Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Medico-Chirurgical: Review
Medico-Chirurgical: Review
MEDICO-CHIRURGICAL REVIEW.
OCTOBER, 1862.
PART FIRST.
Review I.
things thus loosely indicated was not fruitful of iuterest. The mate-
rials of such a history are scanty in the extreme. We can extract
nothing of scientific value from the records within our reach, and rely
rather upon biographical details to show how slowly the noble science
of medicine progresses even among an intelligent though semi-
barbarous race. The diligent and patient Richter has eked out the
greater part of his first volume with reasons for the non-existence
formerly of physicians in Russia?namely, the extreme salubrity of the
country, and the consequent robust health and remarkable longevity
of the people. These reasons would be all the more satisfactory, were
it not for a ghastly list extending over fourteen printed pages of the
various plagues and pestilent visitations from which Russia suffered
between the years 1090 and 1G56. The pictures suggested to the
imagination by this methodical tabular statement are truly appalling.
It is amusing, at the same time, to read Richter's laboured eulogies of
the plcysique of the people amoug whom he lived, and the conclusion
to which he is led, that in the good old times before the corrupting
influences of luxury came in, a doctor would have been a superfluity
in Russia. It is true the Sclavonian races are large, well-made men,
of good average health and strength, but few individuals among them
possess the stamina of a well-fed, well-trained Englishman. It is
pretty well ascertained now that the troops of the Czar sustained
heavier losses through privation and disease under the severe trials of
the Crimean campaign than did the English troops. Boldly assuming,
therefore, that the Russians of the Middle Ages inherited a share of
the ills which visit mankind, we pass from the primitive state of
society in which the father of the family is the medicine-man, to the
1862.] Ilistory of Medicine in Russia. 287
age when priests followed the example of Luke, the beloved physician,
and healed the bodies while they strove to comfort the souls of their
converts. Of such was Ephraim, who accompanied Anna, sister of the
Emperors Basil and Constantine, from Constantinople '
to Kieff, and
there founded a house for the siek. Cave, in his Historia Literaria'
(ii. 113), gives an account of Johannes"
Smera Polovecius, who
flourished in 990,and whom he styles medicus et rhetor" to the Grand
Duke Vladimir, husband of the (Creek) Princess Anna. When Vla-
dimir had resolved to abandon the Pagan religion and impose a new
faith on himself and his people, he thought it wise and becoming in a
[Russian Prince to obtain accurate information on a subject of so much
importance. He sent confidential agents into the various countries
within reach to explore the religious world of that day, and from the
reports thus furnished he decided on rejecting the Mahometan and
Roman Catholic creeds, and adopt the ritual of the Greek Church.
Smera was one of the deputies employed on this delicate mission. His
peregrinations extended as far as Egypt, a letter from whence, written
to the Grand Prince on brass tablets, was long preserved in the prin-
cipal monastery at. Kieff. It was printed in the sixteenth century,
and is remarkable as containing a strong condemnation of the Greek
Church, and a threat that if Vladimir should adopt the faith of that
Church, he, Smera, would not return to Russia. The royal convert,
unlike Louis XI., was not over-terrified by his physician's menace,
and Smera we hope died peaceably in Egypt. The next hero of the
"
healing art?for we are not authorized to call him medicus" by the
solitary operation recorded in his favour?was the Father Confessor of
Sviataslaff, the son of Jaroslaf, who flourished in 1076. He cured a
dangei'ous bleeding of the nose to which the monarch was subject, by
stopping up the nostrils with some kind of rag. With equal absence
of scientific pretension, St. Olympius, in 1087, restored a rich in-
habitant of Kieff by anointing his face with ointment. The plain
sense of St. Agapyt exposed the quackery of a celebrated Armenian
*
Published in English by Mr. Murray. 1844.
1862.] History of Medicine in Russia. 289
ing them really formidable enemies. Ivan, on the other hand, laboured
to obtain a secret alliance with Elizabeth against the Poles, and mani-
fested his displeasure at her caution in the matter by lodging her
ambassador, Randolph, in a house which no one was allowed to
approach. Dr. Reynolds, however, contrived to visit his countryman
clandestinely.
Dr. Elisteus Bomel, a charlatan of some notoriety, appears next in
the long shadowy procession of medical practitioners in Russia. In
the summer of 1570 he accompanied the Russian ambassador who
bore from London a treaty of friendship between Elizabeth and Ivan
*
Edited by Dr. Muiik, vol. i. p. 51. 1861.
