Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 3

1.

Act only in accordance with that maxim through which you can at the same time
will that it become a universal law.” In lay terms, this simply means that if you
do an action, then everyone else should also be able to do.

Cite at least five(5) examples of morally right human action that demonstrates the
possibility that it can be performed by others. Show the maxim (rule of action) applied
in the human action. 5 pts.

Example: 1. She told her friend to stop cheating during the test. Maxim: Honesty
is the best policy.

1. She is very polite and respectful to her co-workers.


Maxim: Treat others as you want to be treated.
2. The school bully's next target trap failed, causing him to injure himself.
Maxim: Do not do to others what you would not wish done to yourself.
3. Dwight has a 3-year long-term relationship with Hannah. He was forced to attend a
rave party by his childhood best friend Josh. Josh introduced Stella to Dwight and
whispered to him that this pretty girl really liked him a lot. Dwight showed no interest,
but Josh still pushes him to Stella even though Dwight doesn’t like the girl. Dwight
decided to leave the party instead and went straight to Hannah’s house and told her all
about it. After a couple of days, Dwight still ignored his best friend Josh and is still mad
at him for being such an enabler.
Maxim: It's better to be safe than sorry.
4. Clint worked hard and crawled his way to the top to finish his degree, despite being a
scholar and a son of a garbage collector who grew up in the slums. That didn’t stop him
from aiming for his dreams. He was always envious of people who easily get what they
want in an instant or in the blink of an eye due to their power and connections. But he
turned that into a motivation to strive harder instead and to build his own career and
empire. He always silently prays for good things that will happen in his journey while
waiting patiently for the right opportunity to come on his way. Now, he is a well-known
Businessman and an Engineer.
Maxim: All good things come to those who wait.
5. Cara has a daughter named Rei. She’s the type of mother that is caring and a good
mother to her child. Rei told herself that she will just be like her mom when the day
comes. Now, Cara is sitting on the couch admiring how her daughter takes care of her
son. Cara complimented her on how type of a good and kind mother Rei had become,
Rei responded to her with a smile and told her “All thanks to you mom.”
Maxim: Be a good example as well as a good teacher.

Think and use other maxim and examples. The maxim above is already taken.
2. One of the problem of Kant's categorical theory: The theory applies only to
rational agents. It would not apply to non-humans or to humans who are not
rational, e.g., humans with brain malfunctioning, illness or persistent vegetative
coma.

In what way can we do good actions even if Kant's ethics of duty won't work with
humans with brain malfunctioning, illness,or persistent vegetative coma? 5 pts.

 Kant's ethics of duty is a moral theory that states that we ought to perform our
duties. Duty is a concept that Kant defines as "the idea of doing something
because it is right in itself." We have a duty to do good things, because they are
good in themselves. In this way, we can do good actions even if Kant's ethics of
duty won't work with humans with brain malfunctioning, illness,or persistent
vegetative coma.

If our actions are not working well in the world, we might not be able to tell what is
right and what is wrong. However, there should be a clear distinction between
right and wrong. If an action is right or wrong depends on whether it helps or
hurts people around us or not. If someone does something for you but it doesn't
help them too much at all then perhaps it wasn't such a good deed after all. That
person may have just been doing something out of obligation rather than from
love for you or your well-being.

Kant's responsibility ethics is an example of a consequentialist ethic. It is built on the


premise that we should do whatever brings the maximum enjoyment to everyone,
regardless of how they feel about it. Kant's ethics of duty also presupposes that
we can always do good even if Kant's ethics of duty will not work with persons
who have brain dysfunction, disease, or are in a prolonged vegetative state. This
assumption is founded on the concept that because we are rational creatures with
free will, we can select our acts and do good for others.

3. One weakness of the categorical imperative: It is not flexible idea. each situation
is different thus the categorical imperative does not work, if you are saying lying
is morally wrong but a situation suggests that lying is the morally better thing to
do one must lie. we like to look at the end result too much rather then the person
and the morality of it.
Let's say a Stranger is asking for your friend's whereabouts. You have the feeling that
your friend's life might be in danger, but, you know where your friend is. Will you lie or
tell the truth to the stranger where your friend is? If you are Immanuel Kant how will
you defend and justify your answer? 5 pts.

 Kant did not believe that there was any morally correct way to lie. He held
that even in extreme cases of an “Inquiring Murderer” we must still tell the truth.
Even if lying to that “Inquiring Murderer” could save someone's life, telling the
truth is the morally right thing to do.

It is very difficult to say whether or not it is right to lie. It may be correct in a


certain situation, but there are other cases that are so grave that lying would be
justified.

If you have the feeling that someone's life might be in danger, and if you know
where your friend is, then it is best not to tell the stranger where he or she can
find your friend. However, if your friend is in danger and the stranger knows this
information already, then telling him or her where your friend is might save that
person's life.

If we assume that lying is wrong, then we should tell the truth because there is no
point in lying when one can get killed anyway if they are caught. However, if
lying is not wrong, then we should lie and save a person from getting killed by
the Stranger.

Kant thinks that it is always better to tell the truth than it would be to lie and risk
getting caught in the lie.

You might also like