Home Law Firm Law Library Laws

Jurisprudence Contact Us

June 2013 - Philippine Supreme Court

Decisions/Resolutions

Philippine Supreme
Court Jurisprudence

Philippine Supreme Court Jurisprudence >

Year 2013 > June 2013 Decisions > G.R. No.
193747, June 05, 2013 - JOSELITO C.
BORROMEO, Petitioner, v. JUAN T. MINA,
Respondent.:
:
 G.R. No. 193747, June 05, 2013 - JOSELITO
C. BORROMEO, Petitioner, v. JUAN T. MINA,
Respondent.

SECOND DIVISION

G.R. No. 193747, June 05, 2013

JOSELITO C. BORROMEO, Petitioner, v.

ChanRobles On- JUAN T. MINA, Respondent.
Line Bar Review
DECISION

PERLAS-BERNABE, J.:

Assailed in this petition for review on

certiorari1 are the April 30, 2010 Decision2

and September 13, 2010 Resolution3 of the

Court of Appeals (CA) in CA-G.R. SP No.
101185, dismissing petitioner Joselito C.
Borromeo�s petitions which identically
prayed for the exemption of his landholding
from the coverage of the government�s
Operation Land Transfer (OLT) program as
well as the cancellation of respondent Juan T.

ChanRobles MCLE Mina�s title over the property subject of the

On-line said landholding.

The Facts

Subject of this case is a 1.1057 hectare parcel

:
 of agricultural land, situated in Barangay
Magsaysay, Naguilian, Isabela, denominated
as Lot No. 5378 and covered by Transfer

Certificate of Title (TCT) No. EP-43526,4

registered in the name of respondent (subject
property). It appears from the foregoing TCT
that respondent�s title over the said
property is based on Emancipation Patent No.
393178 issued by the Department of Agrarian

Reform (DAR) on May 2, 1990.5

Petitioner filed a Petition dated June 9, 20036

before the Provincial Agrarian Reform Office
(PARO) of Isabela, seeking that: (a) his
landholding over the subject property (subject
landholding) be exempted from the coverage
of the government�s OLT program under
Presidential Decree No. 27 dated October 21,
June-2013
19727 (PD 27); and (b) respondent�s
Jurisprudence
emancipation patent over the subject property

be consequently revoked and cancelled.8 To

A.C. No. 7944, this end, petitioner alleged that he purchased

June 03, 2013 - REX the aforesaid property from its previous

POLINAR DAGOHOY, owner, one Serafin M. Garcia (Garcia), as

Complainant, v. evidenced by a deed of sale notarized on

ATTY. ARTEMIO V. February 19, 1982 (1982 deed of sale). For

SAN JUAN, various reasons, however, he was not able to

Respondents. effect the transfer of title in his name.

Subsequently, to his surprise, he learned that

A.C. No. 4191, an emancipation patent was issued in

June 10, 2013 - respondent�s favor without any notice to

ANITA C. PENA, him. He equally maintained that his total

:
 Complainant, v. agricultural landholdings was only 3.3635
ATTY. CHRISTINA C. hectares and thus, within the landowner's
PATERNO, retention limits under both PD 27 and
Respondent. Republic Act No. 6647, otherwise known as
the "Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Law of
G.R. NO. 157020, 1988." In this regard, he claimed that the
June 19, 2013 - subject landholding should have been
REINIER PACIFIC excluded from the coverage of the
INTERNATIONAL government�s OLT program.9
SHIPPING, INC.
AND NEPTUNE SHIP Petitioner filed a subsequent Petition dated
MANAGEMENT
September 1, 200310 also with the PARO
SVCS., PTE., LTD.,
which contained identical allegations as those
Petitioners, v.
stated in his June 9, 2003 Petition (PARO
CAPTAIN
petitions) and similarly prayed for the
FRANCISCO B.
cancellation of respondent�s emancipation
GUEVARRA,
patent.
SUBSTITUTED BY
HIS HEIRS,
After due investigation, the Municipal Agrarian
Respondents.
Reform Officer (MARO) Joey Rolando M.
Unblas issued a Report dated September 29,
A.C. No. 9537
2003,11 finding that the subject property was
[Formerly CBD Case
erroneously identified by the same office as
No. 09-2489], June
the property of petitioner�s father, the late
10, 2013 - DR.
Cipriano Borromeo. In all actuality, however,
TERESITA LEE,
the subject property was never owned by
Complainant, v.
Cipriano Borromeo as its true owner was
ATTY. AMADOR L.
Garcia � notably, a perennial PD 27
SIMANDO,
Respondent. landowner12 � who later sold the same to
petitioner.

G.R. NO. 169214,

June 19, 2013 - Based on these findings, the MARO
recommended that: (a) the subject
:
 SPOUSES MANUEL landholding be exempted from the coverage
SY AND VICTORIA of the OLT; and (b) petitioner be allowed to
SY, Petitioners, v. withdraw any amortizations deposited by
GENALYN D. respondent with the Land Bank of the
YOUNG, Philippines (LBP) to serve as rental payments
Respondent. for the latter�s use of the subject property.
13

G.R. NO. 173829,

June 10, 2013 - The Ruling of the PARO
VALBUECO, INC.,
Petitioner, v. In an undated Resolution, the PARO adopted
PROVINCE OF the recommendation of the MARO and
BATAAN, accordingly (a) cancelled respondent's
REPRESENTED BY emancipation patent; (b) directed petitioner
ITS PROVINCIAL to allow respondent to continue in the
GOVERNOR peaceful possession and cultivation of the
ANTONIO ROMAN;1 subject property and to execute a leasehold
EMMANUEL M. contract over the same pursuant to the
AQUINO,2 IN HIS provisions of Republic Act No. 3844 (RA
OFFICIAL CAPACITY 3844), otherwise known as the "Agricultural
AS REGISTRAR OF Land Reform Code"; and (c) authorized
THE REGISTER OF petitioner to withdraw from the LBP all
DEEDS OF amortizations deposited by respondent as
BALANGA, BATAAN; rental payments for the latter's use of the said
AND PASTOR P.
property.14
VICHUACO,3 IN HIS
OFFICIAL CAPACITY
Aggrieved, respondent filed an administrative
AS PROVINCIAL
appeal to the DAR Regional Director.
TREASURER OF
BALANGA, BATAAN,
The Ruling of the DAR Regional Director
Respondents.

