Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Amor. Jour. Bot. ;";1(1): 1-(;.19(;4.

CHROMOSOME NUMBERS IN NORTH AMERICAN LORANTHACEAE:


(ARCEUTHOBIUM, PHORADENDRON, PSITTACANTHUS,
STRUTHANTHUS) l.~
DELBERT WIENS
Department of Biology and Institute of Arctic and Alpine Research, Universitv of Colorado,
Boulder, Colorado

ABSTHACT
Chromosome numbers are reported from (;7 populations of 3(; taxa, mostly in Phoradendron,
The bask number is 14 in Phoradcndron and probably also in ..Irreuthobiuni. The 4 species of
Struiluuuh.u« for which chromosome numbers are recorded suggest that the basic number is 8. Num-
bers of n = 8 and n = 10 have been reported for Psitlacanth.un, In Phoradcndron. the 22 taxa
examined are all diploid, although 1 instance of polyploidy was discovered. Objects interpreted as
supernumerary chromosomes were discovered in a number of species of Phoradcrulron; no evidence
of sex chromosomes previously reported in Phoradendron. was observed. The Lorunthaooae have
chromosomes comparnhle in size to the largest in the plant kingdom.

I'm; LOnAN'l'HACEAE is composed essentially of approximate dates at which meiosis occurs in the
woody, pan-tropical plants parasitic on the aerial species examined may be determined from Table 1.
portions of vascular plants. Some genera, however, One anomalous situation was discovered in the
have representatives extending well into the typical form of A. uaqinaium occurring in central
temperate regions, e.g., Phorodendrcn and Vise1l1n. Mexico, Staminate material of this form was
Arccuihobium. occurs essentially in the temperate undergoing meiosis in August; however, in Color-
regions of the northern hemisphere. Psitiacanihus ado forma cnjpiopodum undergoes meiosis in
and Struihanthus are restricted primarily to the March,
American tropics. Mm-nons-e-Chromosomc numbers were deter-
The known information on chromosome num- mined in microsporoeytes;" except in 2 instances
bers in the Loranthaceae has been summarized where dividing tapetal cells were utilized. Material
by Gill and Hawksworth (19Gl), who list the was fixed in ;1: 1 absolute alcohol and acetic acid.
chromosome numbers of 22 species occurring in Anthers were squashed and stained in acetocar-
11 genera. The family contains approximately mine. The chromosomes stain deeply and rapidly
1,100 species and perhaps :30 genera (Lawrence, and there is no cytoplasmic staining.
HJ;"j1). In the present study ()7 chromosome A list of species for which chromosome numbers
numbers are reported for ;H species in 4 genera. were determined and the collection data are
Heretofore, Phoradendron serotinum (= Ph. flaoe- summarized in Table 1. The nomenclature em-
secns) appears to be the only member of the ployed in Phoraderuiron. and Arceuthobium is that
family whose chromosomes have been studied in of Wiens (1DG4) and Gill (Hl;jij), respectively.
detail (Baldwin and Speese, 1%7). Voucher specimens are deposited in the Rancho
In Phoraderulron; microsporogenesis begins ap- Santa Ana Botanic Carden Herbarium. The
proximately 2-:j months before flowering and is drawings of chromosomes were prepared with the
generally completed by anthesis; however, in rare aid of a camera lucida.
instances dividing pollen mother cells may still be lb,suvfs AND DISCUSSION-The chromosome
found in the youngest buds of the inflorescence numbers determined in Phoradendron are, with 1
when the first flowers open. In the species of exception, n = 14. The chromosome number of
Arccuihobium. studied, the pollen mother cells the species of A rcciuhobium examined also was
begin to divide approximately 1 month before determined to be n = 14, and no species with
anthesis, except in A. americanum, which under- n = l;j, as reported by Pisek (1D24), were found.
goes meiosis during the summer and flowers in The numbers observed in A rceuihobium. are in
the succeeding spring. Mierosporogenesis probably agreement with those of Dowding (1D;n) who
continues over a period of about :1 weeks. The first reported n = 14 in A. americanurn. The
chromosome numbers determined in Struihanthu«
1 Received for publication Januarv 1 J, 1!Hi3. Based on a
(n = 8, 2n = Hi) are the same as those reported
portion of a dissertation submitted to the Claremont by Covas (lD49) for the South American species,
Graduate School in partial fulfillment of the requirements S. angust~folius (Griseb.) Haum,
for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy.
2 This work was supported, in part, by a grant from the 3 I am indebted to Drs. William M. Klein and T. Paul
society of Sigma Xi. Maslin for making several collections of buds.
[The .TOURNAL for November-December (50: 965-10(1) was issued November "27, 1!J63]
AMERICAN .JOURNAL OF BOTANY, Vol, 51: No.1, 19(;4

