Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Indian Journal of Biotechnology

Vol 14, January 2015, pp 81-86

Simultaneous production of ligninolytic enzymes by a temperature and


pH tolerant strain of Aspergillus niger under different
cultural conditions
Kusum Dhakar1, Rinu Kooliyottil1, Archana Joshi2 and Anita Pandey1*
1
Biotechnological Applications, G B Pant Institute of Himalayan Environment and Development, Kosi-Katarmal
Almora 263 643, India
2
Mody Institute of Technology and Science, Lakshmangarh, Sikar 332 311, India

Received 14 March 2013; revised 27 September 2013; accepted 3 November 2013

Ligninolytic activity, represented by laccase, lignin peroxidase (LiP) and manganese peroxidase (MnP), of a temperature
and pH tolerant strain of Aspergillus niger isolated from a temperate location in the Indian Himalayan Region (IHR), has
been studied under different cultural (physico-chemical & nutritional) conditions. In plate assays, the fungus exhibited
ligninolytic activity at wide range of temperature (5-45°C) and pH (3.5-9.5). In quantitative estimations, carried out at 15, 25
and 35°C, production of laccase was favoured by low temperature (15°), while production of LiP and MnP were favoured by
higher temperatures (25 & 35°C). At optimum growth temperature (25°C), laccase production was the maximum at 7.5 pH.
LiP and MnP production was favoured between 7.5 to 9.5, and 5.5 to 9.5 pH, respectively. Amongst nutritional sources,
nitrogen sources were recorded as better enhancers for enzyme production, followed by vitamins and carbon sources. Folic
acid (0.01%) was also found to be a good enhancer for production of all the three enzymes.

Keywords Aspergillius niger, ligninolytic, Indian Himalayan Region (IHR), temperature/pH tolerant

Introduction the complex and the recalcitrant polymer lignin.


Decomposition is broadly defined as the physical, Ligninolytic activity is associated with three major
chemical and biological process that transforms enzymes, viz., lignin peroxidase (LiP), manganese
complex organic materials into increasingly simpler peroxidase (MnP) and laccase. Peroxidases possess
forms. In forest ecosystems, decomposition of leaf heme structure and require H2O2 for catalysis, while
litter is an important factor controlling nutrient LiP has the ability to oxidize non-phenolic structures
cycling and formation of soil. In high altitudes of related to lignin. Moreover, MnP facilitates the
mountain ecosystems, the degradation process is slow decomposition by generating phenoxy radicals
and takes longer period due to the prevalence of low from phenolic rings. Laccases are multicopper
temperature. Thus, occurrence of temperature tolerant oxido-reductase glycoproteins with the ability to
microorganisms, psychrotolerants in particular, in oxidize phenolics as well as the non-phenolic
such environments plays important role toward compounds in presence of the mediators, such
sustainability of soil health1-3. Fungi, mainly as, ABTS (2,2'-azino-bis 3-ethylbenzothiazoline-6-
basidiomycetes, are well known for their contribution sulphonic acid) and hydroxybenzotriazole (HBT)7.
in litter decomposition and nutrient release. However, Besides ecological importance, these enzymes are
dominance and contribution of ascomycetous fungi also known for their biotechnological applications,
has been recognized for various biological processes such as, in food, pharmaceuticals, textiles and
under low temperature environments in recent synthetic chemistry8. Such applications have led to the
literature4-6. increasing demand of these enzymes at industrial
Ligninolytic enzymes, a group of highly versatile scale. The production of these enzymes can be greatly
enzymes, are known for their role in degradation of affected by modifying physico-chemical and
nutritional conditions9.
—————— The aim of the present study was to determine the
*Author for correspondence
Tel: +91-5962-241041; Fax: +91-5962-241150 ligninolytic activity (due to laccase, LiP & MnP) of a
anita@gbpihed.nic.in temperature tolerant fungus, initially isolated from the
82 INDIAN J BIOTECHNOL, JANUARY 2015