On November 30, 2004, DAR Regional

G.R. No.171692,
Director Renato R. Navata issued an Order,15
:
 June 03, 2013 - finding that petitioner, being the true owner of
SPOUSES DELFIN O. the subject property, had the right to impugn
TUMIBAY AND its coverage from the government�s OLT
AURORA T. program. Further, considering that the subject
TUMIBAY- property was erroneously identified as owned
DECEASED; GRACE by Cipriano Borromeo, coupled with the fact
JULIE ANN TUMIBAY that petitioner's total agricultural landholdings
MANUEL, LEGAL was way below the retention limits prescribed
REPRESENTATIVE, under existing agrarian laws, he declared the
Petitioners, v. subject landholding to be exempt from OLT
SPOUSES MELVIN A. coverage.
LOPEZ AND
ROWENA GAY T. While affirming the PARO's Decision, the DAR
VISITACION LOPEZ, Regional Director did not, however, order the
Respondents. cancellation of respondent�s emancipation
patent. He merely directed petitioner to
G.R. NO. 175773, institute the proper proceedings for such
June 17, 2013 - purpose before the DAR Adjudication Board
MITSUBISHI (DARAB).
MOTORS
PHILIPPINES Consequently, respondent moved for
SALARIED reconsideration,16 challenging petitioner's
EMPLOYEES UNION ownership of the subject property for lack of
(MMPSEU), sufficient basis to show that his averred
Petitioner, v. predecessor-in-interest, Garcia, was its actual
MITSUBISHI owner. In addition, respondent pointed out
MOTORS that petitioner never filed a protest against
PHILIPPINES the issuance of an emancipation patent in his
CORPORATION, favor. Hence, petitioner should be deemed to
Respondent. have slept on his rights on account of his
inaction for 21 years.
G.R. NO. 177103,
June 03, 2013 - The aforesaid motion was, however, denied in
:
 ORIENTAL the Resolution dated February 10, 2006,17
SHIPMANAGEMENT prompting respondent to elevate the matter
CO., INC., to the DAR Secretary.
ROSENDO C.
HERRERA, AND The Ruling of the DAR Secretary
BENNET SHIPPING
SA LIBERIA, On September 12, 2007, then DAR Secretary
Petitioners, v. Nasser C. Pagandaman issued DARCO Order
RAINERIO N.
No. EXC-0709-333, series of 2007,18 affirming
NAZAL, Respondent.
in toto the DAR Regional Director�s ruling.
It upheld the latter�s findings that the
G.R. NO. 177812,
subject landholding was improperly placed
June 19, 2013 -
under the coverage of the government�s
CONCRETE
OLT program on account of the erroneous
SOLUTIONS,
identification of the landowner,19 considering
INC./PRIMARY
as well the fact that petitioner�s total
STRUCTURES
agricultural landholdings, i.e., 3.3635
CORPORATION,
hectares, was way below the retention limits
REPRESENTED BY
ANASTACIO G. under existing agrarian laws.20

ARDIENTE, JR.,
Petitioners, v. Undaunted, respondent filed a petition for

ARTHUR CABUSAS, review with the CA.

Respondent.
The Ruling of the CA

G.R. NO. 179492,

June 05, 2013 - In a Decision dated April 30, 2010,21 the CA
REPUBLIC OF THE reversed and set aside the DAR Secretary's
PHILIPPINES, ruling. It doubted petitioner�s claim of
REPRESENTED BY ownership based on the 1982 deed of sale due
ABUSAMA M. ALID, to the inconsistent allegations regarding the
OFFICER-IN- dates of its notarization divergently stated in
CHARGE, the two (2) PARO Petitions, this alongside the
:
 DEPARTMENT OF fact that a copy of the same was not even
AGRICULTURE- attached to the records of the case for its
REGIONAL-FIELD examination. In any case, the CA found the
UNIT XII (DA-RFU said sale to be null and void for being a
XII), Petitioner, v. prohibited transaction under PD 27 which
ABDULWAHAB A. forbids the transfers or alienation of covered
BAYAO, OSME�A agricultural lands after October 21, 1972
I. MONTA�ER, except to the tenant-beneficiaries thereof, of
RAKMA B. BUISAN, which petitioner was not.22 It also held23 that
HELEN M. ALVARES, petitioner cannot mount any collateral attack
NEILA P. LIMBA, against respondent�s title to the subject
ELIZABETH B. property as the same is prohibited under
PUSTA, ANNA MAE Section 48 of the Presidential Decree No.
A.. SIDENO, UDTOG 1529 (PD 1529), otherwise known as the
B. TABONG, JOHN "Property Registration Decree."
S. KAMENZA, DELIA
R. SUBALDO, Petitioner moved for reconsideration which
DAYANG W. was, however, denied in a Resolution dated
MACMOD,
September 13, 2010.24
FLORENCE S.
TAYUAN, IN THEIR
Hence, this petition.
OWN BEHALF AND
IN BEHALF OF THE
The Petition
OTHER OFFICIALS
AND EMPLOYEES OF
Petitioner contends that the CA erred in
DA-RFU XII,
declaring the sale between him and Garcia as
Respondents.
null and void. In this connection, he avers that
there was actually an oral sale entered into by
G.R. NO. 179643,
him and Garcia (through his son Lorenzo
June 03, 2013 -
Garcia) in 1976. The said oral sale was
ERNESTO L.
consummated on the same year as petitioner
NATIVIDAD,
had already occupied and tilled the subject
Petitioner, v.
property and started paying real estate taxes
:
 FERNANDO thereon. He further alleges that he allowed
MARIANO, ANDRES respondent to cultivate and possess the
MARIANO AND subject property in 1976 only out of mercy
DOROTEO GARCIA, and compassion since the latter begged him
Respondents. for work. The existing sale agreement had
been merely formalized by virtue of the 1982
G.R. NO. 181195, deed of sale which in fact, expressly provided
June 10, 2013 - that the subject property was not tenanted
FREDERICK JAMES and that the provisions of law on pre-emption
C. ORAIS, Petitioner, had been complied with.25 In this regard,
v. DR. AMELIA C. petitioner claims that respondent cannot be
ALMIRANTE, considered as a tenant and as such, the
Respondent. issuance of an emancipation patent in his
favor was erroneous. Likewise, petitioner
G.R. NO. 182963, claims that his right to due process was
June 03, 2013 - violated by the issuance of the aforesaid
SPOUSES DEO emancipation patent without any notice on his
AGNER AND part.
MARICON AGNER,
Petitioners, v. BPI
In his Comment,26 respondent counters that
FAMILY SAVINGS
petitioner cannot change his theory regarding
BANK, INC.,
the date of sale between him and Garcia nor
Respondent.
even raise the same factual issue on appeal
before the Court.[27] Moreover, he asserts
G.R. NO. 188716,
that the 1982 deed of sale was not registered
June 10, 2013 -
and therefore, does not bind him. In any
MELINDA L.
event, he posits that the sale between
OCAMPO, Petitioner,
petitioner and Garcia was null and void.28
v. COMMISSION ON
Finally, he argues that petitioner�s PARO
AUDIT, Respondent.
petitions constitute collateral attacks to his
title to the subject property which are
G.R. NO. 189297,
June 03, 2013 - disallowed under PD 1529.29
:
 PEOPLE OF THE The Court's Ruling
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v. The petition lacks merit.
GUILLERMO
LOMAQUE, Accused- A. Petitioner�s change of theory on
Appellant. appeal

G.R. NO. 191730, The Court first resolves the procedural matter.
June 05, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE Settled is the rule that a party who adopts a
PHILIPPINES, certain theory upon which the case is tried
Plaintiff-Appellee, v. and decided by the lower courts or tribunals
MYLENE TORRES Y will not be permitted to change his theory on
CRUZ, Accused- appeal,30 not because of the strict application
Appellant. of procedural rules, but as a matter of

fairness.31� Basic considerations of due

G.R. NO. 191877,
process dictate that theories, issues and
June 18, 2013 -
arguments not brought to the attention of the
PHILIPPINE
trial court would not ordinarily be considered
AMUSEMENT AND
by a reviewing court,32 except when their
GAMING
factual bases would not require presentation
CORPORATION
of any further evidence by the adverse party
(PAGCOR),
in order to enable him to properly meet the
Petitioner, v. ARIEL
R. MARQUEZ, issue raised,33� such as when the factual

Respondent.; [G.R. bases of such novel theory, issue or argument

NO. 192287] - is (a) subject of judicial notice; or (b) had

IRENEO M. already been judicially admitted,34 which do

VERDILLO, not obtain in this case.
Petitioner, v.
PHILIPPINE Records show that petitioner changed his
AMUSEMENT AND theory on appeal with respect to two (2)
GAMING matters: cralavvonlinelawlibrary
:
 CORPORATION
(PAGCOR),
First, the actual basis of his
Respondent.
ownership rights over the subject
property, wherein he now claims
G.R. NO. 192893,
that his ownership was actually
June 05, 2013 -
based on a certain oral sale in
MANILA ELECTRIC
1976 which was merely formalized
COMPANY,
Petitioner, v. HEIRS by the 1982 deed of sale;35 and

OF SPOUSES
DIONISIO DELOY Second, the status of respondent

AND PRAXEDES as tenant of the subject property,

MARTONITO, which he never questioned during

REPRESENTED BY the earlier stages of the

POLICARPIO DELOY, proceedings before the DAR but

Respondents. presently disputes before the

Court.

