Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Treatment of Corner Node Problems and Its Singularity
Treatment of Corner Node Problems and Its Singularity
Treatment of Corner Node Problems and Its Singularity
Key words: Boundary element methods, boundary point element, comer node
problems, singular matrix, complementary equations.
e = 1 , 2 , . . . , M, with N boundary nodes. The displace- Substitution of the rigid body displacement into eqn
ment and traction fields on the boundary of the body (2) yields
can then be expressed in terms of the nodal values of dis-
placements and tractions through interpolation func-
tions. Thus, at each boundary node eqn (1) can finally
Ti~n = - E f'i~m (i,j= l,2; n= 1,2,...,N). (6)
m=l
be transformed to the following form: 4'5'11'14 rn~n
r'm+1:Om+2 Y
o~u
On
B
Qm-1 ~~'~~k" Qm" Qm+l ~ n2
nl
Fig. 4. Nodal positions for the boundary point element u=300 u=0
method.
at the same location. Applying the traction-stress rela-
tion of-~ = ai:ni to these two nodes, one obtains
llO'xx + mlCrxy = 7"xm, mltryy + lltrxy = 7"7 r X
au =0 A
On
12tYxx + m2ffxy = 7"2 +1 , m2O'yy + 12tYxy = 7"7 +1
(lO) Fig. 5. Boundary conditions of a square plate under steady
state heat conduction.
where (Ix, ml) and (12, m2) are the direction cosines of
outward normals to elements Fm_ l and Fm+1 (see Fro' )~(= 2"~-'E-)I-2u!and # are Lame's constants, and v is
Fig. 4). Here subscripts 1 and 2 refer to different Poisson's ratio. From strain-displacement relationship,
elements. 7"x
=, 7"y and 7"xm+ t, 7"ym+l are tractions at nodes transformation of coordinates, and the interpolation func-
Qm and Qm+x respectively. Solving stresses from eqn tions for linear elements, Cxx and eyy can be expressed as
(10) yields / m m-I m+2 m\
1 I , Ux - Ux_ llux --Ux
(Yxx = 1 (m27.xm- mlT.xm+l ) "xx=-'~'2" 2dm'~- I 2dm+l :
O~ (14)
m
1 u; - uyr n - I u m+'2
y-yy m\
a . = 1(1,7.7+1- 127"7) 'YY
= -- m2
a 2-din--~
-- ml
2dm+l }
1 (llTxm+l 127.xm) = 1 (m27.ym _ rnlrym+l) in which 2din_ 1 and 2din +x are the lengths of elements
Fro-1 and Fro+l; uT'-1, uT', and u~ +2 are the displace-
(ll) ments at nodes Qm-t, Qm, and Qm+2 (Fig. 4). Here,
where ~ = lira 2 - r o l l 2. Eqn. (ll) is applicable when up equals u,.m+l always. Substitution of eqn (14) into
l l / m ! ~ 12/m 2. If l l / m l = 12/m2, the two outward eqn (13) yields the second complementary equation as
normals to elements Fro-l and Fro+ I are parallel. This m2rxm - 12r7 -mlT. m+l + llrym+l =
implies that the boundary is smooth at nodes Q I and (15)
Qm+l, and thus the stresses can be calculated by an a - bx u m - I - byuy -1 - CxU~ +2 - cyu7 +2
ordinary procedure.