1862. J History of Medicine in Russia. 291
Moscow; and we find that the passage from Elizabeth's letter which
we have just given was omitted from the Russian translation, with
the exception of a bare mention of Dr. Jacob, who reached Moscow
in safety. The midwife was detained at "Vologda, so that "the
never knew of her," and she was obliged to return to
Empress
London in the autumn of 1587, leaving her business altogether un-
performed. This chapter from the romance of medical history was
the beginning of a series of events which terminated in the usurpation
of the throne by Boris Godunoff and a frightful civil war. For
further particulars of Dr. Jacob's career in England we refer to Dr.
Munk's ' Roll of the College of Physicians.'
Muscovy would seem to have lost its charms for English doctoi*s
about this time. Dr. Mark Ridley, who was recommended by Queen
Elizabeth to Boris Godunoff in 1594, as "one of her physicians, a
man learned and expert in his profession, and fit for the service of a
became the first natite physician in Russia. John Elmston was the
son of the interpreter to the English Embassy in Moscow. He was
sent to England in 1629, studied at Cambridge, London, and Paris,
enjoyed the protection of King Charles, and returned to Russia a
Doctor of Medicine in 1642. The third medical student thus pro-
vided for was Valentine Byls, son of a physician to the Czar. He
was absent in Holland sixteen years, pursuing his studies and fitting
himself for the medical career Avhich he subsequently followed in
Russia. He took his M.D. degree at Leyden.
This diluted infusion of native blood into the faculty in Russia was
not sufficient to create a national school of medicine. The first phy-
sician of Czar Alexis Michaelovitch, who asceuded the throne in 1645,
was Dr. Andreas Engelhardt, a native of
Brandenburg, who remained
ten years in the Czar's service. To him succeeded Dr. Samuel Collins,
the author of a little book entitled 'The Present State of Russia,' 1671.
Richter has erroneously attributed to him the ' System of Anatomy,'
two vols., folio, 1685, which was published by Dr. Samuel Collins, the
Gulstonian lecturer of 1675. The Russian Collins, after serving the
Czar eight years (1659?1667), returned home and died at Cowley, in
Middlesex, in 1685. Regard for his profession does not appear in his
little book, where he avoids as much as possible parler metier. We
have already mentioned his allusion to " mylady lues venerea" as being
well known in Poland, and taken prisoner by the Russians. Pie
expresses his disgust at the elfish lock which the Poles derived from
Plica, which, he says, they take pride in and wear as a badge of nobility.
One other observation only gives an intimation of the writer's pro-
fession. Speaking of the rigour of Russian fasts, he thus describes
their jealousy of animal substances in their medicines: " If a medicine
has in it Cor. cervi, ungul., Al. or Pil. lepor, they will not take it though
to save their lives."
Russian medical history is equally disregarded in the 'Account of
Muscovy,' published in 1698 by Iodocus Crull, who was made Doctor
of Mediciue of Cambridge by royal mandate in 1681. He had not,
296 Reviews. [Oct
indeed, been in Russia, and in compiling from printed sources his
labours could not but be barren.
The plague of London, in 1665, threatened to put a stop to the
migration of English doctors into Russia. Dr. Thomas Wilson went,
furnished with good recommendations, in that year, but was stopped
at Pleskoff for several months, then was
cautiously allowed to approach
Moscow, and after two years' wearisome delay was forced to return
home without having obtained any employment. Dr. Frundek, a
Dutchman, was rather more fortunate. After encountering obstacles
and delays similar to those which beset Wilson, he was permitted to
enter Moscow in 1666, having left his money and effects at Pleskoff,
and buried his clothes in the ground there. The sanguine disposition
which enabled him to overcome the difficulties of a Muscovite qua-
rantine probably led him to write a book which might have been
serviceable to the author of a ' Strange Story,' and which was published
'
at the Hague in 1660, under the title of Tractatus de Elixirio Arboris
"Vitse, seu Medicina Mea Universali.'
In his last sickness (1676), Alexis Michaelovitch was treated by
Drs. Coster von Rosenberg and Laurence Blumentrost, both of whom
have left works to testify of their medical knowledge, for an account
of which we must refer to Richter's history. They both also left sons,
who succeeded to their practice and to the favour of the reigning
family. To the Princess Sophia the elder Blumentrost owed his life,
when the riotous Strelitzes put one Dr. Gaden to death, and would
have so disposed of all the Court physicians, on suspicion of their
having abridged the days of the Czar Feodor Alexeivitch.
