Professional Documents
Culture Documents
J PRRV 2019 03 009
J PRRV 2019 03 009
Review
PII: S1526-0542(19)30035-1
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prrv.2019.03.009
Reference: YPRRV 1322
Please cite this article as: R.W.H. Hui, Inhaled Corticosteroid-phobia and Childhood Asthma: Current Understanding
and Management Implications, Paediatric Respiratory Reviews (2019), doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.prrv.
2019.03.009
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to our customers
we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo copyediting, typesetting, and
review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please note that during the production process
errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
Inhaled Corticosteroid-phobia and Childhood Asthma: Current Understanding and
Management Implications
*corresponding author
huirex@connect.hku.hk
1
Inhaled Corticosteroid-phobia and Childhood Asthma: Current Understanding and
Management Implications
ABSTRACT
Asthma is the most prevalent chronic disease in children. Inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) is the
first-line controller therapy for children with persistent asthma, however, suboptimal
Steroid-phobia, the fear of side-effects and subsequent aversion of ICS, has been widely
widely from 19-67% in different populations. The concerns about ICS frequently raised by
parents include growth suppression, weight gain, bone weakness, addiction and psychiatric
clinical studies, the other concerns are not evidence-based and are misconceptions.
Conflicting results have been reported regarding the impact of steroid-phobia on ICS
compliance. In contrast, steroid-phobia has consistent and negative effects on asthma control
paediatric asthma, high-quality studies are warranted to investigate the prevalence and impact
KEYWORDS
2
INTRODUCTION
Asthma is the most common chronic disease in the paediatric population, and has shown
increasing incidence and prevalence in recent decades [1-4]. Aside from morbidity and
mortality, asthma in children also yields substantial socioeconomic consequences and places
Inhaled corticosteroids (ICS) is the first-line controller therapy for children with persistent
asthma [1]. Through targeting inflammatory mediators, ICS reduces inflammation and
bronchial hypersensitivity [5]. ICS has been shown to improve symptom control, reduce
exacerbations, improve lung function [6, 7], reduce hospitalisations [8], and reduce asthma
mortality.[9] Despite its proven benefits, suboptimal adherence to ICS remains a key
and the low compliance is a major cause of poor disease control [10].
While factors such as knowledge on inhaler use and parental education influence ICS
of poor ICS adherence [1, 10]. Steroid phobia, the fear of steroid side effects and subsequent
aversion of steroids, has been documented in the literature since 1979 [11, 12], and is well-
recognised among both paediatric [13] and adult [14] populations. The article will review the
literature on steroid-phobia towards ICS in childhood asthma, and explore its management
implications.
The prevalence of steroid-phobia among parents of asthmatic children has been described in a
range of studies. A commonly used tool to assess concerns was the Beliefs about Medicines
prescribed medication. The questionnaire is further divided into the BMQ-Necessity and
BMQ-Concerns subscales to assess opinions on the necessity of the drug and concerns
3
regarding the drug respectively [15]. Percentage of parents with strong concerns about ICS
use in their children, as defined by the BMQ, ranged from 19-30% (Table 1) [16-19]. Other
studies have also described parental concerns regarding ICS in asthma, yet the studies utilised
non-validated questionnaires to measure the outcome. The percentage of parents who have
expressed concerns ranged from 19-67% among studies using non-validated questionnaires
(Table 1) [20-27]. Outside of a 1996 study from Singapore [27], the other studies using non-
compared with the studies using BMQ. This discrepancy could be attributable to disparities in
the assessment instruments. Also, it should be noted that the four studies using BMQ were
sub-studies embedded in larger clinical studies. The families may have received additional
physician advice and education while they took part in the research, and hence have lower
concerns about ICS. Future studies should aim for a comprehensive assessment of steroid-
phobia among all parents of asthmatic children. Since the BMQ questionnaire can be easily
administered, it may be incorporated into routine care, and regular assessment of parental
concerns can be done during the initial prescription of ICS and follow-ups for all patients.
