Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Childbearing Through The Lens of Women With Minor Thalassemia: A Qualitative Study
Childbearing Through The Lens of Women With Minor Thalassemia: A Qualitative Study
2019;8:e1429
www.gmj.ir
Received 2018-11-24
Revised 2018-12-21
Accepted 2019-01-21
1
Nursing and Midwifery Schools, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
2
Reproductive Health Department, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
3
New Baby Programme, Centre for Evidence & Social Innovation (CESI), School of Social Sciences, Education and Social Work,
Queen’s University Belfast, United Kingdom
4
Health Research Center, Life Style Institute, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences Tehran, Iran
5
Health Education Department, School of Health, Baqiyatallah University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran
Abstract
GMJ
Correspondence to:
Khadijeh Mirzaii Najmabadi, Associate Professor, Nurs-
Copyright© 2019, Galen Medical Journal. This is ing and Midwifery School, Mashhad University of Med-
an open-access article distributed under the terms of
the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International ical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran
License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) Telephone Number: +98-5138598016
Email:info@gmj.ir
Email Address: mirzaiikh@mums.ac.ir
Sarayloo Kh, et al. Childbearing and Thalassemia
2 GMJ.2019;8:e1429
www.gmj.ir
Childbearing and Thalassemia Sarayloo Kh, et al.
GMJ.2019;8:e1429 3
www.gmj.ir
Sarayloo Kh, et al. Childbearing and Thalassemia
Interview Questions
4 GMJ.2019;8:e1429
www.gmj.ir
www.gmj.ir
Table 2. Demographic Characteristics of the Participants
GMJ.2019;8:e1429
Spouse Length of Number of Number of Number of Number of children
Code Age Education Occupation
occupation marriage pregnancies children abortions with major thalassemia
Childbearing and Thalassemia
5
Sarayloo Kh, et al. Childbearing and Thalassemia
Table 3. Categories, Sub-Categories, and Themes for Mothers’ Pregnancy Experiences with Minor
Thalassemia
Theme Sub -Category Related topics
Stress and anxiety
Discomfort and being afraid that the child may carry
the disease
Negative Regret
psychological
Low self-confidence
feelings
Concerned about forced abortion
Emotional and physical
experience Worry
Mental pressure
Painfulness of the test
Mother’s weakness
Physical problems Symptoms of intense nausea and dizziness
Difficult pregnancy
Physical difficulty related to abortion
The feeling of motherhood
The feeling of pride
The feeling of value
Rising dignity
Enjoyable pregnancy
Improved marital relationship
Satisfaction Collaboration and attention of the spouse
Stability of family The spouse’s feeling of responsibility owing to
childbirth
The family encouragement
Resort to God
Spiritual support Thank god
Pray
Low awareness of the community
The family disagreement
Social issues
People’s negative view
Social and cultural
Stay at home all the time
issues
Poor culture of People
Cultural issues Stigma
People’s wrong beliefs
test, I was worried about touching the needle for a personal consultation. I was disappoint-
in the baby” (Interviewee Code 3). One of the ed and had to abort my baby... It was so hard
participants who had to abort her pregnancy for me, both physically and mentally…” (In-
because of a prenatal diagnosis of major thal- terviewee Code 8). Others reported that they
assemia described her experience of pregnan- had experienced physical complications dur-
cy as follows: “It was very hard to me. I had ing pregnancy and required special care. One
fulltime stress about health of my baby. When participant for example, who was a midwife,
I became pregnant, I had to be tested. I real- expressed her feeling about her pregnancy as
ized that my baby had major thalassemia and follows: “During pregnancy because of prob-
so I had to abort it. My husband was upset lems, such as dizziness and anemia, my gener-
and left the clinic, but I had to wait and go al wellbeing was affected. I was not prepared
6 GMJ.2019;8:e1429
www.gmj.ir
Childbearing and Thalassemia Sarayloo Kh, et al.
and did not take folic acid. From this point of these women’s responses to being pregnant.
view, it was a bit hard to accept my pregnancy. Women expressed that their belief in God
After I accepted my pregnancy and continued helped them to better cope during pregnancy.
it, I had nausea and dizziness in the first four One woman stated: “I had no idea. I believe
months. I wasn’t happy to experience it…” in God. When I found out I was pregnant, the
(Interviewee Code 11). doctor asked me to have an abortion because
of thalassemia, I was so upset and prayed to
3. Satisfaction God a lot. My husband wouldn’t agree to the
Satisfaction emerged as another important abortion. We were put under the supervision
main theme. Mothers discussed the feelings of a doctor, and he advised us to take a medi-
and emotions relating to their experience of cation before prenatal testing. I kept praying
childbearing. To also ascertain the general im- for a healthy baby” (Interviewee Code 2).
