Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2018-08-17 Times Educational Supplement
2018-08-17 Times Educational Supplement
2018-08-17 Times Educational Supplement
!' Êøêøö÷ " !( ×ò %#!# |#% àëü öæëòòï ÷õìóö äõè ùì÷äï
éòõ öóäõîìñê äñ ìñ÷èõèö÷
ìñ ÷ëè Đðäêìæđ òé ëìö÷òõü
Ùòìñ÷ö ðèäñ óøñì÷ìùè
ðèäöøõèö äñ äï÷èõñä÷ìùè
ÎáÊÖÜ ÑÒÜÝØÛâ ÎáÌÕÞÜÒØ×Ü ÖØÝÒßÊÝÒØ×
÷ò éìûèç¡÷èõð èûæïøöìòñö
àëä÷ ÷ëè õèöèäõæë öäüö
äåòø÷ ÷ëè ìðóòõ÷äñæè
òé ðò÷ìùä÷ìòñ ìñ öæëòòïö
ÍÒÐÒÝÊÕ ÙÞËÕÒÜÑÒ×Ð
,KP[VYPHS
ÍÒÛÎÌÝØÛ Ê×Í ÎÍÒÝØÛ
(UU 4YVa ;OLYL×Z UV[ H SVYYH SVYYH WVPU[ [V
L_HTZ PM [OL YLZ\S[ PZ ISPUK KH[H
à
ÙÊ ÝØ ÝÑÎ ÎÍÒÝØÛ
1VZO\H 4VYYPZ
OH[ PZ [OL >OH[ PZ TVYL PTWVY[HU[ W\WPSZ SLHYUPUN
ÑÎÊÍ ØÏ ÌØ×ÝÎ×Ý
WVPU[ VM [OPUNZ VY \Z RUV^PUN [OH[ [OL`×]L SLHYULK
,K +VYYLSS
L_HTZ& [OLT& 0[ MLLSZ HZ [OV\NO [OL WLUK\S\T OHZ
ÌØ×ÝÎ×Ý ÌÛÎÊÝÒØ× (YL [OL` Z^\UN ^H` [VV MHY [V^HYKZ [OL SH[[LY
1VU :L]LYZ -LH[\YLZ [V ^VYR (JHKLTPJ RUV^SLKNL PZ UV[ H WYV_` MVY
>PSSPHT :[L^HY[ 0UZPNO[ V\[ OV^ HSS SLHYUPUN" [OVZL [LZ[Z KV UV[ [LSS \Z T\JO
:[LWOLU ,_SL` -\Y[OLY T\JO H HIV\[ OV^ ^LSS H Z[\KLU[ JHU JVSSHIVYH[L
*OHYSV[[L :HU[Y` /LSLU (THZZ Z[\KLU[ HKHW[ VY ZLSMYLN\SH[L ;OL` SVVR H[ H ]LY`
1\SPH )LSN\[H` (KP )SVVT OHZ UHYYV^ IHUK VM ZJOVVS L_WLYPLUJL ;O\Z
*OSVL +HYYHJV[[*HURV]PJ SLHYULK VY [V NH\NL OV^ T\JO [OL` OH]L [OL` KV UV[ [LSS \Z T\JO HIV\[ OV^ LMMLJ[P]L
4HY[PU .LVYNL >PSS /HaLSS ILLU [H\NO[& ;V LX\PW Z[\KLU[Z ^P[O L]PKLUJL H ZJOVVS PZ V]LYHSS
2H[L 7HYRLY 1VOU 9VILY[Z VM [OLPY HJOPL]LTLU[Z VY [V KLTVUZ[YH[L [OL (UK OV^ \ZLM\S HYL .*:,Z HUK ( SL]LSZ
.LVYNL 9`HU /LSLU >HYK Z\JJLZZ VM [OL LK\JH[PVU Z`Z[LT& HZ HU PUKPJH[VY VM YLHKPULZZ MVY \UP]LYZP[`
;OLYL OHZ ILLU T\JO JVUZ[LYUH[PVU HUK [OL ^VYSK VM ^VYR HU`^H`&
ÌØ×ÝÎ×Ý ÌÞÛÊÝÒØ× [OPZ `LHY HIV\[ [OL YPZL PU [OL 0[×Z H X\LZ[PVU [OH[ IHYLS` NL[Z
9PJOHYK 1VYKHU :HYHO *\UUHUL U\TILY VM \UJVUKP[PVUHS VMMLYZ HZRLK )LJH\ZL [OLZL L_HTZ HYL
(T` *SHYRL 4HYR /PIILY[-V` THKL [V ZP_[OMVYTLYZ I` UV[ YLHSS` HIV\[ [OL W\WPSZ 0M
,SSH 1HJRZVU 9\ZZLSS 7HY[VU \UP]LYZP[PLZ Ô ZVTL WLY [OL` ^LYL THU` ^V\SK UV[
9VZHSPUL 9VILY[Z JLU[ VM [LLUHNLYZ OH]L OHK H[ IL W\ZOLK PU[V KVPUN [OLT
SLHZ[ VUL \W MYVT WLY JLU[ VY WLYZ\HKLK UV[ [V 6[OLYZ
ÍÎÜÒÐ× Ê×Í ÍÒÐÒÝÊÕ ÖÎÍÒÊ PU HJJVYKPUN [V <JHZ ^V\SK UV[ NL[ VMMYVSSLK HUK
(SL_ 4VYNHU (NH *VSSPZ ;OLYL PZ JVUJLYU [OH[ `V\UN [OLPY JOVPJL VM Z\IQLJ[Z ^V\SK
5PNLS 1VULZ .ÂaLU ;ÂUH WLVWSL NP]LU [OLZL N\HYHU[LLK UV[ IL YLZ[YPJ[LK
VMMLYZ VM WSHJLZ ^PSS OH]L Ù[HRLU (SZV PM [OL NV]LYUTLU[ ^LYL YLHSS`
ÝÎÜ ÐÕØËÊÕ ÌÑÒÎÏ ÎáÎÌÞÝÒßÎ [OLPY MVV[ VMM [OL WLKHSÚ HUK [OLYLMVYL ZLYPV\Z HIV\[ ^VYRYLHKPULZZ [OLU P[ ^V\SK
9VI .YPTZOH^ MHSSLU ZOVY[ VM [OL YLZ\S[Z [OL` JV\SK OH]L OH]L JVTL \W ^P[O H IL[[LY WVSPJ` [OHU
HJOPL]LK IP[S`-L^LY;VW.YHKLZ MVYJPUN Z[\KLU[Z ^OV OHKU×[ HJOPL]LK H *
ÌÕÊÜÜÒÏÒÎÍ ÜÊÕÎÜ 0[×Z LHZ` [V ZLL ^O` ZJOVVSZ HYL ^VYYPLK! VY IL[[LY PU ,UNSPZO HUK TH[OZ [V YLZP[ [OLZL
[OL` HYL Q\KNLK I` ( SL]LSZ HUK .*:,Z .*:,Z H[ JVSSLNL :\YLS` P[ JV\SK JYLH[L H
[LZJ\Z[VTLYZLY]PJLZ'[LZJVT HUK SV^LY YLZ\S[Z O\Y[ [OLT 0[×Z LHZ` [VV IL[[LY TLJOHUPZT [OHU [OL YLNPTL VM LUKSLZZ
[V ZLL ^O` [OL NV]LYUTLU[ PZ ZV JVUJLYULK! YL[HRLZ 6US` WLY JLU[ VM [LLUHNLYZ
ËÛÊ×Í ÊÍßÎÛÝÒÜÒ×Ð Ê×Í P[ TLHZ\YLZ P[Z V^U Z\JJLZZ HNHPUZ[ [OLZL ^P[OV\[ WHZZLZ PU [OLZL Z\IQLJ[Z H[ NV
ÜÙØ×ÜØÛÜÑÒÙ YLZ\S[Z (UK P[×Z LZWLJPHSS` PTWVY[HU[ [OPZ `LHY VU [V ZLJ\YL [OLT H[ ZLL WHNLZ
^P[O [OL ZLJVUK ^H]L VM YLMVYTLK L_HTZ ;OL KLMPUP[PVU VM PUZHUP[` PZ VM[LU ZHPK [V
KPZWSH`LUX\PYPLZ'[LZJVT /PNOLY LK\JH[PVU TPUPZ[LY :HT .`PTHO OHZ IL KVPUN [OL ZHTL [OPUN V]LY HUK V]LY HNHPU
HK]LY[PZPUN[LZJVT JVUKLTULK \UP]LYZP[PLZ HZ TVYL PU[LYLZ[LK PU HUK L_WLJ[PUN H KPMMLYLU[ YLZ\S[ 4HRPUN
NL[[PUN I\TZ VU ZLH[Z [OHU PU OLSWPUN Z[\KLU[Z `V\UN WLVWSL KV [OPZ KLTVUZ[YH[LZ [OH[ [OL
ÜÞËÜÌÛÒÙÝÒØ×Ü 7\[[PUN HZPKL [OL MHJ[ [OH[ P[ PZ [OL NV]LYUTLU[×Z NV]LYUTLU[ PZ IHYRPUN THK
V^U JOHUNLZ [OH[ HYL THRPUN \UP]LYZP[PLZ JOHZL 0U YLHSP[` .*:,Z HUK ( SL]LSZ TLHZ\YL
TLTILYZOPW'[LZJVT [OLZL ÙI\TZÚ ^O` HZZ\TL \UJVUKP[PVUHS VMMLYZ ZJOVVS LMMLJ[P]LULZZ VUS` PU [OL HYLHZ [OH[
[LZJVTZ[VYL HYLU×[ OLSWPUN Z[\KLU[Z& [OL NV]LYUTLU[ ]HS\LZ ;OL`×YL H IHKNL
(M[LY HSS W\WPSZ HYL NL[[PUN ^OH[ [OL` ^HU[ ZSHWWLK VU H Z[\KLU[ [V WYV]L [OH[ [OL Z[H[L
ÖÊÛÔÎÝÒ×Ð Ô H \UP]LYZP[` WSHJL VMMLYLK VU WV[LU[PHS Ô HZ OHZ M\SMPSSLK P[Z YLZWVUZPIPSP[` >OH[L]LY
TLTILYZOPW'[LZJVT ^LSS HZ YLSPLM MYVT [OL WYLZZ\YL HUK Z[YLZZ VM MVSSV^Z PZ UV^ [OLPY V^U MH\S[
JSPMMLKNL L_HTZ >OH[×Z UV[ [V SPRL& )` [OL /HZ [OLYL L]LY ILLU H [PTL ^OLU HU L_HT
ÏÎÎÍËÊÌÔ [PTL [OL` YLJLP]L [OLPY VMMLYZ [OL` ZOV\SK ^HZ SLZZ MVY [OL Z[\KLU[& ;OLPY YLZ\S[Z HYL UV[
SL[[LYZ'[LZJVT OH]L NVUL [OYV\NO TVZ[ VM [OL Z`SSHI\Z VY H WLYZVUHS HJOPL]LTLU[ I\[ H JVU[YPI\[PVU
^V\SK OH]L KVUL OHK [OL NV]LYUTLU[ UV[ [V HU H]LYHNL 0U [OPZ ^VUKLYM\S UL^ ^VYSK
;V LTHPS HU` TLTILY VM V]LYZ[\MMLK P[ ^P[O P[Z UL^ YLMVYTZ (SS HU JOPSKYLU HYL I\[ H \UP[ VM TLHZ\YLTLU[
Z[HMM \ZL [OL MVYTH[ \UJVUKP[PVUHS VMMLY KLWYP]LZ [OLT VM PZ L_[YH >VU×[ HU`VUL [OPUR VM [OL KH[HWVPU[Z&
UHTLZ\YUHTL'[LZJVT YL]PZPVU 4VZ[ WLVWSL JV\SK SP]L ^P[OV\[ [OH[ '(UU4YVa
ÐÎÝÝâ
"( $"
"" #&
'($&
Ýëè ñøðåèõ òé
êìõïö èñ÷èõèç éòõ
Ê¡ïèùèï óëüöìæö
ïäö÷ üèäõ Ýëä÷ ÎÊÛÕâ âÎÊÛÜ ÎáÊÖÜ ÍÒÜÊÍßÊ×ÝÊÐÎ
æòðóäõèö úì÷ë Üëòõ÷äêè òé Ê¡ïèùèï æëèä÷ö Ïìùè úäüö êòòç
ÙÊÛÎ×ÝÜ !! ñøõöèõü çìöôøäïìéìèç öæëòòïö öøóóòõ÷
"('#" Ïäì÷ë öæëòòï åäñö ðøðö
éõòð úèäõìñê ïüæõä
÷èäæëèõö
( ZOVY[HNL VM ULHYS`
-P]L (SL]LS TH[OZ
Z[\KLU[Z OH]L ILLU
çèóõìùèç óøóìïö
;OL HWWYVHJOLZ \ZLK
éòõ åòüö
(U HKQ\KPJH[VY OHZ Y\SLK [OH[ H NYHK\H[L KPZX\HSPMPLK MVSSV^PUN I` ZJOVVSZ [V JSVZL
Ñòúèùèõ êìõïöđ
1L^PZO NPYSZ× Z[H[L ZJOVVS OHZ UV[ LHYS` `LHYZ [LHJOLYZ HU L_HT IVHYK×Z [OL NHW IL[^LLU YPJO
èñ÷õìèö äõè øó åü
IYLHJOLK [OL HKTPZZPVUZ JVKL YPZRZ ÙSL[[PUN KV^U PU]LZ[PNH[PVU PU[V HUK WVVY W\WPSZ OH]L
I` YLX\PYPUN MHTPSPLZ UV[ [V ^LHY V\Y UL_[ NLULYH[PVUÚ [OL SLHR VM H WHWLY ILLU OPNOSPNO[LK PU
KLUPT SLH[OLY VY S`JYH H JOHYP[` ^HYUZ [OPZ Z\TTLY UL^ YLZLHYJO
åì÷ïü¦ÕüæõäËäñ åì÷ïü¦ÎäõïüÜëòõ÷ åì÷ïü¦Öä÷ëöÌëèä÷ åì÷ïü¦Ùòùèõ÷üÐäó
ØÏÜÝÎÍ
ÍéÎ äñç Øéö÷èç ä÷ òççö òùèõ øöè òé èûäð õèöøï÷ö
"(]
æòðóäõèç úì÷ë ä çèæäçè äêò
;OL +LWHY[TLU[ MVY ,K\JH[PVU OHZ KLMLUKLK [OL \ZL
VM L_HT YLZ\S[Z [V Q\KNL ZJOVVSZ PU HU HWWHYLU[ YLI\RL [V
Ýëä÷ õèóõèöèñ÷ö ä 6MZ[LK×Z WSHUZ [V YHKPJHSS` YLMVYT PUZWLJ[PVUZ 6MZ[LK×Z
WYVWVZHSZ [V KV^UNYHKL [OL \ZL VM L_HT YLZ\S[Z HZ H
TLHZ\YL VM ZJOVVS X\HSP[` ^LYL SLHRLK [V H UL^ZWHWLY
åì÷ïü¦Øéö÷èçØççö
!'
|"ð
Ýëè äññøäï
éøñçìñê ÷ëä÷ ÷ëè
ÍéÎ óø÷ö ìñ÷ò
÷ëè Ü÷ìðøïä÷ìñê
Ùëüöìæö
×è÷úòõî
úëìæë ìñæïøçèö
ä óõòêõäððè
öóèæìéìæäïïü
çèöìêñèç ÷ò
ìñæõèäöè ÷ëè
ñøðåèõ òé êìõïö
÷äîìñê Ê¡ïèùèï
óëüöìæö
Üòøõæè Üèè åì÷ïü¦ÙëüöìæöÐäó
Ïïìóåòäõç âòøÝøåè
±Ýèö×èúö ĐÝèö ×èúöđ
ÍÒÜÊÍßÊ×ÝÊÐÎ
ÊÕÊÖâ
Êééòõçäåïè
÷èäæëèõ ëòðèö
Đúòøïç ëèïó
óòòõ óøóìïöđ
:\WWS`PUN HMMVYKHISL
OVTLZ MVY [LHJOLYZ
^V\SK OLSW ^P[O
YLJY\P[TLU[ H[
SV^LYWLYMVYTPUN
ZJOVVSZ H Z[\K` ZH`Z
åì÷ïü¦ÝèäæëÑòðè
ÌØ×ÍÞÌÝ
Ëäññèç Ýèäæëèõ
ÜÊÏÎÐÞÊÛÍÒ×Ð úëò öèñ÷ ïòùè
Ñòú ÷úò ÷òó åòäõçìñê öæëòòïö ÷õìèç ÷ò æòùèõ ïè÷÷èõ ÷ò óøóìï ÊÝÝÊÒ×ÖÎ×Ý
øó $ üèäõö òé Đäóóäïïìñê äåøöèđ ( [LHJOLY PU OPZ MPM[PLZ ×òõ÷ë¡Üòø÷ë çìùìçè Đäïï äåòø÷
;OL ÙHWWHSSPUNÚ ZL_\HS HI\ZL Z\MMLYLK I` W\WPSZ H[ [^V ÙZLJYL[P]LÚ OHZ ILLU IHUULK óøóìï åäæîêõòøñçđ
*H[OVSPJ IVHYKPUN ZJOVVSZ V]LY H `LHY WLYPVK OHZ ILLU ZL[ V\[ PU MYVT [OL WYVMLZZPVU ;OL 5VY[O:V\[O KP]PKL PU [LYTZ VM OV^
H KHTUPUN YLWVY[ ;OL HI\ZL ^HZ PUMSPJ[LK VU JOPSKYLU HZ `V\UN HM[LY ^YP[PUN H SV]L ^LSS W\WPSZ KV H[ HNL ]PY[\HSS` KPZHWWLHYZ
HZ H[ (TWSLMVY[O *VSSLNL PU 5VY[O @VYRZOPYL HUK H[ +V^UZPKL SL[[LY [V H Z[\KLU[ PU VUJL IHJRNYV\UK MHJ[VYZ HYL [HRLU PU[V
:JOVVS PU :VTLYZL[ HJJVYKPUN [V HU PUKLWLUKLU[ PUX\PY` [OL ZP_[O MVYT HJJV\U[ VMMPJPHS YLZLHYJO Z\NNLZ[Z
åì÷ïü¦ÊåøöèÌòùèõ åì÷ïü¦Õè÷÷èõËäñ åì÷ïü¦Ðäó×òõ÷ë
ÊÌÊÍÎÖÒÎÜ
Ñäõõìö äæäçèðü
÷ëä÷ ÷òòî òùèõ
Íòúñëìïïö
æëèä÷èç ìñ Üä÷ö
7\WPSZ H[ H
JVU[YV]LYZPHS
HJHKLT` Y\U I`
/HYYPZ OH]L UV[
ÌØ×ÍÞÌÝ
YLJLP]LK [OLPY TH[OZ
×ò åäñ éòõ
VY ,UNSPZO :H[Z
öæëòòï ïäó÷òó
YLZ\S[Z HM[LY HU
ÍÒßÎÛÜÒÝâ óòõñ ÷èäæëèõ ÎÚÞÊÕÒÝâ
PU]LZ[PNH[PVU MV\UK
Üøææèöö òé Õòñçòñ öæëòòïö ( 7, [LHJOLY ^OV Ëïäæî éäðìïìèö ïèöö ïìîèïü ÷ò
[OH[ [OL` OHK ILLU
Đñò÷ íøö÷ çòúñ ÷ò è÷ëñìæì÷üđ \ZLK OPZ ZJOVVS êè÷ æëøõæë öæëòòï óïäæèö
ÙV]LYHPKLKÚ PU
;OL Z[YVUNLY HJHKLTPJ WLYMVYTHUJL VM SHW[VW [V ]PL^ )SHJR MHTPSPLZ HYL ZPNUPMPJHU[S` SLZZ SPRLS`
[^V WHWLYZ
W\WPSZ PU 3VUKVU JVTWHYLK ^P[O LSZL^OLYL WVYUVNYHWO` MVY \W [V IL HKTP[[LK [V H JO\YJO ZJOVVS [OHU
åì÷ïü¦ÑäõõìöÜä÷ö
JHUUV[ IL ZVSLS` L_WSHPULK I` [OL JP[`×Z [V [^V `LHYZ JHU ZPTPSHY ^OP[L MHTPSPLZ SP]PUN ULHYI` YLZLHYJO
L[OUPJ TP_ HJJVYKPUN [V UL^ YLZLHYJO JVU[PU\L [LHJOPUN W\ISPZOLK I` [OL +M, YL]LHSZ
åì÷ïü¦ÕòñçòñÐäó åì÷ïü¦Õäó÷òóÌïèäõ åì÷ïü¦ÌëøõæëÙïäæèö
ÊÜÜÎÜÜÖÎ×Ý
ĐÎûäðö ëäùè éäìïèç
÷ëè ÷èö÷ ¢ úè ñèèç
ä ñèú öüö÷èðđ
,_HTZ HYL HU V\[KH[LK
WYHJ[PJL Ô SL[×Z MPUK
HUV[OLY ^H` [V LUHISL
Z[\KLU[Z [V KL]LSVW
Z[JLU[\Y` ZRPSSZ
HYN\LZ VUL OLHK
åì÷ïü¦ÎñçÎûäðö
ÐØßÎÛ×ÖÎ×Ý
ĐÜäùè øö éõòð
÷ëè äùäïäñæëè
òé èçø¡öóèäîđ
;OL +LWHY[TLU[
MVY ,K\JH[PVU PZ
VIZLZZLK ^P[O
TLHUPUNSLZZ KH[H
HUK LK\JH[PVUHS
QHYNVU ^YP[LZ
)LYUHYK ;YHMMVYK
åì÷ïü¦ÎçøÜóèäî
àÎÕÕËÎÒ×Ð
Ïìùè åòòîö ÷ò
õèùìùè üòøõ ïòùè
òé ÷èäæëìñê
0M `V\Y WHZZPVU MVY ÊÜÜÎÜÜÖÎ×Ý
ÎÍÝÎÌÑ [LHJOPUN OHZ ILLU đÎûäð õèöøï÷ö æäñ ñèùèõ
àëü ä õòåò÷ úìïï ñèùèõ åè äåïè çò üòøõ ðäõîìñê KHTWLULK I` ÷èïï ÷ëè éøïï ö÷òõüđ
0U YLZWVUZL [V [OL UL^Z [OH[ HY[PMPJPHS PU[LSSPNLUJL [VVSZ HYL ILPUN ^VYRSVHK WYLZZ\YLZ >P[O .*:, HUK (SL]LS YLZ\S[Z SVVTPUN
KL]LSVWLK [V THYR Z[\KLU[Z× LZZH`Z VUL OLHK VM ,UNSPZO HYN\LZ :[LWOHUPL 2LLUHU TLU[HS OLHS[O JHTWHPNULY 5H[HZOH +L]VU
[OH[ THYRPUN P[Z [VV JVTWSL_ H ZRPSS MVY YVIV[Z [V THZ[LY :OL OHZ H SPZ[ VM IVVRZ YLMSLJ[Z VU OV^ ZJOVVSZ HUK W\WPSZ JHUUV[
Z\NNLZ[Z T\JO LHZPLY ^H`Z [V LHZL [LHJOLYZ× THYRPUN ^VYRSVHKZ [OH[ JV\SK OLSW IL Q\KNLK VU NYHKLZ HSVUL
åì÷ïü¦Ûòåò÷Öäõî åì÷ïü¦ÝèäæëËòòîö åì÷ïü¦ÍèùòñÎûäð¦
ÍÊÝÊ ÙÛØÝÎÌÝÒØ×
ÐÎÝÝâ
Ñòú ÷èäæëèõö
æäñ ëèïó öäùè
æëìïçõèñ éõòð
åìê çä÷ä
;LHJOLYZ HYL PKLHSS`
WSHJLK [V OPNOSPNO[
[OL KH[H WYV[LJ[PVU
ULLKZ VM W\WPSZ ZH`Z
3VYK 1PT 2UPNO[
åì÷ïü¦Íä÷äÙøóìï
ÎáÊÖÜ
ĐÊïï äåòäõç ÷ëè
õòïïèõæòäö÷èõ òé
õèöøï÷ö çäüđ
(Z (SL]LS YLZ\S[Z KH`
HUK .*:, YLZ\S[Z KH`
HWWYVHJO VUL MVYTLY
[LHJOLY YLMSLJ[Z VU OV^
H IHK ZL[ VM NYHKLZ SLK
[V OPT SLH]PUN [OL
JSHZZYVVT
åì÷ïü¦ÎûäðÛòïïèõ
Îûäðö
Ñäùè ÐÌÜÎ
õèéòõðö úìçèñèç
÷ëè êäó åè÷úèèñ
õìæë äñç óòòõ
;OL PU[YVK\J[PVU VM [V\NOLY .*:,Z ^HZ Z\WWVZLK
[V YHPZL Z[HUKHYKZ PU [OL JV\U[Y`×Z Z[H[L ZJOVVSZ
I\[ ZVTL SLHKLYZ HYL ^HYUPUN [OH[ P[ OHZ HJ[\HSS`
NP]LU WYP]H[L ZJOVVSZ HU L]LU IPNNLY HK]HU[HNL
V]LY [OL W\ISPJ ZLJ[VY ;OL JVU[YV]LYZ` Z\YYV\UKZ
[OL HS[LYUH[P]L 0.*:, X\HSPMPJH[PVU HKVW[LK I`
THU` WYP]H[L ZJOVVSZ ^OPJO PZ UV^ ZHPK [V IL HU
ÖLHZPLY× VW[PVU àìïï Ñäýèïï PU]LZ[PNH[LZ ¶
ÐÎÝÝâ
ÐÎÝÝâ
ÒÐÌÜÎö ÷ëè ñøðåèõö [OL LX\P[` VM [OL J\YYLU[ Z`Z[LT
,]LU ILMVYL .*:,Z ^LYL YLMVYTLK
JVUJLYUZ OHK ILLU YHPZLK [OH[ ZVTL 0.*:,Z
TPNO[ IL SLZZ JOHSSLUNPUN 0U [OL U\TILY
VM JHUKPKH[LZ MVY 0.*:,Z PU ,UNSPZO SHUN\HNL
L_WSVKLK MYVT [V
# !! )YPHU 3PNO[THU [OLU NLULYHS ZLJYL[HY` VM
[OL (ZZVJPH[PVU VM :JOVVS HUK *VSSLNL 3LHKLYZ
ZHPK ZJOVVSZ ^LYL TV]PUN [V [OL 0.*:,
ILJH\ZL [OL` [OV\NO[ P[ ^HZ ÙLHZPLYÚ HUK
Ýëè ñøðåèõ òé èñ÷õìèö ìñ " !'