1
2 AMERICAN JOURNAL OF BOTANY [Vol. 51

TABLE 1. Chromosome numbers in Arceuthobium, Phoradendron, Psittacanthus and Struthanthus.

Species Chromo no. Supern. chromo Voucher collection data

A. americanum Nutt. ex Engelm. n = 14 COLORADO. Boulder Co.: near Nederland.


Wiens 2966. 8/7/G1.
A. campylopodum Engelm. forma campylo- n = 14 CALIFORNIA. San Bernardino Co.: Big
podum Bear Lake. Wiens 2741. 7/9/GO.
A. campylopodum f. cyanocarpum (A. Nelson) n = 14 COLORADO. Boulder Co.: Ward. Wiens
Gill 2926. 7/6/61.
A. campylopodum f. divaricatum (Engelm.) n = 14 CALIFORNIA. Inyo Co.: Whippoorwill
Gill Flats, on Big Pine-Saline Valley Rd.
Wiens 27.40- G/18/60.
A. vaginatum (Willd.) Presl. f. vaginatum n = 14 MEXICO. Veracruz: south of Perote. Wiens
(Fig.2B) 2574.8/18/59.
A. oaqinaium f. cryptopodum (Engelm.) Gill n = 14 COLORADO. Boulder Co.: near Boulder.
Wiens 2802. 3/23/G1.
Ph. bolleanuni (Seem.) Eichler, subsp. n = 27 CALIFORNIA. Sonoma Co.: ncar Monte
densum (Torr.) Wiens Rio. Wiens 2723. 6/14/GO.
Ph. bolleanum subsp. densum n= 14 Five populations"
Ph. bolleonum subsp. pauciflorum (Torr.) n = 14 2 CALIFORNIA. Los Angeles Co.: Mt. Baldy
Wiens ski area, San Gabriel Mts. Wiens 2461.
5/27/59.
Ph, brachystachyum (DC.) Nutt. n 14 MEXICO. Morelos: lava fields north of
Coajomulco on toll rd. to Mexico City.
Wiens 2530. 8/15/59.
Ph. colijornicum Nutt. n = 14 2-8 CALIFORNIA. San Bernardino Co.: near
Barstow. Wiens 2662. 10/14/59.
Ph. calyculatum Trclease n= 14 MEXICO. Chiapas: IG miles se. of San
Cristobal. Wiens 2976. (coli. by T. Paul
Maslin, 7/23/Gl).
Ph. capitellaiuni Torr. ex Trelease n 14 ARIZONA. Yavapai Co.: near Sedona. Wiens
2763. 9/13/60.
Ph. qoleotiii Trelease n 14 MEXICO. Puebla: ncar Zacatecas, w. of
Perote on hwy. 140. Wiens 2581. 8/18/59.
Ph. quazumae Trelease n = 14 MEXICO. Sinaloa: hwy. 15, n. side of
Mazatlan. Wiens 2495. 8/11/59.
Ph. [uniperinuni Engelm. subsp. juniperinum n = 14 Nine populations':
Ph. juniperinum subsp. libocedri (Engelm.) n = 14 CALIFORNIA. El Dorado Co.: Institute of
Wiens Forest Genetics, Placerville. Wiens 2732.
G/17/GO.
Ph. [uniperinum subsp. libocedri n 14 CALIFORNIA. El Dorado Co.: near Kyburz,
hwy. 50. Wiens 2734. 6/17/GO.
Ph. [uniperinum subsp. libocedri n 14 CALIFORNIA. San Bernardino Co.: Stock-
ton Flat, Lytle Creek Canyon. Wiens 2484.
G/17/fi9.
Ph. lanaium Trelease n 14 3-4 MEXICO. Queretaro: Ileal' Cadereyta. Wiens
2595. 8/20/59.
Ph. minulijolium Urban n = 14 MEXICO. Veracruz: ca. 3 miles S. of Perote.
Wiens 2578. 8/18/59.
Ph. nervosum Oliver n 14 MEXICO. Chiapas: 2G miles so. of San
Crist6bal. Wiens 2080. (colI. by T. Paul
Maslin, 7/2G/61).
Ph. puberuluni Trelease n 14 2 MEXICO. Nayarit: ca. 20 miles s. of Topic
on hwy. 15, Wiens 2506.8/12/59.
Ph. puheruluni n 14 MEXICO. Jalisco: ncar Magdalena on hwy,
15. Wiens 2511.8/13/59.
Ph. reichenbachianum Oliver n 14 MEXICO. Morclos: ncar Temple of Tcpox-
tlan, Tepoxtlan. Wiens 2531. 8/15/59.
Ph. robinsonii Urban n 14 2-3 MEXICO. Puobla: near Tehuac.in. Wiens
2551. 8/17 /.~9.
Ph. schumannii Trelcasc n 14 MEXICO. Durango: hwy. 40, ncar km. 10LO
btwn. Durango and El Saito. Wiens 2632.
8/23/59.
Ph. tomenlosum (DC.) Engelm. subsp. n 14 Four populationss
tomeniosum.
Ph. tomeniosum subsp. macrophsflluni n 14 Five populations"
(Engclm.) Wiens
January, 1964] WIENS--LORANTHACEAE

