Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 6

CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE

Renal bone disease Key points


Thomas Phillips C Hyperparathyroidism develops early in chronic kidney disease
Cathy Pogson (CKD), so should be treated early e if parathyroid hormone
(PTH) concentrations are elevated and rising, check the cal-
Kristin Veighey cium, phosphate and 25-hydroxyvitamin D concentrations and
John Cunningham treat accordingly

C Fibroblast growth factor 23 (FGF-23) increases as an early


Abstract adaptive mechanism against hyperphosphataemia in CKD
Sustained loss of kidney function leads to the evolution of progressive sec-
ondary hyperparathyroidism associated with a characteristic high-turnover C There are important links between metabolic bone disease
form of metabolic bone disease. The drivers of hyperparathyroidism and cardiovascular disease in CKD patients, so when treating
include the failure of renal bioactivation of vitamin D, phosphate retention the bones, keep an eye on cardiovascular issues too
and, in some cases, hypocalcaemia. As renal impairment becomes more
severe, some patients, particularly under the influence of treatment, and C Uraemic bone disease is heterogeneous; high-turnover
particularly if they have diabetes, evolve in a different direction; here, hyperparathyroid bone disease and low-turnover adynamic
low-turnover adynamic bone disease develops, associated with relative bone disease dominate the two ends of the spectrum
suppression of the parathyroid glands. Uraemic patients also develop an
internal milieu that favours soft tissue calcification involving the peri- C PTH measurement is a reasonable surrogate for the severity
articular tissue, skin and vasculature. Arterial calcification is closely associ- and type of bone disease but is part of a greater constellation
ated with arterial stiffening, left ventricular disease and increased cardio- of biomarkers that may in future help to differentiate different
vascular morbidity and mortality. Current therapies aim to minimize bone turnover states
disturbances of skeletal integrity by maintaining calcium, phosphate,
vitamin D and parathyroid hormone concentrations within defined target
ranges. It is hoped, but not yet established, that these measures will also outcomes in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD), collec-
result in a reduction of cardiovascular events in this vulnerable population. tively termed CKD mineral and bone disorder (CKD-MBD).
Keywords Calcimimetics; chronic kidney disease; chronic kidney
disease mineral and bone disorder; hyperparathyroidism; vascular
Hyperparathyroidism and high-turnover bone disease
calcification; vitamin D
A reduction of renal cell mass and glomerular filtration rate
(GFR) leads to progressive phosphate retention and a failure of
renal bioactivation of vitamin D. These abnormalities stimulate
Introduction the parathyroid glands to synthesize and release increased
amounts of PTH, causing secondary hyperparathyroidism, and to
The onset of a significant and sustained reduction in renal function
increase proliferative activity (Figure 1).
is invariably associated with the development of metabolic bone
Failure of vitamin D bioactivation leads to a lower extracel-
disease, disturbances in the metabolism of calcium and phos-
lular fluid calcium concentration, providing further stimulus to
phorus, and abnormalities of the principal calcium-regulating
the parathyroid glands. Calcitriol (1,25-dihydroxycolecalciferol)
hormones calcitriol, parathyroid hormone (PTH) and fibroblast
has a direct inhibitory effect on PTH gene transcription, medi-
growth factor 23 (FGF-23, a potent phosphaturic hormone secreted
ating its effects via a nuclear vitamin D receptor that is present in
by osteocytes). There are also important links between these dis-
the parathyroid glands, osteoblasts and intestinal epithelial cells,
turbances of mineral metabolism and adverse cardiovascular
and many other tissues. The parathyroid glands also express the
calcium-sensing receptor, a G-protein-coupled receptor that me-
diates rapid minute-to-minute responses to changes in extracel-
Thomas Phillips MB BS BSc MRCP(Neph) is a Renal Registrar and Research lular calcium ion concentration.1
Fellow with an interest in chronic kidney disease at University Hospital At the level of bone, PTH at physiological or just supra-
Southampton, UK. Competing interests: none declared. physiological concentrations is anabolic. In contrast, sustained
Cathy Pogson BPharm MRPharmS DipClinPharm NMP is a Specialist Renal elevation of PTH is catabolic, increasing the activity of both os-
Pharmacist at Wessex Kidney Centre, Portsmouth Hospitals teoblasts and osteoclasts, accelerating bone turnover and ulti-
University NHS Trust, UK. Competing interests: CP has received fees mately leading to significant resorptive damage.
from Astellas.
Kristin Veighey MRCP(Neph) PhD is a NIHR Academic Clinical Fellow in
Key biomarkers in CKD-MBD
General Practice and a Renal Consultant. She completed her renal training
in London and Portsmouth. Competing interests: none declared. Elevated FGF-23 is associated with both the progression of kid-
John Cunningham DM FRCP is a Professor of Nephrology at The ney disease and mortality; it rises early in CKD, preceding rises in
Royal Free Hospital and University College London, UK and an active serum phosphate and PTH. Elevation of PTH and FGF-23 are
researcher and clinician. Competing interests: none declared. adaptive mechanisms but are under different feedback controls.