ILSPL]LK [OLPY Z[\KLU[Z Ù^LYL NVPUN [V NL[
¤ðäìñïü éõòð óõìùä÷è öæëòòïö¥
OPNOLY NYHKLZ [OHU PU .*:,Ú
Ýëè ñøðåèõ òé ÞÔ èñ÷õìèö éòõ äé÷èõ ÒÐÌÜÎö úèõè õèðòùèç éõòð
;OPZ TPNO[ ZLLT Z[YHUNL NP]LU [OH[ THU`
÷ëè Ìäðåõìçêè ÒÐÌÜÎö ìñ " !& ö÷ä÷è öæëòòï ïèäêøè ÷äåïèö
WYP]H[L ZJOVVSZ VYPNPUHSS` TV]LK [V [OL 0.*:,
ILJH\ZL P[ ^HZ H TVYL YPNVYV\Z X\HSPMPJH[PVU
I\[ [OL [^V [OPUNZ HYL UV[ ULJLZZHYPS` PYYLJVU
JPSHISL 6UL L_HT PUK\Z[Y` PUZPKLY ZWLHRPUN
[V ;LZ HUVU`TV\ZS` ZHPK P[ ^HZ ^PKLS` [OV\NO[
[OH[ 0.*:,Z VMMLYLK NYLH[LY Z[YL[JO MVY [OL
HISLZ[ JHUKPKH[LZ ^OPSL HSZV ILPUN TVYL
HJJLZZPISL MVY W\WPSZ VU [OL *+ IVYKLY
8\LZ[PVUZ V]LY [OL JVTWHYHIPSP[` VM [OL
X\HSPMPJH[PVUZ OH]L ILJVTL L]LU TVYL WYLZZPUN
ZPUJL .*:,Z ^LYL YLMVYTLK ;OL NV]LYUTLU[
ZWLJPMPJHSS` YLKLZPNULK .*:,Z [V IL TVYL
JOHSSLUNPUN HUK PU ZVTL Z\IQLJ[Z [OL HTV\U[ VM
JVU[LU[ OHZ PUJYLHZLK >P[O UV WHYHSSLS WYVJLZZ
[V THRL 0.*:,Z OHYKLY ZVTL WLVWSL ILSPL]L
[OL X\HSPMPJH[PVU OHZ MHSSLU ILOPUK [OL .*:,
PU [LYTZ VM ^OH[ PZ L_WLJ[LK MYVT JHUKPKH[LZ
1HTLZ ,SKVU [OL WYPUJPWHS VM 4HUJOLZ[LY
,U[LYWYPZL (JHKLT` OHZ L_WLYPLUJL VM IV[O
X\HSPMPJH[PVUZ OH]PUN WYL]PV\ZS` PU[YVK\JLK
[OL 0.*:, PU ,UNSPZO ^OLU OL ^HZ Y\UUPUN
HUV[OLY ZJOVVS PU 4HUJOLZ[LY Ù)LJH\ZL VM P[Z
PU[LYUH[PVUHS Z[H[\Z P[ ULLKLK SLZZ J\S[\YHS
JHWP[HS [V \UKLYZ[HUK HUK ^HZ KLZPNULK MVY H
T\JO IYVHKLY H\KPLUJLÚ OL ZH`Z ;OL UL^
.*:,Z OV^L]LY HYL ÙMH[[LY HUK IYVHKLY HUK
YLX\PYL TVYL RUV^SLKNLÚ
;OL UL^ .*:,Z HYL HSZV KLZPNULK [V
WYV]PKL NYLH[LY Z[YL[JO H[ [OL [VW LUK ;OL
ILZ[ WLYMVYTLYZ HYL JV]LYLK I` [OYLL NYHKLZ
YH[OLY [OHU [OL [^V ( VY ( NYHKLZ
;OH[ ULLK MVY TVYL KPMMLYLU[PH[PVU IL[^LLU
[OL TVZ[ HISL JHUKPKH[LZ ULJLZZP[H[LZ X\LZ
[PVUZ [OH[ HYL TVYL KPMMPJ\S[ :V YLMVYTLK
L_HTZ HSZV JHYY` [OL YPZR VM W\WPSZ ZP[[PUN
OPNOLY [PLY WHWLYZ OH]PUN [OLPY JVUMPKLUJL
Ô HUK [OLYLMVYL [OLPY WLYMVYTHUJL Ô RUVJRLK
I` ILPUN \UHISL [V HUZ^LY X\LZ[PVUZ HPTLK
H[ [OL OPNOLZ[HIPSP[` JHUKPKH[LZ
(UV[OLY KPMMLYLUJL IL[^LLU [OL X\HSPMPJH
[PVUZ PZ [OH[ ZJOVVSZ VW[PUN MVY 0.*:, HYL
NP]LU [OL JOVPJL [V [HRL H M\SS` L_HTHZZLZZLK
JV\YZL VY H JV\YZL [OH[ PUJS\KLZ H JV\YZL^VYR
JVTWVULU[ ;OPZ JVU[YHZ[Z ZOHYWS` ^P[O [OL
YLMVYTLK .*:,Z ^OPJO UV SVUNLY PUJS\KL
JV\YZL^VYR PU TVZ[ Z\IQLJ[Z
Ù*V\YZL^VYR PZ UV^ ZLLU HZ HUH[OLTH Ô P[×Z
H OLYLZ` HSTVZ[Ú ZH`Z ,SKVU 0UZ[LHK ¶
ÐÎÝÝâ
Ñòú æäñ ÷ëè ÒÐÌÜÎ æòñ÷õòùèõöü åè õèöòïùèç
àëèñ ÒÐÌÜÎö úèõè õèðòùèç æäñ ëäùè éäì÷ëĔ öäüö Îç Îïïìò÷÷ èçøæä÷ìòñ öüö÷èð ëäö êòñè ē×ò òñè ôøì÷è îñòúö úëä÷đö
éõòð óèõéòõðäñæè ÷äåïèö ëèäçðäö÷èõ òé Ýëè Ùèõöè Üæëòòï ÷ëõòøêë ìñ õèæèñ÷ üèäõö Üò êòìñê ÷ò ëäóóèñ äñç ÷ëè
ðäñü åòäõçö õèöóòñçèç åü ìñ Ìäðåõìçêè äö ÷ëè ñèú ÐÌÜÎ ðä÷øõèö äææòøñ÷äåìïì÷ü óäõ÷ìæøïäõïü ìñ ÷ëè
úì÷ëçõäúìñê ÷ëèð éõòð Øéôøäï Öäïæòïð Ýõòåè çèóø÷ü êèñèõäï æòñæèõñö ðäü äåä÷è äñüúäü ö÷ä÷è öèæ÷òõ çõìùèö åèëäùìòøõö
õèêøïä÷ìòñ Ëü Êøêøö÷ " " ñòñè öèæõè÷äõü òé ÷ëè Êööòæìä÷ìòñ òé Üëäøñ Ïèñ÷òñ ëèäç òé Ûèìêä÷è ¢ ì÷ æòö÷ö óèòóïè ÷ëèìõ æäõèèõö
úìïï åè õèêøïä÷èç Ñòúèùèõ öòðè Üæëòòï äñç Ìòïïèêè Õèäçèõö äñç Ðõäððäõ Üæëòòï äñç æëäìõ ×ò úòñçèõ óèòóïè äõè ÷ëõäöëìñê
óèòóïè ÷ëìñî ÷ëä÷ Øéôøäï äñç ÷ëè ä éòõðèõ æëìèé èûäðìñèõ äêõèèö òé ÷ëè Ñèäçðäö÷èõöđ äñç äõòøñç ÷ò öèè ìé ÷ëèü æäñ ðäîè
ò÷ëèõ ÞÔ õèêøïä÷òõö öëòøïç ÷äîè ēÊïï èû÷èõñäï èûäðìñä÷ìòñö öëòøïç Ñèäçðìö÷õèööèöđ Ìòñéèõèñæè öèñöè òé ä æòñ÷èû÷ òé èûäð
ä ðòõè óõòäæ÷ìùè õòïè äööøõìñê ìñ öòðè úäü åè õèêøïä÷èç ÷ò úëìæë õèóõèöèñ÷ö èïì÷è óõìùä÷è õèéòõð ÷ëä÷ éõäñîïü ðòö÷
÷ëè åõòäç æòðóäõäåìïì÷ü òé èñöøõè ÷ëèõè ìö ä æòñöìö÷èñæü òé öæëòòïö ñò÷èö ēÊæõòöö ÷ëè óèòóïè úòøïç öäü ëäö åèèñ
äïï ôøäïìéìæä÷ìòñö ö÷äñçäõçöĔ ëè öäüö óõòéèööìòñ úëä÷èùèõ öæëòòï çòñè ÷òò ôøìæîïü
ē¨Ýëè õèêøïä÷òõö© ñèèç ÷ò äêõèè Üòðè óèòóïè ÷ëìñî ÷ëè ¢ ö÷ä÷è äñç ìñçèóèñçèñ÷ ¢ ēÒñ ÷ëä÷ æòñ÷èû÷ ÷ëèõèđö
òñ öòðè åõòäç ðèäöøõèö òé æòñ÷õòùèõöü òùèõ ÒÐÌÜÎö ìö ìñ ÷ëèõè ìö ëøêè äñûìè÷ü äåòø÷ óõòåäåïü êòìñê ÷ò åè óèòóïè
èôøìùäïèñæè úëìæë äõè öøåíèæ÷ ÷ò óäõ÷ ä õèöøï÷ òé ÷ëè åèúìïçèõìñê ÷ëè ìðóäæ÷ òé ÷ëè õòïï¡òø÷ ïòòîìñê ÷ò óòìñ÷ ÷ëè éìñêèõ äñç
èû÷èõñäï öæõø÷ìñü öò ÷ëä÷ óèòóïè öè÷ òé æëäñêèö úëìæë ÷ëè Îñêïìöë òé ÷ëè ñèú èûäð õèéòõðö íøö÷ìéü ÷ëèìõ òúñ óòöì÷ìòñĔ
ÐÎÝÝâ
HSS PZ L_[YLTLS` [LSSPUN 0U WHY[ P[ PZ H YLMSLJ[PVU
VM [OL JVTWSL_P[` VM [OL <2 L_HT SHUKZJHWL
Ù0[×Z UV[ Q\Z[ HU 0.*:,.*:, PZZ\LÚ ZH`Z
,SSPV[[ Ù>L×]L NV[ 5VY[OLYU 0YPZO .*:,Z
^L×]L NV[ >LSZO .*:,Z ^L×]L NV[ ,UNSPZO
.*:,Z ;OLYL×Z ZJVWL MVY HSS RPUKZ VM KP]LY
NLU[ Z[HUKHYKZ HUK NYHKPUN [OH[ PZ NVPUN [V
THRL SPML T\JO TVYL JVTWSPJH[LK MVY WLVWSL
SPRL \UP]LYZP[PLZ HUK LTWSV`LYZ ^OV HYL OH]PUN
[V [Y` [V JVTWHYL X\HSPMPJH[PVUZÚ
(UK [OVZL JVTWHYPZVUZ KV TH[[LY +LZWP[L
[OL L_HT IVHYKZ× WYV[LZ[H[PVUZ [OL JVUJLYUZ
HIV\[ MHPYULZZ WLYZPZ[ ;OL NV]LYUTLU[ ZL[ V\[
[V JYLH[L [V\NOLY X\HSPMPJH[PVUZ ^P[O [OL UL^
.*:, HUK [OL L_HT IVHYKZ [OH[ WYV]PKL
0.*:,Z OH]L PU THU` WLVWSL×Z L`LZ MHPSLK [V
THRL [OL JHZL [OH[ [OLPY X\HSPMPJH[PVUZ HYL
LX\HSS` JOHSSLUNPUN
7YP]H[L ZJOVVSZ JOVVZPUN [OL 0.*:, JHU
WPJR HUK JOVVZL X\HSPMPJH[PVUZ ^P[O [OL YPNO[
IHSHUJL VM JV\YZL^VYR HUK L_HT HZZLZZTLU[
[V Z\P[ [OLPY W\WPSZ HUK ^OLU [OVZL W\WPSZ ZP[
[OLPY L_HTZ [OL` JHU THRL \ZL VM HU[OVSVNPLZ
PU JLY[HPU Z\IQLJ[Z
;OL JSLHYLZ[ PULX\P[` VM HSS PZ [OL MHJ[ [OH[
ZVTL \UP]LYZP[PLZ HYL HZRPUN MVY OPNOLY LX\P]H
SLU[ NYHKLZ MYVT Z[\KLU[Z [HRPUN [OL .*:,
JVTWHYLK ^P[O PUKLWLUKLU[ W\WPSZ ZP[[PUN
0.*:,Z ;OH[ PZ ZVTL[OPUN [OH[ VUS` OPNOLY
LK\JH[PVU HKTPZZPVUZ VMMPJLYZ JHU ZVY[ V\[ )\[
L_HT IVHYKZ TH` HSZV ULLK [V HJ[ HUK LUNHNL
TVYL ^P[O [OL LK\JH[PVU ZLJ[VY HUK [OL W\ISPJ
H[ SHYNL PM [OL` ^HU[ [V IHUPZO [OL JSV\K VM
TPZ[Y\Z[ Z\YYV\UKPUN 0.*:,
(Z ,SSPV[[ ZH`Z [OL` ULLK [V ÙSPM[ \W [OL
IVUUL[Ú ZV [OL W\ISPJ JHU IL ÙYLHZZ\YLK [OH[
[OPUNZ HYL IHZPJHSS` WYL[[` ZPTPSHYÚ
Ù6[OLY^PZL [OPZ ^OVSL Z[VY` ^PSS RLLW
Y\UUPUN Z[\KLU[Z ^PSS ILJVTL KLTVYHSPZLK
HUK ZJOVVSZ ^PSS ILJVTL ^VYYPLKÚ
'^OHaLSS
Îïì÷è øñìùèõöì÷ìèö òģèõ Đïòúèõđ ÒÐÌÜÎ êõäçèö
Íìééèõèñ÷ êõäçìñê öüö÷èðö äõè ÒÐÌÜÎ ìñ Îñêïìöë äñç ìñ ÷ëè õèéòõðèç Îñêïìöë ÐÌÜÎ ¤ä Êööòæìä÷ìòñ òé Üæëòòï äñç
äùäìïäåïè éòõ ÷ëè ÒÐÌÜÎ Ýëè ðä÷ëèðä÷ìæö åø÷ äöîö éòõ % ìñ ïòú Ë æòøïç åè êõäçèç äö ä %¥ Ýëè Ìòïïèêè Õèäçèõö ¤óìæ÷øõèç
Ùèäõöòñ ÒÐÌÜÎ øöèö ÷ëè ñèú )¡! ÷ëè ñèú ÐÌÜÎö Ýëìö æòøïç ðèäñ Õòñçòñ Üæëòòï òé Îæòñòðìæö ìñöè÷¥ öäüö ëè ìö æòñæèõñèç
êõäçè ö÷õøæ÷øõè Ñòúèùèõ éòõ ÷ëè ÷ëä÷ ä óõìùä÷è öæëòòï óøóìï úì÷ë ä èûóèæ÷ö ä ðìñìðøð åü ÷ëè çìöæõèóäñæìèö ìñ úëä÷
Ìäðåõìçêè ÒÐÌÜÎ öæëòòïö äõè ïòú Ì æòøïç åè òééèõèç ä óïäæè êõäçè %¦Ë ìñ Îñêïìöë øñìùèõöì÷ìèö äõè äöîìñê éòõ
êìùèñ ÷ëè æëòìæè òé úëè÷ëèõ ÷ëèü úëìïè ä ö÷ä÷è öæëòòï óøóìï úì÷ë ä $ äñç ðä÷ëö åø÷ ëäö ēÞñìùèõöì÷ìèö ñèèç ÷ò èñöøõè
úäñ÷ ÷ò øöè ÷ëè ñøðèõìæäï ¢ úëìæë úòøïç ëäùè åèèñ êõäçèç öäìç ì÷ æòøïç ÷ëä÷ ÷ëèü äõè öè÷÷ìñê æòðóäõäåïè
öüö÷èð òõ ö÷ìæî úì÷ë Ê ÷ò Ð ä Ì øñçèõ ÷ëè òïç öüö÷èð ¢ úòøïç ìñæõèäöè ÷ëè ö÷äñçäõçöĔ ëè öäüö ēÝëèü
Ýëìö óõèöèñ÷ö ä ôøäñçäõü éòõ ñò÷ êè÷ ä óïäæè ðìñìðøð êõäçè ìñ öëòøïç ñò÷ åè öè÷÷ìñê ä ëìêëèõ
øñìùèõöì÷ìèö åèæäøöè ÷ëèõè ìö Ýëèõè äõè ò÷ëèõ èûäðóïèö Ïòõ ÷ëè õèéòõðèç ÐÌÜÎ õèôøìõèðèñ÷ òñ òñè öüö÷èð
ðòõè çìééèõèñ÷ìä÷ìòñ ìñ ÷ëè )¡! ì÷ö åøöìñèöö ðäñäêèðèñ÷ æòøõöè ÷ò & äö ì÷ åèæòðèö äö òóóòöèç ÷ò ÷ëè ò÷ëèõ
öüö÷èð Ýèö ëäö éòøñç ÷ëä÷ öòðè Úøèèñđö Þñìùèõöì÷ü Ëèïéäö÷ äöîö ðòõè èö÷äåïìöëèç ¢ úëìæëèùèõ úäü õòøñç
ìñö÷ì÷ø÷ìòñö ëäùè õèïä÷ìùèïü ïòúèõ éòõ ä Ë ìñ ÷ëè ×òõ÷ëèõñ Òõìöë Öäïæòïð ì÷ ìö àè úòøïç ëòóè
õèôøìõèðèñ÷ö éòõ ÷ëòöè úì÷ë ðä÷ëö ÐÌÜÎ ¤úëìæë æòñ÷ìñøèö Ýõòåè çèóø÷ü ÷ëä÷ äñüåòçü úëòđö
äïóëäåè÷ìæäï êõäçèö Ïòõ èûäðóïè ÷ò åè êõäçèç äïóëäåè÷ìæäïïü¥ äñç êèñèõäï ñò÷ öè÷÷ìñê ÷ëè
Þñìùèõöì÷ü Ìòïïèêè Õòñçòñ ìñ èôøìùäïèñ÷ ôøäïìéìæä÷ìòñö ïìîè öèæõè÷äõü öäðè ö÷äñçäõç
õèôøìõèö ä ðìñìðøð òé Ì éòõ ÷ëè ÷ëè ÒÐÌÜÎ åø÷ äöîö éòõ ä êõäçè & òé ÷ëè úòøïç õèùìèú ÷ëä÷Ĕ
Ê ïèùèïö
ÞÔ óõòóòõ÷ìòñ òé èñ÷õìèö úì÷ë Ê êõäçèö
Ëòüö Ðìõïö Øùèõäïï
() ( ]
Ùäöö õä÷è
÷òó êõäçè
Ýëè ïòúèö÷ ìñ
Ĥùè üèäõö
(%]
äñç ÷òó
(#]
Ùèõæñè÷äêè ]
(!]
( ]
')]
!' !(
" " " " " " " " "
(SL]LS YLZ\S[Z ^LYL W\ISPZOLK ÞÔ óõòóòõ÷ìòñ òé èñ÷õìèö úì÷ë Ê ¦Ê êõäçèö
`LZ[LYKH` ^P[O [OL WYVWVY[PVU VM Ëòüö Ðìõïö Øùèõäïï
LU[YPLZ YLJLP]PUN HU ( MHSSPUN [V
P[Z SV^LZ[ SL]LS PU MP]L `LHYZ HUK [OL "(
"')] $]
V]LYHSS (, WHZZ YH[L H[ P[Z SV^LZ[ óòìñ÷ö
Ðìõïö ñäõõòú
ZPUJL .PYSZ KLMPLK WYLKPJ[PVUZ êèñçèõ êäó
[OH[ [OL` ^V\SK IL OP[ I` H J\[ PU
Ùèõæñè÷äêè ]
)'&] )'&]
)' ] )'!]
)&)
! !! !" !# !$ !% !& !' !(
" " " " " " " " "
!"%
!"(&!"%
(&]
! )%""$
!
%
'%
"& '!
&#%!'%
%
"%
Ïõèñæë Ðèõðäñ Üóäñìöë Ìëìñèöè
¡!&%]
¡!% ÓÌÚ æòñöìçèõö Ê¡ïèùèï Ü÷èð öøåíèæ÷ö ÷ò åè åìòïòêü
æëèðìö÷õü óëüöìæö çèöìêñ äñç ÷èæëñòïòêü ðä÷ëö
éøõ÷ëèõ ðä÷ëö æòðóø÷ìñê äñç ò÷ëèõ öæìèñæèö
" !( èñ÷õìèö " !( èñ÷õìèö " !( èñ÷õìèö " !( èñ÷õìèö " !( èñ÷õìèö " !( èñ÷õìèö
)'&"' &#(!) #'( & %$!#$ ##%#( " %"'
" !' èñ÷õìèö " !' èñ÷õìèö " !' èñ÷õìèö " !' èñ÷õìèö " !' èñ÷õìèö " !' èñ÷õìèö
)%"$$ &!) ( #&%'( %"##! #'(!$ "& (&
Ûèêìö÷èõ ÏÛÎÎ äñç åòòî üòøõ Ñèäçïìñè öóòñöòõ Ëäê öóòñöòõ Üøóóòõ÷èç åü
÷èööèñöëòúæòøî
ÙÊÞÕ ËÊÝÎÖÊ×
/H]PUN ^HYTLK \W ^P[O [OL NYV^[O TPUKZL[ ^OLU H ZWHKL
IHZPJ TVKLS ^L ILNHU [V IYHUJO ZUHWWLK HUK VUL VM [OL JHZ[SLZ
V\[ PU V\Y KLZPNUZ >L [YPLK NV[ HJJPKLU[HSS` ZH[ VU ;OLYL
TV[[L HUK IHPSL` JVUJLU[YPJ ^HZ ]LYIHS MLLKIHJR TVTLU[Z
JHZ[SLZ ^P[O RLLWZ HUK VM H^L HUK ^VUKLY HUK [OLYL
IH[[SLTLU[Z HUK L_WLYPTLU[LK ^HZ L]LU H ZTHSS WSLUHY` ^OLU
^P[O KPMMLYLU[ [`WLZ VM [\YYL[Z T` KH\NO[LY THKL \Z THYR
>L KPZJV]LYLK [OH[ PM `V\ [OLT V\[ VM P[ JHU×[ IL LHZ`
[\YULK [OL ZWHKL IHJR^HYKZ HUK ILPUN H [LHJOLY×Z JOPSK
ZSPJLK KV^U^HYKZ `V\ JV\SK 6M JV\YZL UVUL VM [OPZ
JYLH[L H Z[HPYJHZL SLHKPUN [V [OL TH[[LYLK ;OL I\aa^VYKZ
K\UNLVU >L K\N TVH[Z HUK HUK [LHJOPUN MHZOPVUZ [OL
\ZLK ZOLSSZ HZ KYH^IYPKNLZ 4` Z[YH[LNPLZ ^L L]HS\H[L ^LYL
KH\NO[LY ZWLU[ H SVUN [PTL YLK\UKHU[ OLYL ;V IL OVULZ[
MHZOPVUPUN H Z^PTTPUN WVVS MVY MYVT [OPZ Z\TTLY OVSPKH`
[OL PUULY JV\Y[`HYK ]HU[HNL WVPU[ 0×T UV[
0 RUV^ 6MZ[LK KVU×[ YLHSS` KV JVU]PUJLK [OL` TH[[LY [OH[
ZHUKJHZ[SLZ I\[ 0×K OH]L ILLU T\JO PU [OL JSHZZYVVT LP[OLY
TVYL [OHU OHWW` [V VWLU [OLZL 0U MHJ[ I\PSKPUN JHZ[SLZ ^P[O
VULZ \W MVY PUZWLJ[PVU ;OL` T` RPKZ ZHUK IL[^LLU V\Y [VLZ
JV\SK OH]L PUZWLJ[LK [OL 0×T UV[ Z\YL HU`[OPUN LSZL
I\PSKPUN WYVJLZZ [VV 0[ OHK WHY[PJ\SHYS` TH[[LYLK 5V[ [OL
L]LY`[OPUN! MYVT KPYLJ[ WHZ[ HUK KLMPUP[LS` UV[ [OL
PUZ[Y\J[PVU [V TVKLSSPUN HUK M\[\YL ;OLYL×Z UV WVPU[ I\PSKPUN
WYHJ[PZPUN VM ZRPSSZ [V JOPSKSLK JHZ[SLZ PU [OL HPY ^OLU `V\×YL
KPZJV]LY` SLHYUPUN I\PSKPUN [OLT PU [OL ZHUK
>L JHSSLK \WVU WYPVY 1V )YPNOV\ZL PZ H WZL\KVU`T VM
RUV^SLKNL KL]LSVWLK ZRPSSZ H WYPTHY` ZJOVVS [LHJOLY PU [OL >LZ[
WYVISLT ZVS]LK HUK ^VYRLK 4PKSHUKZ :OL [^LL[Z 'QVFIYPNOV\ZL
ßìöì÷ ÷èöæòð¦ö÷òõè¦óïäññèõ!(
Ùõòéìïè
×ÒÌÔ ÜÒÖÙÜØ×
×ÒÌÔ ÜÒÖÙÜØ×
[OL [Y\Z[ OHK KPMMLYLU[ ZJOVVSZ ILOH]PUN PU
KPMMLYLU[ ^H`Z X\HSP[` Z[HUKHYKZ ^LYL PUJYLKPIS`
]HYPLK 0[×Z YLHSS` PTWVY[HU[ [OH[ ^L YLJVNUPZL
[OH[ [OL ]HS\L VM \Z HSS ^VYRPUN [VNL[OLY PZ
]LY` T\JO NYLH[LY [OHU [OL ]HS\L VM L]LY`IVK`
^VYRPUN PUKLWLUKLU[S`Ú
6UL L_HTWSL VM [OPZ HWWYVHJO PZ [OL ZPUNSL
WYPTHY` J\YYPJ\S\T [OH[ ^HZ YVSSLK V\[ HJYVZZ [OL
[Y\Z[ [V^HYKZ [OL LUK VM [OL `LHY ;OPZ Z[HUKHYKP
ZH[PVU NVLZ OHUK PU OHUK ^P[O H JVUZJPV\Z H[[LTW[
[V ÙKLT`Z[PM`Ú ^OH[ P[ TLHUZ [V IL WHY[ VM H 4(;
Ê
[OV\NO[M\S H[TVZWOLYL KLZJLUKLK VU T`
@LHY JSHZZ HZ ZVVU HZ 0 Z[HY[LK [V YLHK +RZ
WR EH D /LRQ )VSKS` L_LJ\[LK PSS\Z[YH[PVUZ
IYV\NO[ [OL JOHYHJ[LYZ [V SPML HUK THKL V\Y
JSHZZYVVT ILJVTL WHY[ VM [OL ^PSKLYULZZ 0Z
[OLYL H JSHZZ VM ZL]LU`LHYVSKZ [OH[ ^V\SKU×[
IL [YHUZMP_LK HZ [OL` ZWV[ [OYLL TLUHJPUN
SPVUZ OPKPUN PU [OL K\ZR` NYHZZLZ&
;OLU 3LVUHYK HWWLHYZ /L×Z NLU[SL HUK
RPUK Z\YYV\UKLK I` I\[[LYMSPLZ HUK OHZ H J\[L HUK J\KKS` X\HSP[` 3LVUHYK×Z JYPZPZ JVTLZ ^OLU H WHJR VM SPVUZ Z\NNLZ[ OL ZOV\SK IL
[OH[ THRLZ `V\ PUZ[HU[S` ^HU[ [V NL[ [V RUV^ OPT IL[[LY MPLYJL (Z OL ^YLZ[SLZ ^P[O ^OL[OLY OL ZOV\SK JOHUNL OPTZLSM OL PZ
;OL IVVR PZ JOPWWPUN H^H` H[ [OL YLHKLY×Z MP_LK PKLHZ MYVT [OL ]LY` OLSWLK I` 4HYPHUUL [V ^YP[L H WVLT [OH[ L_WSHPUZ [V [OL SPVUZ [OH[
ILNPUUPUN Ù:VTL ZH` [OLYL PZ VUS` VUL ^H` [V IL H SPVUÚ P[ [LSSZ \Z P[×Z UV[ IHK [V IL KPMMLYLU[ ;OPZ Z[HY[LK H KPZJ\ZZPVU HTVUN [OL
HUK [OL ÙZVTL ZH`Ú PZ YLP[LYH[LK [OYV\NOV\[ [OL Z[VY` ,K =LYL NLU[S` JOPSKYLU HIV\[ ÙILPUN `V\YZLSMÚ HUK ^OH[ [OH[ TLHU[ ( WHY[PJ\SHYS`
N\PKLZ YLHKLYZ [OYV\NO [OL PKLH [OH[ ^OH[ ÙZVTL ZH`Ú PZU×[ HS^H`Z ^LSSWSHJLK PSS\Z[YH[PVU VM VUL VM [OL SPVU WHJR H^HRLUPUN [V [OL
[Y\L /L KVLZ [OPZ ^P[O 3LVUHYK×Z JOHYHJ[LY HUK [OLU I` JYLH[PUN [OL I\[[LYMSPLZ HIV]L OPT OLSWLK ZVTL JOPSKYLU [V \UKLYZ[HUK 3LVUHYK×Z
ILH\[PM\S MYPLUKZOPW IL[^LLU 3LVUHYK HUK 4HYPHUUL [OL K\JR TLZZHNL ;OPZ Z[VY` ^HZ H IYPSSPHU[ ^H` [V Z[HY[ [V [HSR [V [OL JOPSKYLU
)` [OL [PTL 3LVUHYK HUK 4HYPHUUL ^LYL ^YP[PUN WVL[Y` [VNL[OLY HIV\[ PKLU[P[` HUK [OL PUMS\LUJL VM V[OLYZ VU V\Y ILOH]PV\Y
0 RUL^ [OH[ 0 ^HZ NVPUN [V IL \ZPUN [OPZ [L_[ MVY `LHYZ [V JVTL +RZ WR EH D /LRQ MP[Z WLYMLJ[S` ^P[O ,K =LYL×Z V[OLY [P[SLZ WHY[PJ\SHYS`
Ù;VNL[OLY [OL` WSH`LK ^P[O 3LVUHYK×Z WVLT \U[PS [OL ^VYKZ JHTL *UXPS\ )URJ ^OLYL HUV[OLY THPU JOHYHJ[LY JVTLZ [V H YLHSPZH[PVU
\UZ[\JRÚ ;OL SHUN\HNL [OYV\NOV\[ PZ YPJO HUK ZH[PZM`PUN" Z\P[HISL [OH[ [LHJOLZ [OL YLHKLY HIV\[ ILPUN `V\YZLSM
MVY H `V\UNLY H\KPLUJL I\[ ^P[O WSLU[` VM L_WVZ\YL MVY [OLT [V H *H[OLYPUL 3HUN PZ H [LHJOLY H[ >LSSZWYPUNZ 7YPTHY` :JOVVS ;H\U[VU :OL
TVYL JOHSSLUNPUN HUK WVL[PJ ]VJHI\SHY` PZ H ISVNNLY H[ ^LSSZWYPUNZLK\ISVNZVYN HUK [^LL[Z '*SHZZ)VVR*VYULY
Ùøóìï õèùìèúö Ö0[ TPNO[ THRL JOPSKYLU [OPUR! KV ^L OH]L [V HSS KV [OL ZHTL [OPUNZ&×