TABLE I.-Continued

Species Chromo no. Supern. chromo Voucher collection data

Ph. uelutinuni (DC.) Nutt. n = 14 3 MEXICO. Mexico: ca. 10 miles e. of Toluca


on hwy. 15. Wiens 2529. 8/14/59.
Ph. uelutinuni n = 14 MEXICO. Puebla: ca. 20 miles n. of Tehuacrin
on hwy. 150. Wiens 2553. 8/17/59.
Ph. uillosum (Nutt.) Nutt. subsp. uillosum. n = 14 Eight populations"
Ph. oillosuni subsp. coryae (Trelease) Wiens n = 14 ARIZONA. Coconino Co.: Oak Creek Can-
yon. Klein 1470. 7/26/60.
Ph. oillosum subsp. coryae n = 14 NEW MEXICO. Socorro Co.: rd. to South
Baldy Peak, Magdalena Mts. Wiens 2661.
8/21'/59.
Ph. villosum subsp, flacum (1. M. Johnston) n = 14 MEXICO. Durango: km. 995 btwn. Durango
Wiens and EI Saito on hwy. 40. Wiens 2625.
1'/23/59.
Ph. »illosum subsp. flauum n = 14 MEXICO. Durango: km. 1010 btwn. Dur-
ango and EI Saito, on hwy. 40. Wiens 2630.
8/23/59.
Ps. americanus (Jacq.) Mart. (Fig. 2A). n = 8 MEXICO. Mexico: Tepetlixpa. Wiens 2538.
8/16/59.
Ps, calsjculaius (DC.) D. Don 2n = 16 MEXICO. Sinaloa: hwy. 15, ca. 30 miles s, of
Navajoa. Wiens 2491. 8/10/59.
S. inconspicuous (Benth.) StandI. n = 8 MEXICO. Sinaloa: hwy. 15, ca. 40 miles n.
of Mazathin. Wiens 2494. 8/ll/59.
S. micropliullus (HBK) D. Don (Fig.2C). ti = 8 MEXICO. Michoacan: hwy. 15, near Santa
Rosa, ca. 50 miles e. of Morelia. Wiens
2522.8/14/59.
S. »enetus (HBK) Blume 2n = 16 MEXICO. Sinaloa: hwy. 15, near San
Lorenzo, s, of Culiacrin, Wiens 2498.
8/11 /59.