where
It is found that when displacements along one direc-
tion or along two directions are prescribed at both a = (bx + Cx)~mx + (by + cy)~'
nodes of a boundary point element, matrix A in eqn
(5) will become singular 5'13. To cope with thissingular- bx = (A + # ) 1 2 / d m - l , by = (A + # ) m 2 / d m - I
ity, one can keep the two equations in eqn (5) corre- cx = (A + # ) l l / d m + l , cy = (A + # ) m l / d m + l
sponding to either of the two nodes of the boundary
in which -uxmand -Uy"are the prescribed displacements at
point element and replace the other two equations with
node Qm. The condition of using eqns (11) and (15) is
two complementary equations. The first complementary
that the tractions and the direction cosines of outward
equation can be obtained from the third equation in eqn
normals at the corner must satisfy the relationship of
(11) as
eqn (12). Note that eqns (12) and (15) are valid for both
127"xm + rn27"~n - llT"xm+l - mlT"7 +1 = O. (12) plane strain and plane stress problems, but for plane
To have the second complementary equation, we first Table 1. Comparison of internal results on temperature for the
square plate
obtain the following equation from eqn (10) and
Hook's law: Point (a) (b) (d) (e) Exact
m27"m - 127"y
m -mlT.m+l + llT"y +l = xy
(13) 2 2 200.325 200.000 200.000 200.000 200
2a(A + #)(exx + eyy) 3 3 150.000 150.000 150.000 150.000 150
4 4 9 9 . 6 7 5 100.000 100.000 100.000 100
in which exx and eye are strains at boundary point element
Treatment o f corner node problems and its singularity 79
. . . . . _ . . . . . . . -50.13
4 NUMERICAL EXAMPLES
u [ ~ . 9 3 u ~ 2 , 0 7
- " / 2 0 0 , 0 99.97
228.07 ~u 298.0 ~u The aforementioned treatments of corner node pro-
blems are first applied to a steady-state heat conduction
problem. A 6 x 6 square plate with 4 corner nodes O, A,
~ - 4
-51.8
8 . 8
l___1-5o.oo
B, and C shown in Fig. 5 is analyzed. The boundary
conditions (temperature and heat flux) are also shown
in the figure. For comparison, different treatments of
/ _ 24.9 ~ ~.5 corner node problems are applied to the boundary
u ..~175.1124.9 u element analysis of the plate. In each case the linear
275.1 ~u 297.50(d ) ~9._.uu
(c) ~n ~n boundary element is used. The results of temperature u
at certain typical points are given and compared in
Table 1. Figure 6 shows the results of temperature
along O A and the heat flux along A C . Figure 6(a)
shows the results obtained from the method of con-
50 00 -50
tinuous boundary element with M B = N B = 16, where
M B and N B represent the total number of elements
300.00 300 and nodes respectively; Fig. 6(b) the method of two
(e) (f) Exact
nodes linked with a small element at corners using
Fig. 6. Comparison of the results obtained from different M B = N B = 16; Fig. 6(c) the discontinuous element
corner node treatments for the heat conduction in the square method with M B = 12 and N B = 24; Fig. 6(d) the
plate, composite boundary element method using constant
and linear elements with M B = 12 and N B = 16, and
stress problems v shall be replaced by v / ( l + v) in com-
Fig. 6(e) the boundary point element method with
puting A. For an incompressible material, i.e. v = 0.5,
M B = N B = 8. The results from the boundary point
the equations are not applicable.
element method have a higher accuracy even though
For potential problems, the governing equation is
the number of elements used in this method is less than
Au = 0, where A is the Laplace operator and u is a scalar
the other methods.
field such as a temperature field in a heat conduction
Another example of steady-state heat conduction
problem. When a temperature is prescribed at both
problem is a circular plate shown in Fig. 7. The plate
nodes of a boundary point element, matrix A will
has a hole at its center. The radius of the plate is 5 cm
become singular too. In this case, the above-mentioned
and the radius of the hole is 1 cm. A uniform tempera-
procedure in dealing with the singularity is still appli-
ture of 20°C is prescribed along the external surface
cable but now only one complementary equation is
and a uniform flux of 31.21°C/cm is given across the cir-
required:
cular hole. Only a quarter of the plate is considered
m2 rm -- ml'r m+l = a -- bu m - I _ CUre+2 (16) because of the symmetry but boundary elements are used
on the symmetry axes to study the corner node problems.
y
There are four corner nodes A, B, C, and D as shown in
the figure. Table 2 shows the comparison results obtained
from three methods: (a) method of continuous boundary
c element with M B = N B = 24, (b) composite boundary
Table 2. Comparison of results for the heat conduction in the
circular plate
Y 1 2 3 = 0.5, 4 1 = O,
Ux = Ux = Ux Tx = O, Uy
I. = = u4 : -0085
"CX
!l I+I+ {a}
"~x
~~ X
(b)
i: x
72 =
~.~= 0,
1, 2 = Ux
Ux
2
Uy
3 = 0.5,
= uy3 = -0.085,
Table 3. Comparison of results for the square plate subjected to a uniformly distributed load
Point x O.5 O.5 0 1 1 0
y 0 0.5 0.5 0 1 1
Ux (a) 0.2395 0.2679 0.0000 0.4879 0.8018 0.0000
(b) 0.2500 0.2500 0.0000 0.5000 0.5000 0.000
Exact 0.25 0.25 0 0.5 0.5 0
uy (a) -0.0000 -0.0309 -0.0160 0.0000 -0.2414 -0.0585
(b) 0.0000 -0.0425 -0.0425 0.0000 -0.0850 -0.850
Exact 0 -0.0425 -0.0425 0 -0.085 -0.085
axx (a) 0.9676 1.048 1.104 1.000 1.317 1.352
(b) 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000 1.000
Exact 1 1 1 1 1 1
O'yy (a) 0.0331 0.0651 0.0861 -0.2416 -0.0970 0.000
(b) 0.000 -0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.000
Exact 0 0 0 0 0 0
axy (a) 0.0000 0.0404 0.0000 0.0000 0.0970 0.000
(b) 0.0000 -0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000 0.0000
Exact 0 0 0 0 0 0
Treatment o f corner node problems and its singularity 81
Table 4. Comparison of stress results for the square plate with a at a comer node and the procedure for dealing with the
hole at the center subjected to a uniformly distributed load singularity of matrix A when displacements are pre-
Point x 0 0.5 4 scribed at both nodes of a boundary point element are
y 0.5 0 4 efficient and adequate.