The list of physicians who flourished during the reign of this Prince
(1676?1682) is composed exclusively of foreigners, unless we except
Dr. Henry Kellermann, who, though of German blood, was born in
Moscow, was sent abroad to study medicine, and on his return in
1678 was admitted Doctor by the Board of Apothecaries, a medical
corporation founded at the commencement of the seventeenth century.
It was not until the reign of Peter the Great that the same body con-
ferred the rank of Doctor upon a genuine Russian. The Czar had, in
1692, sent to Padua, at his own expense, one Peter Posuikoff, the
son of an officer of his court, for the express purpose of studying medi-
cine. The progress made by the young man in all his studies was
highly commendable, but especially so in the acquisition of foreign
languages, an accomplishment that deprived Prussia of the services of
her first doctor. The exigencies of the Czar's diplomatic service
diverted the best part of Posnikoff's time and attention from mediciue
to State affairs. He was called from Padua to Yienna, went thence
to Amsterdam, and again to Italy and Venice. No record remains of
his medical labours in Russia, after receiving the dignity of Doctor in
1701 from the hands of his countrymen, a dignity which he perhaps
valued as much as the degree of Doctor of Philosophy and of Medicine,
conferred on him in 1696 by the University of Padua,
Gregory Volkoff was another Russian medical student sent by Czar
Peter to Padua in 1698, with a thousand thalers in his purse, and a
1862.] History of Medicine in Russia. 297
passport to bear him safely through his journey. Yet the foreign im-
portation of medical men did not flag in Peter's reign. Richter tells
of a batch of twelve surgeons despatched at one time by General
Gordon from Germany to Russia, and of fifty sent from Amsterdam
in 1G97 by Admiral Cruys. A few further particulars of these worthy
gentlemen destined for the army and navy will be found in Richter's
^second volume.
\ Peter the Great, as we have intimated at the outset of this article,
felt a strong personal interest in medical science. Endowed with
great natural capacity, this semi-barbarous monarch and enthusiastic
reformer watched with intensely eager curiosity all the processes in-
volved in the study and the application of the great art of healing.
"Whether in the dissecting-room he followed the swift revealing hand
of the anatomist; or, at Paris, bade his favourite Dr. Erskine procure
him an opportunity of seeing the operation for the cataract; or, at
Petersburg, talked deep into the night with his Dutch physician,
Bidloo, on the growth of medicinal plants, or astonished Dr. Termont
by performing himself the operations that have been mentioned, the
same active energy in the cause of medicine is always and everywhere
*
The illustrious physiologist
Yon Baer read a Memoir before the Petersburg
Academy in 1850, in which he stated that the Museum is still very much what it was
when Iluysch sold it,and that very few preparations have been added since that date.
This is an additional illustration of the indifferentism of native Russians and of
medical men trained in Petersburg for the scientific department of their profession.
298 Reviews. [Oct.
related to the celebrated Earl of Mar. His career in Russia com-
menced in the
capacity of physician to Count Menstchikoff, and he
was called
by the Czar to preside at the Board of Apothecaries in 1706.
He appears to have enjoyed the personal confidence of Peter, travelling
about with him in Russia and abroad. '
Perry, in his Present State of
Russia,' has the following passage :?
"
Dr. Areskin, a most ingenious gentleman, who is chief physician to the
Czar, and a Member of the Royal Society in England, with whom the Czar
usually informs himself in the curiosities of nature, being, in 1709, with his
Majesty on that side of the country, he went ou purpose by the Czar's order
to see the foresaid saints that are laid in the vault in a monastery near Kieff;
and in discourse I have heard him say, that the Russes in their pretences to
these miracles, sufficiently outdo whatsoever is pretended by all the Papists in
Europe."
Erskine is also spoken of by Alexander Gordon, in his ' History of
"
Peter the Great,' as an agreeable, open-hearted, fine gentleman."