pact of thalassemia on childbearing, women
were asked to talk about their feelings regard- 4. Social and Cultural Issues
ing women with minor thalassemia becoming Social and cultural issues emerged as a third
pregnant. This theme includes the following main theme as it was regarded by participants
three sub-categories: the feeling of value, the as a significant factor that greatly influenced
stability of the family and spiritual support. the suffering of women with thalassemia. It
comprised of two sub-categories, which sepa-
3.1. The Feeling of Value rated social issues from cultural issues. An im-
In general, the participants reported that they portant factor that influenced these women’s
enjoyed their pregnancies without thinking experiences was the reaction of the communi-
about thalassemia. For instance, one partic- ty and family. This had a great psychological
ipant said: “I had a great feeling of pride, effect on their perception of their pregnancy.
when I realized I was pregnant” (Interviewee
Code 8). 4.1. Social Issues
Some women felt elated at the prospect of the Acceptance of the condition by others with-
motherhood experience in the community as well as having to deal
One participant stated: “I had a great feeling with those women without the condition
regarding motherhood. It was a great energy, who experienced normal pregnancies were
like my life was warming up. If you have no important factors. One participant described
baby, you have no home… A baby makes life her friends and neighbors’ view of her preg-
better, and you’re going to progress” (Inter- nancy as: “People say that when women with
viewee Code 8). thalassemia become pregnant, they pray and
hope to have healthy babies. My friends said
3.2. Stability of Family to me: why did you become pregnant again?
The next sub-category was the stability of the You’re sick, and your baby won’t be healthy.
family, which reflected the family’s response I became upset and distracted. The commu-
and support provided regarding the woman’s nity’s view was not good” (Interviewee Code
pregnancy. One of the participants stated: “A 8). The views of some participants regarding
baby plays a very important role in the rela- social factors were as follows: “People have
tionship between the husband and wife. When a different opinion. They think we should not
my child was born, my marital relationship have baby. People have a low level of literacy;
improved and became more intimate, and my they know very little about thalassemia and
marital life became stronger than before the have a negative attitude toward this disease”
arrival of my child” (Interviewee Code 6). (Interviewee Code 5).
GMJ.2019;8:e1429 7
www.gmj.ir
Sarayloo Kh, et al. Childbearing and Thalassemia
because of thalassemia. They believe that the ia as a distressing condition that negatively
child will be ill, so we do not have the right impacted their childbearing experience and
to become pregnant since we would spend a social lives. Women with thalassemia expe-
lot financially if we got pregnant. There is no rience physical and psychological problems
culture…” (Interviewee Code 6). and often struggle to meet the needs of their
child without the support of others. Accord-
Discussion ing to our findings, participants highlighted
the desire and necessity for the provision of
To our knowledge, this is the first study in Iran a comprehensive support system both within
which has explored the individual views and the home and throughout their community.
experiences of mothers with minor thalassem- Therefore, spousal, familial and societal sup-
ia regarding childbearing. Because of its ex- port can have a significant positive effect on
ploratory and qualitative design, the present the physical and mental wellbeing of those
study has contributed to the identification of affected. This particular aspect of the findings
significant issues relating to the experience concurs with previous studies that have found
and views of women with minor thalassem- similar concerns [29, 30]. The consensus from
ia regarding their childbearing and pregnan- these previous studies was that health care in-
cy experience. The study employed a quali- terventions must provide psychological sup-
tative approach to obtain rich, in-depth data, port for women with thalassemia to facilitate
particularly from an exploratory perspective the use of better coping strategies in relation
of the mothers’ experience and views. There to their distress regarding having minor thal-
have been several studies conducted using a assemia. The provision of support for these
range of methodologies and samples regard- women is imperative given the rigid views
ing views and experiences of motherhood and and expectations of the culture and society
childbearing. in which they live. Our findings also concur
with a study by Abdul et al. [31] that investi-
Emotions and Physical Experience gated the impact of thalassemia upon patients
Aujulat et al. (2010), for instance, conducted and their families. The findings indicate that
a study which aimed to better understand the thalassemia can have a significant negative
views of adolescent mothers regarding their psychosocial impact both upon patients and
experiences of pregnancy and motherhood. family members. This again emphasizes the
Several of the participants stated that they felt need for the availability of social and psycho-
valued after childbearing because for them, logical support services. Another significant
motherhood created a sense of maturity and finding from this research was the women’s
responsibility. The findings, in general, in- desire for information; they spoke extensive-
dicated that adolescents were delighted and ly about their educational needs which were
proud of becoming a mother [28]. Our find- generally very limited, particularly in terms of
ings from this present study in part concur the facts and knowledge regarding their con-
with those of Aujulat et al. [28] as the majori- dition. These findings are consistent with pre-
ty of participants were generally excited about vious studies [32, 33] where mothers reported
their pregnancy and had a sense of satisfaction the need for information about the condition
because of becoming pregnant, despite the in- thalassemia, what causes it, what the health
creased risks associated with their health con- risks are and how it can be prevented. Lack
dition. of knowledge about thalassemia and its treat-
ment has thus been demonstrated through our
Support findings and similar studies to cause unnec-
In the present study, the support category was essary anxiety and emotional distress among
an important aspect mentioned by the par- women and their families [34]. Therefore, the
ticipants. The results demonstrate that thal- implementation of tailored health educational
assemia can have a substantial effect on the programs that include professional psycho-
emotional and social lives of those affected. social support and located within the health
In general, participants perceived thalassem- centers is strongly recommended. The results
8 GMJ.2019;8:e1429
www.gmj.ir
Childbearing and Thalassemia Sarayloo Kh, et al.