MEDICINE 51:3 184 Ó 2022 Published by Elsevier Ltd.


CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE

Figure 2 An unenhanced CT scan of the knee of a dialysis patient (in


the context of a new fracture) showing osteopenia and severe arterial
calcification (arrow).

Figure 1
vascular compliance, arterial stiffening and increased pulse-wave
velocity. These abnormalities increase ventricular afterload and
PTH is upregulated in response to decreases in serum calcium
may be important in the genesis of uraemic cardiac disease and
and calcitriol concentrations, and increases in serum phosphate
the high cardiovascular mortality seen in these patients.
concentration, all of which are partially or completely corrected
by the PTH increment. In contrast, FGF-23 release is upregulated
Assessment of osteodystrophy e bone pathology
by increases in serum phosphate, so augments, and can even
associated with CKD
dominate, the hormone-driven phosphaturic response to
decreasing GFR. Finally, FGF-23 powerfully downregulates the The typical derangement seen in a biochemical snapshot of un-
renal production of calcitriol, thereby opposing the action of PTH treated patients with advanced CKD shows high phosphate and
on the vitamin D endocrine system. low calcium concentrations with resulting secondary hyper-
Phosphate independently correlates with mortality in patients parathyroidism. If measured, calcitriol is invariably low and FGF-
with end-stage renal failure on renal replacement therapy. 23 very high. Skeletal X-rays are frequently normal, except in
Because of its role in driving CKD-MBD, it has long been the cases of severe hyperparathyroidism, in which subperiosteal
obvious therapeutic target. erosion and cortical tunnelling may be seen.
The novel biomarkers sclerostin (a marker of bone formation) More recent evaluations show that dual-energy X-ray absorp-
and tartrate-resistant acid phosphatase-5b (TRAP-5b; a marker of tiometry (DXA) testing in patients with CKD is helpful in
bone resorption produced by osteoclasts) are raised in CKD pa- measuring bone mineral density (BMD) and therefore predicting
tients with bone fractures compared with those without. They fracture risk. The Fracture Risk Assessment Tool (FRAX) has been
can therefore be useful biomarkers or, in the case of sclerostin, used to predict osteoporotic fractures in patients with CKD. Novel
even as a potential therapeutic target. radiological tests such as 18fluorine-labelled sodium fluoride
positron emission tomography computed tomography (CT) raise
Extraskeletal calcification the possibility of non-invasive testing of bone turnover state.
Soft tissue calcification, especially involving large arteries, is a
Adynamic bone disease
frequent complication in individuals with CKD (Figure 2). This
calcification occurs in the vascular media and is distinct from the In some individuals, particularly those treated with active
intimal calcification seen in patients with atheromatous disease. vitamin D metabolites and with high exposure to calcium derived
Medial calcification in uraemia is closely associated with loss of from the diet or dialysate fluids, there is relative suppression of

MEDICINE 51:3 185 Ó 2022 Published by Elsevier Ltd.


CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE

PTH, with the result that the skeleton lacks a stimulatory Hyperphosphataemia is managed using a combination of di-
anabolic input. Abnormally low bone turnover develops, with etary phosphate restriction and oral phosphate binders; the latter
low cellular activity. This is associated with increased skeletal bind dietary phosphate in the intestinal lumen, preventing its
morbidity and an associated increase in the tendency to develop absorption. Agents are generally categorized as calcium-based
vascular calcification, with increased cardiovascular morbidity phosphate binders (CBPBs) or non-CBPBs. Calcium acetate is
and mortality. The risk of low-turnover bone disease increases often first line and sevelamer, an exchange resin, and lanthanum
progressively with the severity of CKD, and in some studies has (both non-CBPBs) are common alternatives. All these agents
been the dominant bone lesion identified in CKD stage 5 patients have limited efficacy, suffering from relatively low potency and
on dialysis. For this reason, most guidelines have recommended the need to take large doses timed to coincide with meals. Patient
supraphysiological target ranges for PTH in dialysis patients. compliance is frequently poor and should be checked if serum
Another contributor to low turnover is the use of anti- phosphate is not responding to therapy.
resorptive agents such as bisphosphonates for the treatment of CBPBs, in particular calcium carbonate, have been shown to
osteoporosis. These agents reduce osteoclastic activity, but bone increase calcium and increase measures of vascular calcification;
metabolism remains coupled so new bone formation is also however, there is little reliable proof that this increases cardiovas-
reduced. Bisphosphonates are excreted by the kidney and cular morbidity or overall mortality. Similarly, sevelamer has been
therefore accumulate in individuals with CKD. These drugs shown to reduce vascular calcification, but this is not consistent
should be viewed with caution when the estimated GFR (eGFR) across studies. Non-CBPBs are less likely to cause hypercalcaemia
is <30 ml/minute/1.73 m2. but have increased gastrointestinal adverse effects. CBPBs have a
Some older biomarkers for bone turnover such as bone-specific superior impact on BMD compared with their peers.2
alkaline phosphatase are being reconsidered as potential flags for New iron-based phosphate binders, such as ferric citrate and
low bone turnover states. Newer biomarkers such as WNT-b-cat- sucroferric oxyhydroxide, are now in use. Ferric citrate has been
enin correlate with increased bone turnover. A definitive diagnosis shown to decrease the need for erythropoiesis-stimulating agents
of adynamic bone disease in CKD-MBD is via bone biopsy; however, and intravenous iron in dialysis patients. Both iron-based agents
this is seldom undertaken because of the widespread lack of exhibit effects on phosphate and PTH similar to conventional
expertise in the procedure and its histological interpretation. Inter- phosphate-binding drugs; sucroferric oxyhydroxide is anecdotally a
national guidelines advise a bone biopsy in situations where it more tolerable agent than conventional non-CBPBs because of the
would affect continuing treatment for CKD-MBD. smaller tablet size.
Deficient calcitriol is replaced either by giving calcitriol as an
Management oral or injectable formulation, or in many cases by giving a cal-
citriol pro-drug, alfacalcidol. This agent is then subjected to 25-
The pathogenesis described above implies that management
hydroxylation in the liver, yielding calcitriol. Calcitriol adminis-
should include measures to increase serum calcium, decrease
tration results in increased serum phosphate, so this should be
phosphate and replace deficiencies of both substrate 25-
anticipated and addressed.
hydroxyvitamin D and activated calcitriol. Available therapies
Deficiency of the parent compound 25-hydroxyvitamin D should
are illustrated in Table 1. Caution must be exercised in raising
also be treated. This can be replaced using oral colecalciferol (D3) or
serum calcium beyond the upper limits as this is associated with
ergocalciferol (D2), which can be given in both oral and intramus-
vascular calcification and poor outcomes. All patients should be
cular forms. Doses of at least 1000e3000 U/day are required to raise
offered dietary counselling before initiating treatment. Despite
25-hydroxyvitamin D to sufficient concentrations (>75 nmol/litre).
this, compliance with both dietary measures and binders is
Co-administration of colecalciferol and calcitriol has not been
frequently poor and should be checked if serum phosphate is not
shown to consistently raise calcium concentrations in dialysis pa-
responding to therapy.
tients and is associated with increased BMD.
New active vitamin D compounds have been developed, some
of which, such as paricalcitol, have the potential for more se-
Therapeutic levers in CKD lective action on the parathyroid glands, with less tendency to
Calcium Phosphate PTH raise serum calcium via actions on intestine and bone. Experi-
mental work using these agents has sometimes shown impres-
Calcium acetate [ YYY YY sive evidence of key biomarker reduction (i.e. FGF-23), but proof
Calcium carbonate [[ YY YY of an impact on clinical outcomes is not yet evident.
Sevelamer carbonate 4 YY Y Calcimimetic agents are often used to modulate the action of the
Lanthanum 4 Y Y calcium-sensing receptors on parathyroid cells. These compounds
Iron-based binder 4 YY Y bind to the transmembrane domain of the receptors, resulting in an
Native vitamin D 4 4 4a allosteric modification that increases its sensitivity to calcium. As a
Active vitamin D [ [ YYY result, the parathyroid cells perceive the extracellular calcium con-
Calcimimetic Y Y YYY centration as being higher than it really is. Predictably, this leads to a
Lowered dialysate Ca2þ Y 4 [ simultaneous reduction of PTH and calcium (and additionally in
patients with CKD stage 5, elevation of phosphate).
The arrows depict the expected response(s) of serum biochemical parameters.
a
May lower PTH in early CKD. Oral cinacalcet has proved an extremely effective means of
moving PTH, calcium and phosphate into the desired target ranges
Table 1 when given to patients with hyperparathyroidism and CKD. It