ĐÖü éõìèñç úòøïç èñíòü òø÷ ÷ëä÷ üòø çòñđ÷ ëäùè ÷ò åè ÷ëèü äõè öò ÷ëèü çòñđ÷ ëäùè ÷ò ëè ëäö ÷ò æëòðó Öäõìäññè åø÷
÷ëè æëäõäæ÷èõöđ Ĥèõæè Ò ÷ëìñî ÷ëìö åòòî ìö êòòç éòõ ïìö÷èñ ÷ò ò÷ëèõö äïï ÷ëè ÷ìðè Õèòñäõç çòèöñđ÷ úäñ÷ ÷ò çò ì÷
Ýëìö åòòî ìö äïï äåòø÷ ä ïìòñ æäïïèç âèäõ ! äñç " æëìïçõèñ åèæäøöè ì÷ åèæäøöè öòðè÷ìðèö ÷ëèü æòøïç Ýëè åòòî èñæòøõäêèö óèòóïè
Õèòñäõç Õèòñäõç ìö ä ùèõü êèñ÷ïè ðìêë÷ ðäîè ÷ëèð ÷ëìñî Đçò úè åè çòìñê ÷ëè úõòñê ÷ëìñê ñò÷ ÷ò çò úëä÷ ò÷ëèõ óèòóïè öäü
ïìòñ åø÷ ÷ëè ò÷ëèõ ïìòñö ÷ëìñî ÷ëä÷ ëäùè ÷ò äïï çò ÷ëè öäðè ÷ëìñêöđ Ýìä äêèç ' úì÷ëòø÷ ÷ëìñîìñê
ëè öëòøïç åè Ĥèõæè Õèòñäõç ëäö Ìäüçèñ äêèç ' Õìååì äêèç '
ä åèö÷ éõìèñç æäïïèç Öäõìäññè úëò ĐÒñöóìõìñêđ
ìö ä ÷øõôøòìöè çøæî úëò ëèïóö ĐÊ÷ Ĥõö÷ Ò ÷ëòøêë÷ ì÷ Ýëìö åòòî ìñöóìõèç ðè Õèòñäõç ĐÕèòñäõç ðäçè ÷ëè
Õèòñäõç úì÷ë ëìö óòèðö Ò úòøïç úäö ä öäç åòòîđ ìöñđ÷ Ĥèõæè äñç ñèùèõ úìïï åè õìêë÷ æëòìæèöđ
õèæòððèñç ÷ëìö åòòî ÷ò ðü Ê÷ ÷ëè åèêìññìñê Ò ÷ëòøêë÷ ì÷ úäö Ûèêêìè äêèç ' Ò÷ úäö ä åì÷ öæäõü úëèñ ÷ëè Ĥèõæè
éõìèñç åèæäøöè Ò ÷ëìñî öëè úòøïç ä öäç åòòî åèæäøöè òñè ïìòñ úäö ïìòñö úèõè ÷èïïìñê Õèòñäõç ÷ëä÷
èñíòü ÷ëè æëäõäæ÷èõö òñ ëìö òúñ Ýëèñ ëè ðäîèö éõìèñçö ĐÝëè Ĥèõæè ïìòñö ÷ëìñî ëè ëäç ÷ò åè Ĥèõæè Ò ïìîèç ÷ëä÷
Õòøìöè äêèç ' úì÷ë ä çøæî äñç ÷ëèü Ĥñç ÷ëìñêö ÷ëèõè ìö òñïü òñè úäü ÷ò ÷ëèü úèõè úõòñê äñç Ò ÷ëòøêë÷
÷ëä÷ ÷ëèü ïìîè ÷ò çò ÷òêè÷ëèõ åè ä ïìòñđ ÷ëä÷ Õèòñäõç ðäçè ÷ëè õìêë÷
ĐÐòòç éòõ âèäõ ! Õòïä äêèç ' Ýëìö åòòî ìö äåòø÷ ä ïìòñ ÷ëä÷ ìö æëòìæèö åü ñò÷ ïìö÷èñìñê ÷ò ÷ëè
äñç " æëìïçõèñđ åèìñê ñìæè ÷ò ä çøæî Ýëè Ĥèõæè åìê ñäøêë÷ü ïìòñö
Õèòñäõç ÷ëè ïìòñ ëäö ä ùèõü öóèæìäï ĐÒ÷đö äïï äåòø÷ èñæòøõäêìñê ïìòñö ÷ëìñî ÷ëèõè ìö òñïü òñè úäü Óèööìæä Ê äêèç '
ëìïï úëìæë ìö ä ÷ëìñîìñê ëìïï Ýëè óèòóïè ÷ò åè úëò ÷ëèü äõèđ ÷ò åè ä ïìòñ åü åèìñê Ĥèõæè åø÷ Òé üòø òõ üòøõ æïäöö úòøïç ïìîè
ò÷ëèõ ïìòñö ÷ëìñî ÷ëä÷ ïìòñö öëòøïç Ò ïòùèç ÷ëìö ö÷òõü Ò÷ ìö äïï äåòø÷ Õèòñäõç ÷ëè ïìòñ çòèöñđ÷ äêõèè ÷ò úõì÷è ä õèùìèú óïèäöè æòñ÷äæ÷
åè Ĥèõæè åø÷ ä÷ ÷ëè èñç ÷ëèü Ĥñç èñæòøõäêìñê óèòóïè ÷ò åè úëò Ýëè ò÷ëèõ ïìòñö ÷èïï Õèòñäõç ÷ëä÷ öäõäëæøññäñè±÷èöæòð
Ñìö÷òõü öò õèäï
üòø æäñ ÷òøæë ì÷
([ H [PTL ^OLU OLHKZ HYL Z[Y\NNSPUN [V
IHSHUJL [OL IVVRZ ZJOVVS [YPWZ HYL ILPUN
H_LK )\[ L]LY` W\WPS UV TH[[LY [OLPY
IHJRNYV\UK KLZLY]LZ [OL JOHUJL [V ]PZP[
H ZP[L ^OLYL [OL` JHU MLLS [OL OPZ[VY`
ILULH[O [OLPY MLL[ ^YP[LZ Óòëñ Ëïäîè
ÍÊßÒÍ ÙÊÛÔÒ×Ü
ÍÊßÒÍ ÙÊÛÔÒ×Ü
PM UV[ [OV\ZHUKZ VM [PTLZ ^HZ [HRLU HUK )\[ ÙLK\JH[PVUHS [YPWZ HUK ]PZP[ZÚ HYL UV[ Q\Z[ TLTVYPHS HZ 0 Z[PSS YLTLTILY [OH[ 9VTHU
^OLYL H JOHSSLUNL ^HZ SHPK KV^U [OH[ ^V\SK MVY [OL RUV^SLKNL [OL` HYL MVY [OL L_WLYP WHSHJL ,]LY` JOPSK ZOV\SK OH]L H TVTLU[
PYYL]LYZPIS` JOHUNL YHJL YLSH[PVUZ PU [OL <: LUJL 6M JV\YZL RUV^SLKNL PZ PTWVY[HU[ Ô SPRL PKLHSS` THU` TVTLU[Z SPRL [OH[ ^OH[L]LY
HUK HJYVZZ [OL ^VYSK 9PNO[ [OLYL ^OLYL ^L THU` [LHJOLYZ 0×]L ILLU VU [YPWZ [V MHZJPUH[ IHJRNYV\UK [OL`×YL MYVT
Z[VVK HU PJVU MVY [OL HNLZ ^HZ THKL (UK H PUN WSHJLZ ^OLYL [OL RPKZ ZOV^LK SP[[SL PU[LYLZ[ 0 KPKU×[ NL[ [V ^HSR VU [OL TVZHPJZ [OH[
ZOVY[ KPZ[HUJL H^H` ^HZ [OL >OP[L /V\ZL ILJH\ZL [OL` OHK UV MYHTL^VYR PU[V ^OPJO [V KH` ^OLU 0 ^HZ Ô H NY\TW` ILHYKLK THU
[OL <: *HWP[VS @V\ JV\SK ZLL [OL Z[H[\L VM W\[ ^OH[ [OL` ^LYL ZLLPUN ILJH\ZL [VV SP[[SL KPK HUK OL NH]L TL T` WLUJPS IHJR )\[ 0×T
9VZH 7HYRZ HUK [OH[ VM ;OVTHZ 1LMMLYZVU! ^P[OPU OHK ILLU [H\NO[ [V [OLT 4VZHPJZ HWWLHY NYH[LM\S UV^ 0M OL OHK SL[ TL TH`IL [OL \YNL
HUK IL[^LLU [OLPY SP]LZ ^OH[ H Z[VY` [OLYL PZ TLYLS` HZ JOPWWLK [PSLZ IH[[SLMPLSKZ LTW[` [V [V\JO [OL WHZ[ ^V\SK OH]L ILLU SVZ[ 0 HT
(SS Z[\KLU[Z ZOV\SK OH]L HJJLZZ [V [OH[ NYHZZ Z[H[\[LZ UV TVYL [OHU Z[YLL[ M\YUP[\YL KLSPNO[LK [OH[ 0 Z[PSS OH]L [OH[ KYP]L [V ZLL [OL
0 KVU×[ Q\Z[ TLHU >HZOPUN[VU HUK <: HUK )\[ [OL RUV^SLKNL ^L LUKV^ ZOV\SK HSZV IL THNPJ \W JSVZL! ^L T\Z[ LUZ\YL L]LY` JOPSK PU
JP]PS YPNO[Z OPZ[VY` [OV\NO P[ ^V\SKU×[ IL H H IYPKNL [V [OL YPJO L_WLYPLUJL ZV H Z[\KLU[ V\Y ZJOVVSZ NL[Z [OH[ JOHUJL [VV
IHK [OPUN I\[ [OH[ LSLJ[YPJ TVTLU[ ^OLU JHU ZLL MVY [OLTZLS]LZ ^OH[ ZV MHY `V\ OH]L
[OL WHZ[ [V\JOLZ [OL WYLZLU[ HUK `V\ HYL [OL VUS` OLSWLK [OLT ZLL PU [OLPY TPUK 0U [OL
JVUK\P[ 0 OH]L ILLU H WHZZPVUH[L Z\WWVY[LY IHRPUN OLH[ VM [OL >HZOPUN[VU Z\TTLY
VM [OL NV]LYUTLU[×Z UL^ J\YYPJ\S\T 0[×Z H 0 ILSPL]L ^L MVYNLK MVY [OLZL Z[\KLU[Z HU
LU[P[SLTLU[ MVY HSS JOPSKYLU [V [OL LK\JH[PVU L_WLYPLUJL [OH[ ^PSS SP]L ^P[O [OLT MVY H SPML 1VOU )SHRL PZ H [LHJOLY LK\JH[PVU ^YP[LY HUK
[OH[ [OL TVZ[ WYP]PSLNLK [HRL MVY NYHU[LK [PTL" OVWLM\SS` [OL`×SS YLTLTILY 3PUJVSU×Z WVSPJ` YLZLHYJOLY
/VYZL YPKPUN& >L×]L ;OPZ Z\TTLY 0 YL[PYLK MYVT [LHJOPUN HM[LY ēÝëòöè öæëòòïö úëò óïäü åü ÷ëè
`LHYZ HZ H OLHK[LHJOLY 0 OH]L ^VYRLK PU õøïèö äñç ëäùè ëìêë ö÷äñçäõçö
NV[ NHUNZ HUK JYPTL JVTWYLOLUZP]L HUK NYHTTHY JVLK\JH[PVUHS òé ìñ÷èêõì÷ü äõè çìöäçùäñ÷äêèç
HUK ZPUNSLZL_ ZJOVVSZ (Z OLHK[LHJOLY H[ [^V åü æòðóäõìöòñĔ
VM [OL JV\U[Y`×Z SLHKPUN ZJOVVSZ Ô )L_SL` Óäðèö
0U YLZWVUZL [V `V\Y HY[PJSL Ù.HUNZ KY\NZ HUK .YHTTHY HUK )YPZ[VS .YHTTHY :JOVVS Ô 0×]L ēÑòú ìö ÷ëìö ñèúö Ê æëìïç úëò
HJHKLTPLZ! H IH[[SL V]LY V\Y TVZ[ ]\SULYHISL ILLU VU [OL YLJLP]PUN LUK VM H Z[LHK` Z[YLHT æäñ åäõèïü úõì÷è ìñçèóèñçèñ÷ïü
`V\UN WLVWSLÚ (\N\Z[! VM JV\YZL ^L VM JYP[PJPZT Q\Z[ ILJH\ZL [OLZL ZJOVVSZ HYL ëäö ÷äõêè÷ êõäçè òé % ìñ Îñêïìöë
^V\SK HSS L_WLJ[ [OL 0UKLWLUKLU[ *OPSKYLU×Z ZLSLJ[P]L ;OL JYP[PJPZT JVTLZ KLZWP[L IV[O Ò öèè ì÷ äïï ÷ëè ÷ìðèĔ
/VTLZ (ZZVJPH[PVU [V VIM\ZJH[L HUK ZLLR [V ILPUN ]LY` WVW\SHY HUK OPNOS` ZV\NO[HM[LY I` Êïäö÷äìõ
JVUM\ZL ;OHUL[ ^P[O 2LU[ ^OPJO PUJS\KLZ WHYLU[Z ;OL KLIH[L HIV\[ ZLSLJ[PVU [VV VM[LU ēÜä÷ö äõè ä çèùìæè éòõ ÷ëè ÍéÎ äñç
WSHJLZ Z\JO HZ ;VUIYPKNL HUK :L]LUVHRZ MVJ\ZLZ VU [OL ^YVUN [OPUNZ Øéö÷èç ÷ò ðèäöøõè öæëòòïö äñç
/V^L]LY 0 HT NLU\PULS` Z\YWYPZLK [OH[ [OL *SLHYS` `V\ ^V\SK L_WLJ[ ZLSLJ[P]L ZJOVVSZ ÷èäæëèõö åü Üä÷ö õèöøï÷ö çò ñò÷
5H[PVUHS (ZZVJPH[PVU VM =PY[\HS :JOVVS /LHKZ [V NL[ NVVK YLZ\S[Z" [OLPY PU[HRL PZ HJHKLTPJHSS` ëèïó æëìïçõèñ ìñ äñü úäüĔ
ZOV\SK IL ZV HNNYLZZP]L PU VWWVZPUN V\Y ]PL^ HISL )\[ NYLH[ YLZ\S[Z HSVUL KV UV[ H NVVK Êñçü
[OH[ P[ PZ PTTVYHS [V ZLUK [OL TVZ[ ]\SULYHISL ZJOVVS THRL 0 ZWLU[ TVZ[ VM T` ZLJVUKHY` ēĐØùèõ¡äìçèçđ Òö ÷ëìö ä óòïì÷è úäü
JOPSKYLU [V VUL VM [OL TVZ[ KLWYP]LK Ô HUK ZJOVVSPUN PU H ZLJVUKHY` TVKLYU TV]PUN [V òé öäüìñê Đòùèõ¡óõèööøõèçđ ÷ò
KHUNLYV\Z Ô WHY[Z VM [OL JV\U[Y` )\[ [OLU P[Z [OL SVJHS NYHTTHY MVY ( SL]LSZ ;OL NYHTTHY äæëìèùè õèöøï÷ö éòõ äñ äööèööðèñ÷
JOHPY PZ :HSS` 2LSS` MYVT .YLLU^PJO VUL ^HZ LHZPS` [OL IL[[LY ZJOVVS >O`& )LJH\ZL VM ÷ëä÷ äðòøñ÷ö ÷ò åøêêèõ äïïĔ
VM [OL 3VUKVU IVYV\NOZ HUK HZ `V\Y HY[PJSL [OL J\S[\YL VM L_WLJ[H[PVU HUK HJOPL]LTLU[ Óòè
ZH`Z ZOL [OPURZ JOPSKYLU ZLU[ OLYL HYL ÙPU [OL ;OL NYLH[ ZJOVVSZ 0 OH]L ^VYRLK PU HUK ēÏõäñîïü Ò ÷ëìñî ì÷đö ìððòõäï ñò÷
JV\U[Y` KVPUN OVYZL YPKPUNÚ 0[ ILNNHYZ ILSPLM ]PZP[LK VU PUZWLJ[PVU HYL KP]LYZL I\[ ^OH[ ÷ò çò èùèõü÷ëìñê ÷ò èäöè ÷ëè
[OH[ ZOL SPRL [OL NV]LYUTLU[ ZOV\SK JVU[PU\L [OL` HSS OH]L PU JVTTVU PZ HU HSSWLY]HKPUN óõèööøõè èùèñ ìé ÷ëä÷đö æëèä÷ìñê
[V IL ZV \[[LYS` UHP]L ,P[OLY ^L HYL H ^OP[L J\S[\YL VM Ù@LZ ^L JHU HUK `LZ ^L ^PSSÚ ä÷ ÷ëìö êäðèĔ
^VYRPUNJSHZZ \UKLYWLYMVYTPUN JVHZ[HS HYLH .VVK ZJOVVSZ HYL UV[ NVVK ILJH\ZL [OL` MHJL Üäýïè
ZLYPV\ZS` HMMLJ[LK I` NHUNZ VY ^L HYL H SV]LS` UV JOHSSLUNLZ I\[ ILJH\ZL [OL` PKLU[PM` [OL
ZLHZPKL YLZVY[ PKLHS MVY SVVRLKHM[LY JOPSKYLU \UPX\L JOHSSLUNLZ HUK ^VYR V\[ Z[YH[LNPLZ Êñç ÷ò ēËèúäõè òé ÷èäæëìñê ä
^OV HSS NV OVYZL YPKPUN 0 SP]L HUK ^VYR OLYL >OLU WHYLU[Z JSHTV\Y MVY NYHTTHY ZJOVVS åòòî üòø ¤÷ëòøêë÷ üòø¥ ïòùèçĔ
0 RUV^ ^OH[ P[×Z SPRL HUK ZOL KVLZU×[ WSHJLZ [OL` HYL ZLLRPUN H ZJOVVS [OH[ ^PSS åì÷ïü¦ÏìùèÐòàõòñê
Ùäøï Õøûðòòõè LUJV\YHNL [OLPY JOPSKYLU [V L_JLS WLYZVUHSS` ēÒ õèäç ÷ëè éìõö÷ òé ÷ëè Ïäðòøö Ïìùè
,_LJ\[P]L OLHK[LHJOLY *VHZ[HS (JHKLTPLZ ;Y\Z[ J\S[\YHSS` WO`ZPJHSS` HUK HJHKLTPJHSS` ;OPZ PZ ö÷òõìèö ÷ò ðü æïäöö äñç ëäç ÷ò
WH[LU[S` H YLHZVUHISL HTIP[PVU HUK ^L ^OV æäïï ä ëäï÷ äñç çìöæøöö ÷ëè ñäðèö
( OLHKSPUL VU `V\Y MYVU[ WHNL WVZLK [OL X\LZ ^VYR PU WYV]PKPUN LK\JH[PVU ZLY]PJLZ JHU OLSW Ïäññü äñç Íìæî Ýëèü äêõèèç ÷ëä÷
[PVU Ù(YL V\Y TVZ[ ]\SULYHISL W\WPSZ ILPUN [V KLSP]LY [OPZ I` Z[YP]PUN [V JYLH[L J\S[\YLZ VM Ò öëòøïç öøåö÷ì÷ø÷è ĐÊøñ÷ìè Ïõäñđ
MHPSLK [^PJL&Ú (\N\Z[ ;OL HY[PJSL YL]LHSLK HJOPL]LTLU[ HUK L_WLJ[H[PVU PU L]LY` ZJOVVS èùèõü ÷ìðè Ò öäú ĐÊøñ÷ Ïäññüđ Ò÷
KPZ[\YIPUN KH[H VU [OL PUJYLHZL PU [OL U\TILY Ûòç ÖäæÔìññòñ ÷òòî ðèñ÷äï êüðñäö÷ìæö ÷ò öæäñ
VM JOPSKYLU PU JHYL ILPUN WSHJLK PU JOPSKYLU×Z -VYTLY OLHK )YPZ[VS .YHTTHY :JOVVS äëèäç öò Ò úäöñđ÷ öøõóõìöèç åü
ä ĐÏäññüđ öò ÷ò öóèäîĔ
Ïõòð ÷ëè Ýèö Ìòððøñì÷ü éòõøðö Üøöäñ
àìïï ÷ëè èç÷èæë õèùòïø÷ìòñ âèäë õìêë÷ åèæäøöè äïï ÷ëè ÷èäæëèõö ×ò òñè úìïï æäõè ēàè õèäç Îñìç Ëïü÷òñđö Öòøñ÷äìñ
ìñ öæëòòïö úòõî ÷èæë úè ëäùè ìñö÷äïïèç ÷ëä÷ ÷ëè ēòñïìñèĔ æòøõöèö äõè òé Êçùèñ÷øõè àëò ïè÷ö éìùè îìçö êò
¤åì÷ïü¦ÎçÝèæëÛèù¥ òùèõ ÷ëè ïäö÷ # üèäõö ëäö õøååìöë èûæèó÷ ÷ëè ö÷øçèñ÷ö òéé ìñ÷ò ÷ëè àèïöë ðòøñ÷äìñö úì÷ë
õèçøæèç úòõîïòäç äñç óäõèñ÷ö úëò úìïï ñò÷ öòðè çòñîèüö äñç äñ òïç åïòîè
Ìòðóø÷èõö çò ñò÷ ÷èäæë Ëïäýèõ åè äåïè ÷ò äééòõç èçøæä÷ìòñ úëòđö öæäõèç òé èùèõü÷ëìñêĔ
æëìïçõèñ Ýèäæëèõö ÷èäæë ìñùòïùìñê äæ÷øäï ÷èäæëèõö Ôìõö÷ü
æëìïçõèñ Ìëõòðèåòòîö äõè ×äë Ñìö ìö íøö÷ìéìæä÷ìòñ éòõ Öòöæòúåòõè ēÕòùèç ÷ëèöè åòòîö ä÷ ÷ëè ÷ìðè
èûóèñöìùè ÷òüö ä úäö÷è ïè÷÷ìñê ðòõè óäïö óõòéì÷ éõòð åø÷ Ò úäö ÷òò üòøñê ÷ò ñò÷ìæè
òé öæäõæè õèöòøõæèö èçøæä÷ìòñ Ýëè òåíèæ÷ìùè Óòìñ ÷ëè éòõøðö ä÷ ÷ëä÷ Îñìç Ëïü÷òñ úäö ä êõøðóü
ßìñæèÞïäð ëèõè ìö èçøæä÷ìòñ úì÷ëòø÷ æòððøñì÷ü÷èöæòð èïì÷ìö÷ õäæìö÷Ĕ
Ìïäõè
4YZ 7LYRPUZ
Ðõèê Ðõäééìñ
;OL SLHK ZPUNLY VM <: W\UR IHUK )HK 9LSPNPVU YLTLTILYZ H T\ZPJ [LHJOLY
^OV [H\NO[ OPT [V ZPUN YVJR HUK YVSS HUK NH]L OPT [OL NPM[ VM JVUMPKLUJL
Ö
` ZJOVVS ^HZ PU ^HZ YLHSS` [OL ILNPUUPUN VM T` ZPUNPUN JHYLLY 0 UL]LY [OV\NO[ VM T`ZLSM HZ H WHY[PJ\SHYS`
H ^VYRPUNJSHZZ PU [OH[ P[ NH]L TL JVUMPKLUJL PU T` ZPUNPUN NPM[LK ZPUNLY 0U MHJ[ 0 Q\Z[ HZZ\TLK [OH[
JP[` JHSSLK HIPSP[` HUK [H\NO[ TL [OPUNZ SPRL OHYTVU` L]LY`VUL JV\SK ZPUN [OL ^H` [OH[ 0 KPK
4PS^H\RLL [OH[ ^V\SK SH[LY ILJVTL T` OHSSTHYR ;OL ZJOVVS P[ZLSM ^HZ H SH[L [OJLU[\Y`
BPU [OL Z[H[L 4YZ 7LYRPUZ T\Z[ OH]L ILLU PU OLY [^LU[PLZ I\PSKPUN [OH[ Z[VVK KH\U[PUNS` VU [OL
VM >PZJVUZPU H[ [OL [PTL ZV UV[ H[ HSS VSK VY Z[VKN` (UK SHUKZJHWL 0[ ^HZ ]LY` PUZ[P[\[PVUHS ;OL
PU [OL <:D PU [OL JOVPY ^L KPKU×[ ZPUN [YHKP[PVUHS ZVUNZ T\ZPJ YVVT ^HZ \W PU H JVYULY VM [OL
HS[OV\NO 0 SP]LK HS[OV\NO HYV\UK OVSPKH` JVUJLY[ [PTL ^L I\PSKPUN HUK P[ ^HZ H M\U WSHJL [V IL
PU H WYL[[` ^V\SK SLHYU *OYPZ[THZ JHYVSZ ;OL JOVPY WYHJ[PZLK ILMVYL [OL ZJOVVS KH`
HMMS\LU[ UVY[OLYU Z\I\YI PU ^OPJO T` ;OL X\LZ[PVU VM JV\YZL PZ OV^ KV `V\ OHK HJ[\HSS` Z[HY[LK 0 TLHU JHU `V\ PTHNPUL
TVT ZL[[SLK 4` ZJOVVS [OLYL ^HZ JHSSLK NL[ H I\UJO VM `V\UN WLVWSL PU[LYLZ[LK [OPZ! NL[[PUN RPKZ [V ZPUN H[ PU [OL
3HRL )S\MM ,SLTLU[HY` ^OPJO ^HZ H ]LY` PU JOVYHS T\ZPJ& >LSS [OL ^H` 4YZ 7LYRPUZ TVYUPUN& -VY [OL MPYZ[ TPU\[LZ ^L ^LYL
SPILYHSTPUKLK PUZ[P[\[PVU 0[ OHK H IPN KPK P[ ^HZ [V IL H NVVK ( 9 BHY[PZ[Z HUK HSSV^LK [V WSH` YLJVYKZ ZV [OL VSKLY RPKZ
T\ZPJ KLWHY[TLU[ PM `V\ ^HU[ [V JHSS YLWLY[VPYLD WLYZVU HUK WPJR ZVUNZ [OH[ ^V\SK IYPUN PU [OL SH[LZ[ 3LK ALWWLSPU
P[ [OH[ OLHKLK \W I` H ZPUNSL WLYZVU! ^V\SK YLZVUH[L ^P[O [OL W\WPSZ :OL JOVZL HSI\TZ HUK ^L ^V\SK SPZ[LU [V [OLT VU
4YZ 1HUL 7LYRPUZ [V [LHJO \Z ZVUNZ [OH[ ^LYL VU WVW\SHY 4YZ 7LYRPUZ× Z[LYLV
-YVT [OL YK NYHKL B@LHY D 0 ^HZ PU [OL YHKPV VU YVJR HUK YVSS YHKPV :V ^L ^LYL 0 H[[LUKLK [OL ZJOVVS VU H ZJOVSHYZOPW
JOVPY >L WSH`LK [^V VY [OYLL JVUJLY[Z ZPUNPUN ZVUNZ MYVT :[L]PL >VUKLY HUK ^OPJO ^V\SK IL \UOLHYK VM [OLYL [VKH` ;OPZ
H `LHY [OL JVZ[Z VM ^OPJO ^LYL TL[ I` [OL 1HTLZ ;H`SVY HUK ^L ^V\SK WLYMVYT [OL TLHU[ [OH[ 0 ^HZ HSZV HISL [V H[[LUK H T\ZPJ
SVJHS JVTT\UP[` ZVUNZ VM [OLZL HY[PZ[Z ^OLU [OL WHYLU[Z JHTW \W PU 4HKPZVU K\YPUN [OL Z\TTLY 0 KV
5V[ VUS` KPK 4YZ 7LYRPUZ OLHK \W [OL JHTL [V [OL JVUJLY[Z ILSPL]L [OH[ OHK 4YZ 7LYRPUZ UV[ ZLSLJ[LK
T\ZPJ KLWHY[TLU[ ZOL HSZV KPYLJ[LK WSH`Z 0 ^HZ VM[LU JOVZLU HZ [OL ZVSVPZ[ ZV 0×K TL HZ H ZVSVPZ[ NP]LU TL ZJOVSHYZOPWZ MVY
0 WLYMVYTLK PU H JV\WSL VM [OVZL I\[ 0 IL ZPUNPUN [OLZL ZVUNZ MYVT [OL YHKPV ^P[O Z\TTLY T\ZPJ ZJOVVS HUK JVU[PU\HSS` ZL[ [OL
ZLLTLK [V L_JLS H[ ZPUNPUN 0U MHJ[ [OH[ 4YZ 7LYRPUZ HJJVTWHU`PUN TL VU [OL WPHUV YLZWVUZPIPSP[PLZ MVY NVVK WLYMVYTHUJL VU T`
ZOV\SKLYZ 0 ^V\SKU×[ OH]L HJOPL]LK [OL V[OLY
Ëòõñ ÷ò åè Ëäç HJHKLTPJ HUK WYVMLZZPVUHS [OPUNZ [OH[ JHTL
Ðõèê Ðõäééìñ SH[LY PU SPML *VUMPKLUJL PU VULZLSM PZ [OL
Ëòõñ & ×òùèðåèõ !)&$ Öäçìöòñ àìöæòñöìñ SHZ[PUN NPM[ VM H NYLH[ [LHJOLY
Îçøæä÷ìòñ Õäîè Ëïøéé Îïèðèñ÷äõü Üæëòòï (M[LY 0 OHK ZWLU[ MV\Y `LHYZ PU [OL JOVPY
àìöæòñöìñ Îï Ìäðìñò Ûèäï Ñìêë Üæëòòï T` MHTPS` TV]LK [V 3VZ (UNLSLZ HUK ZOVY[S`
Õòö Êñêèïèö Þñìùèõöì÷ü òé Ìäïìéòõñìä Õòö HM[LY [OH[ 0 Z[HY[LK [OL T\ZPJ WYVQLJ[ [OH[ PZ
Êñêèïèö Ìòõñèïï Þñìùèõöì÷ü ×èú âòõî )HK 9LSPNPVU ([ [OL ZHTL [PTL 4YZ 7LYRPUZ
Ìäõèèõ Üìñæè !)( Ðõäééìñ ëäö åèèñ TV]LK [V :HU -YHUJPZJV ZV 0 SVZ[ [V\JO
÷ëè öìñêèõ òé ÷ëè ìñéïøèñ÷ìäï Êðèõìæäñ )\[ 0 KPK SVVR OLY \W X\P[L YLJLU[S` HUK
óøñî õòæî åäñç Ëäç Ûèïìêìòñ úì÷ë ZOL×Z IHJR PU >PZJVUZPU (UK SV HUK
úëòð ëè ëäö õèïèäöèç !& ö÷øçìò äïåøðö ILOVSK ZOL×Z Z[PSS H T\ZPJ KPYLJ[VY 6UL VM
Òñ " !! ëè åèæäðè ä ùìöì÷ìñê ïèæ÷øõèõ [OLZL KH`Z 0×T [OPURPUN VM NVPUN [V ZLL OLY
òé èùòïø÷ìòñ ä÷ Ìòõñèïï Þñìùèõöì÷ü PU H Z\YWYPZL HWWLHYHUJL
.YLN .YHMMPU ^HZ ZWLHRPUN [V 0HU >PU^VVK
ÊÕÊÖâ
ĐÜëè æëòöè ÷ò ÷èäæë
øö öòñêö ÷ëä÷ úèõè òñ
óòóøïäõ õäçìò öò úè
úèõè öìñêìñê öòñêö
éõòð Ü÷èùìè àòñçèõ
äñç Óäðèö Ýäüïòõđ
9LTHYRZ!
