J Scienta 2008 06 024

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

Scientia Horticulturae 118 (2008) 308–313

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Scientia Horticulturae
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/scihorti

Effect of calcium based fertilization on dried fig (Ficus carica L. cv. Sarılop) yield
and quality
Mehmet Eşref İrget a, Uygun Aksoy b,*, Bülent Okur a, Ali Rıza Ongun a, Mahmut Tepecik a
a
Ege University Faculty of Agriculture, Department of Soil Science, 35100 Bornova-I˙zmir, Turkey
b
Ege University Faculty of Agriculture, Department of Horticulture, 35100 Bornova-I˙zmir, Turkey

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Article history: Fig tree mainly spread in regions where Mediterranean climate prevails can be grown over a wide range
Received 17 December 2007 of soils without any significant deficiency or toxicity symptoms of plant nutrients. Surveys revealed that,
Received in revised form 14 May 2008 however, quality is highly affected by nutrition especially N, K and Ca in fig production for commercial
Accepted 13 June 2008
drying. This research work was initiated based on few studies performed on fertilization of fig. The
experiment was performed between 2000 and 2002 in three fig orchards of cv. Sarılop (syn. Calimyrna) in
Keywords:
Aydın-Turkey. Trees received seven types of fertilization as (i) untreated control; (ii) NPK (430 g N, 200 g
Fig
P2O5 and 430 g K2O per tree); (iii) NPK + 70 g Ca; (iv) NPK + 140 g Ca; (v) NPK + 280 g Ca; (vi)
Fertilization
Calcium
NPK + 420 g Ca and (vii) N + 420 g Ca, Ca(NO3)2 used as the Ca source. Tested fertilizer applications
Fruit quality showed significant differences in respect to yield and quality of fig. Basic NPK fertilization with additional
Yield 280 g Ca treatment increased overall quality by reducing the number of fruit with ostiole-end crack and
Sunscald sunscald. Results showed that applied fertilizers exerted significantly in reduction of cull ratio and could
Ostiole-end crack alleviate the negative impact of yearly drought conditions.
ß 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.

1. Introduction Currently, most of the orchards are located on slopes and fig is


produced as low-input system under rain-fed conditions.
The fig tree (Ficus carica L.) is one of the unique Ficus species Very little research work has been carried out world-wide on fig
widely spread in tropical and subtropical countries which has tree fertilization (Proebsting and Warner, 1954; Hernandez et al.,
edible fruits with high commercial value. Commercial fig produc- 1994). Taking this into consideration, some of the results obtained
tion is either located around the Mediterranean Sea or is realized in in these research papers are summarized.
countries possessing Mediterranean climate as in the case of Aksoy (1981) reported that N, P, K and Ca concentration
California, Australia or South America. In Turkey, the major fig decreased from the initial stage of fruit growth up to the end of the
producer, around 65% of fig trees are in the western Aegean Region harvesting period. Kabasakal (1983) recommended beginning of
especially in Small and Big Meander valleys. The major variety the fruit maturation period for sampling fig leaves as the most
grown in this region is Sarılop (syn. Calimyrna) which is stable period in respect to nutrients.
commercially sun dried (Aksoy et al., 1987, 2001). Brown (1994) examined seasonal variation of plant nutrients in
Sarılop variety is known world-wide for its superior dried fruit Calimyrna (Sarılop) variety and reported reduction in N, P and K
quality. Climatic conditions prevailing in the Meander Basin concentrations through out the season whereas increases in Ca
especially in summer during fruit maturation and drying period and Mg.
play a crucial role on final quality. As a consequence, in the Meander Aksoy and Anaç (1994) applied CaCl2 (1%) as foliar spray towards
Basin almost all fruit go for sun-drying whereas fig fruits produced in the end of the secondfruitgrowth period on trees of three fig varieties,
other regions are sold for the fresh market (Aksoy et al., 1987, 2001). Bursa Black, Göklop and Sarılop known to have variable tendency for
Until the 1950s, fig occupied lowland orchards however after the ostiole-end cracking as resistant, susceptible and intermediate,
introduction of irrigation fig trees were replaced by high value crops. respectively. CaCl2 application decreased crack ratio significantly in
Göklop and increased sunscald slightly in Sarılop variety.
Moreno et al. (1998) determined the minimum, optimal and
* Corresponding author. Fax: +90 232 388 18 65. maximum levels of N, P, K, Ca, Mg and S in fig leaves in a 4-year
E-mail address: uygun.aksoy@ege.edu.tr (U. Aksoy). research carried out in Granada-Spain.

