Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Capstone Project - Caitie Younghwa Lee
Capstone Project - Caitie Younghwa Lee
Capstone Project - Caitie Younghwa Lee
FINAL PROJECT
JENNIFER
31200131
LIDYA CORNELIA
31200096
LYDIA YUSANTO
31200070
FINAL PROJECT
JENNIFER
31200131
LIDYA CORNELIA
31200096
LYDIA YUSANTO
31200070
i
HALAMAN PENGESAHAN
ii
HALAMAN PERSETUJUAN PERBAIKAN
TUGAS AKHIR
Oleh:
JENNIFER
31200131
LIDYA CORNELIA
31200096
LYDIA YUSANTO
31200070
Menyetujui,
Ketua Penguji
Nama Dosen
NIK:
Penguji I Penguji II
iii
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
Praise be to God Almighty, because for his blessings and Grace, we can
complete this Final Project. The Final Project was created to complete one of the
criteria for a Bachelor of Applied Tourism degree in Agung Podomoro University,
Hospitality Business Program. We recognize that various parties assisted and
guided us in the preparation of this Final Project, therefore we would like to thank:
1. Mr. Budi Riyanto SST. Par., M. Par., as the Head of the Hospitality Business
Study Program,
2. Mrs. Herry Windawaty SST. Par., M. Par., as the Academic Adviser who has
provided time, energy, and thoughts to direct us in the preparation of this
Final Project,
3. Ms. Caitie Younghwa Lee, as General Manager of Moxy Bandung who has
provided the information or data we need,
4. Mr. Robby Fachri, as Area Director of Human Resources Marriott Indonesia
who has provided the information or data we need,
5. All civitas or employees of Hotel Moxy Bandung who are willing to provide
facilities for the smooth process of preparing this storytelling,
6. Both parents and the author's family who have provided material and moral
support, and
7. Friends and colleagues who have helped us a lot in completing this Final
Project.
Finally, may God Almighty reward all of those who have assisted. I hope that this
Final Project will be beneficial to further advancement of science.
iv
v
ABSTRAK
vi
ABSTRACT
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ACKNOWLEDGMENT ........................................................................................ iv
ABSTRAK ............................................................................................................... vi
CHAPTER I ............................................................................................................ 1
INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................. 1
CHAPTER II ........................................................................................................... 5
viii
2.1.1 Featured Profile....................................................................................... 7
CHAPTER IV ....................................................................................................... 30
4.1.3 Scene 3: The Role of Woman Leadership in the Hospitality Field ...... 31
ix
4.1.4 Scene 4 & Scene 6: Employees of Moxy Hotel Bandung & Closing... 31
CHAPTER V......................................................................................................... 35
REFERENCES...................................................................................................... 38
APPENDIX ........................................................................................................... 38
x
LIST OF FIGURES
xi
LIST OF TABLES
xii
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
1
through the media, as well as social, educational, and recreational socialization,
all of which encourage gender bias and discrimination (Naznin Tabassum,
2021). Gender stereotyping is regarded as a significant barrier to women's
advancement in managerial careers. The persistence of women's
underrepresentation and involvement in top-level managerial roles (Tina C.
Elacqua, 2009).
2
1.2 Problem Formulation
1. Do today's hospitality organizations, such as Marriott International, give
equitable opportunities for women to advance to positions of leadership?
2. What is the story of Caitie Younghwa Lee's career journey from the
beginning to the present?
3
1.4.3. Policy Contribution
There are no gender limitations in becoming a leader in the world of
work and the number of female General Managers in Indonesia can continue to
grow over time.
4
CHAPTER II
GENERAL DESCRIPTION
OF STORYTELLING OBJECT
The role and duties of a General Manager can seem very complex and
require in-depth managerial skills about the hospitality industry. Traditionally,
gender qualifications for the position of General Manager in the hospitality
world have been taken by men. Even though the hospitality business is
5
expanding, few women hold senior management positions. The hotel industry
is dominated by women, with an average of 55.5% of the workforce, yet it is
controlled by males, because women are mostly found in jobs stereotypically
with their gender (Marinakou, 2014). However, over the past few years, the
promotion of gender equality between men and women in the workplace
especially in hospitality has increasingly taken centre stage, with many women
successfully achieving the position of GM as well as other managerial positions.