soil sample collected from a temperate location in Effect of Physico-chemical Conditions on Production of
Indian Himalayan Region (IHR), under different Ligninolytic Enzymes
cultural conditions. The production of ligninolytic enzymes was
investigated at 3 temperatures (15, 25 & 35°C). At
Materials and Methods 15°C, the readings were recorded at weekly intervals
up to 5 wk. At 25 and 35°C, the readings were
Fungal Culture recorded at every 3rd d up to 15 d. For determination
Fungal culture was taken from the microbial of effect of pH on production of ligninolytic enzymes,
culture collection that has been developed in the the experiments were conducted at 25°C in 4 sets,
Microbiology Laboratory of G B Pant Institute of maintaining pH of the media at 3.5, 5.5, 7.5 and 9.5.
Himalayan Environment and Development, Almora Enzyme activity was estimated at 12th d of incubation,
(Uttarakhand), India. The fungus was originally in each case.
isolated from the soil sample collected from a
temperate location in IHR. The soil pH at sampling Effect of Nutritional Supplements on Production of
Ligninolytic Enzymes
site ranged from 4.5 to 6.5. The location experiences
Effect of carbon sources, replacing glucose by
heavy rainfall and snowfall as well, maintaining low
arabinose, fructose, galactose, lactose, maltose,
temperature up to subzero levels. The fungal culture
trehalose, pectin, starch, cellulose and chitin; nitrogen
was maintained on potato dextrose agar (PDA) slants
sources, replacing ammonium nitrate by ammonium
at 4°C, following sub-culture at prescribed intervals.
sulfate, ammonium acetate, ammonium ferrous
The fungal isolate (Aspergillus niger) under study has
sulfate, potassium nitrate, urea, casein, yeast extract,
been accessioned by Indian Type Culture Collection,
peptone and allylthiourea (0.2% each, separately); and
Indian Agricultural Research Institute, New Delhi,
five vitamin supplements [pyridoxine, B1, biotin,
India (Acc. No. ITCC2546). The description of the
nicotinic acid & folic acid (0.01% each, separately)]
site and properties of the fungal isolate have been
were studied on the production of lignin degrading
reported earlier6.
enzymes. Vitamins were added in the medium at 5th d
Qualitative and Quantitative Estimation of Ligninolytic of incubation. The readings were taken following
Activity 12 d incubation at 25°C.
Modified Kirk and Farrell medium10 was used for All the experiments were conducted in triplicate
the production of lignin degrading enzymes. The and the mean values with standard deviation were
medium contained (g/L): malt extract 2.0, glucose shown as the error bars.
2.0, NH4NO3 2.0, Na2HPO4 0.26, KH2PO4 0.26,
MgSO4.7H2O 0.5, CuSO4.5H2O 0.01, CaCl2.2H2O Results and Discussion
0.006, FeSO4.7H2O 0.005, ZnSO4.7H2O 0.0005, Plate assays revealed the production of ligninolytic
Na2MoO4 0.00002, MnSO4.H2O 0.00009 and H3BO3 enzymes at wide range of temperature (4-35°C) by
0.00007. Plate assay was done by supplementing A. niger. In quantitative estimations conducted at
0.35 g/L ABTS. The inoculated plates were observed 3 temperatures, the production of laccase was favoured
for development of green colour zone around the by low temperature. The maximum (9.2±1.8 U/L)
colony, following 7 d of incubation. production of laccase was estimated at 15°C on 21st d
For quantitative estimation, 50 mL medium of incubation, following decline to 4.2±1.1 U/L
(pH=5.0±0.5) was prepared in 250 mL Erlenmeyer (35th d). At 25 and 35°C, the production of laccase
flasks and 5 mm disc of 7-d-old fungal culture grown was the maximum (8.0±1.0 & 2.4±0.7 U/L,
on PDA was used for inoculation. Laccase activity respectively) at 12th and 6th d, respectively. Contrary
was determined by using ABTS (ε420=36000 M-1cm-1)11 to these results, production of LiP and MnP was
at 420 nm in citrate-phosphate buffer (pH=3.0). favoured by higher temperatures (25 & 35°C).
LiP activity was assayed by veratryl alcohol The maximum LiP was produced (165.3±15.7 U/L)
(ε310=9300 M-1 cm-1)12. MnP activity was determined at 25°C at 9th d of incubation, then declined to
by reading the formation of stable tartrate 91.1±10.6 U/L (15th d). A similar trend of LiP activity
complex through the oxidation of Mn+2 to Mn+3 was recorded at 35°C. At 15°C, the maximum LiP
(ε238= 6500 M-1 cm-1)12 in tartrate buffer (pH=4.5). activity (137.0±7.8 U/L) was recorded at 21st d,
Enzyme activity was defined as 1 µM of substrate declined to 96.6±9.5 U/L at 35th d of incubation. The
oxidized per minute under the given conditions. production of MnP was also favoured by higher
DHAKAR et al: LIGNINOLYTIC ENZYMES BY TEMPERATURE AND pH TOLERANT A. NIGER 83