HYL [OL` YLHSS`
^VY[O P[& :\ITP[[PUN Z[\KLU[Z× L_HT WHWLYZ MVY YL]PL^ PZ
JVZ[S` Ô HUK P[ PZ HSZV YPZR` NP]LU [OH[ NYHKLZ JHU
NV KV^U HZ ^LSS HZ \W :V OV^ KV JHZOZ[YHWWLK
ZJOVVSZ KLJPKL ^OL[OLY [V [HRL H W\U[ VU H W\WPS&
Îïïìò÷÷ Íòøêïäö [HRLZ H SVVR
¶
Ò
[ PZ .*:, YLZ\S[Z KH` HUK `V\ MPUK +LZWP[L [OPZ WVZZPISL WP[MHSS P[ ZLLTZ [OH[
`V\YZLSM MHJLK ^P[O H KPSLTTH! 1HJVI WSLU[` VM ZJOVVSZ HYL Z[PSS ^PSSPUN [V YLX\LZ[
OHZ ^VYRLK OHYK [OYV\NOV\[ [OL YL]PL^Z (JJVYKPUN [V 6MX\HS×Z 9L]PL^Z VM
`LHY OPZ L_HT [LJOUPX\L PZ [VW 4HYRPUN HUK 4VKLYH[PVU YLWVY[ ZLL
UV[JO HUK OPZ TVJR YLZ\S[Z ^LYL IP[S`6MX\HS9L] PU WLY JLU[ VM HSS
L_JLSSLU[ @L[ OPZ MPUHS .*:, THYR .*:, NYHKLZ ^LYL JOHSSLUNLK HUK WLY
KVLZ UV[ YLMSLJ[ [OPZ H[ HSS JLU[ ^LYL JOHUNLK ;OPZ ^HZ HU PUJYLHZL VU
@V\ HYL Z\YL [OH[ VUL VM OPZ WHWLYZ [OL WYL]PV\Z `LHY PU ^OPJO WLY JLU[ VM
OHZ ILLU THYRLK \UQ\Z[S` I\[ `V\Y NYHKLZ ^LYL JOHSSLUNLK HUK WLY JLU[ ^LYL
OLHK VM KLWHY[TLU[ YLM\ZLZ [V OH]L [OL ZJYPW[ JOHUNLK -VY ( SL]LSZ HUK (: SL]LSZ .*,Z
YL]PL^LK I` [OL L_HT IVHYK ;OL WYVJLZZ PZ [OL U\TILYZ ^LYL HSZV OPNOLY! WLY JLU[
JVZ[S` `V\Y JSHZZ HSYLHK` OHZ [OL ILZ[ YLZ\S[Z ^LYL JOHSSLUNLK HUK WLY JLU[ ^LYL JOHUNLK
PU [OL KLWHY[TLU[ HUK [OL ZJOVVS×Z OLHKSPUL PU \W MYVT WLY JLU[ HUK WLY JLU[
MPN\YLZ ^V\SK UV[ IL ZPNUPMPJHU[S` HMMLJ[LK YLZWLJ[P]LS` PU
)\[ ^OH[ HIV\[ 1HJVI& +L[LYTPULK [V NL[ ;OPZ YPZL ZOV\SK WLYOHWZ UV[ JVTL HZ H
OPT [OL ILZ[ KLHS WVZZPISL `V\ L]LU[\HSS` Z\YWYPZL (M[LY HSS ^HZ [OL `LHY PU ^OPJO
KLJPKL [V WOVUL OPZ WHYLU[Z [V Z\NNLZ[ [OL MPYZ[ JVOVY[ VM Z[\KLU[Z ZH[ [OL YLMVYTLK
JVUMPKLU[PHSS` [OH[ [OL` YLX\LZ[ H YL]PL^ .*:, L_HTZ PU ,UNSPZO HUK TH[OZ ^P[O
VM THYRPUN WHWLYZ ILPUN NYHKLK PUZ[LHK VM (.
;OL WHWLY PZ K\S` ZLU[ VMM (UK 1HJVI×Z ;OLYL ^LYL UL^ ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ [V MVSSV^
ZJVYL PTWYV]LZ I` THYRZ W\ZOPUN OPT HUK [OLYL ^HZ ^PKLZWYLHK JVUJLYU V]LY [OL
V]LY H NYHKL IV\UKHY` X\HSP[` HUK JVUZPZ[LUJ` VM THYRPUN 6UL
(TPK [OL PUL]P[HISL OPNOZ HUK SV^Z VM L_HT THYRLY ^OV ^PZOLZ [V YLTHPU HUVU`TV\Z
ZLHZVU [OLYL HYL VM[LU YLZ\S[Z SPRL 1HJVI×Z KLZJYPILK [OL WYVJLZZ HZ ÙZOHTIVSPJÚ (TPK
[OH[ Q\Z[ KVU×[ THRL ZLUZL 0U [OVZL PUZ[HUJLZ HSS [OPZ HZRPUN MVY H YL]PL^ T\Z[ OH]L ILLU
[LHJOLYZ KV UV[ OH]L H ZPTWSL QVI [V ^VYR V\[ WHY[PJ\SHYS` [LTW[PUN
^OH[ OHZ OHWWLULK +PK [OL Z[\KLU[ ZPTWS`
OH]L H IHK KH`& >V\SK H YL]PL^ THRL H Ðòìñê ìñ åïìñç
KPMMLYLUJL [V [OL V]LYHSS NYHKL& >OH[ PM [OL )\[ [OL YL]PL^ WYVJLZZ P[ZLSM OHZ HSZV JVTL
WHWLY PZ Z\ITP[[LK MVY H YL]PL^ HUK [OL NYHKL \UKLY OLH]` MPYL 0U HU VUSPUL WVSS JVUK\J[LK
HJ[\HSS` NVLZ KV^U& 0Z 1HJVI×Z Z[VY` [OL I` ;LZ PU 1\UL [OPZ `LHY WLY JLU[ VM
L_JLW[PVU [V [OL Y\SL& WHY[PJPWHU[Z ZHPK [OH[ [OL YL]PL^PUN WYVJLZZ
>P[O UL^ L_HT ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ IYPUNPUN ^HZ UV[ HZ JSLHY VY Z[YHPNO[MVY^HYK HZ P[
\UJLY[HPU[` I\KNL[Z [PNO[LY [OHU L]LY HUK ZOV\SK OH]L ILLU Ô HU PZZ\L [OH[ OHZ
Z[\KLU[Z× NYHKLZ VU [OL SPUL [OL KLJPZPVU WLYOHWZ ILLU M\Y[OLY JVTWSPJH[LK I` [OL
[V ZLUK H WHWLY MVY YL]PL^ PZ UV[ VUL [V IL MHJ[ [OH[ 6MX\HS PU[YVK\JLK JOHUNLZ [V
[HRLU SPNO[S` :V [OL X\LZ[PVU [LHJOLYZ [OL YLX\PYLTLU[Z MVY YL]PL^Z VM THYRPUN
OH]L [V HZR [OLTZLS]LZ PZ! HYL YLTHYRZ HUK TVKLYH[PVU PU (\N\Z[ àìïï ÷ëìö üèäõ åè äñò÷ëèõ üèäõ
YLHSS` ^VY[O [OL LMMVY[& -VY VUL L_HT IVHYK H MHPS\YL [V YL]PL^ ìñ úëìæë ì÷ úìïï åè úòõ÷ë ÷äîìñê
;V HUZ^LY [OH[ P[×Z PTWVY[HU[ [V \UKLYZ[HUK WYVWLYS` IYV\NO[ JVUZLX\LUJLZ ä óøñ÷ òñ ä õèùìèú
L_HJ[S` ^OH[ H ÙYLTHYRÚ PU]VS]LZ -VSSV^PUN HU PU]LZ[PNH[PVU I` 6MX\HS
;OL 1VPU[ *V\UJPS MVY 8\HSPMPJH[PVUZ (8( HKTP[[LK PU +LJLTILY [V
1*8 ^OPJO YLWYLZLU[Z [OL L_HT IVHYKZ MHPSPUN [V MVSSV^ YLN\SH[PVUZ HYV\UK YL]PL^Z [OL U\TILY VM L_HTZ [HRLU PU YLMVYTLK
ZH`Z [OH[ ZPUJL [OL YLJLU[ J\YYPJ\S\T HUK VM L_HT NYHKLZ ;OL L_HT IVHYK PZZ\LK HU X\HSPMPJH[PVUZ HUK JHUKPKH[LZ JLY[PMPJH[PUN
L_HT YLMVYTZ Ù[OLYL PZ UV Z\JO [OPUN HZ \UKLY[HRPUN WYVTPZPUN [V JOHUNL [OL ^H` PU [OLZL Z\IQLJ[ZÚ
H ÖYLTHYR× I\[ H YL]PL^ VM THYRPUN [OH[ [OH[ P[ [YHPUZ HUK TVUP[VYZ P[Z YL]PL^LYZ ;OL YLWVY[ HJRUV^SLKNLZ [OH[ Z\IQLJ[Z
JHU PUJS\KL H JSLYPJHS JOLJR HUK H ZLJVUK :V OV^ ZOV\SK SHZ[ `LHY×Z WYVJLZZ PUMVYT SPRL ,UNSPZO HYL HSZV VM[LU TVYL SPRLS` [V
L_HTPULY YL]PL^ [V PKLU[PM` NLU\PUL [LHJOLYZ PU THRPUN KLJPZPVUZ [OPZ `LHY& IL X\LYPLK HZ Ù[OLYL PZ UV[ HS^H`Z H ZPUNSL
THYRPUN LYYVYZ VY \UYLHZVUHISL THYRPUNÚ >LSS P[ PZ PTWVY[HU[ [V UV[L [OH[ V]LY ZL]LYHS ÖYPNO[× THYR MVY H Z[\KLU[×Z YLZWVUZLÚ
,HJO L_HT IVHYK UV^ VMMLYZ [OYLL `LHYZ [OPZ OHZ UV[ ILLU H [YLUK VM PUJYLHZPUN )\[ PM [\YI\SLUJL HZZVJPH[LK ^P[O [OL
KPMMLYLU[ WVZ[YLZ\S[Z YL]PL^ ZLY]PJLZ HWWLHSZ VY PUJYLHZPUN Z\JJLZZLZ VM HWWLHSZ YLMVYTZ YLHSS` PZ [V ISHTL HYL [OL L_HT
;OL MPYZ[ [OL JSLYPJHS JOLJR JVUZPZ[Z VM 0U [OLYL ^LYL HJ[\HSS` ML^LY IVHYKZ JVUMPKLU[ [OH[ [OL` JHU NL[ [OL
^OH[ [OL L_HTZ YLN\SH[VY 6MX\HS JHSSZ ÙHU JOHSSLUNLZ [V NYHKLZ [OHU PU " WLY PZZ\LZ HYV\UK THYRPUN HUK YL]PL^Z PYVULK
HKTPUPZ[YH[P]L LYYVY YL]PL^ MVY HU PUKP]PK\HS JLU[ VM HSS .*, HUK .*:, LU[YPLZ ^LYL V\[ ILMVYL [OPZ `LHY×Z Z[\KLU[Z ^OV ^LYL
HZZLZZTLU[ Ù:LY]PJL ÚÚ" [OL ZLJVUK PZ H Z\IQLJ[ [V YL]PL^ PU KV^U MYVT [OL MPYZ[ [V ZP[ YLMVYTLK L_HTZ PU ZL]LYHS
YL]PL^ VM [OL THYRPUN MVY HU HZZLZZTLU[ WLY JLU[ PU Z\IQLJ[Z YLJLP]L [OLPY YLZ\S[Z& >PSS [OPZ
Ù:LY]PJL Ú ;OL MPUHS VW[PVU PZ H YL]PL^ (UK HZ MVY SHZ[ `LHY×Z MPN\YLZ 6MX\HS×Z `LHY IL HUV[OLY `LHY PU ^OPJO P[ ^PSS IL
VM [OL TVKLYH[PVU VM H ^OVSL ZJOVVS×Z PU[LYUHS 9L]PL^Z VM 4HYRPUN HUK 4VKLYH[PVU YLWVY[ ^VY[O [HRPUN H W\U[ VU H YL]PL^&
HZZLZZTLU[ Ù:LY]PJL Ú PUKPJH[LZ [OH[ [OL V]LYHSS PUJYLHZL PU YL]PL^Z Ù0[ PZ UV[ WVZZPISL [V WYLKPJ[ [OL U\TILY
0U H Z[H[LTLU[ [V ;LZ [OL 1*8 Z[YLZZLZ [OH[ ^HZ ÙTHPUS` K\L [V PUJYLHZLZ PU [OL U\TILY VM YL]PL^Z [OH[ ^PSS IL THKL [OPZ `LHYÚ ZH`Z
ÙH NYHKL JHU NV KV^U HZ ^LSS HZ \W HZ H YLZ\S[ VM ,UNSPZO,UNSPZO SHUN\HNL HUK ,UNSPZO H 1*8 ZWVRLZWLYZVU Ú( KLJPZPVU [V LU[LY H
VM H YL]PL^ VM THYRPUNÚ SP[LYH[\YL YL]PL^Z" H YLZ\S[ VM PUJYLHZLZ PU IV[O JHUKPKH[L MVY H YL]PL^ [OL V\[JVTL VM ^OPJO
Ìäïï òõ éòïç
(SS [OPZ ^V\SK Z\NNLZ[ [OH[ YLTHYRZ HYL H
[YPJR` I\ZPULZZ ^OLYL UV NYHKL JOHUNL PZ
TVYL JVTTVU [OHU H NYHKL NVPUN \W @L[
^OPSL JVUZPKLYH[PVU VM [OL SPRLSPOVVK VM
Z\JJLZZ [OL JVZ[ VY OV^ THU` THYRZ H
WHWLY TH` NV \W ZOV\SK WLYOHWZ KL[LYTPUL
H [LHJOLY×Z KLJPZPVU VU H YLTHYR [OLYL PZ
\Z\HSS` H MHJ[VY [OH[ OVSKZ TVYL ^LPNO[ [OHU
HSS [OYLL! [OL [LHJOLYZ[\KLU[ YLSH[PVUZOPW
(Z HZZLZZTLU[ L_WLY[ 7YVMLZZVY 1VOU
.HYKULY KLW\[` WYPUJPWHS LK\JH[PVU HUK
Z[\KLU[Z H[ [OL <UP]LYZP[` VM :[PYSPUN
LTWOHZPZLZ! L_HT THYRPUN PZ UV[ H ZJPLUJL
Ù;OL W\ISPJ HYL UV[ M\SS` PUMVYTLK VM [OL
PTWYLJPZPVU VM THYRPUNÚ OL ZH`Z Ù<S[PTH[LS`
PU THU` L_HTZ [OL Z[\KLU[×Z NYHKL JVTLZ
KV^U [V [OL L_HTPULY×Z Q\KNLTLU[ YH[OLY
[OHU HU` ZJPLU[PMPJ TLHZ\YLTLU[Ú
0M [OL Z`Z[LT PZ NVPUN [V Z\T \W `LHYZ VM
ZJOVVSPUN PU H U\TILY IHZLK VU H Q\KNLTLU[
X\PJRS` TV\U[ \W (UK [OH[×Z UV[ [HRPUN PU[V HK]HU[HNLV\Z HYLHZ WHYLU[Z JHU HMMVYK [V JHSS [OLU ^OLYL H [LHJOLY RUV^Z [OLPY
HJJV\U[ [OL SHIV\Y JVZ[ VM [LHJOLYZ YL]PL^PUN [HRL H W\U[ BVU HJJLZZPUN H ZJYPW[D ;OL` Z[\KLU[ ^LSS HUK Z\ZWLJ[Z [OH[ Z[\KLU[ OHZ
[OL ZJYPW[Z HUK KLJPKPUN ^OPJO WHWLYZ JV\SK HSZV TPNO[ IL TVYL SPRLS` [V W\ZO [OL ZJOVVS ILLU ^YVUNLK [OL` ^PSS MPNO[ MVY [OH[
IL ^VY[O Z\ITP[[PUN MVY YL]PL^ PU[V WH`PUN MVY H YLTHYRÚ Z[\KLU[ UV TH[[LY [OL JVZ[ [OL Z[H[Z VY [OL
-VY ,TPS` :LLILY OLHK VM ZJPLUJL H[ (Z MVY ^OH[ [OL YL]PL^Z [OLTZLS]LZ JVZ[ KHUNLYZ VM NYHKLZ NVPUN KV^U :VTL[PTLZ
)LKHSLZ :JOVVS PU /HTWZOPYL [OPZ WYVJLZZ [OH[ ]HYPLZ KLWLUKPUN VU [OL SL]LS HUK HZ VUL [LHJOLY W\[Z P[ Ù[OL HJ[ VM ZVSPKHYP[`
PZ WHPUZ[HRPUN! ZOL NVLZ [OYV\NO L]LY` ZPUNSL WYPVYP[` VM JOLJR [OH[ H ZJOVVS YLX\LZ[Z PU HZRPUN MVY H YLTHYR PZ HSTVZ[ TVYL
WHWLY MVY LYYVYZ Q\Z[ PU JHZL Ù0[ [HRLZ Ô HUK ^P[O ZVTL IVHYKZ [OL [`WL VM L_HT PTWVY[HU[ [OHU ^OL[OLY [OL YLX\LZ[
HIV\[ [OYLL M\SS KH`Z LHJO MVY .*:, HUK 6*9 MVY L_HTWSL JOHYNLZ i WLY WYVK\JLZ H WVZP[P]L YLZ\S[Ú
( SL]LSÚ ZOL ZH`Z JHUKPKH[L MVY H JSLYPJHS YLJOLJR HUK i MVY H
;OLYL PZ HSZV H ZVJPVLJVUVTPJ HUNSL [V YL]PL^ VM THYRPUN MVY IV[O .*:, HUK ( SL]LS
[OL PZZ\L VM WH`PUN MVY HJJLZZ [V ZJYPW[Z (8( VU [OL V[OLY OHUK OHZ KPMMLYLU[ MLLZ
HUK YL]PL^Z VM THYRPUN HZ VUL OLHK VM KLWLUKPUN VU ^OL[OLY [OL YL]PL^ PZ MVY H
WZ`JOVSVN` WVPU[Z V\[! Ù0U TVYL MPUHUJPHSS` .*:, VY (SL]LS WHWLY (UK L_HT IVHYKZ ,SSPV[[ +V\NSHZ PZ H MYLLSHUJL QV\YUHSPZ[
Ê
UUL -LYUHSK T\Z[ WLLYZ ^P[O ZTHSSLY ]VJHI\SHYPLZ HUK WVVY
OH]L OHK TP_LK SPZ[LUPUN JVTWYLOLUZPVU ZRPSSZ HYL SPRLS`
MLLSPUNZ SHZ[ `LHY HZ [V OH]L VUNVPUN KPMMPJ\S[PLZ PU YLHKPUN
[OL ]VJHI\SHY` JVTWYLOLUZPVU HUK [V KV SLZZ ^LSS
KLIH[L WLHRLK PU V]LYHSS PU ZJOVVSÚ
LK\JH[PVU VUJL )\[ [OH[ ^VYK RUV^SLKNL ZOL ZH`Z PZ
TVYL ;LHJOLYZ UV[ HIV\[ ZPTWS` YLJVNUPZPUN H ^VYK ^OLU
^LYL YLJVNUPZPUN `V\ YLHK P[ Ô `V\ ULLK [V OH]L H KLLW
[OL ]HS\L VM JVU[L_[\HS RUV^SLKNL VM [OH[ ^VYK I\PS[
]VJHI\SHY` HUK OV^ P[ PUMS\LUJLK LK\JH[PVU \W V]LY [PTL PU [OL [VKKSLY `LHYZ
V\[JVTLZ HUK [OPZ OHZ ILLU OLY JHYLLY×Z Ù;OL` OH]L [V OLHY [OVZL ^VYKZ ZWVRLU
MVJ\Z )\[ [OL ZPTWSPMPJH[PVU VM [OL KLIH[L VU V]LY HUK V]LY HNHPU PU TLHUPUNM\S JVU[L_[Z
VJJHZPVU HZ ILPUN HIV\[ ZPTWS` ÙYLJVNUPZPUN 0U [OPZ ^H` RPKZ SLHYU UL^ ^VYKZ YLSH[LK [V
^VYKZÚ T\Z[ OH]L NYH[LK :OL ZH`Z [OLYL PZ UL^ JVUJLW[Z I\PSKPUN \W RUV^SLKNL HZ [OL`
T\JO TVYL [V ]VJHI\SHY` [OHU [OH[ Ô [OVZL NHPU PU ]VJHI\SHY` (UK HZ [VKKSLYZ ILNPU [V
^VYKZ ULLK [V IL \UKLYZ[VVK PU JVU[L_[ [VV MPUK TLHUPUN PU [OL ^VYKZ [OL` OLHY [OL` NL[
Ù,HYS` KPMMLYLUJLZ PU VYHS SHUN\HNL ZRPSSZ HYL IL[[LY HUK IL[[LY H[ PU[LYWYL[PUN ZWVRLU
PTWVY[HU[ ILJH\ZL [OL` WYLKPJ[ SH[LY ZJOVVS SHUN\HNL ;OL` KL]LSVW ]VJHI\SHY` HUK
Z\JJLZZÚ L_WSHPUZ [OL (TLYPJHU WZ`JOVSVNPZ[ JVTWYLOLUZPVU HIPSP[PLZ LU[PYLS` [OYV\NO
^OV PZ J\YYLU[S` IHZLK H[ :[HUMVYK SPZ[LUPUN [V [OL SHUN\HNL ZWVRLU [V [OLT PU
<UP]LYZP[` Ù;OVZL MP]L`LHYVSKZ ^OV RUV^ PU[LYHJ[P]L JVU[L_[ZÚ
TVYL ^VYKZ HUK HYL TVYL MS\LU[ PU 0M `V\ KV UV[ OH]L [OH[ L_WLYPLUJL [OLU
\UKLYZ[HUKPUN ZWLLJO HYL T\JO TVYL SPRLS` ZJOVVS JHU MHPS [V NP]L `V\ [OL OLSW `V\ ULLK
[V Z\JJLLK PU YLHKPUN JVTWYLOLUZPVU H[ HNL -LYUHSK HYN\LZ :OL ZH`Z [OL [LYT ÙSLHYU [V
HUK VSKLY HUK [O\Z HYL TVYL SPRLS` [V KV ^LSS YLHKÚ OHZ [^V X\P[L KPMMLYLU[ TLHUPUNZ [OH[
PU ZJOVVS H[ L]LY` SL]LS 0U JVU[YHZ[ [OLPY HYL VM[LU JVUM\ZLK 0U [OL MPYZ[ ZLUZL P[ ¶
$ WHDFKHUśV KXQW
IRU HYLGHQFH RQţ
àëè÷ëèõ
ðò÷ìùä÷ìòñ
õèäïïü ðä÷÷èõö
/H]L ^L NV[ TV[P]H[PVU HSS ^YVUN PU V\Y ZJOVVSZ&
Êïèû Úøìêïèü L_HTPULZ [OL YLZLHYJO [V MPUK V\[
Í
V HU PTHNL ZLHYJO ^H`Z [OH[ ^L [OPUR ;HRL H TVTLU[ [V YLMSLJ[
VUSPUL MVY [OL ^VYK VU [OL ILOH]PV\Y Z`Z[LT PU `V\Y ZJOVVS /V^
ÙTV[P]H[PVUÚ HUK T\JO VM [OL Z`Z[LT PZ YVV[LK PU W\UPZOTLU[
`V\ ^PSS IL TL[ ^P[O HUK \ZL VM [OL TL[HWOVYPJHS ÙZ[PJRÚ [V ILH[
PUZWPYH[PVUHS X\V[LZ V\Y Z[\KLU[Z PU[V ILPUN Z\JJLZZM\S SLHYULYZ&
JV\WSLK ^P[O PTHNLZ /V^ THU` VM V\Y YL^HYKZ WYVTV[L H SV]L VM
VM TV\U[HPU[VWZ SLHYUPUN JVTWHYLK ^P[O H X\PJRMP_ ÙJHYYV[Ú&
HUK OLYVPJ HJ[Z 0[
PZ UV Z\YWYPZL [OLU Íò üòø öðèïï ä õä÷
[OH[ ^L H[[LTW[ [V TV[P]H[L V\Y [LLUHNL ( SV[ VM V\Y ILOH]PV\Y Z`Z[LTZ HYL Z[PSS
Z[\KLU[Z ^P[O H KPL[ VM HZZLTISPLZ OLYHSKPUN PUMS\LUJLK I` V\[TVKLK UV[PVUZ VM ILOH]PV\Y
[OL Z\Y]P]HS ZRPSSZ VM )LHY .Y`SSZ PU [OL ]HPU HUK TV[P]H[PVU )HJR PU [OL Z )\YYO\Z
OVWL VM PUZWPYPUN [OLT [V Z[PJR H[ [OLPY -YLKLYPJ :RPUULY JVTTVUS` RUV^U HZ )-
O\TKY\T OVTL^VYR HZZPNUTLU[Z 7LYOHWZ :RPUULY JVUK\J[LK L_WLYPTLU[Z PU ^OPJO
\UZ\YWYPZPUNS` [OPZ KVLZ UV[ HS^H`Z ZLLT [V YH[Z ^V\SK YLJLP]L ZUHJRZ PM [OL` VWLYH[LK
KV [OL [YPJR ZTHSS SL]LYZ >OLU [OL JSL]LY YH[Z ^VYRLK
0UZ[LHK ^L ULLK [V O\U[ MVY [OL L]PKLUJL V\[ [OL JVUULJ[PVU [OL [OLVY` VM ÙVWLYHU[
VU TV[P]H[PVU [V MPUK V\[ ^OH[ YLHSS` ^VYRZ JVUKP[PVUPUNÚ ^HZ IVYU ( ZPTWSPZ[PJ
:V ^OH[ KV ^L RUV^ HSYLHK`& >LSS ^L ÙZ[PT\S\ZYLZWVUZLÚ HWWYVHJO [V SLHYUPUN PZ
RUV^ [OH[ TV[P]H[PVU PZ H KYP]PUN MVYJL MVY HSS Z[PSS [OL OHSSTHYR VM THU` ZJOVVS Z`Z[LTZ
SLHYUPUN PUZPKL HUK V\[ZPKL VM [OL JSHZZYVVT ULHYS` H JLU[\Y` SH[LY! MLLK [OLT [YLH[Z HUK
)\[ PU NYHWWSPUN ^P[O [OL L]PKLUJL 0 X\PJRS` [OL`×SS IL TV[P]H[LK [V SLHYU
YLHSPZLK [OH[ 0 [VV OH]L ILLU SHIV\YPUN \UKLY >P[OPU [OPZ Z`Z[LT [OL YVSL VM [OL [LHJOLY
H THZZ VM TPZHWWYLOLUZPVUZ 5V[ VUS` [OH[ ILJVTLZ YLK\JLK [V [OL PZZ\PUN VM YL^HYKZ
I\[ TVZ[ ZJOVVSZ Y\U Z`Z[LTZ VM W\UPZOTLU[ HUK W\UPZOTLU[Z Ù;O\Z NVVK NYHKLZ WYHPZL
HUK YL^HYK [OH[ MS` PU [OL MHJL VM [OL L]PKLUJL HUK WYP]PSLNLZ TH` IL \ZLK [V YLPUMVYJL LMMVY[
VU OV^ [V YLHSS` TV[P]H[L `V\UNZ[LYZ VU HZZPNUTLU[Z HUK IHK NYHKLZ VY SVZZ VM
;OL MPYZ[ TPZHWWYLOLUZPVU [OH[ ^L ZOV\SK WYP]PSLNLZ TH` ZLY]L HZ W\UPZOTLU[ MVY SV^
KPZWLS JVUJLYUZ [OL ^H`Z PU ^OPJO TV[P]H[PVU LMMVY[Ú ^YV[L +LIVYHO 1 :[PWLR PU
HMMLJ[Z Z\JJLZZM\S SLHYUPUN >L RUV^ [OH[ 6M JV\YZL TVZ[ [LHJOLYZ YLHSPZL [OH[
TV[P]H[PVU TH[[LYZ I\[ WLYOHWZ UV[ PU [OL V\Y Z[\KLU[Z HYL TVYL ZH]]` [OHU YVKLU[Z
ÐÎÝÝâ
YLPNU PU H SV[ VM ZJOVVSZ
Ïøõ÷ëèõ õèäçìñê
>L ZOV\SK SLH]L ILOPUK HU` ZPTWSL UV[PVUZ Ýëèöè ÷ëõèè ïìñîö äõè ÷ëè óèõéèæ÷ ö÷äõ÷ìñê
VM [OL JHYYV[ HUK [OL Z[PJR PM ^L HYL [V PUZWPYL óòìñ÷ ìé üòø úòøïç ïìîè ÷ò åè÷÷èõ øñçèõö÷äñç
[OL [`WL VM TV[P]H[PVU [OH[ TH[[LYZ ëòú ÷ò ðò÷ìùä÷è üòøõ ö÷øçèñ÷ö
;OL YLZLHYJOLY ,K^HYK +LJP JVUK\J[LK
L_WLYPTLU[Z VU NYV\WZ VM <: JVSSLNL Z[\KLU[Z O ēÜ÷õèñê÷ëèñìñê ö÷øçèñ÷ èñêäêèðèñ÷
>OLU WSH`PUN ^P[O H W\aaSL JHSSLK :VTH úëä÷ çò ö÷øçèñ÷ö úäñ÷Ĕ òñ ÷ëè ÊÜÌÍ
VUL NYV\W ^HZ WHPK MVY Z\JJLZZM\SS` ZVS]PUN úèåöì÷è ìö ä êõèä÷ õèäç Ĥïïèç úì÷ë
W\aaSLZ ^OPSL [OL V[OLY NYV\W ^HZ UV[ óõäæ÷ìæäï ö÷èóö
;OL YLZ\S[Z PU [OL ZOVY[ [LYT IL[YH`LK H åì÷ïü¦ÊÜÌÍÜ÷õèñê÷ëèñìñê
JY\JPHS [Y\[O! ^OLU [OL MPUHUJPHS YL^HYKZ O Ùèäõöòñ ëäö ä éõèèïü äùäìïäåïè
Z[VWWLK [OVZL Z[\KLU[Z ^OV ^LYL ēÕì÷èõä÷øõè õèùìèú òñ ðò÷ìùä÷ìòñĔ
JVUKP[PVULK [V YLJLP]L [OL JHZO ZPTWS` ÷ëä÷ åõìñêö ÷òêè÷ëèõ ä ïò÷ òé ÷ëè
Z[VWWLK WSH`PUN )\[ [OL NYV\W ^OV WSH`LK õèöèäõæë öò üòø çòñđ÷ ëäùè ÷ò æòïïä÷è
MVY [OL PU[YPUZPJ YL^HYK RLW[ VU WSH`PUN HM[LY ì÷ äïï üòøõöèïé
[OL L_WLYPTLU[ ^HZ V]LY ;OL TVYHS VM [OL åì÷ïü¦Öò÷ìùä÷ìòñÛèùìèú
L_WLYPTLU[! [OL WYHPZL WVPU[Z VY WYPaLZ ^L O ēÌïäööõòòð èðò÷ìòñäï æïìðä÷è
VMMLY MVY KVPUN ^LSS PU JSHZZ TH` IL OH]PUN ö÷øçèñ÷ èñêäêèðèñ÷ äñç äæäçèðìæ
L_HJ[S` [OL VWWVZP[L LMMLJ[ [V [OL VUL ^L äæëìèùèðèñ÷Ĕ åü Ûèüèö è÷ äï ¤" !"¥
^LYL HPTPUN MVY ìö äñ äææèööìåïè äñç ùäïøäåïè
õèöèäõæë óäóèõ
Ýäöî ðäö÷èõö åì÷ïü¦ÌïäööõòòðÎðò÷ìòñäïÌïìðä÷è
4VZ[ ZJOVVSZ OH]L H ]HYPH[PVU VU [OL YL^HYK
ZJOLTL MYVT OV\ZL WVPU[Z [V JSHZZ JOHY[Z
NVSK Z[HYZ [V JPULTH ]V\JOLYZ )\[ [OL [OLU SLHKZ [V [OL PTWVY[HU[ X\LZ[PVU VM Ù^OH[
L]PKLUJL Z\NNLZ[Z [OH[ [VV VM[LU SLHYUPUN KV 0 OH]L [V KV [V Z\JJLLK PU [OPZ [HZR&Ú
