Prelims Reviewer Oblicon

You might also like

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 6

PRELIMS REVIEWER (OBLICON)

Civil Code of the Philippines

Under Article 1156, OBLIGATION Ex. X bought an air-conditioning unit. He


-is a juridical necessity to 1) give, 2) to do and already paid for the item but when the item
3) not to do. was delivered and as soon as the box was
- derived from Obligatio (Latin word) meaning opened, he noticed that the item was
tying or binding damaged. He told the delivery crew that he
wants his money back, but the crew said he
JURIDICAL NECESSITY – the court may be can’t because the item is already transferred.
asked to order the performance of an Can X get his money back?
obligation if the debtor refuses to perform it.
Answer: Yes. Because he didn’t accept the
Essential Requisites of an Obligation: item
1. Active Subject – the one who demands, he
who has the right. 3. QUASI-CONTRACT – Article 1160
– also called Creditor/OBLIGEE - there was no actual contract but it’s as if
2. Passive Subject – the one who is bounded, you entered into one (in a sense these
he who has the duty. obligations maybe considered as arising from
– also called Debtor/OBLIGOR law)
3. Object/PRESTATION – subject matter of - no one shall be enriched / benefited at the
the obligation. expense of another.
-without prestation, there is nothing to Quasi – “as if”
perform.
4. JURIDICAL TIE/Vinculum Juris/Efficient Kinds of Quasi-Contract
Cause – reason why an obligation exists a. Negotiorum Gestio – without consent,
“unauthorized management”
Article 1157. Note: only expenses for preservations are
Obligations arise from: (1) Law; (2) Contracts; reimbursable, not the ornamental.
(3) Quasi-contracts; (4) Acts or omissions b. Solutio Indebiti – “payment by mistake”
punished by law; and (5) Quasi-delicts. Due – pertain to maturity
Demandable – whether it can still be
Sources of Obligation: enforced or not
1. LAW – Article 1158 - beyond 10 years not demandable
2. CONTRACT – Article 1159 & 1305
Ex. - If the loan was on (2006), it is not
Article 1159 demandable now (2017)
a. Stipulations of the parties are the law - If the debtor pays the loan without knowing
between them that it shouldn’t be paid, the creditor must
b. Must be complied in good faith return the money. There is solution indebiti.
- If the debtor pays the loan knowing that it
Article 1305 shouldn’t be paid, the creditor can keep the
CONTRACT – meeting of minds between two money. There is no solution indebiti.
persons, there is a consent.
Consent should have: 4. DELICTS (crimes/ acts/ omissions punished
 Offer-certain/definite by law) Article 1161
 Acceptance-absolute/unconditional Omissions – negligence (culpa)
3 Kinds of Culpa
Note: a contract must pertain to the same a. Contractual Negligence (Culpa Contractual)
object for both parties -negligence in contracts resulting in their
breach
b. Civil Negligence (Culpa Aquiliana) care (ex. Truck drivers, common cargo
-negligence without pre-existing contract carriers)
c. Criminal Negligence (Culpa Criminal) Note: if you ask for a fee, even if you’re not
- negligence resulting in the commission of a customarily engaged in transporting goods
crime. and passenger, you must exert
-punishable in the revised civil code. EXTRAORDINARY diligence.

 SPECIFIC or DETERMINATE THING -


physically segregated, particularly
Examples: designated (PSPD)
• A sales lady broke a vase while she was  GENERIC or INDERTERMINATE THING –
wiping it- Culpa contractual class or genus to which it pertains and
• A window shopper broke a vase in the cannot be pointed out with particularity.
mall- Culpa aquiliana - genus never perish
• An angry person decided to vent his Exceptions: (when not to exercise the proper
frustrations on the vase- not culpa criminal diligence of the good father of the family)
because it is his intention. a. Law so provides
• A truck driver loses control of the b. Stipulation of the parties
vehicle, killing another motorist- Culpa c. Object is a generic thing
criminal because it is not his intention.
5. QUASI- DELICTS/ Torts Article 1162 2. To deliver the fruits (Article 1164)
- As if there is a crime/acts/omissions Creditor/ Obligee has the right to the fruit
- no contractual relation between the parties when the agreed date has come.
Delivered Fruit = Real right
Three (3) kinds of Fruits under Civil Code Undelivered Fruit = Personal right
a. NATURAL FRUIT – spontaneous products of Note: it is not the payment that transfers
the soil, young & other products of animals. ownership, it is the delivery.The creditor is
b. INDUSTRIAL FRUIT – produced by lands entitled to the fruits of the thing when the
through cultivation or labor. time the obligation to deliver arises.
- there is an intervention of man.
Ex. Poultry farm- chickens/hens lay eggs 3. To accession & accessory (Article 1166)
because of the feeds they eat. Accession – improvements/ additions
c. CIVIL FRUIT – product of corporeal Accessory – better use, embellishment, &
property completion

 REAL RIGHT – directed against the


WHOLE World Ex. -Car as the principal item
Ex. Marriage contract  Seat cover, fog lights – accessions
 Personal RIGHT – binding or enforceable  Car keys – accessory
ONLY against a SPECIFIC PERSON. -Diamond Ring
Ex. Your mother can’t be forced to pay the  Diamond – principal
liability under your name.  Ring – accessory
 Accessory Obligation (Obligation to give) -Oyster ordered in a restaurant
-even if not stated, it is already considered  Oyster – principal 
part of the obligation.  Pearl – accessory

1. To take care of the thing with proper ARTICLE 1167


diligence of a good father of the family An obligation to do, to perform an act or
(Article 1163) render a service. It contemplates three (3)
 Proper Diligence – ordinary diligence situations:
(considering the object of the obligation 1. The debtor fails to perform an obligation to
as if they belong to you) do
 Extraordinary diligence – opposite of 2. The debtor performs an obligation to do
ordinary diligence. Must give greater but contrary to the terms
3. The debtor performs an obligation to do the debtor is delayed, creditor can ask
but in a poor manner(“what has been poorly for damages.
done be considered as undone”) 1. Ordinary delay – failure to perform an
obligation on time (creditor did not demand)
Remedies of creditor in positive personal 2. Legal delay – failure to perform an
obligation: obligation on time which failure constitutes a
- get a third (3rd) person who will command breach of the obligation. (creditor demanded)
the debtor to do the job, and if there are Note: No demand, no delay, no damages.
expenses incurred, it will be charged against (3Ds)
the original debtor.
-if the original debtor still refuse, this time the Kinds of delay:
remedy of the creditor is to go to court for 1. Mora Solvendi – delay on the part of the
the collection of that amount. debtor to fulfil his obligation.
 The court can only command: a. Mora Solvendi ex re - real obligations;
a. The debtor to pay obligations to give
b. To stop the debtor what he has been doing b. Mora Solvendi ex persona - personal
obligations; obligations to do
Note: Do not force the debtor to do 2. Mora Accipiendi – delay on the part of the
something for you, if you force him it is creditor to accept the performance of the
considered as harassment. obligation.
3. Compensatio Morae – delay of the obligors
Article 1168 in reciprocal obligation, net result is that
An obligation NOT to do, the debtor does there is NO actionable default on the part of
what was forbidden for him to do. both parties.
Remedies of creditor in negative personal
obligation: Article 1170
- the creditor can go to court, and the court
will order the debtor to stop or refrain to Four (4) grounds for liability:
such act. 1. Fraud (deceit or dolo)
- if there are expenses incurred, it will be 2. Negligence (fault or culpa)
charged against the original debtor. 3. Delay ( mora)
4. Contravention of the terms of the
obligation (contravention of tenor)

Article 1169 Two (2) kinds of Fraud (dolo):


Those obliged to deliver or to do something a. Dolo Causante (causal fraud) – fraud
incur in delay from the time the creditor committed during the time of perfection (nag
judicially or extra-judicially demands from the ooffer and acceptance palang nanloloko na)
debtor their fulfillment of their obligation. (Article 1330)
However, the demand by the creditor shall Note: Contract is Voidable, remedy:
NOT be necessary in order that delay may annulment Annulment = contract is voidable
exist: (valid until annulled)
(pwedeng walang demand, pero delay and Remedy of Void contract= declaration of
debtor if eto ang reasons) nullity of contract
a. Law expressly so declares b. Dolo Incidente (incidental fraud) – fraud
b. Stipulation of the parties/obligation so committed during the performance of an
provides obligation, contract already exists. (Article
c. When demand would be useless 1170)
d. Time is of the essence Note: Contract is Valid, remedy: you can ask
e. Reciprocal obligations for damages

 DELAY (delay or mora) – delay incurred Article 1171 – you are not liable for a future
by debtor when the creditor demands. If fraud.
Article 1172 - the payment for damages may - Usury is now suspended or legally non-
be reduced if there is negligence because it existent. Parties are now free to stipulate any
was unintentional- the payment for damages amount of interest.
may not be reduced if there is fraud because
it was intentional and it involved malice. ARTICLE 1176
A. If there are back-rentals of arrearages,
Article 1173 when issuing receipts, indicate where the
Exerting proper diligence of a good father of received payment is applied. Otherwise, the
the family depends on the: presumption is all debt is paid.
1. Nature of object of the obligation (if the ARTICLE 1177
nature of object does not require the proper The creditor can go after the debtor of his
diligence of a good father of the family you debtor after exhausting every other means of
are not liable for damages) collecting the amount.
 Ex. Sand – does not need the proper
diligence of a good father of the family Example: A owns the apartment in which B is
Fluorescent light – requires the proper renting. B decides to lease it to bed spacers. If
diligence of a good father of the family B can’t pay rent, A can collect the amount
2. Circumstances of persons from B’s bed spacers.
 Ex. Security guard sleeping on a night
duty – liable of damages ARTICLE 1178
3. Circumstances of place All rights acquired in virtue of an obligation
 Ex. CM recto before vs. CM Recto now are generally transmissible.
4. Circumstances of time
 Ex. Car without headlights at night – 10 Special Kinds of Obligation (POCAF JS
liable for damages. DIO)

Article 1174 Pure Obligations


Fortuitous event – Force Majeure (act of man
Obligations with a period
or act of God)
 Ex. Eruption of Volcano Conditional Obligations
No one is to be held liable in the fortuitous
Alternative Obligations
event` Fortuitous event + Damages = Not
Liable Facultative Obligations
Not Fortuitous event + Damages = Liable
Joint Obligations
Requisites of a fortuitous event Solidary Obligations
1. The event must be independent of the
Divisible Obligations
debtor’s will.
2. The event could not be foreseen, or if Indivisible Obligations
foreseen, is inevitable.
Obligations with a penal clause
3. The event must be of such character as to
render it impossible for the debtor to comply
with his obligation in a natural manner.
I. PURE OBLIGATION
4. The debtor must be free from any
participation in, or aggravation of, the  No period 
creditor’s injury and that there is no
 No condition
concurrent negligence on his part.
 Immediately demandable
ARTICLE 1175- Usurious transactions s
II. OBLIGATION W/ A PERIOD – Future &
governed by special laws.
Usury Law – law that regulates the amount of CERTAIN event Examples :
interest the creditor should ask from the
•Everybody will die
debtor.
•I’ll give you P10k if Mr. X will die
•I’ll give you P10k if the sun shines tomorrow 2. Impossible – it shall ANNUL the
•I’ll give you P10k if Mr. X’s 60 year old father OBLIGATION.
dies. a. Legally – susceptible of happening but
•“on Christmas Day” “This Year” contrary to law, morals, good customs, public
•“little by little” “as soon as possible” “from order,/public policy.
time to time” “at any time I have the money”  Example: I will give you P20k if you kill
“In partial payments” “when I am in a your seatmate.
position to pay” NOTE: It is as if we did not have any
agreement, because the condition is illegal
therefore there will be no obligation to be
III. CONDITIONAL OBLIGATION – Future & made.
b. Physically – in nature of things, cannot
UNCERTAIN event; Past & Unknown to the
exist or cannot be undone.
parties.
 Example: Punta ka nga sa 5th floor, talon
ka sandal, dapat una paa pagbagsak mo.

Two Principal Kinds of Condition (as to


As to ORIGIN:
EFFECTS):
1. Potestative – depends upon the will of the
1. Suspensive Condition (Condition
creditor/ debtor.
Precedent/ Condition Antecedent) – the
 Examples:
fulfilment of the condition will give rise to the
a. I will give you this watch if I step out of this
obligation.
room right now.
 Example: I’ll give you P10k if you pass
NOTE: if the fulfilment of the condition is
this subject this semester.
based solely upon the will of the debtor, the
2. Resolutory Condition (Condition
CONDITIONAL OBLIGATION shall be VOID.
Subsequent) – the fulfilment of the condition
b.I will give you this watch if you step out of
will extinguish an obligation.
this room right now.
 Example: You can use my car until you
NOTE: if the fulfilment of the condition is
pass this subject
based upon the will of the creditor, then the
CONDITIONAL OBLIGATION is VALID.
As to FORM:
2. Casual – depends upon the 3rd person/
1. Express – condition is clearly stated.
chance.
2. Implied – condition is merely inferred.
 Examples:
a. I will give you this watch if the couple
As to POSSIBILITY:
outside went kissing.
1. Possible – the condition is capable of
NOTE: the fulfilment of the condition is based
fulfilment, legally and physically.
upon the will of the 3rd person, therefore the
CONDITIONAL OBLIGATION is VALID.
b.I will give you P10k if I will win the lottery 2. Indivisible - the condition is NOT
tomorrow. susceptible of partial performance.
NOTE: the fulfilment of the condition if based
upon the chance, therefore the CONDITIONAL KINDS of PERIOD
OBLIGATION is VALID 1. Suspensive Period (ex die) – the obligation
BEGINS only upon the arrival of the period.
3. Mixed – partly potestative & partly casual. Example: I promise to give you P10k if Mr. X
 Example: I will buy that car if I will be dies.
hired at San Miguel Corporation. 2. Resolutory Period (in diem) – the
NOTE: the fulfilment of the condition depends obligation is valid upto a day certain and
upon the debtor whether he will buy the car TERMINATES upon the arrival of the period.
or not, and it also depends upon the will of  Example: You can use my car until the
the 3rd person (San Miguel whether they will end of this year.
accept the debtor or not)
Three (3) Kinds of Obligation that are
As to MODE: IMMEDIATELY DEMANDABLE
1. Positive – the condition consists in the •PURE OBLIGATION
performance of an act. •RESOLUTORY CONDITION
2. Negative - the condition consists in the •RESOLUTORY PERIOD (In Diem)
omission of an act.

As to NUMBERS: (further discussion in the


next pages)
1. Conjunctive – there are several conditions
& ALL must be fulfilled
2. Disjunctive – there are several conditions
& ONLY ONE or SOME of them must be
fulfilled

As to DIVISILBILITY: (further discussion in the


next pages)
1. Divisible – the condition is susceptible of
partial performance.

You might also like