G.R. NO. 193453,

June 05, 2013 -
Clearly, the factual bases of the foregoing
SPOUSES RUBIN
theories require the presentation of proof as
AND PORTIA HOJAS,
neither of them had been judicially admitted
Petitioners, v.
by respondent nor subject of judicial notice.
PHILIPPINE
Therefore, the Court cannot entertain
AMANAH BANK AND
petitioner�s novel arguments raised in the
RAMON KUE,
instant petition. Accordingly, he must rely on
Respondents.
his previous positions that (a) his basis of
ownership over the subject property
G.R. NO. 195523,
rests on the 1982 deed of sale; and (b)
June 05, 2013 -
that respondent�s status as the tenant
PEOPLE OF THE
of the subject property remains
PHILIPPINES,
undisputed.
Appellee, v.
ERNESTO GANI Y
Having settled the foregoing procedural issue,
:
 TUPAS, Appellant. the Court now proceeds to resolve the
substantive issue in this case.
G.R. NO. 195842,
June 18, 2013 - B. Validity of the sale of the subject
ROBERTO B. property to petitioner
REBLORA,
Petitioner, v. ARMED PD 27 prohibits the transfer of ownership over
FORCES OF THE tenanted rice and/or corn lands
PHILIPPINES, after�October 21, 1972 except only in
Respondent. favor of the actual tenant-tillers thereon.
As held in the case of Sta. Monica Industrial
G.R. NO. 197039, and Development Corporation v. DAR Regional
June 05, 2013 - Director for Region III,36 citing Heirs of
PEOPLE OF THE
Batongbacal v. CA:37
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appelle, v.
ARIEL CALARA Y x x x P.D. No. 27, as amended,
ABALOS, Accused- forbids the transfer or
Appellant. alienation of covered
agricultural lands
G.R. NO. 201675, after�October 21,
June 19, 2013 - 1972�except to the tenant-
JUANITO ANG, FOR beneficiary.��x x x.
AND IN BEHALF OF
SUNRISE In�Heirs of Batongbacal v. Court
MARKETING of Appeals,�involving the similar
(BACOLOD), INC., issue of sale of a covered
Petitioner, v. agricultural land under P.D. No. 27,
SPOUSES ROBERTO this Court held: cralavvonlinelawlibrary

AND RACHEL ANG,

Respondents.
Clearly, therefore,
Philbanking committed
G.R. NO. 198755,
breach of obligation as
:
 June 05, 2013 - an agricultural lessor.
ALBERTO PAT-OG, As the records show,
SR., Petitioner, v. private respondent was
CIVIL SERVICE not informed about the
COMMISSION, sale between
Respondent. Philbanking and
petitioner, and neither
G.R. NO. 202079, was he privy to the
June 10, 2013 - FIL- transfer of ownership
ESTATE GOLF AND from Juana Luciano to
DEVELOPMENT, INC. Philbanking. As an
AND FIL�-ESTATE agricultural lessee, the
LAND, INC., law gives him the right
Petitioners, v. to be informed about
VERTEX SALES AND matters affecting the
TRADING, INC., land he tills, without
Respondent. need for him to inquire
about it.
G.R. NO. 202247,
June 19, 2013 - xxxx
SIME DARBY
PILIPINAS, INC., In other words,
Petitioner, v. JESUS transfer of
B. MENDOZA, ownership over
Respondent. tenanted rice and/or
corn lands
G.R. NO. 202690, after�October 21,
June 05, 2013 - 1972�is allowed
HENRY L. SY, only in favor of the
Petitioner, v. LOCAL actual tenant-tillers
GOVERNMENT OF thereon.�Hence, the
QUEZON CITY, sale executed by
Respondent. Philbanking
:
 on�January 11,
G.R. NO. 202791, 1985�in favor of
June 10, 2013 - petitioner was in
PHILIPPINE violation of the
TRANSMARINE aforequoted provision
CARRIERS, INC., of P.D. 27 and its
Petitioner, v. implementing
LEANDRO LEGASPI, guidelines, and must
Respondent. thus be declared�null
and void.�(Emphasis
A.M. NO. P-10- and underscoring
2741, June 04, supplied)
2013 - JUDGE
ANTONIO C. REYES,
Records reveal that the subject landholding
Complainant, v.
fell under the coverage of PD 27 on October
EDWIN FANGONIL,
PROCESS SERVER, 21, 197238 and as such, could have been

REGIONAL TRIAL subsequently sold only to the tenant thereof,

COURT, BRANCH 61 i.e., the respondent. Notably, the status of

OF BAGUIO CITY, respondent as tenant is now beyond dispute

Respondent. considering petitioner�s admission of such

fact.39� Likewise, as earlier discussed,

A.M. NO. P-06- petitioner is tied down to his initial theory that
2223 [Formerly A.M. his claim of ownership over the subject
NO. 06-7-226-MTC), property was based on the 1982 deed of sale.
June 10, 2013 - Therefore, as Garcia sold the property in 1982
OFFICE OF THE to the petitioner who is evidently not the
COURT tenant-beneficiary of the same, the said
ADMINISTRATOR, transaction is null and void for being contrary
Complainant, v. to law.40
LORENZA M.
MARTINEZ, CLERK In consequence, petitioner cannot assert any
OF COURT, right over the subject landholding, such as his
:
 MUNICIPAL TRIAL present claim for landholding exemption,
COURT, because his title springs from a null and void
CANDELARIA, source. A void contract is equivalent to
QUEZON. nothing; it produces no civil effect; and�it
Respondent. does not create, modify or extinguish a