NL[Z SVZ[ PU W\YZ\P[ VM [OL YL^HYK 4LHU^OPSL 0M ^L MYLL \W [OL [LHJOLY MYVT SVNNPUN
[OL ZOVY[[LYT Z\JJLZZLZ [OH[ JVTL MYVT WVPU[SLZZ YV\[PUL YL^HYKZ ^L JHU MPUK H SP[[SL
KVSPUN V\[ YL^HYKZ NP]L \Z H MHSZL PTWYLZZPVU TVYL [PTL [V VMMLY [OL [VVSZ [OH[ ^PSS OLSW V\Y
[OH[ V\Y Z`Z[LTZ HYL ^VYRPUN 0UZ[LHK ^L Z[\KLU[Z [V SLHYU TVYL LMMLJ[P]LS`
ULLK [V MVZ[LY PU[YPUZPJ TV[P]H[PVU Ô ^OLU ^L >L JHU KPZ[PS [OL YLZLHYJO L]PKLUJL HYV\UK
SLHYU MVY WSLHZ\YL HUK W\YWVZL Ô V]LY L_[YPUZPJ TV[P]H[PVU HUK SLHYUPUN PU[V MV\Y N\PKPUN
TV[P]H[PVU [OL W\YZ\P[ VM L_[LYUHS YL^HYKZ WYPUJPWSLZ MVY [LHJOLYZ!
-\Y[OLYTVYL ^L ULLK [V IYVHKLU V\Y
\UKLYZ[HUKPUN VM TV[P]H[PVU 9LZLHYJOLYZ O 9H[OLY [OHU LUJV\YHNPUN V\Y Z[\KLU[Z [V
)YV\ZZHYK HUK .HYYPZVU WVZLK JOHZL L_[YPUZPJ YL^HYKZ NL[ [OLT [V ZL[
[OYLL \ZLM\S X\LZ[PVUZ [V MYHTL OV^ ^L [OLPY V^U HJOPL]HISL NVHSZ ;OPZ TLHUZ
ZOV\SK ]PL^ TV[P]H[PVU PU [OL JSHZZYVVT! ^L OH]L [V MPUK ^H`Z [V JVUULJ[ ^OH[
[OL` ULLK [V SLHYU [V [OLPY ]HS\LZ
O *HU 0 KV [OPZ [HZR& O 4V[P]H[PVU PZ PUL_[YPJHIS` IV\UK
O +V 0 ^HU[ [V KV [OPZ [HZR HUK ^O`& [V HJOPL]LTLU[ ZV ZWLUK SLZZ [PTL
O >OH[ T\Z[ 0 KV [V Z\JJLLK PU [OPZ [HZR& JV\U[PUN OV\ZL WVPU[Z VY Z[PJRLYZ VU
[OL YL^HYK JOHY[ HUK TVYL [PTL
/LYL TV[P]H[PVU PZ YVV[LK PU [OL ILSPLMZ I\PSKPUN Z[\KLU[Z× JVUMPKLUJL PU [OLPY
VM [OL Z[\KLU[Z PU V\Y JSHZZYVVTZ -PYZ[ RUV^SLKNL HUK \UKLYZ[HUKPUN
[OL` JVUZPKLY ^OL[OLY [OL` HYL JHWHISL O )` YLTV]PUN [OL X\PJRMP_ ZVS\[PVUZ VM
VM JVTWSL[PUN H [HZR! HYL [OL` JVUMPKLU[ YV\[PUL YL^HYK Z`Z[LTZ ^L JHU IL[[LY
LUV\NO& +V [OL` RUV^ LUV\NO& :[\KLU[Z JLSLIYH[L [OL \UPX\L JVU[YPI\[PVUZ VM
^OV Z[Y\NNSL PU JSHZZ ^PSS [`WPJHSS` HUZ^LY V\Y Z[\KLU[Z ^P[O TLHUPUNM\S JLSLIYH[PVUZ
ÙUVÚ [V [OLZL X\LZ[PVUZ HUK [OLPY TV[P]H[PVU VM HJOPL]LTLU[
^PSS IL SV^ HZ H YLZ\S[ 5V YL^HYK JHU IYLHR O /LSW Z[\KLU[Z [V WH` SLZZ H[[LU[PVU
[OPZ ]PJPV\Z J`JSL [V NYHKLZ WLYMVYTHUJL NVHSZ HUK [V
>OH[ [OLZL Z[\KLU[Z ULLK MYVT \Z HYL ZWLUK TVYL [PTL VU ^OH[ [OL` JHU
ML^LY ÙTV[P]H[PVUHSÚ HZZLTISPLZ HIV\[ KV [V PTWYV]L THZ[LY` NVHSZ
(THaVUPHU [YLRZ HUK TVYL PU]LZ[TLU[ PU
KL]LSVWPUN H WV^LYM\S J\YYPJ\S\T [OH[ VMMLYZ
H THW [V \USVJR H ^VYSK VM RUV^SLKNL
;OL X\LZ[PVU ÙKV 0 ^HU[ [V KV [OPZ [HZR&Ú
^PSS HSTVZ[ HS^H`Z JVTL IHJR [V [OL WV^LYM\S (SL_ 8\PNSL` PZ KPYLJ[VY VM [OL /\U[PUN[VU
KYP]L VM ÙPU[YPUZPJ TV[P]H[PVUÚ! [OL SV]L VM 9LZLHYJO :JOVVS PU @VYR HUK H\[OVY VM
SLHYUPUN [OH[ YL^HYKZ ZPTWS` JHU×[ I\` ;OPZ *SVZPUN [OL =VJHI\SHY` .HW
à
KPZLUNHNLTLU[ )\[ [OLYL HYL LMMLJ[P]L HS[LYUH[P]LZ HYN\LZ Üìðòñ Ùèäõöè
OLYL KV L_JS\KLK HJJV\U[PUN MVY TVYL [OHU H [OPYK Z`Z[LT /V^L]LY [OL PUJYLHZPUN \ZL VM
Z[\KLU[Z VM HSS MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVUZ WLY JLU[ MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVUZ JVTIPULK ^P[O
NV ^OLU (UK \UMVY[\UH[LS` KLZWP[L WHYLU[Z ILPUN ZVTL[PTLZ X\LZ[PVUHISL WHYLU[HS Z\WLY]PZPVU
[OL` NL[ SLNHSS` YLX\PYLK [V LUZ\YL [OLPY JOPSK PZ PZ L_WVZPUN ZVTL VM V\Y TVZ[ ]\SULYHISL
L_JS\KLK UV[ MV\UK PU H W\ISPJ WSHJL [OYV\NOV\[ [OL Z[\KLU[Z [V M\Y[OLY YPZR HUK OHYT
MYVT WLYPVK VM [OL L_JS\ZPVU PU T` L_WLYPLUJL >OLYL HYL V\Y ZHMLN\HYKPUN WVSPJPLZ [V
ZJOVVS& H OPNO WYVWVY[PVU VM [OLZL Z[\KLU[Z HYL SLM[ JV]LY [OPZ& 0 JHU [LSS `V\ [OH[ PU [OL THQVYP[`
0U HU PKLHS [V ^HUKLY [OL Z[YLL[Z VM JHZLZ [OL` KVU×[ L_PZ[ 0[ PZ JSLHY [OH[ H
^VYSK [OL` 0 OH]L JVTL HJYVZZ U\TLYV\Z PUZ[HUJLZ UL^ HWWYVHJO PZ ULLKLK )\[ ^OH[ TPNO[
^V\SK YLTHPU PU [OL ZHML[` VM [OLPY V^U OVTLZ ^OLYL L_JS\KLK Z[\KLU[Z OH]L ILLU [OH[ SVVR SPRL&
\UKLY [OL ^H[JOM\S L`LZ VM [OLPY WHYLU[Z )\[ ILMYPLUKLK I` PUKP]PK\HSZ ^OV OH]L L_WVZLK >P[O PUJYLHZPUN ZJY\[PU` VM L_JS\ZPVU
PU YLHSP[` [OPZ PZ VM[LU UV[ [OL JHZL [OLT [V M\Y[OLY HU[PZVJPHS ILOH]PV\Y HUK MPN\YLZ HZ ^LSS HZ NYV^PUN H^HYLULZZ HYV\UK
;OL U\TILY VM MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVUZ PZZ\LK PU ZVTL JHZLZ JYPTPUHS HJ[P]P[` ZHMLN\HYKPUN JVUJLYUZ H U\TILY VM ZJOVVSZ
PU THPUZ[YLHT ZLJVUKHY` ZJOVVSZ PZ YPZPUN 0U V[OLY L_HTWSLZ [OL L_JS\KLK Z[\KLU[ OH]L HSYLHK` ILN\U [V ZLLR HS[LYUH[P]LZ [V
`LHYVU`LHY (JJVYKPUN [V [OL +LWHY[TLU[ LUQV`Z [OL WLYPVK H^H` MYVT ZJOVVS HUK [OL MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVU
MVY ,K\JH[PVU H [V[HS VM MP_LK[LYT VUJL YLHKTP[[LK ILNPUZ [V ILOH]L PU ^H`Z 6UL ZLJVUKHY` ZJOVVS 0×]L ^VYRLK ^P[O
L_JS\ZPVUZ ^LYL PZZ\LK HJYVZZ THPUZ[YLHT [OL` RUV^ ^PSS YLZ\S[ PU M\Y[OLY L_JS\ZPVUZ SVJH[LK PU [OL 4PKSHUKZ OHZ YLWSHJLK
ZLJVUKHY` ZJOVVSZ K\YPUN [OL ;OPZ SLHKZ [V HU \UOLHS[O` J`JSL [OH[ PZ L_[LYUHS MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVUZ ^P[O ^OH[
HJHKLTPJ `LHY ;YV\ISPUNS` Z[\KLU[Z RUV^U L_JLW[PVUHSS` KPMMPJ\S[ [V IYLHR P[ JHSSZ ÙJOHSSLUNL NYV^ HUK JOHUNLÚ KH`Z
[V IL LSPNPISL MVY HUK JSHPTPUN MYLL ZJOVVS ;OL KYP]L [V ZHMLN\HYK HSS Z[\KLU[Z PZ VUL 9H[OLY [OHU ILPUN ZLU[ OVTL Z[\KLU[Z ^OV
TLHSZ HYL MV\Y [PTLZ TVYL SPRLS` [V IL VM [OL JVYULYZ[VULZ VM [OL ,UNSPZO LK\JH[PVU ^V\SK WYL]PV\ZS` OH]L ILLU L_JS\KLK HYL
ÓÊÖÎÜ ÏÛâÎÛ
ÙYLMLYLLKÚ MVY H ZL[ U\TILY VM KH`Z ^P[OPU 0 OH]L ILLU MVY[\UH[L LUV\NO [V ^VYR ^P[O ^OV YLHJOLZ WVPU[Z PZ YLTV]LK MYVT
ZJOVVS ;OL` H[[LUK VU HU HKQ\Z[LK VUL PUULYJP[` ZLJVUKHY` ZJOVVS [OH[ OHZ THPUZ[YLHT SLZZVUZ MVY H ^LLR HUK H[[LUKZ
[PTL[HISL Z[HY[PUN HUK MPUPZOPUN ZJOVVS SH[LY YLMYHTLK P[Z HWWYVHJO [V ILOH]PV\Y ZV [OH[ ILZWVRL ZLZZPVUZ LP[OLY VU H VUL[VVUL IHZPZ
^P[O JVYYLZWVUKPUN IYLHR HUK S\UJO[PTLZ [V [OL \ZL VM MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVUZ HYL YLZLY]LK VY PU H ZTHSS NYV\W
RLLW [OLT ZLWHYH[L MYVT [OLPY WLLYZ MVY VUS` [OL TVZ[ ZLYPV\Z PUJPKLU[Z ;OPZ [HYPMM Z`Z[LT PZ HPKLK I` ^VYR ^P[O
+\YPUN [OL KH` [OL` HYL RLW[ PU PZVSH[PVU 7YL]PV\ZS` [OL ZJOVVS ^HZ PU H Y\[ ^P[O LK\JH[PVUHS WZ`JOVSVNPZ[Z HUK V[OLY
HUK JVTWSL[L [OL ^VYR [OH[ ^HZ K\L [V IL ZL[ [LHJOLYZ HU[PJPWH[PUN [OH[ HU` WVVY ILOH]PV\Y Z\WWVY[ HNLUJPLZ ,HJO ^LLR RL` PUKP]PK\HSZ
PU [OLPY [PTL[HISLK SLZZVUZ ;OPZ H]VPKZ [OLPY ^V\SK YLZ\S[ PU H MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVU ;OLZL ^P[OPU [OL ZJOVVS YL]PL^ H YLWVY[ VM [OL
MHSSPUN ILOPUK ^OPJO ^V\SK WYLZLU[ H M\Y[OLY L_WLJ[H[PVUZ TLHU[ [OH[ ZLUPVY SLHKLYZ VM[LU Z[\KLU[Z TLL[PUN H WHY[PJ\SHY [OYLZOVSK
IHYYPLY [V LUNHNLTLU[ 0U HKKP[PVU H TP_ VM MLS[ WYLZZ\YLK [V [HRL HJ[PVU HUK [OL ZJOVVS×Z ;OPZ ^VYRPUN WHY[` HSZV L_HTPULZ [OL
Z\WWVY[ Z[HMM HUK X\HSPMPLK [LHJOLYZ ^VYR MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVU YH[L LUKLK \W MV\Y [PTLZ YLWVY[Z JVTPUN PU MYVT ZWLJPMPJ PU[LY]LU[PVUZ
KPYLJ[S` ^P[O [OL Z[\KLU[Z LUJV\YHNPUN [OLT OPNOLY [OHU [OL UH[PVUHS H]LYHNL ;OPZ SLK [V HUK Z\WWVY[ TLU[VYZ HUK KLJPKLZ ^OLYL
[V YLMSLJ[ \WVU [OL YLHZVU MVY [OLPY L_JS\ZPVU OLH]` JYP[PJPZT K\YPUN HU 6MZ[LK PUZWLJ[PVU M\Y[OLY HJ[PVU PZ ULLKLK
L_WSVYPUN ^H`Z [V THRL HTLUKZ MVY [OLPY HUK PUZWLJ[VYZ ^LU[ VU [V X\LZ[PVU [OL >OLYL Z[\KLU[Z HYL MV\UK [V OH]L LUNHNLK
ILOH]PV\Y HUK HSVUNZPKL WHYLU[Z KL]LSVWPUN ZJOVVS×Z HYYHUNLTLU[Z MVY ZHMLN\HYKPUN Z\JJLZZM\SS` ^P[O H ZWLJPMPJ PU[LY]LU[PVU
HU ÙLUNHNLTLU[ WSHUÚ [OH[ ZL[Z V\[ [HYNL[Z L_JS\KLK Z[\KLU[Z [OL` HYL JVUNYH[\SH[LK HUK [OLPY WHYLU[Z HYL
HUK ZWLJPMPJ Z\WWVY[ Z[YH[LNPLZ 0UZ[LHK \ZPUN @LHY HZ H WPSV[ `LHY [OL JVU[HJ[LK [V JLSLIYH[L [OL WVZP[P]L WYVNYLZZ
(UV[OLY VW[PVU HKVW[LK I` VUL ZL[ VM ZJOVVS UV^ [YHJRZ L]LY` Z[\KLU[ PU YLSH[PVU ;OL ZJOVVS PU[YVK\JLK [OPZ Z`Z[LT PU
ZJOVVSZ 0×]L ^VYRLK ^P[O PU [OL >LZ[ VM [V [OLPY H[[LUKHUJL U\TILY VM SH[LZ HUK :LW[LTILY HUK HZ VM 1\UL [OLYL OHK
,UNSHUK PU]VS]LZ JVSSHIVYH[PUN [V RLLW JVZ[Z \UH\[OVYPZLK HIZLUJLZ U\TILY VM WVVY ILLU Q\Z[ MV\Y MP_LK[LYT L_JS\ZPVUZ
SV^ ;OL ZJOVVSZ OH]L OPYLK H JVTT\UP[` ILOH]PV\Y WVPU[Z HUK U\TILY VM KL[LU[PVUZ JVTWHYLK ^P[O PZZ\LK K\YPUN [OL ZHTL
JLU[YL HUK WVVSLK YLZV\YJLZ [V LTWSV` [OYLL 0[ OHZ KL]LSVWLK H Z`Z[LT PU ^OPJO H WLYPVK SHZ[ `LHY )HZLK VU [OL KH[H ZLUPVY
TLTILYZ VM Z[HMM ^OV THUHNL H WYVNYHTTL U\TLYPJHS ZJVYL PZ H[[HJOLK [V LHJO ILOH]PV\Y SLHKLYZOPW OHZ HNYLLK [V YVSS V\[ [OL WYVQLJ[
PU ^OPJO L_JS\KLK Z[\KLU[Z H[[LUK [OL JH[LNVY` VY ZHUJ[PVU HUK [OLYL PZ H ZL[ Ù[HYPMMÚ PU @LHYZ HUK K\YPUN [OL JVTPUN `LHY
JVTT\UP[` JLU[YL MVY H ZL[ U\TILY VM KH`Z [OH[ PM L_JLLKLK [YPNNLYZ HU PU[LY]LU[PVU VY ;OPZ HWWYVHJO LUZ\YLZ [OH[ ZHUJ[PVUZ HYL
+\YPUN [OLZL KH`Z Z[\KLU[Z JVTWSL[L Z\WWVY[ Z[YH[LN` WYVWVY[PVUH[L HUK TLHUPUNM\S HZ WHY[ VM
JSHZZ^VYR HUK [HRL WHY[ PU HJ[P]P[PLZ KLZPNULK -VY L_HTWSL VUJL H Z[\KLU[ YLHJOLZ H IYVHKLY Z`Z[LT VM Z\WWVY[ )\[ TVYL
[V OLSW [OLT YLMSLJ[ \WVU [OL JPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ ILOH]PV\Y WVPU[Z H TLL[PUN PZ HYYHUNLK ^P[O PTWVY[HU[S` P[ RLLWZ Z[\KLU[Z PU ZJOVVS ^OLYL
[OH[ SLK [V [OLPY L_JS\ZPVU [OL [\[VY HUK OLHK VM `LHY [V SVVR H[ [OL [OL` JHU IL ZHMLN\HYKLK TVZ[ LMMLJ[P]LS`
)V[O VM [OLZL HS[LYUH[P]LZ HYL NVVK ZWLJPMPJ PUJPKLU[Z HUK [V ZLL ^OH[ Z\WWVY[
L_HTWSLZ VM OV^ ZJOVVSZ JHU ZHMLN\HYK JHU IL VMMLYLK 6UJL [OL Z[\KLU[ YLHJOLZ
Z[\KLU[Z ^OPSL Z[PSS YLWYPTHUKPUN [OLT I\[ WVPU[Z H TLL[PUN PZ VYNHUPZLK ^P[O WHYLU[Z VY
0 ^V\SK HYN\L [OH[ [OLYL PZ H [OPYK L]LU JHYLYZ [V YL]PL^ ILOH]PV\Y HUK [OL Z[\KLU[ PZ
TVYL WYVNYLZZP]L HS[LYUH[P]L! J\[[PUN IHJR HZZPNULK H Z\WWVY[ TLU[VY ^OV ^VYRZ ^P[O :PTVU 7LHYZL PZ H ILOH]PV\Y HUK
VU [OL U\TILY VM L_JS\ZPVUZ JVTWSL[LS` [OLT V]LY H VULTVU[O WLYPVK ( Z[\KLU[ PUJS\ZPVU JVUZ\S[HU[
Òé ÷ëèüđõè ñò÷
åèìñê éòïïòúèç
ïèäçèõö äõè íøö÷
êòìñê éòõ ä úäïî
>OLU ULHYS` HSS Z[HMM HYL SPZ[LK VU [OL ÖL_[LUKLK
ZLUPVY SLHKLYZOPW [LHT× P[×Z [PTL [V X\LZ[PVU ^OH[
P[ [HRLZ [V [Y\S` PUMS\LUJL V[OLYZ HUK NL[ JVSSLHN\LZ
[V ZOHYL H ]PZPVU ^YP[LZ Ìëõìö÷ìäñ Ùòøñ÷äìñ
Í
V ^L OH]L [VV Ô WLYOHWZ H KLW\[` OLHK Ô PZ SPZ[LULK [V
THU` ZJOVVS WVSP[LS` I` L]LY`IVK` HYV\UK [OL [HISL I\[
SLHKLYZ HUK UV[ [OLU [OL YLHS SLHKLY ZWLHRZ ;OL YLHS SLHKLY
LUV\NO SLHKLYZOPW& PZ UV[ NP]LU [OL [P[SL `L[ L]LY`IVK` WH`Z
0 WVUKLYLK [OPZ H[[LU[PVU [V ^OH[ [OL` OH]L [V ZH`
X\LZ[PVU YLJLU[S` HZ ;OL MV\UKH[PVU VM SLHKLYZOPW PZ [Y\Z["
0 ^H[JOLK Z[\KLU[Z WLVWSL I\` PU[V H SLHKLY MPYZ[ HUK [OLU PU[V
H[ T` ZJOVVS YLJLP]L [OLPY ]PZPVU 6]LY [OL `LHYZ 0 OH]L H[[LUKLK
[OLPY @V\UN 3LHKLYZ JV\U[SLZZ ZJOVVS L]LU[Z K\YPUN ^OPJO
(^HYKZ >L UV^ OH]L TVYL [OHU Z[\KLU[Z ZVTLVUL PU WV^LY WLYOHWZ [OL JOHPY VM
Ô ]PY[\HSS` L]LY` JOPSK PU [OYLL `LHY NYV\WZ Ô NV]LYUVYZ OHZ THKL HU HWWLHS ZH` MVY
^OV HYL VMMPJPHSS` `V\UN SLHKLYZ >L HYL JHZO MVY [OL ZJOVVS×Z SH[LZ[ PUP[PH[P]L >OLU
VM JV\YZL KLSPNO[LK ^P[O [OLPY HJOPL]LTLU[Z [OLPY ^VYKZ OH]L MHSSLU VU KLHM LHYZ ^P[O
HUK ]LY` OHWW` ^P[O [OL JVU[LU[ VM [OL ML^ WLVWSL TV]LK [V W\[ [OLPY OHUKZ PU [OLPY
ZJOLTL ^OPJO HPTZ [V LTWV^LY `V\UN WVJRL[Z P[×Z YHYLS` [OL JH\ZL P[ZLSM [OH[×Z
WLVWSL [V THRL H KPMMLYLUJL PU [OLPY SVJHS [OL WYVISLT 0UZ[LHK [OL MH\S[ \Z\HSS` SPLZ
JVTT\UP[` ^OPSL HSZV KL]LSVWPUN SLHKLYZOPW ^P[O [OL ^H` [OL SLHKLY OHZ WYLZLU[LK [OL
ZRPSSZ )\[ [OPZ KVLZ YHPZL X\LZ[PVUZ! OV^ JHU HWWLHS -L^ WLVWSL YLZWVUK ^LSS [V ILPUN
^L OH]L ZV THU` SLHKLYZ ^P[OV\[ HU` WH[YVUPZLK VY SLJ[\YLK
MVSSV^LYZ& (YL SLHKLYZ ^P[OV\[ MVSSV^LYZ UV[ PU IL[^LLU 0M 0×T UV[ JVTMVY[HISL ^P[O T`
ZPTWS` NVPUN MVY H ^HSR I` [OLTZLS]LZ& (UK Ëè äææòøñ÷äåïè ÷ò üòøõöèïé KLJPZPVUZ 0 HT PU [YV\ISL :V L]LU [OV\NO
^OH[ KVLZ P[ TLHU [V IL H SLHKLY HU`^H`& ;OL ^H` `V\ HJ[ KL[LYTPULZ ^OH[ `V\ T` SLHKLYZOPW KLJPZPVUZ OH]L UV[ HS^H`Z
;OLZL X\LZ[PVUZ KV UV[ Q\Z[ HWWS` [V H[[YHJ[! PM 0 ^HU[ WLVWSL [V IL NLULYV\Z ^P[O ILLU WVW\SHY ^P[O [OVZL HYV\UK TL PM 0 JHU
Z[\KLU[Z >L OH]L HSS ZLLU [OVZL ZJOVVS [OLPY MPUHUJLZ 0 ULLK [V TVKLS H NLULYV\Z W\[ T` OLHK VU [OL WPSSV^ HUK ZSLLW H[ UPNO[
^LIZP[LZ [OH[ SPZ[ ]PY[\HSS` L]LY` Z[HMM TLTILY ZWPYP[ [V^HYKZ T` SPZ[LULYZ VY [OL TPZTH[JO [OH[×Z 62
HZ WHY[ VM [OL ÙL_[LUKLK ZLUPVY SLHKLYZOPW IL[^LLU ^OV 0 HT HUK ^OH[ 0 ZH` ^PSS THRL ;OL KL]LSVWTLU[ VM JOHYHJ[LY [OLYLMVYL
[LHTÚ >L JHU HSS PTHNPUL OV^ [OPZ WSH`Z T` ^VYKZ MLLS LTW[` 5L]LY L_WLJ[ MYVT PZ HU PU[LNYHS WHY[ VM SLHKLYZOPW >OH[ NVLZ
V\[ H[ MHJ\S[` HUK KLWHY[TLU[HS SL]LS ^P[O V[OLYZ ^OH[ `V\ ^V\SK UV[ IL WYLWHYLK [V VU ^OLU UVIVK` PZ SVVRPUN PZ L]LY` IP[ HZ
[LUZPVUZ HUK TPZ\UKLYZ[HUKPUNZ HUK MHSSV\[Z KV `V\YZLSM PTWVY[HU[ HZ [OL T\S[P[\KL VM KLJPZPVUZ [OH[
:V PZ [OLYL H JYPZPZ VM SLHKLYZOPW PU V\Y )\[ [OL OHYKLZ[ WLYZVU [V SLHK Ô HUK SLHKLYZ THRL PU [OL ZWV[SPNO[ VM [OL I\Z`
ZJOVVSZ& (UK PM ZV ^OH[ JHU ^L KV HIV\[ P[& [OL WLYZVU [V ^OVT `V\ HYL \S[PTH[LS` ZJOVVS KH`
3L[×Z Z[HY[ I` KLMPUPUN SLHKLYZOPW HJJV\U[HISL Ô PZ `V\YZLSM 0 KPZJV]LYLK /\TPSP[` PZ HUV[OLY LZZLU[PHS JOHYHJ[LY [YHP[
3LHKLYZOPW PZ PUMS\LUJL >OLU H YLHS SLHKLY `LHYZ HNV [OH[ ^OLYL]LY 0 NV 0 HT [OLYL" VM SLHKLYZOPW HUK H Z[YVUN SLHKLY ^PSS HS^H`Z
ZWLHRZ L]LY`VUL SPZ[LUZ ;OPUR VM [OVZL 0 ^HRL \W ^P[O T`ZLSM 0 NV [V ILK ^P[O MPUK H ^H` MVY [OL [LHT [V ^PU (Z ^YP[LY
Z[HMM TLL[PUNZ PU ^OPJO [OL IHKNLK SLHKLY T`ZLSM HUK 0 HT ^P[O T`ZLSM L]LY` TVTLU[ 9HSWO >HSKV ,TLYZVU PZ YLWVY[LK [V OH]L
ÊÕÊÖâ
ZHPK! Ù;OLYL PZ UV SPTP[ [V ^OH[ H THU JHU ( SLHKLY×Z SHZ[PUN ]HS\L PZ TLHZ\YLK I` :V ^OLYL KVLZ [OPZ SLH]L T` ZJOVVS×Z `V\UN
HJOPL]L HZ SVUN HZ OL KVLZU×[ JHYL ^OV NL[Z Z\JJLZZPVU :VTL `LHYZ HNV 0 ^VYRLK MVY H SLHKLYZ& 7LYOHWZ PM [OL` JHU \UKLYZ[HUK
[OL JYLKP[Ú OLHK[LHJOLY ^OV OHK ILLU PU WVZ[ MVY TVYL SLHKLYZOPW PU [OLZL [LYTZ [OL` JHU ^LHY [OLPY
:LJ\YL SLHKLYZ NP]L WV^LY [V V[OLYZ [OHU `LHYZ ^OLU OL ^LU[ VMM VU SVUN[LYT IHKNLZ ^P[O WYPKL (UK MVY [OL YLZ[ VM \Z
ZPJR SLH]L [V MPNO[ H ZLYPV\Z PSSULZZ /L ^HZ Z[HMM& 0M ^L JHU [Y\S` SLHYU [V ZLL SLHKLYZOPW
Öäîè ä öøææèöö òé öøææèööìòñ NVUL MVY TVZ[ VM [OL HJHKLTPJ `LHY Ô HUK HZ ^OV ^L HYL UV[ ^OH[ ^L KV VY ^OPJO [P[SL
7LVWSL UH[\YHSS` MVSSV^ SLHKLYZ ^OV HYL UVIVK` IH[[LK HU L`LSPK >HZ [OPZ ILJH\ZL OL ^L OVSK VY OV^ IPN V\Y VMMPJL VY WHYRPUN
Z[YVUNLY [OHU [OLT 0M 0 HT HU LPNO[ V\[ VM ^HZ HU PULMMLJ[P]L SLHKLY& 8\P[L [OL VWWVZP[L ZWHJL VY ZHSHY` PZ [OLU P[ YLHSS` KVLZU×[ TH[[LY
VU [OL SLHKLYZOPW ZJHSL P[ PZ H WYVISLT [V OH]L 0[ ^HZ WYLJPZLS` ILJH\ZL OL ^HZ ZV LMMLJ[P]L OV^ THU` WLVWSL ^L OH]L VU V\Y L_[LUKLK
H UPUL VU T` [LHT :OL ^PSS LP[OLY Z[H` [OH[ [OL ZJOVVS JV\SK JHYY` VU ^P[OV\[ ZLUPVY SLHKLYZOPW [LHTZ
JHWWLK H[ HU LPNO[ HUK MLLS MY\Z[YH[LK VY ZOL TPZZPUN H ILH[ /L OHK J\S[P]H[LK H YLZPSPLU[
^PSS SLH]L HUK ZVHY ^P[O OLY Z[YLUN[OZ ZLY]PUN Z[HMM ^OV JV\SK SLHK PU [OLPY V^U YPNO[ HUK
ZVTLVUL LSZL×Z ]PZPVU (Z SLHKLY [OL KLJPZPVU ^LYL UV[ YLSPHU[ VU OPT MVY Z\JJLZZ )\[ [OPZ
PZ TPUL HZ [V ^OL[OLY [V YLSLHZL WLVWSL ^P[O [HRLZ H SHYNL HTV\U[ VM [OH[ TVZ[ WYLJPV\Z
KPNUP[` HUK NVVK NYHJL VY [V RLLW T` OPNOLZ[ JVTTVKP[`! [PTL ;OLYL PZ UV ZOVY[J\[ *OYPZ[PHU 7V\U[HPU PZ OLHK VM 9, HUK KPYLJ[VY VM