This will avoid response bias, which is likely present in the current studies, and will provide a
more accurate depiction of the steroid-phobia rates. The valuable data generated may be
Koster et al. adopted an alternate approach, and directly administered the BMQ on 182
asthmatic adolescents, rather than their parents [28]. In the study, only 10.1% of adolescents
reported strong concerns against ICS usage. Overall, the data on steroid-phobia among
adolescents is scarce. Future studies should aim to assess the prevalence of steroid-phobia in
adolescents, as adolescents are likely responsible for handling their own medications and their
views on ICS may have greater impact than the views of their parents. It would also be
interesting to study adolescents and their parents simultaneously to assess whether there is
4
Table 1. Prevalence of inhaled corticosteroid-phobia among parents of asthmatic children
Koster et al. 2011 170 patients from the PIAMA cohort Yes 19.4
Koster et al. 2011 527 patients from the PACMAN Yes 21.6
Conn et al. 2007 622 patients from a trial on physician- Yes 30.0
[25] hospital, US
hospital, Singapore
Children: Medication with Anti-inflammatory Effects; PIAMA: Prevention and Incidence of Asthma
5
PARENTAL UNDERSTANDING ABOUT INHALED CORTICOSTEROIDS SIDE
EFFECTS
As with all drugs, ICS have potential side effects. While ICS adverse effects may have
formed the basis for steroid-phobia, studies have revealed that ICS are shrouded in myths and
misconceptions. Common concerns that parents have raised regarding ICS include growth
suppression [20,22-24], weight gain [23, 24], bone weakness [23], addiction and dependence
[21-24, 26, 27, 29], and psychiatric disturbances [22, 24]. This section will review the
common reasons for parents to fear ICS and explore whether the reasons are valid.
Growth suppression
Growth suppression due to ICS is one of the most commonly stated concerns among parents
[20, 22-24]. This concern is supported by the literature, as a meta-analysis involving 8741
asthmatic children demonstrated that regular use of ICS led to a mean reduction of linear
growth velocity by 0.48 cm per year [30]. Another meta-analysis published in 2014 focused
on the effect of different ICS dosages, and patients on medium dosage ICS had a reduced
growth rate of 0.20 cm per year when compared with low dose ICS users [31]. The long-term
growth effect of ICS has also been studied. In the Childhood Asthma Management Program
trial, patients on ICS had reduced growth velocity in the first year when compared with
patients on inhaled nedocromil or placebo. At the end of the six-year study, the ICS group had
a 1.1cm lower mean height increase when compared with the other groups [32]. After 12
years of longitudinal follow-up of the trial patients, the mean adult height in the ICS group
Although the effect of ICS on growth suppression is statistically significant, the clinical
significance of the relatively small effect size is debatable [34], and parents should be
reassured that other factors such as nutrition and genetics have a greater influence on height
[35]. While ICS leads to growth suppression, it should also be noted that uncontrolled asthma
can lead to poor growth as well [36, 37]. Aversion of ICS may lead to poorly-controlled
6
Weight gain
Weight gain secondary to ICS has been reported in small-scale studies in adult populations
[38]. However, a meta-analysis in the paediatric population has demonstrated ICS to have no
impact on patients’ body weight or body mass index [31]. Nonetheless, the authors of the
meta-analysis noted that the studies on weight changes in children were of low quality and
Bone weakness
While oral corticosteroids are known to reduce bone density and increase fracture risk in
children [39], a similar impact of ICS on children’s bone health has yet been documented.
ICS has been shown to reduce serum markers of osteogenesis [40], however ICS use did not
significantly reduce the bone mineral density [32, 41], nor did it increase the risk of fractures
Inhaler abuse has been previously documented in the literature, yet the studies reported short-
acting beta agonists as the type of inhaler abused, since patients sought the sympathomimetic
effects of the drug [45, 46]. Addiction and abuse of ICS has not been documented in the
patients on topical corticosteroid ointment [47, 48], yet it should be noted that steroid
ointment exerts visible effects on skin lesions. In contrast, the effects of ICS on the airway
takes a long period to act and the effects are less noticeable, hence patients are unlikely to
misuse ICS based on its effects. Experts hypothesize that the concern about ICS addiction
may originate from socio-cultural perceptions of inhaled drugs such as marijuana and heroin
[26, 27].