juridical relation.41 Hence, notwithstanding

A.M. NO. P-10- the erroneous identification of the subject
2879 (Formerly A.M. landholding by the MARO as owned by
OCA I.P.I. No. 09- Cipriano Borromeo, the fact remains that
3048-P), June 03, petitioner had no right to file a petition for
2013 - AUXENCIO landholding exemption since the sale of the
JOSEPH B. said property to him by Garcia in 1982 is null
CLEMENTE, CLERK and void.� Proceeding from this, the finding
OF COURT, that petitioner�s total agricultural
METROPOLITAN landholdings is way below the retention limits
TRIAL COURT, set forth by law thus, becomes irrelevant to
BRANCH 48, PASAY his claim for landholding exemption precisely
CITY, Complainant, because he has no right over the
v. ERWIN E. aforementioned landholding.
BAUTISTA, CLERK
III, METROPOLITAN In view of the foregoing disquisition, the Court
TRIAL COURT, sees no reason to delve on the issue
BRANCH 48, PASAY regarding the cancellation of respondent�s
CITY, Respondent. emancipation patent, without prejudice to
petitioner�s right to raise his other claims
A.M. NO. P-12- and objections thereto through the
3048 (formerly A.M. appropriate action filed before the proper
NO. 11-3-29-
forum.42
MCTC), June 05,
2013 - OFFICE OF
WHEREFORE, the petition is DENIED. The
THE COURT
assailed April 30, 2010 Decision and
ADMINISTRATOR,
September 13, 2010 Resolution of the Court
Complainant, v.
of Appeals in CA-G.R. SP No. 101185 are
:
 NELSON P. hereby AFFIRMED.
MAGBANUA,
PROCESS SERVER, SO ORDERED.
3RD MUNICIPAL
CIRCUIT TRIAL Brion, (Acting Chairperson)* Del Castillo,
COURT,
Perez, and Leonen,** JJ., concur.
PATNONGON,
ANTIQUE,
Respondent.
Endnotes:
A.M. NO. P-13-
3115 (Formerly A.M. *
Designated Acting Chairperson in
NO. 13-3-41-RTC],
lieu of Justice Antonio T. Carpio per
June 04, 2013 - RE:
Special Order No. 1460 dated May
DROPPING FROM
29, 2013. cralawlibrary

THE ROLLS OF
JOYLYN R. DUPAYA,
**
Designated Acting Member per
Court Stenographer
Special Order No. 1461 dated May
III, Regional Trial
29, 2013.
Court, Branch 10,
cralawlibrary

Aparri, Cagayan.
1
Rollo, pp. 4-20. cralawlibrary

G.R. No. L-44,

September 13, 1945 2
Id. at 69-82.� Penned by
- LILY RAQUIZA, ET
Associate Justice Rosalinda
AL. v. J. BRADFORD,
Asuncion-Vicente, with Associate
ET AL. - 075 Phil 50
Justices Romeo F. Barza and Amy
C. Lazaro-Javier, concurring.
G.R. No. 156759,
cralawlibrary

June 05, 2013 -

3
ALLEN A. Id. at 28-30. cralawlibrary

MACASAET,
NICOLAS V. 4
CA rollo, pp. 45-46. cralawlibrary
:
 QUIJANO, JR.,
ISAIAS ALBANO, 5
Rollo, p. 70. cralawlibrary

LILY REYES, JANET

BAY, JESUS R.
6
CA rollo, p. 42.
GALANG, AND
cralawlibrary

RANDY HAGOS,
7
Petitioners, v. "DECREEING THE EMANCIPATION
FRANCISCO R. CO, OF TENANTS FROM THE BONDAGE
JR., Respondent. OF THE SOIL, TRANSFERRING TO
THEM THE OWNERSHIP OF THE
G.R. No. 159691, LAND THEY TILL AND PROVIDING
June 13, 2013 - THE INSTRUMENTS AND
HEIRS OF MARCELO MECHANISM THEREFOR."
SOTTO,
REPRESENTED BY: 8
Docketed as Adm. Case No. A-
LOLIBETH SOTTO 0204-0113-03. cralawlibrary

NOBLE, DANILO C.
SOTTO, CRISTINA
9
Supra note 6.
C. SOTTO,
cralawlibrary

EMMANUEL C.
10
SOTTO AND CA rollo, p. 43. cralawlibrary

FILEMON C. SOTTO;
AND SALVACION 11
Rollo, pp. 31-32. cralawlibrary

BARCELONA, AS
HEIR OF DECEASED
12
MIGUEL Id. at 31.cralawlibrary

BARCELONA,
Petitioners, v. 13
Id. at 31-32. cralawlibrary

MATILDE S.
PALICTE,
14
See Order dated November 30,
Respondent.
2004. CA rollo, pp. 48-49. cralawlibrary

G.R. No. 160786,

:
 June 17, 2013 - 15
Id. at 47-51. cralawlibrary

SIMPLICIA O.
ABRIGO AND
16
Id. at 52-55.
DEMETRIO ABRIGO,
cralawlibrary

Petitioners, v. JIMMY
17
F. FLORES, EDNA F. Id. at 67-69.� Penned by DAR
FLORES, DANILO OIC-Regional Director Araceli A.
FLORES, BELINDA Follante, CESO IV. cralawlibrary

FLORES, HECTOR
FLORES, MARITES 18
Id. at 77-80. cralawlibrary

FLORES, HEIRS OF
MARIA F. FLORES,
19
JACINTO FAYLONA, Id. at 78.
cralawlibrary

ELISA FAYLONA
MAGPANTAY, 20
Id. at 79.
cralawlibrary

MARIETTA FAYLONA
CARTACIANO, AND
21
Rollo, pp. 69-82.
HEIRS OF TOMASA
cralawlibrary

BANZUELA VDA. DE
22
FAYLONA, Id. at 78-80. cralawlibrary

Respondents.

23
Rollo, p. 80. cralawlibrary

G.R. No. 160982,

June 26, 2013 -
24
MANILA JOCKEY Supra note 3. cralawlibrary

CLUB, INC.,
Petitioner,v. AIMEE 25
Rollo, pp. 9-10. cralawlibrary

O. TRAJANO,
Respondent.
26
Id. at 97-117. cralawlibrary

G.R. No. 161878,

27
June 05, 2013 - Id. at 100-103. cralawlibrary

PHILWORTH ASIAS,
:
 INC., SPOUSES 28
Id. at 106-109. cralawlibrary

LUISITO AND
ELIZABETH MACTAL,
29
Id. at 113-115.
AND SPOUSES LUIS
cralawlibrary

AND ELOISA REYES,

30
Petitioners, v. Kings Properties Corporation v.
PHILIPPINE Galido, G.R. No. 170023,
COMMERCIAL November 27, 2009, 606 SCRA
INTERNATIONAL 137, 154, citing Philippine Ports
BANK, Respondent. Authority v. City of Iloilo, 453 Phil.
927, 934 (2003). cralawlibrary

G. R. No. 163061,
June 26, 2013 - 31
Duty Free Philippines Services,
ALFONSO L.
Inc. v. Tria, G.R. No. 174809, June
FIANZA, Petitioner,
27, 2012, 675 SCRA 222, 231. cralawlibrary

v. NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS
32
COMMISSION Jarcia, Jr. v. People, G.R. No.

(SECOND 187926, February 15, 2012, 666

DIVISION), BINGA SCRA 336, 359. cralawlibrary

HYDROELECTRIC
PLANT, INC., 33
Bote v. Veloso, G.R. No. 194270,
ANTHONY C. December 3, 2012. cralawlibrary

ESCOLAR, ROLAND
M. LAUTCHANG,
34
Rule 129 of the Rules of Court
Respondents.
enumerates what matters need not
be proved, to wit:
G.R. No. 172334,
cralavvonlinelawlibrary

June 05, 2013 - DR.