• CALIFORNIA. Inyo Co.: Whippoorwill Flats, on Big Pine-Saline Valley Rd. Wiens 2739.6/18/60. San Bernardino
Co.: near junct. of hwy. 138 and Big Pines Rd. Wiens 2681.4/30/60. (Fill:. 2E). ARIZO~A. Yavapai Co.: near Sedona.
Wiens 26.91.5/6/60. Gila Co.: near Pine. Wiens 2706.5/7/60. MEXICO. Coahuila: ca. 40 miles s. of Saltillo on hwy. 57.
Wiens 2607. 1'/21/59.
b CALIFORNIA. El Dorado Co.: hwy. 89 ca. 5 miles s, of junct. with hwy. !i0. Wiens 2785.6/17/60. Alpine Co.: near
Monitor Pass. Wiens 2786. 6/17/60. Inyo Co.: Whippoorwill Flats, on Big Pine-Saline Valley Rd. Wiens 2788. 6/18/60.
San Bernardino Co.: Big Bear Lake. Wiens 2485.6/25/59. ARIZONA. Coconino Co.: Ashfork. Wiens 2839. 5/25/61.
Coconino Co.: Sedona. Wiens 2697 ..5/7/61. Yavapai Co.: 13 miles s. of Camp Verde on rd. to Pine. Wiens 2714. 5/7/60.
Pin'a Co.: rd. to Mt. Lemmon. Wiens 2703.5/7/60. NEW MEXICO. Taos Co.: ncar Taos. Klein 1483.7/27/60.
c MEXICO. Durango: ncar La Cuesta on hwy. 4!i btwn. Durango and Parral, Wiens 2646.8/25/59. Durango: ca. 20
miles w. of Le6n Guzman on hwy. 40. Wiens 2620. 8/22/59. Coahuila: ca. 50 miles e. of Torreon on hwy. 40. Wiens 2616.
8/22/!i9. Coahuila: ca. 28 miles e. of Saltillo on hwy. 60. Wiens 2613.8/21/59.
d CALIFORNIA. Los Angeles Co.: Cobal Canyon, near Claremont. Wiens 2761. 9/3/60. San Bernardino Co.: Cajon
Pass eamporound. Wiens 2668. 10/14/59. ARIZONA. Coconino Co.: Sedona. Wiens 2764.9/13/60. TEXAS. EI Paso
Co.: near Anthony. Wiens 2660.8/28/.59. MEXICO. Coahuila: Le6n Guzman, w. of Torre6n on hwy. 40. Wiens 2617.
8/22/59.
p CALIFOR!'\IA. Butte Co.: ncar Paradise. Wiens 2726.6/15/60. Marin Co.: ca. 3 miles n, of San Rafael on hwy. 101.
H1'en' 2722.6/14/60. EI Dorado Co.: ea. 15 miles w. of Placerville on hwy. 50. Wiens 2781.6/17/60. EI Dorado Co.:
r-oar Kyburz on hwy. !i0. Wiens 2738. 6/17/60. San Luis Obispo Co.: ca. 10 miles e. of Paso Robles on hwy. 466. Wiens
2,20. (l/12/CO. Kprn Co.: ncar Frazier Mtn. Park. Wiens 2718. 6/12/60. Los Angeles Co.: Cobal Canyon, near Clare-
mer t. Wiens 2716.5/29/60. San Bernardino Co.: near Running Springs, City Creek Rd. Wiens 2742.7/10/60.

In Psittacanthus, numbers of n = 8 and 2n = 16 Trelease (1916), in his monograph of Phoraden-


were recorded. This differs from the report by dron, subdivided the genus into 2 primary divisions
Covas and Schnack (1946) that n = 10. Their without definite rank: (1) the "Aequatoriales"
material (Ps. cunefolius Blume I, however, was (with primarily a tropical distribution I, possessing
also of South American origin. King (1961), in a cataphylls, generally glabrous, and sometimes
study of 2 Mexican species, Ps. auriculatus monoecious; and (2) the "Boreales," (occurring
(Oliver) Eichler and Ps. calyculatus (DC.) D. Don, predominantly in more northerly temperate
also reported a number of n = 10. The latter regions), without cataphylls, often pubescent, and
species is the same in which I determined that always dioecious, Four species analyzed in this
2n = If>. More recently, however, King (pel's. study, Ph. guazumae, Ph. nertosum, Ph. reichen-
comm.) has also observed numbers of n = 8. bachianum and Ph. schumanii, are members of
4 AMEHICAN JOURNAL OF BOTANY [Vol. ;')1