WLYMVYTLYZ HUK NYV^ T`ZLSM [V H UPUL 3LHKLYZOPW KL]LSVWZ KHPS` UV[ PU H KH` ZWPYP[\HSP[` H[ H ZLJVUKHY` ZJOVVS PU 3HUJHZOPYL
ÐÌÜÎ õèöì÷ö
Ýëòøöäñçö òé
üòøñê óèòóïè
Đö÷øæî ìñ äñ
èñçïèöö æüæïè
òé õèöì÷öđ
>P[O .*:, YLZ\S[Z KH` SVVTPUN UL^ YLZLHYJO
YL]LHSZ [OH[ SHZ[ Z\TTLY ZVTL YLZP[ Z[\KLU[Z
^LYL ZP[[PUN [OL L_HT MVY [OL UPU[O [PTL :[\KPLZ
Z\NNLZ[ [OH[ [OL TVYL [PTLZ [OH[ H SLHYULY ZP[Z
HU L_HT [OL SLZZ JOHUJL [OL` OH]L VM WHZZPUN P[
(TPK YPZPUN JVUJLYUZ HIV\[ [OL PTWHJ[ VM Z\JO
L_HTZ VU TLU[HS OLHS[O Óøïìä Ëèïêø÷äü HZRZ!
ZOV\SK ^L NL[ YPK VM MVYJLK YLZP[Z& ¶
ÐÎÝÝâ
ÊÕÊÖâ
×øðåèõ òé ÷ìðèö ×øðåèõ òé ö÷øçèñ÷ö Ùõòåäåìïì÷ü òé ìðóõòùìñê ÷ëè êõäçè åü õèöì÷ ä÷÷èðó÷
ÐÌÜÎ ä÷÷èðó÷èç ìñ ä !&¡!( öè÷÷ìñê
Îñêïìöë
Îñêïìöë
! '"
! )(&!
" $%&"% " &#
# !($($
# %%
$ $%!(
Öä÷ëö
% !!&# ! '&
& "&
' #) " &)
( )
) äñç äåòùè $ # &!
Öä÷ëö
! %%") Ùõòåäåìïì÷ü òñ ä öæäïè òé ¡! úëèõè ! ìö æèõ÷äìñ÷ü äñç ìö ìðóòööìåìïì÷ü Üòøõæè Ìäðåõìçêè Êööèööðèñ÷ åì÷ïü¦Ûèöì÷Ùõòå
" ! &#
# $!&(
$ !!&)
% $#( |&#
& !$! |%&#) |%!"!
' #(
( !"
Ïøñçìñê óèõ öèæòñçäõü Ïøñçìñê óèõ ÏÎ !&¡!( Ïøñçìñê óèõ öæëòòï !&¡!(
) äñç äåòùè & óøóìï ìñ " !&¡!' ö÷øçèñ÷ ìñ " !&¡!( ö÷øçèñ÷ ìñ " !&¡!(
Üòøõæè Òðóè÷øö ÙÎÏ Ïìêøõèö õèïä÷è ÷ò !&¡!( ö÷øçèñ÷ö ìñ îèü ö÷äêè % ìñ " !' Üòøõæè Òñö÷ì÷ø÷è éòõ Ïìöæäï Ü÷øçìèö
+H]PK *VYRL KPYLJ[VY VM LK\JH[PVU HUK ZRPSSZ PU -, (SPJL ,HYKSL` HU ,UNSPZO [LHJOLY H[ Ù>L×YL OVWPUN [OH[ [OL `V\UN WLVWSL ^HP[
WVSPJ` H[ [OL (ZZVJPH[PVU VM *VSSLNLZ ZH`Z [OH[ (J[P]H[L 3LHYUPUN×Z 6_MVYK JHTW\Z ZH`Z! PUN MVY [OLPY .*:, YLZ\S[Z NL[ [OL Z\JJLZZ
[OL HZZLZZTLU[ YLNPTL PU ZJOVVS HUK [OL J`JSL Ù0 HT UV[ JSHPTPUN [OL` SV]L P[ I\[ [OL` OH]L [OL` KLZLY]LÚ OL ZH`Z Ù)\[ ^L RUV^ [OH[
VM YLZP[ MHPS\YL OH]L HU HK]LYZL PTWHJ[ VU Z[\ YLHJOLK [OL WVPU[ ^OLYL [OL` Q\Z[ ^HU[ [V NL[ ^VU×[ IL [OL JHZL MVY L]LY`IVK` ;OV\ZHUKZ
KLU[Z× TLU[HS OLHS[O Ù/V^ JHU Z\JO JVU[PU\HS P[ KVUL 0 HT UV[ Z\YL 0 ZLL P[ ILPUN H IHK [OPUN VM `V\UN WLVWSL HYL [HRPUN ,UNSPZO HUK TH[OZ
[LZ[PUN HJYVZZ `LHYZ VM LK\JH[PVU IL ZLLU HZ :VTL Z[\KLU[Z Q\Z[ ULLK HU L_[YH `LHY VY [^VÚ L_HTZ MVY TVYL [OHU [OL [OPYK [PTL @V\UN
HU`[OPUN V[OLY [OHU H W\UPZOTLU[&Ú OL HZRZ 0TWL[\Z7,- JOPLM L_LJ\[P]L (UK` 9H[JSPMML WLVWSL HYL MP]L [PTLZ TVYL SPRLS` [V WHZZ [OLPY
Ù@V\UN WLVWSL KVU×[ JVTL [V JVSSLNL [V YLZP[ ILSPL]LZ [OH[ ^P[O [OL YPNO[ Z\WWVY[ HSS `V\UN KYP]PUN [LZ[ H[ [OHU [V JH[JO \W ^P[O
[LZ[Z [OL` JVTL [V SLHYU [LJOUPJHS ZRPSSZ [OH[ HYL WLVWSL JHU HJOPL]L H SL]LS PU ,UNSPZO HUK [OLPY .*:,Zß6\Y UL^ KH[H ZOV^PUN [OH[
HZZLZZLK PU H WYHJ[PJHS ^H` 3L[×Z YLTV]L [OL TH[OZ Ô I\[ OL PZ JVUJLYULK [OH[ THU` `V\UN [OV\ZHUKZ VM `V\UN WLVWSL HYL Z[\JR PU HU
+ NYHKL BYLX\PYLTLU[D UV^ HUK HSSV^ [LHJO WLVWSL MYVT WVVYLY IHJRNYV\UKZ HYL UV[ LUKSLZZ J`JSL VM YLZP[Z [LSSZ \Z [OH[ [OLYL PZ H SV[
LYZ [V L_LYJPZL [OLPY WYVMLZZPVUHS Q\KNLTLU[Ú NL[[PUN [OL ULJLZZHY` Z\WWVY[ HUK PZ JHSSPUN TVYL ^VYR [V KVÚ
)\[ UV[ L]LY`VUL ILSPL]LZ [OH[ OH]PUN [V YLZP[ VU [OL +LWHY[TLU[ MVY ,K\JH[PVU [V IVVZ[ 3HZ[ TVU[O ZRPSSZ TPUPZ[LY (UUL 4PS[VU [VSK
[OL X\HSPMPJH[PVU ULNH[P]LS` PTWHJ[Z Z[\KLU[Z PU]LZ[TLU[ PU YLZP[Z ;LZ [OH[ ZOL ^HZ Ù[LYYPIS` H^HYLÚ VM [OL PTWVY
[HUJL VM `V\UN WLVWSL VM NL[[PUN H SL]LS
X\HSPMPJH[PVU PU ,UNSPZO HUK TH[OZ Ù;OL`
äñç úèõè äåïè ÷ò ìñçìùìçøäïìöè ðøæë éäö÷èõ ēËèéòõè úè õòïï òø÷ ÷ëè óõòêõäððè ñä÷ìòñäïïü KVU×[ RUV^ TH`IL OV^ PTWVY[HU[ [OH[ PZ
Òé ÷ëìö æòøïç åè õòïïèç òø÷ éòõ äïï äúäõçìñê úè äõè æòñ÷ìñøìñê ÷ò õèöèäõæë úäüö úè æäñ MVY [OLPY M\[\YL VWWVY[\UP[PLZ [OH[ ^PSS VWLU MVY
åòçìèö äñç éòõ äïï ö÷øçèñ÷ö ì÷ úòøïç åè ä èñëäñæè ÷ëè ëèïó úè êìùè æòïïèêèö äñç óòö÷¡!& [OLTÚ ZOL ZHPK Ù>L×]L NV[ [V THRL Z\YL [OH[
õèäï ìðóõòùèðèñ÷Ĕ óõòùìçèõö ÷ò åèö÷ öøóóòõ÷ ÷ëèìõ ö÷øçèñ÷ö äñç HSS `V\UN WLVWSL NL[ L]LY` VWWVY[\UP[` [V NL[
Ê öóòîèöóèõöòñ éòõ Ùèäõöòñ èûóïäìñö ÷ò ìñéòõð òøõ éø÷øõè óòö÷¡!& óõòùìöìòñ àè H NVVK WHZZ H[ .*:, VY PU M\UJ[PVUHS ZRPSSZ
÷ëä÷ ÷ëè óìïò÷ äïïòúèç æòïïèêèö ÷ò ìçèñ÷ìéü õèæòêñìöè ÷ëè ùäïøè òé øñçèõö÷äñçìñê ïèäõñèõöđ :V ^L×YL SVVRPUN H[ [OL TVTLU[ [V ZLL OV^
êäóö ìñ ïèäõñìñê ÷ëä÷ ñèèçèç ÷ò åè óèõéòõðäñæè äö ÷ëèü ðòùè éõòð öæëòòï ÷ò ^L JHU PTWYV]L P[ 0 YLJVNUPZL [OH[ PM `V\ OH]L
äççõèööèç åü äææèööìñê ä úìçè õäñêè òé óòö÷¡!& ö÷øçìèö äñç äõè æòððì÷÷èç ÷ò óõòùìçìñê MHPSLK [V NL[ [OH[ X\HSPMPJH[PVU KLZWP[L [OL MHJ[
ìñéòõðä÷ìòñ ÷ëõòøêë ÷ëè Ûèöøï÷öÙïøö äñç ìñöìêë÷éøï ìñéòõðä÷ìòñ úëèõè ì÷ æäñ åè óõòùèñ `V\×]L OHK THU` `LHYZ VM LK\JH[PVU ILMVYL [OH[
Êææèöö ÷ò Üæõìó÷ö öèõùìæèö ÷ò åèñèĤ÷ åò÷ë ÷ëè óõòùìçèõ äñç ïèäõñèõĔ ZVTL[OPUN PZU×[ ^VYRPUN ^LSS MVY `V\Ú
5HTL JOHUNLK
Ò îñòú ä çèäç
óäõõò÷ úëèñ
Ò öèè òñè
;OL NV]LYUTLU[×Z PU[YHUZPNLUJL V]LY [OL ZS\TW PU
HWWYLU[PJLZOPW Z[HY[Z OHZ IVYKLYLK VU JVTLK` )\[
[OL YLMVYTLK Z`Z[LT VM ZRPSSZ WYV]PZPVU PZ UV[ ILYLM[
VM SPML Q\Z[ Z[\UULK ILSPL]LZ Öäõî Íäúè
.6=,954,5; 9,-,9,5*,: [V [OL WYL]PV\ZS` 0[ PZ HSZV KPMMPJ\S[ [V \UKLYZ[HUK
[HYNL[ VM TPSSPVU HWWYLU[PJLZOPW Z[HY[Z OH]L ^O` TPUPZ[LYZ W\[ [OLPY SHJR VM YLZWVUZL [V [OL
ILJVTL JVUZWPJ\V\Z I` [OLPY HIZLUJL (M[LY MHSSPUN U\TILYZ KV^U [V [OL YLHZVUZ MVY [OL
HUV[OLY TVU[O×Z ^VY[O VM ^VLM\S KH[H TPUPZ MHSSZ UV[ ILPUN LHZPS` PKLU[PMPHISL Ô [OL ÙJH\ZHS
[LYZ UV^ ZH` [OH[ X\HSP[` PZ TVYL PTWVY[HU[ P[`Ú HZ [OL` W\[ P[ ^OPJO ZV\UKZ SPRL ZVTL[OPUN
[OHU X\HU[P[` ;OL [HYNL[ OHZ HZZ\TLK [OL V\[ VM HU VSK LWPZVKL VM *:0
ÙKLHK WHYYV[Ú THU[SL MVY V\Y ZLJ[VY 4LTILYZ VM [OL (ZZVJPH[PVU VM ,TWSV`TLU[
0U THU` ^H`Z P[×Z H YLHS ZOHTL ILJH\ZL [OL HUK 3LHYUPUN 7YV]PKLYZ (,37 ^LYL ]LY`
WHYYV[×Z ILH\[PM\S WS\THNL [VVR [OL MVYT VM JSLHY HIV\[ [OL YLHZVUZ PU [OL Z\Y]L` YLZ\S[Z
WV[LU[PHSS` [OV\ZHUKZ TVYL ZVJPHS TVIPSP[` YLSLHZLK H[ V\Y UH[PVUHS JVUMLYLUJL PU 1\UL
VWWVY[\UP[PLZ MVY `V\UN WLVWSL" LTWSV`LYZ 4H`IL P[ PZ ILJH\ZL [OL` ZOV^LK [OH[ P[ PZ H
^LYL [V ILULMP[ [VV MYVT H IL[[LY ZRPSSLK HUK JVTIPUH[PVU VM MSH^Z PU [OL KLZPNU VM [OL
TVYL WYVK\J[P]L ^VYRMVYJL PU [OL MHJL VM YLMVYTZ YH[OLY [OHU VUL V]LYHYJOPUN VUL [OH[
)YL_P[×Z SHIV\YTHYRL[ JOHSSLUNLZ [OL NV]LYUTLU[ OHZ ILLU ZV OLZP[HU[ [V HJ[
>OH[L]LY WLVWSL×Z ]PL^Z HYL VU [OL TLYP[Z VM
ZL[[PUN U\TLYPJHS [HYNL[Z L]LY`VUL ZOV\SK IL Ûèåäïäñæìñê ÷ëè öüö÷èð
JVUJLYULK [OH[ [OL U\TILYZ HYL ^H` KV^U VU 5L]LY[OLSLZZ [OL Z\Y]L` JVUMPYTLK [OH[ [OL :4,Z PU [OL WYVNYHTTL HUK YL]LYZLZ [OL
WYL]PV\Z `LHYZ :VTL HWWYLU[PJLZOPW JVPU]LZ[TLU[ YLX\PYLTLU[ MVY ZTHSS HUK WLY JLU[ KYVW PU Z[HY[Z MVY `V\UN WLVWSL
Z[HY[Z OH]L ILLU YLWVY[LK ZV MHY MVY [OL MPYZ[ TLKP\TZPaLK LTWSV`LYZ :4,Z PZ H ]LY` ;OL NV]LYUTLU[ OHZ [OL VWWVY[\UP[` [V
[OYLLX\HY[LYZ VM [OL HJHKLTPJ `LHY ZPNUPMPJHU[ MHJ[VY ILOPUK [OL MHSS PU Z[HY[Z ;OPZ HJOPL]L H IL[[LY IHSHUJL ^OLU [OL UL_[ WOHZL
JVTWHYLK ^P[O HUK MVY [OL PZ ^O` [OL (,37 OHZ ILLU ZLLRPUN HU PTTL VM YLMVYT Z[HY[Z PU 4HYJO >OPSL HSS
ZHTL WLYPVKZ PU HUK YLZWLJ KPH[L Z\ZWLUZPVU VM LTWSV`LY JVU[YPI\[PVUZ MVY UVUSL]` LTWSV`LYZ JV\SK Z[PSS QVPU [OL SL]`
[P]LS`" [OH[×Z H KLJYLHZL VM WLY JLU[ HUK HWWYLU[PJLZ H[ SL]LSZ HUK I` UVUSL]` WH`LYZ VU [OL KPNP[HS HWWYLU[PJLZOPW ZLY]PJL
WLY JLU[ WH`LYZ VY [OVZL LTWSV`LYZ [OH[ L_JLLK [OLPY MVY ZTHSSLY LTWSV`LYZ [OL WYV]PKLY T\Z[ IL
3L]LS Z[HY[Z HYL UV^ TVYL [OHU H OHSM SLZZ SL]` /V^L]LY Q\KNPUN I` [OL WHYSPHTLU[HY` HSSV^LK [V IL [OLPY ÙHNLU[Ú
[OHU ^OH[ [OL` ^LYL [^V `LHYZ HNV ^OPSL ^YP[[LU HUZ^LY [OH[ ZOHKV^ ZRPSSZ TPUPZ[LY (SS YLNPZ[LYLK WYV]PKLYZ T\Z[ IL HSSV^LK [V
HWWYLU[PJLZOPW VWWVY[\UP[PLZ MVY `V\UN WLVWSL .VYKVU 4HYZKLU YLJLP]LK SHZ[ TVU[O SL]LS KLSP]LY [V HSS LTWSV`LYZ I\[ ^P[OPU H THUHNLK
OH]L MHSSLU I` H [OPYK ^OPJO JHU VUS` IL HWWYLU[PJLZOPWZ HYL UV[ YLNHYKLK HZ PTWVY[HU[ LU]PYVUTLU[ (UK ^L T\Z[ H]VPK HUV[OLY
KLZJYPILK HZ H UH[PVUHS KPZNYHJL 0U V[OLY ^VYKZ VY VM OPNO X\HSP[` I` [OL NV]LYUTLU[ KLZWP[L WHPUM\S MHPSLK WYVJ\YLTLU[ L_LYJPZL MVY
[OL ZVJPHS TVIPSP[` HNLUKH OHZ [HRLU H THQVY [OL VI]PV\Z ULLK MVY [OLT PU [OL ZLY]PJL HWWYLU[PJLZOPW WYV]PKLYZ
IH[[LYPUN MYVT [OL WVVY PTWSLTLU[H[PVU VM [OL ZLJ[VYZ TVZ[ HMMLJ[LK I` )YL_P[ ;OL (,37×Z ]PL^ PZ [OH[ IHSHUJLK WYV]PZPVU
SL]` YLMVYTZ ^OPJO ^LYL HJ[\HSS` TLHU[ [V 0M TPUPZ[LYZ OH]L [OYV^U PU [OL [V^LS VU [OL JHU IL HJOPL]LK I` PU[YVK\JPUN HU PUJYLHZPUN
PUJYLHZL VWWVY[\UP[PLZ V]LYHSS >OH[L]LY OHW TPSSPVU [HYNL[ ^L Z[PSS ULLK [V [OPUR HIV\[ HU ZJHSL VM JVPU]LZ[TLU[ YLX\PYLTLU[Z [OH[ Z[HY[Z
WLULK [V +H]PK *HTLYVU×Z ÙNLU\PULÚ JOVPJL HWWYLU[PJLZOPW M\UKPUN Z`Z[LT [OH[ HJ[Z HZ H H[ aLYV MVY SL]LS YPZLZ [V WLY JLU[ MVY SL]LS
IL[^LLU \UP]LYZP[` VY HWWYLU[PJLZOPW& KYP]LY MVY ZVJPHS TVIPSP[` HZ ^LSS HZ PTWYV]PUN HUK [OLU LZJHSH[LZ \W [V WLY JLU[ MVY SL]LS
0[ PZ Z[HNNLYPUN [OH[ ^L MPUK V\YZLS]LZ PU [OPZ ^VYRMVYJL WYVK\J[P]P[` ;OPZ JHU IL HJJVTWHUPLK I` H ZL[ VM MPUHU
WVZP[PVU ^OLU [OL SL]` PZ HJJY\PUN i IPSSPVU ;OPZ TLHUZ H IL[[LYIHSHUJLK KLZPNU [OH[ JPHS PUJLU[P]LZ [OH[ JHU IL [\YULK VU HUK VMM [V
VM YL]LU\L ^OPJO THRLZ [OL [V[HS HWWYLU[PJL PUJYLHZLZ [OL U\TILY VM VWWVY[\UP[PLZ H[ HSS Z\WWVY[ WHY[PJ\SHY SLHYULY JVOVY[Z SL]LSZ NLV
ZOPW I\KNL[ i IPSSPVU SHYNLY [OHU P[ ^HZ SL]LSZ YLZ[VYLZ [OL OPZ[VYPJ LUNHNLTLU[ VM NYHWOPJHS HYLHZ VY ZLJ[VYZ 6UL L_HTWSL ^V\SK
ÊÕÊÖâ
ÖÒÕÎÜ ÌØÕÎ
;HRL WYPKL PU `V\Y WV^LY
[V JOHUNL WLVWSL×Z SP]LZ
;/, :;(;<: VM [OL [LHJOPUN H ^LSJVTPUN ZPNU /L NSHUJLK H[ OPZ
WYVMLZZPVU PZ H ^LSS[YVKKLU [VWPJ UV[LZ [OLU \U[YV\ISLK I` JVUZ[YHPU[Z
>L×YL UV SVUNLY ZLLU HZ N\HYKPHUZ VM VM JV\Y[LZ` WVRLK T` ZVU×Z ULJR
RUV^SLKNL H OPNOS` YHURLK PU[LSSLJ[\HS KLTHUKPUN Ù+VLZ [OH[ O\Y[&Ú
LSP[L SLHYULK Z[H[LZTLU VM [OL WHYPZO 6U [OL VUL VJJHZPVU T` ZVU HUZ^LYLK
0 KVU×[ YLHSS` JHYL HIV\[ [OL Z[H[\Z VM ÙZVY[ VMÚ [OL JVUZ\S[HU[ IHYRLK! Ù0[ ^HZ
T` QVI )\[ ^OLU P[ JVTLZ [V WV^LY H JSVZLK X\LZ[PVU @LZ VY UV&Ú 4` ZVU
[OH[×Z KPMMLYLU[ 7V^LY PZ PTWVY[HU[ HUK NSHUJLK H[ TL 0 RLW[ T` [YHW ZO\[
0×]L NV[ ZOP[SVHKZ ;OLU P[ YLHSS` RPJRLK VMM 4` ZVU
0×T UV[ YPJO VY ILH\[PM\S VY PU H QVI HZRLK +Y 2UVIOLHK HZ OL×Z RUV^U PU
^OLYL T` KLJPZPVUZ HMMLJ[ [OL THZZLZ V\Y OV\ZL PM P[ ^V\SK Z[PSS IL 62 [V \ZL
;OL WV^LY 0 OH]L JVTLZ MYVT [OL OPZ JVTW\[LY UV[L OL KPKU×[ TLU[PVU
MYLLKVT [OH[ LK\JH[PVU OHZ NP]LU TL ]PKLV NHTLZ >L ^LYL [OLU [VSK [OH[
0×SS JOHSSLUNL H\[OVYP[` [OH[ KVLZU×[ P[ ^HZ WVZZPISL I\[ OL ^V\SK HK]PZL
TLL[ T` ]HS\LZ 0×SS HZR KPMMPJ\S[ X\LZ[PVUZ HNHPUZ[ P[" PUZ[LHK T` ZVU ZOV\SK IL
HUK IL H [OVYV\NO WHPU PU [OL HYZL PM YLHKPUN H IVVR HUK [PK`PUN OPZ YVVT
ULLKZ T\Z[ 0 OH]L ZV T\JO WV^LY [OH[ UV[ PNUVYPUN OPZ TV[OLY HUK ZP[[PUN H[
0 VUS` ILJVTL H^HYL VM P[ VU [OVZL YHYL OPZ JVTW\[LY HSS UPNO[ WSH`PUN NHTLZ
TVTLU[Z ^OLU P[×Z YLTV]LK >L ^LYL Z[\UULK :V THU`
IL HU PUJLU[P]L [V LUJV\YHNL WYVNYLZZPVU MYVT 6U [OL MPYZ[ KH` VM [OL Z\TTLY HZZ\TW[PVUZ ^LYL YL]LHSLK ^P[OPU [OH[
SL]LS [V SL]LS OVSPKH`Z T` ZVU MLSS VMM H OHTTVJR ZOVY[ L_JOHUNL! HIV\[ T` ZVU HIV\[
>L JHU YLZ[VYL [OL WYL]PV\Z Z[HY[ U\TILYZ HUK IYVRL OPZ JVSSHYIVUL 0 RUV^ IHK TL HIV\[ V\Y YLSH[PVUZOPW )\[ 0 RLW[
^P[OV\[ SV^LYPUN X\HSP[` PM [OL UL^ Z[HUKHYKZ [PTPUN /L ^HZ Y\ZOLK [OYV\NO ( , T` [YHW ZO\[ >L ^LYL PU H ]\SULYHISL
HYL M\UKLK MHPYS` ( THUHNLK [YHUZP[PVU PU HZ [OLYL ^HZ JVUJLYU [OH[ [OL NYHWLMY\P[ WVZP[PVU HUK [OPZ THU OHK RUV^SLKNL
(WYPS UL_[ `LHY ^PSS VUS` ^VYR PM [OL YLNPZ[LY VM ZPaLK S\TW NYV^PUN \UKLY OPZ ULJR ^HZ ^L ULLKLK! [OL WV^LY [V TLUK T` IV`
HWWYLU[PJLZOPW [YHPUPUN WYV]PKLYZ PZ H NLU\PUL H ZPNU VM ZVTL[OPUN ZPUPZ[LY (M[LY OV\YZ >L×]L HSS L_WLYPLUJLK ZVTLVUL
SPZ[ VM X\HSP[` WYV]PKLYZ ;OL ,K\JH[PVU HUK VM [LZ[Z P[ ^HZ KLLTLK [OH[ Z\YNLY` ^OV OHZ L_LY[LK [OLPY WV^LY V]LY \Z
:RPSSZ -\UKPUN (NLUJ` ULLKZ [V \ZL P[Z H\[\TU ^HZU×[ ULJLZZHY` HUK OL ^HZ ZLU[ OVTL ILJH\ZL [OL` RUV^ ^OH[ ^L KVU×[
ÙYLMYLZOÚ VM [OL YLNPZ[LY [V JVUZPKLY ^O` WLY ^P[O H I\JRL[ VM WHPURPSSLYZ HUK H ZSPUN >OLU WLVWSL \ZL [OLPY RUV^SLKNL [V
JLU[ VM [OL VYNHUPZH[PVUZ VU P[ OH]L UV[ ,]LY` TLKPJHS WYVMLZZPVUHS ^L TL[ [OH[ KVTPUH[L YH[OLY [OHU [V JVU[YPI\[L
KLSP]LYLK HU` HWWYLU[PJLZOPWZ HUK [V YLZWVUK UPNO[ ^HZ JHYPUN LMMPJPLU[ HUK OPNOS` P[ THRLZ TL ^VUKLY OV^ ZLJ\YL [OL`
[V 6MZ[LK×Z JVUJLYUZ HIV\[ [OL JHWHJP[` HUK WYVMLZZPVUHS ^VYRPUN \UKLY JOHSSLUNPUN YLHSS` MLLS PU [OLPY V^U WV^LY
X\HSP[` VM ZVTL UL^ WYV]PKLYZ JPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ 0 OHK [V Z[VW T`ZLSM (Z [LHJOLYZ ^L HYL WV^LYM\S ILPUNZ
;VNL[OLY H TLHZ\YLK HWWYVHJO [V M\UKPUN PTWVZPUN H NPHU[ O\N VM NYH[P[\KL VU ILJH\ZL [OL UH[\YL VM V\Y ^VYR
HUK [OL X\HSP[` VM [OL Z\WWS` IHZL ^V\SK NL[ L]LY` VUL VM ×LT V\Y YLHZVU PZ [V IL NLULYV\Z ^P[O
[OL HWWYLU[PJLZOPW YLMVYTZ IHJR VU [YHJR (Z PUZ[Y\J[LK ^L YL[\YULK [V OVZWP[HS RUV^SLKNL :V SL[×Z Z[VW MYL[[PUN
[^V KH`Z SH[LY (M[LY TVYL [YLH[TLU[ HIV\[ WLYJLW[PVU VM Z[H[\Z HUK ^LHY
MYVT TVYL ^VUKLYM\S TLKPJZ ^L ^LYL V\Y WV^LY ^P[O WYPKL
\ZOLYLK PU[V [OL JVUZ\S[HU[×Z VMMPJL /L :HYHO :PTVUZ ^VYRZ PU JVSSLNLZ HUK HK\S[
QHIILK OPZ MPUNLY H[ \Z HUK JVTTHUKLK! JVTT\UP[` LK\JH[PVU PU [OL ,HZ[ 4PKSHUKZ
4HYR +H^L PZ JOPLM L_LJ\[P]L VM [OL (ZZVJPH[PVU Ù:P[Ú ;HSRPUN [V O\THUZ HZ [OV\NO HUK PZ [OL KPYLJ[VY VM <2-,JOH[ :OL [^LL[Z
VM ,TWSV`TLU[ HUK 3LHYUPUN 7YV]PKLYZ [OL` HYL H KPZVILKPLU[ ZWHUPLS PZ UL]LY '4YZ:HYHO:PTVUZ
Trust Finance
Assistant Farm Stock Person Health & Social Care Health & Social Care
(Agricultural College) Teacher Teacher
Salary: £15,485 - £16,396 pa
Fixed term for 12 months, initially (full time, fixed term to 31.08.19) (full time, fixed term to 31.08.19)
depending on experience Rodbaston campus Tamworth campus Tamworth campus
Full time / 6 month temporary £17,067 - £18,555 per annum £18,555 - £35,304 per annum £18,555 - £35,304 per annum
Start date: As soon as possible Job ref: HR1718-131 Job ref: HR1718-168 Job ref: HR1718-168
South Staffordshire College require an experienced South Staffordshire College are looking for people South Staffordshire College are looking for people
An exciting opportunity for a Finance Stock Person to work as part of a small team under the
Assistant to join an outstanding team. who are passionate in driving young people to who are passionate in driving young people to
direction of the Farm Operations Manager.
achieve excellence to join our very successful Health achieve excellence to join our very successful Health
Based at our Pontefract site, the Trust The Stock Person be responsible for high quality care and Social Care team. and Social Care team.
Finance Assistant will work as part of the and welfare of the farm livestock on the college farm
which forms part of the 450 acre Rodbaston Estate You will be working with a diverse student You will be working with a diverse student
Finance Team in order to provide a high population and you will be expected to demonstrate population and you will be expected to demonstrate
in Staffordshire. The mixed livestock farm comprises