0304-4238/$ – see front matter ß 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.scienta.2008.06.024
M.E. I˙rget et al. / Scientia Horticulturae 118 (2008) 308–313 309

İrget et al. (1999) examined foliar application of Ca, K and K + Ca growing district in western Turkey. The experimental orchards
in nitrate form on fruit quality of Sarılop variety. Potassium have typic Xerofluvent (alluvial) soils. Data related to the
application affected fruit size, colour and firmness positively and experimental sites and physical and chemical soil properties are
Ca application decreased ostiole-end cracks. displayed in Tables 1 and 2, respectively.
Hakerlerler et al. (1999) applied six levels of ZnSO47H2O The climatic condition prevailing in the experimental site is
ranging between 0 and 600 g as soil and five levels (0.0–0.2%) as typical Mediterranean climate with dry and hot summers and mild
foliar application. The applications had significant effects on yield, and rainy winters. The annual rainfall calculated for 1999–2000
lamina Zn concentration, shoot length and fruit quality especially season (October–June), 2000–2001 and 2001–2002 are 512.0,
on colour and sugar content. 436.6 and 778.7 mm, respectively. The precipitation during the
Şahin (2003) evaluated aflatoxin and ochratoxin A formation in fruit growth period (July–September) were 20.3, 2.7 and 96.0 mm
dried figs produced in Big and Small Meander basins and proposed in 2000, 2001 and 2002 summers, respectively.
that toxin formation was significantly related with fruit size and
sunscald. 2.2. Fertilization programmes and experimental design
Most of the other research work on fig nutrition is based on
surveys monitoring nutritional status of fig trees (Aksoy et al., The experiment was designed as randomized blocks with three
1987; Anaç et al., 1987, 1992; Eryüce et al., 1987; Düzbastılar and replicates, each replicate possessing two trees. The tree vigour was
Güleç, 1995; Aşkın et al., 1997), and few evaluated their relation- almost similar, and the average canopy diameter was 6.81 m in
ship with fruit yield and quality (Aksoy et al., 1987; Anaç et al., Kanlıbahçe and 5.95 m in Erbeyli. The treatments tested in the
1992). Studies carried out in Turkey revealed nutrition related experiment are as follows:
problems especially in respect to N, K, Ca and B.
Aksoy et al. (1987) and Anaç et al. (1992) reported as a (1) control (no treatment),
conclusion of surveys that K enhances fruit taste and colour, (2) NPK,
reduces sunscald in fruits, but excess levels promote ostiole-end (3) NPK + 70 g Ca,
crack/split in fruits, whereas Ca reduces ostiole-end crack, but in (4) NPK + 140 g Ca,
case of excess triggers sunscald, reduces fruit size and darkens fruit (5) NPK + 280 g Ca,
colour. (6) NPK + 420 g Ca,
Sunscald and ostiole-end cracks are accepted as defects if they (7) N + 420 g Ca.
go over 1/3 of the surface area or length, respectively according to
the Turkish dried fig standard (TS 541). Defected fruits are removed All trees, except untreated control (1st) and the 7th treatment,
from parties destined for human consumption and thus increase received N, P and K at levels fixed as 430 g N/tree; 200 g P2O5/tree
the cost. Even if the area affected by sunscald is negligible, it may and 430 g K2O/tree. The 7th treatment was included to investigate
modify the taste and palatability and cracks may provide the combined effect of Ca and N under the absence of additional P
additional entrance for insects and fungi. and K. As Ca source Ca (NO3)2 (15.5% N + 26% CaO), as N source Ca
Taking into consideration marked effect of Ca nutrition on yield (NO3)2 and NH4NO3 (33% N), as P source DAP (18-46-0) and as K
and quality of Sarılop (Calimyrna) fig variety, a research was source K2SO4 (0-0-50) was used. Fertilizers were applied yearly as
designed to test the effects of additional soil Ca application two parallel lines on all four sides of the tree at a depth of 10–15 cm
combined with a basic dressing composed of N, P and K or N alone during the period between end-February to mid-March. To avoid
on. mixing of fertilizers, fertilizer containing Ca was applied to one
line, and N, P and K fertilizers to the second line.
2. Materials and methods
2.3. Data collection and statistical analysis
2.1. Experimental material and conditions
Partially shrivelled fig fruits falling onto the ground from each
The trial is carried out in 3 Sarılop (syn. Calimyrna) fig orchards tree were collected separately and further dried on drying trays.
between 2000 and 2002 in two locations in Aydın, the major fig Cull fig fruits defined as defected in Turkish TS 541 (Anonymous,

Table 1
Background information related to the experimental orchards

Location Geographic location Tree age Tree training Irrigation Fertilization Initial conditions/problems
0 00
1. Kanlıbahçe 37851 57 1N >60 Multitrunk 1–2 times Only N fertilizers Yield moderate, internal rot,
darkening of fruit colour right after harvest
278350 0400 7E

2. Erbeyli 378510 5300 1N >30 Single trunk Rain-fed None High cull ratio
278390 5600 0E

Table 2
Soil properties of fig orchards located in Kanlıbahçe in Germencik (1) and in Erbeyli (2) (Aydın/Turkey)

Location Soil depth (cm) Texture pH CaCO3 (%) CEC (cmolc kg1) OM (%) TotalN (%) P (mg kg1) K Ca Mg

(1) Kanlıbahçe 0–24 Sandy loam 7.04 0.55 14.84 1.52 0.084 1.20 167 2071 356
49–75 Loam 7.50 3.53 24.16 1.68 0.067 0.67 137 3684 472

(2) Erbeyli 0–20 Sandy loam 7.54 1.07 11.74 0.67 0.031 2.95 134 1714 235
60–80 Sand 7.85 2.72 4.14 0.21 0.028 1.18 33 437 174

P: water extractable P by the Bingham; OM: organic matter; K-Ca-Mg: 1N NH4OAc pH 7; CEC: cation exchange capacity.
310 M.E. I˙rget et al. / Scientia Horticulturae 118 (2008) 308–313

Table 3
Quality classes in evaluating sun-scald and crack index

Class Crack Sunscald

0 None No cracking None No sunscald


1 Slight Less than 1/3 of fruit length Slight Sun scalded area less than 1/3 of fruit surface

2 Medium Between 1/3–2/3 of fruit length Medium Area between 1/3–2/3 of fruit surface
0
3 Severe More than 2/3 of fruit length Severe More than 2/3 of the fruit surface

2006) and UN/ECE Dried Fig Standards (Anonymous, 2004) were year irrespective of the location. In 2001, total yields were reduced
removed and weighed. Total yield per tree was calculated at the by 26.0 and 19.1%, respectively in Kanlıbahçe and Erbeyli
end of the season. Marketable yield was calculated as the compared to other years of the experiment.
difference between total yield and cull figs. Cull ratio was
calculated as cull/total fruit yield. The number of trunks and 3.1.2. Marketable yield
canopy diameters were also determined to assess tree vigour. The lowest marketable yield values as it is for the total yield
Fruit samples were taken during the harvest period, and were obtained in control parcels as 21.60 and 10.94 kg/tree
physical parameters as average fruit weight (g), cracked (split) or (Table 5) in Kanlıbahçe and Erbeyli, respectively. The highest
sun scalded fruit ratios were analyzed on 15–20 fresh fruit samples marketable yields were in NPK treatment in Kanlıbahçe (26.91 kg/
taken per tree. Fruit maturation was monitored in all trees in both tree) and in NPK + 280 g Ca (16.57 kg/tree) treatment in Erbeyli.
years. Two trained panelists evaluated ostiole-end crack (split) and N + Ca application alone improved marketable yield compared to
sun scalded fruit ratio twice during the harvest period, and the control in both locations. In respect to marketable yield, the
results are expressed as the average of the two. Evaluation of crack difference among treatments other than the control was not
and sunscald rate was made visually according to the 0–3 scale statistically significant in Kanlıbahçe. In Erbeyli, Ca application
(Table 3) and average index values were calculated according to ranging between 70 and 420 g/tree in addition to NPK resulted in
the numbers of fruits in each quality classes. significantly higher marketable yields compared to control, NPK
The trials were set up in three orchards, two of which were and N + Ca applications. The varying responses to the treatments
located next to each other in Kanlıbahçe/Germencik (location 1) between the two locations can be due to the different soil
yielding similar effects therefore average was taken for two years properties. As presented in Table 2, the organic matter, CEC, total N,
in 2000 and 2001. A parallel trial was performed in Erbeyli, as the
third orchard in 2001 and 2002 (location 2). Analysis of variance Table 4
Total dried fig yield (kg/tree) obtained with tested treatments
was applied to data obtained separately in each location for two
years and averages calculated for each location were compared by Treatment Total Yield (kg/tree)
Tukey test (p  0.05) using SAS program (SAS, 2006).
Kanlıbahçe Erbeyli

3. Results and discussion 1. Control 26.38 b 15.84 c


2. NPK 30.87 a 17.87 bc
3. NPK + 70 g Ca 29.44 ab 18.51 abc
3.1. Total and marketable yield 4. NPK + 140 g Ca 29.31 ab 20.43 ab
5. NPK + 280 g Ca 29.28 ab 20.92 a
The tested treatments yielded significant differences in respect 6. NPK + 420 g Ca 30.71 a 19.19 ab
7. N + 420 g Ca 29.70 ab 18.21 abc
to total and marketable dried fig yields.
Tukey 3.35 2.89

3.1.1. Total yield Year 1 33.76 a (2000) 16.85 b (2001)


Year 2 25.00 b (2001) 20.57 a (2002)
In both locations, the lowest yields were obtained in untreated
Tukey 1.74 1.00
control trees as 26.38 and 15.84 kg/tree (Table 4). On the other
hand, the highest yields were obtained with NPK application as Year  treatment (p > F) ns ns
30.87 kg/tree in Kanlıbahçe and NPK + 280 g Ca applications in
Erbeyli as 20.92 kg/tree. NPK + Ca or N + Ca applications did not
have any additional affect on yield in both locations except
Table 5
NPK + 280 g Ca in Erbeyli. The average yield values in both Marketable yield (kg/tree) obtained with tested treatments
locations were within the limits reported by Hakerlerler et al.
Treatment Marketable yield (kg/tree)
(1999) as 14.5 and 22.1 kg/tree.
There are many factors known to affect fruit yield and quality in Kanlıbahçe Erbeyli
fig trees as soil, climatic conditions, cultural practices, e.g. pruning,
1. Control 21.60 b 10.94 d
irrigation, fertilization, plant protection and caprification (Aksoy 2. NPK 26.91 a 13.41 c
et al., 2001). In Sarılop variety caprification is the major factor 3. NPK + 70 g Ca 25.59 a 14.65 abc
affecting fruit set and thus yield, however, shoot length and 4. NPK + 140 g Ca 25.49 a 16.19 ab
5. NPK + 280 g Ca 25.63 a 16.57 a
number of buds per shoots are reported to be related with yield
6. NPK + 420 g Ca 26.86 a 15.29 abc
(Aksoy et al., 1987; Anaç et al., 1992). Based upon the correlations 7. N + 420 g Ca 25.92 a 13.86 bc
obtained in surveys, the researchers mention that nitrogen triggers Tukey 3.12 2.36
shoot growth and tree vigour, increases number of fruits but in
Year 1 30.83 a (2000) 12.18 b (2001)
case of excess levels, reduce fruit quality. The results of the Year 2 20.13 b (2001) 16.64 a (2002)
experiment support these findings that point out the key role of Tukey 1.093 0.82
nitrogen in respect to total yield. Yearly conditions had marked
Year  treatment (p > F) ns ns
effects and the yields obtained in 2001 were lower than the other
M.E. I˙rget et al. / Scientia Horticulturae 118 (2008) 308–313 311

Table 6 Table 7
Average fruit weight (g) Average ostiole-end crack index calculated according to 0 to 3 scale

Treatment Average fruit weight (g) Treatment Ostiole-end crack/split index

Kanlıbahçe Erbeyli Kanlıbahçe Erbeyli

1. Control 16.15 14.43 c Mean 2001 2002 Mean


2. NPK 17.02 15.02 bc
3. NPK + 70 g Ca 16.54 16.48 a 1. Control 1.50 a 1.33 a 1.78 a 1.56 a
4. NPK + 140 g Ca 16.81 16.02 ab 2. NPK 1.40 ab 1.17 a 1.54 ab 1.36 ab
5. NPK + 280 g Ca 17.14 16.24 a 3. NPK + 70 g Ca 1.32 bc 0.92 b 1.25 bc 1.09 bc
6. NPK + 420 g Ca 16.92 15.50 ab 4. NPK + 140 g Ca 1.37 b 0.83 b 1.13 c 0.98 c
7. N + 420 g Ca 16.85 15.65 ab 5. NPK + 280 g Ca 1.33 bc 0.92 b 1.13 c 1.02 c
Tukey ns 1.00 6. NPK + 420 g Ca 1.29 bc 1.17 ab 1.05 c 1.11 bc
7. N + 420 g Ca 1.21 c 1.21 ab 1.00 c 1.11 bc
Year 1 16.98 (2000) 15.18 b (2001) Tukey 0.15 0.41 0.41 0.31
Year 2 16.78 (2001) 16.05 a (2002)
Tukey ns 0.35 Year 1 1.36 b (2000) 1.08 b (2001)
Year 2 1.58 a (2001) 1.27 a (2002)
Year  treatment (p > F) ns ns Tukey 0.06 0.13

