Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2016 - Kam-Kei Lam - Hydrogen Enriched Combustion Testing of Siemens Sgt-400 at High Pressure Conditions
2016 - Kam-Kei Lam - Hydrogen Enriched Combustion Testing of Siemens Sgt-400 at High Pressure Conditions
2016 - Kam-Kei Lam - Hydrogen Enriched Combustion Testing of Siemens Sgt-400 at High Pressure Conditions
GT2016
June 13 – 17, 2016, Seoul, South Korea
GT2016-57470
ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION
Following successful testing of the SGT-400 combustion Siemens Industrial Turbomachinery Ltd. (SITL) developed
system at atmospheric conditions with hydrogen enriched Dry Low Emissions (DLE) combustion system for ultra low
natural gas, a high pressure combustion test campaign was NOx emissions. This system operates in a lean premixed
carried out at the Siemens test facility in Lincoln UK. combustion mode, where the flame is anchored on the shear
Combustion performance at full engine operating conditions layers of the recirculation zones generated by a radial swirler.
was studied, with the aim of demonstrating the capability of the With more than twenty years of development and continuous
standard SGT-400 combustion hardware to fire fuels with optimization, the DLE system has been successfully
increased hydrogen content. Measurements consisted of: a pilot implemented in the Siemens gas turbine product range from ca.
tip thermocouple to monitor the risk of flashback; pressure 5MW (SGT-100) to 15MW (SGT-400) for both mechanical
sensors to capture the combustion dynamics signature; and drive and power generation applications.
emissions instrumentation measuring NO x and CO. The The SGT-400 combustor has a dual fuel DLE design for
combustor was also instrumented with thermocouples to operation on gas and liquid fuels, and achieves low emissions
monitor both the distribution of wall temperatures and potential over a wide range of fuel compositions. Previous development
locations of flashback when utilizing the highly reactive work has demonstrated the ability of the SGT-400 engine to
hydrogen enriched gas. The current paper reports the findings operate with calorific values ranging from 17.5 to 70MJ/Sm3
of the high pressure tests and compares with the atmospheric [1].
results that had been documented previously. Combustion As hydrogen is highly reactive, operation with high
behavior at full engine pressure and temperature was found to hydrogen content fuels is a common challenge to all DLE
be consistent with atmospheric conditions. Pilot tip temperature combustion designs.
increased with the hydrogen gas content due to the higher flame Hydrogen laminar flame speed is a few times higher than
speed. Combustion dynamics shifted to a higher frequency for natural gas flame at stoichiometric and atmospheric conditions.
the hydrogen enriched gas, and heat release fluctuations However, chemical kinetic evaluates that the difference is
increased. NOx emission also increased with the hydrogen reduced, but still significant, as pressure increases [2].
blending due to the enhanced fuel reactivity. The high pressure Increased flame speed raises the flashback risks when using
tests demonstrated that the SGT-400 standard DLE combustion hydrogen enriched gas. There are studies to investigate the
system can operate without risk of flashback for up to 20% vol flashback behavior of hydrogen mixed fuel. Flashback
hydrogen content. The next phase of the hydrogen program is to experimental studies of 50% hydrogen syngas at gas turbine
test a production engine using enriched gas and confirm its full like conditions up to 15bar and 674K air preheat are presented
operational characteristics. Extending the operational envelope in [3]. Pure hydrogen gas flashback at atmospheric pressure and
of the standard DLE combustion system to hydrogen contents up to 623K is investigated in [4].
above 20% vol is also of interest.
NOx Emissions
The characteristics of hydrogen-rich fuels have previously
been investigated in [5-7, 19]. Figure 8 shows NOx dependency
at different load conditions and at different hydrogen volume
percentage mixed with Natural Gas. Bubble size in the plot is
pilot fuel percent and the value is presented next to the bubble.
Furthermore, NOx emissions have been normalized by the
lowest value of the dataset used in the figure.
Across the load spectrum, there is significant change in the
combustor inlet pressure, temperature and outlet temperature.
This reflects in the NOx emission plot. Plot indicates that NOx
emission increases with hydrogen in the fuel.