temperatures, being maximum (2326.9±226.7 U/L) at the minimum MnP production (1439.1±164.5 U/L)
35°C at 12th d of incubation and then declined to was recorded at pH 3.5 (Table 2). The pH of the
2022.4±217.2 U/L at 15th d. The production of MnP medium is known to alter the structure of catalytic site
was higher at 25° in comparison to 15°C. Results on of enzymes affecting the activity. In Rhizoctonia
the production of all the 3 enzymes are presented in praticola, pH 7.5 has been reported optimum for the
Table 1. production of laccase16. In general, acidic pH is
The fungus under study (A. niger) has been known to be more suitable for the production of the
reported to tolerate a wide range of temperature enzymes17. In the present study, the production of
with its optimum growth in mesophilic range6. ligninolytic enzymes has been recorded at a much
Importance of temperature in production of wider range of pH.
bioactive molecules by various fungi, initially The effect of carbon sources on production of
isolated from low temperature environments, ligninolytic enzymes is presented in Fig. 1. Among
has been reported in recent years13-14. In the present 10 carbon sources used at 0.2 % concentration,
study, the production of different ligninolytic arabinose, trehalose and cellulose were found to be
enzymes varied with respect to temperature. While the best enhancers of laccase production (10.6±1.5,
the production of laccase was favoured by 8.9±1.6 & 10.0±2.1 U/L, respectively). Other carbon
psychrophilc range, production of LiP and MnP sources, namely, fructose, galactose, lactose, maltose,
was better under mesophilic temperature range. pectin, starch and chitin resulted in inhibitory effect
Temperature for optimum production of laccase on laccase production. Fructose, maltose, trehalose,
has been reported in between 25 to 30°C15. pectin and chitin were found to be the effective
The production of the ligninolytic enzymes enhancers (100.5±7.1, 97.3±9.2, 91.2±10.6, 92.1±12.9
also varied with respect to pH, most pronounced in & 91.7±11.7 U/L, respectively) of LiP; while
case of laccase. The minimum production of laccase arabinose, galactose, lactose, starch and cellulose
(0.8±0.3 U/L) was recorded at pH 3.5, which exhibited inhibitory effects on LiP production. All the
increased with the increase of pH up to pH 7.5
(8.9±0.6 U/L) and then it declined to pH 9.5 Table 2—Effect of pH on production of ligninolytic enzymes
(4.1±0.5 U/L). The production of LiP was recorded pH Laccase LiP MnP
almost stable at pH 7.5 and 9.5, showing the activities (U/L) (U/L) (U/L)
at 211.6±14.5 and 214.9±15.2 U/L, respectively. The 3.5 0.8±0.3 110.0±28.2 1439.1±164.5
minimum production (110.0±28.2 U/L) of LiP was 5.5 7.6±1.4 149.3±13.2 1737.4±74.5
recorded at pH 3.5. The maximum production 7.5 8.9±0.7 211.6±14.5 1642.8±177.0
(1737.4±74.5U/L) of MnP was recorded at pH 5.5, 9.5 4.1±0.5 214.9±15.2 1618.3±96.3
showing stability at pH 9.5 (1618.3±96.3 U/L), while Values are mean±SD (n= 3)
Table 1—Effect of temperature on production of ligninolytic enzymes
Incubation (d) Laccase LiP MnP
(U/L) (U/L) (U/L)
A 15°C 15°C 15°C
7 0.9±0.3 86.5±17.7 1667.1±133.1
14 3.3±0.5 126.7±8.5 1782.4±105.2
21 9.2±1.8 137.0±7.8 2131.7±288.5
28 5.9±0.9 104.5±14.5 2028.6±262.4
35 4.2±1.1 96.6±9.5 1974.8±197.3
B 25°C 35°C 25°C 35°C 25°C 35°C
3 1.4±0.4 1.3±0.3 52.8±6.9 79.7±4.1 1783.9±87.5 1779.4±104.3
6 1.6±0.6 2.4±0.7 85.8±7.6 94.3±6.1 1751.9±124.0 2028.8±192.1
9 3.9±0.7 2.1±0.2 165.3±15.7 168.4±5.7 2193.4±261.4 2205.1±165.8
12 8.0±1.0 1.7±0.5 92.1±9.3 89.7±10.0 1909.6±145.5 2326.9±226.7
15 4.3±1.0 1.9±0.3 91.1±10.6 80.6±5.7 1933.3±203.1 2022.4±217.2
Values are mean ± SD (n= 3)
84 INDIAN J BIOTECHNOL, JANUARY 2015