Furthermore, the UN or United Nations promotes SDG5 or Sustainable
Development Goal 5 to eliminate discrimination against women by giving equal
opportunity for leadership positions. (Dolly Gaur, 2023).
6
Caitie Younghwa Lee is one of the female General Managers who leads
Moxy Hotel in Bandung. Caitie is one of the women leaders who successfully took
managerial and GM positions in the hospitality world. Her career journey from a
lower position can lead her to become an independent woman today.
2.1.2 Location
Caitie Younghwa Lee is a female General Manager who leads Moxy Hotel,
Bandung. Moxy Hotel, Bandung is a 3-star hotel located at Jalan Ir H. Djuanda No.
69, Bandung, 40116. The hotel was built in 2016 and is one of the first Moxy Hotel
brands in Indonesia said by Andree Susilo, Country Representative Hotel
Development Asia-Pacific Marriott International.
7
Sales at Marriott Executive Apartments located in Jakarta, and after that was chosen
to be a General Manager at Moxy Hotel, Bandung in 2021 until now. In total, Caitie
Younghwa Lee has been in the hospitality field for about 19 years.
Table 2.1
LITERATURE REVIEW
MENILIK-SOSOK-
Jacinda Ardern, a charismatic JACINDA-ARDERN- A look at the journey and leadership style
3. and visionary leader (Armila PEMIMPIN- of New Zealand's youngest female prime
KARISMATIK-DAN-
Miranda Rengganis, 2021) VISIONER.pdf minister and the youngest female leader
(researchgate.net) in the world.
8
Deborah as a wise and just Kuat Kuasa Firman
ALLAH di Seluruh Bumi -
female leader (Utama, Debora's figure inspires women to dare
4. Nikolas Kristiyanto, S.J.,
Franciscus Alam Panji, and S.S., S.S.L, Silvana to be leaders in the midst of a patriarchal
Natalia Nainggolan,
Bobby Steven Octavianus society.
Yulius Suroso, SJ, ... [et
Timmerman, 2023) al.] - Google Buku
Table 2.2
VIDEO REFERENCES
9
Tokyo. In this video, it discusses the
The Ritz-Carlton, Tokyo
problems faced by the hotel to find the
2. https://youtu.be/ Youtube
Interview with John Rolfs,
482oeG9JMmY right ladies and gentlemen to work at the
General Manager
hotel. In addition, how ADR and Revpar
have grown from last year to the current
year, as well as discussing the Ritz-
Carlton's expansion plans throughout
Japan.
https://www.you
Roberto Otálora, Executive It tells the story of the Executive
tube.com/watch
5. Assistant Manager – Youtube Assistant Manager at the St. Regis,
?v=IX7U6eZH4
Passion with Purpose Mexico City, Robert Otálora. Robert
QM
tells us how to manage the hotel well and
10
be a mentor to his employees. One of the
interesting things is when Robert says
that no matter what the challenge is, he
can always find the best solution.
11
CHAPTER III
12
Based on the topic and purpose of our storytelling, our target audience is
adult women in the range of 21-50 years old who have or have the desire to become
career women and want to build their career journey, especially in the hospitality
field. With the hope that after introducing Caitie's career journey, which is full of
motivation, it can inspire women to build enthusiasm for a career and confidence
that women can also become leaders and pursue careers.
On the next day, the first activity started with breakfast. Then we prepared
ourselves and all the needs for shooting. Before lunchtime, we did a short briefing
to Catie. shooting will start after lunchtime until it is finished. After shooting, we
rested while analysing the shooting results. Then we will have dinner and rest.
On the last day, the activities started with breakfast. Then we focused on
completing footage and other unmet needs from yesterday's shooting. After all
shooting activities were completed, we got ready to check out. Before going home,
we had lunch. Then after finishing lunch, we prepared to go home and say thank
you and goodbye to Catie. The trip home will start at 2pm and arrive in Jakarta
around 4pm.
13
3.3 Field Observation Rundown
Table 3.1
BANDUNG RUNDOWN TABLE
Time Activities
Day 1
th
16 October 2023
Day 2
17th October 2023
Day 3
18th October 2023
14
Table 3.2
JAKARTA RUNDOWN TABLE
Time Activities
Day 1
th
6 November 2023
Table 3.3
INTERVIEW OBJECTIVES MATRIX
15
• How to survive in the leaders or General
hospitality field as a female Manager.
General Manager? Knowing the most difficult
• What are the challenges in things or obstacles that
South Korea to become a exist when becoming
female leader? women leaders & how
• What character traits survive being a female
should a woman have to General Manager in
become a General hospitality field
Manager? Provides the obstacles for
• What are the factors of being a female leader in
"Women Leadership" that South Korea
affect effectiveness and Knowing what character
performance for traits a female general
employees? manager should have
• How to balance Provides information
housework/ personal life about the aspects of
and being a General Women Leadership that
Manager? become obstacles or
• What are your motivations support for employee
and goals in pursuing your performance
career and who is your Provides information so
support system? that household chores and
General Manager work
can be balanced
Knowing Caitie Younghwa
Lee's motivation and
intention in pursuing her
career to become GM and
her support system
16
2. Employees of Moxy • How do Moxy Hotel Bandung Knowing the perceptions
Hotel, Bandung employees perceive Caitie or views of Moxy Hotel
Younghwa Lee's leadership Bandung employees about
performance as General the performance of Caitie
Manager? Younghwa Lee
• 1 Word to Caitie Younghwa Knowing the 1 word that
Lee Moxy Hotel Bandung
employees would give for
Caitie Younghwa Lee
3. Robby Fachri (Area • What is your view on Women Find out Robby Fachri's
Director of Human Leaders or Women GMs in views on Women Leaders
Resources – Marriott) Marriott Company? or female GMs at Marriott
• Why do you think the Company
population of female GMs, Knowing Robby Fachri's
especially in the hospitality views on the still relatively
sector, is still relatively small small population of
in Indonesia? Female GMs in Indonesia
17
In addition, this storytelling is also complemented by additional support in
the form of analysis in the context of collecting posters, videos, and direct
interviews with sources. The importance of holistic case analysis involves the
identification of patterns, themes, and concepts during the research, as well as a
deep understanding of the context and the relationship between variables with one
another. Interview analysis is also an important stage of a qualitative method to
explore in-depth information about the research to be made. (Yin, 2014). By having
interview person by person, it can help us to achieve the data we desire.
Interviewing is a frequent data-gathering tool used by social scientists to gain a
better understanding of how persons perceive and act in their social contexts. It is
seen as problematic to understand interviews if researchers just give selected
examples of interview passages as insights into a research participant’s method of
thinking (Axel Philipps, 2019). By then, interviewees produce meaningful
interactions with interviewers who are thereby co-constructors of these meanings
(Holstein J, 2016).
18
3.6 Script and Storyboard Creation
Table 3.4
STORYBOARD
PRODUCT: DOCUMENTARY FILM
TITLE: THE HISTORY OF CAITIE YOUNGHWA LEE: “EMPOWERING
WOMEN’S LEADERSHIP IN THE HOSPITALITY INDUSTRY”
DURATION: 10.56 MINUTES
19
Transition: cut to
Description: Catie tells
2. 1
us about her career
Catie
Younghwa journey before
Lee’s career
becoming a General
journey
Figure 3.3 Caitie Manager
Younghwa Lee’s Journey
(Past)
Camera: Medium close
up
Audio: Autumn in fall
by RecProduction
Duration : 02.00
Transition: cut to
Description: Continued
3
video of Catie talking
about her present career
(Followed by a video
Figure 3.4 Caitie shot of Caitie walking
Younghwa Lee’s Present
Career in the hotel area)
20
hospitality as a female
General Manager?”
21
Camera: Medium close
up
Audio: Touch a dream
by unknown_signal
Duration: 01.00
Transition: cut to
Description:
4
Interspersed with
videos are transitions of
Caitie's daily moments
Figure 3.8 Transition with employees.
Video of Daily Moments
with Employees
22
Audio: Touch a dream
by unknown_signal
Duration: 01.00
Transition: cut to
Description:
6
Interspersed with
videos are transitions of
Caitie seeing employee
Figure 3.10 Caitie performance
Younghwa Lee Seeing
Employee Performance
23
Camera: wide shoot
Audio: Touch a dream
by unknown_signal
Duration: 00.10
Transition: cut to
Description:
8
Interspersed with
videos are transitions of
Caitie
Figure 3.12 Transition
Video of Caitie Younghwa
Lee in Her Spare Time
24
Description:
4. 1
Videoshoot Hotel Moxy
Employees
of Moxy Bandung outlet &
Hotel,
employees at work.
Bandung
Figure 3.14 Moxy Hotel
Bandung’s Outlet
25
Word to Caitie
Younghwa Lee"
26
Description: Featuring
2
answers from Mr.
Robby with the
question: "What is your
Figure 3.18 Interview with
Robby Fachri view on Women
Leaders or Female GMs
at Marriott Company?"
27
Audio: Remember the
time by
DannyKaufmann
Duration: 00.45
Transition: disolve to
Description: Catie
6. 1
gave a closing
Closing
statement about career
women and
3.20 Last Sentence from
housewives, for closure
Caitie Younghwa Lee
followed by a zoom out
effect showing Catie in
front of Hotel Moxy
Bandung
28
logo, and the Hotel
Business Program.
Camera: -
Audio: Remember the
time by Danny
Kaufmann
Duration: 00.10
Transition: fade to
black
29
CHAPTER IV
30
4.1.2 Scene 2: Caitie Younghwa Lee’s Career Journey
During Caitie's interview stage, we asked her some important question,
about her career journey from the beginning until now. The question is intended
to make the audience understand how the journey and ups and downs
experienced by Caitie have led her to become a female leader or as GM at this
time.
31
Younghwa Lee, and who worked from various divisions such as the kitchen,
back office, front office, and others.
32
managers in Indonesia today is still relatively small, but in the future, the fight
for gender equality can be used to fight the patriarchal system that has been
entrenched for a long time, so that the gap between genders can end.
Caitie Younghwa Lee said that there are lot of self-doubts or self-
limitations that are experienced by women with people saying that “you cannot
do it”, and sometimes these women have feelings that maybe they are not good
enough for themselves, so Caitie Younghwa Lee as an ambassador of women
leadership in Marriott International, advocate these people by saying “ you are
capable to pursue your dreams”. For example, in 2021, during the Women
Leadership Conference hosted by Marriott International at the Sheraton Kuta,
Bali, Caitie and other female employees discussed what it means to be a woman
in Indonesia in order to pursue a career in hospitality. Caitie had no idea what
additional challenges they would face because, aside from being women in Bali,
there are additional responsibilities for being a part of the local community, and
it has become difficult for females to become leaders because there are many
important or religious events, such as ceremony and that women must be
someone who organizes and supports the entire community. Caitie also said
there are lot of things that seems to be difficult for women to pursue but she
believed with the right guidance and representation will be able to educate a
future talent so these women can actually grow with a strong belief in
themselves to be a leader and reach the higher dreams that they had.
Caitie began her hospitality career after high school as a bell girl (it is
uncommon in Indonesia to have a female bell attendant), but she began as a full-
time bell girl, carrying baggage, delivering messages, and paging guests, among
other duties. So, that is how she started in Front Office, and then she was able
to move to same Front Office department in Guest Relations, at JW Marriott,
Seoul. Then, as part of Marriott International, she was fortunate enough to be
transferred to Marriott Resort in Grand Cayman Island, in the Caribbean. She
spent four years working her way up in the Front Office department on Cayman
Island before relocating to the beautiful Indonesian island of Bali. She began
33
her career as a Butler at Hilton Worldwide, looking after VIP guests in suites,
and at that property, she was given the option to transition from Front Office to
Sales and Marketing. She had a critical moment when she transitioned from
operations to back office. In Sales and Marketing, Caitie had the ability to
manage a variety of different geographical markets in Bali. After 3.5 years, she
relocated to South Korea and worked in Sales and Marketing at Conrad Seoul.
She returned to Indonesia after about 4 years to be with her family in Jakarta,
and after a few years there, 2021 was the first time she had a General Manager
role at Moxy Bandung.
34
CHAPTER V
5.1 Conclusion
Caitie Younghwa Lee's story, as General Manager of Moxy Bandung,
highlights the critical role of female leaders in overcoming gender stereotypes
and creating equality in the hospitality business, particularly in Indonesia.
Caitie's journey, highlighted by overcoming self-doubt and cultural
expectations, is proof that women can succeed in leadership posts.
5.2 Suggestion
Suggestion on storytelling is advice on the main object that is the focus
of the video presentation. Suggestions contain the author's views on object
findings that are not in accordance with existing general references. Suggestions
35
must be in accordance with the results of the conclusions made. All the answers
provided by the required sources were sufficient for the data of our proposal and
all the facilities needed by us are quite well fulfilled. There is one suggestion
we would like to make for our storytelling videos, which is:
- Arrange schedule with the interviewee or the sources when they are not busy
for shooting purposes.
5.4 Recommendation
The recommendation in this storytelling is the author's recommendation
for other researchers who will raise the profile as a topic for preparing a
capstone project or raising the topic of women leaders in Indonesia. For other
researchers who want to research more deeply on the topic of women leaders,
the author who is part of Agung Podomoro University Students has various
recommendations for other researchers who want to raise Women Leaders as
research material, namely as follows:
- For those who want to raise women leaders as a capstone project topic, it is
advisable to define the scope to help focus on the research. It can include
investigating specific industries whether business or hospitality, and
organizational structures.
- For those who want to raise women leaders as a capstone project topic, it is
advisable to examine the role of mentorship and support networks in
assisting women in their leadership journeys. Investigate how mentorship-
building programs might help with professional and career development for
women to become leaders.
36
- For those who want to raise women leaders as a capstone project topic, it is
important to analyse how culture and stigma from people’s perspectives
may make or destroy a woman's ability to lead an organization or company.
37
REFERENCES
38
APPENDIX
1. What is the story of Catie Younghwa Lee’s career journey from zero to
today?
2. What are the obstacles and challenges in making women a leader in
hospitality as a female General Manager?”
3. How to survive in the hospitality field as a female General Manager?
4. What are the challenges in South Korea to become a female leader?
5. What character traits should a woman have to become a General Manager?
6. What are the factors of "Women Leadership" that affect effectiveness and
performance for employees?
7. How to balance housework/ personal life and being a General Manager?
8. What are your motivations and goals in pursuing your career and who is
your support system?
39
Appendix 2. Expenses (3 People)
Expenses Amount
Videographer Rp1,700,000
Souvenir for Caitie Rp500,000
Souvenir for Robby Rp150,000
Transportation Rp1,000,000
Accommodation Rp1,500,000
Total Expenses Rp4,850,000
40
Appendix 3. Video
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1yyvulxUUFhmdLG7MYrkARZTw6LQczVJt/vie
w?usp=sharing
41
Appendix 4. Poster
42
Appendix 5. Booklet
43
44
45
46
47