RULE 129
ZENAIDA P. PIA,
What Need Not Be
Petitioner, v. HON.
Proved
MARGARITO P.
GERVACIO, JR.,
SECTION
:
 OVERALL DEPUTY 1�.�Judicial notice,
OMBUDSMAN, when mandatory. � A
FORMERLY ACTING court shall take judicial
OMBUDSMAN, notice, without the
OFFICE OF THE introduction of
OMBUDSMAN, DR. evidence, of the
OFELIA M. existence and territorial
CARAGUE, extent of states, their
FORMERLY PUP political history, forms
PRESIDENT, DR. of government and
ROMAN R. DANNUG, symbols of nationality,
FORMERLY DEAN, the law of nations, the
COLLEGE OF admiralty and maritime
ECONOMICS, courts of the world and
FINANCE AND their seals, the political
POLITICS (CEFP), constitution and history
NOW ASSOCIATE of the Philippines, the
PROFESSOR, CEFP official acts of
POLYTECHNIC legislative, executive
UNIVERSITY OF THE and judicial
PHILIPPINES (PUP), departments of the
STA. MESA, Philippines, the laws of
MANILA, nature, the measure of
Respondents. time, and the
geographical divisions.
G.R. No. 172892,
June 13, 2013 - SEC. 2�.�Judicial
PHILIPPINE notice, when
DEPOSIT discretionary. � A
INSURANCE court may take judicial
CORPORATION, notice of matters which
Petitioner, v. are of public
BUREAU OF knowledge, or are
:
 INTERNAL capable to
REVENUE, unquestionable
Respondent. demonstration, or
ought to be known to
G.R. No. 173330, judges because of their
June 17, 2013 - judicial functions.
LUCILLE DOMINGO,
Petitioner, v. SEC. 3. Judicial notice,
MERLINDA COLINA, when hearing
Respondent. necessary. � During
the trial, the court, on
G.R. No. 173946, its own initiative, or on
June 19, 2013 - request of a party, may
BOSTON EQUITY announce its intention
RESOURCES, INC., to take judicial notice of
Petitioner, v. COURT any matter and allow
OF APPEALS AND the parties to be heard
LOLITA G. TOLEDO, thereon.
Respondents.
After the trial, and
G.R. No. 174908, before judgment or on
June 17, 2013 - appeal, the proper
DARMA MASLAG, court, on its own
Petitioner, v. AND initiative or on request
ELIZABETH of a party, may take
MONZON, WILLIAM judicial notice of any
GESTON, REGISTRY matter and allow the
OF DEEDS OF parties to be heard
BENGUET, thereon if such matter
Respondents. is decisive of a material
issue in the case.
G.R. Nos.
175279-80, June SEC. 4 . Judicial
:
 05, 2013 - SUSAN admissions. � An
LIM-LUA, Petitioner, admission, verbal or
v. DANILO Y. LUA, written, made by the
Respondent. party in the course of
the proceedings in the
G.R. No. 175542 same case, does not
and 183205, June require proof. The
05, 2013 - GREEN admission may be
ACRES HOLDINGS, contradicted only by
INC., Petitioner, v. showing that it was
VICTORIA P. made through palpable
CABRAL, SPS. mistake or that no such
ENRIQUE T. admission was made.
MORAGA and
VICTORIA
35
SORIANO, FILCON Rollo, pp. 9, 122-123. cralawlibrary

READY MIXED, INC.,

DEPARTMENT OF 36
G.R. No. 164846, June 18,
AGRARIAN REFORM 2008, 555 SCRA 97, 105. cralawlibrary

ADJUDICATION
BOARD (DARAB),
37
438 Phil. 283, 295 (2002).
and REGISTRY OF
cralawlibrary

DEEDS OF
38
BULACAN, To note, based on the
MEYCAUAYAN MARO�s findings, Garcia is a
BRANCH, "perennial P.D. No. 27 landowner."
Respondents.; See rollo, p. 31. cralawlibrary

VICTORIA P.
CABRAL, Petitioner, 39
Id. at 78.
cralawlibrary

v. PROVINCIAL
ADJUDICATOR,
40
Article 1409 of the Civil Code
JOSEPH NOEL C.
provides as follows:
LONGBOAN /
cralavvonlinelawlibrary
:
 OFFICE OF THE
AGRARIAN REFORM Art. 1409. The following contracts
ADJUDICATOR, are inexistent and void from the
GREEN ACRES beginning: cralavvonlinelawlibrary

HOLDINGS, INC.,
SPOUSES ENRIQUE (1) Those whose cause, object or
T. MORAGA and purpose is contrary to law, morals,
VICTORIA SORIANO good customs, public order or
and FILCON READY public policy; chanroblesvirtualawlibrary

MIXED, INC.,
Respondents.
xxxx

G.R. No. 175900,

These contracts cannot be ratified.
June 10, 2013 -
Neither can the right to set up the
KAPISANANG
defense of illegality be waived. cralawlibrary

PANGKAUNLARAN
NG KABABAIHANG
41
POTRERO, INC. AND Menchavez v. Teves, Jr., 490

MILAGROS H. Phil. 268, 280 (2005). cralawlibrary

REYES, Petitioners,
v. REMEDIOS 42
To note, Section 9 of Republic
BARRENO, LILIBETH Act No. 9700 (which took effect in
AMETIN, DRANREV 2009), amending Section 24 of
F. NONAY, Republic Act No. 6657, partly
FREDERICK D. reads as follows: cralavvonlinelawlibrary

DIONISIO AND
MARITES CASIO, Section 9.�Section
Respondents. 24 of Republic Act No.
6657, as amended, is
G.R. No. 176425, hereby further
June 05, 2013 - amended to read as
HEIRS OF MANUEL follows: cralavvonlinelawlibrary

UY EK LIONG,
:
 REPRESENTED BY SEC. 24.�Award to
BELEN LIM VDA. DE Beneficiaries. - The
UY, Petitioners, v. rights and
MAURICIA MEER responsibilities of the
CASTILLO, HEIRS beneficiaries shall
OF BUENAFLOR C. commence from their
UMALI, receipt of a duly
REPRESENTED BY registered
NANCY UMALI, emancipation patent or
VICTORIA H. certificate of land
CASTILLO, ownership award and
BERTILLA C. RADA, their actual physical
MARIETTA C. possession of the
CAVANEZ, LEOVINA awarded land.
C. JALBUENA AND
PHILIP M. xxxx
CASTILLO,
Respondents. "All cases involving the
cancellation of
G.R. No. 176838, registered
June 13, 2013 - emancipation patents,
DEPARTMENT OF certificates of land
AGRARIAN REFORM, ownership award, and
AS REPRESENTED other titles issued
BY FRITZI C. under any agrarian
PANTOJA, IN HER reform program are
CAPACITY AS THE within the exclusive
PROVINCIAL and original
AGRARIAN REFORM jurisdiction of the
OFFICER, DAR- Secretary of the
LAGUNA, Petitioner, DAR."(Emphasis
v. PARAMOUNT supplied)
HOLDINGS
:
 EQUITIES, INC.,
JIMMY CHUA, ROJAS
CHUA, BENJAMIN
Back to Home | Back to Main
SIM, SANTOS C.
TAN, WILLIAM C.
LEE AND STEWART
C. LIM,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 178947,

June 26, 2013 -
VIRGINIA DE LOS
SANTOS�DIO, AS
AUTHORIZED
REPRESENTATIVE
OF H.S. EQUITIES,
LTD., AND
WESTDALE ASSETS,
LTD., Petitioner, v.
THE HONORABLE
COURT OF APPEALS,
JUDGE RAMON S.
CAGUIOA, IN HIS
CAPACITY AS
PRESIDING JUDGE
OF BRANCH 74,
REGIONAL. TRIAL
COURT, OLONGAPO
CITY, AND TIMOTHY
J. DESMOND,
Respondents. - R E
S O L U T I O N;
G.R. No. 179079 -
:
 June 26, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF
PHILIPPINES, The
Petitioner, v.
TIMOTHY J.
DESMOND,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 179448,