of this study, similar to other qualitative stud- is necessary for women to accept their preg-
ies, are not generalizable to all those women nancy, i.e., through the validation and support
affected with minor thalassemia due to its ex- of family and others. The stigma associated
ploratory nature and small sample size (n=12) with thalassemia is one of the main obstacles
all of which came from the same geographical to the disclosure of having the condition re-
area. sulting in failure to receive adequate care dur-
ing pregnancy. Childbearing was also found to
Conclusion be a major feature in the status and fertility of
women within Iran. Thus, a recommendation
There is a wealth of previous studies that from our findings is the provision of psycholo-
have focused on thalassemia. However, most gists and/ or trained counselors specific to this
of these studies employed a quantitative de- patient group to be available within the health
sign and thus did not have the rich in-depth education interventions to address the issue of
qualitative data derived from the interview mental health. These programmes would aim
regarding women’s own views, experiences, to increase people’s awareness about thalas-
perceptions, feelings and the importance of semia and its prevention community-wide.
support. This rich data provides a much deep-
er understanding of the concept and the main Acknowledgment
concerns that those affected have to endure.
These themes and subcategories can be used This study was supported by the Vice-chan-
as a structure for a larger multi-site study with cellor for Research & Technology of Mashhad
a sufficient sample size for the findings to be University of Medical Sciences (grant num-
generalizable to this patient group as a whole. ber: 951364).
These findings highlight that it is of upmost
importance to provide health education and Conflict of Interest
support interventions including professional
psychosocial support. Psychosocial support The authors report no conflicts of interest.
References
1. Human Genomics in Global Health, World 6. Thompson AA, Kim HY, Singer ST,
Health Organisation. (Accessed 2016, Vichinsky E, Eile J, Yamashita R, Giardina
at http://www.who.int/genomics/public/ PJ, Olivieri N, Parmar N, Trachtenberg F,
geneticdiseases/en/index2.html). Neufeld EJ. Pregnancy outcomes in women
2. Vichinsky EP. Changing patterns of with thalassemia in North America and the
thalassemia worldwide. Ann N Y AcadSci. United Kingdom. Am. J. Hematol. 2013
2005 Nov 1;1054(1):18-24. .1;88(9):771-3.
3. Yazdi kh, Sanagou A, Joybari L. Problems 7. Sheiner E, Levy A, Yerushalmi R, Katz M.
and their coping with them in families Beta-thalassemia minor during pregnancy.
of patients with thalassemia in Golestan Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2004 .1;103(6):1273-
province.2007. J Gorgan Univ Med Sci. 7.
vol1;9(2):71-5(In Persian). 8. Hanprasertpong T, Kor-anantakul O,
4. Abolghasemi H, Amid A, Zeinali S, Radfar Leetanaporn R, Suntharasaj T, Suwanrath
MH, Eshghi P, Rahiminejad MS, Ehsani C, Pruksanusak N, Pranpanus S. Pregnancy
MA, Najmabadi H, Akbari MT, Afrasiabi outcomes amongst thalassemia traits. Arch
A, Akhavan-Niaki H. Thalassemia in Iran: GynecolObstet. 2013 Nov 1;288(5):1051-4.
epidemiology, prevention, and management. 9. Amooee S, Samsami A, Jahanbakhsh J,
. J PedHematolOncol. 2007 ; 1;29(4):233-8. Karimi M. The pregnancy outcome in
5. Davis B. Fertility and pregnancy in patients with minor β-thalassemia.IJRM.
thalassaemia and sickle cell disease. The UK 2011;9(1):9.
guidelines. Thalassemia Reports. 2014 Dec 10. Matão L, Borges de Miranda ME, Freitas D,
4;4(3). Fátima MI. Entre o desejo, direito e medo de
GMJ.2019;8:e1429 9
www.gmj.ir
Sarayloo Kh, et al. Childbearing and Thalassemia
ser mãe após soropositividade para o HIV. 23. Lupton D. The social worlds of the unborn.
