Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ay253 - 2016 - Problem Set 1 Solutions
Ay253 - 2016 - Problem Set 1 Solutions
In regions not too far from the Earth (r . 10RE , where RE is the Earth radius), the geomagnetic
field can be approximated as a dipole field with magnetic moment ME ≈ 8.0 × 1025 erg G−1 (in
cgs units). In spherical polar coordinates (anti-)aligned with the Earth’s magnetic dipole moment,
the three field components are
ME
B=− (2 sin λ, cos λ, 0) , (1)
r3
where λ ≡ π/2 − θ is the latitude.
(1). Show that the equation for a field line is r = r0 cos2 λ, and compute how field strength varies
with λ along a field line. (5 pts).
(2). The Earth’s outer Van Allen Radiation Belt is filled with energetic particles (both electrons
and ions, 0.1 − 10 MeV) that are trapped, bouncing back and forth between mirror points. The
belt extends from about 3RE to 9RE , reaching its greatest intensity at about 4 − 5RE . For this
problem, we consider 3.0 × 104 km (∼ 4.7RE ) as a characteristic radius of the belt at equatorial
plane.
[2a]. Provide a rough estimate of maximum proton/electron energy (in units of eV) above which
guiding-center motion is no longer a good approximation. (5 pts)
Solution: Particle gyroradius must be much smaller than the scale at which magnetic field varies
(∼ RE ). Magnetic field strength at the equatorial plane is the weakest, corresponding to largest
gyro-radius. At R0 = 3 × 104 km, field strength is
ME
B(R0 ) ≈ ≈ 3 × 10−3 G . (5)
R03
1
Protons are non-relativistic, with gyro-radius
B −1
r
E
rL,i = 0.23RE . (7)
MeV mG
Thus, electron gyroradius is much smaller than RE unless their energy reaches GeV level. Proton
gyroradius becomes comparable to RE at a few tens of MeV.
[2b]. Particles would be lost due to collisions with neutrals if they manage to enter the Earth’s
atmosphere (thickness RE ). Compute the equatorial loss cone αleq : the critical particle pitch
angle in the equatorial plane below which particles would be lost. (5 pts)
Solution: Conservation of magnetic moment demands v⊥ 2 /B = const. Together with energy con-
2
servation, we have sin α/B = const. Given equatorial pitch angle αeq , mirror reflection occurs at
latitude λm , which satisifies
sin2 αeq 1
= . (8)
B(R0 , λ = 0) B(R0 , λm )
For critical pitch angle (loss cone), we further require
RE = R0 cos2 λm . (9)
[2c]. For trapped particles, provide a rough estimate of the bounce period τb between mirror
reflection points. (5 pts)
where ds is the arc length along the field line, and for dipole field we have
p p
ds/dλ = r 1 + 4 tan2 λ = R0 cos2 λ 1 + 4 tan2 λ . (12)
2
While this integral can not be evaluated analytically, numerical integrations show that it is of order
unity and varies by within a factor of 2 for λm between 0 and 90◦ (from ∼ 0.7 to ∼ 1.4). Therefore,
a reasonable approximation for τb is simply τb ≈ 4R0 /v. For non-relativistic ions, we have
−1/2
4R0 E
τb,i ∼ ∼ 8.7 s . (15)
vi MeV
(3). Trapped particles will also undergo curvature and grad-B drifts (ignore the E × B drift due
to the Earth’s rotation since it is negligible). Derive the combined curvature and grad-B drift
velocities for electrons and ions (assuming they are non-relativistic). What is the direction of the
drift? How does drift velocity depend on latitude? What are the drift timescales at the equatorial
plane for electrons and ions? (10 pts)
Hint: the curvature drift term in Equation (2.24) in Boyd & Sanderson is not rigorous, but is
applicable when field configuration is current-free (∇ × B ≈ 0) as in a vacuum dipole field. Start
from the standard expression for curvature drift given in the lecture, v c = b × vk2 (b · ∇)b/Ω, and
use the following identities for unit vector b:
to show (b · ∇)b = ∇⊥ B/B in the current-free limit, and then combine it with the grad-B drift
term.
Solution: The combined grad-B and curvature drift velocities are given by
2
1 µ 2 1 v⊥ 2
Vd = b× ∇B + vk (b · ∇)b = b × ∇B + vk (b · ∇)b . (18)
Ω m Ω 2B
Since the (vacuum) dipole field is current-free (we assume the field is unaffected by the ring current,
which is generally a good approximation), or ∇ × B ≈ 0, thus
b 1 ∇⊥ B
(b · ∇)b ≈ × [(∇B) × b] = [∇B − b(b · ∇B)] = . (20)
B B B
Substituting back to (18), we obtain
2 /2 + v 2
v⊥ k mv 2 c
Vd= (B × ∇B) = (1 + cos2 α)(B × ∇B)
ΩB 2 2qB 3 (21)
2Ek c
= (1 − B/2Bm )(B × ∇B)
qB 3
3
Note that because of different sign of charge, electrons and ions drift towards opposite directions.
