Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PEC 2017 Short Circuit Calculation Sample
PEC 2017 Short Circuit Calculation Sample
PEC 2017 Short Circuit Calculation Sample
This post is inspired by the 2017 Philippine Electrical Code (PEC) Appendix D Example D14 (Simplified
Fault Current Calculation). While the 2017 PEC solution is straightforward, it does not explain the
essence of base values and their role in per-unit conversions.
This approach aims to provide clarity and hopefully enlighten confused electrical practitioners that the
Per-Unit Method is a handy tool in analyzing electrical circuits of any size, from the smallest residential
loops to the largest transmission networks.
SITUATION
An industrial complex receives 230 V, 60 Hz from a bank of three single-phase distribution transformers
interconnected into a three-phase configuration. Each distribution transformer is rated 100 kVA, and the
entire bank has an impedance of 5%. The transformer bank taps into a 34.5 kV supply with a 1,000 MVA
short-circuit capacity.
Using the per-unit method, what maximum symmetrical fault currents may occur in each of the fault
points "a", "b", and "c"? From these fault currents, what are the minimum symmetrical kiloAmpere
Interrupting Capacity (kAIC) ratings needed for each molded case circuit breaker (MCCB) A, B, and C?
ANALYSIS
In order to compute everything as a unified circuit, all given per-unit values must be converted to a
common base power value. However, if this new base power is equal to the existing base power,
conversion is not necessary (as demonstrated in some equations below).
There is no need to establish a common base voltage. While the flow of power remains the same in the
entire circuit by virtue of the Law of Conservation (P,in = P,out), the voltage gets affected by the turns
ratio of every transformer it passes.
It is, therefore, wiser to use the existing base voltage of each sub-circuit as the "new" base voltage itself,
than to establish a common base voltage for all only to have it converted with the turns ratio of each
transformer sub-circuit that needs to be examined.
By retaining the existing base voltages, the per-unit supply voltage for each sub-circuit is pegged at 1 pu.
2.) CONVERT PER-UNIT VALUES FROM THE GIVEN BASE VALUE TO THE COMMON BASE VALUE.
For the source sub-circuit, the actual values can be used as given base values.
For the cable conductors in the load-side circuit, their specifications are 250 mm^2 THW in steel conduit
at 100 ft long (30.4878 m).
According to 2017 PEC Table 10.1.1.9 [ or 2017 NEC Chapter 9 Table 9 ] AC Resistance and Reactance for
600 V Cables, the resistance and reactance for such specification are 0.029 ohms per 305 meters and
0.048 ohms per 305 meters, respectively. [ 305 meters ~= 1,000 feet ]
In 2017 PEC Appendix D Example D14, the per-unit impedance of each motor is not directly specified,
but it gives us a clue on where the estimate is acquired: "IEEE Std 141".
IEEE Std 141-1993 (IEEE Recommended Practice for Electric Power Distribution for Industrial Plants)
Section 4.5.4.1 (First-cycle Duties for Fuses and Circuit Breakers) Paragraph 5 states that:
"The low-voltage circuit breaker application guide, IEEE Std C37.13-1981, recommends subtransient
impedances (typically 0.16 to 0.20 per unit) for all motors and allows estimates of typical symmetrical
first-cycle contributions from connected low-voltage motors to substation bus short circuits at 4 times
rated current (the equivalent of 0.25 per unit impedance)."
In determining circuit breaker fault interrupting capacity, the fault current during the first cycle is usually
the biggest concern, and so its equivalent per-unit impedance is used accordingly.
Z,mtr,pu = 0.25 pu
o|---V,pu---Z,a,pu---"a"---|>
o|---V,pu---Z,src,new,pu---Z,xmr,new,pu---"a"---|>
o|---V,pu---Z,b,pu---"b"---|>
o|---V,pu---|---Z,src,new,pu---Z,xmr,new,pu---|---"b"---|>
|----Z,mtr1,new,pu---Z,wire,pu----|
|----Z,mtr2,new,pu---Z,wire,pu----|
3.2.2.) Short-circuit current at fault point "b", per-unit:
i,b,pu = 1 / 0.04457
i,b,pu = 22.4366 pu
[ Note: In 2017 PEC Appendix D Example D14 Step 10.2.d, this fault current is around 19,000 Amps. This
discrepancy will be tackled in another post. ]
o|---V,pu---Z,c,pu---"c"---|>
o|---V,pu---|---Z,src,new,pu---Z,xmr,new,pu---|---Z,wire,pu---"c"---|>
|----Z,mtr1,new,pu---Z,wire,pu----|
|----Z,mtr2,new,pu---Z,wire,pu----|
i,c,pu = 1 / 0.07637
i,c,pu = 13.0941 pu
[ Note: In 2017 PEC Appendix D Example D14 Step 10.3.d, this fault current is around 11,000 Amps. This
discrepancy will be tackled in another post. ]
CONCLUSION
The maximum symmetrical fault currents are 14.971 kiloAmperes at point "a", 16.896 kiloAmperes at
point "b", and 9.861 kiloAmperes at point "c".
The minimum symmetrical kiloAmpere Interrupting Capacity ratings needed then is 15 kAIC for 3ph
MCCB A, 17 kAIC for 3ph MCCB B, and 10 kAIC for 3ph MCCB C.
For comparison, this next scenario demonstrates that an alternative common base value can be used.
Although it produces different new per-unit values, it will still yield practically the same actual results.
==========
REFERENCES
1.1.) 2017 PEC Table 10.1.1.9 Alternating-Current Resistance and Reactance for 600-Volt Cables, 3-
Phase, 60Hz, 75degC - Three Single Conductors in Conduit.
1.2.) 2017 PEC Appendix D Example D14 Simplified Fault Current Calculation.
2.1.) 2017 NEC Chapter 9 Table 9 Alternating-Current Resistance and Reactance for 600-Volt Cables, 3-
Phase, 60Hz, 75degC (167degF) - Three Single Conductors in Conduit.
2.2.) [Not found in 2017 NEC Annex D] (Simplified Fault Current Calculation).
3.) IEEE Std 141-1993: IEEE Recommended Practice for Electric Power Distribution for Industrial Plants
3.1.) IEEE Std 141-1993 Section 4.5.4.1 First-cycle Duties for Fuses and Circuit Breakers.