a.

)
1
Machines Processing time
b 2
g 2

2
Machines Processing time
f 2
g 2
a 2

3
Machines Processing time
b 2
a 2
f 2
g 2

4
Machines Processing time
j 2
k 2
l 2

5
Machines Processing time
i 2
e 2
c 2

6
Machines Processing time
c 2
e 2
i 2
h 2

7
Machines Processing time
k 2
d 2
l 2

8
Machines Processing time
l 2
j 2

9
Machines Processing time
k 2
d 2
j 2

10
Machines Processing time
f 2
g 2

11
Machines Processing time
e 2
h 2
 12
Machines Processing time
f 2
b 2
a 2
 b.) Teoritis
Mesin Jumlah Mesin
utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin a 1.81255004541
95% 90% 2% 3748.438151 3673.469388 0.91336212251 1 b 2.00176788308
95% 90% 2% 3673.469388 3600 0.89509488006 1 c 0.20760984372
d 0.365344849
e 0.32765053919
utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin f 1.8543218647
95% 90% 2% 3187.447407 3123.698459 0.77666847152 1 g 2.68061634488
95% 90% 2% 3123.698459 3061.22449 0.76113510209 1 h 0.25858296535
95% 90% 2% 3061.22449 3000 0.74591240005 1 i 0.20421203011
j 0.41032845132
k 0.4362287915
utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin l 0.45135311554
95% 90% 2% 4336.663139 4249.929876 1.05669179799 2 Total 12
95% 90% 2% 4249.929876 4164.931279 1.03555796203 2
95% 90% 2% 4164.931279 4081.632653 1.01484680279 2 Process Layout
95% 90% 2% 4081.632653 4000 0.99454986673 1 c.) Mesin
a
b
utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin c
95% 90% 2% 265.6206173 260.3082049 0.06472237263 1 d
95% 90% 2% 260.3082049 255.1020408 0.06342792517 1 e
95% 90% 2% 255.1020408 250 0.06215936667 1 f
g
h
utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin i
95% 90% 2% 254.9957926 249.8958767 0.06213347772 1 j
95% 90% 2% 249.8958767 244.8979592 0.06089080817 1 k
95% 90% 2% 244.8979592 240 0.059672992 1 l

Terdapat perbedaan besar p

 Terdapat perbedaan besar p
utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin
95% 90% 2% 607.1328395 594.9901827 0.14793685172 1
95% 90% 2% 594.9901827 583.090379 0.14497811468 1
95% 90% 2% 583.090379 571.4285714 0.14207855239 1
95% 90% 2% 571.4285714 560 0.13923698134 1

utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin
95% 90% 2% 849.9859752 832.9862557 0.20711159241 1
95% 90% 2% 832.9862557 816.3265306 0.20296936056 1
95% 90% 2% 816.3265306 800 0.19890997335 1

utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin
95% 90% 2% 780.9246147 765.3061224 0.19028377552 1
95% 90% 2% 765.3061224 750 0.18647810001 1

utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin
95% 90% 2% 679.9887802 666.3890046 0.16568927392 1
95% 90% 2% 666.3890046 653.0612245 0.16237548845 1
95% 90% 2% 653.0612245 640 0.15912797868 1

utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin
95% 90% 2% 124.9479384 122.4489796 0.03044540408 1
95% 90% 2% 122.4489796 120 0.029836496 1

utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin
95% 90% 2% 499.7917534 489.7959184 0.12178161633 1
95% 90% 2% 489.7959184 480 0.11934598401 1
utility due to breakdown Efficiency Scrap Rate Nil Nol Nml Jumlah mesin
95% 90% 2% 132.8103086 130.1541025 0.03236118631 1
95% 90% 2% 130.1541025 127.5510204 0.03171396259 1
95% 90% 2% 127.5510204 125 0.03107968334 1
 Process Layout Product Layout
Jumlah mesin Jumlah Mesin
2 4 Terdapat perbedaan besar di jumlah mesin yaitu product layout > process layout ( 37>17) sehingga dari
segi biaya process layout memiliki biaya yang lebih kecil sedangkan dari segi penjadwalan, process
3 4 layout memerlukan penjadwalan karena ada beberapa produk yang harus berbagi mesin dengan
1 2 produk lainnya.
1 2
1 3
2 5
3 4
1 2
1 2
1 3
1 3
1 3
18 37

Product Layout
Mesin Terpakai Mesin dibeli Utilitas mesin Mesin Mesin Terpakai Mesin dibeli Utilitas mesin
1.81255004541 2 91% a 1.81255004541 4 45%
2.001767883081 3 67% b 2.001767883081 4 50%
0.207609843722 1 21% c 0.207609843722 2 10%
0.365344849003 1 37% d 0.365344849003 2 18%
0.327650539185 1 33% e 0.327650539185 3 11%
1.854321864703 2 93% f 1.854321864703 5 37%
2.680616344879 3 89% g 2.680616344879 4 67%
0.25858296535 1 26% h 0.25858296535 2 13%
0.204212030112 1 20% i 0.204212030112 2 10%
0.410328451315 1 41% j 0.410328451315 3 14%
0.436228791504 1 44% k 0.436228791504 3 15%
0.451353115539 1 45% l 0.451353115539 3 15%
rata rata 50% rata rata 25%

dapat perbedaan besar pula dengan rata-rata persentase pemakaian mesin dari process layout > product layout ( 50%>25%)sehingga
penggunaan process layout lebih direkomendasikan
dapat perbedaan besar pula dengan rata-rata persentase pemakaian mesin dari process layout > product layout ( 50%>25%)sehingga
penggunaan process layout lebih direkomendasikan