June 26, 2013 -
CARLOS L.
TANENGGEE,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE
OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 179685,

June 19, 2013 -
CONRADA O.
ALMAGRO,
Petitioner, v. SPS.
MANUEL AMAYA,
SR. AND LUCILA
MERCADO, JESUS
MERCADO, SR., AND
RICARDO
MERCADO,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 179736,

June 26, 2013 -
SPOUSES BILL AND
:
 VICTORIA HING,
Petitioners, v.
ALEXANDER
CHOACHUY, SR.
AND ALLAN
CHOACHUY,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 179267,

June 25, 2013 -
JESUS C. GARCIA,
Petitioner, v. THE
HONORABLE RAY
ALAN T. DRILON,
PRESIDING JUDGE,
REGIONAL TRIAL
COURT-BRANCH 41,
BACOLOD CITY,
AND ROSALIE
JAYPE-GARCIA, FOR
HERSELF IN BEHALF
OF MINOR
CHILDREN, NAMELY:
JO-ANN, JOSEPH
AND EDUARD,
JESSE ANTHONE,
ALL SURNAMED
GARCIA,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 180476,

June 26, 2013 -
RAYMUNDO
:
 CODERIAS, AS
REPRESENTED BY
HIS ATTORNEY-IN-
FACT, MARLON M.
CODERIAS,
Petitioner, v. ESTATE
OF JUAN CHIOCO,
REPRESENTED BY
ITS
ADMINISTRATOR,
DR. RAUL R.
CARAG,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 182072,

June 28, 2013 -
UNIVAC
DEVELOPMENT,
INC., Petitioner, v.
WILLIAM M.
SORIANO,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 182130,

June 19, 2013 -
IRIS KRISTINE
BALOIS ALBERTO
AND BENJAMIN D.
BALOIS, Petitioners,
v. THE HON. COURT
OF APPEALS, ATTY.
RODRIGO A. I
REYNA, ARTURO S.
:
 CALIANGA, GIL
ANTHONY M.
CALIANGA,
JESSEBEL
CALIANGA, AND
GRACE.
EVANGELISTA,
Respondents. - G.R.
NO. 182132, June
19, 2013 - THE
SECRETARY OF
JUSTICE, THE CITY
PROSECUTOR OF
MUNTINLUPA, THE
PRESIDING JUDGE
OF THE REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT OF
MUNTINLUPA CITY,
BENJAMIN D.
BALOIS, AND IRIS
KRISTINE BALOIS,
ALBERTO,
Petitioners, v. ATTY.
RODRIGO A.
REYNA, ARTURO S.
CALIANGA, GIL
ANTHONY M.
CALIANGA,
JESSEBEL
CALIANGA, AND
GRACE
EVANGELISTA,
Respondents.
:
 G.R. No. 182295,
June 26, 2013 - 7K
CORPORATION,
Petitioner, v. EDDIE
ALBARICO,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 182855,

June 05, 2013 - MR.
ALEXANDER
�LEX� ADONIS,
REPRESENTED BY
THE CENTER FOR
MEDIA FREEDOM
AND
RESPONSIBILITY
(CMFR), THROUGH
ITS EXECUTIVE
DIRECTOR, MRS.
MELINDA QUINTOS-
DE JESUS; AND THE
NATIONAL UNION
OF JOURNALISTS
OF THE
PHILIPPINES
(NUJP), THROUGH
ITS CHAIRPERSON,
MR. JOSE TORRES,
JR., Petitioners, v.
SUPERINTENDENT
VENANCIO TESORO,
DIRECTOR, DAVAO
:
 PRISONS AND
PENAL FARM,
PANABO CITY,
DIGOS, DAVAO DEL
NORTE,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 182957,

June 13, 2013 - ST.
JOSEPH ACADEMY
OF VALENZUELA
FACULTY
ASSOCIATION
(SJAVFA)-FUR
CHAPTER-TUCP,
Petitioner, v. ST.
JOSEPH ACADEMY
OF VALENZUELA
AND DAMASO D.
LOPEZ,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 183091,

June 19, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
BERNESTO DE LA
CRUZ @ BERNING,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 184116,

June 19, 2013 -
:
 CENTURY IRON
WORKS, INC. AND
BENITO CHUA,
Petitioners, v.
ELETO B. BA�AS,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 184589,

June 13, 2013 -
DEOGENES O.
RODRIGUEZ,
Petitioner, v. HON.
COURT OF APPEALS
AND PHILIPPINE
CHINESE
CHARITABLE
ASSOCIATION, INC.,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 185129,

June 17, 2013 -
ABELARDO
JANDUSAY,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE
OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 185604,

June 13, 2013 -
REPUBLIC OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Petitioner, v.
:
 EDWARD M.
CAMACHO,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 185719,

June 17, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
MARCELINO
COLLADO Y
CUNANAN, MYRA
COLLADO Y SENICA,
MARK CIPRIANO Y
ROCERO, SAMUEL
SHERWIN LATARIO
Y ENRIQUE,* AND
REYNALDO RANADA
Y ALAS,** Accused-
Appellants.

G.R. Nos.
185729-32, June
26, 2013 - PEOPLE
OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Petitioner, v. THE
HONORABLE
SANDIGANBAYAN
(FOURTH
DIVISION),
ANTONIO P.
BELICENA,
:
 ULDARICO P.
ANDUTAN, JR.,
RAUL C. DE VERA,
ROSANNA P. DIALA
AND JOSEPH A.
CABOTAJE,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 185830,

June 05, 2013 -
ECOLE DE CUISINE
MANILLE (CORDON
BLEU OF THE
PHILIPPINES), INC.,
Petitioner, v.
RENAUIL
COINTREAU & CIE
AND LE CORDON
BLEU INT'L., B.V.,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 185821,

June 13, 2013 -
LAND BANK OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Petitioner, v. ATTY.
RICARDO D.
GONZALEZ,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 186014,

June 26, 2013 - ALI
AKANG, Petitioner,
:
 v. MUNICIPALITY OF
ISULAN, SULTAN
KUDARAT
PROVINCE,
REPRESENTED BY
ITS MUNICIPAL
MAYOR AND
MUNICIPAL VICE
MAYOR AND
MUNICIPAL
COUNCILORS/KAGAWADS,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 185891,

June 26, 2013 -
CATHAY PACIFIC
AIRWAYS, Petitioner,
v. JUANITA REYES,
WILFI EDO REYES,
MICHAEL ROY
REYES, SIXTA
LAPUZ, AND
SAMPAGUITA
TRAVEL CORP.,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 186475,

June 26, 2013 -
POSEIDON
INTERNATIONAL
MARITIME
SERVICES, INC.,
Petitioner, v. TITO R.
:
 TAMALA, FELIPE S.
SAURIN, JR.,
ARTEMIO A. BO-OC
AND JOEL S.
FERNANDEZ,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 186137,

June 26, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
DATU NOT ABDUL,
Defendant-
Appellant.

G. R. No. 186732,
June 13, 2013 -
ALPS
TRANSPORTATION
AND/OR ALFREDO
E. PEREZ,
Petitioners, v.
ELPIDIO M.
RODRIGUEZ,
Respondent.