MEDICINE 51:3 186 Ó 2022 Published by Elsevier Ltd.


CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE

should be taken with a main meal to increase its efficacy and reduce of glucocorticoid and anti-calcineurin use after transplantation,
the gastrointestinal adverse effects. However, its use has been and partly undoubtedly because of pre-existing MBD as well as
limited by gastrointestinal adverse effects and compliance issues. other factors, as high pre-transplant PTH predicts poor outcomes.
Etelcalcetide is now in routine use; it is given intravenously, These contribute to osteodystrophy and osteoporosis, which in
which can help with compliance and avoid adverse effects. turn increases fracture risk and mortality in these patients.
Evocalcet, an oral calcimimetic, has shown non-inferiority to Phosphate concentrations are often low in the post-
cinacalcet in trials, with fewer gastrointestinal adverse effects. transplant period, driven by a persistent elevation of FGF-23
Should secondary hyperparathyroidism progress, tertiary hy- and PTH e the latter remains high in nearly 45% of trans-
perparathyroidism can necessitate parathyroidectomy. Surgical plant recipients and represents a significant risk factor for
treatment in these cases improves both MBD biomarkers and fracture. If vitamin D is deficient, replacement is currently
clinical outcomes. Hypercalcaemia can be present in tertiary recommended in the absence of hypercalcaemia as it can also
disease, and calcimimetics are often used as a to bridge to sur- play a role in acute cellular rejection. Cinacalcet has been
gery, or in place of surgery if the latter is not an option. shown to be effective in reducing PTH in transplant recipients in
The other challenge in CKD is the management of osteopo- the absence of adverse effects on the transplanted kidney.
rosis. General principles of management include advising Osteoporosis can be treated with bisphosphonates or denosu-
weight-bearing exercise as this has shown clear benefits on mab; and although these can induce low bone turnover, frac-
BMD in CKD patients, including those on dialysis. Bisphosph- ture risk reduction is demonstrable in patients with CKD stages
onates, as described above, can contribute to low bone turn- 2e4. DXA scanning can be used to assess BMD.
over, especially in dialysis patients, and should therefore
generally be avoided in advanced CKD. The anti-osteoclast Clinical outcomes
monoclonal antibody denosumab is not excreted by the kid-
An overall shortcoming in the CKD-MBD literature is a lack of
neys so has been reported to be safe in patients with CKD stages
reporting on outcomes such as mortality, progression to end-
3 and 4. However, there have been reports of severe hypo-
stage renal failure, fragility fractures or cardiac events. Many
calcaemia in dialysis patients.
studies focus on biomarker change (as some have predicted
Teriparatide, a PTH analogue, may have benefit in increasing
outcome well) and measure vascular calcification (often using
bone turnover in adynamic bone disease; however, its utility is
different scoring methods), rather than clinical outcomes, which
limited by the need to administer it as daily subcutaneous in-
can make it difficult to reach definitive recommendations.
jections, and its impact on clinical outcomes in this population
Very large cohort studies have looked at the influence of