the "Aequatoriales," but only Ph. guazumae is restricted to the Sonoran region and is subjected
monoecious. All possess the same chromosome to greater extremes in aridity than most mistle-
number characteristic of the "Boreales," i.e., 1-1 toes. Muntzing (1!l58) and Mooring (J9nO) report
pairs. that frequencies of these chromosomes increase in
Polyploidy-One polyploid individual (n = 27) populations occurring in arid regions and suggest
of Ph. bolleanum subsp. densum (Table 1) was that they possess some adaptive significance.
discovered on Cupressus in the Coast Ranges of More information on the frequency of these
northern California. This mistletoe occurs also on chromosomes in this and some other species would
other Cuprcssus stands in the coast ranges and be desirable. For example, Ph. tomeniosum. subsp.
foothills of the Sierra 1\ evada of California. Addi- macrophullum (=Ph.jlal'escensvar. macrophyllum)
tional work will be necessary to clarify the cyto- is partially sympatric with Ph. calijornicum; but
logical condition of these populations, since Ph. in other parts of its range, viz. the central valley of
bolleanum subsp, densum is diploid in other parts of California, it occurs under somewhat more mesic
its range (Table 1). Juniperus is the predominant conditions. The frequency of supernumerary
host of this mistletoe from southeastern Oregon chromosomes in different parts of the range of
to northern Chihuahua, but in central Arizona it this species could be of interest.
again parasitizes Cupressue; however these popu- Billings' sex-chromosome hypothesis-Billings
lations are also diploid (Table 1). (J 9:32) reported a unique sex-determining mech-
Supernumerary chromosomes-Structures inter- anism for higher plants (an XO type) in Phora-
preted as supernumerary chromosomes were dis- dendron. His study was based on 2 dioecious
covered in Phoradendron (Fig. 1). The number species, Ph. villosum subsp. oitloeum and Ph.
and systematic distribution of these chromosomes tomentosum subsp. macrophyllum occurring in
are listed in Table 1. Their staining properties southern California. He counted an even number
appear to be heterochromatic. The number present of chromosomes in the somatic cells of pistillate
in dividing pollen mother cells is variable, but the plants (2n = 20). However, in the vegetative cells
mode is 2. Supernumerary chromosomes were not of staminate individuals he described the presence
observed in the other genera examined. of another chromosome which he interpreted as a
The highest number of supernumeraries noted sex-chromosome. At metaphase I of microsporo-
(ca. 8) occurs in Ph. calijornicum, This species is genesis he recognized 1 l associations, one repre-
senting a univalent. At anaphase of thehrst
division, 11 chromosomes moved to one pole and
10 to the other. Later Billings (J 9::l:·n examined the
chromosome numbers during megasporogenesis
and reported a consistent number of n = 10.
Baldwin and Speese (1!l!i7) questioned the
validity of Billings' interpretation on the basis of
their cytological work on the eastern mistletoe,
Ph. seroiinum: Current work on the same species
which Billings studied shows that n = 14, and no
structures resembling univalents were detected
during meiosis; however, no pistillate material was
examined cytologically nor have chromosome
numbers been determined in the somatic tissues
of either male or female plants of these species.
No attempt has been made to correlate the
putative supernumerary chromosomes with a
present or past sex-determining function.
Chromosome size-Stebbins (1950) stated that
the genera Trillium and Paris have the largest
chromosomes in the plant kingdom. Textbooks of
cytology, e.g., Sharp (194;·n and Swanson (J !);,,)7) ,
have credited the monocotyledons with having
generally larger chromosomes than dicotyledons.
The dicotyledonous genus Paeonia, however, has
been recognized as an exception. Turner (1!);")8)
reported large chromosomes in Krameria and gave
I a cursory review of other plants with large chromo-
somes. Covas and Schnack (1!)46) suggested that
Peiuacanthus possessed the largest chromosomes
FIG. I.-Putative supernumerary' chromosomes at in the angiosperms. Baldwin and Speese (1\)57)
prometaphase II in Ph. bolleanuni subsp. pauciflornm, first demonstrated the large chromosomes in
XIOOO. Phorodendron, The metaphase-I associations of
January, H)(H] WIENS-LORANTHACEAl-J 5

't
'I"~
eA .-.,
11!"
.. ~~
o ." F

~, 4~~
G I 20jJ. I H
Fig. 2. Comparative size of chromosomal associations at metaphase I in plants with large chromosomes.-Fig. 2A.
Psittacanthus alllericanus.-Fig. 2B. Arceuihobium oaqinoiuni forma vaginat1l1l/..-Fig. 2C. Siruihantlius microphsjllusr-«
Fig. 2D. Paeonia calijornica (2 chains of 4 plus 1 bivalent).-Fig. 2E. Phoradendron. bolleanu.ni subsp. densum.-Fig. 2F.
Krameria grayi.-Fig. 2G. Tradescantia paludosa.-Fig. 2H. Liliuui michiganense.-FitJ;. 21. Trillium ooatum, All figures
X ()7ii.
6 AMEmCAN JOURNAL OF BOTANY [Vol. 51

some plants recognized as having large chromo- DOWDING, E. S. 1931. Floral morphology of Arceutho-
somes are contrasted with some loranthaceous biurn arnericanurn. Bot. Gaz. 41: 42-51.
genera in Fig. 2. All mounts were prepared accord- GILL, L. S. 1935. Arceuthobiurn in the United States.
ing to the general methods previously described.' Trans. Conn. Aead. Arts and Sci. 32: 111-245.
- - - , AND F. G. HAWKSWORTH. 1961. The mistletoes:
Most Loranthaceae, and Krameria, are woody A literature review. Tech. Bull. No. 1242. U.S. Dept.
perennials and represent exceptions to the ob- Agric., Forest Service, Washington, D.C.
servation (Stebbins, 1938) that woody plants KING, R. M. 1961. Meiotic chromosome numbers for
generally have small chromosomes. Stebbins sug- two species of the genus Psittacanthus (Loranthaceae).
gested that mechanical difficulties might arise Southw. Nat. 6: 48-49.
during mitosis if long chromosomes had to divide LAWRENCE, G. H. M. 1951. Taxonomy of vascular
in the relatively short transverse dimensions of plants. The Macmillan Co., New York.
the cambial initials. MOORING, J. S. 1960. A cytogenetic study of Clarkia
Chromosomal aberrations-Chromosomal aber- unguiculata II. Supernumerary chromosomes. Amer,
rations are detected occasionally in Phoradendron. Jour. Bot. 47: 847-854.
MUNTZING, A. 1958. A new category of chromosomes.
The most common are anaphase bridges which are Proc. 10th Internatl. Congr. Genet., 453-467.
sometimes accompanied by acentric fragments, PISEK, A. 1924. Antherenentwicklung und meiotische
suggesting that they are the result of crossing-over Teilung bei der Wacholdermistel [Arceuthobiurn
in inversion heterozygotes. Micronuclei are de- oxycedri (DC.) M. B.]: Antherenbau und Chromo-
tected occasionally at interkinesis and telophase somenzahlen von Loranihus europaeus Jacq. Sitzungs-
II. ber. Akad. Wiss. Wien, Math.-Nat. KI. Abt. I. 133:
1-15.
LITERATURE CITED SHARP, L. W. 1943. Fundamentals of cytology. Me-
Graw-Hill, New York.
BALDWIN, J. T., JR., AND B. M. SPEESE. 1!l57. Phora- STEBBINS, G. L., JR. 1938. Cytological characteristics
dendron flauescens: chromosomes, seedlings, and hosts. associated with different growth habits in the dicotyle-
Amer. Jour. Bot. 44: 136-140. dons. Amer. Jour. Bot. 25: 189-]9S.
BILLINGS, F. H. 1932. Microsporogenesis in Phoraden- 1950. Variation and evolution in plants.
dron. Ann. Bot. 46: 979-992. Columbia University Press, New York.
1933. Development of embryo-sac in Phora- SWANSON, C. P. 1957. Cytology and cytogenetics.
dendron. Ann. Bot. 47: 261-278. Prentice-Hall, Inc., Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey.
Co VAS, G. 1949. Estudios cariologicos en anthofitas III. TRELEASE, W. 1916. The genus Phoradendron: a
Darwinians 9; 158-162. monographic revision. University of Illinois Press,
- - - , AND B. SCHNACK. 1946. Numero de chromo- Urbana, Illinois.
somas en antofitas de la region de Cuya (Republica TURNER, B. L. 1!l58. Chromosome numbers in the
Argentina). Rev. Argentina Agron. 13: 152-166. genus Krameria: evidence for familial status. Rhodoru
60: 101-106.
4 Slides of Trilliuni and Tradescantia were supplied WIENS, D. 1964. Revision of the acataphyllous species
through the courtesy of Dr. Sherwin Carlquist. of Phonulendron: Brittonia (in press).

You might also like