Psychiatric disturbance
7
Psychiatric adverse effects have also been raised by parents [22, 24]. In particular, negative
impact on their children’s intelligence has been raised by 24% of parents in a large cross-
sectional study in China [22]. Articles have reported about potential psychiatric effects
secondary to ICS in children, and reported effects include agitation, anxiety, hyperactivity and
mood changes [49, 50]. Nonetheless, the number of reported cases are limited, and the studies
are limited by attribution bias. It is also possible that the behavioural changes were secondary
to improved disease control. Children with uncontrolled asthma may have limited exercise
tolerance, which was subsequently improved upon ICS treatment and manifested as
hyperactivity or agitation to the parents [50]. Conversely, the Childhood Asthma Management
Program study assessed the Children’s Depression Inventory as a secondary outcome and
revealed that the ICS group had significantly lower scores than the controls, suggesting that
ICS treatment may lead to lower incidences of depressive symptoms in children [32]. The
data on psychiatric disturbances in children treated with ICS is limited and inconclusive.
Further research should aim to better delineate the potential psychiatric effects of ICS.
Among the frequently raised concerns regarding ICS, growth suppression is a side effect that
is well-recognised and supported by the medical literature. The other concerns regarding
weight gain, bone weakness, addiction, and psychiatric disturbances all do not have evidence-
recurrently expressed concerns regarding ICS, none of the interviewed parents in the studies
raised concerns about the most common adverse effect in ICS use – local oropharyngeal
disturbances. Local oropharyngeal disturbances, namely oral candidiasis and dysphonia, occur
in 5-10% of patients using ICS [51]. Despite its high prevalence, these oropharyngeal effects
are mild and rarely disabling [52], and the relatively benign and transient nature may explain
why the parents seldom raise these local adverse effects as their concerns. Another ICS
adverse effect that has not been documented among steroid-phobic parents is adrenal
suppression. ICS has been demonstrated to have a potential dose-dependent suppressive effect
8
effects of reduced serum cortisol [53, 54], reduced response to the insulin tolerance test [55],
and reduced response to the short Synacthen test [56] have all been documented. Cases of
patients with acute adrenal crisis and presenting with hypoglycaemia, convulsions or coma
have also been reported [57]. Nonetheless, symptomatic cases of ICS-induced adrenal
suppression are very uncommon, and life-threatening cases are even rarer [58], hence it is
predictable that parents have very limited knowledge about this potentially life-threatening
side effect.
Among parents with strong concerns about ICS, it is intriguing that some have explicitly
stated the preference of oral corticosteroids over ICS [23, 25-27]. While the exact reason for
the preference of oral steroids has not been delineated, this is likely attributable to the low
knowledge level regarding asthma treatment and the failure to recognise the more severe
systemic effects from oral steroids. The misperception that oral medications can target the
In spite of the high prevalence of concerns about ICS, the impact of steroid-phobia on
paediatric asthma patients has not been well-defined [10]. This section will review articles
In a 2011 study on 527 parents of asthmatic children, the BMQ-Concern score and the BMQ-
Necessity score on ICS were both associated with drug compliance, as determined by the
Medication Adherence Report Scale (MARS). However, the association between BMQ-
Concern and compliance became non-significant in multivariate analysis, and the only
remaining independent predictor of ICS compliance in that study was the BMQ-Necessity
score [17]. These results have been mirrored in other studies [18, 59], suggesting that in spite
9
of reported concerns about ICS, the impact of parental perception about the necessity of the
Other studies have yielded negative results, where both the ICS concerns in parents [20] or in
the patient themselves [28] were not significant determinants of drug adherence. Contrasting
results have been drawn from other studies. Studies have shown that parents with higher
concerns about ICS were significantly more likely to self-taper or omit the ICS use among
their children [24, 26]. A study from the US has also reported that higher ICS concerns were
associated with a lower MARS score, and the inverse correlation remained significant in
The inconclusive results regarding ICS adherence may be due to methodological limitations.
