“Assessment of Impact of Roadside Bus-Stops on Capacity of

Urban Divided Roads Using Microscopic Simulation Model – A

case study of Jadibuti - Gatthaghar section”

1. Research Background:

Urban transportation systems are integral components of modern cities, facilitating the
movement of people and goods. Efficient road networks play a crucial role in ensuring the
smooth functioning of urban areas. One key aspect of urban transportation infrastructure is
the provision of bus stops, strategically located along roads to facilitate public
transportation. While bus stops are essential for promoting sustainable and accessible public
transit, their impact on the overall capacity and traffic flow of urban divided roads remains
a critical consideration.

The integration of bus stops into urban road networks can introduce complexities in traffic
dynamics, affecting vehicular flow, congestion levels, and overall road capacity.
Understanding and quantifying these impacts are essential for urban planners, transportation
engineers, and policymakers seeking to optimize the performance of road networks and
enhance the efficiency of public transportation systems.

Previous research has explored the relationship between bus stops and road capacity, often
relying on macroscopic analyses and simplified models. However, advancements in
transportation engineering and technology have paved the way for more nuanced and
detailed investigations. Microscopic simulation models have emerged as powerful tools for
studying the intricate interactions between individual vehicles, bus operations, and other
elements of the transportation system.

This research aims to employ a microscopic simulation model to assess the impact of
roadside bus stops on the capacity of urban divided roads. Microscopic simulation allows
for a granular examination of traffic behavior by considering the movements of individual
vehicles, their interactions, and responses to various factors such as signal timings,
geometric configurations, and the presence of bus stops. By adopting a microscopic
approach, this study intends to provide a comprehensive understanding of how the
placement and design of bus stops influence the operational characteristics of urban divided
roads.

Key factors to be considered in this assessment include bus stop location, design attributes,
and their interactions with signalized intersections, turning movements, and pedestrian
activities. The research will also explore potential mitigation measures to optimize road
capacity while maintaining an efficient public transportation system.

Through this investigation, the research aims to contribute valuable insights to the field of
urban transportation planning and design. The findings are expected to inform evidence-
based decision-making processes, guiding the development of transportation policies and
infrastructure projects that balance the needs of public transit users with the overall
efficiency of urban road networks. Ultimately, the research strives to enhance the
sustainability, accessibility, and performance of urban transportation systems in the face of
growing urbanization and evolving mobility patterns.

2. Statement of Problem:

Urban transportation systems are faced with the ongoing challenge of balancing the
imperative to enhance public transit accessibility with the need to maintain the operational
efficiency of road networks. The provision of roadside bus stops, a fundamental element of
urban public transportation infrastructure, introduces a complex set of interactions that can
significantly impact the capacity and performance of urban divided roads. The existing body
of research on this subject primarily relies on macroscopic analyses, often overlooking the
intricate dynamics that unfold at the microscopic level.

The problem at hand lies in the limited understanding of how roadside bus stops, their
placement, and design characteristics influence the capacity of urban divided roads when
examined through a microscopic lens. Traditional analyses often fail to capture the nuanced
interactions among individual vehicles, bus operations, and other elements of the
transportation system, leading to an incomplete assessment of the true impact of bus stops
on road capacity.
Furthermore, as urban populations continue to grow, and cities grapple with increasing
traffic demands, it becomes imperative to develop a comprehensive understanding of the
specific challenges posed by roadside bus stops. The problem statement underscores the
necessity to bridge the existing gap in knowledge by employing advanced microscopic
simulation models that can offer a more detailed and accurate representation of the
interactions between various components within the transportation system.

Key problem areas that require exploration include:

 Microscopic Dynamics: The lack of detailed insights into the microscopic dynamics
of traffic flow around roadside bus stops hinders the development of effective
strategies to optimize road capacity.
 Bus Stop Design and Placement: The optimal design and placement of bus stops
concerning their impact on traffic operations remain poorly understood, impeding
informed decision-making by urban planners and policymakers.
 Interaction with Signalized Intersections: The interplay between bus stops and
signalized intersections is a critical factor influencing road capacity, yet it has not
been thoroughly examined at the microscopic level.
 Mitigation Strategies: The absence of a comprehensive understanding of the
challenges posed by roadside bus stops hampers the development of targeted
mitigation strategies to optimize road capacity without compromising public transit
efficiency.

Addressing these gaps is essential for developing evidence-based recommendations and

interventions that promote sustainable, efficient, and accessible urban transportation
systems. The proposed research seeks to delve into the microscopic intricacies of the
relationship between roadside bus stops and urban divided road capacity, providing a
foundation for informed decision-making in the realm of urban transportation planning and
design.
 3. Research Questions:

a) How do the microscopic dynamics of traffic flow around roadside bus stops
influence the overall capacity of urban divided roads?
b) What is the optimal design and placement of roadside bus stops in the context of
urban divided roads?
c) How do roadside bus stops interact with signalized intersections at the microscopic
level?

4. Research Objectives:

a) Investigate and analyze the microscopic dynamics of traffic flow around roadside
bus stops on urban divided roads using a microscopic simulation model.
b) Examine the optimal design and placement of roadside bus stops in the context of
urban divided roads by evaluating various design attributes through a microscopic
simulation model.
c) Explore the interactions between roadside bus stops and signalized intersections at
the microscopic level using a simulation model.

5. Significance of the Study:

The study holds significant implications for urban transportation planning and optimization.
Understanding the impact of roadside bus stops on the capacity of divided roads at a
microscopic level allows for more precise and targeted interventions in urban infrastructure
design. By employing a microscopic simulation model, the research contributes to the body
of knowledge with empirically grounded insights. The findings will empower urban
planners and policymakers to make evidence-based decisions, ensuring that transportation
policies and projects are rooted in a deep understanding of the specific challenges posed by
roadside bus stops.

The study aids in the efficient integration of public transit systems within urban road
networks. As cities strive to promote sustainable transportation options, optimizing the
performance of bus stops can enhance the attractiveness and reliability of public transit,
encouraging greater usage and reducing dependency on private vehicles. With the
identification of optimal bus stop design and placement, as well as strategies to mitigate
congestion at signalized intersections, the study provides practical solutions for alleviating
traffic congestion in urban areas. This is particularly crucial as congestion not only impacts
road capacity but also contributes to increased travel times and environmental pollution.

The research outcomes can guide resource allocation and infrastructure investment more
effectively. By understanding the nuanced impact of roadside bus stops, cities can prioritize
investments in areas that yield the highest returns in terms of improved road capacity and
enhanced public transit efficiency. As urban populations continue to grow, the study
contributes to the creation of more livable and sustainable cities. Well-designed and
strategically located bus stops can contribute to a seamless urban transportation experience,
reducing travel times, minimizing congestion-related stress, and improving overall quality
of life for residents. The study's insights will be valuable for adapting urban transportation
systems to evolving mobility patterns. With the rise of shared mobility and changing
commuter behaviors, understanding the impact of roadside bus stops becomes crucial for
ensuring the resilience and adaptability of urban road networks.

In summary, the assessment of the impact of roadside bus stops on the capacity of urban
divided roads using a microscopic simulation model is significant not only for addressing
immediate transportation challenges but also for fostering the long-term sustainability and
efficiency of urban infrastructure in the face of dynamic urbanization and shifting mobility
paradigms.

6. Scope and Limitation of the study:

Scope of the Study:

a) Geographical Scope: The study will focus on urban divided roads within a specific
geographical area, allowing for a detailed examination of the impact of roadside bus
stops in a defined urban context.
b) Microscopic Simulation Model: The research will employ a microscopic simulation
model to analyze the impact of roadside bus stops. The scope includes the
development and application of this model to understand the intricate interactions
 among individual vehicles, bus operations, and other elements of the transportation
system.
c) Bus Stop Design and Placement: The study will investigate the optimal design and
placement of roadside bus stops, considering various design attributes and their
effects on traffic flow. This includes a detailed examination of geometric
configurations and their impact on road capacity.
d) Interaction with Signalized Intersections: The research will specifically explore the
interactions between roadside bus stops and signalized intersections at the
microscopic level. This includes an assessment of the influence on traffic flow, as
well as the development of strategies to optimize intersection performance.
e) Mitigation Strategies: The scope extends to identifying and recommending
mitigation strategies to address potential congestion and optimize road capacity
around roadside bus stops. Strategies may include signal timing adjustments,
geometric modifications, or other targeted interventions.

Limitations of the Study:

a) Generalizability: The findings may have limitations in terms of generalizability to

different urban contexts. The study focuses on a specific geographical area, and the
results may not be directly applicable to cities with significantly different
transportation infrastructure, land use patterns, or demographic characteristics.
b) Model Assumptions and Simplifications: The microscopic simulation model relies
on certain assumptions and simplifications to represent complex real-world
interactions. The accuracy of the results is subject to the model's fidelity to actual
conditions, and the study will acknowledge and discuss any inherent limitations
arising from these simplifications.
c) Dynamic Urban Environment: Urban environments are dynamic and subject to
continuous changes in population, land use, and transportation patterns. The study's
findings may not account for future changes and may require periodic reassessment
to remain relevant over time.
d) Data Availability and Accuracy: The accuracy and comprehensiveness of the study
depend on the availability and reliability of data, including traffic patterns, bus
 operations, and road infrastructure details. Limitations in data quality or availability
may impact the precision of the study's results.
e) External Factors: External factors such as weather conditions, special events, or
construction activities could influence the study's outcomes. While efforts will be
made to control for these factors, their unpredictable nature introduces a level of
uncertainty.
f) Resource and Time Constraints: The study is subject to resource and time
constraints, which may limit the extent of data collection, model calibration, and the
comprehensiveness of the analysis. The scope may be adjusted to accommodate
these constraints while still providing valuable insights.

By clearly defining the scope and acknowledging the limitations, the study aims to provide
a focused and meaningful investigation into the assessment of the impact of roadside bus
stops on the capacity of urban divided roads, while maintaining transparency about the
constraints inherent in the research process.

7. Literature Review:

The assessment of the impact of roadside bus stops on the capacity of urban divided roads
has been a subject of considerable interest in the field of transportation engineering and
urban planning. While previous research has explored the relationship between bus stops
and road capacity, there is a growing recognition of the need for more nuanced analyses that
consider the microscopic dynamics of traffic flow.

Early studies, such as those by Parmar R et al. (2016) and Patel C R and Joshi GJ (2014),
primarily relied on macroscopic analyses to assess the impact of bus stops on road capacity.
These studies often utilized aggregate measures, such as delay and level of service,
providing valuable insights into the overall performance of road networks but overlooking
the detailed interactions occurring at the microscopic level.

Recent advancements in transportation engineering have facilitated the adoption of

microscopic simulation models to study the fine-grained dynamics of traffic flow. Notable
contributions by authors like R Pooja et al. (2022) and Y Chen et al. (2016) emphasize the
significance of considering individual vehicle movements, bus operations, and their
interactions within the simulation framework. R Pooja et al. (2022) specifically applied a
microscopic simulation model to investigate the impact of bus stops on road capacity and
identified key factors influencing traffic flow, including bus stop spacing and signal timing.

The work of N. P. Parmar et al. (2018) extended this research by examining the influence of
bus stops on signalized intersections, recognizing the interconnected nature of these
elements within the urban transportation system. Their findings underscored the need for a
holistic approach that considers not only the bus stops themselves but also their interactions
with adjacent traffic control mechanisms.

As urbanization accelerates, the demand for efficient public transportation systems

intensifies, emphasizing the need for a comprehensive understanding of the impact of
roadside bus stops on urban divided roads. Recent studies have expanded the scope of
inquiry, exploring not only the immediate operational effects but also the broader
implications for urban livability and sustainability.

While these studies offer valuable insights, challenges persist in reconciling the various
factors that influence the impact of bus stops on urban divided roads. Notably, the work of
Patkar, M., and A. Dhamaniya (2020) sought to integrate multiple dimensions, including
traffic flow, environmental impact, and user behavior, into a unified framework. By
developing a comprehensive evaluation model, their research underscores the complexity
of the issue and advocates for a holistic approach in assessing the multifaceted impacts of
roadside bus stops.

Despite these advancements, it is crucial to acknowledge the potential limitations of existing

literature. Many studies have focused on specific geographical contexts, and variations in
urban layouts, transportation policies, and cultural factors may influence the transferability
of findings to different locations. Additionally, the rapid evolution of transportation
technologies and modes necessitates ongoing research to stay abreast of emerging trends
and their implications for bus stop impacts on urban divided roads.