Enfermería global. 2014 Apr;34:467-80. 2013 ; (19),153
11. Braga Cartaxo CM, Domingues do 24. Inhorn MC, editor. Reproductive disruptions:
Nascimento CA, Menino Diniz CM, Gender, technology, and biopolitics in the
Rodrigues Pinheiro de Araujo Brasil D, new millennium. New York, NY; Berghahn
da Silva IF. Gestantes portadoras de HIV/ books; 2007 ;(1);239
AIDS: Aspectos psicológicos sobre a 25. Graneheim UH, Lundman B. Qualitative
prevenção da transmissão vertical.SciELO. content analysis in nursing research:
2013;18(3);419-427 concepts, procedures and measures to
12. Mayer B, Trommsdorff G. Adolescents’ achieve trustworthiness. Nurs Educ Today.
value of children and their intentions to have 2004 ;24(2):105-12.
children: a cross-cultural and multilevel 26. Mahmoudi NH, Nakhjavani N, Eshraghi
analysis. J Cross Cult Psychol. 2010;41(5- P. Attitude of Minor Thalassemia Couples
6):671-89. on legal abortion of embryo thalassemia.J
13. Ntozi JP. The desire for children in tropical Mashhad Univ Med Sci 2013; 23;56(3):177-
Africa: the influence of relatives on fertility 81 (In Persian).
decisions in Ankole, Uganda. J Biosoc Sci 27. Lincoln YS, Guba EG. Naturalistic inquiry.
Oct. 1990;22(4):433-46. Sage; 1985.
14. Siegenthaler AL, Bigner JJ. The value of 28. Aujoulat I, Libion F, Berrewaerts J,
children to lesbian and non-lesbian mothers. Noirhomme-Renard F, Deccache A.
J Homosex. 2000 ;10;39(2):73-91. Adolescent mothers’ perspectives regarding
15. Levandowski BA, Kalilani-Phiri L, their own psychosocial and health needs: a
Kachale F, Awah P, Kangaude G, Mhango qualitative exploratory study in Belgium.
C. Investigating social consequences of Patient Educ Counsel. 2010 ;81(3):448-53.
unwanted pregnancy and unsafe abortion in 29. Shosha GM. Needs and concerns of
Malawi: the role of stigma. Int J Gynaecol Jordanian mothers with thalassemic
Obstet. 2012 ;1;118(S2). children: A Qualitative Study. J Am Sci.
16. Glenn EN, Chang G, Forcey LR. Mothering: 2014;10(1):11-6.
Ideology, experience, and agency. New York, 30. James S, Van Rooyen D, Juanita Strümpher
NY: Routledge; 2016 ;387 D. Experiences of teenage pregnancy among
17. Morgan SP, Bachrach CA. Is the Theory of Xhosa families. J Midwifery. 2012;4(3):1-81
Planned Behaviour an appropriate model 31. Jantan AW, Muhammad SA, Mat Zain N,
for human fertility?. Vienna Yearbook of Abdul Rahman S, Mohamed Z, Rahim A,
Population Research. 2011 ;( 1);9:11 8 Faszrul A, Wan Su K. Thalassaemia: a study
18. Ahmed S, Bryant LD, Cole P. Midwives’ on the perception of patients and family
perceptions of their role as facilitators of members. Med J Malaysia. 2011;66(4):326-
informed choice in antenatal screening. 34.
Midwifery. 2013 ; 1;29(7):745-50. 32. Ishfaq K, Ali AA, Hashmi M. Mothers’
19. Hashemieh M, Naghadeh HT, Namini MT, Awareness and Experiences of Having a
Neamatzadeh H, Dehshal MH. The Iran Thalassemic Child: A Qualitative Approach.
thalassemia prevention program: success Pakistan Journal of Social Sciences (PJSS).
or failure?. Iran J Ped Hematol Oncol. 2015;35(1). 109-121
2015;5(3):161. 33. Ghazanfari Z, Arab M, Forouzi M,
20. Sandelowski M, Barroso J. Motherhood POURABOULI B. Knowledge level and
in the context of maternal HIV infection. education needs of thalassemic childern’s
Research in nursing & health. 2003 parents of Kerman city. IJCCN,2010; ;
Dec;26(6):470-82. 3(3):99-103
21. Thomas GM. An elephant in the consultation 34. Prasomsuk S, Jetsrisuparp A, Ratanasiri T,
room?: configuring Down syndrome in Ratanasiri A. Lived experiences of mothers
British antenatal care. Med Anthropol Q. caring for children with thalassemia major in
2016 Jun;30(2):238-58. Thailand. JSPN. 2007;12(1):13-23.
22. Ross EJ. ‘I think it’s self-preservation’: risk
perception and secrecy in early pregnancy.
Health Risk Soc. 2015 ;18;17(5-6):329-48.
10 GMJ.2019;8:e1429
www.gmj.ir