Several studies used non-validated questionnaires to assess drug compliance [20, 24], and
hence the comparability of results between studies may be limited. Some of the studies were
also conducted during routine clinical or pharmacy visits by the medical staff caring for the
patient [17, 20]. This may result in overestimation of compliance due to social desirability
bias. Approaches to tackle this problem may include using telephone interviews, or having the
Asthma control
Conn et al. reported that steroid-phobia in parents was associated with more asthmatic
analysis after controlling for drug adherence [19]. This may simply reflect the high inter-
associated with a higher number of acute asthmatic exacerbations which required nebulisation
treatment [26]. Using the validated Asthma Control Test, Ip et al. demonstrated that parents
with higher ICS concerns had children with significantly lower mean Asthma Control Test
score [20], signifying the negative impact of steroid-phobia on asthma control. Similar results
have also been reported in a 2011 study from Netherlands, where a high BMQ-Concern score
10
led to a two-fold increased risk of uncontrolled asthma, with the results remaining significant
Given the potential overestimation of compliance and the significant effect of ICS adherence
on asthma control [10], the consistent outcome of poor asthma control may be a more
accurate and objective portrayal of the impact of steroid-phobia on paediatric steroid asthma
Steroid-phobia may result in parents seeking alternative therapy for their children’s asthma. A
2005 study from Israel reported that parents with strong ICS concerns were significantly more
likely to resort to homeopathic treatment for their children’s asthma [24]. Similar results have
been shown in a 2017 study from Hong Kong, where parental steroid-phobia was associated
was traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) use in asthmatic children [20]. An interesting case
series has previously reported five cases of inadvertent steroid use in eczematous children
with steroid-phobic parents. The parents of all five patients opted to use TCM instead of
topical steroids for their children’s eczema and reported noticeable disease improvements.
However it was later discovered that the TCM illegally contained potent corticosteroids when
the children presented with varying degrees of Cushingoid features [60]. Among paediatric
asthma cases, particularly in the Chinese population, it may be beneficial to remind parents to
Steroid-phobic parents were also more likely to have discussed their fears about ICS with a
doctor [20], and were more likely to seek information from the lay literature [24]. While this
causality should also be considered. Parents may simply have greater concerns about ICS
because they were educated about more side effects from their doctors, or because they
11
MANAGEMENT OF INHALED CORTICOSTEROID-PHOBIA
Educational programmes in paediatric asthma have demonstrable benefits and can improve
asthma care in children [61-65]. However, these educational programmes have focused on
specific subpopulations that may face more treatment obstacles, such as in parents with
subpopulations is unclear. Indeed, a previous trial has shown that the same set of paediatric
asthma educational intervention may not be applicable and efficacious among different
patient populations [66]. Given the high prevalence of steroid-phobia and its potential
The prescribing physician should clearly explain to the parents about the balance between
risks and benefits in using ICS for asthma [67]. Parents should be reminded of the proven
benefits of ICS in disease control [6-9], and should also be reassured that most ICS side
effects are mild and manageable. Another point that may be raised is that while trials focused
on ICS usage for prolonged periods, ICS regimens are likely to be tapered and adjusted in the
real-world setting, and patients may even be taken off ICS upon satisfactory control. The
patients’ exposure to ICS in the real-world setting is likely to be lower than that in trial
settings, and hence the side effects may also possibly be lower.
CONCLUSION
Steroid-phobia has been reported in parents of asthmatic children and the prevalence varied
suppression, weight gain, bone weakness, addiction and psychiatric disturbances. Outside of
12
growth suppression, which is statistically significant yet mild in clinical studies, the other
concerns raised are not evidence-based and are misconceptions. Conflicting results have been
reported regarding the impact of steroid-phobia on the compliance to ICS. In contrast, steroid-
phobia in parents has consistent and negative effects on asthma control in children. As of
and reduce steroid-phobia. Given the continually raising prevalence of paediatric asthma,
high-quality studies are warranted to investigate the prevalence and impact of steroid-phobia,
with an ultimate goal of developing effective strategies to tackle steroid-phobia and improve
EDUCTIONAL AIMS
asthma patients should be studied. The programmes and related interventional studies
paediatric population will require the understanding and input of patients and families
Mixed methods studies to incorporate both qualitative and quantitative data in order to
13
14
REFERENCES
[1] Papi, A., et al., Asthma. Lancet, 2018. 391(10122): p. 783-800.