Fig. 2 (A-C)—Effect of nitrogen sources on produciton


Fig. 1 (A-C)—Effect of carbon sources on production of
of ligninolytic enzymes: A, Laccase; B, LiP; & C, MnP.
ligninolytic enzymes: A, Laccase; B, LiP; & C, MnP. [G, Glucose;
[AN, Ammonium nitrate; AS, Ammonium sulfate; AA,
F, Fructose; Gal, Galactose; Lac, Lactose; M, Maltose; Tre,
Ammonium acetate; AFS, Ammonium ferrous sulfate; KN,
Trehalose; P, Pectin; St, Starch; Cel, Cellulose; & Chi, Chitin]
Potassium nitrate; U, Urea; Cs, Casein; Ye, Yeast extract; Pep,
carbon sources enhanced the production of MnP; Peptone; & ATU, Allythiourea]
maximum being in case of chitin (2307.9±284.1 U/L). respectively. On the contrary, ammonium sulfate
Addition of nitrogen sources was more effective in and potassium nitrate were found to be inhibitory for
enhancing the production of ligninolytic enzymes LiP production. In case of MnP, allylthiourea was
(Fig. 2). Out of 10 sources, ammonium ferrous found to be the best enhancer that resulted in approx
sulfate, urea, yeast extract and peptone were found to 3-fold enhancement (6499.9±701.8 U/L). Ammonium
enhance the laccase production (10.3±1.8, 10.5±1.2, ferrous sulfate, casein, yeast extract, peptone and
9.5±1.5 & 9.9±1.6 U/L, respectively). However, allylthiourea were the other enhancers (5307.6±780.2,
ammonium sulfate, ammonium acetate, potassium 2576.9±378.8, 2532.1±640.2, 2436.14±390.3 &
nitrate, casein and allylthiourea exhibited inhibitory 6499.6±701.8 U/L, respectively) of MnP. However,
effects on laccase production. Seven of the nitrogen MnP production was inhibited by 4 nitrogen sources,
sources (ammonium acetate, ammonium ferrous namely, ammonium sulfate, ammonium acetate,
sulfate, urea, casein, yeast extract, peptone and potassium nitrate and urea. Addition of different
allylthiourea) resulted in enhancement of LiP carbon and nitrogen sources for regulating the
production, which was recorded as 109.2±13.8, production of ligninolytic enzymes has been well
360.2±74.1, 174.3±12.1, 116.4±12.5, 94.3±14.5, reported18-20. In the present study, among various
191.5±27.7, 170.1±12.4 and 145.2±11.8 U/L, nitrogen sources, organic nitrogen sources, in
DHAKAR et al: LIGNINOLYTIC ENZYMES BY TEMPERATURE AND pH TOLERANT A. NIGER 85

enhancement of laccase production by Cyathus


bulleri21, and effect of physico-chemical and
nutritional parameters as well as other supplements on
production of ligninolytic enzymes from Trametes sp.
have also been reported earlier19.
Literature on ascomycetous fungi in lignin
degradation, specifically from low temperature
environments, is limited. Various species from
the ascomycetous genera, mainly Aspergillus,
Paecilomyces and Penicillium, have been of interest
because of their presence and activities in various
geographical locations, including low temperature
environments under mountain ecosystem4-6,22. The
psychrotolerant strain of A. niger, used in the present
study, was originally isolated from the mixed forest of
Cedrus-Taxus in IHR, where litter degradation is slow
due to the prevalence of low temperature. The present
study highlights the importance of temperature and
pH in production of the ligninolytic enzymes. The
fungus showed its ability to produce ligninolytic
enzymes at a wide and different range of temperature
and pH. Because of the stability at low temperature,
laccase is likely to be more applicable for degradation
in the low temperature environments. Research on
microorganisms dominating the low temperature
environments, such as, Arctic, Antarctic, Andes and
IHR, is getting increasing attention of the scientific
community. The focus in these studies is mainly on
the phylogeny, adaptation mechanisms, biogeography,
bioremediation, biotechnological applications and
ecological resilience23-28.