While these studies contribute valuable insights, there remains a gap in the literature
regarding the optimal design and placement of bus stops in the context of urban divided
roads. The proposed research aims to address this gap by employing a microscopic
simulation model to comprehensively assess the impact of roadside bus stops, considering
various design attributes and their implications for road capacity. By building on the
foundations laid by previous research, this study seeks to advance our understanding of the
intricate dynamics between bus stops and urban divided roads, providing a basis for
informed decision-making in urban transportation planning and design.

In summary, the literature review demonstrates the evolving landscape of research on the
assessment of roadside bus stops' impact on urban divided roads. This study builds upon
this foundation by employing a microscopic simulation model, aiming to provide a
comprehensive understanding that integrates traffic dynamics, environmental
considerations, and user behavior. Through such an approach, the research aims to
contribute to the ongoing dialogue on optimizing urban transportation systems for increased
efficiency, sustainability, and overall urban quality of life.

8. References

1) Rao AM, Velmurugan S, Lakshmi KMVN (2017) Evaluation of influence of

roadside frictions on the capacity of roads in Delhi, India. Transp Res Procedia
25:4771–4782
2) Pallavi G, Mehar A, Neeraja D (2016) Effect of side friction on the traffic flow
behaviour of multilane divided urban road at mid-block sections. In: Proceedings of
12th transportation planning and implementation methodologies for developing
countries, IIT Bombay, Dec 2016
3) Parmar R, Maru A, Chhabra RS (2016) Macroscopic analysis of side friction impact
on speed of urban roads-case study of Jawahar Marg, Indore. In: Proceedings of 12th
transportation planning and implementation methodologies for developing
countries, IIT Bombay, Dec 2016
4) Chiguma ML (2007) Analysis of sidefriction impacts on urban roads: case study
Dares-Salaam. Doctoral dissertation, KTH University, Sweden
5) Salini S, George S, Ashalatha R (2016) Effect of side frictions on traffic
characteristics of urban arterials. Transp Res Procedia 17:636–643
6) Patel CR, Joshi GJ (2014) Mixed traffic speed–flow behaviour under influence of
road side friction and non-motorized vehicles: a comparative study of arterial roads
in India. Int J Civ Environ Struct Constr Archit Eng 8(11):1144–1150
7) Chand S, Chandra S (2017) Improper stopping of buses at curb side bus stops:
reasons and implications. Transp Dev Econ 3(1):5
8) Koshy RZ, Arasan VT (2005) Influence of bus-stops on flow characteristics of
mixed traffic. J Transp Eng 131(8):640–643
9) Chandra S, Kumar U (2003) Effect of lane width on capacity under mixed traffic
condition in India. J Transp Eng ASCE 129(2):155–160
10) Pooja Raj, Gowri Asaithambi & A. U. Ravi Shankar (2022) Effect of curbside bus
stops on passenger car units and capacity in disordered traffic using simulation
model, Transportation Letters, 14:2, 104-113, DOI:
10.1080/19427867.2020.1815145
11) Pooja Raj, Gowri Asaithambi & A. U. Ravi Shankar (2022) Assessment of Impact
of Roadside Bus-Stops on Capacity of Urban Divided Roads Using Microscopic
Simulation Model, Lecture Notes in Civil Engineering 219,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-16-8259-9_14
12) Chen, Y., G. Chen, and K. Wu. 2016. “Evaluation of Performance of Bus Lanes
on Urban Expressway Using Paramics Micro-simulation Model.” Procedia
Engineering 137: 523–530. doi:10.1016/j.proeng.2016.01.28.
13) Patkar, M., and A. Dhamaniya. 2020. “Developing Capacity Reduction Factors for
Curbside Bus Stops under Heterogeneous Traffic Conditions.” Arabian Journal for
Science and Engineering 45: 1–15.
14) Parmar, N. P., P. N. Patel, and L. B. Zala. 2018. “Effect of Traffic Characteristics on
the Dynamic PCU under Mixed Traffic Condition at Urban Signalized Intersection.”
International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology 5 (5): 3614–3624.