remains to be seen. Another anabolic agent is romosozumab
vitamin D therapies on survival and other outcomes. Good evi-
(recently licensed in the UK), a monoclonal antibody against
dence emerged that treatment with active vitamin D compounds
sclerostin, which is an inhibitor of osteoblast function. This agent
is associated with significantly increased in life expectancy
causes a sustained reduction in bone resorption markers and
among dialysis patients. However, new data testing vitamin D
calcium, with an increase in BMD, and has been used in some
receptor activators in dialysis patients without raised PTH con-
studies in patients with CKD on dialysis.
centrations have shown no overall benefit in all-cause mortality
or cardiovascular events; there is also a potential trend towards
Biochemical targets in patients with CKD
increased harm in individuals treated with vitamin D receptor
Observational studies have led to the development of several sets activators, suggesting that the correct strategy is to wait for PTH
of guidelines and biochemical targets relating to bone and min- to rise before initiating an activator.4
eral metabolism in CKD, in the hope of improved clinical out- In the case of calcimimetics, analysis of data from a series of
comes.3 Calcium, phosphate and 25-hydroxyvitamin D should be comparative studies has shown a 10-fold reduction in para-
maintained within normal ranges. thyroidectomy rate and a 50% reduction in fracture rate among
PTH should be maintained in or just above the normal range individuals treated with cinacalcet, compared with those treated
in patients with CKD stage 1 who are not on dialysis. In CKD conventionally. The A Randomized Study to Evaluate the Effects
stage 5 patients on dialysis, the most recent guidelines recom- of Cinacalcet plus Low-Dose Vitamin D on Vascular Calcification
mend supraphysiological (2e9 times the upper limit of normal) in Subjects with Chronic Kidney Disease Receiving Haemodial-
concentrations of PTH. The aim is to set PTH in a range most ysis (ADVANCE) study demonstrated a modest reduction in
likely to be associated with normal or near-normal bone turn- cardiac calcification scores in participants treated with a combi-
over, and to avoid the extremes of adynamic bone disease or nation of cinacalcet and low-dose vitamin D. A large prospective
hyperparathyroid bone disease. study, Evaluation of Cinacalcet Therapy to Lower Cardiovascular
Although it has to be accepted that the use of PTH as a surrogate Events (EVOLVE), demonstrated a significant reduction in PTH,
marker of bone turnover is imprecise, it remains the best compro- but this was not matched by a significant reduction in death or
mise between utility and feasibility in clinical practice. Guidelines cardiovascular events.
are keen to focus on a trend of PTH rather than isolated readings; i.e.
if the trend is upwards, increased therapy is needed. The future of CKD-MBD
Vitamin K deficiency in CKD is common and worsens with CKD
Bone disease after renal transplantation
stage, not rebounding after transplantation. Recent work has
Despite transplantation, these individuals still have a higher highlighted its vital role in mediating osteoclast activity and
fracture risk than the general population. This is partly because suggested that vitamin K supplementation may be a potential

