Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Art Mutawalli-Final
Art Mutawalli-Final
Published in Kashmir University Law Review, Srinagar, Vol. XVII, No. XVII, 2010.
3
. Ameer Ali, Mohammadan Law, Vol. I, 1912, Reprint 1985, p. 441.
2
competent authority, to be the mutawalli of a Wakf and
includes any person who is a mutawalli of a Wakf
sajjjadanashin, amin or other person appointed by a mutawalli
to perform the duties of a mutawalli and save as otherwise
provided in this Act, any person, committee or corporation for
the time being managing or administering any Wakf or Wakf
property:4
Provided that no member of a committee or corporation
shall be deemed to be a mutawalli unless such member is an
office bearer of such committee or corporation;
Appointment of Mutawalli:
4
Wakf Act (Act 43 of 1995) 1995
3
better title to appoint a muezzin and imam for a mosque than
the congregation, unless his appointment is objectionable on
the ground that the persons nominated by him are unfit, as it is
stated in the Nawazil and Abu-Ilaisi”5
8
Mulla’s Principles of Muhammadan Law, 19th Edn. P. 173-174.
5
d. The reason why the minor is debarred from
appointment to the office of mutawalli is because of
his incapacity to discharge the functions of
mutawalli and to understand and comprehend the
concept and functioning of the Wakf. Nor a minor
can appoint his deputy to discharge his duties.
9
Ameer Ali, Mohammadan Law, Vol. I, Reprint 1985, P. 446.
6
would revert to him. If the person appointed be a bondsman,
the appointment would be valid both according to kyas and
istehsan for he possesses the personal capacity…… which the
minor does not. The same is the case of a zimmi (non –
Moselm fellow – subject). And should the Kazi remove the
bonds – man from the wilayat, he would not recover it on
emancipation, nor the other on his adopting Islam,” which is
different from the case of a minor”.10
12
Ibid. p. 449.
13
Ibid. p.450.
8
the Wakf board or by the wakif or in terms of Wakfnamah is
called a De-jure mutawalli.
Office of mutawalli:
Remuneration of mutawalli:
of Wakf property:
Removal of Mutawalli:
15
Radd-ul-Mukhtar, Vol. III, p. 638, as quoted by Ameer Ali,
Mohammadan Law, Vol. I. 1912, Reprint 1985, p.458.
11
The Radd-ul-Mukhtar states the principle thus: When a
mutawalli is appointed by the wakif, he will become
discharged on the death of the wakif. This is according to Abu
Yusuf’s rule on which is the fatwa, for such a mutawalli is
merely an agent on behalf of the wakif. But when the wakif
appoints a mutawalli “for his life and after his death,” such
mutawalli will not become discharged in consequence of the
wakif’s death.
16
Ibid, p.447.
12
The Mutawalli
17
AIR 1933 All 407.
18
AIR 1953 Mad 958.
13
properties and does not involve the discharge of duties
relating to religious or spiritual services or obligations.”
21
AIR 1932 Pat 33; (1932)11 Pat 288; 136 IC 417.
15
A Bench of the High Court of Madras has held in the
case of Khaji Mohamed Hossain v Majiday Mahmood Jamait
Managing Committee,22 that when a society has been
discharging the duties of mutawalli for a period of fourteen
years and has been in undisputed management of the mosque
in derogation of the right of the previous mutawalli it must be
deemed to have acquired the right of mutawalli by
prescription.
Accountability of mutawalli
27
Moideen Bibi Ammal v Rathnavelu Mudali AIR 1927 Mad 69.
18
Board to exercise power under section 63 of the Wakf
Act 1995 is maintained”.
28
AIR 2000 Kant. 141.
29
AIR, 2009 (NOC) 1393, Raj.
19
“Essentially it remains a question of fact, rather a
brass question of fact, as to whether from the
evidence, and / or material on record, a particular
property, is established to be a Wakf property, or in
other words dedication for Wakf purpose can be
inferred by user for a long period of time, it is shown
to be continued at least up to somewhere the first or
second decade of the 20th Century.
Thus, where evidence led on the side of plaintiff, was
found to be sufficient to prove the property to be
Wakf property, and there being no evidence in
rebuttal, on the side of the defendant, the property
would be termed as Wakf property”.
20