However, NOx increase with different H2 percentage has
different slope at different pilot split. Premixing quality is
critical for low NOx emission in DLE combustion. At higher
Figure 6. COMBUSTION PARAMETERS (normalized to pure load increase in the NO x is steeper. Pilot split is kept lower at
methane). high loads and maximum premixing is allowed. Pilot split is
high at low load operation and results in a poor premixing
Figure 7 presents the laminar flame speed for at various quality. Due to the high pilot split, high heat release is likely to
different pressure and temperature conditions calculated using be in the vicinity of pilot face and at center line instead near to
CHEMKIN with the GRI3.0 mechanism [18]. Flame speed the of outer recirculation zone (see Fig. 2). Therefore, it is
tends to increase with increased blending of hydrogen in the expected that at different pilot split at different load conditions
fuel. Also, the flame speed increases with increasing pressure there should be different rate of NO x formation.
and temperature conditions. This behavior suggests a potential At lower load where there is a high pilot split, the increase
risk of flashback due to the increased flame speed. in NOx with added hydrogen is almost flat as indicated by 50%
and 20% load points. There is minor decrease in NOx emissions
with added hydrogen at 20% load. It is hypothesized that at this
low load, fuel and air premixing will be poor and local
equivalence ratio is above 1. With already fuel rich zone,
additional hydrogen does not contribute much change in local
heat release or temperature rise. This is also evident from tip
temperature thermocouple data. At 20% load, tip temperature
remains flat with hydrogen addition as shown in Fig. 12
suggesting thermal NOx may not a major factor.
Furthermore, at lower load where there is lower air
pressure and temperature, instead of thermal NO, prompt NO
could be more significant [20-21]. To prove and quantify above
hypotheses, 1D reactor model approach is being investigated.
CO Emissions
Figure 10 shows effect of load and the effect of hydrogen
on CO emissions. Values next to the bubble in the plot
represents pilot split as a percentage of total fuel. Additionally, Figure 11. SGT-400 WITH PILOT TIP THERMOCOUPLE.
CO emissions have been normalized by the lowest value of the
figure presented dataset. At full load condition CO emission is Figure 12 shows the effect of the pilot tip temperature with
very low and indistinguishable therefore, it was compared at different hydrogen volume percent. Values next to the bubble in
much lower load of 50% and 20%. For a gas turbine the plot represents pilot split as a percentage of total fuel.
combustion, as load or combustor exit temperature reduces CO Moreover, temperatures have been normalized by the lowest
emissions usually increases. This is due to overall reduction in value of the presented in the figure dataset. It is expected that
fuel-air ratio as well as relatively cold conditions. Therefore
0ms 0.5ms
1.5ms 2ms
Figure 16. COMBUSTOR WALL TEMPERATURES WITH 1.9%
PILOT SPLIT. Figure 17. HIGH SPEED CAMERA IMAGES DURING
ATMOSPHERIC TESTS WITH NATURAL GAS.
Combustion Dynamics
Two effects were noted with increasing hydrogen Figure 18 shows high speed images for 50% hydrogen
enrichment: the combustion dynamics shifted from the lower enriched gas mixtures. It exhibits some quite different
frequency band 1 to the higher frequency band 2; and the combustion behaviors compared to pure natural gas (see Fig.
amplitude of fluctuations was about 3 times higher for 17). The flame is chaotic with high local luminosity areas
hydrogen enriched mixtures than for pure natural gas. suggesting the location of stronger heat release. The variation
In order to understand why the high pressure hydrogen of the flame structure over time signifies the transient heat
combustion dynamics shifted to a higher frequency, two sets of release fluctuations. The H2 flame is more compact than the
pure natural gas and 50% hydrogen enriched gas combustion pure NG flame. This combines with the transient heat release
high speed camera images captured in the atmospheric rig test fluctuation is likely the reason for hydrogen enriched gas
[7] are reviewed. exciting dynamics at a higher tone [23]. CFD and
The operating conditions are the same for these images and thermoacoustic analysis is ongoing to validate this.
there is no filter applied to the high speed camera with the same
camera settings of 2000 shots per second and 40 s exposure
time. Both figures include four flame images in the frame rate
of 0.5ms.
Figure 17 presents images corresponding to pure NG
combustion. Flame luminosity is evenly distributed in different
frames indicating that the heat release is uniform. Comparison
of different time snapshots signifies that the flame structure is
steady.
1.5ms 2ms