Year  treatment (p > F) ns 0.05*

available K and Ca contents are lower in Erbeyli compared to alities, environmental or cultural factors are also known to affect
Kanlıbahçe especially below 20 cm depth, around the root zone. fruit cracking (Opara et al., 1997). Cracking is not yet fully
This data emphasizes the need to evaluate site specific conditions investigated in fig fruits, however, previous studies based on
especially soil properties thoroughly prior to any further recom- observations and surveys display that ostiole-end cracking of fig
mendations regarding plant nutrition. fruit is linked with variety, climatic conditions, soil properties
In Kanlıbahçe, average marketable yield was 30.83 kg/tree in (lime and available Ca content) and nutritional status, especially Ca
2000 and decreased by 34.7% to 20.13 kg/tree in 2001. In Erbeyli, (Aksoy et al., 1987, 2001). Shear (1971) also reported that
there was a 26.80% difference in marketable yield obtained deficiency of Ca and B may lead to development of fruit crack,
between 2001 and 2002. while high N would intensify the disorder.
Soil Ca applications are generally regarded as insufficient to
3.2. Fruit quality increase fruit Ca concentration, thereby in overcoming physiological
disorders related to Ca (Mengel and Kirkby, 2001; Poovaiah et al.,
Fig fruit quality was assessed by determining the average fruit 1988; Bangerth, 1979). Ca related metabolic disorders are attributed
weight, ratios of fruit with ostiole-end crack or sunscald and cull to uneven distribution of Ca within the plant rather than Ca uptake
fruit ratio. by the plants. As a consequence, in general foliar Ca applications are
recommended rather than soil applications. The results obtained
3.2.1. Average fruit weight regarding the increases in fruit Ca concentration and consequent
Tested treatments had marked effects on average fruit weight in reduction in ostiole-end cracks through soil Ca applications point
Erbeyli, and additional Ca increased fruit weight compared to out that fig fruit can be highly responsive to soil available Ca or
control, however, the impact was not statistically significant in benefit from soil Ca applications by higher extraction and
Kanlıbahçe (Table 6). In both trials, the untreated control parcels translocation capacity. This can be a case specific for the fig tree
gave the smallest fruit weight with 16.15 g in Kanlıbahçe and since fig fruit is known to be highly rich in Ca compared to other
14.43 g in Erbeyli. Largest fruit were obtained by the addition of Ca fruits (Anonymus, 2002; Aksoy et al., 1987; Anaç et al., 1992), thus
as 280 g to NPK in Kanlıbahçe (17.14 g/fruit) and as 70 g in Erbeyli it is worth to investigate calcium nutrition of fig fruit more in depth
(16.48 g/fruit). The average fruit weight of Sarılop dried fig fruits is in order to contribute to other fruit species, as well. The additional
reported to range between 10.2 and 28.2 g (Aksoy et al., 1987; Anaç additive effects of Ca application in the following years in
et al., 1992; Şahin, 2003). Dried fruit weight varies in Sarılop
cultivar according to the number of fruits on the tree, yearly Table 8
climatic conditions or cultural practices applied (Aksoy et al., Average sunscald index calculated according to 0–3 scale
2001). Dried fruit size is the major factor in determining price of Treatment Sunscald index
dried fig fruits especially for direct consumption. In both locations,
Kanlıbahçe Erbeyli
average fruit weight was decreased at Ca levels exceeding
NPK + 280Ca therefore addition of Ca around this optimum level Mean 2001 2002 Mean
can be recommended to obtain higher fruit weight and thus higher
1. Control 1.73 a 1.92 a 1.71 a 1.82 a
prices. Yearly conditions also put forth significant effects on fruit 2. NPK 1.49 c 1.83 ab 1.38 b 1.61 ab
size in Erbeyli, larger fruits (16.05 g) being obtained in 2002 3. NPK + 70 g Ca 1.54 bc 1.58 b 1.25 b 1.42 b
compared to 2001 (15.18 g) (Table 6). 4. NPK + 140 g Ca 1.59 ab 1.67 ab 1.38 b 1.53 ab
5. NPK + 280 g Ca 1.66 ac 1.83 ab 1.21 b 1.52 ab
6. NPK + 420 g Ca 1.70 a 1.75 ab 1.21 b 1.48 ab
3.2.2. Ostiole-end crack 7. N + 420 g Ca 1.74 a 1.92 a 1.46 ab 1.69 ab
Tested treatments and yearly conditions had significant effects Tukey 0.15 0.32 0.32 0.21
on fruit with ostiole-end crack. In both experiments, the lowest
Year 1 1.55 b (2000) 1.79 a (2001)
crack index was obtained with treatments containing Ca in both Year 2 1.72 a (2001) 1.37 b (2002)
years and locations (Table 7). This result can be attributed to the Tukey 0.10 0.15
role of Ca on stability and integrity of the cell wall (Marschner,
Year  treatment (p > F) ns 0.01**
1995). Fruit internal factors, various biotic, genetic, skin abnorm-
312 M.E. I˙rget et al. / Scientia Horticulturae 118 (2008) 308–313

Table 9
Leaf and fruit Ca and K concentration in Erbeyli

Treatment Leaf Fruit

K (%) Ca (%) K (%) Ca (%)

2001 2002 2001 2002 2001 2002 2001 2002

1. Control 0.54 b 0.66 d 5.62 cd 5.78 cd 1.01 ab 0.98 b 0.31 0.30 b


2. NPK 0.65 a 0.98 a 5.54 d 5.62 d 1.13 a 1.25 a 0.30 0.29 b
3. NPK + 70 g Ca 0.62 ab 0.80 bc 5.67 abcd 5.81 bcd 1.01 ab 1.12 ab 0.30 0.34 a
4. NPK + 140 g Ca 0.66 a 0.88 ab 5.98 abc 6.24 ab 1.00 b 1.07 b 0.32 0.34 a
5. NPK + 280 g Ca 0.66 a 0.99 a 5.63 ab 6.14 abc 1.05 ab 1.14 ab 0.31 0.36 a
6. NPK + 420 g Ca 0.67 a 0.92 ab 6.06 ab 6.33 a 1.02 ab 1.08 b 0.30 0.35 a
7. N + 420 g Ca 0.61 ab 0.70 cd 6.08 a 6.72 a 1.08 ab 0.98 b 0.32 0.36 a
Tukey 0.10 0.14 0.44 0.44 0.12 0.16 ns 0.04

Year 1 0.63 b (2001) 5.80 b (2001) 1.04  (2001) 0.31 b (2001)


Year 2 0.85 a (2002) 6.04 a (2002) 1.09  (2002) 0.33 a (2002)
Tukey 0.05 0.17 ns 0.01
Year  treatment (p > F) 0.01** 0.05* ns 0.05*

preventing fruit crack needs to be considered, as well. Together reported that sunscald significantly reduces quality of figs in
with Ca, the impact of B shall be investigated in future studies. California, although the association between fig sunscald and leaf K
concentrations has not been investigated.
3.2.3. Sunscald
In Kanlıbahçe, fruits receiving NPK alone were the least affected. 3.2.4. Cull ratio
Sunscald index increased with the increasing Ca levels added to The highest overall fruit quality was obtained with addition of
NPK. Control and N + 420 g Ca treatments had the highest sunscald Ca to NPK, 280 g in Kanlıbahçe and 420 g in Erbeyli Ca due to low
index in both locations (Table 8). Similarly, the highest index cull ratio. In Kanlıbahçe, cull fruits totalled to 2.91 kg/tree (8.81%)
values were found in control and N + Ca in Erbeyli. The difference in 2000 and to 4.87 kg/tree (19.66%) in 2001. In Erbeyli, cull fruits
between the years was significant in both locations yielding higher were 4.66 kg/tree (27.94%) in 2001 and 3.93 kg/tree (19.34%) in
sunscald index in 2001. 2002. In both years and locations, control trees possessed the
The actual mechanisms of sunscald of fig fruit need further lowest dried fig quality with highest cull ratio (Table 10). Studies
investigation as it is with fruit cracking. The results of surveys and carried out in dried fig orchards in Small and Big Meander Basin
on-going researchwork disclose significant effect of soil properties reported cull ratios ranging between 13.30 and 89.12% (Anaç et al.,
and aspect (light intensity) on sunscald. In this respect, soil 1992), 28.6–30.4% (Aksoy et al., 1987) and 4.59–31.17% (Şahin,
available potassium content seems to be effective on sunscald 2003). The cull ratios obtained in the experiment are in the lower
incidence, and K applications prevented or reduced the defect. In end of the results of the previous surveys.
Erbeyli, application of NPK enhanced fruit K content significantly, Total yield and cull ratio were affected especially by the lack of
whereas, addition of Ca to NPK decreased fruit K levels (Table 9). rainfall during the period between October and June in 2001. This
These findings support previous results showing positive correla- effect was more pronounced than the negative effect of rain during
tion between sunscald and fruit K concentration and negative fruit maturation and drying period as experienced in 2002. Under
correlation with fruit Ca (Aksoy et al., 1987; Anaç et al., 1992). The drought conditions nutrient uptake and translocation are reduced
results also signify the importance of the balance between K and Ca leading to higher sunscald incidence (Nilsen and Orcutt, 1996).
in respect to sunscald. Drought also favours sunscald of fruits due to early leaf fall that
Previous findings put forward higher incidence of sunburn leads to direct exposure to sun. Ca addition to NPK seemed to
among fruits facing south or those that are under direct and reduce the impact of drought stress and sunscald and crack
intensive sun, and thus lead to the assumption that sunburn can be incidence and thus resulted in lower cull ratio (Table 10). The effect
due to photooxidative damage (Cakmak, 2007). Brown (1994) also of applied nutrients especially of Ca continues in the consequent
years. Observations performed in the following years in the
experimental orchards revealed decreased ostiole-end crack and
Table 10
Cull fruit ratio (%) obtained in tested treatments cull ratios supporting this view.

Treatment Cull ratio (%) 4. Conclusion


Kanlıbahçe Erbeyli
The results obtained proved that tested treatments play a major
1. Control 19.56 a 31.21 a
2. NPK 13.72 b 25.57 b role to obtain high yield and quality in Sarılop fig production.
3. NPK + 70 g Ca 14.35 b 21.17 cd Fertilization with NPK alone or in combination with Ca increased
4. NPK + 140 g Ca 12.75 b 21.41 cd the total yield in both experiments. Addition of Ca up to a certain
5. NPK + 280 g Ca 12.74 b 21.28 cd level to basic NPK fertilization enhanced fruit quality by increasing
6. NPK + 420 g Ca 13.43 b 20.47 d
7. N + 420 g Ca 13.10 b 24.36 bc
average fruit weight and lowering cull ratio through reduced
Tukey 2.86 3.27 sunscald and ostiole-end crack incidence. Together with basic NPK
fertilization Ca addition to the soil at a range of 280 and 420 g Ca/
Year 1 8.81 b (2000) 27.94 a (2001)
Year 2 19.66 a (2001) 19.34 b (2002)
tree is recommended taking into consideration its effect on
Tukey 1.00 1.13 sunscald and further effects in consequent years. As a consequence
of appropriate fertilization, profitability can be advanced through
Year  treatment (p > F) 0.01** ns
higher yields and higher farm prices. The results also show that site
M.E. I˙rget et al. / Scientia Horticulturae 118 (2008) 308–313 313

specific soil and ecological conditions and consequent effects of the Bangerth, F., 1979. Calcium-related physiological disorders of plants. Ann. Rev.
Pyhtopathol. 17, 97–122.
applications must be taken into consideration in fertilization. Brown, P.H., 1994. Seasonal variation in Fig (Ficus carica L.) leaf nutrient concen-
trations. Hort Sci. 29, 871–873.
Acknowledgements Cakmak, I., 2007. Role of Potassium in Alleviating Abiotic Stress. Int. Fert. Soc.,
Proceedings 611, York, UK, pp. 1–20.
Düzbastılar, M., Güleç, I., 1995. Ege Bölgesi İncir Bahçelerinin Beslenmesi Açısından
The project is funded by the Turkish Scientific and Technolo- Toprak Özelliklerinin Belirlenmesi (Analysis of Soil Properties in respect to
gical Research Council (TÜBİTAK) as Project TARP 2574-7 under Fig Nutrition of Fig Orchards in the Aegean Region). İlhan Akalan Toprak ve Çevre
Research Unit. The authors extend their thanks to Erbeyli Fig Sempozyumu, Cilt 2, 73–80, Ankara.
Eryüce, N., Aksoy, U., Anaç, D., 1987. Ege Bölgesi İncir Bahçelerinin Makro ve Bazı
Research Institute and to Güngör Family Farm for their under- Mikro Besin Elementleri İçeriklerinin Yaprak Analizleri Yolu ile Saptanması
standing and hospitality during the experiments, to Prof. Dr. Üzerinde Araştırmalar. II. Küçük Menderes Havzası (Research to Determine
Hayrettin Okut for his support in statistical evaluation and Prof. Dr. Macro and Micro Nutrients in Fig Orchards in the Aegean Region through Leaf
Analysis. II. Small Meander Basin). E.Ü. Zir Fak. Dergisi, Cilt 24 (1), 151–160.
Ernest Kirkby for his valuable comments. Hakerlerler, H.H., Aydın, Ş., İrget, M.E., Aksoy, U., Tutam, M., 1999. The Effect of Soil
and Foliage Applied Zinc on Yield and Quality of Fig (Ficus carica L.) for Drying.
References Soils with Mediterranean Type of Climate 6th International Meeting. Extended
Abstracts. Universitat de Barcelona, Spain, pp. 256–259.
Aksoy, U., 1981. Akça, Göklop ve Sarılop İncir Çeşitlerinde Meyve Gelişmesi, Hernandez, F.B.T., Modesto, J.C., Suzuki, M.A., Corréa, L.S., 1994. Effect of irrigation
Olgunlaşması ve Depolanması Üzerinde Araştırmalar (Research on Fruit and nitrogen levels on qualitative and nutritional aspects of fig trees (Ficus
Growth, Ripening and Storage of Akça, Göklop and Sarılop Fig Fruits), Ph.D. carica L.). Sci. Agric. Piracicaba 51 (2), 292–297.
Thesis (unpublished), Ege Univ. Fac. of Agr. Dept. of Horticulture, Bornova- İrget, M.E., Aydın, Ş., Oktay, M., Tutam, M., Aksoy, U., Nalbant, M., 1999. Effect of
İzmir-Turkey. foliar potassium nitrate and calcium nitrate application on nutrient content and
Aksoy, U., Anaç, D., Hakerlerler, H.H., Düzbastılar, M., 1987. Germencik Yöresi fruit quality of fig. In: Anaç, Martin-Prével, (Eds.), Improved Crop Quality by
Sarılop İncir Bahçelerinin Beslenme Durumu ve İncelenen Besin Elementleri Nutrient Management. Kluwer Academic Publishers, pp. 81–85.
ile Bazı Verim ve Kalite Özellikleri Arasındaki İlişkiler (Nutritional Status of Fig Kabasakal, A., 1983. Sarılop İncir Çeşidinde Bazı Mineral Besin Maddelerinin Mev-
Orchards in Germencik Region and Relationships between Investigated Plant simsel Değişimi ve Toprak-Bitki-Sürgün ve Meyve Gelişmesi İlişkileri Üzerinde
Nutrients and Some Yield Components and Quality). Tariş AR-GE, Project No. Araştırmalar (Research on Seasonal Changes of Some Plant Nutrients and
006, Bornova-İzmir, Turkey. Relationships between Soil-Plant-Shoot and Fruit Growth). Ph. D. Thesis
Aksoy, U., Anaç, D., 1994. The effect of calcium chloride application on fruit quality (Unpublished), Ege Univ. Fac. of Agr. Soil Science Dept., Bornova-İzmir, Turkey.
and mineral content of fig. Acta Hort. 368, 754–762. Marschner, H., 1995. Mineral Nutrition of Higher Plants, 2nd ed. Academic Press,
Aksoy, U., Can, H.Z., Hepaksoy, S., Şahin, N., 2001. İncir Yetiştiriciliği (Fig Growing). London.
TÜBİTAK TARP (Türkiye Tarımsal Araştırma Projesi) Yayınları. Mengel, K., Kirkby, E.A., 2001. Principles of Plant Nutrition, 5th ed. Kluwer
Anaç, D., Aksoy, U., Eryüce, N., 1987. Ege Bölgesi İncir Bahçelerinin Makro ve Bazı Academic Publishers, Dordrecht.
Mikro Besin Elementleri İçeriklerinin Yaprak Analizleri Yolu ile Saptanması Moreno, D.A., Pulgar, G., Villora, G., Romero, L., 1998. Nutritional diagnosis of fig tree
Üzerinde Araştırmalar. I. Büyük Menderes Havzası (Research to Determine leaves. J. Plant Nutr. 21 (2), 2579–2588.
Macro and Micro Nutrients in Fig Orchards in the Aegean Region through Leaf Nilsen, E.T., Orcutt, D.M., 1996. Physiology of Plants under Stress: Abiotic Factors.
Analysis. I. Big Meander Basin). E.Ü. Zir Fak. Dergisi, Cilt 24 (1), 75–90. John Wiley and Sons, Inc., NewYork.
Anaç, D., Aksoy, U., Hakerlerler, H.H., Düzbastılar, M., 1992. Küçük Menderes Opara, L.U., Studman, C.J., Banks, N.H., 1997. Fruit skin splitting and cracking. Hort.
Havzası İncir Bahçelerinin Beslenme Durumu ve İncelenen Toprak ve Yaprak Rev. 19, 217–262.
Besin Elementleri ile Bazı Verim ve Kalite Özellikleri Arasındaki İlişkiler (Nutri- Poovaiah, B.W., Glenn, G.M., Reddy, A.S.N., 1988. Calcium and fruit softening:
tional Status of Fig Orchards in Small Meander Basin and Relationships between physiology and biochemistry. Hortic. Rev. 10, 107–152.
Soil and Leaf Nutrients and Some Yield and Quality Characteristics). Tariş AR- Proebsting, E.L., Warner, R.M., 1954. The effect of fertilizers on yield quality and leaf
GE, Bornova-İzmir. composition of figs. Proc. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 63 (1), 10–18.
Anonymus, 2002. McCance and Widdowson’s The Composition of Foods, 6th SAS. 2006. SAS/STAT User’s Guide, Version 9.3rd. SAS Institute, Cary, NC.
summary ed. Food Standards Agency, Royal Society of Chemistry, Cambridge, Şahin, E., 2003. Büyük ve Küçük Menderes Havzalarında Yetiştirilen Kurutmalık
UK. İncirlerde (Ficus carica L.) Aflatoksin ve Okratoksin A Varlığının, Dağılımının ve
Anonymous, 2004. UN/ECE Standard DF-14 concerning the marketing and com- Kalite ile İlişkisinin Araştırılması (Research on Aflatoxin and Ochratoxin A
mercial quality control of dried figs. Geneva. Incidence and Distribution in Dried Figs Grown in Big and Small Meander
Anonymous, 2006. Dreid Figs.TS 541.Turkish Standards Institute, Ankara. Basin and their relationships with Fruit Quality), Ph. D. Thesis (Unpublished),
Aşkın, A., Ceylan, Ş., Yener, H., 1997. A Study on the Nutritional Status of Fig Orchards Ege Univ. Fac. of Agr. Dept. of Horticulture, Bornova-İzmir, Turkey.
in Birgi-İrimağzı. In: Aksoy, Hepaksoy, Ferguson (eds.), Proceedings of the First Shear, C.B., 1971. Symptoms of calcium deficency on leaves and fruit of ‘York
International Symposium on Fig. Acta Hort. 480, 239–246. Imperial’ apple. J. Am. Soc. Hort. Sci. 96, 415–417.

You might also like