Acknowledgment
Fig. 3 (A-C)—Effect of vitamins on production of ligninolytic
Authors are thankful to the Director, G B Pant
enzymes: A, Laccase; B, LiP; & C, MnP. [C, Control; P, Institute of Himalayan Environment and
Pyridoxine; B1, Thiamine; B, Biotin; N, Nicotinic acid; & F, Development, Almora for encouragement and
Folic acid] providing the facilities. The Department of Science
and Technology, and the Union Ministry of
particular, was found to be more effective in
Environment, Forests and Climate Change,
comparison to the addition of carbon sources.
Government of India, New Delhi, are acknowledged
Vitamin supplements also affected production of for financial support. Senior author (DK) is also
ligninolytic enzymes. Pyridoxine, biotin and folic acid thankful to Indian Council of Medical Research, New
resulted in enhanced production (10.3±1.6, 10.1±1.5 Delhi for the award of fellowship.
& 11.4±1.2 U/L, respectively) of laccase. On the
contrary, addition of B1 and nicotinic acid was found References
to be inhibitory for the production of laccase. While 1 Sharma G, Pandey R R & Singh M S, Microfungi associated
all the vitamins showed strong positive effect on with surface soil and decaying leaf litter of Quercus serrata
production of LiP and MnP, maximum enhanced in a subtropical natural oak forest and managed plantation in
Northeastern India, Afr J Microbiol Res, 5 (2011) 777-787.
production (662.3± 108.7 & 3525.6±483.9 U/L, 2 Pandey A & Palni L M S, The rhizosphere effect in trees of
respectively) was recorded in case of folic acid the Indian Central Himalaya with special reference to
(Fig. 3). Effect of biotin and pyridoxine in altitude, Appl Ecol Environ Res, 5 (2007) 93-102.
86 INDIAN J BIOTECHNOL, JANUARY 2015

3 Kaira G S, Dhakar K & Pandey A, A psychrotolerant strain 17 Elsayed M A, Hassan M M, Elshafei A M, Haroun B M &
of Serratia marcescens (MTCC 4822) produces laccase at Othman A M, Optimization of cultural and nutritional
wide temperature and pH range, AMB Express 5 (2015) 1. parameters for the production of laccase by Pleurotus
[DOI: 10.1186/s13568-014-0092-1] ostreatus ARC280, Br Biotechnol J, 2 (2012) 115-132.
4 Dhakar K, Sharma A & Pandey A, Cold, pH and salt tolerant 18 Mikiashvili N, Wasser S P, Nevo E & Elisashvili V, Effects
Penicillium spp. inhabit the high altitude soils in Himalaya, of carbon and nitrogen sources on Pleurotus ostreatus
India, World J Microbiol Biotechnol, 30 (2014) 1315-1324. ligninolytic enzyme activity, World J Microbiol Biotechnol,
5 Kellner H, Zak D R & Vandenbol M, Fungi unearthed: 22 (2006) 999-1002.
Transcripts encoding lignocellulolytic and chitinolytic enzymes 19 Levin L, Melignani E & Ramos A M, Effect of nitrogen
in forest soil, PLoS One, 5 (2010) e10971. [DOI: 10.1371/ sources and vitamins on ligninolytic enzyme production by
annotation/84b7b537-84f6-49e6-ac7c-9a2f0ad3f862] some white-rot fungi. Dye decolorization by selected culture
6 Rinu K & Pandey A, Temperature-dependent phosphate filtrates, Bioresour Technol, 101 (2010) 4554-4563.
solubilization by cold- and pH-tolerant species of Aspergillus 20 Dhakar K & Pandey A, Laccase production from a
isolated from Himalayan soil, Mycoscience, 51 (2010) temperature and pH tolerant fungal strain of Trametes hirsuta
263-271. (MTCC 11397), Enzyme Res, 2013 (2013) 869062. [DOI:
7 Hatakka A, Biodegradation of lignin, in Biopolymers: Lignin, 10.1155/2013/869062]
humic substances and coal, vol 1, edited by M Hofrichter & 21 Dhawan S & Kuhad R C, Effect of amino acids and vitamins
A Steinbuchel (Wiley-VCH, Weinheim) 2001, 129-180. on laccase production by the bird’s nest fungus Cyathus
8 Maciel M J M, Silva A C e & Ribeiro H C T, Industrial and bulleri, Bioresour Technol, 84 (2002) 35-38.
biotechnological applications of ligninolytic enzymes of the 22 Rinu K, Pandey A & Palni L M S, Utilization of
basidiomycota: A review, Electron J Biotechnol, 13 (2010) psychrotolerant phosphate solubilizing fungi under low
14-15. [DOI: 10.2225/vol13-issue6-fulltext-2] temperature conditions of the mountain ecosystem, in
9 Kanwal H K & Reddy M S, Effect of carbon, nitrogen Microorganisms in sustainable agriculture and
sources and inducers on ligninolytic enzyme production by biotechnology, edited by T Satyanarayana, B N Johri &
Morchella crassipes, World J Microbiol Biotechnol, 27 A Prakash (Springer Science+Buisiness Media, The
(2011) 687-691. Netherlands) 2011, 77-90.
10 Kirk T K & Farrell R L, Enzymatic “combustion”: 23 Dhakar K, Jain R, Tamta S & Pandey A, Prolonged laccase
The microbial degradation of lignin, Annu Rev Microbiol, production by a cold and pH tolerant strain of Penicillium
41 (1987) 465-505. pinophilum (MCC 1049) isolated from a low temperature
11 Han M J, Choi H T & Song H G, Purification and environment, Enzyme Res, 2014 (2014) 120708.
characterization of laccase from the white rot fungus 24 Yarzábal L A, Cold-tolerant phosphate-solubilizing
Trametes versicolor, J Microbiol, 43 (2005) 555-560. microorganisms and agriculture development in mountainous
12 Khiyami M A, Pometto A L & Kennedy W J, Ligninolytic regions of the World, in Phosphate solubilizing
enzyme production by Phanerochaete chrysosporium in microorganisms, edited by M S Khan, A Zaidi & J Musarrat
plastic composite support biofilm stirred tank bioreactors, (Springer International Publishing, Switzerland) 2014,
J Agric Food Chem, 54 (2006) 1693-1698. 113-136. [DOI 10.1007/978-3-319-08216-5_5]
13 Ghildiyal A & Pandey A, Isolation of cold tolerant antifungal 25 Margesin R & Schinner F, Biodegradation and
strains of Trichoderma sp. from glacial sites of Himalayan bioremediation of hydrocarbons in extreme environments,
region, Res J Microbiol, 3 (2008) 559-564. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 56 (2001) 650-663.
14 Rinu K & Pandey A, Slow and steady phosphate 26 Pandey A, Palni L M S & Hebbar K P, Suppression of
solubilization by a psychrotolerant strain of Paecilomyces damping-off in maize seedlings by Pseudomonas corrugate,
hepiali (MTCC 9621), World J Microbiol Biotechnol, Microbiol Res, 156 (2001) 191-194.
27 (2011) 1055-62. 27 Trivedi P, Kumar B, Pandey A & Palni L M S, Growth
15 Zadrazil F, Gonser A & Lang E, Influence of incubation promotion of rice by phosphate solubilizing bioinoculants in
temperature on the secretion of extracellular ligninolytic a Himalayan location, in Plant and Soil: Developments in
enzymes of Pleurotus and Dichomitus squalus into soil, in Plant and Soil Sciences, First International Meeting on
Proc Conf on Enzymes in the Environment (Granada, Spain), Microbial Phosphate Solubilization, vol 102, edited by E
1999. Velazqez & C Rodriguez-Barrueco (Springer, The
16 Janusz G, Roglaski J, Barwinska M & Szczodrak J, Effects Netherlands) 2007, 291-299.
of culture conditions on production of extracellular laccase 28 Margesin R & Miteva V, Diversity and ecology of
by Rhizoctonia praticola, Pol J Microbiol, 55 (2006) psychrophilic microorganisms, Res Microbiol, 162 (2011)
309-319. 346-361.

You might also like