Computing total field strength and its gradient is straightforward
ME p 3M E 2
B= 3 1 + 3 cos2 θ , ∇B = √ 1 + 3 cos θ, sin θ cos θ, 0 . (22)
r r4 1 + 3 cos2 θ
The resulting drift velocity is
Therefore, particles drift in the azimuthal direction. The ions drift westward (negative drift ve-
locity), while electrons drift eastward. Such drift motion creates a net current known as the ring
current. The drift velocity depends sensitively on latitude (due to the cos5 λ factor) and hence the
ring current is concentrated in the equator. At the equator, we have
6Ek cr02 r0 2 Ek
B 6Ek c
v eq
d = (1 − )≈ 2
≈ 4.9 × 10 km s −1
(24)
qME 2Bm qBr 4RE MeV
In reality, particles only spend a fraction of time near the equatorial plane where the drift is the
fastest, and (25) underestimates the drift timescale by a factor of ∼ 3. Therefore, it typically
takes an hour for these energetic particles to complete one cycle of drift around the Earth. While
relativistic correction is needed for electrons, the derivations above suffices for our purposes.
The goal of this problem is to show that ideal MHD conserves energy. We will do this by finding
equations governing the evolution of magnetic, internal, and kinetic energy in conservative form:
∂
(stuff) + ∇ · (flux of stuff) = (sources − sinks) (26)
∂t
For reference, the equations of MHD that you may need are:
∂B
= −c∇ × E (27)
∂t
c
J = ∇×B (28)
4π
∂V J×B
ρ + ρ (V · ∇) V = − ∇p (29)
∂t c
V×B
E+ = 0 (30)
c
∇·B = 0 (31)
∂p
+ V · ∇p + γp∇ · V = 0 (32)
∂t
4
2
(a) The magnetic energy density is given by B
8π . Start from Faraday’s law and derive an equation
for the time evolution of magnetic energy
2 density in terms of the Poynting flux, electric field, and
current density. Hint: 4π · ∂t = ∂t B
B ∂B ∂
8π . You will need vector identities and Ampere’s law. (8
pts)
∂ B2
c
= − [∇ · (E × B) + E · (∇ × B)]
∂t 8π 4π
Then use Ampere’s law for the last term on the RHS and rearrange to get
∂ B2
cE × B
+∇· = −E · J
∂t 8π 4π
p
(b) The internal energy density is given by γ−1 . Start from the energy equation and derive an
equation for the time evolution of the thermal energy density. You will need the vector identity
f ∇ · A ≡ −A · ∇f + ∇ · (f A), but no other equations from MHD. In the conservation equation, the
divergence should be taken of not just the internal energy flux but also contain the contribution
from work done on/by the plasma through pressure gradients forces. (8 pts)
2
(c) The kinetic energy density is given by ρV2 . Start from the momentum equation and derive
an equation for the time evolution of kinetic energy density (recalling the hint from part a). You
will need the continuity equation (multiplied by some factor) to get the additional terms from
5
∂ ρV 2
evaluating ∂t 2 with the product rule. You will need the ideal Ohm’s law to put it terms of a
2
Poynting flux, that A · (A · ∇A) = A · ∇ A2 , and the vector identity A · (B × C) = −(B × A) · C.
(8 pts)
Let’s take the time derivative of ρV 2 /2 to see what cross terms we need:
∂ ρV 2 V 2 ∂ρ ∂ V2
= +ρ
∂t 2 2 ∂t ∂t 2
This suggests that we will need to multiply the continuity equation by V 2 /2. Add the continuity
equation times V 2 /2:
∂ V2
2
V 2 ∂ρ
V
ρ + ρV · ∇ + + ∇ · (ρV) = E · J − V · ∇p
∂t 2 2 2 ∂t
∂ V2 V 2 ∂ρ
2
V2
V
ρ + + ρV · ∇ + ∇ · (ρV) = E · J − V · ∇p
∂t 2 2 ∂t 2 2
| {z } | {z }
ρV 2 ρV 2
∂
∂t 2
∇· 2
V
Combine the first and second terms, and the third and fourth terms on the LHS with the product
rule:
∂ ρV 2
2
ρV
+∇· V = E · J − V · ∇p
∂t 2 2
(d) From parts (a)–(c), you should have three equations which add up to
∂ B 2 ρV 2
2
p ρV p cE × B
+ + +∇· V+ V + pV + = 0, (33)
∂t 8π 2 γ−1 2 γ−1 4π
indicating that total energy is conserved. For each of the equations derived in parts (a)–(c), there
should be source and sink terms that show up on the right hand side that cancel when you add the
equations. What do each of these source and sink terms physically represent? (6 pts)
6
• The term E · J represents the transfer between magnetic energy and kinetic energy. It is the
work done by electromagnetic forces on the plasma. (Note that this is true in ideal MHD.
When resistivity is considered, the additional E · J leads to Joule heating where E = J /σ,
and σ is electric conductivity.)
• The term V · ∇p represents the transfer between kinetic energy and internal energy. It is the
work done by pressure gradients to accelerate or decelerate the plasma.