American dream in the short story the first seven years by Bernard Malmud

#
In Bernard Malamud's short story "The First Seven Years," the theme of the American Dream is
subtly explored through the character of Max and the backdrop of immigrant life in America.
While the American Dream isn't as overtly central as in some other works, it is still present in
several key ways:

1. Education and Opportunity: Max, a university student, embodies the American Dream's
emphasis on education as a means to achieve a better life. He represents the pursuit of
knowledge and self-improvement, with the hope that his education will open doors to a
brighter future. This aligns with the notion that in America, education can lead to upward social
mobility and success.
2. Cultural Aspirations: The story takes place in a Jewish immigrant community, and Max's desire
for education and a better future reflects the aspirations of many immigrant families in
America. Immigrants often came to the United States seeking economic opportunities and a
chance for a more prosperous life for themselves and their children.
3. Personal Fulfillment: Max's pursuit of higher education is not solely about financial success; it is
also about personal fulfillment. This aspect of the American Dream highlights the idea that
individual happiness and self-actualization are important components of the dream. Max's
dream isn't just about achieving financial stability; it's about following his passion and potential.
4. Generation Gap: The story also touches on the generation gap between Max and Feld, the
older generation. Feld's expectations for Miriam's marriage are based on a more traditional
view of success, while Max represents a new generation with different values and aspirations.
This generational divide reflects changing attitudes toward the American Dream over time.
5. Conflict and Resolution: The story explores the tension between different interpretations of
the American Dream. Feld initially struggles to understand Max's aspirations, believing that
marriage and stability are the keys to success. However, as the story progresses, Feld comes to
respect Max's dedication to education and personal fulfillment, signaling a potential
reconciliation between generations and their respective dreams.

In "The First Seven Years," the American Dream is portrayed as a multi-faceted concept that
encompasses not only economic success but also personal growth, self-realization, and the
pursuit of education. Max's character represents the idea that education and personal
fulfillment are integral aspects of the American Dream, and the story suggests that these
dreams are attainable in the context of American immigrant life.
In "The First Seven Years," Sobel and Max are completely opposite. Why do you think Bernard
Malamud put such different kinds of characters into the story?
#
In "The First Seven Years" by Bernard Malamud, the characters of Sobel and Max serve
contrasting roles and personalities in the narrative to highlight different aspects of the central
themes and conflicts. Here are some reasons why the author may have introduced such
different characters into the story:
1. Symbolic Contrast: Sobel and Max can be seen as symbolic representations of different paths
and choices in life. Sobel represents the traditional and stable choice—the one that aligns with
Feld's desires for his daughter, Miriam. Max, on the other hand, symbolizes a more modern and
ambitious approach to life, driven by personal aspirations and self-improvement. Their contrast
illustrates the tension between tradition and progress, as well as the choices Miriam must
consider.
2. Conflict and Tension: The differences between Sobel and Max create tension and conflict in the
story. This conflict serves to highlight the central themes of the narrative, such as personal
growth, cultural identity, and the pursuit of happiness. The clash of these two characters'
worldviews intensifies the drama and allows the reader to explore these themes more deeply.
3. Character Development: The presence of both Sobel and Max contributes to the character
development of Miriam. Her interactions with these two very different men force her to
confront her own desires, values, and the kind of future she envisions. This character
development is central to the story's exploration of personal growth and identity.
4. Reader Engagement: By introducing diverse characters with contrasting personalities and
goals, Malamud engages the reader's interest and allows them to consider different
perspectives and outcomes. This engagement keeps the reader invested in the story's
exploration of complex themes.
5. Realism and Complexity: In literature, realistic and well-rounded characters often have diverse
traits and motivations. Sobel and Max's differences contribute to the complexity of the
narrative and make it more true to life. People in the real world have varying goals and
personalities, and the characters in the story reflect this diversity.
6. Thematic Exploration: The story aims to explore themes such as personal growth, identity,
generational differences, and cultural expectations. To fully examine these themes, it is
necessary to have characters who embody different viewpoints and choices. Sobel and Max
represent two different paths that Miriam could take, allowing for a richer exploration of these
themes.

In essence, the inclusion of characters like Sobel and Max with contrasting qualities and
aspirations serves to enrich the narrative by providing a range of perspectives and possibilities.
Their differences contribute to the depth and complexity of the story's exploration of its central
themes.
In Bernard Malamud's short story "The First Seven Years," the theme of identity is explored
through the characters' struggles to define themselves and their roles in the context of their
cultural and familial expectations. Here are ways in which the theme of identity is evident in the
story:

1. Cultural Identity: The story is set within a Jewish immigrant community, and cultural identity
plays a significant role. Miriam's father, Feld, is concerned about her marrying within their faith
and preserving their cultural heritage. This reflects the importance of cultural identity and
traditions within the community.
2. Generational Identity: The story examines the generational gap between parents and their
children. Feld represents the older generation with traditional values and expectations, while
 Max and Miriam are part of the younger generation seeking to define their own identities and
make choices that align with their personal aspirations.
3. Identity within Relationships: Characters in the story grapple with questions of identity within
the context of their relationships. Miriam's father struggles with his role as a parent and
provider, Max seeks to establish his identity as a student and a potential suitor, and Miriam
herself navigates her identity as a daughter and an individual with her own desires.
4. Personal Aspirations vs. Expectations: The theme of identity is evident in the characters'
conflict between personal aspirations and external expectations. Max and Miriam must
confront their own desires and beliefs about their futures in contrast to Feld's expectations for
Miriam's marriage. This conflict reflects the struggle to define one's identity independently of
societal or familial pressures.
5. Individuality and Self-Discovery: As Max and Miriam pursue their own paths and make choices
that align with their personal aspirations, they are engaged in a process of self-discovery and
the formation of their individual identities. Their willingness to challenge expectations and
forge their own paths reflects the theme of identity development.
6. Gender Identity: Gender roles and expectations also influence the characters' identities.
Miriam's desire for personal growth and independence challenges traditional gender roles, and
her actions reflect her desire to define her identity beyond societal expectations based on
gender.

In summary, "The First Seven Years" explores the theme of identity through the lens of cultural,
generational, and personal identity. The characters in the story grapple with questions of who
they are, what they want, and how they fit into the cultural and familial contexts that shape
their lives. This theme underscores the complexities of identity formation and self-discovery
within the immigrant community depicted in the story.

In Bernard Malamud's short story "The First Seven Years," the theme of personal growth is
evident in the character development of Max and Miriam, particularly in their pursuit of
education, self-discovery, and independence. Here's how the theme of personal growth is
explored in the story:

1. Educational Growth: Max, a university student who frequents Feld's shoemaking shop, is on a
journey of educational growth. He is committed to improving himself through education,
attending night classes to gain knowledge and skills. Max's dedication to learning reflects his
personal growth and desire for self-improvement.
2. Ambition and Aspiration: Max's pursuit of education symbolizes his ambition and aspirations.
He is determined to achieve more in life, and education is a means to that end. His willingness
to invest time and effort in his studies demonstrates his commitment to personal growth.
3. Self-Discovery: As Max pursues his education, he is also on a path of self-discovery. He is
learning not only academic subjects but also gaining a deeper understanding of his own desires
and dreams. This self-discovery is a crucial aspect of personal growth.
4. Independence: Max's pursuit of education and self-improvement signifies his desire for
independence and autonomy. He wants to establish his identity and forge his own path in life,
which is a fundamental aspect of personal growth.
5. Miriam's Growth: While Miriam is not the central character, her personal growth is also
evident in the story. She begins to assert her own desires and aspirations, demonstrating a
newfound independence and self-determination that goes against her father's expectations.
Her growth reflects the theme of individuality and self-discovery.
6. Conflict and Resolution: The story features conflicts between characters, particularly between
Feld and Max. These conflicts revolve around differences in beliefs and expectations. The
resolution of these conflicts often leads to moments of personal growth and understanding for
the characters involved.

Overall, "The First Seven Years" explores the theme of personal growth through the characters
of Max and Miriam. Their pursuit of education, self-discovery, independence, and their
willingness to challenge societal and familial expectations all contribute to their individual
journeys of personal growth and development.

In Bernard Malamud's short story "The First Seven Years," the theme of personal growth is
evident in the character development of Max and Miriam, particularly in their pursuit of
education, self-discovery, and independence. Here's how the theme of personal growth is
explored in the story:

1. Educational Growth: Max, a university student who frequents Feld's shoemaking shop, is on a
journey of educational growth. He is committed to improving himself through education,
attending night classes to gain knowledge and skills. Max's dedication to learning reflects his
personal growth and desire for self-improvement.
2. Ambition and Aspiration: Max's pursuit of education symbolizes his ambition and aspirations.
He is determined to achieve more in life, and education is a means to that end. His willingness
to invest time and effort in his studies demonstrates his commitment to personal growth.
3. Self-Discovery: As Max pursues his education, he is also on a path of self-discovery. He is
learning not only academic subjects but also gaining a deeper understanding of his own desires
and dreams. This self-discovery is a crucial aspect of personal growth.
4. Independence: Max's pursuit of education and self-improvement signifies his desire for
independence and autonomy. He wants to establish his identity and forge his own path in life,
which is a fundamental aspect of personal growth.
5. Miriam's Growth: While Miriam is not the central character, her personal growth is also
evident in the story. She begins to assert her own desires and aspirations, demonstrating a
newfound independence and self-determination that goes against her father's expectations.
Her growth reflects the theme of individuality and self-discovery.
6. Conflict and Resolution: The story features conflicts between characters, particularly between
Feld and Max. These conflicts revolve around differences in beliefs and expectations. The
resolution of these conflicts often leads to moments of personal growth and understanding for
the characters involved.
Overall, "The First Seven Years" explores the theme of personal growth through the characters
of Max and Miriam. Their pursuit of education, self-discovery, independence, and their
willingness to challenge societal and familial expectations all contribute to their individual
journeys of personal growth and development.