G. R. No. 187587,
June 05, 2013 -
NAGKAKAISANG
MARALITA NG SITIO
MASIGASIG, INC.,
Petitioner, v.
:
 MILITARY SHRINE
SERVICES �
PHILIPPINE
VETERANS AFFAIRS
OFFICE,
DEPARTMENT OF
NATIONAL
DEFENSE,
Respondent.; G. R.
NO. 187654, June
05, 2013 -
WESTERN BICUTAN
LOT OWNERS
ASSOCIATION, INC.,
REPRESENTED BY
ITS BOARD OF
DIRECTORS,
Petitioner, v.
MILITARY SHRINE
SERVICES �
PHILIPPINE
VETERANS AFFAIRS
OFFICE,
DEPARTMENT OF
NATIONAL
DEFENSE,
Respondent.

G.R. No.187722,
June 10, 2013 -
SURIGAO DEL
NORTE ELECTRIC
COOPERATIVE, INC.
:
 AND/OR DANNY Z.
ESCALANTE,
Petitioners, v.
TEOFILO GONZAGA,
Respondent.

G.R. Nos.
187896-97, June
10, 2013 - AMANDO
P. CORTES,
Petitioner, v. OFFICE
OF THE
OMBUDSMAN
(VISAYAS),
VICTORY M.
FERNANDEZ, JULIO
E. SUCGANG AND
NILO IGTANLOC,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 188024,

June 05, 2013 -
RODRIGO RONTOS
Y DELA TORRE,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE
OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 188310,

June 13, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
:
 Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
MERCIDITA T.
RESURRECCION,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 189836,

June 05, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
ROMEO
BUSTAMANTE Y
ALIGANGA,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 189846,

June 26, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
RAMIL MORES,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 190818,

June 05, 2013 -
METRO MANILA
SHOPPING MECCA
CORP., SHOEMART,
INC., SM PRIME
HOLDINGS, INC.,
STAR APPLIANCES
CENTER, SUPER
VALUE, INC., ACE
:
 HARDWARE
PHILIPPINES, INC.,
HEALTH AND
BEAUTY, INC.,
JOLLIMART PHILS.
CORP., and
SURPLUS
MARKETING
CORPORATION,
Petitioners, v. MS.
LIBERTY M.
TOLEDO, in her
official capacity as
the City Treasurer of
Manila, and THE
CITY OF MANILA,
Respondents.

G. R. No. 190957,
June 05, 2013 -
PHILIPPINE
NATIONAL
CONSTRUCTION
CORPORATION,
Petitioner, v. APAC
MARKETING
CORPORATION,
REPRESENTED BY
CESAR M. ONG, JR.,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 191267,

June 26, 2013 -
:
 PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
MONICA MENDOZA
Y TRINIDAD,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 191391,

June 19, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
BENEDICT HOMAKY
LUCIO, Accused-
Appellant.

G.R. No. 191752,

June 10, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Appellee, v. JOSE
ARMANDO
CERVANTES
CACHUELA AND
BENJAMIN JULIAN
CRUZ IBA�EZ,
Accused. BENJAMIN
JULIAN CRUZ
IBA�EZ, Accused-
Appellant.

G.R. No. 191903,

June 19, 2013 -
:
 MAGSAYSAY
MARITIME
CORPORATION
AND/OR WESTFAL-
LARSEN AND CO.,
A/S, Petitioners, v.
NATIONAL LABOR
RELATIONS
COMMISSION,
FIRST DIVISION,
AND WILSON G.
CAPOY,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 192239,

June 05, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
RICARDO
PAMINTUAN Y
SAHAGUN, Accused-
Appellant.

G.R. No. 192601,

June 03, 2013 -
PHILIPPINE
JOURNALISTS, INC.,
Petitioner, v.
JOURNAL
EMPLOYEES UNION
(JEU), FOR ITS
UNION MEMBER,
:
 MICHAEL ALFANTE,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 192890,

June 17, 2013 -
LAND BANK OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Petitioner, v.
VIRGINIA
PALMARES, LERMA
P. AVELINO,
MELILIA P. VILLA,
NINIAN P.
CATEQUISTA, LUIS
PALMARES, JR.,
SALVE P.
VALENZUELA,
GEORGE P.
PALMARES, AND
DENCEL P.
PALMARES HEREIN
REPRESENTED BY
THEIR ATTORNEY-
IN-FACT, LERMA P.
AVELINO,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 193314,

June 25, 2013 -
SVETLANA P.
JALOSJOS,
Petitioner, v.
COMMISSION ON
:
 ELECTIONS, EDWIN
ELIM TUPAG AND
RODOLFO Y.
ESTRELLADA,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 192913,

June 13, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
JOEL REBOTAZO Y
ALEJANDRIA,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 193453,

June 05, 2013 -
SPOUSES RUBIN
AND PORTIA HOJAS,
Petitioners, v.
PHILIPPINE
AMANAH BANK AND
RAMON KUE,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 193747,

June 05, 2013 -
JOSELITO C.
BORROMEO,
Petitioner, v. JUAN T.
MINA, Respondent.

G.R. No. 194062,

:
 June 17, 2013 -
REPUBLIC GAS
CORPORATION,
ARNEL U. TY, MARI
ANTONETTE N. TY,
ORLANDO REYES,
FERRER SUAZO AND
ALVIN U. TY,
Petitioners, v.
PETRON
CORPORATION,
PILIPINAS SHELL
PETROLEUM
CORPORATION, AND
SHELL
INTERNATIONAL
PETROLEUM
COMPANY LIMITED,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 194247,

June 19, 2013 -
BASES
CONVERSION
DEVELOPMENT
AUTHORITY,
Petitioner, v. ROSA
REYES, CENANDO,
REYES AND CARLOS
REYES,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 194362,

:
 June 26, 2013 -
PHILIPPINE
HAMMONIA SHIP
AGENCY, INC. (NOW
KNOWN AS BSM
CREW SERVICE
CENTRE
PHILIPPINES, INC.)
AND DORCHESTER
MARINE LTD.,
Petitioners, v.
EULOGIO V.
DUMADAG,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 194382,

June 10, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
GLORIA
CALUMBRES Y
AUDITOR, Accused-
Appellant.

G. R. No. 194384,
June 13, 2013 -
JOSELITO RAMOS,
Petitioner, v. PEOPLE
OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Respondent.
:
 G.R. No. 194846,
June 28, 2013 -
HOSPICIO D.
ROSAROSO,
ANTONIO D.
ROSAROSO,
MANUEL D.
ROSAROSO,
ALGERICA D.
ROSAROSO, AND
CLEOFE R.
LABINDAO,
Petitioners, v.
LUCILA LABORTE
SORIA, SPOUSES
HAM SOLUTAN AND
**LAILA SOLUTAN,
AND MERIDIAN
REALTY
CORPORATION,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 195777,

June 19, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
FERDINAND
CASTRO Y LAPENA,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 196049,

June 26, 2013 -
:
 MINORU FUJIKI,
Petitioner, v. MARIA
PAZ GALELA
MARINAY, SHINICHI
MAEKARA, LOCAL
CIVIL REGISTRAR
OF QUEZON CITY,
AND THE
ADMINISTRATOR
AND CIVIL
REGISTRAR
GENERAL OF THE
NATIONAL
STATISTICS OFFICE,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 197363,

June 26, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
ROMAN ZAFRA Y
SERRANO, Accused-
Appellant.