MEDICINE 51:3 187 Ó 2022 Published by Elsevier Ltd.


CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE

route to decreasing fracture risk, as has been shown in animal reduction in trials. It could potentially be used in conjunction
models. with other conventional phosphate binders. A
Burosumab is a monoclonal antibody against FGF-23 and has
been used in X-linked hypophosphataemia with good results.
KEY REFERENCES
However, it increases serum phosphate, and its application in
1 Cannata-Andía JB, Martín-Carro B, Martín-Vírgala J, et al. Chronic
CKD-MBD remains unclear despite FGF-23 being key to CKD-
kidney disease-mineral and bone disorders: pathogenesis and
MBD pathogenesis.
management. Calcif Tissue Int 2021; 108: 410e22.
A study examining angiotensin II blockade, which combined
2 Phannajit J, Wonghakaeo N, Takkavatakarn K, et al. The impact of
clinical observation with in vitro and in vivo work, showed that
phosphate lowering agents on clinical and laboratory outcomes in
patients on angiotensin II receptor blockers had a reduced risk of
chronic kidney disease patients: a systematic review and meta-
fragility fractures, with the animal model showing that angio-
analysis of randomized controlled trials. J Nephrol 2022; 35:
tensin II activity negatively affected bone elasticity.5 Angiotensin
473e91.
II blockers are commonly used in CKD for their reno-protective
3 Erratum. Kidney disease: improving global outcomes (KDIGO)
qualities in proteinuric patients, so work examining their effect
CKDMBD update work group 2017 clinical practice guideline up-
on CKD-MBD parameters is ongoing.
date for the diagnosis, evaluation, prevention, and treatment of
Sodium-glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2) inhibitors are
chronic kidney disease-mineral and bone disorder (CKD-MBD).
increasingly used in patients with CKD with or without diabetes
Kidney Int Suppl 2017; 7: 1e59.
mellitus. As use continues to rise, consideration must be given to
4 J-DAVID Investigators; Shoji T, Inaba M, Fukagawa M, et al. Effect
their role in increasing phosphate, FGF-23 and PTH concentra-
of oral alfacalcidol on clinical outcomes in patients without sec-
tions as well as reducing calcitriol. No increased risk of fracture
ondary hyperparathyroidism receiving maintenance hemodialysis:
was identified in large-scale trials including patients with renal
the J-DAVID randomized clinical trial. J Am Med Assoc 2018; 320:
impairment, but longer term analyses of their impact on these
2325e34.
outcomes will be helpful to clarify their potential impact.
5 Wakamatsu T, Iwasaki Y, Yamamoto S, et al. Type I angiotensin II
Tenapanor is a novel pan-phosphate transporter inhibitor that
receptor blockade reduces uremia-induced deterioration of bone
has shown good tolerability and effective phosphate and PTH
material properties. J Bone Miner Res 2021; 36: 67e79.

TEST YOURSELF
To test your knowledge based on the article you have just read, please complete the questions below. The answers can be found at the
end of the issue or online here.

Question 1 Investigations.
A 40-year-old man presented after a fall and pain in his left hip.  Calcium 2.24 mmol/litre (2.20e2.60)
He was found to have a fractured neck of femur. He had a history  Phosphate 1.1 mmol/litre (0.8e1.4)
of chronic kidney disease stage 5 and was on maintenance hae-  Estimated glomerular filtration rate 42 ml/minute/1.73 m2
modialysis. He was taking regular alfacalcidol, colecalciferol and (>90)
cinacalcet.  25-Hydroxyvitamin D 33 nmol/litre (45e90)
 Parathyroid hormone 4.3 pmol/litre (1.6e6.9),
Investigations.
 Dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry scanning showed oste-
 Calcium 2.14 mmol/litre (2.2e2.6)
oporotic scores in the vertebrae
 Phosphate 1.4 mmol/litre (0.80e1.50)
 Parathyroid hormone 10 pmol/litre (1.6e6.9) She is advised to take 25-hydroxyvitamin D replacement and
 25-Hydroxyvitamin D 109 nmol/litre (>75) calcium supplementation.

What is the most appropriate additional treatment?


What is the likely bone abnormality in this patient?
A. Denosumab
A. Adynamic bone disease
B. Alfacalcidol
B. Brown tumour
C. Bisphosphonates
C. Osteoporosis
D. Teriparatide
D. Tertiary hyperparathyroidism
E. Strontium ranelate
E. High turnover bone resorption

Question 2 Question 3
An 83-year-old woman presented with a recent vertebral wedge A 52-year-old woman presented with bone pain. She had a long
fracture at L2 found incidentally on an abdominal X-ray while history of advanced renal failure secondary to hypertension. She
she was attending the emergency department with abdominal was being treated with peritoneal dialysis while awaiting trans-
pain. She had type 2 diabetes and was needle phobic. plantation. She had had a previous non-ST elevation myocardial

MEDICINE 51:3 188 Ó 2022 Published by Elsevier Ltd.


CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE

infarction, treated with primary coronary intervention. She was What is the best next step in her management?
taking high-dose alfacalcidol once daily and high-dose sevelamer A. Start cinacalcet
with her meals. B. Increase the sevelamer dosage
C. Reduce the alfacalcidol dosage
Investigations.
D. Start ferric citrate
 Calcium 2.63 mmol/litre (2.2e2.6)
E. Refer her for parathyroidectomy
 Phosphate 1.74 mmol/litre (0.80e1.50)
 Parathyroid hormone 141.2 pmol/litre (1.6e6.9)
 25-Hydroxyvitamin D 91 nmol/litre (>75)

MEDICINE 51:3 189 Ó 2022 Published by Elsevier Ltd.

You might also like