The account of the operation for cataract which the Czar witnessed,
1
occurs in the Memoirs of the Reign of Peter,' by the so-called
Nestesuranoi. It was when the Czar was at Paris in 1717, ou the
day he took leave of the King and the Regent, he ordered Erskine to
bring a skilful oculist to operate on an invalid aged sixty-five, who
had been blind since the battle of Hochstedt. An Englishman named
"Woolhouse was recommended by Du Vernav, and came to the H6tel
Lesdiguieres, where the Russian monarch was residing. On seeing
the needle planted in the eye, Peter turned his head away for a
moment, but recovered himself immediately, and closely watched the
operation to the end, when he held hi3 hand before the invalid's eyes,
and proved the reality of his restoration to sight. Greedy of every
acquisition that might benefit his country, be requested Woolhouse to
undertake the charge of a Russian pupil whom he would send to be
educated as an oculist. To return for a moment to Erskine. Some
obscure hints are given of his being concerned in the notable plot
concocted by Count Gortz of Sweden, the Earl of Mar, and others, for
a Jacobite descent in England, which terminated in the feeble expedi-
capital and the Court. The Czar appears to have sincerely lamented
him, and gave him a public funeral in the Pantheon of modern
Russia?the convent of St. Alexander of iNevsky, near St. Peters-
burg. Erskine's library of four thousand curious books, and his col-
lection of curiosities were bequeathed to the kunstkammer, and now
lie, we believe, at the Petersburg Academy of Sciences. The degree
of his intimacy with the Imperial family may be surmised from the
bequest he made of his principal estate to the Princess Nathalie.
Dr. Blurnentrost the younger, who succeeded Erskine as chief Court
Doctor, was not so high in Peter's personal regard as his Majesty's
Dutch friends, Termont, the surgeon, and Bidloo, the physician, with
whom the monarch, who could speak no foreign language but Dutch,
History of Medicine in Russia. 290
1SG2.]
would pass hours of instructive conversation. A capacity for strong
potations was also an indispensable qualification for the enjoyment of the
Emperor's society, and Holland has never been wanting in hearty topers.
The Czar had once to do violence to his generally strict sense of
justice in favour of Termont, who, in the heat of passion, and under
the influence of strong drink, ran his servant-man through the body.
The Czar next day was amazed to see his boon companion fall at his
feet in an agony of remorse and fear. Upon learning the cause of this
strong emotion, he pardoned the rash surgeon, on condition that he
provided for the wife and children of the deceased serving-man.
Stsehlin, in his ' Original Anecdotes of Peter the Great,' tells (on
the authority of an army-surgeon, Schulz) a story of Termont's widow
and her second husband, which displays the Czar's strong common-
sense, his natural humour, and, which is not altogether foreign to our
purpose, his ability to detect a false pretender to medical knowledge.
Madame Termont had bestowed herself and her fortune on a gallant
journeyman barber-surgeon who came from Dantzig, and the happy
couple made haste to drive through the fortune of the defunct, literally
in a coach-and-four. Folly of this kind was not long in coming to the
ears of the Czar, who on a given day sent for the usurper of his dear
Termont's place. The young man, elated with the pi'ospect of a high
situation at Court, decked himself in costly attire, and on reaching the
palace was ushered into the Imperial presence, where he found a
numerous assembly of boyars. Peter at once put him through a
searching examination on sui'gery, and had no difficulty in proving
the young man's utter ignorance of every branch of his art that went
beyond shaving and bloodletting. Pie thereupon called in a number
of footmen and peasants who lay in ambush in an adjoining room, and
compelled Madame Termont's husband in all his finery to mow their
stubborn beards. The barber-surgeon having completed his task, was
suffered to depart with the same misplaced pomp which had marked
his arrival.
Dr. Nicolas Bidloo was the nephew of Godfrey Bidloo, physician to
our William III. of glorious memory. It will be remembered that
Godfrey Bidloo made a vigorous attack upon W. Cowper, the English
anatomist, for using the fine plates of Bidloo's book on anatomy, and
passing them off for his own. Lambert Bidloo, the father of Nicolas,
was a great apothecary and herbalist, and the latter acquired a double
hold on the confidence of Czar Peter by his familiarity with the sub-
ject of plants and gardens. His advice was taken in the laying out
of both ornamental and botanical gardens in several principal towns
of the empire, and he was appointed director of that which was planted
at Moscow.
The death of Peter the Great in his fifty-third year, of strangury,
suggests a doubt as to the skill of his numerous medical attendants
and friends. Boerhaave is reported to have exclaimed when he heard
"
of the Emperor's death, My God ! is it possible 1 What a pity that
so great a man should have died when a remedy of the value of a few
Medici.'
The Empress, nevertheless, thought fit to meet her end under the
medical care of an Englishman, Dr. Jacob or James Mounsey, who,
1862.] History of Medicine in Russia. 301
after practising successfully for ten years in Moscow, was called to the
Court in 1760. Richter tells us that he married Johanna, the daughter
of James Grieve, a Scotchman, who for some years was city-physician in
Moscow. Grieve was not, it may be supposed, embarrassed with any
excess of modesty; for when about to retire to England, he begged
his son-in-law to ask the Emperor Peter III. for an Imperial recom-
mendation to the Court of England, to enable him to secure a place
there. The recommendation was given with all formality through
the Russian chancellor and the ambassador in London, but, as was to
be expected, without any results, and Grieve died in Moscow about
1763.
We cannot omit from an account of the medical men of the Czarina
Elizabeth that historical personage, Jean Herman Lestocq. He was
the son of a French Protestant surgeon who, after the revocation of
the Edict of Nantes, had resided at Hanover. Attracted by the
brilliant accounts received from Petersburg of fortunes made and suc-
cesses achieved, the young man, who had studied medicine, went
thither in 1713, being in his twenty-first year. He was appointed
one of the surgeons to the Court, and accompanied the Empress
Catherine the First on her journey to Holland in 1716. He was a
light-hearted dissolute fellow, and incurred the serious displeasure of
Peter by some misconduct, the nature of which is not stated. He
was exiled to Kasan, where he remained till the accession of Catherine,
in 1725, when he was recalled, and appointed medical attendant to the
Princess Elizabeth, a young girl of sixteen. "With all the gaiety
and rattle of a Frenchman, Lestocq was a schemer, and after he had
obtained a certain ascendancy over Elizabeth, he directed her thoughts
to the throne. On the death of Peter II. he urged her to declare
herself Czai'ina, but she, preferring the freedom and pleasures of life to
power, refused. Another ten years elapsed, and the throne was again
vacant, having been bequeathed to Ivan, a child in his cradle. As
Elizabeth hesitated to break her oath of fidelity, Lestocq grew more
and more urgent. One of his devices was to paint a picture repre-
senting Elizabeth seated on a throne of flowers, upheld by cupids; on
the other side, dressed as a nun, and surrounded with instruments of
"
torture. Choose," said he, " to-morrow, the purple or the rack."
She chose the purple, and rewarded Lestocq for his services with the
rank of Privy Councillor, Physician to her Majesty, President of the
Medical College, and a pension of 7000 roubles. The Emperor of
Germany sent him a patent of nobility, making him Count of the
Empire, and the King of France likewise forwarded a handsome grati-
fication. But Lestocq wanted the ballast of a true politician. He
intrigued enough, but the Russian chancellor, Bestucheff", out-manoeuvred
him, and in 1718 the unfortunate surgeon was imprisoned, deprived of
rank and fortune, knouted, and finally banished to listing, in the
government of Archangel. He survived his ungrateful sovereign, and
was restored to liberty and some fortune
by Peter III. and his wife
Catherine II. The goods and chattels of which he had been despoiled
having fallen into many hands, could not easily be given back to him.
60-xxx. -2
302 Revieios. [Oct.
Peter said, jestingly, that he might take his own wherever he could
find anything. The notion jumped with the Frenchman's humour.
He found it excellent sport to go to the houses of his spoilers when
the masters were out of the way, and carry off, in the name of the
Emperor, any bit of plate or jewellery, china, vase, or picture, that he
could lay his hands on. Retiring to a small estate in Livonia granted
him by Catherine II., he died there in 17G7.
In the same yeax', 1767, there was published in London, by Dr.
Thomas Dimsdale, ' The Present Method of Inoculating for the Small-
pox,' a work which passed through seven large editions in the course
of three years. The reputation of the author reached the ears of
the Empress Catherine II., who summoned him to Petersburg for the
express purpose of establishing inoculation in Russia. She was herself
the first to submit to the operation which filled many with dread. In
one of his publications, Dimsdale gives an interesting account of his
nominally fixed for every day during ten months of the year, the
1862.] History of Medicine in Russia. 303
Our task is for the present over. We have traced as best we could
the history of medicine in Russia, and in so doing have been neces-
sarily confined to a narrative of the adventures of English, German,
French, and Dutch practitioners of the art. The history of Russian
medicine only begins in the nineteenth century; and though the
names which give distinction to the Russian school of medicine?Yon