G.R. No. 197861,

June 05, 2013 -
SPOUSES
FLORENTINO T.
MALLARI AND
AUREA V. MALLARI,
Petitioners, v.
PRUDENTIAL BANK
:
 (NOW BANK OF THE
PHILIPPINE
ISLANDS),
Respondent.

G.R. No. 197049,

June 10, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
MARIA JENNY REA Y
GUEVARRA AND
ESTRELLITA
TENDENILLA,
Accused-Appellants.

G.R. No. 198732,

June 10, 2013 -
CHRISTIAN
CABALLO, Petitioner,
v. PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 198789,

June 03, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
REGGIE BERNARDO,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 199354,

:
 June 26, 2013 -
WILSON T. GO,
Petitioner, v. BPI
FINANCE
CORPORATION,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 199650,

June 26, 2013 - J
PLUS ASIA
DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION,
Petitioner, v.
UTILITY
ASSURANCE
CORPORATION,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 200094,

June 10, 2013 -
BENIGNO M.
VIGILLA, ALFONSO
M. BONGOT,
ROBERTO CALLESA,
LINDA C. CALLO,
NILO B. CAMARA,
ADELIA T. CAMARA,
ADOLFO G. PINON,
JOHN A.
FERNANDEZ,
FEDERICO A.
CALLO, MAXIMA P.
ARELLANO, JULITO
:
 B. COSTALES,
SAMSON F.
BACHAR, EDWIN P.
DAMO, RENATO E.
FERNANDEZ,
GENARO F. CALLO,
JIMMY C. ALETA,
AND EUGENIO
SALINAS,
Petitioners, v.
PHILIPPINE
COLLEGE OF
CRIMINOLOGY INC.
AND/OR GREGORY
ALAN F. BAUTISTA,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 200329,

June 05, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
RICARDO PIOSANG,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 200402,

June 13, 2013 -
PRIVATIZATION
AND MANAGEMENT
OFFICE, Petitioner,
v. STRATEGIC
ALLIANCE
DEVELOPMENT
:
 CORPORATION
AND/OR PHILIPPINE
ESTATE
CORPORATION,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 200507,

June 26, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
PETER LINDA Y
GEROLAGA,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 200837,

June 05, 2013 -
MAERSK FILIPINAS
CREWING
INC./MAERSK
SERVICES LTD.,
AND/OR MR.
JEROME DELOS
ANGELES,
Petitioners, v.
NELSON E. MESINA,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 200882,

June 13, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
:
 ABEL DIAZ,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 201251,

June 26, 2013 -
INTER-ORIENT
MARITIME,
INCORPORATED
AND/OR TANKOIL
CARRIERS,
LIMITED,
Petitioners, v.
CRISTINA
CANDAVA,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 201701,

June 03, 2013 -
UNILEVER
PHILIPPINES, INC.,
Petitioner, v. MARIA
RUBY M. RIVERA,
Respondent.

G.R. No. 201723,

June 13, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
PERCIVAL DELA
ROSA Y BAYER,
Accused-Appellant.
:
 G.R. No. 203041,
June 05, 2013 -
PEOPLE OF THE
PHILIPPINES,
Plaintiff-Appellee, v.
MOISES CAOILE,
Accused-Appellant.

G.R. No. 205033,

June 18, 2013 -
ROMEO G.
JALOSJOS,
Petitioner, v. THE
COMMISSION ON
ELECTIONS, MARIA
ISABELLE G.
CLIMACO-SALAZAR,
ROEL B.
NATIVIDAD,
ARTURO N.
ONRUBIA, AHMAD
NARZAD K.
SAMPANG, JOSE L.
LOBREGAT,
ADELANTE
ZAMBOANGA PARTY,
AND ELBERT C.
ATILANO,
Respondents.

G.R. No. 207264,

June 25, 2013 -
REGINA ONGSIAKO
:
 REYES, Petitioner, v.
COMMISSION ON
ELECTIONS AND
JOSEPH SOCORRO
B. TAN,
Respondents.

A.M. No. MTJ-11-

1778 (Formerly OCA
IPI No. 08-1966-
MTJ), June 05, 2013
- MARICOR L.
GARADO,
Complainant, v.
REYES, JJ. JUDGE
LIZABETH
GUTIERREZ-
TORRES,
Respondent.

A.M. No. P-01-

1448 (FORMERLY
OCA IPI NO. 99-
664-P), June 23,
2013 - RODOLFO C.
SABIDONG,
Complainant, v.
NICOLASITO S.
SOLAS (CLERK OF
COURT IV),
Respondent.

A.M. No. P-08-

:
 2439 (Formerly OCA
IPI No. 08-2733-P),
June 25, 2013 -
JUDGE MA. MONINA
S. MISAJON,
MUNICIPAL TRIAL
COURT (MTC), SAN
JOSE, ANTIQUE,
Complainant, v.
JERENCE P.
HIPONIA, CLERK II,
ELIZABETH B.
ESCANILLAS,
STENOGRAPHER I,
WILLIAM M.
YGLESIAS,
PROCESS SERVER,
AND CONRADO A.
RAFOLS, JR.,
UTILITY AIDE, ALL
OF THE SAME
COURT,
Respondents.

A.M. No. P-11-

2980 (Formerly OCA
I.P.I. No. 08-3016-
P), June 10, 2013 -
LETICIA A.
ARIENDA,
Complainant, v.
EVELYN A.
MONILLA, COURT
:
 STENOGRAPHEIL
III, REGIONAL
TRIAL COURT,
BRANCH 4, LEGAZPI
CITY, Respondent.

A.M. No. RTJ-09-

2181 [Formerly A.M.
No. 09-4-174-RTJ],
June 25, 2013 -
OFFICE OF THE
COURT
ADMINISTRATOR,
Complainant, v.
RETIRED JUDGE
GUILLERMO R.
ANDAYA,
Respondent.

A.M. NO. SCC-08-

11-P, June 18, 2013
- CIVIL SERVICE
COMMISSION,
Complainant, v.
ISMAEL A. HADJI
ALI, COURT
STENOGRAPHER I,
SHARI'A CIRCUIT
COURT, TUBOD,
LANAO DEL NORTE
[FORMERLY A.M.
NO. 04-9-03-SCC]
(RE: FORMAL
:
 CHARGE BY THE
CIVIL SERVICE
COMMISSION VS.
ISMAEL A. HADJI
ALI, COURT
STENOGRAPHER I,
SHARI'A CIRCUIT
COURT, TUBOD,
LANAO DEL NORTE),
Respondent.

A.M. SB -13-20-P
[Formerly A.M. No.
12-29-SB-P], June
26, 2013 - RIA
PAMELA B.
ABULENCIA AND
BLESSIE M.
BURGONIO,
COMPLAINANTS, v.
REGINO R.
HERMOSISIMA,
SECURITY GUARD
II, SHERIFF AND
SECURITY
DIVISION,
SANDIGANBAYAN,
Respondent.

Adm. Case No.

7332, June 18,
2013 - EDUARDO A.
ABELLA,
:
 Complainant, v.
RICARDO G.
BARRIOS, JR.,
Respondent.
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
 Copyright © 1998 - 2024 Disclaimer | E-mail Restrictions | ReDiaz

ChanRobles™ | Virtual Law Library™ | chanrobles.com™

: