
expand the space dependence of q(=, t) into a Fourier series of the form
where, from the periodic boundary conditions (equation 5. 75), the permissible wavevectors a r e given by
where
where
is the Kronecker delta, and therefore, the Fourier coefficients Qk(t) a r e given by
iQk
2
where
and
Using tha Fourier s e r i e s axpansion for the displacement field, we now have
and
where k have
I&\.
(5. as)
where
M =
i s the total mass of the medium, and cs i s a constant with units of velocity. then have
&V
1 CiJo~"(po)la
Qk,
we
where
J = 1,2.
There i s a slight complication that a r i s e s f r o m the fact that the coordinates and j in fact, f r o m the defining equations 5.82a and 5.82b we see that
Q~
Q-Lj
and
a r e not independent.
Q&~ Q-b~ a
Qba
(5. 89a)
- Q-ba
(5. 88b)
not ail the
'5,
can be used to f o r m a s e t of orthogonal coordinates. In particular, if we use Q j Lj a s a coordinate, we must exclude Q - k j. The Lagrangian can be expressed, however, a s a
d
where the summation over the positive k-(haU) space is denoted by the plus sign prefix of the
k -
summation index.
Lj
to the coordinates
P
o r , substituting for the Lagrangian,
&,j
=-
aL
w,,
= M"
'
PLj
hj
'
where
In other words
where
We can now compute the energy of the liquid in thermal equilibrium a t a temperature
where n(w) is the density of states p e r angular frequency. To compute the density of states, we note that there a r e two modes f o r each wavenumber
&
corresponding to j = 1 and
N(ol<cu) = 2
o r , since k
( 2 ~/V ~ )
= s/cS
and therefore
aad therefore
= hw/kgT,
The definite integral i s a pure number and given by ( s e e for example F. Reif, Fundamentals of Statis tical and Thermal Physics, Appendix 1 1)
(E)
EG =
~ T ' V ( ~ ~ T ) ~
30(cSh)'
Cv =
h15(lcs)"
which i s seen to be proportional to the cube of the temperature. Substituting for the Boltzmann and Planckl s conatants,
we have the theoretical prediction f o r the heat capacity of liquid ' ~ e t low temperatures a c
0. O O O ~ ) ( T / O K )(~ , / ~ ) " K ~ J
where the uncertainty in the theoretical prediction r e s u l t s f r o m the finite accuracy with which the speed of sound is known. to be [J. Wiebes, C.C. The measured heat capacity of liquid 4 ~ below 0. b0?S i s found e
= (0.0204
* 0.0004)
(TPK)"
(J/g)
OK-'
This expression f o r the heat capacity fails a t temperatures higher than 0. 6 ' ~ o r a n f interesting reason: our continuum assumption fails! As the temperature i n c r e a s e r higher
since, f o r a mode of excitation of wavenumber k, the appropriate length scale (wavelength) goes like
In(.
The interesting thing i s that the model of a system of uncoupled harmonic The effect of the d i s c r e t e particles
[u = m(k)].
on
The Hamiltonian, a s given by equation 5.92, i s a s sketched below. See problem 5.18.
i s still c o r r e c t
(&I
Problems
5. 1
Derive the eigenfunctions and energy levels of a two-dimensional harmonic o s c i l l a t o r whose potential i s given by V(x,y) =
1 7 k[xacosaa +
yasinaa]
T h i s i s a good model f o r the vibrations of the c e n t r a l a t o m of a p l a n a r molecule of the type sketched below
5.2
'C,
a R=-ix.
5. 3
a.
5. 4
Show t h a t
5. 5
5. 6
Using the o p e r a t o r s
fc
and
$, e x p r e s s e d in t e r m s of the l a d d e r o p e r a t o r s (equations
( m ( z ( n ) and (m\$ln). C o m p a r e with the c o r -
responding p r o c e d u r e a s outlined in problems C. 4 and C. 5 of Appendix C. 5. 7 Write down the m a t r i x representation corresponding to the b a s i s defined by equations 5.28 f o r
5. 8
xi
be the d e p a r t u r e of the i th
Problems (continued) 5. 9 Express the Hamiltonian of the preceding problem using the annihilation and creation operators defined by equation 5.46. 5. 10 Find the value of the commutators [ai, a . ] , [ai, a j 1, where J the annihilation and creation operators defined by equation 5.46. [ai, a.],
J
a.
and ai
t are
5. 11 Compute and plot the heat capacity of a single harmonic oscillator a s a function of
hm /kgT.
~g
-($I
6Y
no?
L
where
ddSE
where
Derive the classical equation of motion f r o m the Lagrangian density given by equation (ii) and show that
)Iz
x, sia(wt+B)
(i)
(ii)
p(t). x,
2, p,
pa
I s the
(iii)
E/hm
ao.
lx-
5' 1)
can be written as
ca
P ( [ ~ - ~ ' I ) n 2Po ( 5 - x 1 ) 6
where cs is the speed of sourrd,
pd
- g ( l ~ - ~ l ,) (
i s the equilibrium density, 6 ( 5 - 4 l ) i s the three i s a function that possassea a peak at the g()x-x'))
0,
model for the liquid a s given by the expression for the potential of equation 5.72
(i)
~ ( k for )
this system.
(iii)
g ( r ) as a function of
as
~(k), where r
r
g(r)?
0,
III-xll.
a?