[2] Wong, G.W., T.F. Leung, and F.W. Ko, Changing prevalence of allergic diseases in the Asia-
[3] Lau, Y.L. and J. Karlberg, Prevalence and risk factors of childhood asthma, rhinitis and
[4] Nunes, C., A.M. Pereira, and M. Morais-Almeida, Asthma costs and social impact. Asthma
[5] Szefler, S.J., Glucocorticoid therapy for asthma: clinical pharmacology. J Allergy Clin
[6] Rachelefsky, G., Inhaled corticosteroids and asthma control in children: assessing
[7] Castro-Rodriguez, J.A. and G.J. Rodrigo, Efficacy of inhaled corticosteroids in infants and
preschoolers with recurrent wheezing and asthma: a systematic review with meta-analysis.
[8] Suissa, S., P. Ernst, and A. Kezouh, Regular use of inhaled corticosteroids and the long term
[9] Suissa, S., et al., Low-dose inhaled corticosteroids and the prevention of death from asthma.
[10] Desager, K., F. Vermeulen, and E. Bodart, Adherence to asthma treatment in childhood and
[11] Tuft, L., "Steroid-phobia" in asthma management. Ann Allergy, 1979. 42(3): p. 152-9.
[12] Patterson, R., et al., Prednisonephobia. Allergy Proc, 1989. 10(6): p. 423-8.
[13] Patterson, R., P.A. Greenberger, and D.R. Patterson, Potentially fatal asthma: the problem of
[14] Boulet, L.P., Perception of the role and potential side effects of inhaled corticosteroids among
[15] Horne, R., J. Weinman, and M. Hankins, The beliefs about medicines questionnaire: The
development and evaluation of a new method for assessing the cognitive representation of
15
[16] Koster, E.S., et al., Uncontrolled asthma at age 8: the importance of parental perception
[17] Koster, E.S., et al., Inhaled corticosteroid adherence in paediatric patients: the PACMAN
[18] Conn, K.M., et al., The impact of parents' medication beliefs on asthma management.
[19] Conn, K.M., et al., Parental beliefs about medications and medication adherence among
[20] Ip, K.I., et al., Steroid phobia, Chinese medicine and asthma control. Clin Respir J, 2017.
[21] BinSaeed, A.A., Caregiver knowledge and its relationship to asthma control among children
[22] Zhao, J., et al., The knowledge, attitudes and practices of parents of children with asthma in
[23] Zedan, M.M., et al., Steroid Phobia among Parents of Asthmatic Children: Myths and Truth.
[24] Gazala, E., R. Sadka, and N. Bilenko, Parents' Fears and Concerns Toward Inhaled
Corticosteroid Treatment for Their Asthmatic Children. Pediatric Asthma, Allergy &
[25] Yoos, H.L., H. Kitzman, and A. McMullen, Barriers to anti-inflammatory medication use in
[26] Chan, P.W. and J.A. DeBruyne, Parental concern towards the use of inhaled therapy in
[27] Lim, S.H., et al., Parents' perceptions towards their child's use of inhaled medications for
[28] Koster, E.S., et al., Adolescents' inhaled corticosteroid adherence: the importance of
[29] Roncada, C., et al., Asthma treatment in children and adolescents in an urban area in
southern Brazil: popular myths and features. J Bras Pneumol, 2016. 42(2): p. 136-42.
[30] Zhang, L., S.O. Prietsch, and F.M. Ducharme, Inhaled corticosteroids in children with
persistent asthma: effects on growth. Cochrane Database Syst Rev, 2014(7): p. Cd009471.
[31] Pruteanu, A.I., et al., Inhaled corticosteroids in children with persistent asthma: dose-
16
[32] Szefler, S., et al., Long-term effects of budesonide or nedocromil in children with asthma. N
[33] Kelly, H.W., et al., Effect of inhaled glucocorticoids in childhood on adult height. N Engl J
[34] Loke, Y.K., et al., Impact of Inhaled Corticosteroids on Growth in Children with Asthma:
[35] Perkins, J.M., et al., Adult height, nutrition, and population health. Nutr Rev, 2016. 74(3): p.
149-65.