quality, efficient, effective and supportive beef, sheep and cereal enterprises and is operated on excellent classroom management techniques whilst excellent classroom management techniques whilst
finance service for all academies within a commercial basis which also supports teaching and teaching a range of abilities from level 1 through to teaching a range of abilities from level 1 through to
the trust. A willingness to work flexibly learning in agriculture and related land based industries. foundation degree. foundation degree.
within the team is essential as are strong The successful applicant will be educated to at least You will have extensive experience of working in You will have extensive experience of working in
organisational, time management and NVQ level 3 or possess at least 3 years’ experience of the Health and Care Industry and be qualified to at the Health and Care Industry and be qualified to at
customer service skills. livestock husbandry to high standards. least an appropriate first degree or equivalent and least an appropriate first degree or equivalent and
Ideally, having previously worked in a Experience in operation of farm machinery, record possess an appropriate teaching qualification (or be possess an appropriate teaching qualification (or be
keeping and a knowledge of all aspects of livestock willing to work towards one). willing to work towards one).
finance environment, the successful production methods, animal health and nutrition is
candidate may have experience of ordering required. Applicants from a nursing and / or midwifery Applicants from a nursing and / or midwifery
and invoice procedures, excellent accuracy background are particularly welcome and a current background are particularly welcome and a current
Knowledge of pedigree breeding and preparation of Nurse qualification is desirable. Nurse qualification is desirable.
and attention to detail and a good level of IT show cattle would also be advantageous.
skills. Whilst this is a temporary role in the Applications will be considered upon receipt. For an application pack please email your For an application pack please email your
first instance there may be the possibility of details quoting the post reference number to: details quoting the post reference number to:
For an application pack please email your details
a permanent position being available. quoting the post reference number to: recruitment@ recruitment@southstaffs.ac.uk or go to www. recruitment@southstaffs.ac.uk or go to www.
southstaffs.ac.uk or go to www.southstaffs.ac.uk/ southstaffs.ac.uk/about-us/college-vacancies/ to southstaffs.ac.uk/about-us/college-vacancies/ to
about-us/college-vacancies/ to download an download an application form and job description. download an application form and job description.
Please visit https://nclt.ac.uk/vacancies/ application form and job description. Closing date: Friday 24 August 2018 at 12:00 Closing date: Friday 24 August 2018 at 12:00
to apply. Closing date: Friday 7 September 2018 at 12:00 midday. Interviews to take place Friday 31 August midday. Interviews to take place Friday 31 August
Closing date: 22 August 2018. midday. 2018. August 2018.
South Staffordshire College is an equal opportunities employer and welcomes applicants South Staffordshire College is an equal opportunities employer and welcomes applicants South Staffordshire College is an equal opportunities employer and welcomes applicants
NCLT has a commitment to safeguarding students from all sections of the community. We are committed to safeguarding and promoting the from all sections of the community. We are committed to safeguarding and promoting the from all sections of the community. We are committed to safeguarding and promoting the
and the successful candidate will be subject to welfare of children and young adults and expect all staff to share this commitment. This welfare of children and young adults and expect all staff to share this commitment. This welfare of children and young adults and expect all staff to share this commitment. This
pre-employment checks, including an Enhanced DBS. position is subject to an Enhanced Disclosure check under the Rehabilitation of Offenders position is subject to an Enhanced Disclosure check under the Rehabilitation of Offenders position is subject to an Enhanced Disclosure check under the Rehabilitation of Offenders
We are committed to equal opportunities and welcome Act 1974, medical clearance and satisfactory references. Please be aware successful
applications from all sections of the community. Act 1974, medical clearance and satisfactory references. Please be aware successful Act 1974, medical clearance and satisfactory references. Please be aware successful
applicants will be expected to fund their own DBS check, which is currently at £44.
applicants will be expected to fund their own DBS check, which is currently at £44. applicants will be expected to fund their own DBS check, which is currently at £44.
tes.com/recruit
÷èöæòð¦ìñö÷ì÷ø÷è¦ïèäõñ¡öèööìòñö
Dedicated to
recruitment
opportunities
in education
Email your job
advertisement to
recruitment@
tesglobal.com
or contact us on
020 3194 3050
Queen Anne’s School • 6 Henley Road • Caversham • Reading • Berkshire • RG4 6DX
Queen Anne’s School • 6 Henley Road • Caversham • Reading • Berkshire • RG4 6DX
Teacher of English
ST MARY’S SCHOOL ASCOT Part-Time/Permanent
Independent Roman Catholic Girls’ School for 380 girls aged 11–18
Chase Grammar School is seeking to appoint
Learning Support a talented part-time Teacher of English who
is dynamic and well-qualified; someone who
Assistant is focused on inspiring and engaging our
students fully and creatively.
Salary: £8.59 – £9.67 per hour The successful applicant will be an excellent
(£15,537 – £17,490 per annum communicator and an inspiring teacher
actual) linked to competency and whose passion for the subject is self-evident.
qualifications. A high degree of organisational skill is also
(Rates effective 1st September) LEARNING SUPPORT TEACHER required, as well as commitment to the
wider life of this successful and growing
Full Time/Permanent
FOR PUPILS WITH SPLD independent school (please read through the
job description for more information).
As a Learning Support Assistant, you will be
supporting the students with their education (SPECIFIC LEARNING DIFFICULTIES) The start date for this role is September or as
and also with their emotional needs, personal soon as possible.
care and behavioural challenges. In school, Part time, approximately 16 hours per week, predominantly after Chase Grammar School is committed to safeguarding and
you will carry out a range of duties, supporting promoting the welfare of children and young people.The
all elements of learning from academic
the school day • Required for September 2018 successful candidate must be able to satisfy an enhanced
disclosure check with the Disclosure and Barring Service
achievement and basic life skills through to self- and must attend and comply with all Safeguarding Training
care and personal development. The role will A vacancy exists for an enthusiastic and committed Learning Support Teacher. and the School’s Safeguarding Policy.
require you to be creative, patient and adaptive.
Every child we support is unique and they will The successful candidate will be suitably qualified and have experience To apply, candidates must complete
require an individualised approach to ensure that working with SEN pupils. the school’s Application form and Pre-
each of them has the opportunities to reach their Employment Medical form and send
full potential in a caring and safe environment. St Mary’s School Ascot has its own salary scale. it, together with a letter of application
addressed to Dr P Silverwood, the School
This role is perfect for all levels of experience, For further details of the post and an application form, please contact
and here at Meldreth Manor School we will Principal to Lmm@chasegrammar.com
work with you to develop your skills and Nicola MacRobbie on 01344 296710 or recruitment@st-marys-ascot.co.uk to arrive no later than 09:00, Tuesday, 28
confidence in the role. So, if you’re looking Information about the school can be found at www.st-marys-ascot.co.uk August 2018.
to develop your career within a unique
educational setting and are passionate about Closing date: 20 August 2018
giving children and young people life chances St Mary’s School Ascot is committed to safeguarding and promoting the welfare of children,
that will shape their futures, this is the perfect and applicants must be willing to undergo child protection screening appropriate to the post,
role for you. including checks with past employers and the Disclosure & Barring Service.
Visit www.tes.com/jobs to apply.
Closing date: 27 August 2018 www.st-marys-ascot.co.uk
Teacher of Geography
Starting January 2019 • Opportunity to become
Boarding Housemaster for the right candidate TEACHER OF FRENCH & SPANISH
This is a superb opportunity for someone who has a degree in geography or closely
related subject, to join our dynamic and innovative school. The role would suit an Part time (0.9) • Maternity cover • Required for September/October 2018
enthusiastic and pedagogically creative experienced teacher, who is excited about Queen Anne’s School is an exciting place to work, where every member of the school team
being part of a team who have consistently high results at IGCSE, GCSE and A Level. is valued. We aim to recruit the highest calibre of staff through all areas of the school.
The current post-holder is a housemaster and we would certainly consider a Queen Anne’s School is a community and all staff work with a professional, committed and
candidate who is interested in becoming a boarding housemaster as well as enthusiastic attitude.
joining the school as a geography teacher. The School is located in beautiful 35 acre grounds with good transport links and within
The right candidate will answer ‘Yes’ to the following questions: easy walking distance of Reading Station. We offer a number of staff benefits including
• Do students leave your lessons inspired and enthused? excellent training and Inset opportunities, discounted gym membership, subsidised meals,
free car parking, Child Care Voucher Scheme, pension scheme, School fee reduction
• Are you passionate about teaching and learning?
where appropriate. Queen Anne’s School is an ILM (Institute of Leadership and Management)
• Do you have experience of teaching at A Level? accredited centre for training.
We offer excellent free lunches, contributory pension scheme and a beautiful
We are seeking to appoint a qualified, enthusiastic and inspirational Teacher of French
working environment. Staff are also encouraged to make use of the free
and Spanish to teach French up to A Level and Spanish to KS3 within this academically
gym membership, open air swimming pool during summer months and to join selective and dynamic school.
a variety of staff teams such as football and cricket.
Full details of this position and how to apply are available from http://bit.ly/QASCareers
Informal pre-application discussions and visits are welcome; or by emailing HR@qas.org.uk
please call Moya Flynn on 01189 405218 or 07739 345171.
Queen Anne’s is committed to safeguarding and promoting the welfare of children
Closing date: Wednesday 22 August 2018 • Interviews: Friday 24 August 2018 and young people and expects all staff and volunteers to share this commitment.
Applicants will be required to undergo child protection screening appropriate to the post,
For further details and an application form go to including checks with past employers and the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS).
Shiplake College is committed to safeguarding and promoting the welfare of children and applicants www.qas.org.uk
must be willing to undergo child protection screening appropriate to the post, including checks with past
employers and the Disclosure and Barring Service. The school is an equal opportunities employer. Queen Anne’s School • 6 Henley Road • Caversham • Reading • Berkshire • RG4 6DX
TEACHER OF GERMAN
Full Time • Maternity cover • Required for January 2019
Queen Anne’s School is an exciting place to work, where every member of the school team
is valued. We aim to recruit the highest calibre of staff through all areas of the school.
Queen Anne’s School is a community and all staff work with a professional, committed and
enthusiastic attitude.
The School is located in beautiful 35 acre grounds with good transport links and within
easy walking distance of Reading Station. We offer a number of staff benefits including
excellent training and Inset opportunities, discounted gym membership, subsidised meals,
free car parking, Child Care Voucher Scheme, pension scheme, School fee reduction
where appropriate. Queen Anne’s School is an ILM (Institute of Leadership and Management)
accredited centre for training.
We are seeking to appoint a qualified, enthusiastic and inspirational Teacher of German
Netball Coach
to teach German (up to and including A-Level) within this academically selective and Required from September 2018
dynamic school. The ability to teach French to KS3 would be an advantage.
Full time / £22,785 - £35,211
Full details of this position and how to apply are available from http://bit.ly/QASCareers
or by emailing HR@qas.org.uk We are looking for an enthusiastic, self-motivated and experienced
Queen Anne’s is committed to safeguarding and promoting the welfare of children
Netball Coach to build upon the very high standards of this lively
and young people and expects all staff and volunteers to share this commitment. and highly successful department
Applicants will be required to undergo child protection screening appropriate to the post, Full details of the post and how to apply may be obtained from:
including checks with past employers and the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS).
www.putneyhigh.gdst.net/about/work-with-us
Registered Charity
Closing date: 30 August 2018. Interviews: 4 September 2018.
www.qas.org.uk We are committed to the safeguarding of children and child protection
screening will apply to this post.
