Montaigne and Bacon
Montaigne’s essays are characterized by an insistent first person voice.
Whether he discusses his reading, his thoughts, or his experiences, the
consciousness that shapes his writing is transparently his own.
His essays meander and digress, though always more
purposefully than might first appear, and their effect is of a man exploring
his world and regularly being surprised at what he discovers in the process.
In contrast, Bacon‘s essays almost entirely lack personal references.
Propositional rather than experiential, they strike modern readers as
having a sermonic, rhetorical quality that contrasts sharply with
Montaigne’s more casual works.
JB Priestly says that Bacon’s works are not essays in the core sense of theMichel de Montaigne /mi
when, in 1580, he gave the title Essa
Montaigne’s essays were disci
and often run to many thousands
An essay is not devoted to narrative
It may use anecdotes —the chief interest isno
The essayist dons the role of social philosophe
Theodor Adorno “Essay as Form” -essay Fr
freedom’-
Plutarch
St Augustine
Thomas a KempisFrancis Bacon says “the word is la
_ Seneca’s epistles as essays “disp
Bacon described his Essays (1597) as
give an appetite than offend with satis
Dr Johnson “a loose sally of mind: an.
a regular and orderly composition” (Dictiona
t whi
The genealogy
Characters of Theophrastus (3rd c. BC),
the Meditations of Marcus Aurelius (2nd c. AD) anc
to Lucilius (1st c. AD) all qualify for inclusion in thisEssay (F essai, ‘attempt’) A composition, usually in prose
(Pope's Moral Essays in verse are an exception), which
may be of only a few hundred words (like Bacon’s Essays)
or of book length (like Locke’s Essay Concerning Human
Understanding) and which discusses, formally or
informally, a topic or a,variety of topics.
It is one of the most flexible and adaptable of all literary
forms,Montaigne and Bacon
Montaigne’s essays are characterized by an insistent first person voice.
Whether he discusses his reading, his thoughts, or his experiences, the
consciousness that shapes his writing is transparently his own
His essays meander and digress
their effect is of a man exploring his world and regularly being surprised at
what he discovers in the process.
In contrast, Bacon‘s essays almost entirely lack personal references.
Propositional rather than experiential, they strike modern readers as
having a sermonic, rhetorical quality that contrasts sharply with
Montaigne‘s more casual works.
JB Priestly says that Bacon’s works are not essays in the core sense of the
genreThey present multiple perspectives on a viven topic.
The successions of aphorisms that constitute the essays generally
take one position, then its almost opposite, before eventually
landing somewhere in the middle.
The effect is to represent thought as it occurs rather than to report
its resultsTwo factors promoted the rise of the essay during the early 17th
century.
Firstly the bases of knowledge were shifting at this time.
reviously, knowledge was still founded on the authority of
lier writers and on principles of deduction.
round 16" and 17*" c observation and experiment began to
erge as plausible and desirable (Inductive)
Since the focus was on observation (empiricism) the nature,
circumstances, and experiences of the writer became important1e 17th century several new prose forms proliferated.
writings approached the essayistic:ssay in England began as imitation-mimicry of classical texts
Tudor text books
uctive philosophy (observation rather than authority)
oristic writings , meditative prose, character sketchesumentative Philosophical treatises of writers like Thomas Hobbes
1679) influenced the genre.
shn Locke‘s (1632-1704) An Essay Concerning Human Understanding
689) he called it an essay because of its conditional/adhoc/quasi
ire-probative as opposed to magistral form of knowledgenons and meditations
John Donne Meditation XVII
Devotions Upon Emergent Occasions
lento sonitu dicunt, morieris.
this bell tolling softly for another, says to me, Thou
die.
continent, a part of the main. If a clod be washed
by the sea, Europe is the less, as well as if
}e own were. Any man's death diminishes me,
ause | am involved in mankind; and therefore never
to know for whom the bell tolls; it tolls for theeth century also witnessed an «xpansion of
other types of what might be
d —utilitarian prose writing: travels, biographies,
and journals, pamphlets, journalism, and— Oo
17° c Sermons
Treatise
Epistles-Tracts
Defoe’s Journalistic writings too contributed to the periodical
The Periodical Essay (see Pat Rogers)
The Enlightenment-Rise of the public sphere(Jiirgen Habermas) in the
18" century
the proliferation of pamphlets and periodicals, the essay was becoming
an increasingly popular form -dedicated readership-subscribers
Weekly papers, current events, topics-coffee houses( began in 17**c
but proliferated in the 18thc —-known as “Penny Universities”)
Earliest coffee houses in Damascus qahveh khaneyportant consequences for essays and essayists.
st - the regular access to a consistent readership invited
ists to adopt a more familiar, as opposed to formal, style,
if they were corresponding with known readers.
ind - the periodical format enhanced the
sional and topical nature of the essay.
ly could writers use current events as
of departure, but the range of appropriate occasions
ded to include personal experiences in the lives of the
(as in Addison’s — “A Visit to Westminster Abbey”)Richard Steele joined by Joseph Addison
a week
Sir Isaac Bickerstaff (Swift s creation)
711-12)chiefly Addison’s efforts
fictional characters such as Sir Roger de Coverley(country)
b(town)-the focus on the relationship between
d society,and criticism
ler a nd The Idler, Guardian, The Examiner, The Bee