Crxx (a) 2.914 0.000 1.315
(b) 2.981 0.000 1.000
Exact 3 0 1 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
~ryy (a) 0.000 -0.691 -0.100
(b) 0.000 -1.009 0.000 Financial support under National Science Foundation
Exact 0 - 1 0
Grant No. MSS-9114048 to Polytechnic University is
~xy (a) 0.000 0.000 O.100 gratefully acknowledged.
(b) 0.000 0.000 0.000
Exact 0 0 0
REFERENCES
In general, the non-conforming boundary element
methods can reach a better result than the conforming 1. Cruse, T. A. Application of the boundary integral
element methods in dealing with the corner node equation solution method in solid mechanics. In Varia-
problems, but the increase in the number of degrees of tional Methods in Engineering, Vol. 3, ed. C. A. Brebbia.
freedom is its disadvantage. Southampton University Press, Southampton, 1972.
2. Yan, G. & Ding, F. M. Basis of Boundary Element
It is found that the boundary point element method is
Methods, Press of Chongqing University, Chongqing,
an effective approach because better results can be 1986.
achieved by using fewer elements. This is due to the fact 3. Hartmann, F. Computing the C-matrix in non-smooth
that the boundary point element method simulates the boundary point, in new developments. In Boundary
actual situation at a geometric corner where the dis- Element Methods, ed. C. A. Brebbia. Butterworths,
placements are always continuous and the tractions can London, 1980, CML, Southampton, 1983.
4. Brebbia, C. A. & Walker, S. Boundary Element Techniques
be continuous or discontinuous depending on the speci- in Engineering. Butterworths, London, 1980.
fied boundary conditions. The boundary point element 5. Brebbia, C. A., TeUes, J. C. F. & Wrobel, L. C. Boundary
method is applicable not only to a linear element but also Element Techniques, Theory and Applications in Engineer-
to higher order elements such as a quadratic element. In ing. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1984.
the case of a higher order element, the linear boundary 6. Brebbia, C. A. The Boundary Element Method for
Engineers. Pentech Press, London, 1978.
point element can still be used at corners. In addition, 7. Patterson, C. & Sheikh, M. A. Interelement continuity in
the boundary point element method can be easily imple- the boundary element method. In Topics in Boundary
mented to an existing boundary element program by just Element Research, Vol. 1, ed. C. A. Brebbia. Springer-
adding one more type of element to the program. It is also Verlag, Berlin, 1984.
shown that the proposed formulae for calculating stresses 8. Yan, G. & Ding, F. M. Composite boundary element
methods, Journal of Numerical Methods and Computer
Applications, 1989 10(3).
V
9. Parreira, P. On the Accuracy of Continuous and Discontinu-
ous Boundary Elements, The 4th Congresso Nacional de
Mecdnica Tdorica e Aplicada, Coimbra, 1987.
10. Mitra, A. K. & Ingber, M. S. Resolving difficulties in the
BIEM caused by geometric comers and discontinuous
boundary conditions, in Boundary Elements IX, eds. C. A.
Brebbia, W.L. Wendland & G. Kuhn. Springer-Verlag,
q~x Berlin, 1987.
11. Du, Q. H. & Yao, Z. H. Some basic problems and
A engineering applications of boundary integral equation - -
xx .qk--- ( B
boundary element method in elasticity, Journal of Solid
Mechanics, 1982, 1, 1-22.
12. Banerjee, P. K. & Butterfieid, R. Boundary Element
Methods in Engineering Science. London, McGraw Hill,
1981.
13. Brebbia, C. A. Recent Advances in Boundary Element
Methods, Proc. 1st Int. Conference Boundary Element
Methods. Southampton University, Pentech Press,
London, 1978.
Fig. 9. Thin square plate with a circular hole at the center 14. Timoshenko, S. P. & Goodier, J. N. Theory of Elasticity,
subjected to a uniformly distributed load. 3rd edn. McGraw-Hill, New York, 1970.