Queen Anne’s School • 6 Henley Road • Caversham • Reading • Berkshire • RG4 6DX
Catering Supervisor
Dates: Job start: September 2018
Salary: ELSS Support Staff Pay Scale
Contract type: To be confirmed
Contract term: One Year Fixed Term
PA to Head of Junior
The East London Science School is about to enter its fifth year. School and Junior LATE STAY SUPERVISOR RECEPTIONIST &
As our popularity grows, we are keen to recruit exceptional Permanent/Part Time ADMIN ASSISTANT
individuals to work in partnership with the Principal to develop
this unique and exciting school. School Secretary Salary: £11.70/hour
Full Time/Fixed Term to July 2019
From: September 2018
The successful candidate will: Term time only plus 28 days We are the Stephen Perse Foundation. Location: Dame Bradbury’s School,
• Ensure all aspects of the preparation of food and beverages Saffron Walden
to the standards required by the school Pro rata of £30,000 to £33,000 per annum Extraordinary things happen here every day.
• Be responsible for serving 200+ meals a day The Stephen Perse Foundation is inspiring. It is a The Stephen Perse Foundation has its
• During service times ensure that tables and counters are as Dulwich College is one of the country’s community in which everyone, staff or student, own competitive salary scale
clean as reasonably practicable leading independent boys’ schools, achieves and makes a contribution every day.
• Report immediately any accidents, fire, theft, loss, damage, Start date: September 2018
situated in a 70-acre campus in South By teaching students to think for themselves, we
unfit food or other irregularities and take such action as We are the Stephen Perse Foundation.
may be appropriate or possible East London, 13 minutes from Victoria. achieve exceptional results – but for us, education
• Liaise with school business manager is not just about grades. We see the individual Extraordinary things happen here every day.
• Take cashless payment from students at the till using the We are looking for a PA to the Head behind the results. We develop strength of
of Junior School and Junior School character, a sense of social responsibility and an The Stephen Perse Foundation is inspiring. It
prepaid card system
Secretary to assist the Head of the ability to innovate and collaborate. We look for is a community in which everyone, staff or
Download an application form and job description and, once and develop this added value with our staff as student, achieves and makes a contribution
completed, email to careers@eastlondonscienceschool.co.uk Junior School in the efficient running of well as our students. every day.
Closing date: 20th August 2018 the Junior School, involving liaison with
other departments within the College Responsible to: Head of School and Office Manager Responsible to: Administration Manager 3-11
Interview date: TBC
and also teachers, boys and parents. Location: Senior School, Union Road, Cambridge Location: Dame Bradbury’s
Note: Successful candidates will be notified by phone or email.
The position is often the first point of Job purpose: To supervise late stay during the
The East London Science School is committed to safeguarding and
short-term absence of the assigned teacher. Role Description: To assist with the smooth
promoting the welfare of children and applicants must be willing contact in the College and thus holds a running of the Dame Bradbury’s reception/office
to undergo child protection screening appropriate to the pivotal role. Hours of work: Hours of work can either be
post, including checks with past employers. All undertaking administrative duties as required.
successful candidates will be subject to an 3.15 pm - 6.00 pm or 3.45pm - 6.00pm Thursday
Enhanced DBS disclosure. Closing Date: 4.00pm on Friday 24 to Friday, term time only plus four INSET days Closing date 24 August 2018.
August 2018 with interviews being per academic year (35.8 weeks per year). Please apply directly through our online
held during the week beginning 3 Closing date 24 August 2018. recruitment portal by visiting www.
September 2018. stephenperse.com/recruitment.
Please apply directly through our online
Further details are available from recruitment portal by visiting We are unable to accept CVs as a method of
www.stephenperse.com/recruitment. application.
www.dulwich.org.uk/appointments
or by contacting We are unable to accept CVs as a method The Stephen Perse Foundation is committed
of application. to safeguarding and promoting the welfare of
020 8299 5183/9326/9288. The Stephen Perse Foundation is committed to safeguarding children, and applicants must be willing to undergo
and promoting the welfare of children, and applicants must be child protection screening appropriate to the post,
We are committed to safeguarding and promoting willing to undergo child protection screening appropriate to the
the welfare of children. A DBS Disclosure is post, including checks with past employers and the Disclosure including checks with past employers and the
required to Enhanced level. Charity 1150064 and Barring Service. Disclosure and Barring Service.
Senior STEM
Technician
Actual Salary: £17.7k pa.
www.toothillschool.co.uk www.toothillschool.co.uk 37.5 hours pw, Term
time 38 weeks, +
INSET days, + HR Officer
Attendance Officer Science Technician 1 week (40 weeks)
Full Time | Permanent
Start date: 1 September 2018
Salary: NJC Scale 3 Salary: £17,681 - £18,672 Do you have a scientific background or interest, or do
(£17,681 - £18,672) pro rata, pa you have practical Laboratory Technician experience?
Full-time – Permanent The Foundation is looking to recruit
Part-time – Permanent Bohunt School in Wokingham is seeking to appoint a an enthusiastic and highly competent
STEM Technician to support teaching and learning in administrator to work within the
This vacancy would be suitable for an STEM; experience is preferable but not essential. Foundation’s small but busy Human
An exciting opportunity has arisen in Student
Services for an organised, meticulous and experienced Science Technician or for Bohunt School Wokingham is a brand new secondary Resources Department.
proactive individual to join the team. This is a school which opened to year 7 in September 2016,
somebody, with a Science background, growing to 1500. It is part of the Bohunt Education
The successful candidate must be highly
job share and you would therefore need to be who is looking to start their career organised, have the ability to work
able to work Wednesday, Thursday and Friday. Trust built upon the success of Bohunt School Liphook.
in the field. Although desirable, independently to plan, prioritise, multi-
The role mainly involves supporting a team of task, and work to strict deadlines. Given
The Key duties of this role are: experience of working in a school technicians to provide technical support, ensuring that the nature of this post, confidentiality,
• Oversee and monitor the attendance and
punctuality of all students for assigned setting is not essential. equipment is functioning properly and is ready to use,
diplomacy and tact must be maintained
and that the right materials are available for particular
year groups As an ‘Outstanding’ school, we are lessons. Sometimes laboratory technicians may be
at all times.
• Meet with key staff to discuss concerns not complacent—we know that Toot expected to work closely with students to explain or Required from September 2018
regarding students whose attendance falls Hill School can be even better, with a demonstrate experiments or how to use equipment, as Closing date: 24 August 2018
below 90% in order to identify the students well as helping teachers with a class and supporting
who need to be targeted for intervention national and international reputation. individual students on research projects. Early applications are advised as the
• Work closely with the Head of Year and Over the next few years we will continue College reserves the right to appoint at
This is an excellent opportunity for a D&T or Science
Pastoral SLT in addressing the needs of to transform the school so that it Technician to help shape the development and
any stage during the application process.
persistently absent students to ensure they becomes an even better place to shape infrastructure of STEM as a pioneering flagship for the Completed application forms and
return to School on a consistent basis new school, and opportunities for career progression cover letters must be emailed to
young lives. recruitment@sdmail.org.uk
• To produce regular reports on attendance, for the right person are extensive.
with data to show improvements made by Salary dependent upon knowledge and experience, For further details please visit
targeted cohort of students. To apply for this role please applications will be considered as they are received. www.stdunstans.org.uk
visit the vacancies section CVs are not accepted. St Dunstan’s College is committed to safeguarding and
To apply for this role please visit of the school website, promoting the welfare of children; the successful applicant
TO APPLY: Visit www.tes.com/jobs will be subject to an enhanced disclosure through the DBS.
the vacancies section of the school www.toothillschool.co.uk, Closing date: 31 August 2018. St Dunstan’s Educational Foundation
website, www.toothillschool.co.uk,
and complete an online
and complete an online Bohunt School Wokingham is committed to safeguarding and
Registered Charity Number 312747
application form. application form. promoting the welfare of children and young students and expects
all staff to share this commitment. The successful applicant will Stanstead Road, London, SE6 4TY
Closing date: 21 August 2018 Closing date: 21 August 2018 need to undertake an Enhanced DBS check. 020 8516 7200 I www.stdunstans.org.uk
Surbiton, London
Head of IT
Start date: September 2018
Art Technician
Salary: £50,000.00 - £60,000.00 Facilities Assistant Full Time/Permanent
Salary: Competitive
East Dale Road, Melton Full Time/Permanent Salary: £19,000 Tenure: 38 weeks of the year (term-time plus
North Ferriby HU14 3HS OVERALL JOB PURPOSE 2 weeks) (Monday to Friday, 8:30am – 4:30pm,
• To lead the delivery of IT Services within The Start date: 1st September, 2018 37.5 hours per week)
Abbey School so the wider community is Full Time/Permanent Start date: September 2018
effectively supported in the delivery of their Surbiton High School’s dynamic Art department seeks an Art
educational ambitions. The Quest Academy was opened in September
2010 and has made rapid progress to Technician who is passionate about inspiring, encouraging and
• To support the IT Strategic Group in their empowering our pupils in the subject.
implementation of the School’s educationally become a “good school” (Ofsted June 2015).
led IT Vision and IT Strategic Plan for Key Responsibilities:
teaching and learning.
We require a Facilities Assistant to join • Keeping the Art studio ordered and tidy
our Premises team and help maintain our • Working with the art staff to prepare lessons
• To lead the management of all IT resources • Stock taking and ordering of materials
and contracts, ensuring optimisation. new 16 million pound campus. • Assisting with the department budget
School KNOWLEDGE, SKILLS & EXPERIENCE REQUIRED
General
You will be a flexible and hardworking
person, ideally with skills in either carpentry,
• Ensuring health and safety procedures are adhered to
• Helping students build armatures or other structures as required
• Loading and unloading the kiln, firing the kiln (training can
Administrator • A degree in IT or Microsoft MSCE/Cisco
qualifications/Chartered IT Professional or
equivalent experience
metal work, plumbing or electrical and a
keen interest in general maintenance.
be provided)
• Making canvases for students
• Occasionally helping teachers in practical lessons, such as
• Analytical and problem solving skills Please note that some of the work is physical
Start date: 3 September 2018 printmaking
• Excellent communication and presentation and outdoors and there are some evenings • Taking minutes in the department meetings
skills, both verbal and written and Saturday mornings on a rota for which • Contributing to the organisation and running of co-curricular
A genuinely ‘Outstanding’ school, • Confidence to deal with all levels of staff, overtime is paid. and enrichment activities, as well as wider School initiatives
including governors and students where applicable
with a strong reputation for Full details, an application form, job • Such other duties as the Principal may reasonably direct.
To apply please complete an application
developing exceptional practitioners. form (available of The Abbey Website) and description and person specification are For any queries relating to the role or your application,
send together with your CV and a covering attached or available from our website please email recruitment@surbitonhigh.com
Please see our online advert letter to recruitment@theabbey.co.uk. www.thequestacademy.org.uk – or via To apply online visit: https://unitedlearning.current-
for more details. Georgina Bolter at the contact details below. vacancies.com/Jobs/Advert/1346663?cid=1567
Interviews will be held on Thursday 6th
Please note that the School reserves the right to appoint at
September 2018. Please return forms to: Georgina Bolter, any stage during the recruitment process.
Closing date: 31 August 2018.
The school is committed to safeguarding and c/o The Quest Academy, Farnborough Closing Date: 8:00am, Tuesday 4 September 2018
promoting the welfare of children and young Avenue, Croydon, CR2 8HD. Telephone: Interviews to be held week commencing: 10 September 2018
people and expects all staff to share this 0208 768 3352 or email: Surbiton High School is committed to safeguarding and promoting
commitment. The successful candidate will be gbolter@thequestacademy.org.uk the welfare of children, and applicants must be willing to undergo
subject to an Enhanced DBS check. Registered child protection screening appropriate to the post, including checks
Charity No 309115. Closing date: noon on Friday 24th August, 2018. with past employers and the Disclosure and Barring Service.
126 Years of Living out our Ethos in the Spirit of St Angela Merici
IT Technician
Salary: £17,681 to £18,672 per The Royal School
annum Per Aspera Ad Astra
Full-time/Permanent Assistant Catholic Education - Extraordinary Women
Physical Education
Teacher – Female
Full-Time – Permanent
Junior School Teacher
Start date: August 2018 Full Time/Permanent
Physical Education Teacher - Female
The International School of
Creative Science Wellington College is committed to providing world-class educational
Age range: Primary opportunities in the city of Tianjin. We seek to recruit and develop staff
Employed by: NCBIS – to support the Cover Teacher (Male) members who are fully engaged with the stated vision of the school – [to]
vision, positive ethos and policies of the
school Full Time/Permanent “aspire to create a caring, international community that develops well-
Location: UAE rounded individuals with strong values and the skills to thrive within an
Responsible to: Principal/Head of School
Start Date: September 2018 ever-changing global society” and who are guided in their professional
Qualifications: Degree, and PGCE or QTS and personal conduct by the core Wellington values – courage, respect,
or appropriate coaching qualifications Develop schemes of work and lesson plans
in line with curriculum objectives. Facilitate integrity, kindness and responsibility. In this way, the post holder should
Experience: Minimum 3 years teaching or
other relevant experience e.g. coaching, learning by establishing relationship with regard the following outline of the job description not as a checklist of
youth work. pupils, and by their organization of learning things to achieve, but as a starting point for their growth in the role.
resources and the classroom-learning
To find out more about the school, please Responsibility to and for:
visit our website at www.ncbis.co.uk environment.
• Responsible to the Head of Juniors.
To apply please complete the attached Develop and foster the appropriate skills
• Responsible for the supervision of persons providing support in
application form and send to and social abilities to enable the optimum
InternationalEducation@hays.com development of children, according to age, the classroom.
Or call Penny Kontopyrghou to find out ability and aptitude. The post requires you:
more about this opportunity on 0207
2598771/00447595 968 600. Assess and record progress and prepare • To be able to teach pupils in the age range 4-11 years.
pupils for examinations. By linking pupils’ • To ensure that due regard is given to equal opportunity issues
Please feel free to send a CV and a knowledge to earlier learning and developing
letter of application in addition to the in line with school policy.
ways to encourage it further, and challenging • Other responsible duties as directed by the Head of Juniors.
application form, with a recent photo.
and inspiring pupils to help them deepen their
The closing date for applications is 30th knowledge and understanding. The completed application form, together with a letter of introduction
August 2018. The school reserves the
rights to appoint earlier if an exceptional Qualifications: and an up-to-date CV, including the names and contact details of three
candidate applies for the post, so early • Bachelor’s Degree in Arabic Language/ referees, should be sent to posts.tianjin@wellingtoncollege.cn.
applications are strongly encouraged. Islamic Studies
Initial interviews will be held by Skype. Closing date: 31st December 2018
• Minimum 2 years teaching experience in
UAE This post is exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974 and as such all applicants who
Successful candidates will be required to apply for an Enhanced
are appointed to this post will be subject to an Enhanced Disclosure from the Criminal Records
Disclosure from the Disclosure and barring service (https:// Closing date: 11/09/2018 Bureau before the appointment is confirmed. This check will include details of cautions, reprimands or
www.gov.uk/government/organisations/disclosure-and-
For more information, please visit website: warnings, as well as convictions and nonconviction information. Once provisionally appointed, the
barring-service and/or for a police clearance from their home
successful applicant(s) may also be required to apply for an Enhanced Disclosure at predetermined
or resident country. http://beam.co.ae/
intervals during the course of their employment whilst in this post.
Newton British Academy Newton British Academy Newton British Academy Newton British Academy
Health and Social Care Information Technology Science Teacher Secondary DT Teacher
Teacher Teacher We are looking to recruit enthusiastic, The Newton Group is seeking
We are looking to recruit enthusiastic, We are looking to recruit enthusiastic, creative and dynamic teachers of the enthusiastic, creative DT teachers to
creative and dynamic teachers of the creative and dynamic teachers of the highest quality to join our successful team. join our successful team. Applicants
highest quality to join our successful team. highest quality to join our successful team. Applicants should possess a commitment should possess a commitment to
Applicants should possess a commitment Applicants should possess a commitment to helping children achieve high academic helping children achieve high academic
to helping children achieve high academic to helping children achieve high academic standards in a lively and engaging standards in a lively and engaging
standards in a lively and engaging standards in a lively and engaging manner, whilst integrating differentiation manner, whilst integrating differentiation
manner, whilst integrating differentiation manner, whilst integrating differentiation and a range of learning styles into their and a range of learning styles into their
and a range of learning styles into their and a range of learning styles into their daily practice. daily practice.
daily practice. daily practice.
An excellent remuneration package An excellent remuneration package
An excellent remuneration package An excellent remuneration package is on is on offer to successful candidates is on offer to successful candidates
is on offer to successful candidates offer to successful candidates including: including: including:
including: • A competitive tax-free salary • A competitive tax-free salary • A competitive tax-free salary
• A competitive tax-free salary • A 2-year renewable contract • A 2-year renewable contract • A 2-year renewable contract
• A 2-year renewable contract • Furnished accommodation • Furnished accommodation • Furnished accommodation
• Furnished accommodation • Fee discounts for teachers’ children • Fee discounts for teachers’ children • Fee discounts for teachers’ children
• Fee discounts for teachers’ children • A merit-based incentive scheme • A merit-based incentive scheme • A merit-based incentive scheme
• A merit-based incentive scheme • Medical insurance and Visa costs • Medical insurance and Visa costs • Medical insurance and Visa costs
• Medical insurance and Visa costs • Baggage allowance • Baggage allowance • Baggage allowance
• Baggage allowance • Annual flight allowance and transport • Annual flight allowance and transport • Annual flight allowance and transport
• Annual flight allowance and transport
All applications should be sent to All applications should be sent to All applications should be sent to
All applications should be sent to
recruitment@newtonschools.sch.qa recruitment@newtonschools.sch.qa recruitment@newtonschools.sch.qa
recruitment@newtonschools.sch.qa
(please include the position you are (please include the position you are (please include the position you are
(please include the position you are
applying for in the subject). Interviews applying for in the subject). Interviews will applying for in the subject). Interviews applying for in the subject). Interviews will
will take place via Skype / Google take place via Skype / Google hangouts. will take place via Skype / Google take place via Skype / Google hangouts.
hangouts. Only shortlisted candidates Only shortlisted candidates will be hangouts. Only shortlisted candidates Only shortlisted candidates will be
will be contacted. contacted. will be contacted. contacted.
Closing date: 23rd August 2018 Closing date: 23rd August 2018 Closing date: 23rd August 2018 Closing date: 23rd August 2018
Visit our website: http://newtonschools.sch.qa/ Visit our website: http://newtonschools.sch.qa/ Visit our website: http://newtonschools.sch.qa/ Visit our website: http://newtonschools.sch.qa/
tes.com/schoolportal
âòëäñ Ðõäëäð
)HZLK PU [OL MHZ[KL]LSVWPUN JP[` VM *VSVTIV :YP 3HURH [OPZ ,UNSPZO [LHJOLY OHZ
MV\UK OPZ MLL[ ^VYRPUN PU H ILH\[PM\S JV\U[Y` ^P[O WSLU[` VM [PTL MVY YLZ[ HUK WSH`
Ò
OHK HS^H`Z ^HU[LK [V [LHJO PU
ÊÕÊÖâ
:YP 3HURH )LMVYL TV]PUN OLYL
0×K ]PZP[LK THU` [PTLZ [V ZWLUK
OVSPKH`Z ^P[O MHTPS` HUK MYPLUKZ
HUK ^HZ HS^H`Z HZ[VUPZOLK I` [OL
JV\U[Y`×Z ILH\[`
0 NYHK\H[LK MYVT [OL <UP]LYZP[`
VM 6_MVYK ^P[O H KLNYLL PU *SHZZPJZ
HUK \UZ\YL VM ^OH[ 0 ^HU[LK [V KV
UL_[ 0 [H\NO[ H[ [OL *VSVTIV 0U[LYUH[PVUHS
:JOVVS PU :YP 3HURH MVY H `LHY HZ HU
\UX\HSPMPLK [LHJOLY 0[ ^HZ T` [PTL [OLYL
[OH[ ZWHYRLK T` SV]L VM [LHJOPUN" 0 YL[\YULK
[V [OL <2 JVTWSL[LK H :JOVVS +PYLJ[
X\HSPMPJH[PVU HUK [H\NO[ ZLJVUKHY` ,UNSPZO
HUK KYHTH MVY H ML^ `LHYZ PU 3VUKVU
0 YL[\YULK [V :YP 3HURH [V [LHJO ,UNSPZO
SHUN\HNL HUK SP[LYH[\YL H[ [OL )YP[PZO :JOVVS
PU *VSVTIV 0[ PZ Z\JO HU L_JP[PUN [PTL
[V IL OLYL! [OL ^HY `LHYZ HYL SVUN NVUL HUK
[V\YPZT PZ YLHSS` WPJRPUN \W
;OL ZJOVVS KH` Y\UZ MYVT HT [V WT
HUK \USLZZ 0 HT Y\UUPUN HU HM[LYZJOVVS JS\I
VY H[[LUKPUN OV\ZL HJ[P]P[PLZ Ô 0 HT HSZV H
OLHK VM OV\ZL Ô 0 JHU IL IHJR OVTL [V ^PUK
KV^U HUK LUQV` [OL YLZ[ VM [OL KH` PU NVVK
[PTL 4HU` Z[HMM HYL ]LY` JVTMVY[HIS` OV\ZLK
JSVZL [V [OL ZJOVVS HUK L]LUPUNZ HYL ZWLU[
JVVRPUN VY KPUPUN V\[ ^P[O MYPLUKZ PU H JP[`
[OH[ PZ ILJVTPUN PUJYLHZPUNS` ]PIYHU[ 6U
^LLRLUKZ VUL JHU [YH]LS KV^U ZV\[O [V H IVK` 0U [LYTZ VM VWWVY[\UP[PLZ [V PTWYV]L TPKKSL VY ZLUPVY THUHNLTLU[ ^OV
WSL[OVYH VM ZHUK` ILHJOLZ HUK YLZVY[Z VY Z[HMM [YHPUPUN [OYV\NO JVSSHIVYH[PVU ^P[O [OLTZLS]LZ TH` IL V\[ VM [OL Ù[YHPUPUN SVVWÚ
OLHK \W JV\U[Y` [V 2HUK` VY IL`VUK V[OLY ZJOVVSZ HIYVHK P[ ^V\SK IL NYLH[ PM 0U[LYUH[PVUHS ZJOVVSZ OLYL ULLK [V IL MHY
4` YVSL PU]VS]LZ [LHJOPUN P.*:, ,UNSPZO PU[LYUH[PVUHS ZJOVVSZ OLYL VWLULK [OLTZLS]LZ TVYL MVY[OJVTPUN ^P[O YLNHYKZ [V L_[LYUHS
SHUN\HNL HUK SP[LYH[\YL HUK [HRPUN H ZTHSS \W [V Z\JO HJJYLKP[H[PVU HUK ZJY\[PU` *7+ HUK 0 OVWL [OPZ JOHUNLZ PU [OL M\[\YL
I\[ RLLU (SL]LS SP[LYH[\YL JSHZZ (S[OV\NO <USPRL PU [OL <2 ^OLYL HSS Z[HMM \UKLYNV *VSVTIV PZ MHZ[ KL]LSVWPUN HZ H [OYP]PUN
P[ PZ HU ÙPU[LYUH[PVUHSÚ ZJOVVS TVZ[ Z[\KLU[Z Z[H[\[VY` [YHPUPUN WLYPVKZ SVJHS [LHJOPUN Z[HMM LJVUVTPJ O\I ^P[O H NYLH[ KLHS VM MVYLPNU
OLYL HYL ^LHS[O` SVJHSZ ^OV HZWPYL [V HUK KV HYL TVZ[S` VUS` KLNYLLOVSKLYZ ^P[OPU [OLPY PU]LZ[TLU[ Ô HU` ]PZP[VY [V [OL JP[` UV^ ^PSS
Z[\K` H[ [VW \UP]LYZP[PLZ ^VYSK^PKL ;OLYL PZ Z\IQLJ[ HYLH :VTL ZJOVVSZ VMMLY L_[LYUHS HUK UV[PJL [OL MYHU[PJ SHUKYLJV]LY` WYVQLJ[
H ZTH[[LYPUN VM MVYLPNU L_WH[ JOPSKYLU [VV Z\WWSLTLU[HY` 0U[LYUH[PVUHS )HJJHSH\YLH[L HKQHJLU[ [V [OL PJVUPJ .HSSL -HJL .YLLU
6UL SV]LS` [OPUN PZ [OH[ THU` VM [OL VY *HTIYPKNL (ZZLZZTLU[ 0U[LYUH[PVUHS ^OLYL KYLKNLYZ HYL I\Z` JYLH[PUN UL^ SHUK VU
Z[\KLU[Z LUNHNL PU V\[YLHJO WYVQLJ[Z ^P[O ,K\JH[PVU [YHPUPUN I\[ VM[LU HJHKLTPJ HUK [OL ZLHMYVU[ 0 HT Z\YL [VW PU[LYUH[PVUHS ZJOVVS
SLZZWYP]PSLNLK ZJOVVSZ PU :YP 3HURH VM[LU WHZ[VYHS KL]LSVWTLU[ PZ SLM[ PU [OL OHUKZ VM JOHPUZ ^P[O SPURZ HJYVZZ [OL NSVIL ^PSS IL RLLU
PU Y\YHS HYLHZ VU TV]PUN PU /LHS[O` JVTWL[P[PVU [OH[ KYP]LZ
:[\KLU[Z OLYL HYL YLZWLJ[M\S HUK ]HS\L
âòøõ çäü
\W Z[HUKHYKZ JHU VUS` IL H NVVK [OPUN
OVULZ[ HUK PUUV]H[P]L [LHJOPUN 4` ZJOVVS Íò üòø úäñ÷ ÷ò ÷èïï ÷ëè úòõïçđö ÷èäæëèõö
HSVUN ^P[O THU` V[OLY PU[LYUH[PVUHS ZJOVVSZ äåòø÷ üòøõ úòõîìñê çäü ÷ëè øñìôøè
PU *VSVTIV PZ `L[ [V IL HJJYLKP[LK I` [OL æìõæøðö÷äñæèö ìñ úëìæë üòø ÷èäæë òõ ÷ëè
*V\UJPS VM )YP[PZO 0U[LYUH[PVUHS :JOVVSZ åõìïïìäñæè òé üòøõ æïäöö Òé öò èðäìï îä÷è
VY [OL -LKLYH[PVU VM )YP[PZO 0U[LYUH[PVUHS óäõîèõ±÷èöêïòåäïæòð àè úìïï êìùè üòøõ @VOHU .YHOHT PZ HU ,UNSPZO SHUN\HNL HUK
:JOVVSZ PU (ZPH HUK PUZ[LHK P[ VWLYH[LZ \UKLY öæëòòï |! ìé üòøõ ö÷òõü ìö óøåïìöëèç SP[LYH[\YL ZWLJPHSPZ[ HUK OLHK VM OV\ZL H[
[OL N\PKHUJL VM H UVTPUHS SVJHS \TIYLSSH [OL )YP[PZO :JOVVS PU *VSVTIV :YP 3HURH
&
ÐÎÝÝâ
! #
A A 6(1 . A 6(1 .
33
2Q WDVN 7DUJHW 0HW *RRG 3URJUHVV
6FRWW /LD (YD
5LFKDUGV 'DYLHV :LOVRQ
0RQGD\ WK
A 6(1 . B A 33
*RRG 3URJUHVV JLYHQ WR 6LDQ
6LQFH XVLQJ &/$66 &+$576 DW WKHLU VFKRRO RI VWD EHOLHYH LW KDV KDG DQ Ζ03$&7
21 5('8&Ζ1* /2: /(9(/ 'Ζ65837Ζ21 ZLWK VWDWLQJ LW KDV KDG D 0$-25 Ζ03$&7