[36] Doull, I.J., The effect of asthma and its treatment on growth. Arch Dis Child, 2004. 89(1): p.
60-3.
[37] Pedersen, S., Long-term outcomes in paediatric asthma. Allergy, 2002. 57 Suppl 74: p. 58-74.
[38] Rizk, A.K., et al., Sex differences in the effects of inhaled corticosteroids on weight gain
[39] Kelly, H.W., et al., Effect of long-term corticosteroid use on bone mineral density in children:
[40] Sorva, R., et al., Effects of inhaled budesonide on serum markers of bone metabolism in
[41] Bahceciler, N.N., et al., Inhaled corticosteroids and bone density of children with asthma. J
[42] Gray, N., et al., Association Between Inhaled Corticosteroid Use and Bone Fracture in
[43] Schlienger, R.G., S.S. Jick, and C.R. Meier, Inhaled corticosteroids and the risk of fractures
[44] Loke, Y.K., et al., Bone mineral density and fracture risk with long-term use of inhaled
corticosteroids in patients with asthma: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ Open,
[45] Boyd, C.J., C.J. Teter, and S.E. McCabe, Pilot study of abuse of asthma inhalers by middle
[46] Boyd, C.J., S.E. McCabe, and C.J. Teter, Asthma inhaler misuse and substance abuse: a
random survey of secondary school students. Addict Behav, 2006. 31(2): p. 278-87.
17
[47] Rapaport, M.J. and M. Lebwohl, Corticosteroid addiction and withdrawal in the atopic: the
[48] Hajar, T., et al., A systematic review of topical corticosteroid withdrawal ("steroid addiction")
in patients with atopic dermatitis and other dermatoses. J Am Acad Dermatol, 2015. 72(3): p.
541-549.e2.
[49] Hederos, C.-A., Neuropsychologic changes and inhaled corticosteroids. Journal of Allergy
[50] de Vries, T.W., et al., Reported adverse drug reactions during the use of inhaled steroids in
children with asthma in the Netherlands. Eur J Clin Pharmacol, 2006. 62(5): p. 343-6.
oropharyngeal adverse events: results from a meta-analysis. Ann Allergy Asthma Immunol,
[52] Galvan, C.A. and J.C. Guarderas, Practical considerations for dysphonia caused by inhaled
[53] Phillip, M., et al., Integrated plasma cortisol concentration in children with asthma receiving
[54] Wyatt, R., et al., Effects of inhaled beclomethasone dipropionate and alternate-day
hypoglycaemia in asthmatics treated with inhaled fluticasone propionate. Arch Dis Child,
[56] Paton, J., et al., Adrenal responses to low dose synthetic ACTH (Synacthen) in children
receiving high dose inhaled fluticasone. Arch Dis Child, 2006. 91(10): p. 808-13.
[57] Todd, G.R., et al., Survey of adrenal crisis associated with inhaled corticosteroids in the
treated for asthma with inhaled corticosteroid. Paediatr Child Health, 2012. 17(5): p. e34-9.
associated with parental information and knowledge: the PIAMA birth cohort.
18
[60] Hon, K.L., et al., Paradoxical use of oral and topical steroids in steroid-phobic patients
[61] Coffman, J.M., et al., Effects of asthma education on children's use of acute care services: a
[62] Krishna, S., et al., Internet-enabled interactive multimedia asthma education program: a
[63] Lozano, P., et al., A multisite randomized trial of the effects of physician education and
organizational change in chronic-asthma care: health outcomes of the Pediatric Asthma Care
Patient Outcomes Research Team II Study. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med, 2004. 158(9): p. 875-
83.
[64] Shah, S., et al., Effect of peer led programme for asthma education in adolescents: cluster
[65] Chan, D.S., et al., Internet-based home monitoring and education of children with asthma is
comparable to ideal office-based care: results of a 1-year asthma in-home monitoring trial.
[66] Stevens, C.A., et al., Parental education and guided self-management of asthma and wheezing
in the pre-school child: a randomised controlled trial. Thorax, 2002. 57(1): p. 39-44.
[67] Hossny, E., et al., The use of inhaled corticosteroids in pediatric asthma: update. World
19